Fiscal Adjustment and Economic Diversification

128 Pages·2017·4.22 MB·English

W o r l d E c o n o m i c a n d F i n a n c i a l S u r v e y s
Regional Economic Outlook
Sub-Saharan Africa
Fiscal Adjustment and
Economic Diversification
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
T
17
C
O
I N T E R N A T I O N A L M O N E T A R Y F U N D
©2017 International Monetary Fund
Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Regional economic outlook. Sub-Saharan Africa. — Washington, D.C.: International
Monetary Fund, 2003–
v. ; cm. — (World economic and financial surveys, 0258-7440)

Began in 2003.
Some issues have thematic titles.
1. Economic forecasting — Africa, Sub-Saharan — Periodicals. 2. Africa, Sub-Saharan —
Economic conditions — 1960 — Periodicals. 3. Economic development — Africa, Sub-Saharan
— Periodicals. I. Title: Sub-Saharan Africa. II. International Monetary Fund. III. Series: World
economic and financial surveys.
HC800.R4 2017
ISBN: 978-1-48431-251-3 (paper)
ISBN: 978-1-48432-100-3 (Web PDF)
The Regional Economic Outlook: Sub-Saharan Africa is published twice a year, in the
spring and fall, to review developments in sub-Saharan Africa. Both projections and
policy considerations are those of the IMF staff and do not necessarily represent the
views of the IMF, its Executive Board, or IMF management.
Publication orders may be placed online, by fax, or through the mail:
International Monetary Fund, Publication Services
P.O. Box 92780, Washington, DC 20090 (U.S.A.)
Tel.: [phone] Telefax: [phone]
E-mail : [email protected]
www.imf.org
www.elibrary.imf.org
Contents
Abbreviations .................................................................................................................................vi
Acknowledgments ........................................................................................................................vii
Executive Summary ........................................................................................................................x
1. The Quest for Recovery ...............................................................................................................1
A Modest Recovery is Underway ..............................................................................................3
What Lies Ahead—Outlook and Risks ...................................................................................13
Fiscal Consolidation Is Envisaged in Many Countries ............................................................15
Stimulating Growth in the Medium Term .............................................................................18
2. The Impact of Fiscal Consolidation on Growth in Sub-Saharan Africa ...............................27
Learning from the Past ...........................................................................................................28
The Effect of Fiscal Policy on Output ....................................................................................33
Fiscal Consolidations, Economic Activity, and Mitigation Policies.........................................36
Policy Considerations and Conclusions ..................................................................................40
3. Economic Diversification in Sub-Saharan Africa ...................................................................55
Patterns of Structural Transformation and Export Diversification ..........................................56
Macroeconomic Gains from Further Economic Diversification..............................................61
Getting the Policy Mix Right .................................................................................................65
Conclusions ...........................................................................................................................70
Publications of the IMF African Department, 2009–17 ............................................................109
Boxes
1.1. Countries in Fragile Situations ...............................................................................................19
1.2. CEMAC’s Regional Economic Strategy .................................................................................22
1.3. Improving Monetary Policy Frameworks in Sub-Saharan Africa ............................................24
2.1. Sub-Saharan Africa’s Revenue Potential .................................................................................43
2.2. Eliminating Fuel and Energy Subsidies ..................................................................................45
2.3. Leveraging Existing Social Safety Nets. ..................................................................................47
3.1. Different Measures of Diversification .....................................................................................58
Tables
1.1. Sub-Saharan Africa: Real GDP Growth .................................................................................14
1.2. Sub-Saharan Africa: Other Macroeconomic Indicators ...........................................................14
2.1. Selected Groups: Estimated Fiscal Multipliers in the Literature ..............................................35
3.1. Explaining Economic Growth through Different Measures of Diversification in
Developing Economies ........................................................................................................63
3.2. Results from Bilateral Trade Regressions ................................................................................65
3.3. Drivers of Economic Diversification ......................................................................................66
iii
REGIONAL ECONOMIC OUTLOOK: SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA CONTENTS
Figures
Chapter 1
1.1. Sub-Saharan Africa: Real GDP Growth 2013–19 ....................................................................1
1.2. Sub-Saharan Africa: Total Public Debt as a Percentage of GDP ...............................................2
1.3. Sub-Saharan Africa Trading Partners: Real GDP Growth, 2010–17 ........................................3
1.4. Change in Selected Commodity Prices since 2013 ...................................................................3
1.5. Sub-Saharan African Frontier Market Economies: International Sovereign Bond Issuances......4
1.6. Sub-Saharan African Frontier Markets and Emerging Market B-Rated Spreads, 2015–17 .......4
1.7. Sub-Saharan Africa: Contributions to Change in Real GDP Growth, 2016–17 .......................5
1.8. Sub-Saharan African Oil Exporters: Contributions to Real GDP, 2010–17 .............................5
1.9. Sub-Saharan Africa: Inflation, January 2012–March 2017 .......................................................5
1.10. Sub-Saharan Africa: Overall Fiscal Balance, 2010–17 ...............................................................6
1.11. Sub-Saharan Africa: Change in Overall Fiscal Balance and Components, 2010–17 ..................6
1.12. Sub-Saharan Africa: Change in Monetary Policy Rate from January 2016–August 2017 .........7
1.13. Sub-Saharan Africa: Exchange Market Pressure, 2016–17 ........................................................8
1.14. Sub-Saharan Africa: Current Account Deficit and Sources of Financing, 2011–17 ..................8
1.15. Sub-Saharan Africa: Level of International Reserves, 2013 and 2017 .......................................9
1.16. Sub-Saharan Africa: Exports of Leading Agricultural Goods Producers ..................................10
1.17. Sub-Saharan Africa: Average Change in Debt-to-GDP Ratio and Components, 2011–16 .....10
1.18. Sub-Saharan Africa: Public Sector Debt Decomposition, 2010–16 ........................................11
1.19. Sub-Saharan Africa: Total Debt Service as a Percentage of Revenue, 2010–17 .......................11
1.20. Sub-Saharan Africa: Fitch Credit Risk Ratings, 2013–17 .......................................................11
1.21. Sub-Saharan Africa: Change in Banks’ Exposure to the Government and Change in
Private Credit Growth, Average, 2011–13 versus Average, 2014–16 ...................................12
1.22. Sub-Saharan Africa: Bank Nonperforming Loans as a Percentage of Total Loans ...................12
1.23. Sub-Saharan Africa: Number of Correspondents Exits, 2011–16 ...........................................13
1.24. Sub-Saharan Africa: Growth Prospects, 2017 and 2018 .........................................................13
1.25. Sub-Saharan Africa: Public Debt as a Percentage of GDP, 2011–22 ......................................15
1.26. Sub-Saharan Africa: Fiscal Consolidation, 2017–22 ...............................................................16
1.27. Sub-Saharan Africa: Fiscal Indicators, Cumulative Change from 2010 ...................................16
1.28. Selected Regions: Governance Indicators, 2015 .....................................................................18
Chapter 2
2.1. Sub-Saharan Africa: Fiscal Balance Decomposition ................................................................29
2.2. Sub-Saharan Africa and Emerging Market and Developing Economies: Episodes of
Commodity-Revenue Decline .............................................................................................30
2.3. Sub-Saharan Africa and Emerging Market and Developing Economies:
Spending-Based Fiscal Consolidation Episodes ....................................................................31
2.4. Change in the Overall Fiscal Balance and Components: Spending-Based Fiscal
Consolidation Episodes .......................................................................................................32
2.5. Sub-Saharan Africa versus Emerging Market and Developing Economies:
Revenue-Based Fiscal Consolidation Episodes .....................................................................32
2.6. Sub-Saharan Africa: Effect of Fiscal Policy on Output ...........................................................34
2.7. Sub-Saharan Africa: Fiscal Multipliers during Periods of High and Low Growth ...................36
iv v
REGIONAL ECONOMIC OUTLOOK: SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA CONTENTS
2.8. Sub-Saharan Africa: Fiscal Multipliers during Periods of High and Low
Governance Quality ............................................................................................................36
2.9. Sub-Saharan Africa: Fiscal Multipliers during Periods of High and Low Efficiency
of Public Investment............................................................................................................37
2.10. Sub-Saharan Africa: Impact of Spending-Based Fiscal Consolidation on Economic Activity ..38
2.11. Sub-Saharan Africa: Impact of Investment, Consumption, and Revenue-Based
Consolidations on Output ...................................................................................................38
2.12. Sub-Saharan Africa: Impact of Tax-Based Consolidation on Economic Activity ....................39
2.13. Sub-Saharan Africa: Impact of Fiscal Consolidations under Different Monetary Conditions .40
2.14. Sub-Saharan Africa: Impact of Fiscal Consolidations in Different Debt Environments ..........40
2.15. Sub-Saharan Africa: Impact of Fiscal Consolidations and Role of Exchange Rate
Flexibility, International Reserves Buffers, and Openness to Trade ......................................41
Chapter 3
3.1. Sub-Saharan Africa: Real Sectoral Shares, 1995–2014 ...........................................................57
3.2. Labor Productivity and Changes in Employment Shares, 2000 versus Latest .........................57
3.3. Measures of Export Diversification and Quality .....................................................................59
3.4. Goods Export Diversification by Country, 1962–2014 ..........................................................60
3.5. Economic Complexity ...........................................................................................................61
3.6. Economic Complexity Across Countries: Export of Goods, 1995 and 2015...........................62
3.7. Sub-Saharan Africa: Export Diversification and GDP per Capita Growth ..............................63
3.8. Size of Manufacturing Sector and Trade ................................................................................64
3.9. Drivers of Export Diversification ............................................................................................67
iv v
Abbreviations
BEAC Bank of Central African States
CAPB cyclically adjusted primary balance
CBRs correspondent banking relationships
CEMAC Economic and Monetary Community of Central Africa
EAC East African Community
EMDEs emerging market and developing economies
EMEDEV all emerging market economies
GDP gross domestic product
ICRG International Country Risk Guide
LPM local projections method
REO Regional Economic Outlook (IMF)
SARB South Africa Reserve Bank
SSA Sub-Saharan Africa
SDGs Sustainable Development Goals
WAEMU West African Economic and Monetary Union
WEO World Economic Outlook (IMF)
vi
Acknowledgments
The October 2017 issue of the Regional Economic Outlook: Sub-Saharan Africa (REO) was prepared by
a team led by Jaroslaw Wieczorek under the direction of David Robinson.
The team included Francisco Arizala, Romain Bouis, Paolo Cavallino, Wenjie Chen, Cristina Cheptea,
Jesus Gonzalez-Garcia, Cleary Haines, Marwa Ibrahim, Lisa Kolovich, Yun Liu, Miguel Pereira Mendes,
Nkunde Mwase, Monique Newiak, Friska Parulian, Axel Schimmelpfennig, Preya Sharma,
Charalambos Tsangarides, Frank Wu, Keerthi Yellapragada, Mustafa Yenice, and Jiayi Zhang.
Specific contributions were made by Emre Alper, Karim Barhoumi, Lennart Erickson, Enrique Gelbard,
Salifou Issoufou, Tunc Gursoy, Trevor Lessard, Daniela Marchettini, Edouard Martin, Cameron McLoughlin,
Clara Mira, Koffie Nassar, Toomas Orav, Alun Thomas, Mauricio Villafuerte, and Aline Coudouel, and
Emma Monsalve (both from the World Bank).
Natasha Minges was responsible for document production, with production assistance from
Charlotte Vazquez. The editing and production were overseen by Linda Long of the Communications
Department.
The following conventions are used in this publication:
• In tables, a blank cell indicates “not applicable,” ellipsis points (. . .) indicate “not available,” and 0
or 0.0 indicates “zero” or “negligible.” Minor discrepancies between sums of constituent figures and
totals are due to rounding.
• An en dash (–) between years or months (for example, 2009–10 or January–June) indicates the
years or months covered, including the beginning and ending years or months; a slash or virgule
(/) between years or months (for example, 2005/06) indicates a fiscal or financial year, as does the
abbreviation FY (for example, FY2006).
• “Billion” means a thousand million; “trillion” means a thousand billion.
• “Basis points” refer to hundredths of 1 percentage point (for example, 25 basis points are equivalent
to ¼ of 1 percentage point).
vii

Executive Summary
THE QUEST FOR RECOVERY
The broad-based slowdown in sub-Saharan Africa is easing, but the underlying situation remains difficult.
Growth is expected to reach 2.6 percent in 2017, but the pickup reflects mainly one-off factors, notably a
recovery in oil production in Nigeria and the easing of drought conditions in eastern and southern Africa,
and a somewhat improved external environment. Even with this uptick, growth will barely surpass the rate of
population growth. While a third of the countries in the region continue to grow at 5 percent or more, in
12 countries, comprising over 40 percent of the region’s population, income per capita is expected to decline.
Growth in the region is expected to pick up further in 2018 and reach 3.4 percent, but ongoing policy
uncertainty in Nigeria and South Africa hinders a stronger rebound, and growth is not expected to increase
further in 2019. Many of the faster growing economies continue to be driven by public spending, with debt
levels and debt service costs rising.
The external environment has improved, but the recovery remains modest and vulnerabilities are rising.
• Strengthening global growth, including in key trading partners such as China and the euro area, provides
some positive tailwinds to growth in sub-Saharan Africa. In addition, increased appetite for yield
has fostered a rebound in sovereign bond issuances by the region’s frontier economies; however, low
commodity prices continue to weigh on growth prospects for commodity exporters.
• Public debt as a share of GDP has increased since 2013 and is now above 50 percent of GDP in close to
half of the region’s economies. The number of low-income countries in debt distress or facing high risk
of debt distress increased from 7 in 2013 to 12 in 2016, and all of the region’s frontier markets or other
countries with credit ratings, except Namibia, have been downgraded below investment grade. The debt
increase has been driven by a widening in fiscal deficits, slow growth, the slump in commodity prices,
and exchange rate depreciations in some countries. While current accounts have improved and exchange
market pressures eased somewhat, international reserves are below adequacy levels in many countries.
Reflecting this buildup of vulnerabilities, downside risks dominate. Delays in implementing policy
adjustments could reduce fiscal space for progrowth expenditures, crowd out private investment, and
adversely impact the external sector. Elevated public debt levels raise concerns about debt sustainability in
the region, while the spiraling banks-sovereign nexus could further strain the financial sector. Many countries
also face risks stemming from the disruption in correspondent bank relationships.
In this context, implementing the fiscal consolidations planned in many countries, together with
structural reforms to tackle constraints on growth, is the key policy priority.
Fiscal consolidation needs are largest and most pressing in the oil-exporting countries. In some cases (such as
Angola) a considerable adjustment has already been made, mostly by cutting capital spending. Going forward,
oil-exporting countries should focus on raising noncommodity revenues and targeted reductions in recurrent
spending. Nevertheless, where consolidation is urgent, notably in oil-exporting countries, cuts in public
investment may be unavoidable. Other countries also need to initiate fiscal consolidation, albeit to a smaller
extent, focusing also on the composition and efficiency of spending.
Sub-Saharan African countries also need to implement structural reforms and seize opportunities to enhance
growth above current projections through structural transformation and export diversification, including by
improving access to credit, infrastructure, and the regulatory framework, and building a skilled workforce.
ix
REGIONAL ECONOMIC OUTLOOK: SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA
THE IMPACT OF FISCAL CONSOLIDATION ON GROWTH IN SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA
The second chapter examines the effects on output from changes in public expenditure and revenue in sub-
Saharan African countries during 1990–2016. Past fiscal consolidations—defined as periods during which
fiscal positions improved based on spending cuts or noncommodity revenue mobilization—have typically
been associated with negative effects on output.
The estimated effects on output from changes in fiscal policy—fiscal multipliers—are generally smaller
in sub-Saharan African economies than those identified in advanced or emerging market economies. On
average in sub-Saharan Africa, fiscal consolidations based on reducing public investment have had the largest
contractionary effect on output, those based on current spending cuts or on revenue mobilization, have
smaller effects on output. However, the impact depends critically on country characteristics, the supporting
policy environment, and the efficiency of spending and the strength of institutions.
These findings suggest that countries in the region should focus on revenue mobilization to mitigate the
negative impact of fiscal consolidation on growth. However, as revenue mobilization takes time, cuts in
expenditures may be unavoidable, particularly in countries facing an urgent need to undertake adjustment.
In such cases, it is important to protect both key infrastructure spending, so as to not unduly constrain future
growth prospects, and to place priority on social spending on health, education, and social safety nets in order
to minimize impacts on lower-income households.
ECONOMIC DIVERSIFICATION IN SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA
The third chapter takes stock of progress with economic diversification in sub-Saharan Africa. The picture
is not uniform. At the aggregate level, structural transformation has been slower than in other regions. Still,
workers have moved from low-productivity agriculture into higher-productivity manufacturing and services
jobs, contributing to overall productivity growth. Moreover, some of the region’s other resource-intensive
economies and non-resource-intensive economies have achieved export diversification at a similar pace as
global peers. In contrast, the region’s oil exporters have seen increased specialization, reflecting higher oil
prices and new production.
Structural transformation and export diversification are positively associated with growth, in particular at early
stages of development. Cross-country regressions suggest that macroeconomic stability, access to credit, good
infrastructure, a conducive regulatory environment, a skilled workforce, and equality have been associated
with higher economic diversification. Country case studies highlight the heterogeneity of growth experiences.
A common element of successful policy interventions is that they build on a country’s endowments and
expand underlying capabilities. Addressing market failures can help, as can trade integration.
x