http://dx.doi.org/10.19183/how.23.1.143 TheDesignofaTheme-BasedandGenre-Oriented StrategicReadingCoursetoImproveStudents’Reading ComprehensionSkillsataPublicSchoolinColombia Diseñodeuncursodeestrategiasdelecturaorientado porlainstrucciónbasadaencontenidosyelenfoquedegéneros paraelmejoramientodelashabilidadesdecomprensiónlectora delosestudiantesdeuncolegiopúblicoenColombia* FabiánPadillaDeLaCerda [email protected] UniversidaddelNorte,Barranquilla,Colombia This paper reports the process of designing and partially implementing and evaluating a content-based and genre-oriented syllabus with a group of ninth graders at a public school in Barranquilla,Colombia.Thesyllabussoughttopromotereadingstrategiesinordertoimprovelearners’ comprehensionofnaturalsciencetexts.Theresultsofthisinterventionshowthattheuseofacademic textswithlowachievers,whointurncandevelopagoodcomprehensionofdifferentkindoftexts,is possibleifthesestudentsareawareofthestructureofthetextstheyarereadingandiftheyareprovided withreadingstrategiesthatareappropriateforeachgenre. Key words: Content-based instruction, genre approach, reading comprehension, reading strategies,syllabusdesign. * Received:July20,2015.Accepted:February21,2016. Howtocitethisarticle(APA6thed.): PadillaDeLaCerda,F.(2016).Thedesignofatheme-basedandgenre-orientedstrategicreadingcourseto improve students’ reading comprehension skills at a public school in Colombia. HOW, 23(1), 49-67. http://dx.doi.org/10.19183/how.23.1.143. This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 InternationalLicense.LicenseDeedcanbeconsultedathttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/. HOWVol.23,No.1,April/September2016,ISSN0120-5927.Bogotá,Colombia.Pages:49-67 49 FabiánPadillaDeLaCerda Esteproyectomuestraelprocesodediseñoylaparcialimplementaciónyevaluacióndeunprogra- mabasadoencontenidosygénerostextualesconestudiantesdenovenogradodeunaescuelapúblicade Barranquilla,Colombia.Elplandeestudioteníacomoobjetivopromoverestrategiasdelecturaparame- jorarlacomprensióndetextosdeCienciasNaturales.Losresultadosdeestaintervenciónmuestranque esposibleutilizartextosacadémicosconestudiantesdenivelprincipiante,loscualespuedenalcanzar unamuybuenacomprensióndediversostiposdetextos,siselesdaaconocerlaestructuradeltextouti- lizadoyselesproveeconestrategiasdelecturaqueseanacordesconelgénerotextual. Palabrasclave:comprensióndelectura,diseñodeprograma,enfoquedegéneros,estrategiasde lectura,instrucciónbasadaencontenidos. Introduction TheeducationalsysteminColombiaisdividedintotwomainsectors:privateandpublic. Ontheonehand,privateschoolsareusuallywell-structuredintermsoflocations,materials, andresources.Ontheotherhand,mostpublicschoolshaveaseriesoflacksandnecessities which make them vulnerable when they are compared to private institutions. In fact, this disparity is also found in the field of English teaching since students from private schools oftenhaveagoodlevelofEnglishwhilestudentsfrompublicschoolsbarelygettoknowthe basicsafterfinishinghighschool.ThiscanbereflectedintheresultsoftheSABERtest,the national standardized examination for students finishing secondary school, where lots of public school students reach A2, the level expected for primary students according to the CommonEuropeanFrameworkofReference(CEFR). With the purpose of increasing the level of English among the students of the public sector, the Ministerio de Educación Nacional (MEN, National Ministry of Education) has implemented theProgramaNacionaldeBilingüismo(PNB, NationalBilingualProgram), which statesthatColombianstudentsshouldhaveahighlevelofEnglishandbecompetentinthe four skills of this language by the year 2019. The students of the public school where this studywascarriedoutalsofacedproblemswhenusingEnglish,especiallywhentakingeither institutional or standardized tests such as the SABER, which is basically based on reading competence. In turn, since reading represents one of the most essential means to acquire knowledgeandreadingcomprehensionisoneofthemostcommonproblemsstudentsface in secondary school, I decided to implement a research project in order to help students enhance their reading comprehension skills. The following research question guided this inquiry: How does a reading class, focused on a theme-based and genre-oriented syllabus, developstudents’readingcomprehensionskills? Thisarticledescribes theprocessofdesigning,partiallyimplementing,andevaluatinga content-based and genre-oriented syllabus that promotes reading strategies to improve learners’ reading comprehension of natural science texts. For this intervention, a needs 50 HOW TheDesignofaTheme-BasedandGenre-OrientedStrategicReadingCourse toImproveStudents’ReadingComprehensionSkillsataPublicSchoolinColombia analysis was carried out in several steps to identify initially general needs and later, more specific wants and lacks of the target students regarding the reading skills and the content areas. Data were collected through classroom observations, a reading comprehension test, andathink-aloudprotocol.Thedecisionfortheselectionofthecontentwassupportedbyan analysisoftheschoolprograms, aswellassurveys aboutstudents’preferences, interviews, and observations of content teachers’ classes. As a result, a four-unit syllabus focused on natural science topics was designed for ninth graders at a public school located in Barranquilla,Colombia. TheoreticalConsiderations Theimplementationofthisprojectwasfoundedontheconceptionofreadingasasocial, interactive,anddynamicprocess;asAlderson(2000)indicates,readingisaprocessinwhichthe reader interacts with a text. During the development of this interaction the reader not only deciphers the text, gives meaning toevery word, or gives meaning tothe whole text, but also thinksaboutwhatheorsheisreading,relatesthisnewmeaningtowhatheorshepreviouslyknew orread(schemata),andpredictswhatheorsheexpectstocome.Wallace(1992)arguesreading representsadynamicrelationship(interaction)amongthewriter,thereader,andthetextitself. Sheconceivesreadingasa“social,criticalandinterpretativeprocess”(p.4).Forher,readingis predominantly social in “the sense that readers and writers enact their roles as members of communities” (p. 9). Therefore, considering that reading is conceived as a social and active process,thisinterventionwasbasedonsocially-orientedapproachestolearningandlanguage. Vygotsky’s Sociocultural Theory According to Vygotsky (1978), learning takes place when children interact with other people and through their cooperation with others (interpersonal plane). Moreover, when childreninteract,theyalsointernalizemodelsorpatternswhicharethenindividualizedand become independent accomplishments. Likewise, this theory suggests that human higher mental functions such as rational thoughts and learning originate in social activities which takeplaceonplanesthatareexternaltotheindividual;forexample,thesocial,thehistorical, or the institutional planes (Johnson, 2003). The sociocultural theory was essential for this projectsince,asLee(2010)states,reading“isasocialinteractionalprocessrequiringactive constructionofmeaningamongreaders”(p.226).Thismeansthatreadingisnotaprocess enclosedinsidethebrain,butratheranabilitythathumanbeingscandevelopwithothers. Genre and Genre-Based Approach As any other approach to teaching, a genre approach looks for the best way to help studentslearnaforeignlanguage.Thisapproachisbasicallysupportedondifferentprinciples HOWVol.23,No.1,April/September2016,ISSN0120-5927.Bogotá,Colombia.Pages:49-67 51 FabiánPadillaDeLaCerda whosemainpillaristhetext.Consideringthatstudentswillperforminrealcontextsoutside theschool,thegenreapproachsuitsperfectlythoseteacherswhothinkoftheirstudentsas activemembersofacademic,occupational,orsocialcontextsorcommunitiesinwhichthey havetobeabletoread,write,orspeak(Hyland,2007).Theconceptofgenrefirstappeared withBakhtin(1973)andhistheoryofdialogueordialogicprinciples.Inthistheory,theauthor conceivesgenresasthewaysindividualsconceptualizetheworldandasthemeanstheyuseto refertoreality. Ontheotherhand,Derewianka(1991)explorestheconceptofgenreanddescribessix differentkindsofgenresandtheirrespectivepurposes.Firstofallnarratives,whichtellstories toentertainreaders;second,recountsthatreconstructpastexperiencesbyretellingeventsin originalsequences;inotherwords,totellwhathappened.Third,instructionsorproceduresthat showhowprocessesandeventsareachievedorhowsomethingisdone.Inthefourthplace, explanations, which tell how or why something works or happens. In the fifth place, Derewiankamentionsreports.Themainobjectiveofreportsistopresentfactualinformation about a class of things and their characteristics. The last type of genre is represented by argumentsandexpositionswhichprovidereasonsforastateofaffairsorajudgment.Allthese kindsofgenresarefoundeverywhereindifferentmediumssuchasletters,e-mails,messages, textbooks, newspapers, recipes, manuals, songs, novels, advertisements, menus, lectures, speeches,andallkindofdiscoursesthathavetobereadandunderstoodbystudentsinside andoutsidetheclassroom. Thegenreapproachwassuitableforthisprojectbecauseitprovidedausefulwayto organizeareadingprogramthatsuitedthestudents’needsintermsoftextsandactivities whichweremeaningfulforthem.Beingabletoidentifythestructureofatextpromptsa way to read it and to be more successful at understanding and learning from it. Consideringthisinterventionwasbasedonreading,theuseofdifferentkindsofwritten texts was pivotal to get students familiarized with their structures and facilitate their comprehensibility. Content-Based Instruction In education, content-based instruction (CBI) represents the integration of specific content with language teaching objectives. Other definitions of this approach are given by Brinton,Snow,andWesche(1989),whostateCBIisanapproachthat“integrateslanguage instruction withcontent instruction, but whichallowsthe content to determine the nature andorderofthelinguisticsyllabus”(p.2).SomewritersbelievetheobjectiveofCBIistolearn content while others think that content is just an excuse to facilitate learning a language, whichisitsrealobjective.OtherauthorssuchasDueñas(2004)preferabalancedapproach andofferthesamestatustobothlanguageandcontent. 52 HOW TheDesignofaTheme-BasedandGenre-OrientedStrategicReadingCourse toImproveStudents’ReadingComprehensionSkillsataPublicSchoolinColombia Thereareseveralreasonswhythisapproachwasappropriateforthedevelopmentofthis intervention. First, CBI prompts reading texts as the main resources for giving input to students.Authentictextswereusedtopresentinformationtothelearnerswhousedmaterials that were produced for native speakers. Furthermore, due to the fact the target school is trying to become a bilingual school as a long term goal, CBI was then a perfect approach servingasareferenceorstartingpoint. Reading Strategies When readers read a text, they employ different techniques that facilitate their comprehension. These techniques are known as strategies. Chamot (1987) says learning strategies are “techniques, approach or deliberate actions that students take in order to facilitate the learning, recall of both linguistic and content area information” (p. 71). Additionally,Oxford(1989)thinkslearningstrategiesare“behaviorsoractionsthatlearners usetomakelanguagelearningmoresuccessful,self-directedandenjoyable”(p.154).Reading strategiesareusedbyreadersinordertounderstandbetteratextandasaresponsetointernal orexternalfactorsthatinfluencetheirchoice. Areadingstrategyisusuallyaplanthatisselectedintentionallybyanindividualinorderto construct and provide meaning to a text. Learners use strategies before, during, and after reading.Accordingtothisprocedure,strategiescanalsobeclassifiedasbefore,during,and afterreadingstrategies(Preszler,2005).Beforereadingstrategiesareusedbyreadersandalso by reading teachers with their students in order to activate their prior knowledge and to increase the reader’sinvolvementinboththe text and the learning process. Duringreading strategiesarethosethathelpreaderstokeeptrackofthetext,makeprogressinthereading process and maintain comprehension as they read. After reading strategies are also called interactivestrategiessincemostofthetimetheyrequirestudentstoshareideasandinteract withothers(Preszler,2005). ContextandParticipants For the purpose of this project, 35 students of ninth grade were intervened. The interventiontookplaceatapublicschoollocatedinthesouthwesternpartofBarranquilla, Colombia.Thisinstitutionhasstudentsfromdifferentsocialclasses,but90%ofthembelong tosocioeconomicstrata1,2,and3(justbelowmiddleclass).Theschoolisdeeplycommitted tothegoalsofthePNBtoraisethelevelofcommunicativecompetenceinEnglishby2019. To accomplish this purpose, students are divided into levels of performance and learning. Aftertakingaplacementexamatthebeginningoftheschoolyear,allthestudentsofthesame grade during English classes are separated and classified into three levels. Level 1 has the students with the lowest knowledge of English, and Level 3 the ones with the highest. HOWVol.23,No.1,April/September2016,ISSN0120-5927.Bogotá,Colombia.Pages:49-67 53 FabiánPadillaDeLaCerda Moreover, students receive English classes with the help of computers and technical resources.Additionally,andasaconsequenceoftheintroductionofthebilingualismproject intheinstitution,in2012studentsstartedstudyingeighthoursofEnglishperweek. Regarding the English teachers, the staff consists of 14 members; all of them have a bachelor degree inModern Languages; three of them have already finished a postgraduate courseinCurriculumDesignandfiveofthemhaveobtaineddiplomasatalocallanguages institute.Inturn,theteacherresearcherwhoisconductingthisinterventionholdsamaster degree in the Teaching of English. Another means of linguistic and methodology improvement for teachers is the presence of native English speaker volunteers from both governmentalandinternationalorganizations. Ontheotherhand,theschoolPEI(ProyectoEducativoInstitucional[Institution’sEducational Project]) has set out as its visional plan for 2014 to become a leader in the fields of labor competences, technology, commerce, and English skills in order to help students to be successfulinboththeacademicfieldandjobmarket.Themissionoftheschoolistoproduce competentandcompetitivestudentswithadefinedlifeprojectorientedtobesuccessfulin thisglobalworld.WithregardtotheEnglishprogram,studentshadalwaysfollowedaseries ofbooksclassifiedaccording totheCEFR;however,thesebooksdidnotprovidestudents withauthenticinputandthetextswerenotmeaningful. Consequently, in 2010 reading skill became an object of study that began to gain importanceamongEnglishteachers,buttherewaslittleinterventiontoovercomestudents’ readingcomprehensiondifficulties.Itwasnotuntiltheimplementationofthepresentstudy attheendof2012thattheschoolbegantotakeactionsinordertogivereadingarelevant statusandhelpstudentsreachhigherlevelsofL2readingcomprehension. DataCollectionProcedure Thedatacollectionprocessofthisinterventionhadtwomoments:Onemomentwasthe needs analysis and the other moment was related to the design, implementation, and evaluationofthecontent-basedgenreorientedreadingcourse. The Needs Analysis For the needs analysis the instruments applied were a questionnaire for students, interviewsofteachersandcoordinator,andclassobservations.Thequestionnaireconsisted of twenty-one questions about the students’ expectations and beliefs toward the English learningprocess,theirnecessitiesandinterestsrelatedtotheirreadingskills,andtheirreading strategyuse.TheinterviewsofEnglishteachersandcoordinatorshowedthegeneralconcern regarding the students’ low level of comprehension and how this was related to their low 54 HOW TheDesignofaTheme-BasedandGenre-OrientedStrategicReadingCourse toImproveStudents’ReadingComprehensionSkillsataPublicSchoolinColombia results on the national SABER test and other external examinations. The observation demonstrated students were satisfied neither with the methodology employed to teach readingnorwiththeactivitiesortextsteachersusedtodeveloptheirreadingcomprehension. Oncetheneedsanalysisdemonstratedstudentsneededaninterventiontoenhancetheir readingcomprehension,someotherinstrumentswereappliedtoconfirmtheseresultsandto takethemostappropriatedecisionsregardingthecoursedesign.Theseinstrumentswerea readingproficiencytest,athinkaloudprotocol,acontentteachersclassobservation,anda student’ssurveyoncontent. Reading Proficiency Test Itwasdesignedtoassessthetargetgroup’slevelofproficiencyinreadingcomprehension. Thetestconsistedoftenquestions;sixofthemevaluatedtheliterallevelwhilefourevaluated theinferentialone(seeAppendix1).ThestudentsweregivenaSABERtypetextrelatedto Scienceinwhichtheyhadtoreadthreeshorttextstocompletetheexam.Thirty-fivestudents tooktheexaminationandwerewarnedthatitwasnotaregularexaminordertoreducetheir anxiety.Resultsshowedstudentshadseriousreadingcomprehensionproblems,probablyfor theirlackofuseofreadingstrategies;therefore,athink-aloudprotocolwasapplied. Think-Aloud Protocol This instrument allowed the observer to see first-hand the process of task completion (Lewis,1982).Itwasappropriateforthisprojectbecauseitletmeobservemystudents’useof reading strategies while reading a text in English. For this technique, three students were selected; a low, an average, and a high-performance student. They read the same text for determiningtheirlevelofreadingproficiencyandwereaskedaseriesofquestionsthatwere prepared beforehand. These questions were asked while students were reading the text to infer some of their reading processes (see Appendix 2). The think-aloud protocol showed theyallemployedstrategiessuchasusingimagesinthetextforpredictingwhatthetextwas aboutandforconfirmingtheinformationtheywerereading,aswellastheuseoftitlesandthe subtitlestopreviewcontent(seeTable1). Thisinstrumentdemonstratedsomedifferencesamongthethreestudents.Thestudent with the highest score on the exam seemed to be the most strategic while reading. The intermediate student expressed his background knowledge and his knowledge of English usuallyhelpshimwhenreadinginthetargetlanguage.Meanwhile,thestudentwiththelowest level did not use many strategies for the comprehension of the passage. This was the only student that used the knowledge of his mother tongue as a strategy to understand the vocabularyorthemeaningofwords. HOWVol.23,No.1,April/September2016,ISSN0120-5927.Bogotá,Colombia.Pages:49-67 55 FabiánPadillaDeLaCerda Table1.TheThink-AloudProtocol Advanced Intermediate Beginner Interviewer:Whatwasthefirst Interviewer:Whatwasthefirst Interviewer:Yes,butwhatdo thingyoudidwhenyoustarted thingyoudidwhenyoustart youdowhenyouread? readingthetext? readingthetext? Student:Itrytoidentifythe Student:Textwordsstarted Student:Ilookedatthe words. rollinginmymind,andthenit images. I:Andwhatdoyoudoto beganlikewhenavideois I:Andafterthat,whatelsedid identifythem? playing. youdo? S:Firstofall,Idon’t I:Andthenwhatdidyoudo S:Istartedreadingthetext. understandthem.Well,there tounderstandthetext? I:Immediately? aresomeIdon’tbutsomeI S:ThefirstthingIdidasI dounderstand. S:Yes. listenedtothattapewas I:Andwhatdoyoudoto I:Beforestartingreadingthe playingbackimagesinmy understandtheonesyoudo text,didn’tyoureadthetitle? head.Forinstance,bearslive notknow? S:No,Ialwaysstartreading inAfricasoIimagineabear, S:Well...therearesomethat thetext. themapofAfricaandAfrican looklikeSpanishbutnotallof peopleandlandscape. I:Andwhydidn’tyouseeit? them.ThereareothersIdo I:Andwhatelsehelpsyou S:BecauseIgoimmediatelyto know,though. understandthetext? thetext,soIfindoutwhatitis I:Whatdidyoudotogetthe about. S:Connectors,connectors gist? helpme. I:OK,goahead. S:Well...firstbytheimage, I:Didyoufindany? ... secondbecauseIseethetext S:Yesandtheyhelpme I:Howdoyougettoknow isaboutdifferentanimals. organize. whatthetextisabout? I:Whatelsehelpedyou I:Whydidyoulookup?What S:Byreadingthetext.Igo understandthetext? didyoudothere? throughitandthatmakesme S:Thewordsthatare...thatare S:Becausethetitleofthetext knowaboutit. not…thatisthewordsIknow oftentellsmethemainideaof I:Whatelsehelpsyoutoknow inSpanish. thetextortheparagraph.... whatthetextisabout? Thereisaquestion:ifIknow S:WhatIhavelearnedin thedifferencebetweenfrog, Englishclass. whichis“rana”inSpanish, I:OK.Goahead. andtoad,whichmeaningI don’tknow.AsI’mnotsure,I decidedtolookatthetitle again. 56 HOW TheDesignofaTheme-BasedandGenre-OrientedStrategicReadingCourse toImproveStudents’ReadingComprehensionSkillsataPublicSchoolinColombia Survey on Content The survey was applied to select the topics of the reading texts for the design of a content-basedcourse.Itwasdesignedasachecklistforstudentstochoosetheirfavorite.The topics were selected from the syllabus of the other school subjects such as science, social studies,arts,andethics.Studentschosethetopicsofscience,socialstudies,andartsasthe ones they preferred the most; therefore, the content class observations were addressed to thesesubjects.Forscience,thetopicthatrankedthemostwastheanimalkingdomaswellas theSolarSystemandthegreatcontributorstosocialstudiesandfamousartists. Content Class Observations Theobservationswerefocusedonthemethodologycontentteachersusedtoteachtheir subjects in Spanish. Of the three content subjects students selected, they seemed to participate,like,andbemoreinterestedinscience.ThiswasoneofthereasonswhyItookthe decision to implement a reading course in science. On the other hand, the data gathered strongly pointed to the need to improve students’ reading skills through contextualized readingactivitieswithoutneglectingthedevelopmentoftheotherskills. ThePedagogicalProposal Approaches to Course Design The proposed course embraces a hermeneutic approach to education because this endorses autonomy, construction of knowledge, and human development as its main features, andstudents are free toconstruct theirownknowledgeaccording totheirreality. This selection is supported by the fact that it is essential for students to develop critical thinkingandautonomyintheuseofreadingstrategies.Concerningtheapproachtolearning, this course design is framed within the sociocultural approach, represented by Vygotsky (1978),whichplacesemphasisontheacquisitionofknowledgethroughtheinteractionofthe participants(Johnson,2003).Regardingtheapproachtolanguage,thiscoursehasafunctional orientationofthelanguageandconceivesitasasocialsystemofsymbolsimmersedinareal context.Asdefinedinsystemicfunctionallinguistics(SFL),languagehasvariationsaccording tothecontextofsituationandthecontextofculture. Fromthisidea,thiscoursedesignusestheconceptofgenreandisbasedondifferenttypes oftextswithdifferentkindsoffunctions.Thecoursedesignusesbiographies,classification, process, and mechanism texts that are analysed and reconstructed in terms of specific activities suitable for each text type. These activities are called DARTS(Directed Activities RelatedtoText)whicharedesignedtogainknowledgeofthestructureofthetextandwhich HOWVol.23,No.1,April/September2016,ISSN0120-5927.Bogotá,Colombia.Pages:49-67 57 FabiánPadillaDeLaCerda arereallyhelpfulinthestudyofacademiccontenttexts(Lunzer,Gardner,Davies,&Greene, 1984). Goals and Objectives The goals are defined in terms of target, learning and humanistic goals. This is an importantpartoftheprojectsinceitconstitutestheoutlineforthedesignofthewholecourse (seeTable2). Table2.GoalsandObjectivesofthePedagogicalProposal Objectives Goals Studentsshouldbeableto: Comprehendtextsrelatedtoninthgrade Target:Developmentofreadingskill sciencecurriculum. Learning:Encouragementofreading Makeuseofdifferentreadingstrategies. strategies Human:Encouragementofrespectand Worktogether,respect,andaccepttheir acceptanceofothers’opinions classmates’opinions. Syllabus Focus Ichosecontent-basedapproach(CBA)asthemostappropriatesyllabusfocusofthisdesign. Amongthereasonsforthisselectionaretheuseofacademicandauthenticreadingsasoneof themainsourcesofinputaswellastheflexibilityandadaptabilitytoanykindofcontext.The reading texts were taken from science books used in bilingual schools and from different websites. Accordingly, this content-based course was theme-based because it encourages the use and teaching of content without neglecting the language which is its most important objective.Theme-basedapproachreferstoacoursethatoffersastronglanguageprojectionand givesflexibilityandautonomyintheselectionofthecontent(Dueñas,2004). Ontheotherhand,matrixsyllabusstructurewasthemostsuitableforthedesign.Thematrix showstheconnectionthatexistsamongallthekeyelementsofthiscoursesuchasthetopics, thegenresandtexts,thereadingstrategies,andthelinguisticstructures.Thetopicsandthe unitswereorganizedintermsofgenres.Inthefirstunitstudentsreadfourbiographiesabout the fathers of taxonomy: The First Taxonomist (Andrea Cesalpino), A Man of Science (Charles Darwin), The Father of Classification (Carl Linnaeus), and A Religious Scientist 58 HOW