Table Of Content

RY CD A CM R CD B LI ^l" W CD LA CO KIN o LABOUR ARBITRATION S A CD L A R O co B CASES AND MATERIALS PREPARED BY LAURA TRACHUK WITH THE ASSISTANCE OF KENNETH P. SWAN AND STEPHEN PARKS JANUARY 2002 LABOUR ARBITRATION CASES AND MATERIALS PREPARED BY LAURA TRACHUK WITH THE ASSISTANCE OF KENNETH P. SWAN AND STEPHEN PARKS JANUARY 2002 Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2018 with funding from University of Toronto https://archive.org/details/labourarbitratioOOtrac LABOUR ARBITRATION - CASES AND MATERIALS TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER ONE - Introduction Page Labour Relations Act, 1995 ss, 48-50 1 Employment Standards Act ss. 99-101 5 Hospital Labour Disputes Arbitration Act ss. 5-9 8 Kevin Burkett, “Cost and Delay in Labour Arbitration: Is There a Silver Lining? in 1997 Labour Arbitration Yearbook, p.317. John Kagel, “Mediating Grievances” in Arbitration 20 1993; Proceedings of the 46th Annual Meeting of the National Academy of Arbitrators (Washington: B.N.A., 1994), p.76 CHAPTER TWO - Jurisdiction Weber v. Ontario Hydro (1995), 125 D.L.R. (4th) 583 34 (S.C.C.) District of Parry Sound Social Services Administrative 51 Board and Ontario Public Service Employees Union, Local 324, Decision of the Ont. C.A. June 19, 2001 Rick MacDoweil, “Labour Arbitration - The New Labour 66 Court?” in Canadian Labour and Employment Law Journal (2000) Vol.8 No. 2 p.121 George Surdykowski, “The Limits of Grievance 95 Arbitration: Weber and Pilon in Perspective” in 1999 Labour Arbitration Yearbook p. 67 Page 2 CHAPTER THREE - Impartiality, Neutrality and Independence O. P. S. E. U. (Kowal) and Crown in Right of Ontario 99 (Ministry of Health) G.S.B. File 813/88, December 21, 1989 (Verity) Ontario Medical Association and The Province of Ontario 114 June 8, 1995, (Burkett) Canadian Union of Public Employees and Service 132 Employees International Union and the Minister of Labour for Ontario, Decision of the Ont. C.A. November 21,2000 now reported at (2000) O.R. (3d) 417 CHAPTER FOUR - The Arbitration Process Re Dartmouth General Hospital, Toronto and 166 C.U.P.E. Local 1156 {1988) 1 L.A.C. (3d) 444 (Langille) Re Scarborough General Hospital and Ontario Nurses’ 169 Association,(1996) 60 L.A.C. (4th) 170 (Langille) Re Canada Post Corp. and Canadian Union of 173 Postal Workers,(1993) 35 L.A.C. (4th) 300 (Christie) Re Maple Leaf Pork and United Food and Commercial 181 Workers International Union, Local 1227, (1999) 84 L.A.C. (4th) 62 (Armstrong) Re Clarke Institute of Psychiatry and Ontario Nurses’ 189 Association,(1995) 45 L.A.C. (4th) 284 Page 3 CHAPTER FIVE- Arbitral Doctrines and Evidence Re Meadow Park Nursing Home and Service Employees 194 InternationalUnion, Local 220, (1983), 9 L.A.C. (3d) 137 (Swan) Re Crowne Plaza Ottawa and Hospitality and Service 200 Trades Union,Local 261, (2000) 92 L.A.C. (4th) 357 (Browne) Re City Wide Taxi and Ontario Taxi Union (U.S. W.A.), 206 Local 1688,(1999) 78 L.A.C. (4th) 428 (Baum) Re Quaker Oats Co. of Canada Ltd. and Service Employees 222 Union, Local 183(2000) 91 L.A.C. (4th) 1 (Emrich) Bernie Adell “Evidence in Labour Arbitration: Is There 233 Too Much Pressure to Admit Almost Everything?” (1997) 23 Queen’s L.J. 67. CHAPTER SIX - Judicial Review Regina v. Barber et.al., Ex parte Warehousemen and 258 Miscellaneous Drivers' Union Local 419, (1968) 68 D.L.R. (2d) 682 Oshawa Wholesale Ltd. and Ontario Produce Co. Ltd. v 264. Warehousemen and Miscellaneous Drivers Union Local 419et.al.( 1971) 71 CLLC 14,094 Board of Education for the City of Toronto v. Ontario 265 Secondary School Teachers’ Federation, District 15 (1997) 97 CLLC 220-018 (S.C.C.) Essex County Roman Catholic School Board v. Ontario 280 English Catholic Teachers’ Assn., [2001] O.J. No. 3602 Docket No. C34932 (Ont. C.A. decided September 13, 2001) Page 4 Toronto Catholic District School Board v. Ontario English 288 Catholic Teachers’ Assn. (Toronto Elementary Unit), [2001] O.J. No. 3748 Docket No. C35667 (Ont. C.A. decided September 24, 2001) Kenneth P. Swan, “Ships Passing in the Night: 295 Miscommunications Between Arbitrators and the Courts”, now published in 1999-2000 Labour Arbitration Yearbook p.1.