Governance of Arctic Marine Shipping

117 Pages·2008·1.05 MB·English

Governance of Arctic Marine Shipping

1 August 2008

Contributors:

David VanderZwaag
Aldo Chircop
Erik Franckx
Hugh Kindred
Kenneth MacInnis
Moira McConnell
Angus McDonald
Ted McDorman
Sonja Mills
Tony Puthucherril
Susan Rolston
Phillip Saunders
K. Joseph Spears

Research Assistants:
James Lawson
Freedom-Kai Phillips

Law • Policy • Governance

Marine & Environmental Law Institute • Dalhousie Law School • 6061 University Avenue • Halifax, NS B3H 4H9 • Canada
Tel: [phone] • Fax: [phone] • Email: [email protected] • Website: www.dal.ca/law/MELAW
ii
Contents

List of Tables and Figures ......................................................................................................... v

Acknowledgements .................................................................................................................vii

Acronyms ..................................................................................................................................ix

Introduction ................................................................................................................................1

Part I: International Law of the Sea Framework ........................................................................4

UNCLOS: The Overarching Legal Framework .............................................................4
Coastal State Jurisdiction and Control ......................................................................4
Internal Waters .....................................................................................................4
Territorial Sea .......................................................................................................5
Contiguous Zone ..................................................................................................6
Exclusive Economic Zone ....................................................................................6
Continental Shelf ..................................................................................................7
International Straits ..............................................................................................9
Article 234 ............................................................................................................9
Flag State Control ...................................................................................................10
Port State Control ....................................................................................................11
Maritime Boundaries in the Arctic ..........................................................................11
High Seas and the International Seabed Area .........................................................12

Part II: International Public Maritime Law Framework ..........................................................13

Introduction ..................................................................................................................13
Maritime Safety and Seafaring Rules and Standards ...................................................13
Arctic Guidelines ....................................................................................................16
Standards for Seafarers in the Arctic and Maritime Labour Law Issues ................19
Seafarer Training .....................................................................................................20
Seafarers’ Working and Living Conditions ............................................................21
Search and Rescue ..................................................................................................21
Maritime Environmental Rules and Standards ............................................................23
Onboard Waste Management and Operational Ship-source Pollution ...................23
Contingency Planning for Accidental Oil Pollution ...............................................26
Anti-fouling Substances ..........................................................................................28
Ballast Water Management .....................................................................................28
Particularly Sensitive Sea Areas .............................................................................30
Places of Refuge for Ships in Need of Assistance ..................................................31
Wreck Removal .......................................................................................................32
The Role of Ports in International Maritime Law ........................................................33
Enforcement Through Port State Control ...............................................................33
iii
Ports and Maritime Security ...................................................................................34

Part III: International Private Maritime Law Framework ........................................................35

Introduction ..................................................................................................................35
Carriage of Goods and Passengers by Sea ...................................................................35
Bulk Goods in General Cargo or Tramp Vessels ....................................................36
Packaged Merchandise on Northern Supply and Liner Services ............................37
Passengers on Cruise Ships .....................................................................................38
Marine Insurance .........................................................................................................39
Salvage .........................................................................................................................41
Liability and Compensation for Ship-source Pollution Damage .................................43
Oil Spills from Tankers ...........................................................................................43
Hazardous and Noxious Substances Spills from Ships ...........................................45
Bunker Oil Spills from Non-tankers .......................................................................46
The United States Experience .................................................................................47
Regional Developments: The European Union and the Antarctic ..........................48

Part IV: Selected National Legal Frameworks ........................................................................49

Canada ..........................................................................................................................50
Current Legal Regime .............................................................................................51
Arctic Waters Pollution Prevention Act and Regulations ..................................51
Canada Shipping Act, 2001 and Regulations .....................................................53
Marine Security ..................................................................................................55
Liability and Compensation for Ship-source Oil Pollution ................................56
Other Codes and Guidelines for Arctic Shipping ...............................................59
Russian Federation .......................................................................................................61
Current Legal Regime .............................................................................................62
1990 Regulations ................................................................................................62
1996 Guide to Navigation ..................................................................................65
1996 Regulations ................................................................................................65
1996 Requirements .............................................................................................66
Recent Changes and Future Legal Regime .............................................................66

Conclusion ...............................................................................................................................67

Key Findings ............................................................................................................................68
Further Research ..........................................................................................................73

References ................................................................................................................................75

Appendix A. List of International Maritime and Other Conventions ......................................94
Appendix B. List of Laws and Regulations ...........................................................................100
Appendix C. National Maritime Boundaries in the Arctic ....................................................103
Appendix D. Ratifications of International Maritime Law Agreements and Instruments .....106
iv
List of Tables and Figures

Table 1. Global intergovernmental shipping and related organizations
Table 2. Examples of international non-governmental shipping and
related organizations
Table 3. National submissions to the CLCS for the Arctic Ocean
Table 4. Polar Classes set out in the IMO Arctic Guidelines and IACS Unified Requirements
Table 5. Arctic NAVAREA coordinators
Table 6. The International Group of Protection & Indemnity (P & I) Clubs
Table 7. Liability limits

Figure 1. Overview map of the Arctic Ocean and maritime boundaries
Figure 2. Geographical scope of the IMO Arctic Guidelines
Figure 3. Arctic NAVAREAs
Figure 4. Routes through the Canadian Arctic archipelago
Figure 5. Northern Sea Route passageways

v
vi
Acknowledgements

This report is the result of research conducted by members and associates of the Marine
& Environmental Law Institute, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada. The
principle editors acknowledge the support and assistance of several institutions and persons.
We thank the Marine Safety Division of Transport Canada, Ottawa, Canada, for their
support in commissioning this report as part of Canada’s contribution to the Arctic Council’s
Arctic Marine Shipping Assessment. We would like to thank Ross MacDonald, Esther
Cunningham, Victor Santos-Pedro, François Marier, Doug O’Keefe, Jerry Rysanek, Paul
Topping, and Lysane Durand, Transport Canada, and Dr. Lawson Brigham, U.S. Arctic Research
Commission, for their thoughtful and detailed comments on the draft report.
We also thank Professor Edgar Gold, Q.C., O.C., Dalhousie University and University of
Queensland, for his comments on the draft report.
Numerous individuals provided information to the individual authors. In particular we
would like to thank Cecilia Denne of the World Maritime University Library; The Company of
Master Mariners of Canada (Maritime Division); Mr. Allan Johnson, Government of Nunavut;
Mr. Bud Streeter, Lloyd’s Register North America, Inc.; Mr. K. Farsi, Det Norske Veritas; and
Captain George Q. Parnell, author of Ice Seamanship (Nautical Institute) for their invaluable
assistance. The research assistance of James Lawson and Freedom-Kai Phillips, students at
Dalhousie Law School, is also gratefully acknowledged.
The maps for this report were drawn by James Boxall, Raymond Jahncke and Jennifer
Strang of the GIS Centre at Dalhousie University. We thank them for their generous contribution
and prompt response to our request.
Finally, the editors express their gratitude to all the contributing authors for their
commitment and co-operation throughout the project. Numerous discussions on Arctic shipping
among the authors broadened our individual understanding of the complexities of the subject and
were invaluable to the final report.

David VanderZwaag
Aldo Chircop
Marine & Environmental Law Institute
Dalhousie Law School

Halifax, 1 August 2008
vii
Acronyms

ABS American Bureau of Shipping
AECO Association of Arctic Expedition Cruise Operators
AFS International Convention on the Control of Harmful Anti-Fouling Systems
on Ships
AIRSS Arctic Ice Regime Shipping System (Canada)
AIS automatic identification system
AMAP Arctic Monitoring and Assessment Programme (Arctic Council)
AMSA Arctic Marine Shipping Assessment
ARCOP Arctic Operational Platform
ASPPR Arctic Shipping Pollution Prevention Regulations (Canada)
AWPPA Arctic Waters Pollution Prevention Act (Canada)
BIMCO Baltic and International Maritime Council
BWMP ballast water management plan
CANUSNORTH Canada-United States Joint Marine Pollution Contingency Plan – Beaufort
Sea Geographic Annex
CASAR Civil Aviation Search and Rescue (Canada)
CBD Convention on Biological Diversity
CCG Canadian Coast Guard
CHC Canadian Hydraulics Centre
CSC International Convention on Safe Containers
CLC International Convention on Civil Liability for Oil Pollution Damage
CLCS Commission on the Limits of the Continental Shelf
COLREGS International Regulations for Preventing Collisions at Sea
COMSAR Sub-Committee on Radiocommunications and Search and Rescue (IMO)
COPE Compensation for Oil Pollution in European waters fund
DE Sub-Committee on Ship Design and Equipment (IMO)
DFAIT Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade (Canada)
DFO Department of Fisheries and Oceans (Canada)
DNV Det Norske Veritas
EC European Commission
EEZ exclusive economic zone
EPPR Emergency Prevention Preparedness and Response Working Group
(Arctic Council)
EU European Union
FAO Food and Agricultural Organization of the United Nations
FAL Facilitation Committee (IMO)
FPSO floating production, storage and offloading unit
FSU floating storage units
GMDSS Global Maritime Distress and Safety System
HNS hazardous and noxious substances
IACS International Association of Classification Societies
IGC Code International Gas Carrier Code
IHO International Hydrographic Organization
ILO International Labour Organization
viii
IMDG Code International Maritime Dangerous Goods Code
IMF International Monetary Fund
IMO International Maritime Organization
INSROP International Northern Sea Route Programme
IOPC Funds International Oil Pollution Compensation Funds
ISM Code International Safety Management Code for the Safe Operation of Ships
and Pollution Prevention
ISPS Code International Ship and Port Facilities Code
JANSROP-GIS Japan Northern Sea Route-Geographic Information system
LC Legal Committee (IMO)
LLMC Convention on Limitation of Liability for Maritime Claims
LNG liquefied natural gas
LOF Lloyd’s Open Form
LPG liquefied petroleum gas
LSA life saving appliance
MARPOL International Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships
MEPC Marine Environment Protection Committee (IMO)
METAREA meteorological area
MLA Marine Liability Act (Canada)
MLC Maritime Labour Convention
MOU memorandum of understanding
MPCF Maritime Pollution Claims Fund (Canada)
MRCC Marine Rescue Coordination Centre (Canada)
MSC Maritime Safety Committee (IMO)
NAV Sub-Committee on Safety of Navigation (IMO)
NAVAREA navigational area
NORDREG Arctic Canada Traffic Zone (vessel traffic reporting)
NRC Natural Resources Canada
NRDA Natural Resources Damage Assessment Regulations (United States)
OPA Oil Pollution Act of 1990 (United States)
OPRC International Convention on Oil Pollution Preparedness, Response and
Co-Operation
OSLTF Oil Spill Liability Trust Fund (United States)
P&I protection and indemnity
PORCP National Place of Refuge Contingency Plan (Canada)
PSSA particularly sensitive sea area
REET Regional Environmental Emergencies Team
RO response organization
SAR search and rescue
SDR special drawing right
SOLAS International Convention on Safety of Life at Sea
SOPEP shipboard oil pollution emergency plans
SOPF Ship-source Oil Pollution Fund (Canada)
STCW International Convention on Standards of Training, Certification and
Watchkeeping for Seafarers
STOPIA Small Tanker Oil Pollution Indemnification Agreement
ix
STS ship-to-ship
TBT tributylin
TCC Technical Cooperation Committee (IMO)
TOPIA Tanker Oil Pollution Indemnification Agreement
TROOP Guidelines for Transfer of Refined Oil and Oil Products in Arctic Waters
(Arctic Council)
UNCLOS United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea
UNCITRAL United Nations Commission on International Trade Law
UNCTAD United Nations Conference on Trade and Development
USCG United States Coast Guard
VTS vessel traffic services
WHO World Health Organization
WMO World Meteorological Organization
WWF World Wildlife Fund for Nature International
x