Hegel, Deleuze, and the Critique of Representation: Dialectics of Negation and Difference

308 Pages·2012·2.869 MB·English

by  Henry Somers-hall

HEGEL.D ELEUZE.A ND THE
CRITIQUEO F REPRESENTATION
--..,.,
SUNY seriIenestr,st eicoPnhsis:lo opahnyCd r itiTchaelo ry
RodolpGhaes cehdeoi,rt
HEGEDLE.L EUZAEN.DT HE
CRITIQOUFER EPRESENTATION
DialoeNfce tgiaactnsDid io ffne rence
HENRY SOMERS-HALL
STATEU NIVERSIOTFY NEW YORKP RESS
Covearr tF:i eldb yE4 m maM cNally,
graphointp ea per2,2 0e m X 150e m,2 009.
Publisbhye d
STATUEN IVERSIOTFY N Ew YoRK PARELssB,A NY
© 2012S tatUen iverosfiN teyw Y ork
Allr ighrtess erved
Printientd h eU niteSdt atoefsA merica
Nopa rto ft hiboso km aybe useodrr eproduicnae ndym annewrh atsoevweirt hout
writtpeernm issiNoon p.a rotf t hiboso k maybe storienda retriseyvsatle m
ort ransmiitnta endyf ormo rb ya nym eanisn cluding eleelcetcrtornoisct,a tic,
magnettiacp em,e chanipchaolt,o copyreicnogr,d oirno gt,h erwwiisteh out the
prioperr missiionwn r itionftg h ep ublisher.
Fori nformatcioonnt,a ct
StatUen iversofiN teyw Y orPkr esAsl,b anNyY,
www.sunypress.edu
ExcelsEidoirt iiosna sni mprionfSt t atUen iverosfiNt eyw Y orPkr ess
ProductLiaounr,Si eea rl
Market,iA nngneM .V alentine
LibraoryfC ongreCsasta loging-in-DPautab lication
Somers-HHaelnlr,y .
HegeDle,l euaznedt, h ec ritioqfru eep resen:td aitailoenco tfni ecgsa tainodnd ifference/
HenrSyo mers-Hall.
p.e m-. (SUNYs eriIenst,e rsecpthiiolnoss:oa pnhdcy r ittihceaolry )
Inclubdiebsl iograrpehfiecrae(lnp c.e s) a ndi ndex.
ISBN9 78-1-4384-(4h0a0r9d-c5:oa vlekpr.a per)
1.R epresent(aPthiiolno sop2h.D ye)l euGziel,l 1e9s2,5 -19935.H. e geGle,o rWgi lhelm
Friedr1i7c7h0,- 183I1.Ti. t le.
Bl05.R42S06162
193--dc22 2011012005
109 87 56 4 3 2 1
CONTENTS
LiosfIt l lruastitons ix
LiosfAt b bervaitions xi
Acknowledgments XV
Introduction
PARTO NE
THEPR OBLOEFRM E PRNETASTEION
CHAPTEORN E.De leaunzTder n ascendEemnptiarli cism 11
Introduction 11
Kanatn d Ctrihtieqo ufPe u rRee ason 14
SaratnrTdehe T ranscendence oft hEeg o 23
Del euazneTd h Leo giocfS ense 35
Conclusion 38
CHAPTETRW O.D ifferaennIdcd eei ntty 41
Introduction 41
Aristotle 43
The GaennEduq su ivionAcr iitsyt otle 49
Chanagnetd h e Idnudailv i 52
Aquinas 55
SymboLloigci c 56
PrelimCionnacirloyun ss 61
Heegaln Adr istotle 62
Zeno 64
Conclusion 66
PARTT WO
REPSONSETSOR EPRENSTETAION
CHAPTETRH REEB.er gsonism 69
Introduction 69
BergsAocnc'oosufK n atn atn Cdl aslLs oigciac 70
vi CONETNTS
BergsMoentho'dos fI nttuioin 78
Bergasnothdne T woK inodfMs u lptliicity 85
Cocnlusion 89
CHAPETRF ORU.Th eV irtaunathdle A ctual 91
Introduction 91
TheTw oM uilptlicities 93
Depitnh DealneMdue zlree aPuo-nty 111
De laenudz eSt threu cotftu hPrere o blem 191
BergosnRo anv aisson 121
Conclusion 122
CHATPERF I.VI EnfienT ihtought 152
Inrtoduction 152
Kanatn Hde gel 152
TheM etaphyDseidcuaclat niMdoe tna physics 143
FroBme git noE snscee 136
TheE sselan nttdih aIen esisaeln t 139
ThSet rucotfRu erflee ction 142
The DeteromfRi enflaetcitoinosn 164
ThSe pecvuelP artoiposition 150
TheC onpctoe fE sseinnAc rei stanoHdte lgee l 155
Conclusion 157
PARTT HREE
BYEONDR EPRETASTIEONN
CHAPTERS XI.H eegaln Dde leounOz net olaongthdye C alculu1s6 1
Introduction 161
TheC alculus 126
Hegaenltd h Cea lculus 166
Berkaenltdeh yFe o undaotfti hoCena sl culus 107
Deleaunztdeh C ea lculus 127
Heegaln Dde leuze 187
TheK anntA inatinomies 197
1�
c���
CHATPERS EEVN.F orDcieeff,r e,na cneOdp position 178
Inrtoduction 178
Foracnetd h Uen dearnsdting 188
TheI nvedW rotreld 195
CONETNTS vii
Deelueaz ntdh Ien rvteWeodr ld 200
TheOn ea ntdh Mean y 204
Conclusion 209
CHATPEERI G.HH TegDeell,e uaznethd,e S trucotfu Otrrhege ia snm2 11
Inrtoduction 211
TheP hiloosfNo apthuyr e 212
HegaenlEd v olution 214
HeegslA 'ccoouftn htSe t rucotftu hOrere g anism 217
HeeglC,u v,ia enrCdo mparAantaitvoem y 221
Delu eezG,e offraoynT,dr nascendental Anato2m2y 4
TeratoalnoTdgel ye ology 229
ContinignHe engcsePy lh 'iloosfNo apthuyr e 233
Conclusion 236
Conclusion 239
Noets 247
Biobglriaphy 257
Index 285

ILLUSTRATIONS
Fig4ur.e1E uclpiadr'aasl salu enli qluitemi inlgie n. 94
Fig4ur.e2G eomtreibcaasflio Rsri enmna'psa rlaa lxolime. 95
Fig4ur.e3A lple rpendtioac s utlraalrinsigem h ettei na p oint9.5
Fig4ur.e4P ictreoprrieatslae tnoifoR ni enmna'gse otmrey. 96
Fig4ur.e5A triaAnBgClc eo mpoosfge edo sdiecs. 98
Fig4ur.e6A phasspea wcihet t wdoe groeffee rse dom
populwaitthve edc t. ors 101
Fig4ur.e7P hapsoera tiartr,r iavtte hdr othuegi hn tegration
ofv ectionthr esv ecfitoerl d. 120
Fig4ur.e8P hapsoer torfaap irte datsoyrms-.tpe rey 140
Fig4ur.e9A Loreantzt ractor. 190
Figu1r4-ew se re boanst ehdo fsreo Kml i,Mn aethematicsi nW esternC ul­
tu,r4 e644,74 37,a4 n,4d 7F6i.g 5uwre a s tafkreoGnmra yI,de aso fS pace,
p.1 3.F6 igu6ar ne7dsw erbea soentd h oisnMe a inzTehri,n ikCnio nmgp lex­
it3y.3,F igu8wr easb asoendC oheann Sdt ewTahreCt o,l lapCshea ,oo sf
20.5
ix