Islam: Questions And Answers Volume 21 Basis for Jurisprudence and Islamic Rulings i ii Islam: Questions And Answers Volume 21 Basis for Jurisprudence and Islamic Rulings Muhammad Saed Abdul-Rahman B.Sc., DipHE iii © Muhammad Saed Abdul-Rahman, 2003 ISBN for all volumes 1 86179 080 5 ISBN for volume 21 paperback 1 86179 404 5 ISBN for volume 21 hardback 1 86179 405 3 ISBN for volume 21 pdf eBook 1 86179 406 1 ISBN for volume 21 Microsoft eBook 1 86179 407 X ISBN for volume 21 Palm eBook 1 86179 408 8 All Rights reserved British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data. A Catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Designed, Typeset and produced by: MSA Publication Limited, 4 Bello Close, Herne Hill, London SE24 9BW United Kingdom iv Contents Introduction ..............................................................................1 Chapter 1...................................................................................3 General.................................................................................3 45880: Does the ruling on driving a car vary from one country to another? ..........................................3 30842: Saving system in Aramco and attitude towards the various fatwas concerning it......................13 10887: what is definition of haram &halal?..................19 9466: What is moderation in religion?..........................21 9197: Is there any difference between Sunnah, mustahabb and nafil? ....................................................24 9084: The difference between haraam and makrooh ....25 751: Why adultery, gambling and the flesh of swine are haraam...........................................................25 2376: Are all actions allowed unless specifically prohibited or vice versa?...............................................27 Chapter 2.................................................................................29 Accountability....................................................................29 45672: Should she wear hijab even though her family will be harmed because of that?.........................29 13793: Obligatory duties for those who are deaf and mute........................................................................32 27101: Is it permissible for a kaafir to pray with the Muslims?.................................................................33 12840: Are women equal with men in reward and punishment? ...........................................................35 21246: She did not know the signs of puberty so she did not fast in Ramadaan, out of ignorance........38 10065: Who are the ones who will be excused for ignorance about ‘aqeedah and matters of fiqh?.......40 3240: To whose record are the good deeds of prepubescent children added? .......................................46 Chapter 3.................................................................................48 v Sources for Islamic Rulings and Shari’ah..........................48 44877: Our attitude concerning da’eef (weak) ahaadeeth which speak of good deeds...........................48 39286: Is it correct to think that fatwas may vary according to time and place?.................................50 23280: Imitation (taqleed), following the evidence (daleel) – and was Ibn Hazm a Hanbali?.......................54 1105: Does Islam regard men and women as equal? ............................................................................57 13932: The wisdom behind facing the Ka’bah .............67 22239: Applying laws which are not mentioned in the Qur’aan or Sunnah..............................................71 22245: There is no secret knowledge in Islam that is only for the awliyaa’ (“saints”)..................................74 22289: Attitude towards al-Israa’eeliyyaat....................76 13189: How did Islamic fiqh develop?.........................77 14076: Is it permissible to give a fatwa based on taqleed ......................................................................83 21133: Ruling on things that were done at the time of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) which he did not know about ......85 12390: Judging by that which Allaah has revealed.......85 9516: Should the easier fatwa be followed? .................91 10645: Is it permissible for a Muslim to choose the easiest scholarly opinion?........................................92 8294: Differences among the fuqahaa’..........................93 10521: Claim that the Sunnah cannot be trusted...........96 10845: Should we adopt a gradual approach when applying the rulings (of sharee’ah)? ....................99 2071: When can a young man make ijtihaad and issue fatwas?.........................................................101 6586: Will a person who neglects the Sunnah be punished?................................................................102 3922: Who is to say what is halaal and haraam ?........104 1053: Does the Sunnah govern people’s worldly affairs?.........................................................................106 604: Justification for following the Sunnah................109 vi Chapter 4...............................................................................114 Innovations in Religion and Worship (Part 1) .................114 49702: False report attributed to Zaynab (may Allaah be pleased with her) about healing of disease.....................................................................114 49678: Does Allaah come down to the first heaven on the night of the fifteenth of Sha’baan?.......119 49675: Should he fast on the fifteenth of Sha’baan even if the hadeeth is da’eef?......................121 10070: Celebrating innovated festivals.......................124 47425: The best way to call those who do not pray and to deal with innovators .................................125 7051: Gathering to eat and celebrate on the last day of Sha’baan...........................................................128 8907: Laylat al-Nusf min Sha’baan (the middle of Sha’baan) should not be singled out for worship..................................................................129 45622: Ruling on the imam saying to the congregation, “Pray Pray like a man bidding farewell”.........................................................130 1305: Giving certain days meaning is not permitted .....................................................................133 46665: He wants to give his wife a gift on the anniversary of their marriage each year.................134 34842: Ruling on erecting a monument to the Unknown Soldier...................................................135 34511: Ruling on burying the deceased in a coffin ........................................................................136 27237: Is there such a thing as Du’aa’ Kanz il-‘Arsh?.............................................................138 31833: Lies about a dream falsely attributed to the Watchman of the Prophet’s tomb ......................139 20885: Praying behind followers of bid’ah, whether that bid’ah amounts to kufr or not.................151 21642: The ruling on wearing one’s adornment on the Day of Aashooraa.............................................153 22722: Ruling on gathering to make du’aa’ and recite vii Qur’aan........................................................................155 11938: Question about a strange Sufi way of worship....................................................................157 36769: If he does the farewell tawaaf, he should go out walking normally and should not walk with his face towards the Ka’bah.................169 22752: Warning against the book Dalaa’il al-Khayraat..................................................................171 31200: What is al-waneesah........................................174 37638: Ruling on celebrating al-Qarqee’aan ..............179 37841: Uttering the intention out loud for salaat al-Taraaweeh and other prayers is bid’ah..........181 37643: Uttering the intention to fast out loud is an innovation (bid’ah) .............................................182 37683: Du’aa’ for completing the Qur’aan (khatam) ......................................................................183 37753: Communal du’aa’ after Taraaweeh prayer ......186 26867: Remembering Allaah by repeating a single name such as “Allaah”......................................187 34566: How du’aa’ after prayer should be recited ......189 14623: Making du’aa’ together for one who has given charity..........................................................191 22828: Is it permissible to pray on behalf of someone who does not pray?..................................192 27029: Ruling on offering a sacrifice when building of the mosque is completed ..........................193 12808: There are no trivial issues in Islam .................194 21976: Making du’aa’ after the obligatory prayers is bid’ah ..........................................................197 21902: Guidelines on shar’i wird................................198 32443: Reciting du’aa’ for forgiveness in unison following prayer ..............................................200 22646: Sending blessings upon the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) when the iqaamah is pronounced................................201 9057: Mocking innovators ..........................................202 486: Religious celebrations in islam...........................204 viii 26152: Questions about an imam................................205 26804: Her mother wants to give her a birthday party – what should she do?........................................209 695: Can one celebrate completing the Qur’aan?.......211 7505: Salaat al-Naariyah.............................................212 13810: A Christian woman asks about the Prophet’s birthday and what it means to the Muslims ................222 26793: Qur’aan on Fridays and du’aa’ before Fajr .....225 22872: Is it prescribed to boycott innovators in this day and age?.........................................................226 Chapter 5...............................................................................229 Innovations in Religion and Worship (Part 2) .................229 23443: Is using loudspeakers for the adhaan an innovation (bid’ah)?....................................................229 20005: There is no specific du’aa’ to be recited before reading Qur’aan ...............................................231 14390: Putting a bunch of flowers on a grave.............233 13642: Offering gifts to some women on Christmas ....................................................................233 21875: Ruling on printing the name of Allaah in the Qur’aan in a different colour.............................235 14234: Innovated way of doing wudoo’......................235 21903: Ruling on gathering to read Qur’aan together on the occasion of the death of ‘Ali (may Allaah be pleased with him)...............................239 22457: Specifying a number of times to recite dhikr or du’aa’ that is not narrated in sharee’ah..........241 21373: Kissing one’s thumbs when the name of the Prophet is mentioned is a bid’ah...........................243 13478: Are the compilation of the Qur’aan and the first adhaan for Jumu’ah forms of bid’ah (innovation)?...............................................................244 10491: Dhikr recited in unison following the prayers.........................................................................248 22322: The difference between setting an appointed time for lessons and setting an appointed time for qiyaam al-layl ...............................251 ix
Description: