Table Of Content

INQUIRY An Interdisciplinary Journal of Philosophy Editor WAYNE MARTIN Past Editors ARNE NAESS ALASTAIR HANNAY Index Vol. 46, 2003 ROUTLEDGE INQUIRY ; An Interdiscipiinary Journal of Philosophy EDITOR Wayne Martin FOUNDED BY Arne Naess EDITOR EMERITUS Alastair Hannay EDITORIAL ASSISTANT Ryan Hickerson EDITORIAL BOARD Paul M. Churchland, University of California, San Diego; Stephen R. L. Clark, University of Liverpool; G. A. Cohen, All Souls College, Oxford; Hubert L. Dreyfus, University of California, Berkeley; Jon Elster, Columbia University; Dagfinn Follesdal, Stanford University and University of Oslo; Helge Hgibraaten, Norwegian University of Science and Technology; Anthony O’ Hear, University of Bradford; Charles Taylor, McGill University MANUSCRIPTS FOR CONSIDERATION. For addresses and instructions for authors, see the inside back cover. PLEASE NOTE THE NEW EDITORIAL ADDRESS DISKETTES will be requested only on acceptance of a submission PUBLISHER Correspondence concerning publishing matters (copyright, requests for permission, reprints and advertising) should be addressed to: Taylor & Francis, PO Box 2562 Solli, N-0202 Oslo, Norway. Tel: +47 22 12 98 80. Fax: +47 22 12 98 90. E-mail: post @tandf.no SUBSCRIPTION Annual subscription price for 2003 (four issues — airmail postage included) Institutions US$ 195.00. Individuals US$ 70.00. Students US$ 45.00. Visa/American Express/Mastercard/Eurocard accepted Orders for subscriptions and back issues, and changes of address should be addressed to: Taylor & Francis, Rankine Road, Basingstoke RG24 8PR, UK. Fax: +44 (0) 1256 330245 E-mail: orders @tandf.co.uk U.S. address. Taylor & Francis Group, Journals Customer Service, 325 Chestnut Street 8th Floor, Philadelphia, PA 19106, USA. Tel: +1 800 354 1420. Fax: +1 215 625 2940 E-mail: [email protected]. Information about journals and books from Taylor & Francis is available on our homepage [email protected] Electronic access. Free electronic access is available to all subscribers of the print version. More details about this can be found on our website: www.tandf.no/inquiry Individual articles in /nquiry are available from Document Delivery companies authorized by Taylor & Francis. For this journal documents are available from: Institute for Scientific Information, 3501 Market Street, Philadelphia PA 19104, USA. Fax (+1) 215 386 6362: Faxon Research Services, 238 Main Street, Suite 201, Cambridge MA 02142, USA. Fax (+1) 617 661 1484; The UnCover Company, 3801 E. Florida Ave., Suite 200, Denver CO 80210, USA Fax: (+1) 303 758 5946; EBCSO Publishing, PO Box 2250, Peabody MA 0190-7250, USA Fax: (+1) 508 535 8545 Inquiry is available in microform from University Microfilms International, 300 North Zeeb Road, Ann Arbor MI 48106, USA Inquiry is indexed/abstracted in: ABC POL SCI, Am. Hist. Life (1972- ), Arts & Humanit Citation Ind., Arts & Humanit. Search, Current Contents/Arts & Humanit., Exp. Acad Index (1989— ), FaxonFinder, Hist. Abstr., Part A, Mod. Hist. Abstr. (1972— ), Hist. Abstr., Part B, Twent. Century Abstr. (1972— ), Index Book Rev. Humanit., Intern. Bibliogr. Soc Sc., International Bibliography of the Social Sciences, Intern. Current Awaren. Serv . Periodica Islamica, Philos. Index, Soc. Plan. Policy Dev. Abstr., Sociol. Absti Inquiry (USPS permit number 538 710) is published quarterly, in March, June, September and November. The 2003 US institutional subscription price is US$ 195. Periodicals postage paid at Camplain, NY by US Mail Agent IMS of New York, 100 Walnut Street, Champlain, NY US Postmaster: Please send address changes to sINQ, PO Box 1518, Champlain, NY 12919, USA PAGE BROS Typeset and printed in Great Britain by 3E BR Page Bros, Norwich CONTENTS Editorial ALLISON, HENRY E.: Reply to the Comments of Longuenesse and acidic isin doesnot italiaennddectenhalc yion AMERIKS, KARL: On Being Neither Post- Nor Anti-Kantian: A Reply to Breazeale and Larmore Concerning The Fate of Autonomy BAZ, AVNER: On When Words are Called for: Cavell, McDowell, and the Wording of the World BREAZEALE, DANIEL: Two Cheers for Post-Kantianism: A response to Karl Ameriks CARMAN, TAYLOR: First Persons: On Richard Moran’s Authority and Estrangement CROSS, ANDREW: Faith and the Suspension of the Ethical in Fear and Trembling DE MUIJNCK, WIM: Wide Physical Realization DOPPELT, GERALD: The Theory of Justice from a Hermeneutic Perspective FORSTER, ECKART: Reply to Freidman and Guyer FORSTER, MICHAEL N.: Gods, Animals, and Artists: Some Problem Cases in Herder’s Philosophy of Language..................::c.c:ccceeeeee FRIEDMAN, MICHAEL: Eckart Forster and Kant’s Opus postumum GINSBORG, HANNAH: Aesthetic Judging and the Intentionality of Pleasure GUYER, PAUL: Beauty, Systematicity and the Highest Good: Eckart Forster's Kant’s Final Synthesis LARMORE, CHARLES: Back to Kant? No Way LIVINGSTON, PAUL: Thinking and Being: Heidegger and Wittgenstein on Machination and Lived-Experience LONGUENESSE, BEATRICE: Kant’s Theory of Judgment, and Judgments of Taste. On Henry Allison’s Kant’s Theory of Taste. MANNING, RICHARD N.: Interpretation, Reasons, and Facts NAGASAWA, YUJIN: Thomas vs. Thomas: A New Approach to Nagel’s Bat Argument REHG, WILLIAM: Grasping the Force of the Better Argument: McMahon versus Discourse Ethics REIFF, MARK R: The Politics of Masochism SCHATZKI, THEODORE R.: Living Out of the Past: Dilthey and Heidegger on Life and History SCHINDLER, D.C.: The Community of the One and the Many: Heraclitus on Reason TUCKER, AVIEZER: The Epistemic Significance of Consensus ....... Special Issue mS CN UN TRING NMG a sickc accnsccdadccdnnccsabacccuccccedcccsaasseaescess 143-292 Books Received 135, 293, 409, 523 ergdN Phg, tire aa