Men portrayed by Browning

213 Pages·010.061 MB·English

by  Davis, Esther Ritter

MEN PORTRAYED BY BROW ING
A T hesis
Presented to
the Faculty of th e School of E nglish
The U niversity of Southern C aliforn ia
In P artial F ulfillm en t
o f the Requirements for the Degree
M aster of Arts in English
by
Esther R itter Davis
June 1950
UMI Number: EP44263
All rights reserved
INFORMATION TO ALL USERS
The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted.
In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript
and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed,
a note will indicate the deletion.
Dissertation Publishing
UMI EP44263
Published by ProQuest LLC (2014). Copyright in the Dissertation held by the Author.
Microform Edition © ProQuest LLC.
All rights reserved. This work is protected against
unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code
ProQuest LLC.
789 East Eisenhower Parkway
P.O. Box 1346
Ann Arbor, Ml 48106 - 1346
£ '«T0 O 3 ^ /
This thesis, written by
[email protected]:
under the guidance of h.&JZ.. Faculty Committee,
and approved by all its members, has been
presented to and accepted by the Council on
Graduate Study and Research in partial fulfill­
ment of the requirements for the degree of
M aster of A rts
Ju n e.............................................................................................
Dean
Date.... Jlima...l95.0._______
Faculty Committee
Chairman
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER PAGE
INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................... 1
C ontradictory in te rp re ta tio n s of
Brovming’s ch aracter p o rtray a ls ..................... 6
Browning’s alleg ed purpose in h is
p o r t r a y a l s ........................................................................ 1 0
Types of men p r e s e n t e d ..................................................14
I BROWNING'S PORTRAYAL OF MEN WHO LIVED
ACCORDING TO AND OPENLY JUSTIFIED A
NEGATIVE PHILOSOPHY OF L I F E .............................................20
The unscrupulous type''of m a n ........................................21
Count Guido Franceschini in "The Ring
and the B o o k " ................................................... 22
The e ld e r man in "The Inn A lb u m " .................25
The Duke of F errara in "My Last Duchess" . 29
The Duke in "The F lig h t of the Duchess" . . 30
A husband in "A F o r g i v e n e s s " ...................................32
The Lover in "Porphyria’s Lover" .................... 35
The Greek in "P ietro o f A b a n o " ......................36
The King in "Instans T y r a n n u s " ......................39
Count G authier in "Count Gismond" ..................... 41
The Doctor in "Doctor— ”■ .............................................44
The Pope in "The Pope and theN et" . . . . 46
iii
CHAPTER PAGE
The s p ir itu a lly warped type of m a n ........................47
Donald in "Donald” ............................................................49
Bishop Blougram in "Bishop Blougram’s
Apology" ............................................................................51
Mr. Sludge in "Mr. Sludge, ’th e Medium’" . 54
Djabal in "The Return of the Druses" . . . 56
Chiappino in "A S o u l's Tragedy" ............................ 5$
The Leader in "The Lost L e a d e r " ..............................64
The Bishop in "The Bishop Orders his Tomb '
a t Saint Praxed’s Church" ...................................... 65
The despicable type of m a n ...................................... 67
The Monk in "Soliloquy of the Spanish
C lo ister" .................................................... . . . . . 6B
Johannes Agricola in "Johannes A gricola
in M e d i t a t i o n " ..................................................................70
Paul Desforges Mai H ard in "The Two
Poets of C r o i s i c " ............................................................72
Hob in "Halbert and H o b " ...........................................75
George Bubb Dodington in "George Bubb
D o d in g to n " ...................................................... 77
The type of man lured by the f l e s h ...............79
Don Juan in "F ifine at the F a i r " ......................$0
Fra Lippo Lippi in "Fra Lippo Lippi" . . . S3
CHAFrER PAGE
Francesco Romanelli In ’’B eatrice
S i g n o r i n i " ......................................................................34
Solomon in ’’Solomon and B alk is” .......................36
II BROWNING’S PORTRAYAL OF MEN WHO WERE
CONSCIOUS OF A POSITIVE PHILOSOPHY OF
LIFE, BUT CHOSE. TO LIVE ACCORDING TO
THE NEGATIVE...........................................................................33
The v in d ic tiv e type of m a n ........................................ 33
The Farmer and Lodovico Buti in
’’F ilippo B aldinucci on th e P riv ileg e
of B u ria l” ......................................................................89
De Lorge in ’’The Glove” ................................................91
The Pied Piper in the ’’Pied Piper
of Hamel in ” ......................................................................93
The type of man who chose a seeming
good and lo s t the b e s t .....................................................94
Cleon in "Cleon” ......................... 95
Karshish in ”An E p istle ” ................................................99
The Duke in "Daniel B a rto li” ...................................100
Prince Berthold in "Colombe’s Birthdajr” . . 102
A ristophanes in "A ristophanes’ Apology” . . 104
The type of man who was a s p iritu a l coward » 106
M artin Relph in "M artin Relph" .......................... 106
V
CHAPTER PAGE
Duke Ferdinand in "The Statue
and the Bust" . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 109
Andrea d e l Sarto in ’’Andrea d e l Sarto” . . • 112
Lover in ’’Too late" . . . . . . . . . . . . . 113
Henry, Earl Mertoun, in "A B lot in
the 'Scutcheon” . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 114
The w ell-in ten tio n ed , but m isguided type
of man 116
P acchiarotto in "Pacchiarotto and How
He Worked in Distem per” . . . . . . . . . . 116
The Grammarian in "A Grammarian's Funeral” 113
Francis Furini in "Francis Furini" . . . . . 122
Leonce Miranda in "Red Cotton Night-Cap
Country" . . . . . • . * • ;. M. . . . . 123
Thorold, Earl Tresham, in "A B lot in the
'Scutcheon” . . . . . . . . . . . 125
Prince H ohenstiel in "Prince E oh en stiel-
Schwangau, Savior of Society" . . . . . . . 126
Wentworth, Earl of S trafford , in
"Strafford" . . . .............................................................128
The P atriot in "The Patriot" .........................129
Caius O ctavius Caesar the August in
"Imperante Augusto Natus E st— " . . . . . . 129
CHAPTER PAGE
T heocrite in rfThe Boy and the Angel" . . . 131
The type of man m ystified by l i f e ..............................132
Caliban in "Caliban Upon Setebos" ....................... 132
The Husband in "The Worst of I t " .........................135
The Lover in "St. M artin’s Summer" . . . . 136
Saul in " S a u l " .......................................................................137
P ietro in "P ietro of Abano” ........................................13$
I I I BROWNING’S PORTRAYAL OF MEN-WHO KNEW AND
LIVED ACCORDING TO A POSITIVE PHILOSOPHY
OF L IF E .................................................................................................140
The type of man whose sense of values,
though r e a l, is not th a t commonly held . . 140
Herv^ Riel in "Herve R i e l " ................................ 140
Ivan Ivanovitch in "Ivan Ivanovitch" . . . 143
The P ain ter in "P icto r Ignotus" ......................... 145
Ned B ra tts in "Ned B r a t t s " .............................146
The lover in "In a G o n d o la " ............................. . 147
The poet in "How I t S trik es a Contemporary” 14$
The type of man redeemed by l o v e ..............................149
Admetos in "B alu stio n ’s Adventure" . . . . 149
The Dying man in " C o n f e s s io n s " ..............................151
Valence in "Colombe’s Birthday" ............................ 152
Rosny in " R o s n y " ..................................................................152
vii
CHAPTER PAGE
Hoseyn in "M ul^ykeh".......................... . . . . . 153
The type o f man -who had the courage of
h is con viction s . . . . . . . . .......................... 155
G iuseppi Caponsacchi in "The Ring and
the Book" . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 156
Horbert in "In a Balcony" .......................... 157
Fust in "Fust and H is Friends" . . . . . . 158
C live in "Clive" . ................................................ 160
John in "A Death in the Desert" 162
Charles Emmanuel in "King V ictor and
King Charles" . . . . . . . . 164
Count Gismond in "Count Gismond" . . . . . 166
Pope S ixtu s in "The Bean-Feast" . . . . . 167
The type of man im m ortalized by
sublim ation of s e lf ................................... 169
Luria in " L u ria" ................................................ 169,
Pheidippides in "Pheidippides" . . . . . . 172
The boy so ld ier in "Incident of the
French Camp" .......................... . . . . . . . . 174
The Ita lia n P atriot in "The Ita lia n
in E n g la n d " .................................................................. 175
The type of man ennobled by a mere glim pse
of in fin ite tru th 176
viii
CHAPTER PAGE
Abt Vogler in "Abt V o g l e r " ........................................177
P aracelsus in "P aracelsus” ......................... 178
S ordello in ”Sordello" .............................................. 1$1
Rene Gentilhomme in "The Two Poets of
C r o i s i c " .................................... 1$3
Lazarus in "An E p i s t l e " .................................... IS4
Ixion in " I x i o n " ..................................................................1£>5
The Lawyer in "Ponte D e ll’ Angelo, Venice" 1B6
Sebald, Ju les, Luigi, and Monsignor in
"Pippa P a s s e s " .............................. 1$3
David in " S a u l " .......................................................................193
Rabbi Ben Ezra in "Rabbi Ben Ezra" . . . . 194
CONCLUSION . ..........................' ........................................................................197
BIBLIOGRAPHY ......................................................................................................... 199