LUISS UNIVERSITY PRESS PAOLO CELLINI Internet Economics Understanding Digital and New Media Markets © 2015 LUISS University Press - Pola Srl All rights reserved isbn 978-88-6856-058-4 Luiss University Press – Pola s.r.l. Viale Pola, 12 00198 Roma tel. 06 85225485 fax 06 85225236 www.luissuniversitypress.it e-mail [email protected] Graphic design: HaunagDesign Editing: Spell srl Le fotocopie per uso personale del lettore possono essere effettuate nei limiti del 15% di ciascun volume/fascicolo di periodico dietro pagamento alla SIAE del compenso previsto dall’art. 68, commi 4 e 5, della legge 22 aprile 1941 n. 633. Le fotocopie effettuate per finalità di carattere professionale, economico o commerciale o comunque per uso diverso da quello personale possono essere effettuate a seguito di specifica autorizzazione rilasciata da CLEARedi, Centro Licenze e Autorizzazioni per le Riproduzioni Editoriali, Corso di Porta Romana 108, 20122 Milano, e-mail [email protected] e sito web www.clearedi.org. Foreword to Internet Economics by Vinton G. Cerf Vice president and Chief Internet Evangelist, Google Paolo Cellini’s book provides us with a fascinating view of the Internet as an economic phenomenon and as a general-purpose artifact that is being put to work in an endless variety of ways. It is a vast assembly of technology and institutions, driven by a variety of business models (including non-profit and government cases), and sustained by the collaboration of huge numbers of involved entities. Cellini applies economic and system analytic tools to provide readers with a deeper understanding of the Internet’s character and its role in our lives. I want to focus on the notion of artifact for a moment. The term means, roughly, ‘made by man’ as opposed to ‘found in nature.’ It seems reasonable to view the progress of our species as the story of the artifacts we have created, applied, evolved and even abandoned in favor of new ones. These are almost always enabling tools that make us more efficient, more effective and more able to overcome human limitations. Artifacts often have economic consequences since they may reduce costs, increase productivity, free time for new endeavors, enable new ways of accomplishing old goals and way to accomplish new goals. It seems important to think broadly about the notion of artifact since we might also include the invention of new institutions and practices that have effects similar to the invention of new tools and technologies. Thus, institutional artifacts that include social and institutional practices are usefully included in the broad sweep of this concept. Along side the invention of stone hand axes, adzes and scythes, obsidian-flaked knives, bows and arrows, spears and atlatls1, we may place the invention of tribes and tribal governance, Hammurabi’s Laws, the organization and management of cities, farming practices, the invention of money and the invention of Guilds. All of these are human inventions we choose to call artifacts in this essay. Human progress is the story of our invention and adoption of artifacts. The Internet is simply another, rather large-scale artifact of human invention. What makes it so interesting, as Cellini elaborates in this book, is its scale and the fabric of cooperation, collaboration and coordination that allows it to work. There is no central control. There are hundreds of thousands of independent networks, each operated independently, collaborating on the basis of bilateral and multi-lateral agreements. Voluntary standards, developed in an open and collaborative fashion in multiple fora, notably the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF), the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C), the Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers (IEEE), among many others. The so-called TCP/IP protocol suite2 binds the vast arrange of networks into the network of networks we call the Internet. A system of institutions manages the Internet’s Domain Name System and Internet Address assignment process: the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN), the five Regional Internet Registries for numerical addresses3, hundreds of top-level Domain Name Registries and independent Registrars, and the Root Zone Operators who lie at the core of the mechanism for mapping domain names into Internet Protocol addresses. The global Internet Society with its many chapters, houses the Internet Architecture Board, the IETF, the Internet Research Task Force (IRTF) and many chapters around the world for people interested in the use of the Internet and the governance policies that affect its operation and application. In addition to these administrative mechanisms, there are countless organizations, businesses and individual contributors that provide a wide range of products and services that rely upon or facilitate the operation of the Internet. The design of the Internet is called layered because it is logically structured so as to partition responsibility for various aspects of its operation to independent parties. Some organizations provide backbone transmission and switching support for moving packets of data from source to sink in the system. Some provide access to the Internet by fixed and mobile transmission systems. Some provide the hardware and software that animates the components of the Internet. Some make application software or provide services relying on huge server farms of computers, sometimes called Data Centers. The general-purpose Internet is largely application agnostic. Anything that can be implemented by the exchange and interpretation of the data in Internet Packets is fair game. As the Internet’s capacity has increased, new applications have become feasible. The casual ability to enable devices to become part of the Internet has led us to the so- called Internet of Things in in which devices become a part of the vast landscape of programmable technology/appliances/tools/machines reachable through the global Internet. This bears some relationship to a road system in which the technology of road building and the actual construction of roads creates incentive for designing and building vehicles that can use the roads for transport and buildings adjacent to the roads to house residents, support business operations including manufacturing, service the vehicles on the roads and the people in them. The road builders provide general constraints on the design of vehicles that can use the roads and law enforcement tries to assure that the users of the roads follow rules that contribute to safety and efficiency. While all analogs have weaknesses, seeing the Internet as a system of interconnected roads supporting a wide range of vehicles, users and uses and adjacent buildings, is not a bad metaphor for thinking about its implications in the future. Like many other technologies, the Internet changes the costs or speed with which communication of information can be accomplished. In addition, because the information flowing on the Internet is machinable4 the users of the Internet are able to apply the Internet’s vast computing capacity to find and process an increasingly wide range of information. Barriers to trade are reduced, delivery of digital content is speeded up, discovery of others with common interests is facilitated, ability is maintained, and important business and personal relationships are enhanced. Of course, all neutral technologies also can be abused and the Internet is no different. It is this agnostic aspect of