Table Of Content

LEADING ARTICLES — AUTHORS Abeyratne, Ruwantissa I. R., Would Competition in Commercial Bennun, Mervyn E., Prosecuting Professional Pilots in the United Kingdom After November Oscar: Reflections on the Law and Burt, James L. III, Bogus Aircraft: Offenses and Defenses Gleimer, Eileen M., Slot Regulation at High Density Airports: How Did We Get Here and Where are We Going? ...........+++++++: 877 Kenney, Stephen C., Recent Developments in Aviation Law O’Connor, Kathleen M. & Sreenan, Gregory P., Apportionment of Damages: Evolution of a Fault-Based System of Liability for Negligence Sweeney, Terence, The Requirement of Notice in the Warsaw Convention Tarry, Scott E. & Truitt, LawrenceJ. , Rhetoric and Reality: Tort Reform and the Uncertain Future of General Aviation Truitt, R. Daniel, Hints of an Uneven Playing Field in Aviation Feete: Fs TRG PUIG «ones cccscvccccscesssescessoseecensces 577 LEADING ARTICLES — TITLES Apportionment of Damages: Evolution of a Fault-Based System of Liability for Negligence, Kathleen M. O’Connor & Gregory Bogus Aircraft: Offenses and Defenses, James L. Burt, III Hints of an Uneven Playing Field in Aviation Torts: Is There Proof?, R. Daniel Truitt 1056 JOURNAL OF AIR LAW AND COMMERCE Prosecuting Professional Pilots in the United Kingdom After November Oscar. Reflections on the Law and Policy, Mervyn E. Bennun Recent Developments in Aviation Law, Stephen C. Kenney Rhetoric and Reality: Tort Reform and the Uncertain Future of General Aviation, Scott E. Tarry & Lawrence J. Truitt Slot Regulation at High Density Airports: How Did We Get Here and Where are We Going?, Eileen M. Gleimer The 1990 Independent Safety Board Act Amendments, Craig Would Competition in Commercial Aviation Ever Fit Into the World Trade Organization?, Ruwantissa I. R. Abeyratne COMMENTS Bankruptcy of Airlines: Causes, Complaints, and Changes, PUNO, HEE G. cc ccccvicccvcpecccccssoteccccovccecceses 1017 Cabin Air Quality in Aircraft: What is the Problem? What is Being Donore Wh at Can be Done AboutIt ? Who Can Do It and How?, Smith, Anita Jean Employee-Owned Airlines: The Cure for an Ailing Industry?, Caver, "Fly to London for $298”: The Battle Between Federal and State Regulation of Airfare Advertising Heats Up, Blacker, Jonathan. 205 Global Positioning System (GPS): Defining the Legal Issues of Its Expanding Civil Use, Epstein, Jonathan M HIV Employment Discrimination in Air Transportation, McCormack, NAFTA Dispute Resolution Provisions: Leaving Room for Abusive Tactics by Airlines Looking Southward, Barber, Michael Potential Liability From Electromagnetic Interference with Aircraft Systems Cause by Passengers’ On-Board Use of Portable Electronic Devices, Ritchie, Carolyn (Re)Learning to Fly: Russian Aviation in the Post-Soviet Era, Howie, GENUS c0escvecvscentvapessestensncscdcessseesnencsenes Schleier v. Commissioner: The Supreme Court’s Response to the Split Among Circuits Over Taxability of ADEA Awards, Baker, Lizbeth 1996] INDEX 1057 The Japanese Initiative on the Warsaw Convention, Baden, Naneen K. The United States’ Response to International Air Safety, Manning, Shirlyce Hawaztian Airlines, Inc. v. Norris: Railway Labor Act Preemption of State-law Claims, Stieber, Kathryn 1058 JOURNAL OF AIR LAW AND COMMERCE [61 TABLE OF CASES Abramson v. Japan Airlines Co. ... 449 Bowdry v. United Airlines, Inc. .... 67 Aerolineas Argentinas v. United Boyle v. United Technologies GD kteroncveesaegenernes 82, 83, 84 Alaska Airlines, Inc. v. Johnson .... Bradley v. Appalachian Power Co. 372 Alessi v. Raybestos-Manhattan, Inc.. Brakeman v. Potomac Insurance Aloha Airlines, Inc. v. Ahue Co. Alvarez v. Servicios Aereos de Hon- Broin v. Phillip Morris Companies, Brosnahan v. Western Air Lines, ih wo oad arh il pic kt 707, 708, 709 Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp. Andrews v. United Airlines, Inc. . 63, v. Federal Trade Commission .. . 571 "708, 709 Budden v. United States Argenbright Security v. Ceskosloven- Bullwinkel v. FAA ske Aeroline 73 Burke v. Northwest Airlines, Inc. .. Argubright v. Beech Aircraft Corp. 627 Butterfield v. Forrester Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe Rail- way v. Buell 774, 782, 784, 787 Avemco Insurance Co. v. Cessna PE ecetviwnicsseoncens 119 Carlucci v. Piper Aircraft Corp... 173, 174 Baker v. Delta Airlines, Inc Carnival Cruise Lines, Inc. v. Balani Impex Ltd v. Malaysian Air- 415, 417, 422, 423, 424 line System Berhad Celotex Corp. v. Catrett Bancorp Mortgage Co. v. Bonner Chan v. Korean Air Lines, Ltd Mall Partnership 410, 415, 417, 419, 420, 421, Banner Advertising, Inc. v. People . 422, 423, 424, 425, 426, 427 Barber v. United States Childers v. Northwest Airlines, Inc. 676 Chouest v. American Airlines, Inc. . 15 City of Grapevine v. Department of Baugh v. Trans World Airlines .... Transportation Bayne v. Adventure Tours USA, Inc. 16 Cipollone v. Liggett Group, Inc... . Beaudet v. British Airways, PLC ... Cleburne v. Cleburne Living Center 295 Beck v. Thompson Cleveland v. Piper Aircraft Beech Aircraft Corp. v. Rainey .... Corp. Beyer v. Beech Aircraft Co. ..... 174, 175, 178, 179 Commander Properties v. FAA .... Block v. Compagnie Nationale Air Commercial Energies, Inc. v. United CEC iccacapeneetaeaen Blum v. RES Associates, Ltd. ...... 100 Commissioner v. Glenshaw Glass . . Board of Commissioners v. Issac. . . 110 Consolidated Rail Corp. v. Railway Board of County Commissioner v. Labor Executives’ Ass’n 773, 783, 784 Bocre Leasing Corp. v. General Mo- Continental Airlines, Inc. v. Intra SPC. svc ccccericcsnnedesas RE 4 0 tnanaddawueer 78 Booher v. United States Department : 750, 751, 752, 753 of Transportation Cortes v. Delta Air Lines, Inc Boswell v. Bludworth Bond Ship- Cosgrove v. McDonnell Douglas He- es ctabsencacevcacienave licopter Co 1996] INDEX County of Westchester v. Commis- Finley v. United States sioner of Transportation FMC Corp. v. Holliday Craig v. Atiantic-Richfield Co Glenn v. Cessna Aircraft Co. ...... Csizmazia v. Sabena Belgian World Globe Newspaper Co. v. Superior 567, 568, 573, 574 Culinary Foods, Inc. v. Raychem Gluckman v. American Airlines, Inc. 78 GU x esccsensescenceuscnenss Goldsmith v. Olon Andrews, Inc... 870 Curley v. American Airlines, Inc. .. Gould v. Aerospatiale Helicopter Dahelite v. United States Datskow v. Teledyne Continental Motors Aircraft Products Gustafson v. City of Lake Angelus. 109 Davis v. Bender Shipbuilding and Haley v. United Airlines, Inc. ... 706, 710 Repair Co., Inc. ........00c000. 62 Hamdeh v. American Airlines, Inc. 42 Dean v. Sikorsky Aircraft Haper & Cannuli v. Cessna Deutsche Lufthansa Aktiengesell- Harrell v. Champlain Enterprises, schaft v. Civil Aeronautics Board 400 Doe v. City of New York Harris v. Republic Airlines, Inc. .. . Doe v. Kohn Na&s Grtaf. .. 301, 302, 304 Harriss & B & H Aircraft Sales, Inc. v. Norsworthy & DBS Investments, Doricent v. American Airlines, Inc. Dow Chemical Co. v. Alfaro Hawaiian Airlines, Inc. v. Norris . Downey v. Commissioner 779, 781, 783, 784, 785, 786, 949, 959, 961 787, 788, 789 Durrett v. Cessna Aircraft Corp. ... Hawley v. City of Cleveland Eastern Airlines, Inc. v. Floyd Henderson v. FAA Eastern Air Lines v. Union Trust Hill v. Piper Mi ccewesenanianees 582, 583, 586, 587 Hinson v. Hoover East River Steamship Corp. v. Trans- Hirras v. National Railroad Passen- America Delaval, Inc. 84 Egan v. Kollsman Instrument Corp. 400 Elgin, J. & E. Railwayv . Burley.... 764, Hodges v. Delta Airlines, Inc. ..... 15, 17 765, 766, 767, 772, “785, 784 Hollie v. Korean Airlines Co., Ltd. . 53 Eichler v. Lufthansa German Air- Holmes v. Cessna Aircraft Co Honda Motor Co., Ltd. v. Oberg .. Engebretsen & Hartford Insurance Hood v. Smith’s Transfer Corp. ... Co. v. Fairchild Aircraft Corp. ... Howard v. FAA Esa v. Olympic Airways Idris v. Hanson Estate of Cook v. Gran-Aire, Inc. .. Iervolino v. Delta Airlines, Inc. .... Estate of Zarif v. Korean Airlines Indian Towing Co. v. United States Ingham v. Eastern Airlines Evansville-Vanderburgh Airport Au- In re Air Crash Disaster at Warsaw, thority District v. Delta Airlines, Poland, on March 14, 1980 402, 405, 407, 408, 417 Farley v. Cessna In re Air Crash Disaster Near New Federal Insurance Co. v. Air Express Orleans, Louisiana on July 9, International, Corp 402, 405, 418 Fenn v. American Airlines, Inc... .. In re Air Disaster at Lockerbie, Fillpot v. Midway Airlines, Inc. .... Scotland on December 21, 1988. 33, 57 1060 JOURNAL OF AIR LAW AND COMMERCE (61 In re Air Disaster at Ramstein Air Linglev . Norge Division of Magic Base, Germany on August 29, Chef, Inc... .6 6, 759, 777, 778, 782, 784 1990 Lisi v. Alitalia-Linee Aeree Italiane, In re Korean Airlines Disaster of Louisiana Bank of Ouachita Parish 405, 406, 407, 408, 409, 417, v. Zadoorian 418, 450 Ludecke v. Canadian Pacific Air- In re Midway Airlines, Inc. ........ 156 In re Pan Am Corp. ........--++-- 56 In re ParAiir Csras h of March 3, In re Uranium Antitrust Litigation . In re Zalewski's Estate Martin v. Eastern Airlines, Inc. .... International Brotherhood of Team- Maryland Aviation Administration v. sters v. Daniel Jack v. Trans World Airlines, Inc. . . McCulloch v. Maryland McGilvra v. National Transportation Jaffe Aircraft Corp. v. Carr Mergen v. Piper Aircraft Corp. .... Jatkoe v. United States Mertens v. Flying Tiger Line, Inc. . 396, Jay v. International Salt Co 397, 398 JetCraft Corp. v. Flight Safety Inter- Metropolitan Life Insurance Co. v. Jet Power, Inc. v. United States .... Midwest Helicopter Airways v. Sikor- Johnson v. American Airlines, Inc. . sky Aircraft Johnson v. Pratt & Whitney Canada, Miller v. United Technologies Moore v. Illinois Central Railroad . Moorhead v. Mitsubishi Aircraft Dit Ct tevncasdtapiosbabene’ 623 Morales v. Trans World Airlines, ee 11, 14, 15, 19, 22, 23, 24, 223, 227, 231, 232, 236, 237, Kansas v. Trans World Airlines, Inc. Kansas v. United States Nakajima v. United States Kay v. USAir, Inc National Union Fire Insurance Co. Kiefer v. Continental Airlines, Inc. . v. Care Flight Air Ambulance Ser- Kleiser v. Airport Commission i 118, 140 Laker Airways Limited v. Sabena National Union Fire Insurance Co. Belgian World Airlines v. Dawn Aeronautics, Inc Lamkin v. Braniff Airlines, Inc Landreth Timber Co. v. Landreth . Lathigra v. British Airways PLC.... Lay v. St. Louis Helicopter Airways, Lear v. Upali (USA), Inc New York v. Trans World Airlines . 221, Lemon v. Kurtzman 222, 228, 224 INDEX 1996] 1061 NLRB v. Bildisco & Bildisco _Richmond Newspapers, Inc. v. Norris v. Hawaiian Airlines, Inc. . . . 566, 567, 569, Northwest Airlines, Inc. v. County of 571, 572, 573 EE ova cuctndnakeedeeen Rickel v. Commissioner Northwest Airlines, Inc. v. FAA .... Robinson v. NTSB Northwest Airlines, Inc. v. Tennes- Rocky Mountain Helicopters v. Bell see State Board of Equalization . Helicopter Northwest Airlines, Inc. v. United Rodriguez Pardo v. Delta Airlines, States Department of Transporta- BR irisvctedind camawatasews 706, 710 Rodriquez v. United States Norwest Capital Management & Roscoe v. Department of Forestry. . Trust Co. v. United States Ross v. Pan American Airways O’Hearn v. Delta Airlines, Inc. .... Royal Insurance Co. v. Emery Air Ocampo v. Korean Airlines Co., Freight Corp. .........-..++++ Sakaria v. Trans World Airlines, Inc. San Diego Unified Port District v. Pansy v. Borough of Stroudsburg . . Gianturco Pasinato v. American Airlines, Inc.. Schleier v. Commissioner Patelczik v. Clarkston Travel Bu- Schmitz v. Commissioner reau, Inc. and Northwest Airlines, Ti dete GNoikaac inteten ack bale tsaioepet adel Paul v. N.L. Industries, Inc Pearson v. Lake Forest Country Day Schuler v. United States Schwamb v. Delta Airlines, Inc Pegasus Helicopters, Inc. v. United Schwartz v. Lufthansa German Air- Technologies Corp Penny v. Giuffrida SEC v. W.J. Howey Co. ........... People v. Western Airlines, Inc. ... Sedigh v. Delta Airlines, Inc 220, 221 Seligman v. Northwest Airlines, Inc. Pistillo v. Commissioner Shaffer v. Maier Posadas de Puerto Rico Assocs. v. Sharp v. Howard County Board of Tourism Co. of Puerto Rico .... 107 Powell v. Dell-Air Aviation, Inc... .. 713 Shaw v. Delta Airlines, Inc. ....... Press-Enterprise Co. v. Superior Sheffer v. Springfield Airport Shen v. Japan Airlines Publicker Industries, Inc. v. Cohen Sherer v. Hartzell Propeller, Inc. .. Purcell v. Seguin State Bank & Skinnner v. Railway Labor Execu- RE iccedusocuncaatnsan d 959, 962 tives’ Associatidn Smith v. Hughes Aircraft Co Smith v. Smith Spring v. United States Springer v. United States Stagl v. Delta Air Lines, Inc. ...... Rauch v. United Instruments, Inc. . 751 State v. Metropolitan Airports Com- Ravreby v. United Airlines, Inc. . 714, 715 Remo v. United States 92 Ricci v. American Airlines 715, 716 1062 JOURNAL OF AIR LAW AND COMMERCE Steering Committee v. United States 63 United States v. Jenny 172 United States v. Munsingwear, Inc. 146 United States v. 1980 Lear Jet, Inc. Sugimoto v. Exportadora de Sal, United States v. Northrop ee United States v. Oesterblad Sutton v. Earles United States v. Ross Teamsters v. Lucas Four Co. ...... United States Department of Trans- Texas & Pacific Ry. v. Rigsby portation v. Paralyzed Veterans of Third National Bank in Nashville v. America Wedge Group Universe Tankships, Inc. v. United Threlkeld v. Commissioner Town of Brookhaven v. Spadaro... USAir, Inc. v. United States Depart- Transco Leasing Corp. v. United ment of the Navy Uselton v. Commercial Lovelace Transcontinental Freight Systems, Motor Freight, Inc. ............ Inc. v. Air France Wagman v. Federal Express Corp. . Trans World Airlines, Inc. v. Frank- Walker v. Eastern Air Lines lin Mint Corp Walt Disney World Co. v. Wood ... Trans World Airlines, Inc. v. Wang v. FMC Corp Warren v. Flying Tiger Line, Inc. .. Webb v. United States Union Iberoamericana v. American CL, <dcn den ndwaeeaiaké Western Airlines, Inc. v. Criswell .. United Mine Workers of America v. Westmoreland v. Columbia Broad- casting System, Inc. ............ Wolens v. American Airlines, Inc... . 232, 233, 239, 240, 241, United States v. Compton Worthington v. United States United States v. Hawkins Woznick v. Richards