Higher-order Vagueness, Radical Unclarity, and Absolute Agnosticism

30 Pages·2010·0.81 MB·English

by  Susanne Bobzien

ImPhilospopherrs’int
! ! "#$%&’!()*!+#,!()
Overview
-%.%/0!1232
AB;!C9C;D!CD;8;:E8!9!:;F!EB;=DG!=H!B@IB;DJ=DK;D!L9I7;:;88,!AB@8!EB;J
=DG!@8!9:!@MCD=L;M;:E!=:!N7DD;:E!EB;=D@;8!=H!L9I7;:;88!@:!EB9E!@E!Oi)
Higher-order Vagueness, K;8ND@>;8!EB;!P@:K!=H!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8!D;Q;L9:E!E=!EB;!6=D@E;8!C9D9K=R*!
OiiS!D;E9@:8!EB;!TD=>78E:;88U!=H!L9I7;!CD;K@N9E;8*!OiiiS!@:ED=K7N;8!9!:=J
E@=:!=H!B@IB;DJ=DK;D!L9I7;:;88!EB9E!@8!N=MC=8@E@=:9Q*!>7E!OivS!9L=@K8!
EB;!C9D9K=R;8!=H!B@IB;DJ=DK;D!L9I7;:;88,!AB;!EB;=DGU8!N;:ED9Q!>7@QKJ
Radical Unclarity, @:IJ>Q=NP8V!<=DK;DQ@:;B==K!@8!K;W:;K!98!D9K@N9Q!7:NQ9D@EG,!X:NQ9D@EG!@8!
K;W:;K!>G!M;9:8!=H!N=MC;E;:E*!D9E@=:9Q*!@:H=DM;K!8C;9P;D8!OTYZ[/\8US!
FB=8;!N=MC;E;:N;*!;EN,*!@8!@:K;R;K!E=!EB;!8N=C;!=H!EB;!7:NQ9D@EG!=C;D9J
E=D,!AB;!7:NQ9D@EG!@8!D9K@N9Q!8@:N;!@E!;Q@M@:9E;8!NQ;9D!N98;8!=H!7:NQ9D@EG!
and 9:K*!EB9E!@8*!NQ;9D!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8,!AB@8!D9K@N9Q!7:NQ9D@EG!Q;9K8!E=!9!
O>@L9Q;:N;JN=MC9E@>Q;*!:=:J@:E7@E@=:@8ES!9>8=Q7E;!9I:=8E@N@8M!9>=7E!
EB;!8;M9:E@N!8E9E78!=H!9QQ!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8,!AB;!N=DD;8C=:K@:I!M=K9Q!
8G8E;M!F=7QK!>;!9!:=:J:=DM9Q!L9D@9E@=:!=:!6]^,
Absolute Agnosticism !"#$%&’()!@:ED=K7N;8!>98@N!N=:N;CE8!9:K!E;DM@:=Q=IG,!!"#$%&’(*!K;J
Q@M@E8!EB;!C9C;D!E=C@N!HD=M!D;Q9E;K!>7E!K@8E@:NE!@887;8,!!"#$%&’(+!CD;8;:E8!
EB;!D;Q;L9:E!:=E@=:!=H!B@IB;DJ=DK;D!L9I7;:;88!9:K!WL;!>98@N!Q=I@N9Q!
CD@:N@CQ;8!EB9E!E=I;EB;D!NB9D9NE;D@?;!EB@8!:=E@=:_!@E!8;E8!=7E!EB;!M9‘=D!
CD=>Q;M!H9N;K!>G!EB;!D;N;@L;K!C=8@E@=:8!=:!B@IB;DJ=DK;D!L9I7;:;88V!
EB9E!EB;G!N9::=E!CD;8;DL;!aD=>78Eb!B@IB;DJ=DK;D!L9I7;:;88!F@EB=7E!
>;@:I!N97IBE!@:!EB;!C9D9K=R;8!=H!B@IB;DJ=DK;D!L9I7;:;88,!!"#$%&’,(-(E=
).(CD;8;:E!9:!9QE;D:9E@L;!EB;=DG!=H!B@IB;DJ=DK;D!L9I7;:;88!EB9E!M9@:J
E9@:8!D=>78E:;88!F@EB=7E!H9QQ@:I!H=7Q!=H!EB;!C9D9K=R;8,!Section -!@:ED=J
Susanne Bobzien
K7N;8!9:!7:NQ9D@EG!=C;D9E=D!EB9E!N=L;D8!EB;!>=DK;DQ@:;B==K!=H!L9I7;!
;RCD;88@=:8*!9:K!@E8!@:E;DCD;E9E@=:,!AB;!=C;D9E=D!@8!9:!7:NQ;9DJFB;EB;D!
Yale University
=C;D9E=D!I=L;D:;K!>G!9!Q=I@N!M=K;Q;K!=:!:=:JN=:E@:I;:NG!Q=I@N8,!AB;!
@:E;DCD;E9E@=:!@8!>98;K!=:!EB;!@K;9!EB9E!FB;EB;D!8=M;!a!@8!>=DK;DQ@:;!F
K;C;:K8!=:!FB;EB;D!9!D;Q;L9:EQG!N=MC;E;:E*!D9E@=:9Q*!@:H=DM;K!8C;9PJ
;D!OYZ[/\S!N=7QK!E;QQ!FB;EB;D!a!@8!F,!AB;!:=E@=:!=H!9!YZ[/\!@8!=>E9@:;K!>G!
8ED@CC@:I!=DK@:9DG!8C;9P;D8!=H!9QQ!D;Q;L9:E!;C@8E;M@N!B9:K@N9C8,!YZ[/\J
:;88!@8!@:K;R;K!E=!EB;!8N=C;!=H!EB;!7:NQ9D@EG!=C;D9E=D,!AB;!D;Q;L9:E!
4!5)()!6789::;!<=>?@;: :=E@=:!=H!E;QQ@:IJFB;EB;D!@8!I=L;D:;K!>G!9!M9DI@:JH=DJ;DD=D!CD@:N@CQ;,!
<www.philosophersimprint.org/)())()/> cE!@8!8B=F:!FBG*!@H!>=DK;DQ@:;!YZ[/\8!;R@8E*!EB;G!N9::=E!>;!ND@E;D@9Q!H=D!
! /%/-++’!d#de[’+ Higher-Order Vagueness, Radical Unclarity, & Absolute Agnosticism
>=DK;DQ@:;B==K,!!"#$%&’(/!@:ED=K7N;8!9!ND@E;D@=:!H=D!K@8E@:I7@8B@:I!EB;! C9ENB!:7M>;D!h5U,!i;!78;!Fa!H=D!8@MCQ;!vague sentences*!EB9E!@8*!8;:E;:NJ
7:NQ9D@EG!NB9D9NE;D@8E@N!H=D!>=DK;DQ@:;B==K!OaD9K@N9Q!7:NQ9D@EGbS!HD=M! ;8!EB9E!N=:E9@:!9!6=D@E;8JL9I7;!CD;K@N9E;!9:K!9!K;8@I:9E=D,!i;!78;!j!
=EB;D!P@:K8!=H!7:NQ9D@EG!N=L;D;K!>G!EB;!7:NQ9D@EG!=C;D9E=D!F@EB!EB;!I@LJ H=D!CD;K@N9E;8!N=:8ED7NE;K!HD=M!F!>G!C7EE@:I!9:G!N=M>@:9E@=:!=H!NQ9DJ
;:!@:E;DCD;E9E@=:,!AB@8!ND@E;D@=:!@8!9>8=Q7E;!;C@8E;M@N!@:9NN;88@>@Q@EG,!cE! @EG!9:K!7:NQ9D@EG!=C;D9E=D8!9:K!:;I9E@=:!8@I:8!@:!HD=:E!=H!F*!@:NQ7K@:I!
H=DN;8!7C=:!78!9>8=Q7E;!9I:=8E@N@8M!9>=7E!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8,!!"#$%&’(0( :=:;,!kL;DG!6=D@E;8!8;D@;8!D7:8!=:!FB9E!F;!N9QQ!@E8!dimension D,!c:!=7D!
N=QQ;NE8!EB;!>98@N!9R@=M8!=H!9!Q=I@N!=H!B@IB;DJ=DK;D!>=DK;DQ@:;!L9I7;J ;R9MCQ;*!EB;!N=Q=7D!8C;NED7M!HD=M!D;K!E=!=D9:I;!@8!EB;!K@M;:8@=:!=H!
:;88*!@:NQ7K@:I!9:!9R@=M!EB9E!;M>=K@;8!EB;!;Q;M;:E!=H!D9K@N9Q!7:NQ9DJ EB;!8;D@;8,!l;@IBE!F=7QK!>;!EB;!K@M;:8@=:!H=D!9!6=D@E;8!F@EB!TE9QQU,!i;!
@EG!NB9D9NE;D@8E@N!H=D!>=DK;DQ@:;B==K,!AB@8!CD@:N@CQ;!OEB;!%%JvD@:N@CQ;S! N9QQ!EB;!context C!EB;!87M!=H!H9NE=D8!;RE;D:9Q!E=!9:!7EE;D9:N;!=H!9!L9I7;!
89G8!EB9E*!FB;:!@E!@8!7:NQ;9D!FB;EB;D!Fa*!@E!@8!7:NQ;9D!FB;EB;D!@E!@8!7:J 8;:E;:N;!EB9E!9D;!D;Q;L9:E!E=!EB;!8;M9:E@N!;L9Q79E@=:!=H!EB9E!7EE;D9:N;,m
NQ;9D!FB;EB;D!Fa,!o:!@:H=DM9Q!CD==H!@8!I@L;:!EB9E!EB;!:=E@=:!=H!D9K@J n=D!9:!7EE;D9:N;!N=:E9@:@:I!T@8!D;KU!EB@8!may!@:NQ7K;!Q@IBE@:I!N=:K@J
N9Q!7:NQ9D@EG*!E=I;EB;D!F@EB!EB;!@:E;DCD;E9E@=:!=H!EB;!7:NQ9D@EG!=C;D9E=D*! E@=:8*!>9NPID=7:K!N=Q=7D*!N=MC9D@8=:!NQ988*!NQ988@WN9E@=:!N9E;I=D@;8!
;:E9@Q8!EB;!%%JvD@:N@CQ;,!!"#$%&’(1!;RCQ@N9E;8!FBG!7:NQ;9D*!=D!B@KK;:*! 9:K!M=D;,!AB=8;!a !E=!a @:!C!=:!D!H=D!FB@NB!@E!@8!7:NQ;9D!FB;EB;D!EB;G!
n m
NQ;9D!N98;8!9D;!@:N=MC9E@>Q;!F@EB!EB;!@:E;DCD;E9E@=:!=H!EB;!7:NQ9D@EG! 9D;!F!N=:8E@E7E;!EB;!borderline zone!=H!F!@:!C!=:!D,!o:G!a!@:!EB;!>=DK;DJ
=C;D9E=D,!o!H7DEB;D!9R@=M!@8!@:ED=K7N;K!E=!;RNQ7K;!87NB!N98;8,!AB@8! Q@:;!?=:;!=H!F!@:!C!=:!D!@8!9!borderline case!=H!F!@:!C!=:!D*!=D*!FB9E!@8!EB;!
9R@=M!;:E9@Q8!EB;!CD@:N@CQ;!EB9E!@H!8=M;EB@:I!@8!NQ;9D*!@EU8!NQ;9D!EB9E!@EU8! 89M;*!@8!borderline F/! F!@:!C!=:!D,!o:!7EE;D9:N;!=H!TFaU!@:!C!@8!9!border-
NQ;9D!OEB;!YYJvD@:N@CQ;S,!!"#$%&’(2!CD;8;:E8!EB;!D;87QE@:I!Q=I@N9Q!8G8E;M*! line utterance!@p!@:!C, a!@8!9!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;!=H!F,!i;!9887M;!EBD=7IB=7E!
FB@NB!N=M>@:;8!B=M=I;:;@EG!=H!9QQ!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8!=H!9!L9I7;!;RJ EB9E!9QQ!8;M9:E@N!;L9Q79E@=:!=H!7EE;D9:N;8!=H!L9I7;!8;:E;:N;8!@8!D;Q9E@L;!
CD;88@=:!D;Q9E@L;!E=!9!N=:E;RE!F@EB!@:W:@E;!=DK;D8!=H!7:NQ9D@EG,!!"#$%&’(3 E=!9!N=:E;RE!9:K!9!K@M;:8@=:_q!>7E!F;!F=:UE!9QF9G8!;RCD;88QG!8E9E;!EB@8,
8B=F8!B=F!>=EB!D=>78E:;88!9:K!E=Q;D9:N;!9D;!CD;8;DL;K!@:!EB;!8G8E;M,! l@IB;DJ=DK;D!L9I7;:;88!@8!M=8E!N=MM=:QG!K@8N788;K!@:!E;DM8!=H!
!"#$%&’().(N=:8@K;D8!FB9E!8;M9:E@N8!9:K!Q=I@N!w!@H!9:G!w!B=QK!H=D!EB;! NQ9D@EG*!K;W:@E;:;88!=D!K;E;DM@:9NG,!i;!H9L=7D!clarity!9:K!78;!T@E!@8!
>=DK;DQ@:;!?=:;8!9:K!FB9E!B9CC;:8!E=!C;:7M>D9Q!N=::;NE@=:8,!Sec- NQ;9D!EB9E!a!@8!F U!D9EB;D!EB9:!Ta!@8!K;W:@E;QG!F!!U!=D!T@E!@8!K;E;DM@:9E;!EB9E!
$%&’())(K;M=:8ED9E;8!EB9E!EB;!EB;=DG!=H!9>8=Q7E;!9I:=8E@N@8M!K;L;Q=C;K! a!@8!F!!U!9:K!8@M@Q9D,!iB;:!N=MC9D@:I!EB;=D@;8*!F;!K@8D;I9DK!EB;!K@p;DJ
@:!Sections ]g(.!@8!@MM7:;!E=!EB;!L9D@=78!C9D9K=R;8!=H!B@IB;DJ=DK;D! ;:N;8!>;EF;;:!EB;8;!H=DM7Q9E@=:8*!8@:N;!H=D!CD;8;:E!C7DC=8;8!EB;G!9D;!
L9I7;:;88!EB9E!B9L;!>;;:!C7E!H=DF9DK!>G!iD@IBE*!n9D9*!6B9C@D=!9:K! =H!M@:=D!D;Q;L9:N;,!AB;!D;98=:!H=D!NB==8@:I!NQ9D@EG!@8!EB9E!F;!>;Q@;L;!
i@QQ@9M8=:,!c:!9:!9CC;:K@R!Oi. e,!!"#$%&’()*S!L9D@=78!r7;8E@=:8!9>=7E!EB;! @E!E=!>;*!@:!EB;!WD8E!@:8E9:N;*!9:!;C@8E;M@N!r7;8E@=:!FB;EB;D!8=M;EB@:I!
;R@8E;:N;!=H!YZ[/\8!9D;!9:8F;D;K, @8!9!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;,s
1. Preliminaries (,! i;!E9P;!7EE;D9:N;8!=H!K;NQ9D9E@L;!8;:E;:N;8!98!CD@M9DG!ED7EBJ>;9D;D8_!>7E!
FB9E!F;!89G!F=DP8 mutatis mutandis!H=D!8;:E;:N;8J@:JN=:E;RE*!8E9E;M;:E8*!9:K!
A9P;!9!6=D@E;8!8;D@;8!F@EB!:7M>;D;K!N=Q=7D!C9ENB;8!D9:I@:I!HD=M!D;K! =EB;D!OC=E;:E@9QS!ED7EBJ>;9D;D8!EB9E!K=!‘78E@N;!E=!EB;!N=:E;RE!8;:8@E@L@EG!=H!
E=!=D9:I;,!v9ENB!:7M>;D!(!@8!D;K*!:7M>;D!())!@8!=D9:I;,!6=M;FB;D;!@:! L9I7;!;RCD;88@=:8,
>;EF;;:!EB;D;!9D;!C9ENB;8!H=D!FB@NB!@E!@8!7:NQ;9D!FB;EB;D!EB;G!9D;!D;K! 5,! AB;!C9D9M;E;D!dimension!>;N=M;8!D;Q;L9:E!FB;:!=:;!N=:8@K;D8!L9I7;!7EE;DJ
9:N;8!=H!B@IB;D!=DK;D8,
=D!=D9:I;J9:KJ:=EJD;K,!i;!78;!EB;!Q;EE;D!F!H=D!Sorites-vague O=D!vague )
S t,! u>L@=78QG*!EB@8!K=;8!:=E!M9P;!78!;C@8E;M@N@8E8,!6=D@E;8!C9D9K=R;8!I;E!EB;@D!
predicates*!EB9E!@8!CD;K@N9E;8!EB9E!I@L;!D@8;!E=!WD8EJ=DK;D!6=D@E;8!C9D9J
CQ978@>@Q@EG!HD=M!EB;!H9NE!EB9E!F;!can’t tell!EB;!Q98E!N98;!EB9E!89E@8W;8!e. g,!TE9QQU!O=D!
K=R;8*!87NB!98!T@8!D;KU_!9:K!a 9:K!a!E=!a !H=D!K;8@I:9E=D8!Q@P;!TN=Q=7D! TK;W:@E;QG!E9QQU*!etc.S,!iB;EB;D!G=7!9D;!9:!;C@8E;M@N@8E!@8!K;N@K;K!>G!FB;EB;D!
m n
\f[$#/#\f’Z/U![&\Z[+0! g!!5!!g! "#$,!()*!+#,!()!O-%.%/0!1232S
! /%/-++’!d#de[’+ Higher-Order Vagueness, Radical Unclarity, & Absolute Agnosticism
cE!@8!NB9D9NE;D@8E@N!H=D!L9I7; !CD;K@N9E;8!EB9E!EB;G!9D;!E=Q;D9:E!9:K! L;@:*!M7QE@JK@M;:8@=:9Q!L9I7; !CD;K@N9E;8!9D;!N=:8@K;D;K!
6 6
EB9E!EB;@D!L9I7;:;88!@8!D=>78E,!o!CD;K@N9E;!@8!tolerant!FB;:!EB;D;!@8!9! =:QG!@:8=H9D!98!EB;G!9QQ=F!EB;!N=:8ED7NE@=:!=H!8;L;D9Q!=:;J
:=E@=:!=H!K;ID;;!=H!NB9:I;!EB9E!8;;M8x!E==!8M9QQ!E=!M9P;!9:G!K@p;DJ K@M;:8@=:9Q!6=D@E;8!C9D9K=R;8,
;:N;!E=!@E8!9CCQ@N9>@Q@EG*!98!H=D!@:8E9:N;!9!8@:IQ;!B9@D!H=D!T>9QKU,!A=Q;D9:N;!
ii,!! Ontic clarity!O98!=CC=8;K!E=!;C@8E;M@N!NQ9D@EGS,!i;!N9:!89GV!
I@L;8!D@8;!E=!EB;!9CC9D;:EQG!8;9MQ;88!ED9:8@E@=:!=H!L9I7;!CD;K@N9E;8!
TAB@8!@8!9!NQ;9D!D;K*!EB9E!@8!9!M7E;K!D;KU_!TAB@8!F9E;D!@8!NQ;9D*!
HD=M!N98;8!FB;D;!EB;G!9CCQG!E=!EB=8;!FB;D;!EB;G!K=:UE,!AB;!L9I7;:;88!
EB9E!F9E;D!@8!M7DPGU,!l;D;!NQ9D@EG!@8!9:!98C;NE!=D!CD=C;DEG!
=H!L9I7; !CD;K@N9E;8!@8!robust y!@:8=H9D!98!EB;D;!@8!H=D!9!L9I7; !;RCD;8J
6 6 =H!EB@:I8!@:!EB;!F=DQK,!<G!N=:ED98E*!F;!9D;!N=:N;D:;K!F@EB!
8@=:!F!O@:!C!=:!DS!:=E!=:QG!9!>=DK;DQ@:;!?=:;!N=:8@8E@:I!@:!9!:7M>;D!=H!
epistemic!NQ9D@EG*!98!@:!TcE!@8!NQ;9D!EB9E!EB@8!9DI7M;:E!@8!L9Q@KU!
87NN;88@L;!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8!=H!FB@NB!F;!N9::=E!E;QQ!FB;EB;D!EB;G!9D;!
=D!TAB@8!C9ENB!@8!NQ;9DQG!D;KU,
F_!F;!9Q8=!N9::=E!E;QQ!FB;D;!EB@8!>=DK;DQ@:;!?=:;!>;I@:8!9:K!FB;D;!@E!
;:K8,!o:G!89E@8H9NE=DG!EB;=DG!=H!L9I7; !CD;K@N9E;8!B98!E=!9NN=7:E!H=D! iii,!! Degrees of clarity!O98!=CC=8;K!E=!B@IB;D!=DK;D8!=H!NQ9D@EGS,!
6
>=EB!E=Q;D9:N;!9:K!D=>78E:;88,z AB;D;!N9:!>;!L9DG@:I!K;ID;;8!=H!;C@8E;M@N!NQ9D@EGV!cE!N9:!
>;!NQ;9D!EB9E!Fa*!>7E!:=E!L;DG!NQ;9D,!uD!=:;!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;!
2. What we are not concerned with
N=7QK!8;;M!Q;88!7:NQ;9D!EB9:!9:=EB;D,!67NB!K;ID;;8!=H!
A=!CD;J;MCE!M@87:K;D8E9:K@:I8*!F;!M;:E@=:!9!H;F!EB@:I8!F;!9D;!:=E! NQ9D@EG!9D;!K;ID;;8!=H!WD8EJ=DK;D!NQ9D@EG,!AB;!K@p;D;:E!K;J
N=:N;D:;K!F@EBV ID;;8!9D;!9QQ!9E!EB;!89M;!Q;L;Q,
i,! Any vagueness that is not Sorites vagueness,!n=D!;R9MCQ;*!9QJ iv,! 45"(&67%’869(:8’;<8;"("=>6",,%&’,(?#:"86@A(?7"$"6B%’8$"@A(?7"C-
EB=7IB!;RCD;88@=:8!Q@P;!T:@N;U!9:K!TD;Q@I@=:U!9D;!:=!K=7>E! nite’, etc., and their logic,!c:!C9DE@N7Q9D*!F;!9D;!:=E!N=:N;D:;K!
L9I7;!@:!8=M;!8;:8;*!F;!9D;!N=:N;D:;K!F@EB!EB;M!=:QG!@H! F@EB!OaS!FB;EB;D!=DK@:9DG!Q9:I79I;!CD;K@N9E;8!87NB!98!T@E!
9:K!@:8=H9D!98!EB;G!9D;!L9I7; ,!AB;!D9E@=:9Q;!>;B@:K!EB@8! @8!NQ;9D!EB9E!x!@8!D;KU!=D!T@E!@8!K;W:@E;QG!K;W:@E;!EB9E!x!@8!
6
D;8ED@NE@=:!@8*!WD8E*!EB9E!EB;!6=D@E;8!C9D9K=R!@8!EB;!M=8E!8;J >9QKU!9D;!L9I7;!OEB;G!CD=>9>QG!9D;S_!9:K!ObS!FB;EB;D!=DK@J
D@=78!NB9QQ;:I;!L9I7;!;RCD;88@=:8!C=8;!E=!CB@Q=8=CB;D8_! :9DG!Q9:I79I;!;RCD;88@=:8!87NB!98!T@E!@8!K;E;DM@:9E;!EB9EU!
9:K!8;N=:K*!EB9E!@:!N98;8!Q@P;!T:@N;U!9:K!TD;Q@I@=:U!L9I7;J =D!TNQ;9DQGU!N9:!>;!@E;D9E;K!OEB;G!CD=>9>QG!N9:S!9:K!FB9E!
:;88!@8!=:;!=H!8;L;D9Q!H9NE=D8!EB9E!M9P;!87NB!;RCD;88@=:8! Q=I@N9Q!D7Q;8!F=7QK!I=L;D:!87NB!@E;D9E;K!;RCD;88@=:8,!u7D!
K@{N7QE!E=!B9:KQ;!>=EB!Q=I@N9QQG!9:K!8;M9:E@N9QQG*!9:K! B7:NB!@8!EB9E!EB@8!P@:K!=H!B@IB;DJ=DK;D!L9I7;:;88!@8!=H!
F;!CD;H;D!K;9Q@:I!F@EB!;9NB!H9NE=D!8;C9D9E;QG,!c:!EB;!89M;! Q@EEQ;!8@I:@WN9:N;!CD9NE@N9Q!9:K!CB@Q=8=CB@N9Q,!i;!9D;!=:QG!
@:E;D;8E;K!@:!>=DK;DQ@:;B==K!98!@:ED=K7N;K!9>=L;,!u7D!
G=7!EB@:P!EB;!reasons why we can’t tell!9D;!;C@8E;M@N,!X8@:I!9!NQ9D@EG!=C;D9E=D!
CD=‘;NE!@8!E=!7:;9DEB!EB;!Q=I@N!EB9E!I=L;D:8!L9I7; !CD;K@J
@:8E;9K!=H!9!K;W:@E;:;88!=C;D9E=D!EB78!P;;C8!M=D;!=CE@=:8!=C;:,!|D;;:=7IB! 6
O5))tS!@8!B;QCH7Q!=:!EB@8!C=@:E, N9E;8!9:K!EB;@D!>=DK;DQ@:;!?=:;8,!cE!@8!=7D!L@;F!EB9E!9:!@:J
],! i;!D;I9DK!E=Q;D9:N;!98!9!phenomenon!@:!:;;K!=H!;RCQ9:9E@=:,!u:!E=Q;D9:N;! K;CEB!9:9QG8@8!=H!=DK@:9DG!Q9:I79I;!F=:UE!B;QC!F@EB!EB@8!
8;;!9Q8=!iD@IBE!O(}~hS!9:K!O(}~(cid:127)S,
CD=‘;NE,
h,! AB;!;RCD;88@=:!F98!=D@I@:9QQG!@:ED=K7N;K!>G!A;D;:N;!l=DI9:_!8;;!e. g,!l=DI9:!
O(}}]S!C,!((cid:127)5!9:K!:,~, v,! The vagueness of ‘vague’,!X:K=7>E;KQG*!EB;!CD;K@N9E;!TL9I7;U!
(cid:127),! (cid:128)H,!n9D9!O5))tS!(}~g(cid:129), @8!@E8;QH!L9I7;*!9:K!@:!EB@8!8;:8;!8;N=:KJ=DK;D!L9I7;:;88*!
\f[$#/#\f’Z/U![&\Z[+0! g!!t!!g! "#$,!()*!+#,!()!O-%.%/0!1232S
! /%/-++’!d#de[’+ Higher-Order Vagueness, Radical Unclarity, & Absolute Agnosticism
9:K!C=88@>QG!B@IB;DJEB9:J8;N=:KJ=DK;D!L9I7;:;88*!;R@8E8,(cid:137) O%(cid:130)) Uja j ! Cja & ! C ! ja,
l=F;L;D*!EB@8!@8!:=E!=7D!E=C@N!;@EB;D,
UFa!@8!D;I9DK;K!98!;r7@L9Q;:E!E=!Ta!@8!>=DK;DQ@:;!F!!U,!AB78!a!@8!>=DK;DQ@:;!
3. Higher-order borderline vagueness F!@p!a!@8!>=DK;DQ@:;!! FV
iB9E!F;!9D;!N=:N;D:;K!F@EB!@8!9!K@p;D;:E!P@:K!=H!B@IB;DJ=DK;D!L9I7;J U ! Fa j ! C ! Fa & ! C ! ! Fa >G!O%(cid:130))
:;88!w!EB;! P@:K! M=8E! HD;r7;:EQG! K@8N788;K,! AB;! r7;8E@=:! B;D;! @8!
U ! Fa j ! CFa & ! C ! Fa K=7>Q;!:;I9E@=:*!
FB;EB;D!EB;D;!9D;!:=E!=:QG!8@MCQ;!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8!=H!>;@:I!D;K*!89G*!
! N=MM7E9E@L@EG!=H!(cid:131)
>7E!9Q8=!>=DK;DQ@:;!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8*!9:K!C=88@>QG!>=DK;DQ@:;!>=DK;DJ
Q@:;!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8*!9:K!8=!H=DEB,!A=!9L=@K!N=:H78@=:*!EB@8!CB;:=MJ O67>8E@E7E@=:!=H!Q=I@N9QQG!;r7@L9Q;:E!H=DM7Q9;!F@EB@:!EB;!8N=C;!=H!C
;:=:!8B=7QK!D;9QQG!>;!N9QQ;K!TB@IB;DJ=DK;D!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8U*!=D!TB@IBJ @8!CD;87M;K!C;DM@EE;K,S!<G!@E;D9E@=:*!a!@8!>=DK;DQ@:;!>=DK;DQ@:;!F!@p!@E!
;DJ=DK;D!>=DK;DQ@:;!L9I7;:;88U,(cid:138)!AB;!:=E@=:8!=H!NQ9D@EG!OK;E;DM@:9NG*! @8!7:NQ;9D!FB;EB;D!Fa_!EB@8!N9:!>;!;RCD;88;K!98!UDFa,!AB;!Q=I@N9Q!8G8J
K;W:@E;:;88S!CB@Q=8=CB;D8!B9L;!@:ED=K7N;K!9D;!I;:;D9QQG!9887M;K!E=! E;M8!EB9E!B9L;!>;;:!N=:8ED7NE;K!F@EB!87NB!9:!7:NQ9D@EG!=C;D9E=D!L9DG,!
8E9:K!@:!EB;!H=QQ=F@:I!D;Q9E@=:!E=!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8V!a!@8!9!>=DK;DQ@:;! l=F;L;D*!@:8=H9D!98!EB;G!C7DC=DE!E=!N9CE7D;!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8!F@EB!EB;!
N98;!=H!F!@p!Fa!@8!7:NQ;9D_!9:K!Fa!@8!7:NQ;9D*!@H!@E!@8!:;@EB;D!NQ;9D!EB9E! 7:NQ9D@EG!=C;D9E=D*!>=DK;DQ@:;!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8!F@EB!EB;!@E;D9E;K!7:J
a!@8!F!:=D!NQ;9D!EB9E!a!@8!:=E!F,!(cid:139);E*!F;!D;C;9E*!EB;!CB@Q=8=CB@N9Q!@887;! NQ9D@EG!=C;D9E=D*!etc.*!O9:K!EB;G!K=(cid:132)S!E%8;68B()!8B=7QK!>;!9:!9NN7D9E;!
@8!:=E!9>=7E!EB;!N=MCQ;R!8;M9:E@N8!=H!=DK@:9DG!Q9:I79I;!;RCD;88@=:8! D;CD;8;:E9E@=:!=H!EB;!;RE;:8@=:9Q!K@8ED@>7E@=:!=H!=C;D9E=D8!=:!9:G!NB=J
87NB!98!TNQ;9DU!=D!TK;E;DM@:9E;U,!(cid:140)9EB;D*!8=M;!>98@N!8;M9:E@N!H;9E7D;8!=H! 8;:!K@M;:8@=:!=H!EB;!L9I7;!CD;K@N9E;,m(cid:133)
EB;8;!;RCD;88@=:8!9D;!7E@Q@?;K!@:!=DK;D!E=!N9CE7D;!EB;!CB;:=M;:=:!=H!
f dimension D f
>=DK;DQ@:;B==K,
!"#"$%& CFx UFx C! Fx
6E9:K9DKQG*!9!NQ9D@EG!OK;W:@E;:;88*!K;E;DM@:9NGS!=C;D9E=D!T@E!@8!NQ;9D!
!"#"$%’ CDFx UDFx CUFx UDFx CD! Fx
OK;W:@E;*!K;E;DM@:9E;S!EB9E!FaU!=D!CFa!ODef Fa, DA, (cid:136)’0Ova), IJS!@8!@:J
!"#"$%( CFFx UFFx CUDFx UFFx CDUFx UFFx CUDFx UFFx CF! Fx
ED=K7N;K*!9:K!@E!@8!9887M;K!EB9E*!8G:E9NE@N9QQG*!EB@8!=C;D9E=D!N9:!>;!@EJ
…
;D9E;KV!CFa, CCFa!O=D!C(cid:141)Fa) …, CnFa,!AB;!=:;!EB;=D;M!7:9:@M=78QG!
Level n CnFx UnFx CU’GHFx … UnFx C’GHUFx UnFx … CU’GHFx UnFx Cn! Fx
9NN;CE;K!H=D!EB@8!=C;D9E=D!@8
!"#$%#&’(
O0) Cja f!ja.
N
E%8;68B()!M9P;8!L@879QQG!;RCQ@N@E!8;L;D9Q!9887MCE@=:8!EB9E!NB9D9NE;DJ
AB;!NQ9D@EG!=C;D9E=D!@8!EB78!H9NE@L;,!cE!@8!H7DEB;D!N=MM=:!E=!@:ED=K7N;!
@?;!EB;!L9I7;:;88 !=H!9:!;RCD;88@=:!TF!!U!D;Q9E@L;!E=!9!K@M;:8@=:!D,!n@D8E*!
9:!7:NQ9D@EG!=D!@:K;E;DM@:9NG!=C;D9E=D,!AB@8!@8!7879QQG!E9P;:!E=!8E9:K! 6
@:!EB;!H=QQ=F@:I!D;Q9E@=:!E=!EB;!NQ9D@EG!=C;D9E=D(cid:142) TGAU!H=D!@E!@8!K;E;DM@:9E;!FB;EB;D!AU_!i@QQ@9M8=:!O(}}]S*!9E!5h}g(cid:127)(*!87II;8E8!
EB9E!9:!T@E!@8!7:NQ;9D!FB;EB;DU!=C;D9E=D!>;!9:9QG?;K!98!T@E!@8!7:NQ;9D!EB9E!A!9:K!
~,! AB@8!@887;!@8!K@8N788;K!@:!6=D;:8;:!O(}(cid:129)hS*!lGK;!O5))tS*!(cid:143)9D?@!O5))tS,
7:NQ;9D!EB9E!:=E!AU,!6=M;!97EB=D8!K=:UE!K;W:;!87NB!9!8;N=:K!=C;D9E=D*!>7E!
(cid:129),! iB9E!i@QQ@9M8=:!Q9>;Q8!>=DK;DQ@:;!L9I7;:;88!@:!B@8!O(}}}S!9E!(t(cid:127)g~!D;CD;J 8E@QQ!M9DP!=7E!N98;8!=H!@:K;E;DM@:9NG*!etc., e. g,!^N|;;(cid:134)^N(cid:135)97IBQ@:!O(}}hS!55(cid:129)V!
8;:E8!>7E!=:;!=H!8;L;D9Q!8G8E;M8!=H!B@IB;DJ=DK;D!>=DK;DQ@:;!L9I7;:;88!EB9E! 8;:E;:N;8!EB9E!9D;!:;@EB;D!K;W:@E;QG!ED7;!:=D!K;W:@E;QG!H9Q8;!9D;!7:8;EEQ;K_!
B9L;!>;;:!87II;8E;K, 6B9C@D=!O5))(cid:127)S!()(g5V!! (cid:136)’0OPa)&! (cid:136)’0O! PaS!H=D!TPa!@8!@:K;E;DM@:9E;U,
},! E. g,!n@:;!O(}~hS!5(cid:129)~*!TIAU!H=D!T@E!@8!@:K;W:@E;!EB9E!AU_!(cid:144);;H;(cid:134)6M@EB!O(}}~,5S!5(cid:129)! (),!n=D!H=DM9Q!8G8E;M8!EB9E!C7DC=DE;KQG!D;CD;8;:E!B@IB;DJ=DK;D!>=DK;DQ@:;!L9I7;J
TcU!98!@:K;W:@E;QG!=C;D9E=D_!(cid:144);;H;!O5)))S!5(cid:127)*!((cid:127)(cid:129)!‘IpU!H=D!Tp!@8!@:K;E;DM@:9E;U_! :;88!>7E!EB9E!K=!:=E!WE!Diagram!(*!EB;!=:78!E=!8B=F!EB;!C;DE@:;:N;!=H!EB;@D!
n@;QK!O5))t,(S!(cid:145)5*!T! GAU!H=D!T@E!@8!@:K;E;DM@:9E;!FB;EB;D!AU_!n@;QK!O5))t,5S!5(cid:129)(! Q=I@N!E=!EB;!CD=>Q;M!=H!L9I7;:;88!Q@;8!F@EB!EB;@D!CD=C=:;:E8,
6
\f[$#/#\f’Z/U![&\Z[+0! g!!]!!g! "#$,!()*!+#,!()!O-%.%/0!1232S
! /%/-++’!d#de[’+ Higher-Order Vagueness, Radical Unclarity, & Absolute Agnosticism
EF=!9887MCE@=:8!9>=7E!C;:7M>D9Q!N=::;NE@=:8V!cH!9:!=>‘;NE!a!=:!D!@8! oE!Q;L;Q!t*!UFFx!N=L;D8!H=7D!N98;8,!o:K!8=!H=DEB,mq
n!E@M;8!NQ;9DQG!F*!EB;:!9QQ!=>‘;NE8!=:!D!E=!EB;!Q;HE!=H!a!9D;!n!E@M;8!NQ;9DQG!
i;!N9QQ!EB;!8;NE@=:!=:!D!FB@NB!@8!EB;!7:@=:!=H!>=DK;DQ@:;!?=:;8!=H!9QQ!
F_!9:K!@H!9:!=>‘;NE!a!=:!D!@8!n!E@M;8!NQ;9DQG!:=E!F*!EB;:!9QQ!=>‘;NE8!=:!
=DK;D8!EB;!overall borderline zone,!iB9E!8=M;!97EB=D8!D;H;D!E=!98!T>=DJ
D!E=!EB;!D@IBE!=H!a!9D;!n!E@M;8!NQ;9DQG!:=E!F_!F@EB!n!(cid:148)!),!AB;8;!9887MCJ
K;DQ@:;!NQ9D@EGU!=D!T>=DK;DQ@:;!NQ;9D!EB9EU!Oi. e,!EB;!CF/! CF!>=DK;DQ@:;!
E@=:8!N9:!>;!;RCD;88;K!H=DM9QQG!98!O=:!9:G!K@M;:8@=:!D)
N98;8S!N9:!>;!;RCD;88;K!98!UCFx!=D!U ! CFx,
O\Y) CnFa f CnFa cE!@8!K@8E@:NE@L;!=H!B@IB;DJ=DK;D!>=DK;DQ@:;!L9I7;:;88!B=F!EB;!L9D@J
m m mJm
=78!Q;L;Q8!=H!L9I7;:;88!9D;!D;Q9E;K!E=!;9NB!=EB;DV!EB;!I;:;D9Q!@K;9!@8!
O\Y ) Cn! Fa f Cn! Fa
q m m(cid:146)m EB9E!;9NB!B@IB;D!Q;L;Q!improves on!EB;!CD;L@=78!=:;,!n=D!@:8E9:N;*!EB;!
F@EB!EB;!8E9:K9DK!K@D;NE@=:9Q@EG!HD=M!F!E=!! F!D7::@:I!HD=M!Q;HE!E=!D@IBE,! Q=F;D!Q;L;Q8!M9G!;9NB!>;!D;I9DK;K!98!@:N=MCQ;E;,!c:!EB9E!N98;*!FB;DJ
6;N=:K!EB;D;!@8!EB;!9887MCE@=:!OY S*!=D!TNQ9D@EG!;R@8E;:N;U*!EB9E!EB;D;! ;L;D!=:!D!Q;L;Q!n(cid:146)(!B98!9!H=DM7Q9!8E9DE@:I!F@EB!U*!Q;L;Q!n!@8!EB;:!E9P;:!
Ô
9D;!NQ;9D!N98;8!=H!F!9:K!=H!! F,!O\YS*!O\Y S!9:K!OY S!E=I;EB;D!I79D9:E;;! E=!N=:E9@:!9!I9C!F@EB=7E!8B9DC!>=7:K9D@;8!EB9E!@8!:=E!N=L;D;K!>G!EB;!
m q Ô
EB9E*!@H!EB;D;!9D;!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8!=H!F!9:K!NQ;9D!N98;8!=H!F!9:K!! F!=:!9! H=DM7Q9;!=:!Q;L;Q!n,!(cid:135);L;Q!n(cid:146)(!B;D;!CD=L@K;8!8=M;!P@:K!=H!CD;N@8@WN9J
K@M;:8@=:!D*!EB;:!EB;!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8!9D;!Q=N9E;K!>;EF;;:!EB;!NQ;9D! E@=:!=H!Q;L;Q!n,!oQE;D:9E@L;QG*!Q;L;Q!n!M9G!>;!D;I9DK;K!98!9!provisional
N98;8_!M=D;=L;D*!EB9E!EB;D;!9D;!NQ;9D!N98;8!9E!;@EB;D!;:K!=H!D,!i;!E9P;! ;RB978E@L;!NQ988@WN9E@=:!8NB;M;!H=D!9QQ!a!=:!D*!F@EB!EB;!>=7:K9D@;8!
EB;8;!D;87QE8!E=!D;(cid:149);NE!=7D!>98@N!@:E7@E@=:8!9>=7E!L9I7; !CD;K@N9E;8,mm Q;HE!7:8C;N@W;K,!c:!EB@8!N98;!Q;L;Q!n(cid:146)( F=7QK!>;!9!revision!O:=E!9!CD;J
6
AB@DK*!EB;D;!@8!EB;!Q@:;9D@EG!9887MCE@=:!O$-S!EB9E*!9E!;L;DG!Q;L;Q*!;L;DG!a N@8@WN9E@=:S!=H!Q;L;Q!n,!k@EB;D!F9G*!Q;L;Q!n!F=7QK!>;!87C;D8;K;K!9:K!
H9QQ8!@:E=!=:;!=H!EB;!N9E;I=D@;8!Q@8E;K!H=D!EB9E!Q;L;Q!=:!D,!n=D!Q;L;Q!n*!F;! D;CQ9N;K!>G!Q;L;Q n(cid:146)(,!uH!N=7D8;*!I@L;:!O0S*!EB;!Q=F;D!Q;L;Q8!9D;!9QQ!@:!
N
N9:!;RCD;88!EB@8!H=DM9QQG!98!O=:!9:G!K@M;:8@=:!D) some!8;:8;!CD;8;DL;K!@:!EB;!B@IB;D!=:;8,
oE!9:G!Q;L;Q!n*!F;!N9:!@K;:E@HG!WD8E*!8;N=:K*!9:K!B@IB;DJ=DK;D!>=DJ
O$-) Óx [CnFx v UnFx v CU’GHFx v CDU’GDFx v CFU’GFFx
K;DQ@:;!N98;8*!9:K!B@IB;D!=DK;D8!=H!L9I7;:;88*!98!H=QQ=F8V
v … v C’GHUFx v Cn! Fx(cid:150),
o:G!7EE;D9:N;!=H!9!8;:E;:N;!F@EB!U!98!Q98E!=C;D9E=D!>;H=D;!Fa
(cid:135)98EQG*!EB;D;!@8!no!9887MCE@=:!EB9E!9QQ!=H!EB;!8;NE@=:8!9E!Q;L;Q8!5!9:K!
;RCD;88;8!EB9E!a!@8!9!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;!O=H!8=M;!=DK;DS!=H!F,!AB78!
B@IB;D!B9L;!@:8E9:N;8,!AB@8!>;N=M;8!8@I:@WN9:E!Q9E;D,
H=D!@:8E9:N;!O@H!F;!8E=CC;K!9E!Q;L;Q!tS!7EE;D@:I!CDUFa*!F;!F=7QK!
E%8;68B()!9Q8=!@QQ78ED9E;8!B=F!EB;!7:NQ9D@EG!=C;D9E=D!N9DL;8!=7E!9!
;RCD;88!EB9E!a!@8!9!ONQ;9DQG!NQ;9DS!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;!=H!F,
M@KKQ;!8;NE@=:!FB@NB!D;CD;8;:E8!EB;!>=DK;DQ@:;!?=:;!=H!F!=:!D*!9:K!
B=F*!9E!B@IB;D!Q;L;Q8*!EB;!M@KKQ;!8;NE@=:8!M7QE@CQG, oE!9:G!Q;L;Q!n*!9!WD8EJ=DK;D!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;!=H!F!@8!9:G!a!H=D!FB@NB!
@E!B=QK8!EB9E!ja!9E!Q;L;Q!n!;:E9@Q8!UFa,
oE!Q;L;Q!(*!UFx!N=L;D8!EB;!7:NQ;9D!N98;8!>;EF;;:!CFx!9:K!C ! Fx,
oE!9:G!Q;L;Q!n*!9:!mEBJ=DK;D!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;!=H!F!@8!9:G!a!H=D!
oE!Q;L;Q!5*!UDFx!N=L;D8!EB;!7:NQ;9D!N98;8!OHD=M!Q;HE!E=!D@IBE!=:!
FB@NB!@E!B=QK8!EB9E!ja!9E!Q;L;Q!n!;:E9@Q8!UmFa,
EB;!K@M;:8@=:S
o!CD;K@N9E;!F!@8!nEBJ=DK;D!L9I7; !@p!ÔxUnFx,
! >;EF;;:!CDFx!9:K!CUFx*!9:K 6
! >;EF;;:!CUFx!9:K!CD! Fx, (5,!v7E!K@p;D;:EQG*!UDFa!@8!;r7@L9Q;:E!E=!! CDFa & ! CUFa & ! CD! Fa_!UFFa!E=!
! CFFa & ! CUDFa & ! CDUFa & ! CF! Fa_!9:K!I;:;D9QQG*!UnFa!@8!;r7@L9Q;:E!E=!
((,!AB;!K@9ID9M8!D;CD;8;:E!=:QG!K@M;:8@=:8!EB9E!B9L;!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8!=H!F!9:K! ! CnFa & ! C’GK’GHLUK’GHLFa & ! C’GK’GDLUK’GDLFa & … & ! C’GK’GBLUK’GBLFa & ! Cn! Fa,
NQ;9D!N98;8!=H!>=EB!F!9:K!! F, F@EB!n(cid:146)m!N=:‘7:NE8!9:K!m!(cid:147)!OnJmS,
\f[$#/#\f’Z/U![&\Z[+0! g!!h!!g! "#$,!()*!+#,!()!O-%.%/0!1232S
! /%/-++’!d#de[’+ Higher-Order Vagueness, Radical Unclarity, & Absolute Agnosticism
AB@8!EB;:!@8!w!>G!9:K!Q9DI;!w!EB;!:=E@=:!=H!B@IB;DJ=DK;D!L9I7;:;88!EB9E! 8=JN9QQ;K!TC9D9K=R;8!=H!B@IB;DJ=DK;D!L9I7;:;88U,m(cid:137)!OtS!oE!WD8E!>Q78B*!EB;!
@8!EB;!E=C@N!=H!EB;!CD;8;:E!C9C;D, 87II;8E@=:!E=!N7E!=p!B@IB;D!=DK;D8!9E!8=M;!Q=FQG!Q;L;Q!M9G!8;;M!CQ97J
AB;D;! 9D;! M9:G! K@p;D;:E! EB;=D@;8! =H! B@IB;DJ=DK;D! >=DK;DQ@:;! 8@>Q;,!(cid:139);E!@E*!E==*!L@=Q9E;8!EB;!D=>78E:;88!D;r7@D;M;:E,!AB;!EB;=DG!=H!
L9I7;:;88*!>7E!M=8E!N9:!>;!8=DE;K!@:E=!EBD;;!ID=7C8!78@:I!EB;!H=QQ=FJ B@IB;DJ=DK;D!L9I7;:;88!CD;8;:E;K!@:!EB;!H=QQ=F@:I!8;NE@=:8!N=M>@:;8!
@:I!ND@E;D@9Vms EB;!9KL9:E9I;8!=H!EB;!WD8E!EF=!L@;F8!F@EB=7E!8B9D@:I!EB;@D!8B=DEN=MJ
@:I8,!c:!C9DE@N7Q9D*!@E!9L=@K8!EB;!C9D9K=R;8!=H!B@IB;DJ=DK;D!L9I7;:;88!
AB;D;!9D;!:=!B@IB;DJ=DK;D!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8,mx
G;E!D;E9@:8!D=>78E:;88,
AB;D;!9D;!@:W:@E;!B@IB;D!=DK;D8!=H!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8,!6=M;E@M;8!
EB@8!@8!N9QQ;K!D9K@N9Q!B@IB;DJ=DK;D!L9I7;:;88,my 4. The unclarity operator and its interpretation
o8!>98@N!=C;D9E=D!H=D!=7D!EB;=DG!F;!NB==8;!9:!7:NQ9D@EG!=C;D9E=D!U { }
AB;D;!9D;!9!8M9QQ!:7M>;D!=H!W:@E;!=DK;D8!=H!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8*!
OD;9KV!T@E!@8!7:NQ;9D!FB;EB;DUS,!(cid:135)=I@N9QQG*!87NB!9:!7:NQ9D@EG!=C;D9E=D!
EB;@D!:7M>;D!L9DG@:I!HD=M!=:;!L9I7;!;RCD;88@=:!E=!9:=EB;D,mz
8E9:K8!E=!EB;!NQ9D@EG!=C;D9E=D!C!OT@E!@8!NQ;9D!EB9EUS!98!9!N=:E@:I;:NG!=C;DJ
k9NB!=H!EB;8;!EBD;;!8E9E;M;:E8!8;;M8!CD=>Q;M9E@N,!O(S!AB;!9887MCE@=:! 9E=D!OT@E!@8!N=:E@:I;:E!FB;EB;DUS!8E9:K8!E=!EB;!:;N;88@EG!=C;D9E=D,m(cid:138)!AB;!
EB9E!EB;D;!9D;!:=!B@IB;DJ=DK;D!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8!9CC;9D8!E=!NQ98B!F@EB! N7DQG!>D9NP;E8!9D;!9:!@:8;C9D9>Q;!C9DE!=H!EB;!=C;D9E=D,!cE!8@I:@W;8!EB9E!
EB;!H9NE8!9:K!E=!L@=Q9E;!EB;!D=>78E:;88!D;r7@D;M;:E!H=D!L9I7; !;RCD;8J F;!B9L;!TFB;EB;DU!D9EB;D!EB9:!TEB9EU,!AB;!D;98=:!H=D!EB@8!NB=@N;!=H!:=E9J
6
8@=:8*!98!@E!8;;M8!E=!@:ED=K7N;!9!8B9DC!>=7:K9DG,!O5S!AB;!9887MCE@=:! E@=:!@8!EB9E*!H=D!N=:L;:@;:N;*!F;!@:ED=K7N;!9!8;N=:K!NQ9D@EG!=C;D9E=D!
EB9E!EB;D;!9D;!:=E!‘78E!ONQ;9DS!WD8EJ=DK;D!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8*!>7E!9Q8=!>=DJ C!(cid:151)!(cid:152)!OD;9KV!T@E!@8!NQ;9D!FB;EB;DUS!EB78
K;DQ@:;!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8*!>=DK;DQ@:;!>=DK;DQ@:;!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8*!etc.,
OY) C!(cid:151)ja} j ! U!(cid:151)ja(cid:152),
87(%’C’%$<B*!F98!@:ED=K7N;K!@:!=DK;D!E=!F9DD9:E!D=>78E:;88,!c:!E;DM8!=H!
NQ9D@EG*!EB;!7:K;DQG@:I!@K;9!@8!EB9E!H=D!EB;D;!:=E!E=!>;!9!8B9DC!>=7:K9DG! AB@8!=C;D9E=D!C9D9QQ;Q8!EB;!:=:JN=:E@I;:NG!=C;D9E=D_!@E!:;;K8!E=!>;!
>;EF;;:!FB9E!@8!NQ;9DQG!F!9:K!FB9E!@8!>=DK;DQ@:;!F*!@E!@8!D;r7@D;K!EB9E*! 8G:E9NE@N9QQG!K@p;D;:E@9E;K!HD=M!EB;!NQ;9DJEB9E!=C;D9E=D,!AB;!78;!=H!
F@EB=7E!9:!7CC;D!Q@M@E*!=:;!N9:!W:K!9:!a!EB9E!@8!Unn!:;RE!E=!9:!a!EB9E! U!(cid:151)!(cid:152)!98!>98@N!=C;D9E=D!B98!EB;!9KL9:E9I;!EB9E!@E!D;CD;8;:E8!>=DK;DQ@:;J
@8!Cnn!H=D!;L;D!B@IB;D!n,!l=F;L;D*!EB;8;!EB;=D@;8!=H!D9K@N9Q!B@IB;DJ=DJ B==K!K@D;NEQG,!AB@8!M9P;8!EB;!D;Q;L9:N;!=H!EB;!Q=I@N9Q!EB;=D;M8!F;!
K;D!L9I7;:;88!9D;!N=7:E;D@:E7@E@L;!9:K*!M=D;!@MC=DE9:EQG*!Q;9K!E=!EB;! @:ED=K7N;!E=!9!EB;=DG!=H!L9I7;:;88!M=D;!D;9K@QG!@:E;QQ@I@>Q;,
(cid:140);I9DK@:I!EB;!@:E;DCD;E9E@=:!=H!EB;!7:NQ;9DJFB;EB;D!=C;D9E=D*!F;!
8E9DE!F@EB!9!CD;Q@M@:9DG!9NN=7:E!=H!7:NQ9D@EG!FB@NB!F;!B=C;!E=!W:K!
(t,!c:!E;DM8!=H!E%8;68B()*!EB;!WD8E!C=8@E@=:!E;DM@:9E;8!F@EB!n!(cid:147)!(_!EB;!8;N=:K!
9QQ=F8!H=D!@:K;W:@E;!n_!EB;!EB@DK!B98!L9D@;K!W:@E;!n!H=D!K@p;D;:E!F, I;:;D9Q!9CCD=L9QV
(],!AB@8!L@;F!@8!M9@:E9@:;K!e. g,!@:!69@:8>7DG!O(}}(S*!AG;!O(}}]S*!6=9M;8!O(}}}S*!
U {Fa(cid:152)!@:!N=:E;RE!C!@p!EB;D;!N=7QK!>;!9!OF@EB!D;8C;NE!E=!FaS!N=MJ
n9D9!O5))tS!O@MCQ@;KS*!(cid:135)7KF@I(cid:134)(cid:140)9G!O5))5S!O@MCQ@;KS*!iD@IBE!O5))tS!OCD;J
H;DD;KS_!6B9C@D=!O5))tS!]]*!O5))hS!9:K!O5))(cid:127)S!NB,h*!6M@EB!O5))(cid:129)S, C;E;:E!D9E@=:9Q!@:H=DM;K!8C;9P;D!=H!k:IQ@8B!FB=!N9::=E!E;QQ!
(h,!AGC@N9Q!C9889I;8!9D;!n@:;!O(}~hS!(cid:145)h!98!=:;!=CE@=:!N=:8@K;D;K*!(cid:154)7MM;EE!O(}~hS! FB;EB;D*!F@EB!D;I9DK!E=!C, a!@8!F,
((cid:129)5*!l;NP!O(}}tS*!(cid:144);;H;(cid:134)6M@EB!O(}}~,5S!(h*!i@QQ@9M8=:!O(}}}S!O9DI7@:I!EB9E!
8;N=:K!=DK;D!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8!;:E9@Q!@:W:@E;!=DK;D8!=H!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;8S_! AB;!K@NE@=:9DG!M;9:@:I!=H!TN9:!E;QQ!FB;EB;DU!=:!FB@NB!=7D!78;!@8!
(cid:144);;H;!O5)))S!t(gtt*!5)(cid:129)_!|D;;:=7IB!O5))tS!9:K!O5))hS,!AB;!L@;F!@8!:@N;QG!
CD;8;:E;K!OEB;:!D;‘;NE;KS!@:!69@:8>7DG!O(}}(S!((cid:127)~g}_!n9D9!O5))tS!(cid:145)(, (~,!(cid:128)H,!iD@IBE!O(}}5S*!n9D9!O5))tS*!|D;;:=7IB!O5))hS*!(cid:153)9DK@:@!O5))hS*!6B9C@D=!
O5))(cid:127)S!NB,h_!9Q8=!6;NE@=:!((!>;Q=F,
((cid:127),!(cid:154);H;:K;K!@:!<7DI;88!O(}})S*!O(}}(cid:129)S_!N=:8@K;D;K!98!87CC=DE;K!>G!@:E7@E@=:!@:!
n@:;!O(}~hS!5}(cid:129)*!(cid:144);;H;!O5)))S!tt, ((cid:129),!n=D!EB;!Q=I@N!=H!O:=:JSN=:E@:I;:NG!NH,!^=:EI=M;DG(cid:134)(cid:140)=7EQ;G!O(}(cid:127)(cid:127)S*!(cid:144)7B:!O(}}hS,
\f[$#/#\f’Z/U![&\Z[+0! g!!(cid:127)!!g! "#$,!()*!+#,!()!O-%.%/0!1232S
! /%/-++’!d#de[’+ Higher-Order Vagueness, Radical Unclarity, & Absolute Agnosticism
M=K;Q;K!@8!EB;!=:;!F@EB!EB;!:;9DJ8G:=:GM!TN9:!K@8N;D:!FB;EB;DU,!cE! E=!EB;!r7;8E@=:!Tja (cid:155)!=D!! ja (cid:155)U!F=7QK!8E@QQ!>;!EB;!89M;!98!sU8!
n n
@8!9887M;K!EB9E!9!8C;9P;D!s can tell whether!ja!@p!EB;!H=QQ=F@:I!N=:K@J 9NE79Q!9:8F;D_!M=D;!CD;N@8;QG*!@H*!I@L;:!a F;D;!K@p;D;:E!@:!EB9E*!
n
E@=:8!9D;!89E@8W;KV =:!9!K@M;:8@=:!D*!@E!F;D;!Q=N9E;K!FB;D;!de facto!8=M;!9K‘9N;:E!
=>‘;NE8!a , a *!(cid:156)_!a , a *!(cid:156)!M9G!>;!Q=N9E;K!OF@EB!EB;!@:E;DJ
s!7:K;D8E9:K8!EB;!K=7>Q;!r7;8E@=:!Tja(cid:155)!=D!:=E!ja(cid:155)Um(cid:142)!9:K*!upon nJm nJq n(cid:146)m n(cid:146)q
L9Q8!>;EF;;:!a , a , etc.*!>;@:I!87@E9>QG!8M9QQS* sU8!prima facie
being asked*!;@EB;D!ED7EBH7QQG!9:8F;D8!TjaU!=D!ED7EBH7QQG!9:8F;D8! nJm nJq
D;8C=:8;!F=7QK!>;!EB;!89M;!98!sU8!9NE79Q!9:8F;D,
T:=E!jaU,!A=!9:8F;D!9!r7;8E@=:!Tja(cid:155)!=D!:=E!ja(cid:155)U!F@EB!TjaU!=D!F@EB!
T:=E!jaU!@8!E9P;:!E=!>;!9!Q@:I7@8E@N!9NE!=H!988;DE@=:!EB9E!CD;87CJ <;@:I!9>Q;!E=!E;QQ*!98!@:ED=K7N;K!B;D;*!@8!:=E!9!CD=C=8@E@=:9Q!9EE@E7K;,!
C=8;8!EB;!I;:;D9Q!7:K;D8E9:K@:I!=H!B=F!r7;8E@=:8!9:K!9:8F;D8! cE!@8!E@;K!E=!N;DE9@:!Q@:I7@8E@N!9:K!N=I:@E@L;!N9C9N@E@;8!=H!9!8C;9P;D!E=!
9D;!D;Q9E;K!9:K!EB;!8C;N@WN!7:K;D8E9:K@:I!EB9E!EB;!9:8F;D! 9:8F;D!N;DE9@:!r7;8E@=:8,!c:8E;9K!=H!Tx!N9::=E!E;QQ!FB;EB;D!jaU!F;!9Q8=!
CD=L@K;K!OTjaU!=D!T:=E!jaUS!@8!9:!9:8F;D!E=!EB;!r7;8E@=:!98P;K,! 89G!Tx!N9:!:;@EB;D!D7Q;!=7E!EB9E!ja!:=D!D7Q;!=7E!EB9E!! jaU, i;!H7DEB;D!
TAD7EBH7QQGU!@8!@:E;:K;K!98!TF@EB=7E!QG@:I!=D!@:E;:E!E=!K;N;@L;U, 9887M;!EB9E!8=M;=:;!N9:O:=ES!E;QQ!FB;EB;D!ja!@p!EB;G!N9:O:=ES!E;QQ!
FB;EB;D!! ja,
s!=>E9@:8!B;D!9:8F;D!>G!78@:I!EB;!M=8E!K@D;NE!D=7E;,!(cid:154);C;:K@:I!
YZ[/\ !@8!9:!9ND=:GM!H=D!TC=MC;E;:E!R9E@=:9Q!I:H=DM;K!Sp;9P;DU*!
=:!EB;!r7;8E@=:*!EB@8!D=7E;!F@QQ!EGC@N9QQG!@:L=QL;!C;DN;CE@=:*!=>J M8
F@EB!EB;!87>8ND@CE!T U!@:K@N9E@:I!EB;!D;Q;L9:E!8N=C;!=H!EB;!8C;9P;DU8!
8;DL9E@=:*!@:E7@E@=:*!@M9I@:9E@=:*!N9QN7Q9E@=:*!M;987D@:I!=D!@:J M8
N=MC;E;:N;!9:K!@:H=DM9E@=:,!6=M;=:;!@8!9!YZ[/\ !CD;N@8;QG!@H!8B;!@8!9!
H;D;:N;,!n=D!@:8E9:N;*!@H!G=7!N=:L;G!E=!G=7D!N=Q=7DJ>Q@:K!>D=EB;D! M8
YZ[/\ *!8@:N;!EB;D;!@8!:=!K@p;D;:N;!@:!D;Q;L9:E!N=MC;E;:N;!9:K!@:H=DJ
EB9E!EB@8!N=Q=7D!C9ENB!@8!>7DI7:KG*!B;!@8!:=E!as a result!B@M8;QH! ! M8
M9E@=:!H=D!EB;8;!EF=!N98;8,qq!AB;!NB=@N;!=H!78@:I!YZ[/\8!98!ND@E;D@=:!@8!
9>Q;!E=!E;QQ!OK@8N;D:S!FB;EB;D!EB;!C9ENB!@8!>7DI7:KG,
>98;K!=:!EB;!9887MCE@=:!EB9E!FB;EB;D!8=M;EB@:I!@8!9!>=DK;DQ@:;!N98;!
s!=>E9@:8!B;D!9:8F;D!F@EB=7E!87C;D:9E7D9Q!988@8E9:N;,!n=D!;R9MJ 8B=7QK!K;C;:K!:;@EB;D!=:!9:!@:K@L@K79QU8!Q9NP!=H!D9E@=:9Q@EG*!:=D!=:!
CQ;*!@:!EB;!;L;:E!EB9E!9!K@L@:@EG!D;L;9Q;K!E=!G=7!EB9E!G=7D!HD@;:K! B;D!@:N=MC;E;:N;!=D!Q9NP!=H!;R@8E@:I!@:H=DM9E@=:*!Q@:I7@8E@N!=D!=EB;D*!
<9QKF@:!F98!>9QK!>G!89G@:I!T<9QKF@:!@8!>9QKU*!G=7!F=7QK!:=E!as a 9>=7E!EB;!N98;!9E!@887;*!:=D!=:!B;D!H9E@I7;*!K@{N7QE@;8!N=:N;:ED9E@:I*!
result!G=7D8;QH!>;!9>Q;!E=!E;QQ!OK@8N;D:S!FB;EB;D!<9QKF@:!@8!>9QK, E;:K;:NG!E=!>;!;98@QG!K@8ED9NE;K*!etc.!AB78!EB;!:=E@=:!=H!9!YZ[/\!@8!=>J
E9@:;K!>G!8E9DE@:I!F@EB!9NE79Q!B7M9:!>;@:I8!9:K!>G!EB;:!D;M=L@:I!9QQ!
cH!s!9:8F;D8!TjaU*!EB;:!ja_!@H!s!9:8F;D8!T:=E!jaU*!EB;:!:=E!ja,
;C@8E;M@N!B9:K@N9C8!N=:N;D:@:I!EB;@D!9>@Q@EG!E=!E;QQ!FB;EB;D!ja*!F@EBJ
c:!B;D!9:8F;D* s!Q;9L;8!9!M9DI@:!H=D!;DD=D,q(cid:133)!c:!M=D;!K;E9@QV!6@M@J =7E!EB;D;>G!D;:K;D@:I!EB;M!:=:JB7M9:!=D!KG8H7:NE@=:9Q!98!;L9Q79J
Q9D!E=!TP:=FU*!TN9:!E;QQ!FB;EB;DU!:9E7D9QQG!B98!9!M9DI@:!H=D!;DD=D,! E=D8,!YZ[/\8!9D;!:=E!>;8E=F;K!9:G!87C;D:9E7D9Q!C=F;D8,!i@EB!D;8C;NE!E=!
AB9E!@8*!@:!9!N=:E;RE!C, s!F=7QK!=:QG!D;8C=:K!F@EB!Tja U!=D!T! ja U! D9E@=:9Q@EG*!9!YZ[/\!@8!9887M;K!E=!>;!B9:K@N9CJHD;;!F@EB!D;I9DK!E=!Q=I@J
n n
@H*!I@L;:!EB@:I8!F;D;!8Q@IBEQG!K@p;D;:E*!sU8!prima facie!D;8C=:8;qm N9Q!D;98=:@:I!@:!9!W:@E;!:7M>;D!=H!8E;C8!O@:NQ7K@:I!EB;!78;!=H!D;N7D8@L;!
H7:NE@=:8!9:K!M9EB;M9E@N9Q!@:K7NE@=:S,!i@EB!D;8C;NE!E=!@:H=DM;K:;88*!
(},!AB;!K=7>Q;!r7;8E@=:!Tja(cid:155)!=D!:=E!ja(cid:155)U!O98!=CC=8;K!E=!Tja(cid:155)US!@8!D;r7@D;K!E=!
;:87D;!EB;!C;D8=:!9NE79QQG!N=:8@K;D8!FB;EB;D!ja!=D!FB;EB;D!! ja,!AB;!C7DJ 9!YZ[/\ !@8!9887M;K!E=!>;!@:!EB;!>;8E!C=88@>Q;!C=8@E@=:!E=!I9EB;D!EB;!
M8
C=8;!=H!EB;!T(cid:155)U!9HE;D!EB;!WD8E!ja!@8!E=!CD;L;:E!9!M@RJ7C!F@EB!EB;!r7;8E@=:!T(cid:157)ja
have!E=!I=!H=D!=:;!=D!EB;!=EB;D*!cUK!89G!! jaU*!Tja(cid:155)U!OF@EB!7CF9DK8!@:E=:9E@=:S*!
=D!:=E!ja(cid:150)(cid:155)U*!FB@NB!N=:N;D:8!EB;!kRNQ7K;K!^@KKQ;,
TBMM*!CD=>9>QG!jaU*!etc.!<G!N=:ED98E*!sU8!9NE79Q!9:8F;D!TjaU!O=D!T! jaUS!E=!EB;!
5),!l;D;!F;!9D;!KD9F@:I!=:!9:!@K;9!>G!^@NB9;Q!|Q9:?>;DI!HD=M!B@8!O5))tS!6;N,!],t, 9NE79Q!r7;8E@=:!Tja(cid:155)!=D!:=E!ja(cid:155)U!F=7QK!>;!9:!988;DE@=:!O8;;!9>=L;S,
5(,!o!prima facie!D;8C=:8;!@8!9:G!@MM;K@9E;!D;8C=:8;!>G!s!EB9E!H9L=7D8!ja!=D! 55,!AB;!@:K;R@:I!98@K;*!YZ[/\8!9D;!:=E!9!E;DD@>QG!=D@I@:9Q!@:L;:E@=:,!(cid:140);Q9E@L;8!=H!
! ja*!;L;:!@H!@E!K=;8:UE!B9L;!988;DE@L;!H=DN;!9:K!K=;8:UE!Q;9K!E=!9!D;8C=:8; TjaU! EB;@D8!C=C7Q9E;!M9:G!N=:E;MC=D9DG!C7>Q@N9E@=:8!F@EB!;C@8E;M=Q=I@N9Q!N=:J
=D!T! jaU!EB9E!B98!988;DE@L;!H=DN;_!e. g,!T(cid:135)==P8!Q@P;!jaU*!Tja*!c!EB@:PU*!Ti;QQ*!@H!c! E;:E*!@:NQ7K@:I!EB;=D@;8!=H!L9I7;:;88,
\f[$#/#\f’Z/U![&\Z[+0! g!!~!!g! "#$,!()*!+#,!()!O-%.%/0!1232S
! /%/-++’!d#de[’+ Higher-Order Vagueness, Radical Unclarity, & Absolute Agnosticism
D;Q;L9:E!@:H=DM9E@=:!9>=7E!ja,!l;D;*!9!C;D8=:!FB=!N9:!I9EB;D!@:H=DJ NQ;9DQG!>9QK!C;=CQ;!98!=CC=8;K!E=!F@EB!8=M;!NQ;9DQG!:=E!>9QK!C;=CQ;*!
M9E@=:!9>=7E!ja!K@D;NEQG!O>G!C;DN;CE@=:*!89GS!@8!N=:8@K;D;K!98!>;@:I! etc.!n=D!OiS*!F;!I@L;!9:!9:9Q=I=78!;R9MCQ;!HD=M!9:!;RC;D@M;:E!@:!9!
@:!9!>;EE;D!C=8@E@=:!EB9:!9!C;D8=:!FB=!L;D>9QQG!D;N;@L;8!EB;!@:H=DM9J 8=M;FB9E!K@p;D;:E!8N;:9D@=V!FB;:!87>‘;NE8!F@EB!perfect!;G;8@IBE!9:K!
E@=:!HD=M!9:=EB;D!C;D8=:,qs perfect!N=Q=7D!L@8@=:!F;D;!98P;K!E=!@K;:E@HG!TC7D;!>Q7;U!=:!9!8C;NED7M!
oQEB=7IB!EB;!:=E@=:!=H!9!YZ[/\!@:NQ7K;8!@K;9Q@?@:I!;Q;M;:E8*!H=D! D7::@:I!HD=M!C7DCQ;!E=!E;9Q!OF@EB!9QQ!;RE;D:9Q!H9NE=D8!P;CE!WR;KS*!EB;G!
WD8EJ=DK;D!L9I7; !CD;K@N9E;8!F!EB;D;!8B=7QK!>;!CQ;:EG!=H!YZ[/\ !9D=7:K*! L9D@;K!;L;D!8=!8Q@IBEQG!@:!EB;@D!‘7KI;M;:E,!6@M@Q9DQG*!@H!8;L;D9Q!YZ[/\
6 Fa Fa
98!Q=:I!98!a!@8:UE!E==!NQ=8;!E=!EB;!>=DK;DQ@:;!?=:;!=H!F,!n=D!L9I7; !E;NBJ F;D;!98P;K!TFa(cid:155)!=D!:=E!Fa(cid:155)U*!D;I9DK@:I!EB;!89M;!N=:E;RE!C*!EB;@D!prima
6
:@N9Q!E;DM8!87NB!98!TL;DM@Q@=:U!=D!TN7M7Q78!NQ=7K8*!>;@:I!9!YZ[/\!M9G! facie!D;9NE@=:8!M9G!K@p;D!8Q@IBEQG,
>;!D;8ED@NE;K!E=!;RC;DE8!H=D!M=8E!a!=:!9:G!D!=H!F,!n=D!:=:JE;NB:@N9Q! (cid:154)@p;D;:N;8!D;I9DK@:I!EB;!;L9Q79E@=:!Q@P;!OiS!9:K!OiiS!9D;!:=E!K@p;DJ
E;DM8!EB;D;!F=7QK!>;!:=!87NB!D;8ED@NE@=:,!n=D!@:8E9:N;*!@:!EB;!N98;!=H!9! ;:N;8!@:!C*!8@:N;!C!@8!N=:8E9:E,!AB;G!9D;!K@p;D;:N;8!@:!EB;!K@8C=8@E@=:8!
C9ENB!=H!C7D;*!=C9r7;*!M9EE;!D;K!K@8CQ9G;K!@:!=DK@:9DG!Q@IBE@:I!N=:K@J =H!EB;!@:K@L@K79Q!EB9E!;L9Q79E;8!=D!@:!EB;!F9G!EB;!@:K@L@K79Q!I=;8!9>=7E!
E@=:8!F@EB=7E!9:G!NQ988@WN9E=DG!D;8ED@NE@=:8*!E=I;EB;D!F@EB!9!CD=MCE@:I! EB;!;L9Q79E@=:,!c:!=7D!EB;=DG*!F;!9NN=7:E!H=D!87NB!K@p;D;:N;8!>G!@:ED=J
r7;8E@=:!FB;EB;D!EB;!C9ENB!@8!D;K*!M=8E!8C;9P;D8!=H!k:IQ@8B!F=7QK! K7N@:I!9:!9KK@E@=:9Q!C9D9M;E;D*!9!C9D9M;E;D!FB@NB!F;!N9QQ!C=88@>Q;!
>;!YZ[/\8_!=:QG!8;L;D;QG!N=Q=7DJ>Q@:K*!=D!=EB;DF@8;!D;Q;L9:EQG!B9:K@J 8@E79E@=:8!=H!;L9Q79E@:I!H=D!Fa!D;I9DK@:I!C,!i;!78;!/’!98!9:!9>>D;L@9J
N9CC;K*!C;=CQ;!F=7QK!:=E!N=7:E,!kL;:!@:!9:K!9D=7:K!EB;!>=DK;DQ@:;! E@=:!H=D!TC=88@>Q;!8@E79E@=:!=H!;L9Q79E@:IU,qx!c:!87NB!C=88@>Q;!8@E79E@=:8!
?=:;*!YZ[/\J:;88!KD9F8!7QE@M9E;QG!=:!9NE79Q!C;=CQ;U8!9NE79Q!Q@:I7@8E@N! =H!;L9Q79E@:I!/’*!EB;D;!M9G!=D!M9G!:=E!;R@8E!9!YZ[/\ ,!AB;!/’!H=D!Fa
Fa
9:K!N=I:@E@L;!9>@Q@E@;8V!EB;!I;:;D9Q!M;9:@:I!=H!EB;!E;DM8!78;K!@:!Fa D;I9DK@:I!C!F@EB!9!YZ[/\ !9D;!@:K@L@K79E;K!>G!K@p;D;:N;8!@:!EB;!YZ[/\8U!
Fa
@8!C9DE!=H!EB;!@:H=DM9E@=:!9!NZ[/\ !B98_!9:K!EB9E!M;9:@:I!K;C;:K8!@:! K@8C=8@E@=:8!E=!prima facie!D;9NE!E=!EB;!r7;8E@=:!TFa(cid:155)!=D!:=E!Fa(cid:155)U!9:K!@:!
Fa
8=M;!N=MCQ;R!F9G!=:!EB;!9NE79Q!78;!=H!EB;!E;DM8!>G!9NE79Q!C;=CQ;, EB;!prima facie!F9G8!EB;G!I=!9>=7E!;L9Q79E@:I!EB;!r7;8E@=:,qy
o!YZ[/\ !@8!9:!;C@8E;M@N9QQG!M9R@M9QQG!r79Q@W;K!@:K@L@K79Q!F@EB!D;J AB;!Q9DI;D!EB;!;C@8E;M@N!B9:K@N9C8!=H!;C@8E;M@N9QQG!;r79QQG!r79Q@J
Fa
8C;NE!E=!FB;EB;D!Fa,!cE!H=QQ=F8!EB9E*!@H!@E!@8!C=88@>Q;!EB9E!EB;D;!@8!M=D;! W;K!@:K@L@K79Q8!9D;*!EB;!Q9DI;D!EB;!;C@8E;M@N9QQG!D;Q;L9:E!K@p;D;:N;8!
EB9:!=:;!YZ[/\ *!9QQ!EB=8;!YZ[/\ !9D;!;C@8E;M@N9QQG!equally!r79Q@W;K! >;EF;;:!EB;M!M9G!>;,!6@:N;!YZ[/\8!9D;!>G!K;W:@E@=:!M9R@M9QQG!r79Q@J
Fa Fa
F@EB!D;8C;NE!E=!FB;EB;D!Fa,!cE!K=;8!:=E!H=QQ=F*!EB=7IB*!EB9E!9QQ!EB=8;! W;K*!9:K!EB78!M@:@M9QQG!B9:K@N9CC;K*!EB;!;C@8E;M@N9QQG!D;Q;L9:E!K@HJ
YZ[/\ !9D;!;C@8E;M@N9QQG!identically!r79Q@W;K!F@EB!D;8C;NE!E=!FB;EB;D!Fa,! H;D;:N;8!>;EF;;:!EB;M!F@QQ!7879QQG!>;!8M9QQ,!i;!9887M;!EB9E!9:G!
Fa
c:!C9DE@N7Q9D*!@E!@8!C=88@>Q;!EB9E!YZ[/\ !K@p;D!8=M;FB9E!OiS!@:!EB;@D!K@8J
Fa 5],!u7D!8@E79E@=:8!=H!;L9Q79E@:I!/’!9D;!8=M;FB9E!8@M@Q9D!E=!(cid:158)=B:!^Nn9DQ9:;U8!N=:J
C=8@E@=:!E=!prima facie!D;9NE!E=!EB;!r7;8E@=:!TFa(cid:155)!=D!:=E!Fa(cid:155)U!=D!OiiS!@:!EB;! E;RE8!=H!988;88M;:E*!NH,!e. g,!^Nn9DQ9:;!O5))h,(S!=D!O5))h,5S,!o:!/’!B98!9!E;MJ
C=D9Q!K7D9E@=:!9:K!9:!;L9Q79E=D!M9G!8B@HE!C;D8C;NE@L;!F@EB!D;I9DK!E=!Fa!@:!9:!
prima facie!F9G8!EB;G!I=!9>=7E!;L9Q79E@:I!EB;!r7;8E@=:,!(cid:154)@p;D;:E!prima
/’,!c:!H9NE*!C;D8C;NE@L;J8B@HE8!E=F9DK8!EB;!>;8EJN98;J8N;:9D@=O8S!H=D!;L9Q79E@:I!
facie!F9G8!=H!I=@:I!9>=7E!;L9Q79E@:I!Tc8!<9QKF@:!>9QK(cid:155)!=D!@8!<9QKF@:!:=E! Fa!M9G!>;!EB;!D9E@=:9Q!EB@:I!E=!K=,
>9QK(cid:155)U!F=7QK!>;!E=!F9QP!9D=7:K!<9QKF@:!98!=CC=8;K!E=!M9P;!<9QKF@:! 5h,!AB;!Q@:;!>;EF;;:!N=:E;RE8!9:K!8@E79E@=:8!=H!;L9Q79E@=:8!@8!(cid:149)7@K!@:!EB;!8;:8;!
C;DH=DM!9!C@D=7;EE;*!=D!E=!N=MC9D;!<9QKF@:!@:!=:;8!M@:K!F@EB!8=M;! EB9E!FB9E!@8!C9DE!=H!9:!/’!@:!=:;!;L9Q79E@=:!N9:!>;!C9DE!=H!EB;!N=:E;RE!@:!9:J
=EB;D!;L9Q79E@=:,!o:!;L9Q79E=D!M9G!EDG!E=!98N;DE9@:!FB;EB;D!8=M;EB@:I!@8!
C7DCQ;*!F@EB!D;I9DK!E=!8=M;!N=:E;RE!C*!>G!N9DDG@:I!@E!HD=M!EB;!@:K==D8!=7E!
5t,!l;:N;*!@H!9:!@:K@L@K79Q!s!@8!I@L;:!EB;!@:H=DM9E@=:!EB9E!ja!>G!8=M;!=EB;D!@:K@J @:E=!K9GQ@IBE,!67NB!9!C;D8C;NE@L;J8B@HE!F=7QK!EB;:!>;!C9DE!=H!EB;!/’,!oQE;D:9J
L@K79Q*!9:K!@E!@8!@:!CD@:N@CQ;!C=88@>Q;!E=!I9EB;D!EB9E!ja!K@D;NEQG!O89G!>G!C;DN;CJ E@L;QG*!EB;!;L9Q79E=D!M9G!EDG!E=!98N;DE9@:!FB;EB;D!EB9E!EB@:I!@8!C7DCQ;!I@L;:!
E@=:!=H!a!E=I;EB;D!F@EB!P:=FQ;KI;!=H!EB;!M;9:@:I!=H!TjUS*!9:K!s!B98!:=E!K=:;! EB;!Q@IBE@:I!8@E79E@=:!@E!@8!@:,!c:!EB9E!N98;!EB9E!Q@IBE@:I!8@E79E@=:!@8!C9DE!=H!EB;!
EB9E*!EB;:!s!@8!:=E!9!YZ[/\ , N=:E;RE*!FB@NB!EB;:!K@p;D8!HD=M!C!@:!8C;N@WN@EG,
M8
\f[$#/#\f’Z/U![&\Z[+0! g!!(cid:129)!!g! "#$,!()*!+#,!()!O-%.%/0!1232S
! /%/-++’!d#de[’+ Higher-Order Vagueness, Radical Unclarity, & Absolute Agnosticism
K@p;D;:N;8!@:!prima facie!D;8C=:8;!F@QQ!>;!9>8=D>;K!>G!EB;!:9E7D9Q!M9DJ 8=!>;N978;!EB;!M9DI@:8!H=D!;DD=D!D9E@=:9Q!F;QQJ@:H=DM;K!C;=CQ;!=DK@J
I@:!H=D!;DD=D!=H!TN9:!E;QQ!FB;EB;DU,qz!i;!N9QQ!EB@8!EB;!M9DI@:JH=DJ;DD=D! :9D@QG!Q;9L;!98!9!89H;EGJ?=:;!E=!CD;L;:E!N=MM7:@N9E@=:!H9@Q7D;!>;H=D;!
N=:8ED9@:E,!c:!M=D;!K;E9@QV!o!YZ[/\U8!9>@Q@EGJE=JE;QQJFB;EB;D!@8!EB;!89M;! EB;G!M9P;!9:!988;DE@=:!TjaU!=D!T! jaU!;RN;;K!EB;!=:;8!@:ED=K7N;K!>G!
8=DE!=H!9>@Q@EGJE=JE;QQJFB;EB;D!=DK@:9DG!8C;9P;D8!=H!k:IQ@8B!B9L;!H=D! EB;!N=:8ED9@:E,q(cid:142)!cE!@8!9!N=:8;r7;:N;!=H!EB;!M9DI@:JH=DJ;DD=D!N=:8ED9@:E!
M9:G!EB@:I8,!l;:N;*!@H!EB;G!9D;!9>Q;!E=!E;QQ!FB;EB;D!ja!D;I9DK@:I!C, EB9E*!@H!=:;!YZ[/\ s!N9:!E;QQ!FB;EB;D!ja*!EB;:!9QQ!;C@8E;M@N9QQG!;r79QJ
M8
@E!H=QQ=F8!EB9E!EB;G!Q;HE!9!M9DI@:JH=DJ;DD=D!O98!K;8ND@>;K!9>=L;S,!AB;! QG!r79Q@W;K!8C;9P;D8*!9:K!EB9E!@8!9QQ!=EB;D!YZ[/\ *!N9:!E;QQ!FB;EB;D!
M8
M9DI@:JH=DJ;DD=D!N=:8ED9@:E!EB;:!@8V!I@L;:!9!8;D@;8!=H!=>‘;NE8!a , … a , !ja*!E==,
nJm nJq
a , a , a , a , … a =:!9!K@M;:8@=:!D*!EB;!M@:@M9QQG!D;r7@D;K!M9DJ AB;!@:E;DCD;E9E@=:!=H!7:NQ9D@EG!@:!E;DM8!=H!YZ[/\8!9:K!EB;@D!9>@Q@EGJ
nJm n n(cid:146)m n(cid:146)q n+m
I@:!H=D!;DD=D!H=D!9!YZ[/\ s!>;@:I!9>Q;!E=!E;QQ!FB;EB;D!ja !OD;Q9E@L;!E=! E=JE;QQJFB;EB;D!N9:!:=F!>;!C7E!M=D;!H=DM9QQG!EB78V!@:!N=:E;RE!C
M8n n
DS!@8!w!@:!;@EB;D!K@D;NE@=:!HD=M!a !w!EB;!;RE;:E!e!=H!EB;!M9R@M9Q!8;NE@=:!
n O% ) N Ôx [YZ[/\ x & ! Tx {Fa}],
=:!D!FB@NB!N=:E9@:8!9!L9D@9:N;!@:!D;8C=:8;!E=!Tja (cid:155)!=D!! ja (cid:155)U!>G!@:J c:E Fa
n n
K@L@K79Q8!;C@8E;M@N9QQG!;r79QQG!r79Q@W;K!98!s!F@EB!D;8C;NE!E=!ja,!o8!C FB;D;!YZ[/\ x!8E9:K8!H=D!EB;!CD;K@N9E;!Tx!@8!9!YZ[/\ U!9:K!Tx {Fa(cid:152)!8E9:K8!
Fa Fa
@8!B;QK!N=:8E9:E*!9:K!EB;!YZ[/\8!N=:8@K;D;K!9D;!>=EB!;r79QQG*!9:K!M@:@J H=D!EB;!M=K9Q@?;K!CD;K@N9E;!Tx!N9:!E;QQ!FB;EB;D!FaU,!AB;!;:E@D;!;R@8E;:J
M9QQG*!;C@8E;M@N9QQG!B9:K@N9CC;K*!e!@8!>=7:K!E=!>;!8M9QQ!H=D!=DK@:9DG! E@9Q!H=DM7Q9!@8!M=K9Q@?;K,!AB;!aF=DQK8b!EB;!M=K9Q!=C;D9E=D!D7:8!=L;D!
Q9:I79I;!L9I7; !CD;K@N9E;8,q(cid:137)!cE!M9G!F;QQ!>;!8M9QQ;D!EB9:!EB;!K@p;DJ 9D;!EB;!C=88@>Q;!8@E79E@=:8!=H!;L9Q79E@:I!/’,!AB;8;!8@E79E@=:8!N=L;D!
6
;:N;!>;EF;;:!a !9:K!a !@:!8=M;!6=D@E;8!8;D@;8,q(cid:138)!i;!9887M;!EB9E*!98!9! EB;!CD;8;:N;!=D!9>8;:N;!=H!C=88@>Q;!;L9Q79E=D8!Oi. e,!EB;!YZ[/\ )s(cid:133)!9:K!
n n(cid:146)m Fa
D7Q;*!EB;!M9DI@:JH=DJ;DD=D!N=:8ED9@:E!@8!97E=M9E@N9QQG!89E@8W;K,!AB@8!@8! C=88@>Q;!K@p;D;:N;8!>;EF;;:!EB;M!EB9E!M9G!D;M9@:!K;8C@E;!EB;!H9NE!
EB9E!EB;@D!;C@8E;M@N!r79Q@WN9E@=:8!D;I9DK@:I!Fa!9D;!>G!K;W:@E@=:!;r79Q!
5(cid:127),!c:!EB;!N98;!=H!M=D;!N=MCQ;R!CD;K@N9E;8*!FB;D;!EB;!K@p;D;:N;8!9M=:I!M9R@J O8;;!9>=L;S,sm!AB;!@:E;DCD;E9E@=:!=H!EB;!C!(cid:151)!(cid:152)!=C;D9E=D!@8!9NN=DK@:IQGV!@:!
M9QQG!r79Q@W;K!@:K@L@K79Q8!9D;!Q9DI;D!K7;!E=!8@E79E@=:8!@:!FB@NB!EB;!;Q@M@:9J
!N=:E;RE!C
E@=:!=H!=:;!B9:K@N9C!B98!E=!>;!ED9K;K!=p!9I9@:8E!EB9E!=H!9:=EB;D*!F;!9887M;!
EB9E!YZ[/\8!:9E7D9QQG!Q;9L;!Q9DI;D!89H;EG!M9DI@:8!E=!CD;L;:E!N=MM7:@N9E@=:!
H9@Q7D;,!On=D!M=D;!K;E9@Q8!=:!87NB!ED9K;J=p!8@E79E@=:8!8;;!>;Q=F!6;NE@=:!(5,5,S OY ) M Óx [YZ[/\ x f Tx {Fa(cid:152)(cid:150),
c:E Fa
5~,!AB@8!F9G!=H!@:ED=K7N@:I!9!M9DI@:!H=D!;DD=D!K@p;D8!@:!EF=!D;8C;NE8!M9DP;KQG!
AB78! :=:J>=DK;DQ@:;B==K! =H! Fa! D;r7@D;8! EB9E!w!F@EB! D;8C;NE! E=! 9!
HD=M!i@QQ@9M8=:U8!O@:!B@8!O(}}5S!9:K!O(}}]S!NB,!(cid:129)S,!n@D8E*!7:Q@P;!78*!i@QQ@9M8=:!
9887M;8!EB9E*!H=D!9:G!6=D@E;8!8;D@;8!a, a , … a , a , etc., x!P:=F8!EB9E!Fa!=:QG!
m q nJm n n
@H!Fa !9:K!Fa ,!OcE!@8!EB@8!7:K;D8E9:K@:I!=H!EB;!M9DI@:!H=D!;DD=D!EB9E!H=DN;8!
nJm n(cid:146)m
B@M!E=!I@L;!7C!EB;!(cid:159)(cid:159)JvD@:N@CQ;,S!6;N=:K*!B;!K=;8!:=E!K;W:;!B@8!M9DI@:JH=DJ 5},!cH!@E!@8!:=E*!F;!N9:!@:ED=K7N;!9!:=DM9E@L;!ND@E;D@=:*!EB9E!9!YZ[/\ !N9:!=:QG!truly
;DD=D!N=:8ED9@:E!D;Q9E@L;!E=!8;E8!=H!@:K@L@K79Q8!;C@8E;M@N9QQG!;r79QQG!r79Q@W;K! E;QQ!FB;EB;D!Fa!@:!EB=8;!N98;8!@:!FB@NB!EB;!N=:8ED9@:E!@8!89E@8WF;aK,!uD!;Q8;*!F;!
F@EB!D;8C;NE!E=!Fa, N9:!D;CQ9N;!EB;!M9DI@:JH=DJ;DD=D!N=:8ED9@:E!F@EB!EB;!9887MCE@=:!EB9E!YZ[/\
Fa
N9:!N=MM7:@N9E;!F@EB!;9NB!=EB;D!9>=7E!Fa!F@EB=7E!D;8ED@NE@=:8,!<7E!F;!>;J
5(cid:129),!|@L;:!EB;!M9DI@:JH=DJ;DD=D!N=:8ED9@:E*!@8!@E!EB;!N98;!EB9E*!@H!9!YZ[/\ can tell
Fa Q@;L;!EB@8!7::;N;889DG,
FB;EB;D!Fa*!EB;:!8B;!knows!FB;EB;D!Fa!w!F@EB!9!:=E@=:!=H!P:=FQ;KI;!Q@P;!
i@QQ@9M8=:U8!@:!B@8!O(}}]S(cid:155)!(cid:160)=*!@E!@8!:=E,!i@QQ@9M8=:U8!P:=FQ;KI;!=C;D9E=D!K t),!6;;!>;Q=F*!6;NE@=:!(5,(,
@8!K;W:;K!@:!87NB!9!F9G!EB9E*!=:!9:G!6=D@E;8!K@M;:8@=:!D!H=D!F, KU8!M9DI@:!
t(,!AB;!CD=C=8;K!ND@E;D@=:!=H!7:NQ9D@EG!EB78!K@p;D8!M9DP;KQG!HD=M!=EB;D8!>98;K!
H=D!;DD=D!:;N;889D@QG!;RN;;K8!EB;!K@p;D;:N;!>;EF;;:!9:G!9K‘9N;:E a!9:K!a ,!
n n(cid:146)m =:!9!:=E@=:!=H!r79Q@W;K!@:K@L@K79Q8,!cE!@8!:;@EB;D!>98;K!=:!EB;!9>8;:N;!=H!
l;:N;*!@H!8=M;=:;!P:=F8!EB9E!Fa *!EB;:!Fa ,!c:!EB;!CD;8;:E!EB;=DG*!@E!@8!C=8J
n n(cid:146)m N=:8;:878!=D!EB;!CD;8;:N;!=H!K@89ID;;M;:E!9>=7E!Fa!9M=:I!N;DE9@:!r79Q@J
8@>Q;!EB9E!EB;D;!9D;!6=D@E;8!8;D@;8!FB;D;!9!YZ[/\ !N9:!E;QQ!FB;EB;D!Fa *!>7E!
FaOn) n W;K!87>‘;NE8_!:=D!@8!@E!EB;!D;87QE!=H!N=:8;:878!9M=:I!87NB!87>‘;NE8!EB9E!a
Fa !@8!:=E!EB;!N98;,!AB@8!@8!8=!>;N978;!EB;!M9DI@:!H=D!;DD=D!e!H=D!T>;@:I!9>Q;!
n(cid:146)m @8!>=DK;DQ@:;!F_!:=D!@8!@E!D;87QE@:I!HD=M!EB;!9CCQ@N9E@=:!=H!8=M;!8E9E@8E@N9Q!=D!
E=!E;QQU!M9G!>;!8M9QQ;D!EB9:!EB;!K@p;D;:N;!>;EF;;:!a!9:K!a !=:!EB;!6=D@E;8!
n n(cid:146)m CD=>9>@Q@8E@N!M;EB=K8!78;K!E=!NQ988@HG!EB;!L@;F8!D;I9DK@:I!Fa!=H!87NB!87>‘;NE8_!
K@M;:8@=:!D_!9:K!>;N978;!9!C=8@E@L;!prima facie!D;9NE@=:!E=!TFa(cid:155)!=D!:=E!Fa(cid:155)U!=:!
:=D!K=;8!@E!D;r7@D;!EB;!9NE79Q!;R@8E;:N;!=H!EB;!D;Q;L9:E!r79Q@W;K!@:K@L@K79Q8,
@E8!=F:!K=;8!:=E!;:E9@Q!Fa,
\f[$#/#\f’Z/U![&\Z[+0! g!!}!!g! "#$,!()*!+#,!()!O-%.%/0!1232S
! /%/-++’!d#de[’+ Higher-Order Vagueness, Radical Unclarity, & Absolute Agnosticism
N=:E;RE!C!w!@:!9QQ!C=88@>Q;!8@E79E@=:8!=H!;L9Q79E@:I!9QQ!D;Q;L9:EQG!r79Q@J N=:8@K;D!9!D;KJID;;:!N=Q=7DJ>Q@:K!C;D8=:!9!87@E9>Q;!‘7KI;!H=D!FB;EB;D!
W;K!@:K@L@K79Q8!N9:!E;QQ!FB;EB;D!Fa,sq 8=M;!D;KK@8BJ>D=F:!=>‘;NE!@8!>=DK;DQ@:;!D;K(cid:134):=EJD;K,S!(cid:160)=F!87CC=8;!
AB;!M9DI@:JH=DJ;DD=D!N=:8ED9@:E!B98!N;DE9@:!N=:8;r7;:N;8!H=D!EB;! EB;D;!@8!9!YZ[/\ FB=!@8!9!>=DK;DQ@:;!YZ[/\ *!N9QQ!B@M!(cid:128)D@8C@:,!AB;:!
Fa Fa
@:E;DCD;E9E@=:8!=H!EB;!C!(cid:151)!(cid:152)!9:K!U!(cid:151)!(cid:152)!=C;D9E=D8,!AB;!N=:8ED9@:E!;:E9@Q;K! @E!F=7QK!>;!C=88@>Q;!H=D!EB;D;!E=!>;!9!YZ[/\ !FB=!N=7QK!:=E!
(cid:128)(cid:140)c6vOFaS(cid:128)D@8C@:
EB9E*!@H!=:;!YZ[/\ s!N9:!E;QQ!FB;EB;D!ja*!EB;:!9QQ!YZ[/\ !N9:!E;QQ!FB;EBJ 9:8F;D!EB;!r7;8E@=:!Tc8!(cid:128)D@8C@:!9!YZ[/\ (cid:155)!=D!@8!(cid:128)D@8C@:!:=E!9!YZ[/\ (cid:155)U,!
M8 M8 Fa Fa
;D!ja,!^=D;=L;D*!8@:N;!@E!@8!@DD;Q;L9:E!FB;EB;D!EB=8;!;C@8E;M@N9QQG! c:!=EB;D!F=DK8*!@E!F=7QK!>;!C=88@>Q;!EB9E!;L;:!EB;!;C@8E;M@N9QQG!>;8E!
;r79QQG!r79Q@W;K!@:K@L@K79Q8!B9CC;:!E=!9NE79QQG!;R@8E*!@E!F@QQ!9Q8=!B=QK! r79Q@W;K!@:K@L@K79Q8!N9::=E!K@8N;D:!FB;EB;D!(cid:128)D@8C@:!B98!?;D=!;C@8J
EB9E!@H!D;I9DK@:I!C!=:;!YZ[/\ !N9:!E;QQ!FB;EB;D!ja*!EB;:*!D;I9DK@:I!C, E;M@N!B9:K@N9C!F@EB!D;I9DK!E=!Fa!=D!B98!8=M;!8M9QQ!;C@8E;M@N!B9:K@J
M8
@:!9QQ!C=88@>Q;!8@E79E@=:8!=H!;L9Q79E@:I!/’*!@H!EB;G!N=:E9@:!9!YZ[/\ *!EB9E! N9C!F@EB!D;I9DK!E=!Fa*!9:K!EB9E!@8*!FB;EB;D!(cid:128)D@8C@:!@8!=D!@8:UE!ND@E;D@9Q!
M8
YZ[/\ !N9:!E;QQ!FB;EB;D!ja,!i;!N9:!N9CE7D;!EB@8!N=:8;r7;:N;!@:!EB;! H=D!EB;!>=DK;DQ@:;B==K!=H!Fa,!(cid:128)=7QK!F;!D9E@=:9QQG!F9:E!(cid:128)D@8C@:!E=!>;!
M8
CD@:N@CQ; C9DE!=H!=7D!ND@E;D@=:!H=D!EB;!>=DK;DQ@:;B==K!=H!Fa(cid:155)!AB;!9:8F;D!N9:!=:QG!
>;!@:!EB;!:;I9E@L;,!cH!EB;D;!9D;!YZ[/\ !FB=!9D;!>=DK;DQ@:;!YZ[/\ *!EB;G!
O^Hk) Ôx [YZ[/\ x & Tx (cid:151)ja}] f M Óx [YZ[/\ x f Tx (cid:151)ja}] Fa Fa
m M8 M8 8B=7QK!>;!;RNQ7K;K!HD=M!>;@:I!ND@E;D@9Q!H=D!EB;!>=DK;DQ@:;B==K!=H!Fa,!
TcH!EB;D;!@8!9!YZ[/\ !FB=!N9:!E;QQ!FB;EB;D!ja*!EB;:!@:!9QQ!/’!9:G!YZ[/\ OAB;G!F@QQ!EB;:!>;!97E=M9E@N9QQG!;RNQ7K;K!HD=M!>;@:I!C9DE!=H!EB;!ND@E;J
M8 M8
N9:!E;QQ!FB;EB;D!ja,U!AB;!N=:L;D8;!=H!EB@8!CD@:N@CQ;!@8 D@=:!H=D!EB;!>=DK;DQ@:;J>=DK;DQ@:;B==K!=H!Fa, etc.*!8@:N;!EB@8!D7:8!=:QG!
=L;D!N98;8!EB9E!@:L=QL;!EB;!YZ[/\8!EB9E!9D;!ND@E;D@9Q!H=D!EB;!>=DK;DQ@:;J
O^Hk) N Ôx [YZ[/\ x & ! Tx (cid:151)ja}] f Óx [YZ[/\ x f ! Tx (cid:151)ja}]
q M8 M8 B==K!=H!Fa,S!YZ[/\ !FB=!9D;!>=DK;DQ@:;!YZ[/\ !N9:!>;!;RNQ7K;K!HD=M!
Fa Fa
TcH!EB;D;!@8!9:!/’!F@EB!9!YZ[/\ !FB=!N9:UE!E;QQ!FB;EB;D!ja*!EB;:!EB;D;!@8! >;@:I!ND@E;D@9Q!H=D!EB;!>=DK;DQ@:;B==K!=H!Fa!>G!EB;!9KK@E@=:!=H!9!87@EJ
M8
:=!YZ[/\ !FB=!N9:!E;QQ!FB;EB;D!ja,U!(cid:143)@9!O^HkS!9:K!O^HkS*!EB;!M9DJ 9>Q;!8;D@;8!=H!N=:‘7:NE8!@:E=!EB;!@:E;DCD;E9E@=:!=H!C {Fa(cid:152)V
M8 m q
I@:JH=DJ;DD=D!N=:8ED9@:E!EB78!I79D9:E;;8!7:9:@M@EG!9M=:I!9QQ!YZ[/\
M8 OY ′) M ÓR!(cid:157)YZ[/\ x
F@EB!D;8C;NE!E=!ja*!D;Q9E@L;!E=!C!9:K!D,!OAB@8!D;(cid:149);NE8!EB;!D;98=:9>Q;! c:E Fa
& [M Óy [YZ[/\ y f Ty {YZ[/\ x}]
9887MCE@=:!EB9E!9:G=:;!H7QQG!N=MC;E;:E*!D9E@=:9Q*!9:K!@:H=DM;K!D;J (cid:128)(cid:140)c6vOFa)x Fa
& [M Óz [YZ[/\ z f Tz {YZ[/\ y}]
I9DK@:I!ja!D;8C;NE8!9:!9K;r79E;!T89H;EG!?=:;U*!9E!EB;!L;DG!Q;98E!=H!8@?;!e, (cid:128)(cid:140)c6v!O(cid:128)(cid:140)c6vOFa)x)y Fa
& [M Ów [YZ[/\ w f Tw {YZ[/\ z}]
N=:N;D:@:I!a*!H=D!9:G!K@M;:8@=:!D*!98!9!CD;N=:K@E@=:!H=D!988;DE@:I!ja,S (cid:128)(cid:140)c6vO(cid:128)(cid:140)c6v!O(cid:128)(cid:140)c6vOFa)x)y)z Fa
& [etc.…] … ]]] f Tx {Fa}]
iB9E!M=K9Q!EB;=D;M8!B=QK!H=D!EB;!7:NQ9D@EG!9:K!NQ9D@EG!=C;D9E=D8!
F@QQ!@:!C9DE!K;C;:K!=:!FB;EB;D!borderline YZ[/\s!9D;!@:NQ7K;K!@:!EB;!ND@J OY ′S!N9:!EB;:!>;!9>>D;L@9E;K!98V
c:E
E;D@=:!H=D!O:=:JS>=DK;DQ@:;B==K,!cE!N9:!>;!8B=F:!EB9E!87NB!@:NQ78@=:!
OY ″) M ÓR!(cid:157)YZ[/\* x f Tx {Fa}]
F=7QK!7:K;DM@:;!EB;!L;DG!@K;9!=H!O7:SNQ9D@EG!‘78E!@:ED=K7N;K, c:E Fa
(cid:140);N9QQ!EB9E!EB;!I@8E!=H!EB;!EB;=DG!=H!7:NQ9D@EG!K;L;Q=C;K!B;D;!@8!EB9E! F@EB!YZ[/\* x = YZ[/\ x
Fa Fa
F;!9D;!Q==P@:I!H=D!EB=8;!Fa H=D!FB@NB!@E!B=QK8!EB9E!EB;@D!8;M9:E@N!L9Q7;! & [M Óy [YZ[/\ y f Ty {YZ[/\ x}]
(cid:128)(cid:140)c6vOFa)x Fa
@8!@:9NN;88@>Q;!;L;:!E=!B7M9:8!@:!EB;!>;8E!=H!;C@8E;M@N!N=:K@E@=:8,!i;! & [M Óz [YZ[/\ z f Tz {YZ[/\ y}]
(cid:128)(cid:140)c6v!O(cid:128)(cid:140)c6vOFaSRSy Fa
9D;!9HE;D!EB=8;!N98;8!FB;D;!EB;!@:9NN;88@>@Q@EG!@8!:=E!K7;!E=!9:G!;C@8J & [M Ów [YZ[/\ w f Tw {YZ[/\ z}]
(cid:128)(cid:140)c6vO(cid:128)(cid:140)c6v!O(cid:128)(cid:140)c6vOFa)x)yS?! Fa
E;M@N!B9:K@N9C!=H!9:!@:K@L@K79Q!TE;8E!C;D8=:U,!O(cid:158)78E!98!F;!F=7QK!:=E! & [etc. …] … ]]]!ss
tt,!AB;!;R@8E;:N;!=H!9!YZ[/\¡!K=;8!not!CD;87CC=8;!EB;!;R@8E;:N;!=H!9:!@:K;W:@E;!
t5,!AB;!6h!9R@=M!8B=7QK!>;!=P!H=D!EB;!=C;D9E=D8!N 9:K!M B;D;, 87NN;88@=:!=H!YZ[/\8!=H!;L;D!B@IB;D!=DK;D8,!oQQ!EB9E!@8!D;r7@D;K!@8!EB9E*!@:!9QQ!
\f[$#/#\f’Z/U![&\Z[+0! g!!()!!g "#$,!()*!+#,!()!O-%.%/0!1232S