EEccoollooggiiccaall SStteewwaarrddsshhiipp Gifted Children and By Roberta J. McHardy, Pamela B. Blanchard, and Catharina F. de Wet I n even the earliest studies of giftedness in young children (Burks, Jensen, & Terman, 1930; Hollingworth, 1926), researchers noted distinct character traits among gifted students, which included global aware- ness, sensitivity to complex issues, and a tendency to worry about injustice and dangers that often are beyond a child’s control. Dabrowski and Piechowski (1977) described what they called emotional overexcitabilities that can be observed among gifted students as great depth and intensity of emotional life expressed through a wide range of “feeling, attachments, compassion, heightened sense of responsibility, and scrupulous self-examination” (p. 287). This sensitivity of students is one of the positive gifts they bring to a classroom and the world. Yet, characteristics of sensitivity in gifted children can sometimes frustrate or annoy classmates and, unfortunately, some teachers who do not have the same sense of global awareness and responsibility. It can be difficult to reassure young gifted students that solutions will be found to complex problems without patronizing them or minimizing their concerns. This article describes ways in which gifted students explored issues of ecological concern through a description of student projects that addressed coastal erosion and habitat reduction in mean- ingful ways. Through projects such as these, children who were impacted by Hurricanes Katrina and Rita became empowered to help restore their environment. 16 fall 2009 • vol 32, no 4 Ecological Stewardship The Need for Action helping.” (M. Herbert, personal accepts significant answerability communication, May 20, 2008) to society. Ecological stewardship One of the most heartbreaking focuses on the living components aspects of the devastation caused by Fortunately, several ecological of an ecosystem, while keeping Hurricanes Katrina and Rita has been programs were already in place in in mind larger ecosystem and the impact on children in the coastal Louisiana and Mississippi that could environmental concerns. Thus regions of Louisiana and Mississippi give children the means to play a part ecological stewardship projects in the recovery efforts. As quickly can generally be grouped into (McHardy, 2008). Uncertainty about as teachers were able to access the plant-based and animal-based what was happening during the evacu- resource personnel who designed these projects. (p. 269) ations, and in some cases, separation programs, assistance was provided to from family members, threw the chil- either restore activities that had been Connecting Ecological dren involved into turmoil. Children underway before the storms or to Stewardship to Environmental suffered further trauma when those Education Theory begin new activities in schools that who could return to their houses were looking for a meaningful way to were faced with the long-term task of meet their students’ emotional needs. In planning ecological steward- rebuilding their homes and their lives. ship projects, it is useful for project Thus, uncertainty about the passing Ecological Stewardship organizers to keep two frameworks storms was replaced by uncertainty in mind: Roth’s (1992) Four Stages about the future. Mona Herbert, a Defined of Environmental Literacy and Kolb’s fifth-grade teacher of the gifted in New (1984) Learning Cycle. In a paper Orleans, LA, described the dilemma The U.S. Environmental Protection outlining the evolution of the term this introduced to classrooms: Agency (2005) defined environmental environmental literacy, Roth postulated stewardship as: that while there is some variability in I really saw on the part of the the sequence, people’s development children . . . this sense of helpless- the responsibility for environ- of environmental literacy progresses ness . . . I almost resented people mental quality shared by all through four levels: awareness, con- saying that the children were those whose actions affect the cern, understanding, and action. See resilient. And that they were just environment, reflected as both a Table 1 for a detailed description of going to bounce back . . . [They value and a practice by individu- Roth’s four Stages of Environmental would say,] “My mom and dad als, companies, communities, Literacy. were laying new floor last night, and government organizations. In order for students to develop so I didn’t get a chance to do Positive stewardship behavior environmental literacy, they first need my homework,” and they were demonstrates acceptance of a certain level of awareness and fac- pushed out of the way some- this responsibility through the tual knowledge about the context of where else and they couldn’t help. continuous improvement of the stewardship activity. Ultimately, (M. Herbert, personal commu- environmental performance to the stewardship opportunity will nication, May 20, 2008) achieve measurable results and become a significant activity within the sustainable outcomes. (p. 8) “action” stage of the participants’ jour- But teachers found that their students ney. Therefore, managers of ecological very much wanted to and needed to Worrell and Appleby (2000) defined stewardship projects, whether they are help. Herbert noted: ecological stewardship in similar terms: teacher-driven or agency-driven, must recognize these four stages and plan Because gifted kids see into the Stewardship is the responsible activities that will provide students future, that’s the problem. They use (including conservation) of with the opportunities to move from get so affected; they get caught natural resources in a way that one stage to the next. up in it . . . They are almost takes full and balanced account In summarizing recent neuroscience paralyzed at times because . . . of the interests of society, future research into the way the human brain they see it as doom . . . I wanted generations, and other species, learns, Zull (2002) wrote that learning continued on page ?? the kids to be able to say, “I’m as well as of private needs, and is physical. The structure of the brain is gifted child today 17 Ecological Stewardship Table 1 curriculum. These experiences may be Stages of Environmental Literacy presented in a variety of formats such as invited speakers, field trips (real or virtual), picture books, videos, and Awareness Perception of human/nature interactions and consequences in general demonstrations. Students who exhibit or around a particular issue. high interest in the topics presented Concern Perception of real or potential negative consequences of a set of human/ during Type I enrichment, and are nature interactions and a feeling that some changes in those interac- tions need to occur. eager to pursue questions regarding these topics, are introduced to skills Understanding Acquisition of detailed information about the present and future impli- cations and consequences of current human/nature interactions and training, or Type II enrichment. Type alternative interactions. II enrichment consists of group and individual training in thinking and Acquisition of thinking and decision-making skills and their use in pro- feeling processes, learning-to-learn cessing acquired information. skills, research and reference skills, Action Application of understandings to individual and corporate behavioral and written, oral, and visual commu- changes that alter human/nature interactions in what is perceived as nications skills. These “how-to” skills a responsible way that reduces or eliminates negative consequences. are the kinds of skills students need Note. From Roth (1992). to pursue their questions or areas of concern about the topics introduced the foundation of the structure of the Connecting Ecological during Type I enrichment. In their learning cycle. Zull referred to David Stewardship to Gifted Education pursuit of answers to their questions Kolb’s (1984) learning cycle frame- Theory and Practice or solutions to their concerns, students work. The learning cycle has been may engage in Type III enrichment described in a number of variations, Theorists concerned with learning activities, which are defined as first- with the number of phases varying opportunities for gifted students agree hand investigations of real problems from three to five across models (Atkin that such curricula and opportunities (Renzulli & de Wet, in press). & Karplus, 1962; Bybee, 1997; Kolb, should be relevant to their experiences This delineation of Type III enrich- 1984), but all suggest that instruction and their lives; have a product focus; ment activities has had a great impact can be sequenced into a series of teach- provide opportunities for them to apply on the field of gifted education in that ing or learning stages or phases. For and extend what they have learned to it provides a rationale for and describes a review of the history of the learn- the solving of problems, addressing of the means whereby teachers can men- ing cycle, see Lawson, Abraham, and issues, and creating of products that are tor students in self-selected areas of Renner (1989) and Lawson (1995). purposeful and meaningful to them; interest. Students assume the role of Kolb’s four-part learning cycle has and allow, indeed require, students to a firsthand inquirer, seeking to answer its roots in the theories of Dewey and use the concepts, language, materials, questions and provide solutions for Piaget, and is based on the idea that and methodologies of professionals in problematic situations in their schools, learning begins with concrete experi- the field (Tomlinson, 2005). neighborhoods, and communities. ence. For learning to be complete, the A useful framework for providing One of the benefits of students engag- learner must progress through four such opportunities to students has ing in Type III activities is the collateral phases of action (Kolb, 1984): con- been described by Renzulli (1976). learning that takes place—learning of crete experience, reflective observation, The Enrichment Triad Model proposes advanced content and skills necessary abstract hypotheses, and active testing. that teachers and students engage in to complete these projects that are of Zull (2002) suggested that each phase three types of enrichment teaching great interest to the student. This kind of Kolb’s learning cycle takes place in and learning instead of traditional of learning might not occur in the gen- a particular physical structure in the academic training for students and eral classroom and in general curricu- brain. Furthermore, he argues that the traditional teaching by teachers. Type lum. The Enrichment Triad Model has learning cycle is complete only when we I enrichment consists of exploratory been incorporated into the Schoolwide have tested, or acted upon, our ideas. activities on a variety of topics, areas Enrichment Model (Renzulli & Reis, Ideas without action remain lifeless and of interest, and fields of study that stu- 1997) and has become the framework motionless until they are tested. dents may not experience in the regular for teaching in many schools. (A 18 fall 2009 • vol 32, no 4 Ecological Stewardship research base detailing the effective- being damaged by coastal land loss and ness of the Enrichment Triad Model storms (Roth’s Awareness and Concern as well as the Schoolwide Enrichment Phases, as well as Renzulli’s Type I Model is available at http://www. enrichment). gifted.uconn.edu/sem/semresearch. After a scientist’s visit to Mona html). This model will be used to Herbert’s school in New Orleans, she analyze three ecological stewardship debriefed students to gauge interest programs described in this paper, and in pursuing the goals of the Coastal can provide a framework for creating Roots Program. Not surprisingly, her similar projects across the country. students overwhelmingly chose to par- ticipate in the Coastal Roots Program Figure 1. Students at an elementary The Coastal Roots based at their school (see Figure 1). school digging trenches to install Wetlands in Louisiana have a num- Program—Preserving their school’s plant nursery. ber of important functions, such as a Coastline flood mitigation, storm buffer, and Photo by Pam Blanchard, LSU. juvenile fish habitat. Teachers connect In the Coastal Roots Program, the hands-on stewardship activities in designed by Louisiana State University the Coastal Roots Program to appropri- (LSU) professor Pamela Blanchard ate classroom lessons so that students (2007), students from more than are able to put their new knowledge 25 schools across south Louisiana into action through a meaningful out- grow native seedlings in tree nurser- door learning experience. ies located on their school grounds. This program was designed to engage Coastal Roots is important to me teachers and students in critical coastal because my house flooded from environmental issues such as ecologi- Hurricane Katrina. I hope the cal stewardship, wetlands functions/ Coastal Roots Program will help values, wetland loss, habitat restora- protect us in future storms or tion, and conservation, while at the hurricanes. (Caitlin Leiva, fifth Figure 2. Middle school same time teaching basic geologic and grade) students planting marsh grass horticulture concepts and skills. The on a hurricane protection purpose of Coastal Roots is to provide I feel that the CR program will levee near Montegut, LA. a program based upon active learning stop my home from flooding about coastal erosion and restoration again during a hurricane. I also Photo by David Bourgeois, LSU AgCenter/Louisiana Sea Grant College Program. issues in Louisiana. Fourth-grade feel that if the wetlands disap- participant Karen Wang stated that pear there will be less delicious These students are learning how to “Coastal Roots is an educational and seafood for the locals to enjoy. germinate and grow seedlings that can fun program. Every 45 minutes one (Mason Varuso, fourth grade) help restore the damaged ecosystems football field of wetlands is lost. I feel (Roth’s Knowledge Phase and Renzulli’s really good about planting trees at a Students in the program planted national park where lots of people will their restoration seeds in “can yards” Type II enrichment), and how to plant come to visit.” during the early spring and tended their seedlings in an area in need of Representatives of the Coastal Roots their seedlings over the next 9 months habitat restoration (Roth’s Action phase Program disseminate information about as they grew in the school nurseries. and Renzulli’s Type III activities). They the program to schools in a variety of The following fall, students trans- come to understand effective ways to ways, including visiting schools to ported their seedlings and planted sustain marsh habitats, maintain habitat describe the ecological issues involved them at a partner restoration site that diversity, and provide food for coastal (Type I enrichment). Through this proj- had been established to protect the animals and birds. This type of steward- ect, elementary, middle, and secondary fragile wetlands and forests of south ship project is a year-round, long-term continued on page ?? students learn about how ecosystems are Louisiana (see Figure 2). project, and the type of project that is gifted child today 19 Ecological Stewardship in which they chose to participate. One of the things that coastal Important hallmarks of Type III proj- residents learned after the recent hur- ects were students pursuing questions ricanes was that our coastal forests of particular interest and concern to provided an important wind break to them personally, engaging in activities the hurricane-force winds that swept that they personally found stimulating, over southern Louisiana. Students in and creating a product or service of the LSU Coastal Roots Program are their own choosing. The Coastal Roots helping to replant some of the coastal Program allowed students to engage in forests that were severely damaged dur- a variety of activities and produce dif- ing the storms. ferent end products. Students involved in this project began their participation Hurricanes such as Katrina, from the first day by helping install Gustav, and Rita affected New the plant nurseries (see Figure 1). At Orleans with devastating force. school, they planted the seeds and If we keep planting saplings, they Figure 3. Tree protectors tended the seedlings. will grow into towering trees that decorated by students. will act as our first line of defense Coastal Roots is important not from these natural disasters. My Photo by Deborah Schultz, Barataria-Terrebonne only for the effect it has on the class and I have been learning National Estuary Program. environment but also the impact about erosion and hurricanes’ on the children who participate effects on us. It was actually fun recognized by environmental educators in it. Planting trees made me to go out and be stewards by as the way to make a real difference in feel like I, at a young age, can planting over 700 trees to help students’ thinking and actions (Barnett do something about our envi- Louisiana. (Andrew Souther, et al., 2006; Basile & White, 2000). ronment and how to save it. It fourth grade) When students were asked to reflect on feels awesome to make an impact their experiences, the impact on their on our environment. (Shelby Paddlefish Incubators thinking was clear: Dwyer, fifth grade) to Preserve a Species Coastal Roots is important The Coastal Roots Program also because it is saving our coastline provided the opportunity for out- A second example of environmen- and that is helping to save the of-state students to partner with a tal stewardship is the Native Fish in world, one tree at a time. To me, Louisiana school by conducting penny the Classroom Project supported by Coastal Roots isn’t just a school drives to raise funds to purchase tree the Louisiana Department of Wildlife project; it is an opportunity to protectors (see Figure 3). and Fisheries (Capello, Somers, Bihm, raise awareness for Louisiana’s These slim tree protectors are & Smith, 2005). In this project, stu- coast and every little piece helps. needed to protect young seedlings dents at schools in central Louisiana (Sarah Rogers, fifth grade) from the appetite of hungry nutria are helping to restore populations of (large semiaquatic rodents native paddlefish, a threatened species living The CR program challenged us to the area). Children from a New in the sluggish bayous and streams mentally where we learned about York school, who wished to become that cross the coastal plain of south the wetlands and challenged us involved with children in Louisiana, Louisiana (Kolb’s Action stage and physically where we had to a lot decorated the tree protectors with per- Renzulli’s Type III). of digging and physical work. manent markers and shipped them to a In the past, paddlefish have been We did this to help the world Coastal Roots school to use when they harvested for their eggs, which are con- be better little by little. (James install seedlings at the restoration site. sidered “American caviar.” The species Konen, fourth grade) The drawings on the tree protectors is threatened due to overharvesting and often showed students’ understanding the disruption of their nesting grounds This type of project also provided of the problem and solutions to coastal during the hurricanes. Children at students with a variety of activities land loss in Louisiana. schools in central Louisiana near 20 fall 2009 • vol 32, no 4 Ecological Stewardship Figure 4. Thomas Blanchard Figure 5. Thomas Blanchard checking wood duck eggs showing an elementary in a nest box he maintains in the Atchafalaya Basin. student how to put sawdust into a wood duck Photo by Pam Blanchard, LSU. box that he made. Photo by Pam Blanchard, LSU. the last 100 years, natural predators, snakes from climbing up the pole to the harvesting of trees, and increasing get to the nest in the box. farmland acreage have significantly Maureen Mabile, a pre-K teacher in Alexandria and Ville Platte, with the reduced the number of wood ducks in Pierre Part, LA, incorporated the wood help of Louisiana Department of southern Louisiana’s Atchafalaya Basin. duck nesting project into her unit on Wildlife and Fisheries agent Angela Wood ducks, which migrate more than forest animals. She invited local resident Capello, are raising paddlefish in their and avid hunter Thomas Blanchard, Sr. 500 miles through Louisiana, normally classrooms. Each spring, students are to help children learn about wood duck lay their eggs in naturally occurring given harvested paddlefish eggs, which nesting habits, their predators, and are large enough to be seen with the holes in trees. Unfortunately, preda- current efforts to sustain their popula- naked eye. Students feed and maintain tors, including raccoons, snakes, and tions in the Atchafalaya Basin (Roth’s the fish in circulating system aquari- humans, find wood duck eggs an easy Awareness and Concern phases and ums in the classroom until they are meal. This pressure on successful egg Renzulli’s Type I). He brought a wood finger length in size. Then the fish are hatching has reduced the number of duck caller, male and female wood taken back to the Booker Fowler Fish wood ducks in the Atchafalaya ecosys- duck decoys, and a wood duck box he Hatchery, where they finish growing tem to dangerously low levels. built. He showed a homemade video of and are eventually released by Wildlife In response to this problem, the baby wood ducks flying out of the box and Fisheries biologists into local Louisiana Department of Wildlife and (Roth’s Knowledge phase). Ms. Mabile streams to help sustain the paddlefish Fisheries, as well as many environmen- let her students show what they had populations in the region (Capello et tally concerned hunters, have built and learned through their drawing and art al., 2005). deployed wood duck boxes through- projects, dictation, and journal writing out the Atchafalaya Basin and most in the various learning centers around Wood Duck Boxes to of southern Louisiana to help sustain the classroom (Roth’s Action phase; see Preserve a Habitat the wood duck population. The wood Figures 4 and 5). duck boxes are built of cypress or red An appropriate extension of this A third example of appropriate eco- cedar and are attached to a tall pipe. lesson that would provide students logical stewardship for young children The boxes usually have a predator col- the opportunity to participate in continued on page ?? is the wood duck nesting project. Over lar attached to prevent raccoons and stewardship themselves (Renzulli’s gifted child today 21 Ecological Stewardship Type III activities) might be complete their project. Materials . . . even very to have students help build or might be donated by community decorate a wood duck box in groups concerned with the same one of the learning centers in young children issue, or the professional orga- their classroom. They could nization partnering with classes arrange the wood shavings involved in the project. Consider are able to in the box and help install it writing a grant for funding the on their school grounds. A project. parent might film the instal- engage in lation of boxes the students Step 5: Establish Roles made as they are placed in and Responsibilities meaningful the Atchafalaya Basin. This project demonstrates that Engage students in the plan- even very young children are and helpful ning process to establish material able to engage in meaningful and people needs and a time- and helpful stewardship proj- line for the project. Help them stewardship ects. Abdi, Taylor, and Freilich delineate responsibilities or jobs (1998) provided more ideas needed to complete the project for such science projects suit- projects. and allow them to choose which able for young children. jobs and responsibilities they might wish to assume. community for possible ecological A Framework for issues. Step 6: Help Students Creating Ecological Master the Skills Needed Stewardship Projects Step 2: Help Students Become Informed in Your School Ask your professional partners to provide the how-to training in skills Utilize resources to provide students Teachers can create opportunities students will require to successfully with information according to Roth’s for their students anywhere in the complete their project (Type II train- Awareness phase and Renzulli’s Type I country to engage in ecological stew- ing). These skills should approximate enrichment. ardship projects using the framework the skills professionals in the field described below. would use. Step 3: Debrief Students Step 1: Find Appropriate Projects Step 7: Help Students After completion of Type I expe- Carry Out the Project Use local newspapers and govern- riences, hold discussions to identify mental agency literature, as well as those students who exhibit Roth’s This meets Roth’s Action stage and, if community resources, to identify eco- Concern phase, or what Renzulli students are engaged in pursuing a part logical threats and endangered animals (1976) refers to as “excitement and in the project based on their individual and/or habitats in your area. Each state interest in the project” (p. 16). interest and concern, it also conforms has a wildlife or natural resources to Renzulli’s Type III activities. department that would be happy to Step 4: Establish a invite students to partner with it in its Partnership With Experts Step 8: Find Audiences preservation and stewardship efforts. for Student Products An ecological stewardship project Both professionals and volunteers does not have to part of a statewide or who are interested in the topic or Be sure to celebrate and advertise national program. It can be as simple field of study can provide knowledge, the students’ progress at various appro- as replanting and preserving indig- resources, and opportunity support for priate times. This will meet two goals: enous plants on the school grounds. the project. They can help to procure It offers encouragement to students Investigate your schoolyard and local the materials students will need to to remain engaged, and it provides 22 fall 2009 • vol 32, no 4 Ecological Stewardship an authentic, real-world audience for dren. Dimensions of Early Childhood, McHardy, R. (2008). Hurricane Katrina’s students’ work. The element of authen- 26(3–4), 31–36. impact on gifted programs in Louisi- ticity in language, materials, methodol- Atkin, J. M., & Karplus, R. (1962). ana, 2005–2007. Journal for the Edu- ogy, and audience is an essential part of Discovery or invention? The Science cation of Children Placed at Risk, 13, Teacher, 29(5), 45–51. effective curriculum for gifted students 259–272. Barnett, M., Lord, C., Strauss, E., Rosca, (Renzulli & de Wet, in press; Renzulli, Renzulli, J. S. (1976). The enrichment C., Langford, H., Chavez, D., et al. Leppien, & Hays, 2000; Tomlinson, triad model: A guide for developing (2006). Using the urban environment 2005). defensible programs for the gifted and to engage youths in urban ecology field Gifted students often display talented. Gifted Child Quarterly, 20, studies. The Journal of Environmental intense awareness and concern for their Education, 37(2), 3–11. 303–326. environment. When natural or man- Basile, C., & White, C. (2000). Respecting Renzulli, J. S., & de Wet, C. F. (in press). made disasters occur, their very real living things: Environmental literacy Developing creative productivity in young people through the pursuit of need to take productive action can be for young children. Early Childhood stymied by adults’ needs to move chil- Education Journal, 28(1), 57–61. ideal acts of learning. In R. Beghetto dren out of the way or adult percep- Blanchard, P. B. (2007). Coastal Roots: & J. Kaufman (Eds.), Nurturing creativ- tions that children will not be able to A pre-college plant-based steward- ity in the classroom. West Nyack, NY: ship program to connect students with Cambridge University Press. make substantial impacts on complex coastal issues. Plant Science Bulletin, 53, Renzulli, J. S., Leppien, J. H., & Hays, T. environmental problems. We might 138–146. S. (2000). The multiple menu model: A even suggest that oft-heard statements Burks, B. S., Jensen, D. W., & Terman, L. practical guide for developing differenti- about the resilience among children M. (1930). The promise of youth: Follow- ated curriculum. Mansfield Center, CT: who experience disasters firsthand up studies of a thousand gifted children: Creative Learning Press. could be an unfounded assumption as Genetic studies of genius, Vol. 3. Stan- Renzulli, J. S., & Reis, S. M. (1997). The well. Programs such as Coastal Roots ford, CA: Stanford University Press. schoolwide enrichment model: A how-to and others can be vehicles for coming Bybee, R. W. (1997). Achieving scientific guide for educational excellence (2nd to terms with what has happened in a literacy: From purposes to practices. Ports- ed.). Mansfield Center, CT: Creative disaster such as a hurricane. mouth, NH: Heinemann. Learning Press. By providing opportunities for these Capello, A., Somers, R., Bihm, C., & Roth, C. E. (1992). Environmental literacy: students to be of service in an authen- Smith, N. (2005). Native fish in the Its roots, evolution, and directions in the classroom: Teacher guide. Baton Rouge: tic and meaningful way, teachers can Louisiana Sea Grant College Program. 1990s. Columbus, OH: Education be of great help in the development Dabrowski, K., & Piechowski, M. M. Resources Information Center/Center of their students’ active participation (1977). Theory of levels of emotional for Science, Mathematics and Environ- in crucial issues of the day, as well as development (Vols. 1–2). Oceanside, mental Education. the development of strong affective NY: Dabor. Tomlinson, C. A. (2005). Quality cur- skills. Most importantly, these types of Hollingworth, L. S. (1926). Gifted chil- riculum and instruction for highly opportunities suffuse gifted students in dren: Their nature and nurture. New able students. Theory Into Practice, 44, the immediacy of positive citizenship York: Macmillan. 160–166. and stewardship, regardless of their Kolb, D. (1984). Experiential learning: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, ages or circumstances. Or, as fourth Experience as the source of learning and Environmental Stewardship Staff Com- grader Dawson Eiserloh noted, “You development. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: mittee. (2005). Everyday choices: Oppor- see the stats on the news about what Prentice Hall. tunities for environmental stewardship: Lawson, A. E. (1995). Science teaching and we need to do to save our wetlands. Technical report. Retrieved from http:// the development of thinking. Belmont, Now, we need to stop watching and epa.gov/innovation/pdf/techrpt.pdf CA: Wadsworth. start doing.” GCT Worrell, R., & Appleby, M. C. (2000). Lawson, A. E., Abraham, M. R., & Renner, Stewardship of natural resources: Def- J. W. (1989). A theory of instruction: References Using the learning cycle to teach science inition, ethical and practical aspects. concepts and thinking skills. Unpub- Journal of Agricultural and Environ- Abdi, S. W., Taylor, S. I., & Freilich, M. lished manuscript, National Associa- mental Ethics, 12, 263–277. B. (1998). Science activities for teachers tion for Research in Science Teaching, Zull, J. E. (2002). The art of changing the continued on page ?? and families to explore with young chil- Kansas State University, Manhattan. brain. Sterling, VA: Stylus. gifted child today 23