Table Of Content

Michigan Law Review VOLUME 92 1993-1994 The University of Michigan Law School Michigan Law Review Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109-1215 CONTENTS VOLUME 92 Subject Index Articles Notes PE .tbbeRbebeeinedebnticeeeeeecceicn Books Reviewed Copyright © 1994 By THE MICHIGAN LAW REVIEW ASSOCIATION SUBJECT INDEX (a) after a reference indicates a leading article; (c) correspondence; (n) note; (r) book review. ABORTION CHILD CUSTODY Life’s sacred value — common ground or Black identity and child placement: the best battleground — Alexander Morgan interests of black and biracial children — Capron (r) 1491-502 Kim Forde-Mazrui (n) 925-67 Religion and the search for a principled mid- Divorce, custody, gender, and the limits of dle ground on abortion — Michael W. law: on Dividing the Child — Lee E. Tei- McConnell (r) 1893-909 telbaum (r) 1808-39 ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE CIVIL PROCEDURE See also Jurisprudence, Minorities, Philoso- phy. Civil procedure: other disciplines, globaliza- Equal Access to Justice Act — are the bank- tion, and simple gifts — Gene R. Shreve ruptcy courts less equal than others?, The (r) 1401-08 — Matthew J. Fischer (n) 2248-86 CIVIL RIGHTS ARBITRATION AND AWARD See also Employment Discrimination, See International Arbitral Procedure. Handicap Discrimination, Race. Anticaste principle, the — Cass R. Sunstein BACON, FRANCIS (a) 2410-55 Light, shadow, science, and law — Allen D. Caste and the civil rights laws: from Jim Boyer (r) 1622-36 Crow to same-sex marriages — Richard A. Epstein (a) 2456-78 BANKRUPTCY Bankruptcy policymaking in an imperfect COMPARATIVE LAW: CIVIL world — Elizabeth Warren (a) 336-87 PROCEDURE See Civil Procedure. BOOKS See also Books Reviewed, in this volume CONSTITUTIONAL HISTORY index. 1994 survey of books relating to the See also Constitutional Law, Legal History, law 1333-996 Self-Incrimination. Notes on current books on law and related Book notice — reviewing Gillman: The subjects 195-98, 478-79, 774-75, 1034-36, Constitution Besieged: The Rise and De- 1327-28, 2287-93, 2645-48 mise of Lochner Era Police Powers Jurisprudence 1438-46 BOUNDARIES Inherent power in mapping ownership, The CONSTITUTIONAL LAW — Michael P. Conzen (r) 1637-45 See also Elections, Federalism, State Law, War and Emergency Powers. BRITAIN Book notice — reviewing Epstein: Bargain- See War and Emergency Powers. ing with the State 1855-64 Constitution of reason, The — Robin L. CAMPAIGN FUNDS West (r) 1409-37 Constitution, the legislature, and unfair sur- Book notice — reviewing Sorauf: IJnside prise: toward a reliance-based approach Campaign Finance: Myths and Realities to the Contract Clause, The — Robert A. 1865-72 Graham (n) 398-437 When is the Senate in recess for purposes of CHILD ABUSE the Recess Appointments Clause? — See Due Process of Law. Michael A. Carrier (n) 2204-47 Michigan Law Review [Vol. 92 CONSTITUTIONAL THEORY No time for trumpets: Title VII, equality, See also Constitutional Law. and the fin de siécle — D. Marvin Jones Book notice — reviewing Harris: The Inter- (a) 2311-69 pretable Constitution 1447-55 Only girls wear barrettes: dress and appear- Three mistakes about interpretation — Paul ance standards, community norms, and Campos (c) 2388-97 workplace equality — Katharine T. Bart- lett (a) 2541-82 CRIME Public policy exclusion and insurance for intentional employment discrimination, The See also Law Enforcement. — Sean W. Gallagher (n) 1256-326 Rediscovering Hegel’s theory of crime and Structuralist and cultural domination theo- punishment — Markus Dirk Dubber ries meet Title VII: some contemporary (r) 1577-621 influences — Martha Chamallas (a) 2370-409 CRIMINAL PROCEDURE Title VII and the complex female subject — See Self-Incrimination. Kathryn Abrams (a) 2479-540 DECONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL LAW Transcendental deconstruction, transcendent See Environmental Protection, Pollution. justice — J.M. Balkin 1131-86 ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION DISCRIMINATION Allocating the burden of proof to effectuate See Civil Rights. the preservation and federalism goals of the Coastal Zone Management Act — DOMESTIC RELATIONS Martin J. LaLonde (n) 438-77 See Child Custody. ETHICS DUE PROCESS OF LAW See Legal Ethics. Constitutionality of employer-accessible child abuse registries: due process impli- EUROPEAN COMMUNITY cations of governmental occupational blacklisting, The — Michael R. Phillips Beyond the reasons stated in judgments — Giorgio Gaja (r) 1966-76 (n) 139-94 DURESS FEDERAL JURISDICTION See Constitutional Law. See Removal of Causes. ECKERT, ELEONORA V. FEDERALISM Tributes Rehabilitating federalism — Erwin Chemerinsky (r) 1333-46 ELECTIONS See also Campaign Funds, Representative FIFTH AMENDMENT PROTECTIONS Government. See Self-Incrimination. Race and redistricting: drawing constitutional lines after Shaw v. Reno — T. FIRST AMENDMENT PROTECTIONS Alexander Aleinikoff & Samuel Is- See also Pornography. sacharoff (a) 588-651 Book notice — reviewing Eldridge: A Dis- tant Heritage: The Growth of Free Speech EMPLOYMENT AT WILL in Early America 1693-99 Life-cycle justice: accommodatinjugs t cause and employment at will — Stewart J. FOREIGN LAW Schwab (a) 8-62 See European Community. EMPLOYMENT DISCRIMINATION FRAUD See also Civil Rights, Due Process of Law, Race. See Law and the Arts. Employment discrimination law in perspective: three concepts of equality — John J. GOVERNMENT Donohue III (a) 2583-612 See Constitutional Law 1994] Index HABEAS CORPUS JURISPRUDENCE Incorporating the Suspension Clause: is Incommensurability and valuation in law — there a constitutional right to federal Cass R. Sunstein (a) 779-861 habeas corpus for state prisoners? — Objectivity in legal judgment — Heidi Li Jordan Steiker (a) 862-924 Feldman (a) 1187-255 HANDICAP DISCRIMINATION JURY SELECTION Book notice — reviewing Shapiro: No Pity: See Juries. People with Disabilities Forging a New Civil Rights Movement 1953-58 LABOR LAW Labor law successorship: a corporate law HOMOSEXUALITY AND LESBIANISM approach — Edward B. Rock & Michael See Sexual Orientation. L. Wachter (a) 203-60 HUMAN RIGHTS LAW AND THE ARTS Emerging from emergency: human rights in Strings attached — violin fraud and other South Africa — Etienne Mureinik deceptions — Carla J. Shapreau (r) 1977-88 (r) 1743-53 INCOME TAX LAW ENFORCEMENT Politics of the income tax, The — Joseph Brutality in blue: community, authority, and Bankman (r) 1684-92 the elusive promise of police reform — Debra Ann Livingston (r) 1556-76 INSIDER TRADIN©™ Insider trading deterrence versus managerial LEGAL EDUCATION incentives: a unified theory of section Book notice — reviewing Granfield: Mak- 16(b) — Merritt B. Fox (a) 2088-203 ing Elite Lawyers: Visions of Law at Harvard and Beyond 1737-42 INTERNATIONAL ARBITRAL Toil of the firestarters — Peter A. Alces PROCEDURE (r) 1707-24 Book notice — reviewing Dore: The UNCI- TRAL Framework for Arbitration in Con- LEGAL ETHICS temporary Perspective 1989-95 Knowledge about legal sanctions — Stephen INTERNATIONAL LAW McG. Bundy & Einer Elhauge (a) 261-335 See Joint Ventures. LEGAL HISTORY JOINT VENTURES See also Francis Bacon, Boundaries, First Amendment Protection, Income Tax, Ju- Are we compatible? current European risdiction, War and Emergency Powers. Community law on the compatibility of “Am I, by law, the lord of the world?”: how joint ventures with the Common Market the juristic response to _ Frederick and possibilities for future development Barbarossa’s curiosity helped shape west- — Alyssa A. Grikscheit (n) 968-1033 ern constitutionalism — Charles J. Reid, Jr. (r) 1646-74 JUDGMENTS An intent-based approach to the acceptance LEGAL PROFESSION of benefits doctrine in the federal courts Power from the people — Milner S. Ball — Mitchell N. Berman (n) 742-73 (r) 1725-36 JURIES LEGAL THEORY Postconviction review of jury discrimination: See Constitutional Law, Constitutional The- measuring the effects of juror race on jury ory, Multinational Corporations. decisions — Nancy J. King (a) 63-130 JURISDICTION LIABILITY INSURANCE Book notice — reviewing Purcell: Litigation See Employment Discrimination. and Inequality: Federal Diversity Jurisdic- tion in Industrial America, 1870- LITERATURE 1958 1700-06 See also Poetry. vi Michigan Law Review [Vol. 92 In search of Faulkner’s law — Richard RELIGION Weisberg (r) 1776-85 See also Abortion. Multicultures of belief and disbelief, The — MORALITY Sanford Levinson (r) 1873-92 West on story and theory — L.H. LaRue (r) 1786-91 REMOVAL OF CAUSES MULTINATIONAL CORPORATIONS Removal and the Eleventh Amendment: the case for district court remand discre- Corporation's split personality, The — tion to avoid a bifurcated suit — Benson Herbert Hovenkamp (r) 1792-96 K. Friedman (n) 683-741 OPINIONS REPRESENTATIVE GOVERNMENT See Constitutional History. Expressive harms, “bizarre districts,” and PERIODICAL INDEX voting rights: evaluating election-district appearances after Shaw v. Reno — Index to recent articles and comments ap- Richard H. Pildes & Richard G. Niemi pearing in leading law reviews 199-202, (a) 483-587 480-82, 776-78, 1037-46, 1329- Ugly: an inquiry into the problem of racial 32, 2294-310, 2649-60 gerrymandering under the Voting Rights Act — Daniel D. Polsby & Robert D. PHILOSOPHY Popper (a) 652-82 See also Abortion, Crime, Morality, Public Choice Theory. SECURITIES Book notice — reviewing Holmes: The Hail Britannia?: institutional investor be- Anatomy of Antiliberalism 1547-55 havior under a limited regulation — More democratic liberalism, A — Joshua Bernard S. Black & John C. Coffee, Jr. Cohen (r) 1503-46 (a) 1997-2087 POETRY Monument to a regulatory system, A — Norman S. Poser (r) 1797-807 Practicing poetry, teaching law — David A. Skeel, Jr. (r) 1754-75 SELF-INCRIMINATION POLLUTION Historical origins of the privilege against Environmental TQM: anatomy of a pollu- self-incrimination at common law, The — tion control program that works! — E. John H. Langbein (a) 1047-85. Donald Elliott (r) 1840-54 Taking the fifth: reconsidering the origins of the constitutional privilege against PORNOGRAPHY self-incrimination — Eben Moglen (a) 1086-130. Book notice — reviewing MacKinnon: Only Words 1943-52 SEPARATION OF POWERS PUBLIC CHOICE THEORY See Constitutional Law. Liberal markets — Jeremy Waldron (r) 1456-90 SEXUAL HARASSMENT See Pornography. PUNISHMENT See Crime. SEXUAL ORIENTATION See also Civil Rights. RACE Poised at the threshold: sexual orientation, See also Child Custody, Civil Rights, Elec- law, and the law school curriculum in the tions, Employment Discrimination, Juries, nineties — Jane S. Schacter (r) 1910-28 Representative Government. Book notice — reviewing Spann: Race SOUTH AFRICA Against the Court: The Supreme Court See Human Rights. and Minorities in Contemporary America 1959-65 Michael Jackson pill: equality, race, and cul- STANDING TO SUE ture, The — Jerome McCristal Culp, Jr. Article II revisionism — Cass R. Sunstein (a) 2613-44 (c) 131-38 1994] Index Vii STATE LAW War powers: an essay on John Hart Ely’s Moses and modernism — Neil H. Cogan War and Responsibility — Philip Bobbitt (r) 13467-63 (r) 1364-400 THEORY WOMEN See Philosophy. See also Employment Discrimination. WAR AND EMERGENCY POWERS Book notice — reviewing Bem: The Lenses Executive detention in time of war — of Gender: Transforming the Debate on Richard A. Posner (r) 1675-83 Sexual Inequality 1929-42 ARTICLES “Am I, by Law, the Lord of the World?”: Incommensurability and Valuation in Law How the Juristic Response to Frederick — Cass R. Sunstein 779-861 Barbarossa’s Curiosity Helped Shape Incorporating the Suspension Clause: Is Western Constitutionalism — Charles J. There a Constitutional Right to Federal Reid, Jr. (book review) 1646-74 Habeas Corpus for State Prisoners? — Anticaste Principle, The — Cass R. Jordan Steiker 862-924 Sunstein 2410-55 Inherent Power in Mapping Ownership, Article II Revisionism — Cass R. Sunstein The — Michael P. Conzen (book (correspondence) 131-38 review) 1637-45 Bankruptcy Policymaking in an Imperfect Insider Trading Deterrence Versus Manage- World — Elizabeth Warren 336-87 rial Incentives: A Unified Theory of Sec- Beyond the Reasons Stated in Judgments — tion 16(b) — Merritt B. Fox 2088-203 Giorgio Gaja (book review) 1966-76 Knowledge About Legal Sanctions Brutality in Blue: Community, Authority, — Stephen McG. Bundy & Einer and the Elusive Promise of Police Reform Elhauge 261-335 — Debra Ann Livingston (book Labor Law Successorship: A Corporate review) 1556-76 Law Approach — Edward B. Rock & Caste and the Civil Rights Laws: From Jim Michael L. Wachter 203-60 Crow to Same-Sex Marriages — Richard Liberal Markets — Jeremy Waldron (book A. Epstein 2456-78 review) 1456-90 Civil Procedure: Other Disciplines, Global- Life-Cycle Justice: Accommodating Just ization, and Simple Gifts — Gene R. Cause and Employment at Will — Stewart Shreve (book review) 1401-08 J. Schwab 8-62 Constitution of Reasons, The — Robin L. Life’s Sacred Value — Common Ground or West (book review) 1409-37 Battleground — Alexander Morgan Corporation’s Split Personality, The — Her- Capron (book review) 1491-502 bert Hovenkamp (book review) 1792-96 Light, Shadow, Science, and Law — Allen Divorce, Custody, Gender, and the Limits of D. Boyer (book review) 1622-36 Law: On Dividing the Child — Lee E. Michael Jackson Pill: Equality, Race, and Teitelbaum (book review) 1808-39 Culture, The — Jerome McCristal Culp, Emerging from Emergency: Human Rights Jr. 2613-44 in South Africa — Etienne Mureinik (book review) 1977-88 Monument to a Regulatory System, A — Norman §S. Poser (book review) 1797-807 Employment Discrimination Law in Per- spective: Three Concepts of Equality — More Democratic Liberalism, A — Joshua John J. Donohue III 2583-612 Cohen (book review) 1503-46 Environmental TQM: Anatomy of a Pollu- Moses and Modernism — Neil H. Cogan tion Control Program that Works! — E. (book review) 1347-63 Donald Elliott (book review) 1840-54 Multicultures of Belief and Disbelief, The — Executive Detention in Time of War — Sanford Levinson (book review) 1873-92 Richard A. Posner (book review) 1675-83 No Time for Trumpets: Title VII, Equality, Expressive Harms, “Bizarre Districts,” and and the Fin de Siécle — D. Marvin Voting Rights: Evaluating Election- Jones 2311-69 District Appearances After Shaw v. Reno Objectivity in Legal Judgment — Heidi Li — Richard H. Pildes & Richard G. Feldman 1187-255 Niemi 483-587 Only Girls Wear Barrettes: Dress and Ap- “Hail Britannia?”: Institutional Investor pearance Standards, Community Norms, Behavior Under Limited Regulation — and Workplace Equality — Katharine T. Bernard S. Black & John C. Coffee, Bartlett 2541-82 Jr. 1997-2087 Poised at the Threshold: Sexual Orientation, Historical Origins of the Privilege Against Law, and the Law School Curriculum in Self-Incrimination at Common Law, The the Nineties — Jane S. Schacter (book — John H. Langbein 1047-85 review) 1910-28 In Search of Faulkner’s Law — Richard Politics of the Income Tax, The — Joseph Weisberg (book review) 1776-85 Bankman (book review) 1684-92 Vili 1994] Index ix Postconviction Review of Jury Contemporary Influences — Martha Discrimination: Measuring the Effects of Chamallas 2370-409 Juror Race on Jury Decisions — Nancy Taking the Fifth: Reconstructing the Ori- J. King 63-130 gins of the Constitutional Privilege Power from the People — Milner S. Ball Against Self-Incrimination — Eben (book review) 1725-36 Moglen 1086-130 Practicing Poetry, Teaching Law — David A. Three Mistakes About Interpretation — Skeel, Jr. (book review) 1754-75 Paul Campos (correspondence) 388-97 Race and Redistricting: Drawing Con- Title VII and the Complex Female Subject stitutional Lines After Shaw v. Reno — — Kathryn Abrams 2479-540 T. Alexander Aleinikoff & Samuel Toil of the Firestarters — Peter A. Alces Issacharoff 588-651 (book review) 1707-24 Rediscovering Hegel’s Theory of Crime and Punishment — Markus Dirk Dubber Transcendental Deconstruction, Transcen- (book review) 1577-621 dent Justice — J.M. Balkin 1131-86 Rehabilitating Federalism — Erwin Ugly: An Inquiry into the Problem of Racial Chemerinsky (book review) 1333-46 Gerrymandering Under the Voting Rights Religion and the Search for a Principled Act — Daniel D. Polsby & Robert D. Middle Ground on Abortion — Michael Popper 652-82 W. McConnell (book review) 1893-909 War Powers: An Essay on John Hart Ely’s Strings Attached — Violin Fraud and Other War and Responsibility: Constitutional Deceptions — Carla J. Shapreau (book Lessons of Vietnam and Its Aftermath — review) 1743-53 Philip Bobbitt (book review) 1364-400 Structuralist and Cultural Domination West on Story and Theory — L.H. LaRue Theories Meet Title VII: Some (book review) 1786-91 NOTES Allocating the Burden of Proof To Effectu- Equal Access to Justice Act — Are the ate the Preservation and Federalism Goals Bankruptcy Courts Less Equal than of the Coastal Zone Management Act — Others?, The _ Matthew J. Martin J. LaLonde 438-77 Fischer 2248-86 Are We Compatible?: Current European Intent-Based Approach to the Accept- Community Law on the Compatibility of ance of Benefits Doctrine in the Joint Ventures with the Common Market Federal Courts, An — Benson K. and Possibilities for Future Development Friedman 742-73 — Alyssa A. Grikscheit 968-1033 Public Policy Exclusion and Insurance for Black Identity and Child Placement: The Intentional Employment Discrimination Best Interests of Black and Biracial Chil- — Sean W. Gallagher 1256-326 dren — Kim Forde-Mazrui 925-67 Removal and the Eleventh Amendment: Constitution, the Legislature, and Unfair The Case for District Court Remand Dis- Surprise: Toward a Reliance-Based Ap- cretion To Avoid a Bifurcated Suit — proach to the Contract Clause, The — Mitchell N. Berman 683-741 Robert A. Graham 398-437 When Is the Senate in Recess for the Pur- Constitutionality of Employer-Accessible poses of the Recess Appointments Child Abuse Registries: Due Process Clause? — Michael A. Carrier 2204-47 Implications of Governmental Occupa- tional Blacklisting, The — Michael R. Phillips 139-94