All materials in this journal subject to copyright by the American Library Association may be used for the noncommercial purpose of scientific or educational advancement granted by Sections 107 and 108 of the Copyright Revision Act of 1976. Address ARTICLE usage requests to the ALA Office of Rights and Permissions. School Librarians and Open Educational Resources Aid and Implement Common Core Instructional Content in the Classroom Krista Welz [email protected] 62 Knowledge Quest | Power to the Pupil: Student Agency in the School Library All materials in this journal subject to copyright by the American Library Association may be used for the noncommercial purpose of scientific or educational advancement granted by Sections 107 and 108 of the Copyright Revision Act of 1976. Address usage requests to the ALA Office of Rights and Permissions. By 2013 a majority of states adaptation by a community of users 2011 states began considering the adopted the Common Core for noncommercial purposes. These standards. By 2013 forty-five states State Standards (CCSS) in English educational resources reside in had implemented the CCSS. These Language Arts and Mathematics the public domain on the Internet new standards meant directing in a response that addressed the and include textbooks, videos, students away from routine memori- declining educational achievements podcasts, and any other learning- zation toward higher-order critical of students in the United States. A related materials such as teachers’ thinking (Burks et al. 2015). major challenge to Common Core guides, lesson plan recreations, implementation is the shortage of experiments, demonstrations, and Although the CCSS were controver- new and authentic standard-aligned curricula (Butcher 2015). Teachers sial among both teachers and parents, material (William and Flora Hewlett and students have access to these when the standards were adopted Foundation 2015). As districts face resources without the obligation to teachers were still expected to recreate the necessity of purchasing new pay royalties or license fees, and, as their own curriculum, lesson plans, instructional materials aligned a result, education transformation and benchmark assessments—in with the CCSS, open educational reaches the classroom with a lower many cases, from scratch. A survey resources (OERs) have become cost than if commercially produced conducted in 2016 by the Center for crucial. The OER has become a materials are used. Education Policy Research at Harvard central model for the develop- University reported that 80 percent ment and dissemination of free Creative Commons licenses permit of ELA teachers and 72 percent of online content. Digital libraries of the sharing of resources through mathematics teachers use curricular OERs have increased significantly, free legal tools, and serve an active materials that they or their coworkers providing schools and teachers role in the open-access movement. at their school created (Kane et al. with standards-based materials Creative Commons licenses are 2016). Teachers also reported seeking for developing CCSS-aligned not substitutes for copyrights. a vast array of online sources for their curriculum (Waters 2013). The licenses work alongside the materials. Not only did 45 percent copyright and allow producers to of school districts report significant Open Educational Resources change the copyright terms to best problems locating standard-aligned Defined fit users’ needs (Sharma 2013). textbooks and material, but the standards required lessons that were The theory of OERs was initially Adapting and Implementing different from what most teachers defined at the 2002 UNESCO the CCSS were accustomed to teaching. Fur- Forum on the Impact of Open thermore, fewer than 50 percent of The CCSS are relatively new in Courseware for Higher Education the school districts that adopted the education. In 2009 state leaders in Developing Countries (Armellini CCSS offered professional develop- encouraged creation of the CCSS and Nie 2013). The OER concept ment workshops that demonstrated as real-world learning goals for is defined as technology-enabled aligning the CCSS with classroom the purpose of developing college- open provision of educational instruction and student assessment (C. and career-ready students. By resources for consultation, use, and Thompson 2015). Volume 45, No. 4 | March/April 2017 63 All materials in this journal subject to copyright by the American Library Association may be used for the noncommercial purpose of scientific or educational advancement granted by Sections 107 and 108 of the Copyright Revision Act of 1976. Address usage requests to the ALA Office of Rights and Permissions. OER Implementation OERs every week. Teachers can can spend less time discovering locate materials through special- classroom materials and additional Adoption of the CCSS can be ized OER search engines such as time with their students. regarded as the perfect storm OER Commons. (See the sidebar for (Johnson 2014). It brought a the URL of this and other OER- According to Electronic Education Report change to schools by making it related resources.) OER Commons (Schools Interested 2013), schools necessary to depend on technology provides a voluminous collection are more likely to use reliable OERs in classrooms, redesign curricula, of resources aligned to the CCSS; as supplemental material rather and, more importantly, access OERs the collection includes lesson plans, than as a first source for Common in an effort to align lessons with primary sources, and assessments Core curricula. Teachers have standards. Rather than relying on (Ash 2012). Teachers can also access expressed their concern about a lack textbooks, teachers are obliged to CCSS-aligned exercises and courses of sufficient professional develop- assess and access OERs. The con- for students from Khan Academy, ment training within the area of tinuation of the development and use CK–12 materials to support standards-based content. Providing enhancement of classroom curricula students’ mastering of science more professional development by teachers is now regarded as a and math concepts, incorporate workshops for teachers would help process (Cavanagh 2013). videos from PBS Learning Media, them recognize how OERs can be and share lesson plans with other used as the main sources in lesson According to Liana Heitin (2015), educators on websites such as Share plans (Piehler 2016). fewer than 33 percent of educators My Lesson. have access to premium CCSS- School Librarians and OERs aligned textbooks. In general, Other curated and standards- standards-aligned commercial aligned OER sources popular School librarians provide vital content is not being widely among teachers are Curriki, Better services to their school. These produced. For a variety of reasons, Lesson, Gooru, EngageNY, and services include selecting print some states are abandoning the K–12 OER Collaborative (Johnson and digital resources, organizing CCSS. The fear that more states 2014). OpenEd is one of the world’s material, and instructing both might abandon the CCSS has caused largest K–12 standards-aligned students and teachers on appropri- publishers to not fully invest in open educational resources library. ate technology tools to help augment developing CCSS-aligned textbooks During a U.S. Department of curriculum units. School librarians (William and Flora Hewlett Education #GoOpen Exchange have extensive experience in teaching Foundation 2015). Moreover, the event in February 2016, OpenEd both students and teachers how to Council of Great City Schools publicized the fact that Microsoft identify credible and authoritative conducted a survey and reported had plans to publish a free OpenEd online sources and sorting through that a majority of teachers are Open Education Search App free and premium information, such using instructional materials they (OpenEd 2016). In addition, the as databases, informational text, developed on their own. Use of U.S. Department of Education reference materials, and multimedia. OERs could facilitate a collabora- has included OERs in its 2016 Therefore, school librarians tive effort in the development of National Education Technology are transformational leaders in CCSS-compliant curricula among Plan. The U.S. Department of supporting OER initiatives in school school districts. The content that Education’s #GoOpen campaign districts and selecting OERs appro- OERs provide is well-suited to target encourages states, school districts, priate for the curriculum (Kompar the lack of commercially produced and educators to use openly licensed 2016). standards-aligned materials (C. educational materials to transform When district officials decree that Thompson 2015). teaching and learning. OERs must be used in their schools, OER Extent and Availability OERs are free to use and remix for a team of educators usually forms a committee to help identify and select personal use, permitting teachers As more school districts are using appropriate OERs. School librarians to easily differentiate instructional free online resources to enhance should join these committees and material for students (Ash 2012). classroom lessons and textbooks, provide expertise in selecting quality Schools can form small groups of the extent and availability of OERs, helping to organize them teachers to design core sets of OER OERs are continuously developing into appropriate curriculum units, materials for specific grade levels. (Terrell 2016). Digital libraries and making sure the OERs align As a result, individual teachers are adding to the collection of with the CCSS. Many educators 64 Knowledge Quest | Power to the Pupil: Student Agency in the School Library All materials in this journal subject to copyright by the American Library Association may be used for the noncommercial purpose of scientific or educational advancement granted by Sections 107 and 108 of the Copyright Revision Act of 1976. Address usage requests to the ALA Office of Rights and Permissions. may be unfamiliar with copyright The Grandview (WA) School District and Creative Commons, as well as changed their entire Pre-K–10 math Following the lead of unaccustomed to using technology and English Language Arts curricula to deliver content. School librarians by gathering and coordinating OERs the U.S. Department can support their schools’ classroom from a variety of sources (Cavanagh teachers by providing professional 2015b). of Education, the policy development on how to access and share OERs, such as through Freeport (ME) Middle School should require that any Google Classroom or Edmodo. transformed its eighth-grade math Many OERs include interactive curriculum into a CCSS-aligned OERs created through the features and assessments, such as program. The program implements CK–12’s PLIX (Play-Learn-Inter- an array of OERs, allowing students expenditure of public funds act-Explore) interactive exercises. to investigate math and learn sta- School librarians can help other tistical relationships. The program should have open licenses. educators organize and share their has proven to be effective, and more OER material in an easily accessible, than 90 percent of the school’s CCSS-aligned structure—whether eighth-graders passed the annual and academic improvement. In 2015 for a single lesson, video tutorial, math placement exam (Waters 2013). T. J. Bliss, a chief program executive presentation, or full course. All for the William and Flora Hewlett Utah’s State Office of Education has of these efforts can help promote a Foundation, identified the recent been compiling CCSS textbooks blended-learning classroom envi- recognition OERs have received constructed entirely of OERs (Welz ronment as students engage with as a notable indicator that OERs 2016). authentic OERs. are becoming essential to resolving In these and other states, use of strategic problems in education. Early Adopters of OERs OERs has resulted from educational Further, Bliss pointed out that the policy changes and resulted in importance of the availability of Since educators in many school the creation of a set of standards- OERs has finally been acknowledged districts are under pressure as they aligned rubrics to help educators by policymakers at the national level search for CCSS-aligned materials, assess OERs’ quality (Ash 2012). (Cavanagh 2016). an increasing number of teachers and policymakers are finding OERs OER Policies Nearly every state will develop a attractive. Such free online, flexible, local control policy for the adoption and sharable instructional content In December 2015 use of OERs and implementation of OER. offers advantages that can help received a major boost from a Guiding teachers and administra- schools save money on expensive federal law signed by President tors in explaining the advantages, textbooks. Twenty-six states are Barack Obama. The OER concept exploring the strategies, and promoting open OERs in some won bipartisan support on Capitol emphasizing quality examples of form, and eighteen states have taken Hill during the drafting of the OERs for school districts should be steps to share them with districts Every Student Succeeds Act, P.L. considered to be part of the control (Cavanagh 2015a). 114-95. ESSA now allows states policy. Ideally, in states that have and local education agencies to adopted the CCSS, school districts K–12 school districts in many states guide block grant money dedicated will employ OERs as a strategy for have set out on an ambitious new to technology toward OERs. In developing content that will support path in using OERs. For example, addition, in October 2016 the education of college- and career- Bethel (WA) School District Obama administration proposed a students (Voss 2015). exchanged its commercial K–5 new regulation that would require math curriculum for OERs created Additionally, following the lead of that any new intellectual property by EngageNY. Part of the New the U.S. Department of Education, developed with grant funds from York State Education Department, the policy should require that any the U.S. Department of Education EngageNY’s CCSS-aligned OERs created through the expen- be made available with an open English and math resources have diture of public funds should license. ESSA’s Student Support been downloaded twenty million have open licenses. Teaching and and Academic Enrichment Grants times by various school districts learning resources that reside in the (Title IV-Part A) proclaim OERs as in the United States and overseas public domain or have been released being support for student assistance (Cavanagh 2015c). Volume 45, No. 4 | March/April 2017 65 All materials in this journal subject to copyright by the American Library Association may be used for the noncommercial purpose of scientific or educational advancement granted by Sections 107 and 108 of the Copyright Revision Act of 1976. Address usage requests to the ALA Office of Rights and Permissions. under an intellectual property Common Core Open Educational Resources Websites license that permits their free use and repurposing by others can Achieve the Core: ELA/ http://achievethecore.org/category/411/ela-literacy- and should be modified to provide Literacy Lessons [and lessons further support for students Assessments] with special needs. Furthermore, Achieve the Core: http://achievethecore.org/category/854/ school districts should include Mathematics Lessons [and mathematics-lessons OERs in their professional devel- Assessments] opment activities (Voss 2015). Annenberg Learner http://www.learner.org OER Barriers Better Lesson http://betterlesson.com/common_core_math CK–12 http://www.ck12.org/teacher Because OERs are digital, teachers Curriki http://www.curriki.org and students cannot access them without computers, tablets, or Digital Public Library of https://dp.la smart mobile devices (Waters America 2013). Lack of funding and lack of Edcite https://www.edcite.com administrative support, along with EDSITEment https://edsitement.neh.gov/ a lack of commitment to develop- Edutopia: Open Educational ment and use of OERs, are also https://www.edutopia.org/open-educational- Resources (OER): Resource barriers to the implementation resources-guide Roundup of OER use in school districts (Johnson et al. 2014). An easy- EngageNY https://www.engageny.org to-use OER platform is needed #GoOpen http://tech.ed.gov/open/districts so teachers can easily search and Gooru http://www.gooru.org/welcome retrieve content (G. Thompson Great Minds https://greatminds.org 2016). HippoCampus http://www.hippocampus.org With the onset of the OER iBerry http://iberry.com movement, the increased IOER (Illinois Open popularity of digitally delivered http://ioer.ilsharedlearning.org Educational Resources) content may present commercial publishers with hardships because Learning Registry http://learningregistry.org of the decreasing demand for Khan Academy https://www.khanacademy.org conventional hardbound materials. Learning Registry http://learningregistry.org/educators Because school districts desire inexpensive, flexible instruc- Lesson Planet http://www.lessonplanet.com/state-standards tional content, some publishers Merlot II https://www.merlot.org/merlot/materials.htm are adapting and launching their OER Commons https://www.oercommons.org/oer own open resources. For example, Open Culture http://www.openculture.com Pearson designed an OER platform called Project Blue Sky OpenEd https://www.opened.com/search that permits users to explore post- OpenStax https://openstax.org secondary materials that include Orange Grove https://www.floridashines.org/orange-grove textbooks, lesson plans, and http://www.pbslearningmedia.org/about/products/ videos—both OERs and Pearson- PBS Learning Media teachers developed (Cavanagh 2013). http://powermylearning.org/education/learning/ PowerMyLearning Educators understand the benefits educational-games-activities of OERs but have realized that Share My Lesson https://sharemylesson.com using OERs requires sufficient Smithsonian Learning Lab https://learninglab.si.edu time for searching and assessing materials (G. Thompson 2016). In UnboundEd https://www.unbounded.org 2016 the Babson Survey Research Virtual Library of http://smago.coe.uga.edu/VirtualLibrary/index.html Group (2016) published the results Conceptual Units 66 Knowledge Quest | Power to the Pupil: Student Agency in the School Library All materials in this journal subject to copyright by the American Library Association may be used for the noncommercial purpose of scientific or educational advancement granted by Sections 107 and 108 of the Copyright Revision Act of 1976. Address usage requests to the ALA Office of Rights and Permissions. of a survey of over three thousand schools and the demands for per- and their skills in supporting school faculty members regarding sonalized instructional content in cross-curricular active learning, the OER selection process. Faculty classrooms (Cavanagh 2013). strengthening literacy and critical- awareness of OERs was found to thinking skills, and developing Many educators may view use have increased 25 percent over higher-order question sets that of OERs as a new trend that has the previous school year. However, align to the Common Core State emerged in various school districts, the study also reflected educators’ Standards. The use of OERs is especially those OERs that are concerns about time, effort, and transforming education by making CCSS-aligned. However, OERs evaluation of the materials—all of free, readily available content certainly aren’t new to education. which survey participants regarded obtainable by educators. These types Many educators have been using as substantial barriers (Allen and of materials will help school districts these types of materials since the Seaman 2016). create opportunities for educators late 1990s (Godwin 2016). Inter- to collaborate at revolutionary OER Evaluation estingly, there has been increased levels and share/remix high-quality interest in open education within resources that are designed by Educators can evaluate whether the last few years because of high— themselves and their colleagues. OERs are aligned with the CCSS and rising—costs of textbooks and Recognition of the school librar- by using rubrics and an evaluation the lack of commercially produced ian’s expertise is required for the tool designed by OER Commons CCSS-aligned material. successful curation of OER content and Achieve, Inc. (Waters 2013). and of CCSS-aligned material in all Achieve’s EQuIP (Educators School librarians are experienced forms. School librarians are at the Evaluating the Quality of Instruc- evaluators and curators of content, center of success for OER curation tional Products) rubrics determine and, therefore, valuable assets in and Future Ready students, and specific units that are CCSS- school districts adopting OERs. librarians are leaders in the digital aligned. The Student Achievement School librarians also have the skills transformation of learning. Partners’ Instructional Materials to conduct professional development Evaluation Tool (IMET) can be for colleagues facing the sometimes- used to assess materials that are daunting task of integrating OERs Krista Welz is library currently in use and aid in selecting into their lesson plans. additional CCSS-aligned material media specialist at North School librarians can be at the (Piehler 2016). These tools measure Bergen School District forefront of the increasingly OERs based on their technologi- in North Bergen, New popular Future Ready #GoOpen cal interactivity and the quality of movement. School librarians Jersey. She is currently a instructional assignments and practice exercises. School districts, can promote OER openness to doctoral student in the Educational Technology their schools’ classroom teachers nonetheless, should implement Leadership Program at New Jersey City and administrators, advocate their own final analysis to assure University. She specializes in technology to selection committees, help the quality and appropriateness of fellow-educators review openly integration in schools and libraries. She is a specific OERs for classroom use (Butcher 2015). licensed works, and focus profes- member of AASL. She has been reviewing books sional development on currently and apps for School Library Journal since Conclusion available OERs. Certainly, 2010. She was named North Bergen High librarians’ curation of #GoOpen While school districts struggle to resources can help school districts School Educational Services Professional of locate materials that align to the discover quality OERs. Improving the Year for 2016–2017. She also serves as CCSS, the educational market will access and the use of learning an EdTPA Performance Assessment Consultant become a blend of commercial resources lies at the heart of school for the New Jersey City University College of and open materials. Use of OERs librarians’ transformational endows educators with many leadership skills. They can and Education. She is co-founder of Edcamp Urban options and, at the same time, must lead beyond their libraries and is a Google for Education Certified Trainer. addresses their professional- and be willing to commit to the She is a creator and moderator of the bi- ism in selecting the best overall OER movement. monthly #NJLibChat Twitter Chat. She can be instructional materials. The rise in popularity of OERs demonstrates School districts must recognize followed on Twitter @kristawelz or her website the growing status of technology in the school librarians’ expertise at <www.kristawelz.com>. Volume 45, No. 4 | March/April 2017 67 All materials in this journal subject to copyright by the American Library Association may be used for the noncommercial purpose of scientific or educational advancement granted by Sections 107 and 108 of the Copyright Revision Act of 1976. Address usage requests to the ALA Office of Rights and Permissions. Works Cited: Allen, I. Elaine, and Jeff Seaman. ———. 2015c. “Teachers, District Devote Piehler, Chris. 2016. “OER for 2016. Opening the Textbook: Time to Open-Resource Transition” Common Core.” THE Journal 43 (2): Educational Resources in U.S. Higher (June 10). <www.edweek.org/ew/ 24–25. Education, 2015–16. Babson articles/2015/06/11/teachers-district- Survey Research Group. <www. devote-time-to-open-resource- “Schools Interested in OER for onlinelearningsurvey.com/reports/ transition.html> (accessed December Supplemental Resources.” 2013. openingthetextbook2016.pdf> 14, 2016). Electronic Education Report 20 (20): 1–7. (accessed January 2, 2017). ———. 2016. “Open Education Resources Armellini, Alejandro, and Ming Nie. Get Major Boost from ESSA.” Sharma, Yash Paul. 2013. “Open 2013. “Open Educational Practices Education Week (January 19). <www. Access and Creative Commons—A for Curriculum Enhancement.” edweek.org/ew/articles/2016/01/20/ New Platform for Open Educational Open Learning 28 (1): 7–20. open-education-resources-get- Resources and Scientific major-boost-from.html> (accessed Research.” Current Science 105 (11): Ash, Katie. 2012. “Open Educational December 15, 2016). 1461. Resources Surge.” Education Week’s Digital Directions 6: 42–45. Godwin, Amee Evans. 2016. “OER Terrell, Jessica. 2016. “Schools Librarians: Making Connections to Maximize Free Content.” Education Babson Survey Research Group. 2016. Open Learning and Literacy.” <www. Digest 81 (9): 48–52. “Faculty Survey Finds Awareness of newschallenge.org/challenge/how- Thompson, Carolyn. 2015. “Years Open Educational Resources Low might-libraries-serve-21st-century- into Common Core Learning But Improving.” PR Newswire (July information-needs/evaluation/ Standards, Teachers Lament Lack 26). <http://search.proquest.com/ oer-librarians-making-connections- of Materials.” US News & World Report docview/1806637186?account to-open-learning-and-literacy> (June 23). <www.usnews.com/news/ id=12793> (accessed December 14, (accessed December 14, 2016). business/articles/2015/06/23/ 2016). Heitin, Liana. 2015. “Most Math years-into-common-core-teachers- Burks, Brooke A., et al. 2015. Curricula Found to Be out of Sync lament-lack-of-materials> (accessed “Adapting to Change: Teacher with Common Core.” Education December 15, 2016). Perceptions of Implementing the Week (March 4). <www.edweek.org/ Thompson, Greg. 2016. “What’s Hot, Common Core State Standards.” ew/articles/2015/03/04/mostmath- and What’s Losing Steam in Ed Tech Education 136 (2): 253–58. curricula-found-to-be-out.html> in 2016.” THE Journal 43 (1): 24–31. Butcher, Neil. 2015. “A Basic Guide (accessed December 15, 2016). Voss, Hans. 2015. “State Policy to Open Educational Resources Johnson, Doug. 2014. “Open Recommendations for Providing (OER).” Paris, France: United Educational Resources: On the Web Educators Access to College- and Nations Educational, Scientific and Free.” Educational Leadership 71 (6): Career-Ready Open Educational and Cultural Organization. 85–86. Resources.” Washington, DC: <http://unesdoc.unesco.org/ images/0021/002158/215804e.pdf> Johnson, Larry, et al. 2014. NMC Horizon Achieve. <www.achieve.org/files/ (accessed December 15, 2016). Report: 2014 K–12 Edition. Austin, TX: OERStatePolicyRecommendations New Media Consortium. <http://cdn. 0324.pdf> (accessed December 15, Cavanagh, Sean. 2013. “Free Online nmc.org/media/2014-nmc-horizon- 2016). Content Forces Publishers to report-k12-EN.pdf> (accessed Waters, John K. 2013. “OER and the Adjust.” Education Week (July 3). December 15, 2016). Common Core.” THE Journal 40 (2): <www.edweek.org/ew/articles/201 3/07/03/36publishers.h32.html> Kane, Thomas J., et al. 2016. Teaching 34–38. (accessed December 14, 2016). Higher: Educators’ Perspectives on Common Welz, Krista. 2016. “Common Core Core Implementation. [Cambridge, and Open Educational Resources.” ———. 2015a. “Districts Put Open MA]: Harvard University, Center for <www.mackintysl.com/forums/ Educational Resources to Work.” Education Policy Research. <http:// topic/common-core-and-open- Education Week (June 10). <www. cepr.harvard.edu/files/cepr/files/ educational-resources> (accessed edweek.org/ew/articles/2015/06/11/ teaching-higher-report.pdf> (accessed January 2, 2017). districts-put-open-educational- December 15, 2016). resources-to-work.html> (accessed William and Flora Hewlett Foundation. December 14, 2016). Kompar, Fran. 2016. “The Trending 2015. Open Educational Resources: Librarian.” Teacher Librarian 44 (1): Advancing Widespread Adoption to Improve ———. 2015b. “District Makes 58–62. Instruction and Learning. <www.hewlett. Far-Reaching Change to Open Resources.” Education Week (June OpenEd. 2016. “Helping Educators org/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/ 10). <www.edweek.org/ew/ Find the Right Open Educational Open_Educational_Resources_ articles/2015/06/11/district-makes- Resources—New Help From December_2015.pdf> (accessed far-reaching-change-to-open- Microsoft and OpenEd.com.” PR December 15, 2016). resources.html> (accessed December Newswire (February 26). <www. 14, 2016). prnewswire.com/news-releases/ helping-educators-find-the-right- open-educational-resources-- new-help-from-microsoft-and- openedcom-300227157.html> (accessed December 15, 2016). 68 Knowledge Quest | Power to the Pupil: Student Agency in the School Library