Mechanical Integrity Workshop Notebook

258 Pages·2004·9.17 MB·English

Best Practices Workshop:

Nondestructive Testing
Methods for Mechanical
Integrity
November 9 – 10, 2004
The Pyle Center, Madison, WI
Disclosure
DISCLAIMER OF WARRANTIES AND LIMITATION OF LIABILITIES

THIS COMPILATION OF PRESENTATION MATERIALS FOR THE MECHANICAL
INTEGRITY WORKSHOP WAS PREPARED BY THE IRC. NEITHER THE IRC,
WORKSHOP SPEAKERS, THEIR COMPANIES, NOR ANY PERSON ACTING ON
BEHALF OF THEM:

(A) MAKES ANY WARRANTY OR REPRESENTATION WHATSOEVER,
EXPRESS, OR IMPLIED, (I) WITH RESPECT TO THE USE OF ANY INFORMATION,
APPARATUS, METHOD, PROCESS OR SIMILAR ITEM DISCLOSED IN THESE
WRITTEN MATERIALS, INCLUDING MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A
PARTICULAR PURPOSE, OR (II) THAT SUCH USE DOES NOT INFRINGE ON OR
INTERFERE WITH PRIVATELY OWNED RIGHTS, INCLUDING ANY PARTY'S
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY, OR (III) THAT THE CONTENTS OF THESE WRITTEN
MATERIALS ARE SUITABLE TO ANY PARTICULAR USER'S CIRCUMSTANCE;
OR

(B) ASSUMES RESPONSIBILITY FOR ANY DAMAGES OR OTHER LIABILITY
WHATSOEVER (INCLUDING ANY CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES, EVEN IF THE
IRC, IRC REPRESENTATIVE, OR SPEAKER HAS BEEN ADVISED OF THE
POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGES) RESULTING FROM THE USE OF THE
CONTENTS OF THIS GUIDEBOOK OR ANY INFORMATION, APPARATUS,
METHOD, PROCESS, OR SIMILAR ITEM DISCLOSED IN THESE PRESENTATION
MATERIALS.

THIS NOTEBOOK IS A COPYRIGHTED PUBLICATION AND ITS CONTENTS
SHALL NOT BE REPRODUCED OR DISTRIBUTED WITHOUT PRIOR
WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE IRC.
Best Practices Workshop:
Nondestructive Testing Methods
for Mechanical Integrity
November 9 – 10, 2004
The Pyle Center, Madison, WI
Tuesday, November 9th
8:00 am Welcome and Workshop Goals • ASME Section V - Nondestructive
Doug Reindl, IRC Examination (2001 edition)
• ANSI K61.1-1999/CGA G-2.1-1999
• Review NDT technologies – methods, • IIAR Bulletin 109 & 110
limitations, practices • NBBI 2001 National Board Inspection Code
• Review PSM requirements for NDT (ANSI/NB-23)
• Exchange information between NDT
contractors and end-users 12:00 pm Lunch
• Identify best practices for conducting non-
destructive evaluation for mechanical 1:00 pm MI Focus Area Workshop
integrity IRC staff facilitates – all participate

8:15 am Overview of PSM Requirements Attendees split into break-out groups to
for Mechanical Integrity prioritize areas of focus for insuring the on-
Doug Reindl, IRC going integrity of ammonia refrigeration
systems. Each group will develop a consensus
• Applicability list of priority areas to be shared with other
• Written procedures attendees.
• Components
- Piping 2:15 pm MI Focus Area Workshop
- Vessels Reports
- Insulation IRC staff facilitates – all participate
• Training
Attendees report on the results of their breakout
• Inspection and Testing
groups.
- Methods

- Frequency
2:45 pm Break
- Documentation

- Equipment deficiencies
3:00 pm NDT Best Methods for Ammonia
• Quality Assurance
Refrigeration – Contractor’s
• Relationship to Process Safety Information
Perspective

Jim Kovarik, ConAm Inspections
9:45 am Break

• Selection of NDT Technologies
10:00 am Overview of Current MI
• Damage Mechanisms
Standards in Refrigeration and
• Equipment and methods
Kindred Industries
Daniel Dettmers, IRC • Keys to achieving a successful MI program
• Why should you initiate an MI Program
• API 510 and API 570
4:00 pm Mechanical Integrity
• ANSI/API RP 572-2001
Demonstrations/Reception
• API RP 574

• API RP 575
• Digital Radiographic Profiler: Lixi, Inc.
• ANSI/API RP 576-2000
• Infrared Camera: Infrared Solutions
• ANSI/API RP 578-1999
• Ultrasonic Thickness Gauge: Panametric
• ANSI/ASME B31.3-2002
• Magnetic Particle/Liquid Dye Inspection:
• ANSI/ASME B31.5-2001
Magnaflux
Copyright 2005 - IRC All Rights Reserved
Wednesday, November 10th
8:00 am Mechanical Integrity Field Group 3 – Designing for Mechanical Integrity
Experiences
This group will consider principles associated
• Godan Nambudiripad: General Mills with “designing for mechanical integrity” by
• Dan Webb/Mike Carrell: CF Industries discussing 3 primary questions:
• Bent Wiencke: Nestlé
• Steve Thiery: General Mills • What can designers (and manufacturers) do
to improve the mechanical integrity of
Invited end users will share successes, failures industrial refrigeration systems?
& insights from their MI programs. Time will • What can contractors (refrigeration and
be left at the end for others to speak on their NDT) do to improve the mechanical
experiences. integrity of industrial refrigeration systems?
• What can owners/operators do to improve
10:00 am Break the mechanical integrity of industrial
refrigeration systems?
10:15 am Data Requirements for Best
Practices (Breakout Groups) 12:00 pm Lunch
IRC staff facilitates – all participate
1:00 pm Breakout Group Reports
Group 1 - Inspection Requirements IRC staff facilitates – all participate

The focus of this breakout group is to develop Attendees report on the results of their breakout
priorities for mechanical integrity inspections. groups.

• The group will create a matrix defining the 2:15 pm Workshop Conclusion/Next
probability of a component to fail and the Steps
significance of the failure
• The group will then discuss the frequency, IRC staff summarizes results, lessons and
method and reasonable cost required to lingering questions from the workshop. Group
maintain the integrity of the components decides what further actions need to be taken by
targeted by the matrix. designated organizations, the IRC, the workshop
participants and the industry.
Group 2 - Needs of a proper MI program
2:30 pm Adjourn
This group will consider the needs of a proper
mechanical integrity program by answering the
questions:

• What resources, information, data,
guidance, technology, outside support, etc.
are required to support effective MI
programs in this industry?
• Is this currently available in another
industry, standard or organization?
• If available, does it make sense to import it
to our industry?

Copyright 2005 - IRC All Rights Reserved
Tab 1

Welcome and
Workshop Goals
Doug Reindl, IRC
November 9 – 10, 2004
The Pyle Center, Madison, WI
Copyright 2005 - IRC All Rights Reserved
WWeellccoommee
ttoo tthhee
UUnniivveerrssiittyy ooff WWiissccoonnssiinn
TThhee PPyyllee CCeenntteerr
770022 LLaannggddoonn SStt
MMaaddiissoonn,, WWII
MMeessssaaggeess:: ((660088)) 226622--11112222
FFaaxxeess:: ((660088)) 226622--88551166
Copyright 2005 - IRC All Rights Reserved
University of Wisconsin-Madison
UUnniivveerrssiittyy ooff WWiissccoonnssiinn
AAmmmmoonniiaa RReeffrriiggeerraattiioonn SSeerriieess
IInnttrroodduuccttiioonn ttoo AAmmmmoonniiaa IInntteerrmmeeddiiaattee AAmmmmoonniiaa
RReeffrriiggeerraattiioonn
RReeffrriiggeerraattiioonn SSyysstteemmss
MMaarrcchh 22--44,, 22000055
(cid:132)(cid:132) DDeecceemmbbeerr 77--99,, 22000055
(cid:132)(cid:132)
OOccttoobbeerr 1133--1155,, 22000055
(cid:132)(cid:132) AAuuddiittiinngg PPrroocceessss SSaaffeettyy
AAmmmmoonniiaa RReeffrriiggeerraattiioonn
MMaannaaggeemmeenntt SSyysstteemmss
SSyysstteemm SSaaffeettyy
JJaannuuaarryy 1122--1144,, 22000055
AApprriill 1133--1155,, 22000055 (cid:132)(cid:132)
(cid:132)(cid:132)
EEnneerrggyy EEffffiicciieennccyy
DDeessiiggnn ooff AAmmmmoonniiaa
IImmpprroovveemmeenntt SSttrraatteeggiieess
RReeffrriiggeerraattiioonn SSyysstteemmss
SSeepptteemmbbeerr 1122--1155,, 22000055 FFeebbrruuaarryy 1166--1188,, 22000055
(cid:132)(cid:132) (cid:132)(cid:132)
AAmmmmoonniiaa RReeffrriiggeerraattiioonn PPiippiinngg EEnnggiinneeeerriinngg CCaallccuullaattiioonnss ffoorr
PPrroocceessss SSaaffeettyy aanndd RRiisskk
NNoovveemmbbeerr 22--44,, 22000055
(cid:132)(cid:132)
MMaannaaggeemmeenntt
PPHHAA iinn AAmmmmoonniiaa
RReeffrriiggeerraattiioonn ((NNEEWW))
MMaayy 1188--2200,, 22000055
(cid:132)(cid:132)
Copyright 2005 - IRC All Rights Reserved
SSeepptteemmbbeerr 2288--3300,, 22000055
(cid:132)(cid:132)
LLooggiissttiiccss && OOtthheerr IInnffoorrmmaattiioonn
WWee wwiillll hhaavvee rreeffrreesshhmmeennttss aanndd bbrreeaakkss
tthhrroouugghhoouutt tthhee ddaayy
WWee wwiillll hhaavvee lluunncchh ttooggeetthheerr
TTuurrnn ooffff cceelllluullaarr pphhoonneess aanndd ppaaggeerrss!!
WWeebb tteerrmmiinnaallss aarree aavvaaiillaabbllee ffoorr yyoouurr uussee
Copyright 2005 - IRC All Rights Reserved
OOuurr GGooaallss
UUnnddeerrssttaanndd ffuunnddaammeennttaall pprriinncciipplleess &&
pprraaccttiicceess ffoorr MMII ooff ppiippiinngg ssyysstteemmss ttoo iinnssuurree
tthheeiirr ccoonnttiinnuueedd ssaaffee ooppeerraattiioonn
RReevviieeww NNDDTT mmeetthhooddss ffoorr ppiippiinngg ssyysstteemmss &&
vveesssseellss
RReevviieeww ccuurrrreenntt tteessttiinngg pprraaccttiicceess wwiitthhiinn &&
oouuttssiiddee ooff tthhee iinndduussttrriiaall rreeffrriiggeerraattiioonn iinndduussttrryy
IIddeennttiiffyy ggaappss iinn ccuurrrreenntt rreeccoommmmeennddeedd
mmeecchhaanniiccaall iinntteeggrriittyy pprraaccttiicceess && iiddeennttiiffyy
mmeeaassuurreess ttoo cclloossee tthhoossee ggaappss
Copyright 2005 - IRC All Rights Reserved
UUllttiimmaatteellyy,, OOuurr GGooaall iiss ttoo
MMaakkee iinndduussttrriiaall rreeffrriiggeerraattiioonn
ssyysstteemmss
!
!
SSAAFFEERR
Copyright 2005 - IRC All Rights Reserved