History in the early years Until recently, history was sometimes seen as being inappropriate for young children. Increasingly, however, teachers are discovering that children enjoy finding out about the past, yet teachers are often unsure about what counts as ‘real’ history. Hilary Cooper here explains the strands of thinking involved in historical enquiry at any level, the extent to which pre-school children can think in this way and how teachers can build on this thinking once children are in school, making history an integral part of good practice. The book includes case studies to illustrate points and activities through which historical thinking can be developed. Hilary Cooper is Director of Professional Studies in the Department of Teaching and Education Studies at Lancaster University. She has also spent many years as a class teacher in a variety of primary schools and has published widely in the area of primary history. Teaching and learning in the first three years of school Series Editor Joy Palmer This innovatory and up-to-date series is concerned specifically with curriculum practice in the first three years of school. Each book includes guidance on: (cid:127) subject content (cid:127) planning and organisation (cid:127) assessment and record keeping (cid:127) in-service training This practical advice is placed in the context of the National Curriculum and the latest theoretical work on how children learn at this age and what experiences they bring to their early years in the classroom. History in the early years Hilary Cooper London and New York First published 1995 by Routledge 11 New Fetter Lane, London EC4P 4EE This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2002. Simultaneously published in the USA and Canada by Routledge 29 West 35th Street, New York, NY 10001 © 1995 Hilary Cooper All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilized in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data A catalogue record for this book has been requested ISBN 0-415-10100-X (Print Edition) ISBN 0-203-13756-6 Master e-book ISBN ISBN 0-203-17827-0 (Glassbook Format) Contents List of illustrations vii Editor’s preface ix Acknowledgements xi Introduction 1 Part I Children’s early learning: a context for history in the first three years of school 1 Understanding change over time 7 2 Interpretations of the past 17 3 Deductions and inferences from sources 22 Part II History during the first three years of school 4 Teaching children to understand concepts of time and change 27 5 Interpretations 48 6 Deductions from sources 79 Part III Organisation, planning and assessment 7 Whole-school or Key Stage planning 109 8 Planning a unit of study 124 Part IV Four case studies 9 Case study 1: year 2/3—‘Memories of Childhood’/‘The Victorians’ 147 10 Case study 2: year 2—A class museum 152 vi Contents 11 Case study 3: year 1—‘Castles’ 161 12 Case study 4: children with severe learning difficulties— ‘A Victorian Kitchen’ 169 Part V In-service workshops 13 In-service workshops: some examples 181 Resources referred to in the text 196 Bibliography 197 Index 204 Illustrations FIGURES 7.1 Outline of approaches to planning examined in Part III 110 7.2 How topics may be sequenced and related appropriately to local resources 117 8.1 The planning process 125 8.2 Work in other curriculum areas which links with a history- focused topic, ‘Castles’ 138 8.3 How art, music, maths and science make connections between the history and geography components of a humanities- focused topic, ‘The Farm’ 140 8.4 Cycle of teachers’ self-evaluation 141 BOXES 4.1 The measurement of time 30 4.2 Chronological sequences (1) 35 4.3 Chronological sequences (2) 37 4.4 Concepts and topics 44 4.5 Historical vocabulary 46 4.6 Activities which allow children to become conscious of levels of probability 47 5.1 The ship 67 5.2 The castle 70 5.3 Cave/shelter 72 5.4 The Victorian kitchen 74 5.5 The Victorian letterbox 76 6.1 Looking at paintings: a possible sequence of questions 88 6.2 Looking at photographs 91 7.1 Three strands of historical thinking 121 7.2 Recording assessments 122 viii Illustrations 8.1 A picture gallery 126 8.2 A museum 126 8.3 An archaeological site, castle, windmill, church, great house 127 8.4 The history component of an integrated topic, ‘Clothes’ 130 8.5 Example of a history-focused topic, ‘Castles’ 132 8.6 The history dimension an integrated topic, ‘Clothes’ 134 8.7 The history dimension of a humanities-focused topic, ‘The Farm’ 136 8.8 Planning a unit 142 8.9 Example of a timetable 142 8.10 Teachers’ checklist of each child’s achievements 143 9.1 Long-term plan devised collaboratively by the three year 2/3 teachers 148 9.2 An example of one teacher’s weekly plan derived from the topic web 149 9.3 Activity plan—Objects on display 150 9.4 Activity plan—Ordering photos 150 9.5 Activity plan—My life 150 9.6 Assessment 151 11.1 Long-term plan for history activities showing assessment opportunities 161 13.1 Introducing historical thinking through stories 184 13.2 Topic grid 190 Editor’s preface Each book in this series focuses on a specific curriculum area. The series relates relevant learning theory or a rationale for early years learning to the practical development and implementation of subject-based topics and classroom activities at the infant level (i.e. Reception, Y1, Y2). It seems that the majority of existing books on primary education and the primary curriculum focus on pupils aged 7–11 years. It is hoped that this series presents a refreshing and much needed change in that it specifically addresses the first three years in school. Each volume is intended to be an up-to-date, judicious mix of theory and practical classroom application, offering a wealth of background information, ideas and advice to all concerned with planning, implementing, monitoring and evaluating teaching and learning in the first three years in school. Theoretical perspectives are presented in a lively and interesting way, drawing upon recent classroom research findings wherever possible. Case studies and activities from a range of classrooms and schools illuminate many of the substantial issues related to the subject area in question. Readers will find a similar pattern of contents in all the books in the series. Each discusses the early learning environment and the transition from home- to school-based learning, and addresses the key questions of what this means for the early years teacher and the curriculum. Such discussion inevitably incorporates ideas on the knowledge which young children may have of subjects and an overview of the subject matter itself which is under scrutiny. As the thrust of the series is towards young children learning subjects, albeit in a holistic way, no doubt readers will wish to consider what is an appropriate content or rationale for the subject in the early years. Having considered young children as learners, what they are bringing into school in terms of prior knowledge, the teacher’s task and the subject matter itself, each book then turns its attention to appropriate methods of planning, organising, implementing and evaluating teaching and learning activities. Crucial matters such as assessment, evaluation and