Table Of Content

FEDERALISM UNDER CHALLENGE Volume I Richard Simeon Katherine Swinton 1993-1994 Faculty of Law University of Toronto * These materials were prepared with the assistance of Lise Favreau and Rebecca Netley. They are for the sole use of University of Toronto students. bORA LASKIN LAW LIBRARY UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO FEDERALISM UNDER CHALLENGE Volume I Richard Simeon Katherine Swinton 1993-1994 Faculty of Law University of Toronto * These materials were prepared with the assistance of Lise Favreau and Rebecca Netley. They are for the sole use of University of Toronto students. Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2019 with funding from University of Toronto ( https://archive.org/details/federalismunderc01sime FEDERALISM UNDER CHALLENGE TABLE OF CONTENTS Page # PART I FEDERALISM, THE CHARTER AND DIMENSIONS OF CANADIAN IDENTITY Chapter 1: Introduction D.V. Smiley, The Federal Condition in Canada . 1 R. Simeon and I. Robinson, State. Society and the Development of Canadian Federalism . 5 Charles Taylor, "Shared and Divergent Values" . 13 Michael Adams and Mary Jane Lennox, "The Public's View of the Canadian Federation".30 Chapter 2: Federalism and Language Rights: Regionalism and Dualism.39 Jean Laponce, "Reducing the Tensions Resulting From Language Contacts: Personal or Territorial Solutions?" 39 Stdphane Dion, "Explaining Qudbec Nationalism" . 41 Andrew Stark, "English-Canadian Opposition to Qudbec Nationalism" . 69 A,Qt Qyi^beg, y, PlfriKie.90 MacDonald v. City of Montreal.97 Socidt<§ des Acadiens du Nouveau-Brunswick Inc, v? Association of Parents fgr Fairness jp .Education . . 101 Ford v, A-G, Qv^bec.103 Mahe v. Alberta.no Section 16.1 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freecteias.11? - i - Chapter 3: Aboriginal Self-Government David Hawkes, and Alan Maslove, "Fiscal Arrangements for Aboriginal Self-Government" . 118 Ian Scott, and J.T.S. McCabe, "The Role of the Provinces in the Elucidation of Aboriginal Rights in Canada".139 Douglas Sanders, "The Constitution, the Provinces and Aboriginal Peoples" . 141 Native Womens Association of Canada v. Canada.147 Native Women's Association of Canada v. Canada .... 156 M.E. Turpel, "Aboriginal Peoples and the Canadian Charter: Interpretive Monopolies, Cultural Differences" 163 Chapter 4:_Changing Conceptions of Identity and Citizenship Jean Leonard Elliott, and Augie Fleras, "Immigration and the Canadian Mosaic".168 Alan Cairns, "Constitutional Minoritarianism in Canada". 184 B. Baines, "After Meech Lake: The Ms/Representation of Gender in Scholarly Spaces" . 200 Micheline de Seve, "The Perspectives of Qudbec Feminists".209 R. V. S. (S. ) . [1990] 2 S.C.R. 254 . 215 PART II INSTITUTIONS Chapter 5: Representation Reg Whitaker, "Federalism and Democratic Theory" .... 222 Janine Brodie, "Women and the Electoral Process in Canada".230 Reference re; _Electoral Boundaries Commission Act. ss. 14. 20. (Sask. ).f..244 • • - li - D. Smiley, and R. Watts, Intrastate Federalism in Canada.. . 263 G. Robertson, A House Divided: Meech Lake. Senate Reform and the Canadian Union.277 Donald Lenihan, "Squaring Politics and Principles: Institutional Reform in Canada" . 291 Chapter 6: Participation and Decision-making Keith Banting, "Federalism and the Supreme Court of Canada: The Competing Bases of Legitimation" . 306 D. V. Smiley, "An Outsider's Observations of Federal- Provincial Relations Among Consenting Adults" . 320 J.S. Dupre, "Reflections on the Workability of Executive Federalism" . 327 n• •x • - 5 V 1 :