More Studies on the Cérvéka/Lokéyata More Studies on the Cérvéka/Lokéyata By Ramkrishna Bhattacharya Cambridge Scholars Publishing More Studies onthe Garvaka/Lokayata By Ramkrishna Bhattachaxya This book firstpublished 2020 C ambridge Scholars Publishing Lady StephensonL ibrary,N ewcastle upon Tyne, NE6 2PA, UK BritishL ibrary C atalo guing in Public ation Data A catalogue rec ord for this book is available from the BritishL ibrary Copyright© 2020 by Bamkrishna Bhattacharya Allr ights for this book reserved. No part of this book may be reprodu c ed, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic , mechanical,p hotocopying, recording or otherwise, witho ut the prior permission of the copyright owner. ISBN (10):1—5275—4082—0 ISBN (13): 978-1-5275-4082-8 For Dr Krishna Del Toso A close friend, an excellent collaborator, and a fellow-traveller Copyright © 1920. Cambridge Scholars Publishing. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair usespermitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law. Copyright © 1920. Cambridge Scholars Publishing. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair usespermitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law. LPFRPMPLWCCCCATCCCCCCTororrhrehbhhhhhhhhhhaoeekhekelebaaaaaaaaaametcf-o-aea rpCppppppppp'PvCCre ycrttttttttttyaaaPreeeeeeeeveeiafieiaaernrrirrrrrrrrrrrert atvv.l- coaaENFFvi. SOTCSTTatsi.etti ik.ohiooihaakeeiwmkia.n vgnxa.eoua-nrnnvanre.eohme e . fv.fe srddi l....LMM n e tofi ........ nt I .......l..aoh kto k............a ast............teakkdh............ett ............ec sfieDKey............r'............ riyzr a............aaeiaOi............ayaat............lnrtai...i.........ltkshill....i........dvtidsa............msai.....a....... kam.t. ...... ....m Th...a.....a.... b t............U ie t...n.........ariv .o...........nicip ...d.........nnmeC.. ......’.... Mar... ......... Gsth............anihtt............C lamhh............irr ieE...n.........svteee............ae ............O aapM e ............ntrJ.V...........kdihki........a....cafil.a.......N.... a ei.s.M..........stbnl.s...........sio ?........:....sSfi Td........u.. ..a .m...........Tlta.q....d.......ithE............ ehEd. .e..........ve............er.-v....p.....a..N .i.......d.... Saa..M....i......fi.s..........h.h.Tlt...........hoi.u.......a....asi............mad.dS...........nrm............m .ey...........id.......m..... . ...........faoi............ n............e-.f............ p.... .......'M.tk............hu............a...........a.e.n...........l........... t.a.....d......e.......V......i..........a. r............afi.i...........ra............lnf.m...........kl............di............sa.r........... .m.t.......'...-.kh............s...........i.e ........... fiR............. .i..........tN.n..........a.m............. z...........m.I........... .'n...........l...a.........a...........d..k...........y............i.e..........a.a.............é..........n.. ..... .....i.1......... .a... . 2779 0.8644 ix x1900494590i viii Contents Copyright © 1920. Cambridge Scholars Publishing. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair usespermitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law. BBMWCCCaCCCCCTCCTCCCCTTVnrihhhwehhhhhhaéhhhhoaabhhdeeeraaaaaaaarraamtralosaevvv i ppppppppkppoBsCSe aamrtaOutttttttttt ipgsaeeeeeeeeeekktaokaneha braasrrrrrrrrrrlarcAdinae tsvesFENFE SS iTTTiMMMatat p cam CoatiilhiewwTikafuglrenhkxiii tutssiv iaisOenroheareebttvey:cerceaetrcd xr/tenlete uEtuvee. nvsLe eeeet .Stetnantt lal .etoheyenllleeolo.enaklaa o s... ka enn nndf..e...a nnnto.... ..a n n... t...... sByysattkh.........yyoh .. ........ kfinO ea.......... oeI. .........IIrrBd ....t......I ihIrG .......a....f t C....r.......i IWag..t...W....:...hah........... ..saC.............iaree...........n..prov.............slvs .............aaaarC.............pdtd.............tkls .............yalkas.........a....ysa.............atr s............. iiRMvs............. fs i.............iafi n.........fl....ec.........e....knt......... a....lma.............taad.............ht.............tin/ I...........o..eeLt.............ts....... ......ndo S............. ............. kto.............Cao.............a.............fro.......... ... yvt.............Shm.............aa.............oe.............tdm.............au .............aC............. re.............cr.............ani.............ea.............rt............. vaMn..........................ara.............i.......a......ke.......s...................atsa.............e.............: m............. rp.............i.............aa.............g.............fil.............rs.............ac............. .............ha..........................ag.......................... u..........................p..........................t.............a.................................... ................................................................................. 1111111112222975473282 2 451 3769649741111 Copyright © 1920. Cambridge Scholars Publishing. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair usespermitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law. DnukmhiiEiLaCfvTtatodfoaTdonnnhorrneanaonpstinefxahhiuas avhe e vsorsndbpIpdvgadwertcoetit nIIBn eotTvwodoe hle dr imnto bwoaorsbkhdd iracruonhleew rkdvl aorhnoh eileeiiiisikcsenfrnad asaecadalbopalaoeeonea,da yCn intgthrleu .ucmssinreaiitk id sgl toMogosesas 2l an plsA o ripoe mbde enintnr ucerse0t eatsrn uhrdr evo e rhsnst aLe 1—oeidt ileeeraoe aedndaye inafitgocv1t s p k ra dk flstehubmia nape vieekelshnt)o aestatt oee Btr.ot aslaeemehss,ae aaef eokr s n m h rwrtmttyqdtiTi Il titra.tnuri fhhs oitlsyweoaeas hua see its isd gnabc th nT rd ivttfimemelhdhti nsiyaoeaiaiis etAthaaohesteenllea hi p n vhtp tot atts lnbmi ttisllda vboios oeetIneea ydGnstantgoseonoenu e mhs fiu gmt mmg knpt o obraeih rd d oaeome tBbc amtrdekefspnI a.ywiayvhn efhafne taat. a tlr gtnfs oaalp i is as wn dueeSrlrSesfia otH oot tw stehythepyonroltevoenuhstomfptyB aetaij trui le ceo r hndeddlefdoi ab tPrs tohsitdaoamo hldhaetiyrhch gegadltrtpseasils-tufape o elReriitaesive haro,saanwd toist nny re s rotfs oofryrnturtt saiongepEiC ddii ayc snonat raiaonat dcbrsoteh lb aa sh eaaely h tlnlmnF heocetiedeyoad tsrt niasbrio Iodia vh aatni v n .toenAeo madgh,aettnuo hfe oanhrr eahondnd,c v ecpy hgpoe rdfyC,mf eSke B t i.aigh syrpr thtnu rta .taa helCat iioea.i ahaethpEfatIbhflcn .e/nosneao nesm,de raLaouieliTeia e hj in bu s nr er ri oswrctbun ert Steaheea lnhvtg hnh keoblnr weionrIdeaseofidopne aoieKnmc meusvpc ts ugkerioseihy rudfiouxen tetoaosieamretwriae h rig npattr rma n bt /nnshiotr,eonyiehopLelnovsa ;s noyodte a aanf tteol re m ffr bBhri a r isfi,koDj rtgtnrieaa kt vr oahsaro etnihaaa,ir nhdfigaoynlr ret emtscodtlSedso a syg a th r s pKo ttfa l ekimfaearanhh iayaSaesoeionnsk hgrwd h eet crct euasai ssiihd aeeidhtunasoarhmtsaysatot nsil.e arseu i(vsryhson nb mfinisrcF Te . ebaefktr, hlnb olksksdo eltaiesi hahlenltIaahtraonaeu riah r:rra ie seaait ltSeynfsleocys ti tihegDeymumwns norh cCmiknboeo b rdttz,ftnoeeeCaej u i tthsoreaapioad eh ne f ylasr Saoisefrue uff ihl seadsooi vnyoini2ToerndIn usnrr at..evsarn srfnn0s ao f em n tdrmMa dtaok deattet0tttresaiihh hhh knanes oiitlwiis9xomsynns—seeaseaeeasyhaf.t;.,