Table Of Content

R CCOO B LI LO FAULT AND RESPONSIBILITY W A CO L CX3 KIN o AS 5 L A 1^ R BO CO Professors B. Chapman and M. Moran 1999/2000 DEC - 2 1999 SACaiTV OF LAW FAULT AND RESPONSIBILITY Professors B. Chapman and M. Moran 1999/2000 Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2018 with funding from University of Toronto https://archive.org/details/faultresponsibil00chap_4 FAULT AND RESPONSIBILITY CONTENTS I Introduction ‘Moral Luck’ - in Thomas Nagel, Mortal Questions (Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1979) 24-38.1 ‘Moral luck’ - in Bernard Williams, Moral Luck: Philosophical Papers 1973-1980 (Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1981) 20-39.9 Ripstein, Arthur, “Equality, Luck, and Responsibility,’’ 23 Philosophy & Public Affairs (1994) 3-23.19 II Fault and Responsibility in Tort Law - General Theory Holmes, O., “The Common Law’’ (Boston: Little Brown, 1881).30 Epstein, R., A Theory of Strict Liability: Toward a Reformulation of Tort Law (San Francisco: Cato Institute, 1980) 3-49.33 Honore, Tony, “Responsibility and Luck,’’ 104 The Law Quarterly Review (1988) 530-553 .57 Weinrib, E., “Liberty, Community, and Corrective Justice’’ 1(1) Can. J. of Law & Jurisprudence (1988) 3-17 .69 III Fault and Responsibility in Tort Law - Special Problems Vaughan v. Menlove (1837), 3 Bing. (N.C.) 468.77 Coleman, Jules, “Mental Abnormality, Personal Responsibility, and Tort Liability’’ - in B.A. Brody & H.T. Engelhart Jr., (eds.) Mental Illness: Law and Public Policy (Holland: D. Reid Publishing Co., 1980) 107-133.80 McHale v. Watson (1966), 115 C.L.R. 199.94 Nelson v. Town of the Pas (1969) 67 WWR 580-583 ...103 1 State V. Williams {\91\) AUV.2&, 1167-1174.105 IV Fault and Responsibility in Criminal Law - General Theory Horder, Jeremy, “Criminal Culpability: The Possibility of a General Theory” 12 Law and Philosophy (1993) 193-215.113 Duff, R.A., “Choice, Character, and Criminal Liability” 12 Law and Philosophy (1993) 345-383.125 Brudner, A., “Agency & Welfare in the Penal Law” - in S. Shite, J. Gardner, & J. Horder, (eds.) Action and Value in Criminal Law (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1993) 21-53.145 V Fault and Responsibility in Criminal Law - Special Problems A. The Act Requirement Husak, Douglas, “Does Criminal Liability Require an Act?” - in A. Duff (ed.). Philosophy and the Criminal Law (Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1998) 60-100.162 Alexander, Larry, “Reconsidering the Relationship Among Voluntary Acts, Strict Liability, and Negligence in Criminal Law” - in M. Gorr & S. Harwood (eds.). Controversies in Criminal Law: Philosophical Essays on Responsibility’ and Procedure (Boulder: Westview Press, 1992) 32-54.183 Chapman, B., “Agency and Contingency: the Case of Criminal Attempts” 38 U ofTLaw Journal (1988) 355-377.195 B. The Mens Rea Requirement ‘Recklessness” - in R.A. Duff, Intention, Agency d Criminal Liability: Philosophy of Action & the Criminal Law (Oxford: Basil Blacku'ell, 1990) 139-179.207 Pickard, Toni, “Culpable Mistakes and Rape: Relating Mens Rea to the Crime” 30 UofTLawJ. (1980) 75-98.228 C. Defense of Provocation and Culture Klimchuk, D., “Outrage, Self-Control, and Culpability” 44 UofTLawJ. (1994) 441-468.241 Baker B., “Provocation as a Defence for Abused Women who Kill” 1(1) Can. J. of Law & Jurisprudence (1998) 193-211 .256 Yeo, Stanley, “Sex, Ethnicity, Power of Self-Control and Provocation Revisited” 18 Sydney Law Review (1996) 304-322.266 Wong, C., “Good Intentions, Troublesome Applications: The Cultural Defence and Other Uses of Cultural Evidence in Canada” 42 Criminal Law Q. (1999) 367-396.276 VI Individual Responsibility in ‘Abnormal’ Moral Contexts Delgado, R., “’Rotten Social Background’; Should the Criminal Law Recognize a Defence of Severe Environmental Deprivation?” 3 Law & Inequality (1985) 9.292 Vuoso, G., “Background, Responsibility, & Excuse” 96 Yale Law J. (1987) 1661-1686.303 Jaspers, Karl, “German Guilt” - in R.A. Falk, G. Kolko, & R.J. Lipton (eds.,) Crimes of War (New York: Random House, 1971) 476-485 .317 R. V. Finta (1994) 112 D.L.R. (4**^) 513 (excerpt).322 Calhoun, C., “Responsibility and Reproach” 99 Ethics (1989) 389-406.341 Wolf, Susan, “Sanity & the Metaphysics of Responsibility”.351 ‘The Politics of the Rule of Law’ - in D. Dyzenhaus, Judging the Judges, Judging Ourselves: Truth, Reconciliation & the Apartheid Legal Order (Oxford: Hart Publishing, 1998) 136-183...360 VII Individual Responsibility in Institutional Contexts Luban, D., “The Adversary System Excuse” - in D. Luban, ed.. The Ethics of Lawyers (New York: New York UP, 1994) 139-178. 384 Wolf, Susan, “The Legal and Moral Responsibility of Organizations” - in J. Pennock & J. Chapman (eds.,) NOMOS XXVII: Criminal Justice (New York: New York UP, 1985) 267-286. 405 VIII Remedying the Wrongs Sher, G., “Ancient Wrongs & Modem Rights” \Q{\) Philosophy & Pub. Affairs (1980) 3-17 .416 Schwartz, W., “The Holocaust: Does Time Heal all Wrongs?” 20 Cardozo Law Rev. (1998) 433-442.424 Wente, Margaret “Fifth Column - who pays for the sins of the fathers...” Globe & Mail, Tues. Sept. 28, 1999 pg. A22.....430 F.S.M. V. Clarke (1999) B.C.J. No. 1973 ...431 Chisolm, T.E., “Sweep Around Your Own Front Door: Examining the Argument for Legislative African American Reparations” 147(3) U. of Penn. Law Rev. (1999) 677-727.451 Allen, J., “Balancing Justice & Social Unity: Political Theory & the Idea of a Tmth & Reconciliation Commission” 49(3) U. ofT.LawJ. (1999) 315-353.477 IV