Contents Internet Traffic Engineering 1 Guest Editorial; Terje Jensen Telektronikk Section I: Introduction/Overview Volume 97 No. 2/3 – 2001 3 Computers and Communication; Yngvar Lundh ISSN 0085-7130 20 Internet Protocol and Transport Protocols; Terje Jensen Editor: Ola Espvik 39 Traffic Engineering Principles, Activities and Mechanisms; Terje Jensen Tel: (+47) 913 14 507 email: [email protected] 54 Basic IP-related Mechanisms;Terje Jensen Status section editor: Section II: Traffic, Resources, Routing Per Hjalmar Lehne Tel: (+47) 916 94 909 86 Planning and Designing IP-based Networks; email: [email protected] Terje Jensen, Mette Røhne, Inge Svinnset, Rima Venturin and Irena Grgic Editorial assistant: 107 Achieving Service Differentiation in a Differentiated Services Network by Gunhild Luke Use of MPLS; Inge Svinnset Tel: (+47) 415 14 125 email: [email protected] 116 The Design of Optimal Multi-Service MPLS Networks; Editorial office: Åke Arvidsson and Anthony Krzesinski Telenor Communication AS Telenor R&D 130 State-of-the-art of IP Routing;Boning Feng, Anne-Grethe Kåråsen, PO Box 83 Per Thomas Huth and Bjørn Slagsvold N-2027 Kjeller 145 Routing Strategies for IP Networks; Norway Tel: (+47) 67 89 00 00 Walid Ben-Ameur, Nicolas Michel, Bernard Liau and Eric Gourdin email: [email protected] 159 IP Multiplexing for Low Capacity Links?;Olav Østerbø Editorial board: Ole P. Håkonsen, Section III:Interdomain, SLA, Policy, Management Senior Executive Vice President. Oddvar Hesjedal, 170 Traffic Engineering – Inter-domain and Policy Issues; Terje Jensen Vice President, R&D. Bjørn Løken, 186 Agreements in IP-based Networks; Irena Grgic and Mette Røhne Director. 213 Modelling the Topology of IP Networks; Graphic design: Terje Henriksen, Anne-Grethe Kåråsen and Ståle Wolland Design Consult AS, Oslo Section IV: Measurements Layout and illustrations: Gunhild Luke, Britt Kjus (Telenor R&D) 230 Traffic Measurements in IP Networks;Brynjar Å Viken and Peder J Emstad Prepress and printing: 245 A Distributed Test Environment for IP Performance Evaluation; Optimal as, Oslo Poul E Heegaard and Brynjar Å Viken Circulation: 4,000 269 Methods for monitoring, controlling and charging QoS in IP Networks; Jorma Jormakka, Irena Grgic and Vasilios Siris Section V: Systems and Services 287 Network Principles and Applications;Terje Jensen 311 Voice Transmission over Internet;Johan M Karlsson 319 Quality Issues for Packet-based Voice Transport; Danny De Vleeschauwer, Annelies van Moffaert, Maarten J C Büchli, Jan Janssen and Guido H Petit 332 Quality of Service in UMTS;Thor Gunnar Eskedal and Frédéric Paint 346 Optical Network Functionality: From “Dumb Fat Pipes” to Bright Networking;Evi Zouganeli 355 Abbreviations Guest Editorial TERJE JENSEN To survive in today’s competitive environment, The Internet Protocol (IP) has become a pivotal a service provider must continually evolve its component in communication between various network and enable new revenue-generating ser- devices. It is rarely possible to make a single vices faster and more cost effectively than the protocol suffice the diverse needs of all applica- competitors. Prior to the Internet, prior to recent tions and users. To a certain extent, however, mobile services, prior to e-business, a change in one may claim that the IP suite is addressing the telecommunication industry was seen as such an objective. However, looking at the origi- more predictable. Business leaders knew to take nal use of IP when it was designed, there are action – actions like reducing costs, launching many other applications of the protocol these new products, upgrading the networks, and so days; as more demanding services – like tele- forth. Now providers are far less sure who their phony, video distribution and mission-critical Terje Jensen competitors are, the value of their core strengths business applications – are gradually put onto and skills, and whether the business they have IP-based networks, additional functions must be done well in for many years will continue to implemented in the networks and end-systems. keep them profitable in the future. Hence, one is stretching the capabilities of IP and additional mechanisms are necessary to Some may claim that a main cause for the uncer- allow IP to hold on to a central position. Several tainty is that recent development of applications of these mechanisms are related to Traffic Engi- and service demands has been going on outside neering, that is, means activated to ensure the the sphere of the service providers. In particular, performance of the communication solutions. the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) has This will also allow for more predictable received major contributions from some main responses on service requests and swiftly players and been guided by inputs from the support of more advance services and users. academic world. For sure this has resulted in a plethora of applications and usage patterns, and Quite a few phenomena influence the evolution phenomenal traffic growth. However, as more of IP-based networks, of which some interacting Front cover: The conflict commercial concerns are entering the stage the factors are: between market require- providers would regain more control, for exam- • Increased load and expansion; more efficient ments and the service ple by utilising the Traffic Engineeringsolu- ways of handling the traffic is sought. Scala- provider’s resources tions. This also advocates further work on stan- bility challenges are commonly faced for this At low traffic pressure incom- dardisation, ensuring interoperable configura- reason. ing traffic equals traffic car- ried. The artist Odd Andersen tions. Including procedures for managing multi- indicates this situation by his ple service types and requirements, Internet • New technologies; efficient ways of interact- 45 degrees black lines. How- Protocol (IP) Traffic Engineering thus provides ing with IP-based networks are looked for. ever, every traffic machine – mechanisms for optimal operation and manage- Anexample of this is the relation between be it switches, routers or the ment of the IP-based network. Thereby, a functions related to IP and an underlying whole network – has a capac- ity limit at which the line provider would also improve its chances in optical layer. breaks into a horizontal posi- thefrenzied market. tion. After that no more traffic • New user groups; additional requirements can be carried whatever the Basically, one option could be simply to increase could be placed on the IP-based network. pressure! the capacity of the network, like adding more Thus, efficient ways of differentiation be- But the enormous increase bandwidth to the links. A problem with this tween the groups are asked for, also accom- –and non-established nature argument is that capacity should then be added panied by appropriate charging solutions. – of Internet traffic blasts wherever there is a problem, including the pro- through all aspects of capacity and quality constraints. The cessing capacity, and also in the access network, • New applications; innovative ways of utilising artist’s skyrocketing white on the servers, etc. Furthermore, and perhaps an IP-based networks are steadily observed, e.g. lines indicate the unprece- even heavier argument is that the possibility for related to electronic business, mobile services, dented demands to proper service differentiation would then still be rather and so forth. engineering of traffic ma- limited. Being able to offer a portfolio of differ- chines in thenew market environments. ent services is recognised as a key enabler for • Increased dependency on the network; coming ensuring a provider’s profitability. Again, from the service providers themselves as com- The artist’s generic message: Matching capacity of all com- Traffic Engineering is promoting a set of mecha- mercial aspects, but also from their customers, ponents to uncertain Internet nisms and procedures supporting a provider to of which several are basing their business on traffic demands. achieve such goals. This becomes more impor- an operational network. Ola Espvik, Editor in Chief tant as the number of users and services grows. Telektronikk 2/3.2001 1 • Increasing number of actors involved in ser- then treated in a set of articles in the second sec- vice provision and delivery; connecting sys- tion, called traffic, routing, resources. Interdo- tems and networks managed by different main, SLA, policyandmanagementis the fol- actors, partly co-operating and partly compet- lowing section, addressing essential questions ing, require adequate sets of means for a given for commercially offering services – in a fast, actor to ensure its business and service levels accurate and automatic way. The papers deal towards its customers. This is further compli- with internal procedures and systems (e.g. man- cated by the dynamic commercial and techni- agement systems) as well as relations with other cal environment that an actor faces. actors (e.g. agreements). Measurementsare piv- otal to follow and document the performance of Several aspects have to be addressed as part of the network. A set of papers is showing how to Traffic Engineering. A selection of the topics carry out measurements and factors to consider. has been included in this issue of Telektronikk. The last section is called systems and services, These are divided into a number of sections as presenting a few areas where solutions for IP shown in the table of contents. Firstly, a set of and Traffic Engineering are used or required, papers of introductorynature presents an over- like for mobile, for optics, and for voice. view of the IP suite, history of Internet and prin- ciples of Traffic Engineering. Basic topics of As the use of abbreviationsflourishes, a com- designing and operating an IP-based network are mon list is collected at the end of this issue. 2 Telektronikk 2/3.2001 Computers and Communication Early Development of Computing and Internet-technology – a Groundbreaking Part of Technical History YNGVAR LUNDH Building the Arpanet and using it as a laboratory for development was a major contribution both to computing and to telecom. During the 1970s a very innovative and thorough research and development took place under the leadership of the United States Department of Defense, Advanced Research Projects Agency. From the outset the effort can best be characterized as basic technical research. Tenresearch groups worked together as a team at developing the Internet-technology itself. At the same time the development was influenced by many other research groups, mainly in the United States, who actively pursued specialized networking applications, thereby creating needs and uncovering possi- bilities. Concurrently dramatic developments took place both in circuit and device techniques for com- puters and in the politics of telecom operation. A glimpse of the Norwegian perspective is included through the eyes of the small participating group in Norway. The text endeavours to be readable without Yngvar Lundh (69) graduated from the Norwegian Institute of prior technical special knowledge. Its objective is to interrelate main technical events of computing in a Technology in 1956. He served historic perspective. as leader of development teams and projects in computer and telecom technology, with the Norwegian Defence research Strengthening Telecom and World Wide Web – WWW Establishment until 1984, then Computer Techniques People today tend to think of Internet as synony- with the Norwegian Telecom Administration / Telenor until Internet is not only a modern hobby, nor an mous with World Wide Web. That technique 1996, then in his own consulting exotic new trading arena, nor new mail, nor new opens a splendid new view of a world of infor- company. Since 1980 he also distribution of information. Internet is all of that mation. Simple point and click movements catch served as Professor of Informat- ics at the University of Oslo. His and much more. A result of a successful develop- posted information anywhere in the world inde- main projects concerned digital ment since the late 1960s of basic new technical pendently of distance. Information is posted in computing and circuit technol- principles, it pertains to computer collaboration the form of “home pages”. The information is ogy, enabling the start of “hi- tech” companies, notably Norsk and to various forms of information transfer. We coded in standardized format and is stored in Data AS, and systems for de- shall refer to these techniques as Internet-tech- computers connected to the network. For the fence and for telecom enhanc- nology. During the same period – the last 25 coding and formatting various aids are readily ing and employing emerging technologies. Lundh is a mem- years of the twentieth century – important devel- available and easy to use. Hence the “Web tech- ber of he Norwegian Academy opment took place in two other areas. Electronic nology” can be used by anyone who wants a of Technological Sciences. circuit and device techniquesmade it possible message to be presented. It immediately be- [email protected] tofabricate computers cheap and small, thereby comes available to the whole world. That is a making them more interesting economically. world that can be described as “countless mil- They can now be used as components in new lions” and which grows such that it will shortly roles (for that matter the same circuit technology comprise at least everyone who has or could also made even more powerful computers possi- have a telephone. At the same time the technol- ble). Telecommunicationswent through a pro- ogy is developed further towards user-facilities found reorganization. This admitted new actors with far more comprehensive abilities than tele- and driving forces into the technical and com- phones at conveying information. mercial evolution of telecom networks. However, World Wide Web is far from the Those are features of a development presently entire Internet. It is only one – admittedly very causing drastic changes in our relationship with conspicuous – example of exciting new possibil- information and its use. Most likely we are just ities that can be implemented on top of the Inter- at the beginning of a new era. Nobody knows net-technology itself. The Web technique first where it will take us. This technology is already emerged as a practical internal information dis- beginning to change important functions of our tribution system in a large international research society. Some of the perspectives that can now establishment in Switzerland – CERN – in be perceived imply exciting new possibilities. 1990–91. From there it spread incredibly fast throughout the Internet, i.e. to “the whole world”. This article describes that technical development without assuming special technical knowledge But the basic ideas were already 25 years old and avoids detail that is better described else- then. The idea of being able to open windows where. Outlines of the historic development of via CRT-screens on collections of information the internetworking technology and parts of ofvarious types near or far and to navigate in a computer- and telecom techniques are described. world of information by point and click move- Special focus is directed at the 1970s when most ments of hands and fingers were demonstrated of the basic technical development took place. already in 1968. Telektronikk 2/3.2001 3 -----In any picture or text hyperlinks may be built in. As an example, clicking stations were another of Engelbart’s ideas long the name of a particular personmay before the microprocessor). And, of special immediately bring in his importance, the ban on commercial traffic in the picture located in some Internet was lifted in 1991. Some of the prereq- computer – anywhere in the world uisites were met relatively early. Computer screens, first demonstrated in the late 1950s, • CV began to be common from the early 1970s, per- • e-mail sonal computers a little later. Computer co-oper- • web-add ation in general, vendor independent networks, • work beyond the groups participating in developing • home the Internet techniques themselves, became usual from around 1980. Some of the ideas that Engelbart demonstrated in 1968 are still (2001) Mr. Ola Norman awaiting comprehensive use, but are expected tobecome similarly important. Examples are telephony and moving pictures. Hyperlinks make information The leading person and creating and driving World Wide Web is primarily an example of stored elsewhere available by force in these developments was Douglas Engel- technical possibilities that Internet technology pointing at a reference to it bart of Stanford Research International – SRI – opens up as a carrier of entirely new and exciting and clicking in Menlo Park, California. Engelbart developed forms of information handling. and demonstrated a comprehensive set of con- cepts and techniques of groundbreaking impor- Electronic Mail tance. The most significant was perhaps the Message transfer was a dominating application “mouse”, the little thing you hold in your hand. of the Internet already from the start of the Everybody who has seen a computer today has development in 1969. That form of communica- seen it. Equally important is the “hyperlink”. tion was especially practical and a necessary tool That is a reference pointer-code that can be in the decentralized collaboration of the ten embedded in any information-image – text or groups of researchers who undertook the basic picture – displayed on a computer screen. A research and development in the 1970s. mouse-click onthe pointer opens the referred The concept of workstation image. That happens independently of where in The original vision of resource sharing network- was demonstrated at SRI by the net that information happens to be located. ing, an important source of inspiration for the Douglas Engelbart as early development, comprised a number of other, as1968. It had cathode ray A quarter of a century would elapse before these more or less exotic, applications. E-mail was an screen, a “mouse” for the ideas could be seriously employed and put to overwhelming generator of traffic for many right hand and a five-finger extensive use. Only then the technical and eco- years. It perhaps still is, at least was so until the key-set for the left hand. The nomic prerequisites were met. Microprocessors Web started another “landslide” of new users. user could point, click and type had made low priced personal computers com- Tomany people either e-mail or Web is still anywhere at the screen while mon as “workstations” and the Internet was synonymous with the Internet. looking steadily available and ubiquitous (networking work- E-mail is an important form of communication already. It has unique properties in comparison to ordinary mail and telephone. Therefore it defends a place of its own as a communications medium. It overcomes both time and distance, itis fast, but still the addressee may answer pre- cisely, for record, when convenient after having had plenty of time to think, unlike the telephone. E-mail is suitable for automation in various forms. And it is cheap. However, e-mail is still – in 2001 – far from having reached its full potential as a general communication medium. “Old-fashioned” mail and telephone are far ahead in general availabil- ity. The most important shortcoming is that e- mail only reaches those who often use comput- ers, connected to the Internet – and whenthey use the computer. To make certain that a mes- sage gets there, at least to most people, it will still be best to call or send a letter. 4 Telektronikk 2/3.2001 E-mail will be much more usable the day when The Internet is a network of Local the receiving apparatus immediately emits a nets interconnected by gateway area beep or blinking light signalling the arrival of computers. Nets may be of net amessage. The messaging apparatus should be different types. From one host G equally cheap to own as a telephone that rarely computer to another rings. We are still some distance from being able G Net of information travels in packets leased to send important messages to many recipients along routes which may lines by e-mail only. But the trend is pointing in that G change with network “shape” direction. And a transmitter and receiver of e- Packet Packet and traffic load. The Internet mail will not be a PC only. It will be built into radio G satellite Protocol (IP) helps navigate telephones or other future “popular boxes”, that net net through the network. The G we have not yet seen, but which will creatively Transport Control Protocol be made usual in the future world. Many such G G (TCP) helps ensure that a boxes will be gadgets with remotely controlled message transported functions, etc. Local Local piecemeal as a number of area area packets gets properly Wireless or Wired Somehow net net re-assembled The actual reason for the name Internet is that the network may employ various carrier media Host A Host B of many different kinds interconnected for the transportation of information. Further, Internet-technology implies mechanisms type of net. The individual nets are connected for optimized mixing of different transport re- into one network (of nets) called Internet. Gate- quirements. Urgent messages get there fast while way computers make the interconnection. They less urgent traffic may be transported more cheap- convert the information on its way to the next ly using otherwise idle periods. Traffic types are net into a format suitable for appropriate han- more or less error prone. Particularly important dling there. traffic needs precedence – e.g. for resolving problems in the network itself, and so on. The basic development of Internet-technology took place in the period 1969 – 1980. It com- Characteristics such as error density, urgency, prised understanding the problems and the possi- and precedence are measurable quantities to be bilities, creating and testing the technical meth- specified, and to be met accordingly. Internet ods and defining the results as standards that technology lets different requirements be met were open and available for use by anyone. automatically by the available network capabilities. The main result of this development is that dif- In particular this enables many carrier media of ferent computers can now co-operate and ex- rather different capabilities to co-operate in the change all types of information. Further, the transport such that each medium is exploited to its best ability. Prevailing media now are leased lines capable of specific bit transfer rates – num- ber of pulses per second. Various standard band- widths (pulses per second) are available. Several other carrier media are important and will be used increasingly. Local area networks prevail within buildings and geographically limited cor- porate sites. Radio computer networking of vari- ous kinds is evolving further. Satellites have many exciting possibilities. The same is true of cable networks originally built for broadcasting television. These are probably best suited for rural and urban areas respectively, and have great potential for being exploited further. The background for the name Internet is net of interconnected nets. The individual transport Teleprinter, (“Teletype”, networks are operated separately as mask-shaped “Telex machine”) built for the nets of leased lines, packet radio nets, packet international Telex network satellite nets, and so on. Each of these media was extensively used as transports packets in ways best suited for each computer terminals Telektronikk 2/3.2001 5 Remote Computers and Time Sharing Computer Early computers and their users communicated center using teleprinters – “Teletype machines” – that conveyed text directly both into and out of the computers. For many years information was transferred in and out of computers via punched Modems cards or punched paper tape. The need for effi- cient use of computer time dictated these media. They were much faster and hence occupied less of the valuable computer time waiting for slow Tele-net fingers and printer mechanisms. Special line printers to be directly driven by the computer were developed. For many years powerful line- printer machines were essential parts of com- Modems puter centres, and they produced vast amounts • • • • • • • • Terminals ofpaper printouts. Although they are capable of fast printing of text on paper lineprinters have been surpassed in performance by newer de- vices. Both ink jet printers and xerographic printing mechanisms using lasers for pattern generation are almost household items today, and they outperform the earlier, powerful mech- anical line printers both at efficiency, quality and Timesharing allows many information can be transported through different flexibility. users to work directly and types of transport media. Each transport is auto- simultaneously with the com- matically handled as required by interconnected The first operating systems were developed early puter from remote locations carrier media that may have different character- in the 1960s. That is programs that manage the istics. computer itself and its attached resources. Since then a computer without an operating system is Figure 5 CRT-screens and The transport is handled according to technical unthinkable. The operating system manages the timesharing were major steps rules called protocols. They depend on more computer and its various tasks. As an example in adapting the power of detail and are significantly more complicated the operating system permits the fast central computers to the abilities of than the protocol that govern ordinary telephone processing unit to carry on at full speed while people. This picture was copied traffic. In reality the protocols are implemented slower attached units such as printers work at from a brochure in 1971. The as programs in computers. Microprocessors of theirspeed. Important operating systems today large company impressed various processing powers are now available and are Windows, NT, UNIX and Linux, each in customers calling in. As soon can be used as components in devices built to several variations. While Internet-technology is as the customer gave his name use the Internet for various purposes. It appears independent of individual machines and operat- the operator could (actually that we are presently at the beginning of an era ing systems, the one operating system that was type it immediately and thus of future types of information networks. most prevalent during the first decade of net- display his data, hence –) working development was “Tenex” by Digital “remember” details about him Equipment Corporation – DEC. It was a popular operating system especially for that company’s tenth major computer model (“Programmed Data Processor”) – PDP 10. Towards the end of the 1970s Unix became more and more popular and has become an important industry standard serving many types of computers. In the 1990s Microsoft Corporation’s various “Windows” systems have overtaken it in volume outnumber- ing all others. A remarkable phenomenon during the period ofinternetworking development is the absence of IBM from that development. From the late 1950s that large, internationally distributed com- pany had a uniquely large market share for com- puters and everything in computing. Especially IBM took leadership in many areas of technical standard setting. Cards, magnetic tapes, codes, etc. were “IBM-compatible”. IBM also set their 6 Telektronikk 2/3.2001 own comprehensive and successful standards in computer networking. The operating system enables a computer to do several tasks at the same time. A particularly important development was timesharing. The Computer Time-Sharing System – CTSS – was demonstrated in its earliest form at MIT in the early to mid 1960s. Timesharing permits several users to access the computer simultaneously. Several user terminals, typically Teletype machines, may be connected to the computer. Each user experiences the communication with the computer – via the timeshared operating sys- tem – as if she had the computer to herself alone. The computer actually shares its time between several users and several tasks. The users per- ceive increased load from more users as slower response from the computer. Powerful comput- ers may serve many, perhaps several tens of users without noticeably slow response. Standard Teletype machines are specialized typewriting machines made to be connected for mode”. The actual users, i.e. those who devel- Special printer terminals transfer of written – teletype – messages through oped programs and those who delivered data for became available the international Telexnetwork. In the 1960s processing, were not allowed to communicate specialized typewriting computer terminals directly with the computer. The user submitted began to replace the use of Teletype machines jobs consisting of programs and/or data, usually for computer purposes. They were faster and in the form of a deck of punched cards or a roll The line printer was the output more flexible to use, had more comprehensive of punched paper tape. A popular profession was medium from computer character sets and could produce nicer print. that of punching machine operator, transferring centers. It produced large Only from the beginning of the 1970s terminals written programs or data from paper into amounts of printed pages with Cathode Ray Terminal screens became punched cards, using the specialized “off-line” folded together more and more usual. From around 1980 CRTs were dominating computer use. Terminals are connected to computers via [telephone] lines. Gradually it became usual to employ the tele- phone network for communication with comput- ers. The signals between the terminal and the computer were converted into signals that could be transmitted similarly to speech signals. They were “modulated” and “demodulated” by modems. In this way users of computers could have terminals placed at the users’ premises, connected to computers elsewhere via fixed – leased – or “dial-up” telephone lines. Vendors of computing services established large computer centres sometimes with extensive nets of leased lines and connection points for modem connections. The one single application making most use of early computer networking was seat reservation for airline passenger traffic. Already in the 1960s the large airlines had ubiquitous, often global networks for that purpose. Computer Centres and Personal Computers For economic management of expensive com- puters stable full employment of the machine is important. Before the invention of timesharing computer centres were run in “closed shop Telektronikk 2/3.2001 7 From the mid 1970s that technical development permitted complete programmable computers to be made cheaply enough to make it meaningful economically for one person to have the com- puter alone. The movement of the human per- son’s fingers and her ability to think and formu- late commands and questions are very slow if measured in a computer’s time scale. Looking at the exploitation of a personal computer – PC – one will typically find the computer running idle most of the time while the user thinks or does something else. The PC-phenomenon – econom- ically seen – is that it makes economic sense to have the machine idling, but immediately avail- able to the user – the person. Unlike the situation today that was far from true for many years. Resource Sharing Networks Computers began to have practical significance in business as tools and production machinery from the last half of the 1950s. Computer tech- nology and its use have continued to improve and increase since then. This technology has an unbelievably large and increasing importance. The punched card was an punching machines. Operating staff accepted The development has continued and continues important input medium well jobs through a window and delivered results in on. All the time it becomes more specialized into the 1970s. Itwas only the form of line printer print-outs (and the andrefined. replaced when timesharing returned card decks). During program develop- and sufficient disk storage ment that typically meant lists of error messages. Academic interest in this dramatic development permitted users to enter their The primary task of the operating staff was to started in a few places. From the late 1950s it programs directly and leave keep the computer in stable and reliable opera- was the basis of a new industry, rapidly growing. them in the computer. One tion for high productivity, referring to the use of IBM was the foremost, gigantic, standard setting card represented upto 80 computer time as an overwhelming cost factor. “powerhouse” among several great companies. characters. (Pictures copied Those card decks could be large, sometimes fill- A large and growing number of engineers and from “Britannica.com”) ing long steel drawers almost too heavy to carry. technical scientists engaged themselves in the study and development of the great new poten- Electronic integrated circuits and devices for tial that they saw and that began to open up storage and presentation (semiconductor mem- around 1960. ory, storage disks and CRT screens) have gone through a very comprehensive development One broadly based research program started in indeed continuously since 1960. Then the first the late 1960s. The Advanced Research Projects digital circuits could be built in large scale using Agency – ARPA – of the United States Depart- transistors rather than vacuum tubes. That devel- ment of Defense sponsored the building of a opment improved performance characteristics resource-sharing network called Arpanet. It bymany orders of magnitude (and continues connected four computers at universities and rapidly to improve further). research establishments in the western United States. The research program was basic technical research and the visions about Arpanet were resource sharing. Important and valuable re- sources that could be shared and hence be better exploited were several: Powerful computers By 1970 the integrated circuit (although quite weak by today’s measures) were technology had developed to a too expensive to be procured by all those who point where microprocessors wished for them and who could have put them could be “stamped out” togood use. It became desirable to make such cheaply on silicon wafers in computer resources available to more groups large numbers. This picture ofpeople. Thereby new problem areas might be shows an experimental wafer attacked and manifold creativity might more eas- with anarray of several ily meet in fruitful collaboration – resource shar- different circuit chips. The ing. matrix is cutinto individual chips 8 Telektronikk 2/3.2001