Market Socialism: The Debate Among Socialists

106 Pages·1997·2.19 MB·English

by  David Schweichart

,!
\
MARKET SOCIALISM
ThDee baAtmeo nSgo cialists
Participants
DAVISDC HWECIKART
)AMELSAWLER
HILLEL TICKTIN
BERTEOLLLL MAN
ROUTLEDGE
NewY orka nLdo ndon
i
I
1
}
Contesn t
�,'
Publisihn1e 99d8 b y
Routledge
29W est3 5thS treet Particiipnta hnDete sb ate VII
NewY orkNY, 10001
Introduction 1
PublisihnGe rde aBtr itian1i n99 8b y BERTEOLLLL MAN
Routledge
ParOtn e for
11N ewF ettLearn e
LondoEnC 4P4 EE 1. "MarkSeotc ia:lA iD semfense" 7
DAVISDC WHEICKART
Copyri©g 1h99t8 b yR outledge
2. "Maras xM arkSeocti alist" 23
JAMELSA WLER
Prinitnetd hU en itSetda toefAs m eriocnaa c id-pfarpeeer
Desiagnndt ypograJpahcDyko: n ner ParTtwo against
Alrli ghrtesse edrvN.o p arotft hibsoo k mbea yr eprionrrt eepdr oduocreu dt ilized 3. "ThPer obliesMm a rkSeotc liiasm" 55
HILLTEILC KTIN
ina nfy orm byoa rn ye lecntircmoe,c hanoirco atlh,me era nnso,wk nown or here­
afteirn venitnecdl,u pdhiontgo cionpgy raencdo rdoirin nag n,iy n formsattoiroang e 4. "MarkMeyts tificianCt aipoint aanldiM asrtk Seotc iaSlociisett ies"8 1
orr etriseyvsat,lwe imthopuetr misisnwi roint firnogtm h peu blishers. BERTEOllL LMAN
ParTth ree criticism
LibroafrC yon grCeastsa ilnogg-in-PubDlaitcaa tion 5. SchweoinT cickkatritn 125
MarkSoceita litshmde:e bate Socamioanlgi /se tdsi tbeyBd e rrOeIlllm an; 6. TicktoinnS chweickart 129
patricipaDnatvsiS,dc hwei,caJkmaerLastw leHri,l TIlcekltin, 7. LawloenrO Ilman 173
andB errOeIlllm an 8. OIlmoannL awler 149
p. cm.
Inclubdiebsl iogrraepfheircaeannlcdi e nsd ex. ParFto ur response
ISB0N -4159-69615-.- ISB0N- 41-591697-(3p b)k . 9. Ticktin 159
1.M ixeedc onom2y.. SocialiCsampt.iai lsm3..
10.S chweickart 169
I. OIlman, BSecrhtweelrilctD.k,a a viIdI..
11.O Ilman 177
HB90.M361599 7
12. Lawler 183
33.89-DC21 971-8313
CIP
SeleBciltbi ogroanpM hayr kSeotc ialism 193
Index 197
Particiipnat nhteDs e bate
DaviSdc hweiicaskp arrotf eisnts hoDere partomfPe hnitl osophy at
LoyoUlnai vteyrC,sh iicaHgeho o.l ds iPnh .mDa.tsh ematics (University
ofK entuacnkpdyh )i los(oOphShityoa Utnei verHseii tsty ha)eu. t hor
ofC apitaolrWio srkme Crosn trol? aAnnEd c oEntAohppmiricacaia lsn adl
AgaiCnasptim t,aa nlodif ns umeraorutsio cnMl aerxsi smma,r kseotc ial­
isma,no dt hteorp rieclsa ttose odc itahleioasrntpyd r catice.
James Liaaspw rloefrei sntsh Doeer p amretnotfP hliosoapth ySt thaet e
UniveorfsN ietwYy or k Bautf faanlPdor esiodfte hnSeto cifeottrhy e
PhilosoSpthuiodcfyMa alr xiHsemr .e cehiivPseh d. fDr.o tmh Uen i­
versoifCthyi caHgeo t�ih sae u thoofTr h Eex isteMnatxriiasoJlfme i nas­t
PauSla ratnr1de. 0H.e,er diatnyRd,a citshemed, i otfHo ro w MTuructhh
DoW eT letlh Ceh ieldnrT?h Peo lioftC ihdcirsl'e Lsni teraanthdua wrsre i,t ­
tennu meraorutsi ocntl heiesd eoafMs a r,Hx egealn,Sd a ratsrw ee lals
ond ieffreanstp eocfet dsu cattihoenoarly .
HilTIlceklt iisanR eadeRru sisnai nadEna sEtu ropSetaund aineds
Chairomfta hnCe e ntfeotrrh Set uodfSy o ciTahleiosartnyM d o vements
att hUen iverosfG iltays gHoew .ai lssE odt ioorfC ritJioquurneoa:fl
SociTaheloiryHsi.tPs h .cDo.m efrso tmh Uen iveorfMs oistcyo Hwei. s
thaeu thoofOr r iogfti hnCe r iistnih sUe S STRh:Pe o liEtciocnaoofDlm i ys ­
inegttriaaonnPd o liofRt aiDcciess criimSnio nuaAttfrhii oacnna cd,o -author
ofT heI deaso fL eoTront saknyhd,a wsr itotveeenri ghty oanr tviacrlie­s
outso ipcrse lattote hdet siet les.
Bertelli asOp lrlomfaeinsnts hDoeer p artomfPe onlti attNi ecwYs or k
UniversHiet rye.c eivheidsd octorfartoem OxfoUrndi versHiet iys.t he
V11l MarketS ocialism
authoofAr il einoaMnta:xr s'C ocpnetioofM na ni nC apailtiSsoitce Styo,c ial
anSde xRuealvlui otoann,Dd i aleIcntviiaegctsaitlao nncdso ,- edoifSt tourd ­
iesS oicniP aeldaiggsyoTt,h Leeft aAdecmMya:x rsiStc ahropslo hnAi merican
Camspeutsh,rv eoel u,ma ensTdh Ue. CSo.sn ttiit2ou0nY0:ea rosfC rciti.is m
Introduction
Hei as ltshoce r eaotfto hCrea l sSsrtu gbgolaegr adm e.
BERTEOLLLL MAN
"ChesPhuis[rsae s kAeldi ce}
Woulydo tue mlelp leawshei,wc ahIy o ugthotg of rohme re?"
"That daeg poeodnded aosln w heyroewu a nttog etto s,a"ti hde
Cat.
"Id onm'utc cha wrhee rsea,Ai"ld i ce.
"Thiednto esmna'tttw ehri wcahyy o guo ,s"a tihdCe a t
-LewiCsa rrAolleil'Ac,sd venitnWu ornedelsra nd
Ands oi ti sf oarlo lfu sC.a pitatloidosacymc uapnii ensc reasnianrg­ly
roswt roiflpa nbde twteheuenn neceasnstdah iremy p oisbslwei,tw ha ter
frobmo tshi des woavseihriti n en vgel ra rwgaveerBs u.bt e ftohrbeee lea­
guerpeodp ulasteietkohsnse a foefht iyg hgerro u,tn hdehya vteo pbeer ­
suadtehda t altrheeca odlyo ssal opfcr aopbilteaamrlnseio sotmn ly
gettwionrgbs uet tthheairtise n deahe idg hgerro utnowd h itchhec ya n
decamp. MTahragtacrwheoedtrrs '",sT heirsne oa lter,na"ar tneio vwe
fouonndm illoiflo intpshs we o rolvde Pre.o pwlheob elitehvwieis l l put
upw itahl moasntdy e groefse u effriWnhgy.b othteosr t grgulfeoa r
chantgheac ta nnboetT? h ec olloaftp hsSeeo viUenti osne etmosh ave
reinftohrvicisee dodw d,l eyn oguhe,v en ammaonnoygn t hLee ftw ho
nevceorn sitdheSero evdUi neitao m no dela noyft. hI intn hghiiss torical
setttihnoogsf,ue sw hob elitehvaaqet u alitsautpievareliltoyer r insa tive
possiblgei vtmeopu prs ito troei xtpyl aainnpdio nrgt rwahyaittnh gii ss,
sot hapte opwlielh alv aeg oorde asfoocnrh oosoinnpega tihn ttoh e
futurraet her thaDne vaenloootpuhicrenr rgi. t iocfci aspmist alism is
simpnloyet n ouigifhet ,v ewra. sN owm,o rteh aenv esro,c iamluisstt s
devomtoero efo uart tention to-socialism.
Mansyo ciailnti hsUetn si tSetda atneedsl seewh haevbree gutno
resptoont dh cirsi isnbi esl biyeg fi vifuntgu preo ssibainil nictrieeass­
ingilmyp orptlaanictnte h eaicrc ooufpn rte sternbotlu eOsn.eg roofu p
2 Market Socialism Introdnu 3c tio
sociawlhiohs atvdseo nteh miosr sey stemlayat,ni dc amploerres ilsyt,e nt madoefh imT.h eo rdoeftr h beo oiksa s f ollPoawrIst-:e ssbayys
thapne rhaanpyso enleas rete h owsheoh avceo mteo cbael "lmeadr ket Schweairatcn kLda wltehrda etf emnadr kseotc iaPlairIstIm -;e sbsya ys
soci,aw"lii tsththr see sttu hlamta rkseotc iailnsio swom n oeft hmea in Tickatnimdne t hoaptp ois(tet ghree alteenrgo tfmh ye ssiadsyu teo the
toipcosfd ebaotnte h Lee fwto r-lwdiTdhee.m a iqnu eisotnasd dressed fatchta hta lfi dtoe faw listt hhm ea rkienct a pittahluoisffes rmi,on nge
herien cl-uWdheati msa rkseotc iaHloiwsw mo?u lidwt o r?kW hich possciobnlteie nx tw htiov cihet wh een tdierbea PtaerI)tI; I -shorter
ofo ucru ernrptr oblemsi stw ooluwvlhedi, lc eha uvnet ou?cH hoewd pieicne s whSicchhw earictcr kizteiTsicc kitiTnic,k tcirni tiSccihzwees­
woulidct omaeb o?uW thaitsi trse latcipaoint atloHi oswdm o?e ist ick,aL ratwlcerri etsim ceia,nz Idc riticize LaIwVl-eargn;a iand Part
compawrietm ho rter adivtiisoinoaofsln o sc iaDliidMs amr?x at ake shoprite icnew sh iecahc ohfu sr espotnotd hcser itimcaidsoemfh s i m.
posiotnii otWn?h at odtohs eorc iafilnids tlsai cnik tai,nn wdgh adto Whatesviedre r eteahrdee vn etulaycl omdeosw onn o,u hro piets h at
thepyr opionstsee?a I dnt hper esveonmlteu f,o ur socia,wl hios t scholars heo r wsihbleel a blteor esptooMn adr agrTehta tcahnehdre c ro -skep­
havbee edne epilnyv olivnte hddi esb ate-ttwwoao g fnaosirt,-i gve tics fwriectsohhn vitchtatitho enir sien deaenad l ter.nA antdpi,ev re­
theainrs wteotr hse qsuee stions. hap,ks nowiwnhge wreew anttog ou,n liAkleiw ceec ,aa nto nceo uste t
Firsptrv,oi saTo h.ef ouorfu s waerleal w atrhea ttho ep preosfs ed int hrei gdhitr ection.
thwiosr alrdne o ats ki"nHogw d ow eo rngiazseoc iteoot byt aami onr e
efficiuesnoetfr esou?rL"ci eksewfiotsrhe e,"m D,wo e n eemdo rweo rk­
ercso'o oprsa r atieocnoanlo pmlniac?i "sn oatp ressqiunegs tion.
Insttehaedy, twoka nnotw hocwo nttohefetn hte liirvw eisbl elb etter
undseorc iaWlilitlsh meh.ya vmeo rien tsetriesnagf,e r, haingdh er paid,
morsee cujroebW si?l l stthibelewy lo rriedn oahtbva oiunetgn ough
monetyob uy tthhient ghsew ya nt? tWhieglyel t etdhuec aatnido n
medihcealltp h atth efiarm inleye dWsi?lt lh esyt ihlavlbe o ssaensd
landlaonrdd sc arnodo-kys ecso-pwsh ot hretahteewiner lb le iinng
som anwya yasn mda kteh eamnx ioaunsad f ir?daM osotft hree st is
"mecha,ni"im cpsorttoa nbte b ustiu,ntr heee,y eosfm osptep olteob, e
takuepno nlayft etrh eesses enatrsiepa olkste oYn.et e,v eernycd o mes
witihta sp propmreiaa.nWt siet hout igonfto hreiqsnuege sattnihyoe n s,
authooftr hsbi oso hka vbee emna incloyn cewrintdehed fi gnt ihnset ruc­
turraelf otrhmast bcroiuanlbgdo tuhte nseee dcehda nTgheews o.r okf
translwahtaitneigvso e fvr a liunoe u src holeaxrclhyai nngtdeoi rect
answteowr hsa pte opalraeec tuaaslkliryne gmn asio,fc osuera,no ngo­
incgh allenge.
DavSicdh weari,tca]kmeLsa wlHeirl,Tl icektli ann,Idp articiinp ated
ad ebaotnme a rkseotc iaaltti hSseom c iisSatcl ho'Cl oarnsferienNn ecwe
YorkC itiynA pr1i99l5. W e havaelb le einn volivnse idmr id leabates
witeha coht haenrwd i toht hsecrh olars at variinot uhse meetings both
UniedtS taatneadsb ro,aa ndwde h avaelw lr itattreinco lnte hssi usb ­
jectS-cihnw eiccka,ast rewtboo'o sks. I nt hper esveonltu wmeeh ,a ve
triteocd o nvneoyot n loyuv ri eownsm arkecti aslboiusatml ssoo me­
thionftg h ien teecltleuxacli tetmhaceotnm tfe rso bme inagd eibnao tfe
thkiisn Sod r.a tthheasrni mpsltya tipnogis toiueoran csh,u sao lfcs roi t­
icizoensep ersofnr omt heo thesri dea,n dt henre sopndst oc riticisms

1.
MarkeSto cialAi sDme:f ense
DAVISDC HWEICKART
Iti ns oatl am oedt hedsaeyt soa dvocsaotcei aolfai nssymo . rT thep un­
dihtasv set oprpeepde atthimena gn ttrhaas to ciailsdi esaamdn tdh at
libecpraiatla ilsti hsteme loofhs i stTohriiyssn. o l ongneerwI sti. sa n
accep"atfce.tdS" o ciaildsie samd .
Thed eactehr tihfaibsce aetne sniogotnn elfdyoc rl ascsoimcmaaln d
. .11
sociablufitos armlv le rsoifmo anrsk seotc ialwieslwmli ,toa hrsw ithout
workseerl f-emmaennaHtgu.n gareicaonn oJmainsKotos r n,oa nicaen
advocoafmt aer kseotc ia,nl oiwcs omnfidaesns:te lryt s
Classsioccailai lasic somh erseyns.tt e.mC. a.pi tailasc i oshme rseynst­
te.m .T.h.ea t tetmorp eta lmiazreks eotc iaolnti hsoemt ,h hearn pdr,o ­
ducaensi ncohseyrsetnietnwm h,i tchhe arreee l emetnhtarste peealc h
othtehrde:o minaonfpc ueb loiwcn erasnhtdih poe p eraotfti homena r­
keatr neo cto mpat!i ble.
Asf osre mlafn-aegme,n t"iisot n eo ft he deaodft- herene dfso rm
prosc".e2 s
There laeratesw tgoa o to rde anssoo,n teh eor,et thoietc haelr empiri­
catlo,d issfernoKtmo rnafia'ssh iowniasbdloFemi .ro sfat l tlh,e hraes
develoovpeterhdl e a tswte nyteyaa rl sa rbgoedo yft heorleittiecraalt ure
concewrintemhda r kaeltt erntaoct paiivteastl hiarstem a cahd eiesffr ent
concluSseicoon,nt} dh mleoy sdty naemciocn oimnty hw eo rrlidg nhotw ,
encompassosm1ie.n bg2i llpiepoolnie ms,a rkseotc i.a list
,1\
CHINA
Iifit ns o ftah sionatbod leef esnodc iatlhiessme, i itdes av yesns lore os s
defeCnhdi nAatl. e aosntt h lee tfhte re remsatianl dwseaofrmeten ders
ofs ociisambl,ul te rfti,tg o,hrc entneoor n,le i kCehsi naC.h iItnnha e re
areex ecuthiuomnarsni, g vhitosl atliaocknd se,om fro accwyo,r kers
8 MarkSeotc ialism MarkSeotc iaAl Diesfme:n 9s e
workuinndge exrp loictoantdiivtmeii soonngsyey,,n virondmeegnrtaa­l mentisnm odefranr imm plemaennndte swc onsumerF ogtroh oed s.
datiaonpndo lictoircpratuliM oonr.e oCvheirn,a pnroco ojmelpcletisn g workpienogp ilnte hc ei wthyou ntaiy le aorrs oa ghoa tdol itvher ough
internatviiosnitaohlnami tis gthr ta lwloyr koefrt shw eo rolrdt he thwei ntoencr a bbaangrdeo octr oapnsbd u wyh afte owt hveerg etables
wretcohfte hdee a hr.t anfdr uwietrasev ailoaftfbh lfeer osziedne wtahlpekl se,t ohfbo arnaa nas,
Chiinnsao itn spirnaotwti howena ayRl u sswiaias nt haeft ermoaft h oransgtersa,w bgerrereainnemsdse ,a otfas l kli ntdhsac tan no wb ep ur­
thBeo lshReevovilku toirao snC ,h iwnaafs ro m anoyn t hLee fitnt he chasienid n doomra rkyeetrasor u hnadcs h antgheeidlr i vaentsdh ediire t.
1960osr a sVi etnoarmN iacragourCa u bhaa vbee en.w iOsnhteeh sta ht e Acrotshnsea timoenac to nsumpptecirao pnhi atisan cresaosmteewd o
deefcotfCs h niesseo ciweetrnyeo stog larTihnegir.ase4r oflroeu topian anadh atlifm seisn 1c9e8 M0.i lloifow nosr khearvsge a inneedwh ous­
imagienrap y o liptriocjaseluc casth s oci.aWl ei nsemesdt irvriisnigo ns. indgu ri"nrge fo{rtmhssec, a"qr ueo taerWsee ilb'usib]ly tt h eeinrt er­
Wen eedb eat botl oei magwihnaeit sa ,sy e"ton,w he.rY"eet t heirasel so prisseots h,a t twtoho ert hrfeaem itlhiaets tuoss headar s ei ngle
an eefdror ealism itnh aeac scsolemispsshimanengnfd tal siu roefas c tual apartnmoewen atc hha ve otwhnhe oimre s. tWhileta hfsietnmw o nths,
histoerxipmceearnlit Ssi.nt cheea rrfeee ew xrpeimemnotrsme o mentous thweo rwke eikns taotwen efidr mhsa bse elno wefrreodfm o rty-eight
thawnh aitns o wt ranspiinCr hiinnwgae n, e etdot hicnakru elfalbyo ut houtrofs o rruyra-,m f aojaonrwd i dewleyl coimmepdro vement.7
whacta ann cda nnot befo rmdt ehdCeuh cienedex srpeei ence.
Ifb y" sociawlemi esaman"m odeercno nowmityh otuhtme a jor Theem pireivciadle nces udgogeteshs aCtnth o itin Usat opIitiafs .a r
meanosfp roudctiionpn r ivhaatned s, thiescn l eCaahr ilsnyoa c ialist formt haCtr.i tairneco swt r ontgob ec oncearbnoehudut m arni gvhitos­
econoNmoyto. n ly doedse sCchiritinsbaaees" l mafr kseotcl iiasbtu,t" latitohnlesa ,co kfg enudienmeo crwaocryke,ex rp loi(teavtiidoenn ced
thsee -ldfescriisep mtpiiorniw cealllol-uygn rd.Ae sdo f1 990o, nl5y. 1 bya,m onogt htehri nagh so,r rendooufis n druasattcerc iiadlte hnet s),
percoefCn hti sn aG'NwPa sg enaetrebdyt h"ep rtievs"ae ctAonrd) marekdlhyi ghiefnnart m orittaryla tferos gtihralfnsrob oy,es nviron­
despciotnes iderabloeff roqeuicagannpt ifitltaoilwei isnn ttgoh c eo un­ mentdaelg radaantwdii odne esapcdro rprtuiNoenv.te hrelCehsnisa,' s
tr(ym osftorlmyH onKgo nagn Tda iwamno,s tilnytj oo ivnetn tures), reaaclc polmishmheanvbtees es nr unnIifsn ogc.i ailsai nes mma ncipa­
that poofCr htniieosinen vestimnfe inxte d uatsisleiftunzsdi fsnor gm i torpyr ojceocntc ewrinteihdm provtihrneeg ma alt ecroianld iotfi ons
abroiaosdn ltyh irpteerecn(e aonsft1 993)a,n d emplofyuosrp ebra­rely repaelo palnend,o a tna ll--noorthUitnogp iatnhiessnom c,i aoflg iosod ts
cenotft hneo n-agriwcourolkrtfcusero,am le ofirsv imexi llwioorenkr s. wi(lpla irctultahrolosyfue sw hoh avree gualcacrte osb sa na,ns atsraw­
Byw ayo fc ontrtahsewtre,er aeso, f1 991s,o m2e. m4i llciooonp erative berrgireeesn,sa ,nd m easth)o unlodbt e tqouoi tcokd ismtihsess e
firmsC hiinne am,p loy36im nigl lwioorenkr asn,ad n ot1h00em ri llion acmcpolishments.
workeemrpsl oiynse tda te-eonwtneerd.p rises MoreoCvhenira,d' esv elnotptamrlea jercetmoaruiynn csl Ietiap sro .s ­
Thi"sic nohermeanrtks"eo tc ialishta bsee cesontn roimkysi uncg­ly sibtlheat thc eo ntradoifCc htniieossneos c iawliilislnm t ieyfnt sot he
'l
I
ceuslsaf,v eirnaaggn ansitsgoh itpneenr cpeenyrte ar annual growtIh rate poinsto coeifxa psll iooInti.s also possibled aetynh taetr China will one
ovetrhp ea sfittfe eyne adrusr,iw nhgi tcihm ree paelcr a iptcao nsumption I threa nokfcs a piistamBl.ut th owsheom ainttahien ibnielvoiifott nyae
hamso rteh adno ub,lh eosduinsgp ahcaeds o ub,lt ehidena fnmto rittayl or botht hoeefsv ee nittuiaaerlisest ,e etmosm er,e daignt elae easvW.e
ratheabs e ecnu bty m orteh afinf tpye rctehnnetu ,m boefdr o ctors has don oyte ktn ohwo wt he nCehseiex piemrewnitcl olm oeu Cth.i mnaay
icnreabsyfie fdtp ye rcaennldtei ,e f xpectagnocnyfeor mhs aisx ty-seven remnam iasteorft hper odtuiecvnee rightia eussn leaasnhmdea dym, o ve
tos eveAnntdyo .nt oopf a ltlh iisn,e qtuyaa,slm ieasubryet dhG ei ni tod emocriattsiaenzltdefo a ddrietossts h gerra dveefi cieTnhcitisoe os .
coeffichiaeasnc tt,u deacllilnsyedu bsitaalnltyt-otd uhleeo weroiftn hge ipso ssible.
incodmieeff renbteitawlet eonwa nn cdo untErvyes.no6s keptainc al Ina neyv nett,om aintianti hfneca e soufcp ho werefuvli detont chee
obsearsv eRro Wbeielwr,hto t augahttJ iUlniivne orfTs ecihtnyo liong y cnotrtahryam ta rkseotc iailsui nswmo rikssa ublrepe rloyb lteiTmcha.e
Changch1u99n3 c,io nn cedes: EastEeurrno peecaonn omwihsost ocs o nfidemnatdsleuy c ahs steirons
and swohw oh oleheeamrbtreadtclheyped r itviaaztiaonnfde r e-market­
Changcuhnuinv esrtsuidteywn htos ,c ome epvoeonrp eefrar soamn t izatoifto hneo iwrne conowmoiueldsdo w eltloc ompatrhweer eckage
backgrospeaku nodfst ,ht er ansfoorftm haetviiirol nl waigteihsn ,v est- idnucbeydt hereifro trowm hsa atm arkseotc ialwirosugm hhtas.