Evolution’s Witness Odontodactylus scyallurus Mantis Shrimp Image © James Brandt, MD Evolution’s Witness How Eyes Evolved Ivan R. Schwab University of California, Davis Histology by Richard Dubielzig, DVM, and Charles Schobert, DVM Comparative Ocular Pathology Laboratory of Wisconsin (COPLOW) 1 1 Oxford University Press, Inc., publishes works that further Oxford University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education. Oxford New York Auckland Cape Town Dar es Salaam Hong Kong Karachi Kuala Lumpur Madrid Melbourne Mexico City Nairobi New Delhi Shanghai Taipei Toronto With offi ces in Argentina Austria Brazil Chile Czech Republic France Greece Guatemala Hungary Italy Japan Poland Portugal Singapore South Korea Switzerland Th ailand Turkey Ukraine Vietnam Copyright © 2012 Oxford University Press Published by Oxford University Press, Inc. 198 Madison Avenue, New York, New York 10016 www.oup.com Oxford is a registered trademark of Oxford University Press All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior permission of Oxford University Press. ____________________________________________________________ Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Schwab, Ivan R. Evolution’s witness : how eyes evolved / Ivan R. Schwab ; histology by Richard Dubielzig, Charles Schobert. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-19-536974-8 (hardback) 1. Eye—Evolution. 2. Adaptation (Biology). 3. Anatomy, Comparative. 4. Evolution (Biology) I. Title. [DNLM: 1. Eye—anatomy & histology. 2. Adaptation, Biological. 3. Anatomy, Comparative. 4. Biological Evolution. 5. Vision, Ocular--physiology. WW 101] QP475.S374 2012 612.8’4—dc23 2011016413 ____________________________________________________________ 1 3 5 7 9 8 6 4 2 Printed in China on acid-free paper To all my students, who have taught me much This page intentionally left blank CONTENTS Foreword by Russell Fernald, PhD xi 3. Eukaryotes Organize and Metazoans Arise Acknowledgments xiii Neoproterozoic Era 1000–543 million years ago, Introduction xv Cryogenian Period 850–650 million years ago, Ediacaran Period 650–543 million years ago 17 Multicellular Animals 17 Prologue: Molecular Genesis: Sensory Input 21 Hadean Eon 4600–3750 million years ago 3 Th e Eye and the Brain 21 1. Th e Age of First Cellular Life Metazoans and Th eir Eyes 24 Archean Eon 3750–2500 million years ago 5 4. Early Animals Prepare the Ground Prokaryotes 5 Ediacaran Period 650–543 million years ago 25 Early Cells—Protobionts 5 A Major Genetic Step 27 First Life 5 Urbilateria 27 First Witness 6 Another Major Genetic Step 28 Th e Road to Cellular Success 8 Wormy Beginnings 28 Retinal (or Retinaldehyde, a form of Genetic Development of Eyes 29 Vitamin A) 8 Annelids 31 Photolyases and Cryptochromes 9 Mollusks Take the Stage 36 Sunlight and Blue Light 9 Kimberella quadrata and Beginning to Organize 10 Acanthochiton communis 36 Genetic Machinery—Th e Toolkit 10 Small Shelly Fauna 37 Prokaryotic Gifts 10 5. Vision’s Big Bang Blazes the Trail Further Organization 11 Early Paleozoic Era, Cambrian Explosion 543–490 2. Th e Age of Complex Cellular Life million years ago 38 Proterozoic Eon 2500–543 million years ago, Th e Burgess Shale 38 Cryogenian Period 850–650 million years ago, Invertebrates in Ascendancy 38 Ediacaran Period 650–543 million years ago 12 Th e First Eye 39 Inception of Eukaryotes 12 Trilobites 39 Nucleated Kleptomaniacs 12 More Invertebrates and Th eir Eyes Appear 43 Bridging the Gap to Metazoa 15 Specifi c Examples 43 vii 6. Th e Age of Arthropods Arthropods Come Ashore 109 A Major Phylum Begins: Paleozoic Era, Cambrian Th e Superposition Eye 109 Period 543–490 million years ago 50 Th e Apposition Eye 110 Compound Eye Development 50 12. Stealth, Speed, and Predation Apposition Eye 51 Paleozoic Era, Devonian Period 415–362 million Superposition Eye 56 years ago 114 Th e Crabs 61 Arachnida 114 7. Vertebrates Gain a Foothold 13. Th e Age of Tetrapods and Terrestrials Paleozoic Era, Cambrian Vertebrate Animalia Comes Ashore . . . Paleozoic Era, Period 543–490 million years ago 63 Late Devonian Period 385–362 million years ago 119 Phylum Chordata 63 Vertebrate Quest for Land 119 First True Vertebrate 65 Early Tetrapodian Eyes 121 Conodonts 65 Th e Challenge of a Terrestrial Environment 124 Building a Vertebrate Eye 66 Eyelids and the Lacrimal System 125 Tapetum 68 Extraocular Muscles 125 Why Color Vision? 69 Tear Glands 126 8. Shelly Fauna Rule the Seas Cornea and Lens 126 Paleozoic Era, Ordovician Retina and Vision 127 Period 490–445 million years ago 70 Neurologic Changes 128 Mollusca 70 Consolidation of the Assumption of Land 130 Bivalvia 70 14. Terrestrial Life Flourishes Gastropoda 75 Paleozoic Era, Carboniferous Period 9. Th e Piscine Eye Develops 362–299 million years ago, Permian Paleozoic Era, Silurian Period 299–251 million years ago 131 Period 445–415 million years ago 77 Vertebrates 131 Vertebrate Expansion 77 Synapsids and Th eir Eyes 131 Placoderms 77 Diapsids and Th eir Eyes 132 Elasmobranchs 81 Invertebrates of the Permian 133 10. Th e Piscine Eye Matures Permian Extinction 136 Paleozoic Era, Early Devonian 15. Reptiles Push the Ocular Envelope Period 415–398 million years ago 85 Th e Age of Reptiles: Mesozoic Era, Bony Fish Appear 85 Triassic Period 251–208 million Anatomy of Piscine Eye 85 years ago 138 Th e Outer Coats of the Eye 85 Synapsids 138 Th e Lens 87 Sauropsids 138 Neurology and Optics 97 Anapsids 138 Habitat Expansion 100 Diapsids 139 Piscine Camoufl age 107 Th e Adnexa of the Reptilian Eye 139 11. Insects Arise to Fly Reptilian Eye 142 Paleozoic Era, Early Devonian Lepidosaurs 149 Period 415–398 million years ago 109 Archosaurs 151 viii Contents 16. March of the Archosaurs Nictitans 186 Mesozoic Era, Triassic Period 251–208 million Cornea 189 years ago, Jurassic Period 208–145 million Iris and Pupil 189 years ago 152 Accommodation 189 Archosaurs 152 Uvea: Choroid, Ciliary Body, and Iris 189 Th e Order Testudines Retina 190 (Turtles, Terrapins, and Tortoises) 152 Visual Processing 190 Crocodilians 156 Oil Droplets 192 Archosaurian Sisters 158 Macular Design 192 Ichthyosaurs 158 Single Fovea 193 17. Dinosaurs and Th eir Companions Infula 193 Mesozoic Era, Triassic Period 251–208 million Convexiclivate Fovea—Single Deep years ago, Jurassic Period 208–145 million Fovea 194 years ago 161 Bifoveate Birds 194 Pterosaurs 161 Pecten 197 Dinosaurs 162 Neurologic Evolution 199 Sauropods 162 21. Pollinators Coevolve Th eropods 162 Mesozoic Era, Cretaceous Period 145–65 million 18. Cephalopods Change Direction years ago; Cenozoic Era, Tertiary Period 65–2 million Mesozoic Era, Jurassic years ago 202 Period 208–145 million years ago 164 Th e Earth in Bloom 202 Coleoids 164 A Bounty for Insects 202 Cephalopod Lens 164 Social Hymenoptera: Wasp, Bees, Extraocular Muscles 164 Ants, and Sawfl ies 207 Coleoid Expansion 164 True Flies and a New Eye 211 19. Snakes Arise from the Ground Diptera 211 Mesozoic Era, Cretaceous Brachyceran Flies 212 Period 145–65 million years ago 172 22. Mammalia Diversifi es Fossorial Lizards 172 Mesozoic Era, Cretaceous Period 145–65 million years Recreating an Eye 172 ago; Cenozoic Era, Early to Mid-Tertiary Period 20. Th e Age of Birds—Th e Eye Taken to Great Heights 65–56 million years ago 216 Mesozoic Era, Cretaceous Period Mammals Th rive 216 145–65 million years ago; Cenozoic Era, Th e Descent of Color Vision 218 Tertiary Period 65–2 million years ago 176 Marsupials 221 Birds Arise 176 23. Th e Age of Mammals Globe Morphology 177 Mesozoic Era, Late Cretaceous Period 100–65 million Globose Globe 178 years ago; Cenozoic Era, Tertiary Period 65–1.8 Flattened Globe 178 million years ago, Quaternary Tubular Eye 180 Period 1.8 million years ago 224 Orbital Size and Contents 184 Mammals Extend Th eir Dominance 224 Visual Fields 184 Placental Mammals 224 Eyelids 185 Primate Tuning of Color Vision 226 Contents ix