2 0 1 5 VIRTUAL ISSUE NO. 3 M E T H O D S i n C S PROCEEDINGS OF THE ARISTOTELIAN SOCIETY T H E V I R T U A L I S S U E An Aristotelian Society Publication 2 0 1 5 VIRTUAL ISSUE NO. 3 M E Guest Editor Ben Colburn T H O D S ii n Henry Sidgwick J. H. Muirhead G. F. Stout S. Alexander E. E. Constance Jones G. C. Field Margaret MacDonald C C. D. Broad Michael Tanner Mary Midgley Onora O’Neill Robert Stern Philip Stratton-Lake S Frank Jackson Brad Hooker Justin Clarke-Doane Lorna Finlayson Robert Cowan Anna Bergqvist Roger Crisp Connie Rosati Sophie Grace Chappell Jimmy Lenman PROCEEDINGS OF THE ARISTOTELIAN SOCIETY First published in 2015 by The Aristotelian Society © The Aristotelian Society 2015 Produced and designed for digital publication by the Aristotelian Society, London. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored or transmitted in any form or by any means without the prior permission in writing activities & publications from the Aristotelian Society. The Aristotelian Society, founded in 1880, meets honorary director fortnightly in London to hear Rory Madden, and discuss philosophical University College London papers. The Proceedings is published as a journal in editor one annual print edition, Matthew Soteriou, with three online journals University of Warwick appearing via Wiley Online Library in March, guest editor June and September. The Ben Colburn, Supplementary Volume, University of Glasgow published annually in June, contains the papers to be managing editor read at the Joint Session of Hannah Carnegy, the Aristotelian Society and University College London the Mind Association in July. The Virtual Issue, published project editors annually in the autumn, Mark Cortes Favis and contains classic papers Josephine Salverda, from the Society’s archive. University College London Information about individual subscriptions can be found on graphic design the Society’s website at LO/LA www.aristoteliansociety.org. uk. table of contents Classic the language of methods in ethics: political theory introduction Margaret MacDonald..106. .19..................Ben Colburn Commentary ‘never go to sleep’: Classic political theory as a is the distinction foreign language between “is” and .126...........Lorna Finlayson “ought” ultimate and irreducible? Henry Sidgwick, J. H. Muirhead, G. F. Stout Classic some reflections on and S. Alexander............24. moral-sense theories in ethics Commentary is the distinction C. D. Broad..................136. between “is” and “ought” ultimate and Commentary c.d. broad on moral irreducible? sense theories in ethics .50................Frank Jackson .168.............Robert Cowan Classic practical dualism Classic E. E. Constance Jones....62. examples in moral philosophy Commentary Michael Tanner............184. on jones’s ‘practical dualism’ Commentary .72..................Brad Hooker thick description revisited: tanner on thick concepts and perspectivalism in value Classic philosophy the place of definition .202............Anna Bergqvist in ethics G. C. Field.....................82. Commentary Classic objectivity in ethics and the neutrality of the mathematics moral philosopher .98......Justin Clarke-Doane Mary Midgley..............218. Commentary in defence of (a sort of) neutrality .236.................Roger Crisp Classic constructivisms in ethics Onora O’Neill..............244. Commentary o’neill’s ‘constructivisms in ethics’ .262..............Connie Rosati Classic the relation between moral theory and metaphysics Robert Stern.................274. Commentary from metaphysics to ethics via philosophy of mind: three routes .290.............. Sophie Grace Chappell Classic why externalism is not a problem for ethical intuitionists Philip Stratton-Lake.....310. Commentary why externalism is a problem for ethical intuitionists .324............Jimmy Lenman METHODS IN ETHICS: INTRODUCTION by Ben Colburn VIRTUAL ISSUE NO. 3 | 2015
Description: