DOCUMENT RESUME CE 071 129 ED 460 253 Shohet, Linda, Ed. AUTHOR Literacy across the Curriculum: Connecting Literacy in the TITLE Schools, Community and Workplace, 1995-1996. Centre for Literacy, Montreal (Quebec). INSTITUTION National Literacy Secretariat, Ottawa (Ontario).; Human SPONS AGENCY Resources Development Canada, Ottawa (Ontario).; Dawson Coll., Montreal (Quebec). ISSN-1192-3288 ISSN PUB DATE 1996-00-00 114p.; Includes "Media Focus" Volume 5, Numbers 1-4. NOTE AVAILABLE FROM Centre for Literacy, 3040 Sherbrooke Street,West, Montreal, Quebec H3Z 1A4, Canada. PUB TYPE Collected Works - Serials (022) JOURNAL CIT Literacy across the Curriculum; v11 n1-4 Spr 1995-Win 1996 EDRS PRICE MF01/PC05 Plus Postage. DESCRIPTORS Adult Basic Education; *Adult Literacy; *Educational Research; *Educational Resources; Educational Technology; Foreign Countries; Instructional Materials; *Literacy Education; Reading Instruction; Research Reports; Writing Instruction IDENTIFIERS Canada; *Media Education ABSTRACT This document contains four issues of a journal that aims to connect literacy in the schools, the community, and the workplace. Each issue also contains an insert focusing on media literacy. Some of the topics covered in the spring 1995 issue include the following: positioning literacy--naming literacy; literacy and machines--an overview of the use of technology in adult literacy programs; the United Kingdom experience of workplace literacy; families and literacy; writing and roadkill on the information highway; surfing the net in pursuit of the muse; turned off, tuned out--left out (television); what do employers really want?; and what adults need to know and be able to do. The summer 1995 issue features the following: health and literacy; the United Kingdom experience of investing in people; work-based learning; the new reading disk; computer technology survey of Ontario adult literacy programs; David Buckingham on media literacy; Spain 1995--International Conference on Media Education; Prime Time Parent Media Literacy workshop kit; policy conversation on new technologies and literacy; and adult literacy software evaluation criteria. In the Fall 1995 issue, the following are addressed: knowing more, doing less; international comparison of adult literacy released; what happens to kids with learning disabilities when they grow up?; inquiry projects and inquiry maps; participatory action research; making peace with the media; media education in English Quebec--an overview; and substance abuse and media education. The Winter 1996 issue includes the following: participation and the pleasure principle (of literacy education); a grammar of the visual?; literacy and technology--trying to reach adults where they are; evaluating television for teaching literacy; and adult literacy media alliance; poetry lessons for literacy--conversation poems; assessing media work; and New York City's public schools get support for critical media use in the information age. All issues include teaching methods, resources, reviews, conference notes, and announcements. (KC) Reproductions supplied by EDRS are the best that can be made from the original document. Literacy across the Curriculum: Connecting Literacy in the Schools, Community and Workplace, 1995-1996 Linda Shohet, Editor Volume 11, Numbers 1-4 U.S. DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION Office of Educational Research and Improvement PERMISSION TO REPRODUCE AND EDUCATIONAL RESOURCES INFORMATION DISSEMINATE THIS MATERIAL HAS CENTER (ERIC) BEEN GRANTED BY This document has been reproduced as received from the person or organization L. Shohet originating it. Minor changes have been made to improve I:I reproduction quality TO THE EDUCATIONAL RESOURCES INFORMATION CENTER (ERIC) Points of view or opinions stated in this document do not necessarily represent official OERI position or policy. 1 AVAILABLF, BEST COPY 2 SPRING 1995 Vol. 11 No. 1 IncOmang JL F 4111MCLik Conne©Ung neracy In the schooGls, comnwri.Ry and workpflace Naming literacy - Positioning literacy Have we extended the meaning of literacy so far in the past 15 years The that it is in danger of becoming turn devoid of meaning? Gunther Kress thinks so. of the visual Professor of Education at the University of London's Institute of Kress Education, Kress is a developer of spoke in critical linguistics, best known in March academic circles for his work on at the childrens' reading and genre Conference on College theory. But it is his current work Composition and Communication on literacy and what he calls in Washington D.C. He talked "multimodal" text that should win about the displacement of writing _D) him a following among a much from its central position in 4 To ponder broader audience. communication as technology, globalization and multicultural Literacy and machines 5 He believes that using the term social realities intensify the "turn Positioning literacy 6 literacy as a metaphor to describe of the visual." To illustrate his - The U.K. experience something that seems to mean point, Kress used three examples, 10 In the classroom: Families and "not much more than (competence comparing two children's books, in) some form of culturally two science textbooks and two literacy significant behaviour" [see BOX 11 newspapers. 12 What do employers really want? has caused us to lose the literal 14 What adults need to know meaning of the word [see BOX 21 The children's books were a Resources: ALBSU materials and to blur or misconstrue the 15 British Ladybird story and a Dick questions connected to it. Bruna book from Holland. The Conferences 16 Ladybird story carried the text on 18 Announcements continued on page 2 The Centre for Literacy Rilontreai, Quebec 3 2 .rritu Uterecy continued from page 1 broadcasting established the BBC dis as the official national standard of the left side and the image on the Across the language and interpretation. right; the language tells the Curuicadum Texts in the two countries reflect reader how to see the world. The those cultural positions. Bruna book was entirely The Centre for illustration around which readers Literacy Now the shift to the visual seen in can tell stories depending on 3040 Sherbrooke Dick Bruna has spread. where they stand; here, the Street West, Comparing traditional and tabloid unifying principle resides in the Montreal, Quebec, newspapers, we find that image. Kress contextualized this Canada, language has shrunk and example by noting that the Dutch H3Z 1A4 graphics/images carry more of from the time they introduced Editor: Linda Shohet the meaning. Science textbooks radio in Holland gave air time to Layout & design: provide another example. Until many cultural groups while the the 1960s, language was the British from the beginning of Depot legal 1991 ISSN 11924288 BOX 1. Bibliothèque Nationale du Quebec The problem of literacy as a metaphor The Centre for Literacy/Le centre a resource dalphabatisation is This metaphoric extension facilitates a rapid move from a concern centre and with the detail of the formal aspects of literacy to a consideration of teacher-training project designed to provide training, research, and information services its uses and effects...lt mirrors precisely the shift from the lettered which promote and link the advancement of person as the possessor of specific linguistic/cultural skills to the literacy in the schools, the workplace and homme cultivé as the possessor of a broad range of desirable the community. The Centre gratefully cultural attitudes. acknowledges the support of the National ... The slippage between linguistic and cultural meanings can have Literacy Secretariat, Human Resources the political effect that cultural values and social practices which Development Canada, and Dawson College. are seen as undesirable are attacked under the guise of an attack on literacy standards. Differentiating AO writing and reading Writing is the production of a text which exists potentially for many readers; the text establishes the domain, 'sets the agenda,' for the Literacy for the 21st century reader's engagement with the text. While that does not determine Literacy encompasses a complex set of the specific readings of the text...it does determine the ground on abilities to understand and use the which reading takes place. Reading is the production of a text for dominant symbol systems of a culture for one reader, the self, in a response to a text which both establishes personal and community development. In a the domain, and attempts to structure its reception. The political technological society, the concept of literacy potential of writing and reading are...radically distinct; to gloss and is expanding to include the media and over that distinction in contemporary approaches to reading or to electronic text, in addition to alphabetic and literacy seems to me a fundamental political and social problem. In number systems. These abilities vary in my view, it amounts to a spurious empowerment of those who are different social and cultural contexts readers, in the name of democratic, egalitarian social structures, according to need and demand. Individuals while leaving real power unchallenged with those who have the must be given life-long learning means for the production of texts for many, who have full control of opportunities to move along a continuum the technology of literacy. that includes the reading and writing, critical understanding, and decision-making Gunther Kress. "Questions in a social theory of literacy," Learning to Write, abilities they need in their community. Rout ledge, (London/New York1994): pp. 194-195 & 197-198. Literacy Across the Curriculum Spring 1995 The Centre for Literacy Vol. 1111 No. 1 Issues arising central medium for carrying the information with images as Kress's analysis provides me with illustration. Today, image is a frame for discussing a recent central and language is study tour in the U.K. where I comment. Kress suggests this spent a week with four Canadian is a reflection of science having colleagues meeting researchers, lost its sense of who it is policy-makers and practitioners addressing in the classroom. at the Adult Literacy and Basic Skills Unit (ALBSU) and visiting literal meaning cic to workplace and community-based program sites. Kress does not see these trends as "the end of civilization." A fuller and written representations and This issue of LAC contains reports account of his thinking is given in other representations of meaning and observations on that visit the second edition of his book such as drawing, music, dance. with a focus on the way that Learning to Read where he has He also wants to reestablish the literacy/basic skills has been added a critical chapter entitled fundamental distinction between positioned on the British social "Questions in a social theory of reading and writing which have and political agenda (pp. 6-9). It literacy." He calls for a return to been blurred as the terms have also has excerpts from some precision in talking about literacy been replaced by the word current reports from Canada and that distinguishes between verbal "literacy." [see BOX 2IFrom this the U.S.which indicate trends reassessment follows a changed related to school, work and basic pedagogy in schools and a BOX 2 skills, some of them contradictory changed politics of workplace and to each other (pp. 12-14). With the 'What is literacy?' community literacy. exception of New Brunswick, there is no place in Canada where For a start I wish to make a Kress has deep convictions about literacy/basic skills has been distinction between verbal the power of [literal] literacy to incorporated into the social vision literacy on the one hand, and produce "a culture of innovation" beyond rhetoric. Without that literacy as a description of any which he believes is essential for deeper analysis and political form or means of representation our survival in a rapidly changing action, it is more than possible - 'media literacy"computer world of technology and that literacy could literally fall off literacy'- and, more decisively, information. the agenda entirely within two as a word describing 'cultured' years in most parts of this aspects of human practices country. [LSI =cultural literacy', 'moral literacy' - on the other hand. BOX 3 Equally I wish to rule out the plural form literacies' for the The multi-modality of literacy moment. This leaves 'literacy' as a word which describes one ... no message ever appears in one mode. Written language inevitably aspect of human involves the medium of typography, or of handwriting, and the communication, namely the medium of layout. Further, writing has to appear on or with a form of representation through medium - paper, stone, textile, a rockface, a marble slab. The language of socio-cultural medium with which language appears inevitably adds its meaning; meanings and in which the brass plate on which a business's name appears adds a different language is represented visually menaing to that of a cheaply printed plastic sign. If the name appears by means of letters and on paper, the quality of the paper, for instance, becomes a semiotic associated graphic signs. medium so that 'good quality paper' or 'glossy paper' add meaning to Gunther Kress, "Questions in a the verbal text willy-nilly. Multi-modality is an unavoidable condition social theory of literacy," Learning of verbal literacy in its appearance in text as message. to Write, Rout ledge, (London/New Gunther Kress, "Questions in a social theory of literacy," Learning to Write, York1994): 209. Rout ledge, (London/New York1994): 211. The Centre for Literacy Spring 1995 - 14)11.11 No. 1 Ligeracy Across Me Curriculum 5 TO PONDER r4 On poetry comes into play when the governs the interactive text on the anonymous diskette opens up into monitor, too: the reader-user the unfolding universe of popular, applies herself to see the text and semiserious programs like the expand. This is the opposite of city-planning game Simcity or the cant about the "freedom" readers software history game Civilization. have when dealing with interactive texts: it is the freedom The pleasure in these realms is of the detective trying to solve What has poetry to do like that of living with a poem: a crime, or the captive trying to with computer escape, a kind of authorial say, the 237 words of Willaim software? They share a Butler Yeats's "Sailing to tyranny compared with the great human myth or Byzantium" or the mere 96 words welcoming, available pages trope, an image that of Blake's "London" (My computer of a book. could be called the secret passage: counted the words for me.) the discovery of large, manifold Reciting the poem, repeating it, Robert Pinsky, "The Muse in the channels through a small, Machine: Or, The Poetics of Zork," The memorizing it, meditating it, we ordinary looking or all but New York Times Book Review, March play with it and work at it for the invisible aperture. 19, 1995. pp 3, 27. pleasure of feeling it unfold to millions of times the original size. Pressed to define the special This sense of effort to see more attributes of poetry as an art, I would name speed and memory. Whipping from image to abstraction, from narrative to reflection, from neat epigram to sensuous trope, poetry can cross n b stories she forbade. The result terrain and change direction with was the creation by Loeb of his tremendous swiftness. Compared fantasy to perpetuate the perfect to ordinary language, it can be II crime "The books he read by like ice-skating compared to day were not the books he read by walking. (Discursive prose, to folence night...Which, think you, shaped extend the comparison a bit the life of Dickie Loeb? Is there mischievously, often resembles any kind of question about Darrow even used his wading staright ahead.) And the it?...these books became a part of love of books and their effort to enlarge memory to his dreams and a part of his life, influence in court. In recall genealogy or history, for and as he grew up his visions defending Richard is the most obvious example grew to hallucinations...to Loeb and Nathan source for the development complete the perfect crime. Can Leopold, he first noted Leopold's of verse. there be any question about it?" philosopical dependency upon the [Quoted in Arthur Weinberg (ed.), theories of Friedrich Nietzsche Speed and memory: these Clarence Darrow, (derived from books, of qualities link poetry with the Attorney for the course), then turned computer... Damned, pp. 63-64 his attention to Loeb's (1957)1. reading This fascination with the habits. tremendous volume that can be Jordan D. Luttrell, While a indicated or stored in a tiny space "Clarence Darrow and the young boy, is an essential element of our Books in His Life," AB Darrow pleasure in lyric poetry. That the Bookman'sWeekly, contended, same principle also has something April 24, 1995, 1805. Loeb was to do with the pleasures of the force-fed the personal computer is suggested "best books" by a by the way the idea persists not well-intentioned only in Zork descendants like the governess. At night, currently popular Myst, which is surreptitiously, he full of concealed doorways leading devoured the detective to vast mazes. The same principle Lkerscy Across Ms Curricukim The Centre for Literacy Spzing 1995 Voll. 11 No. 1 6 5 Aew d t e ova An cy pro r nne 1t Mane un a of tachra hz flo The use of [The National Center on technology in adult Adult Literacy (NCAL) in literacy programs is Philadelphia is enhanced or limited disseminating current by philosopical and research findings in a new historic traditions format called NCAL Briefs. within the literacy These briefs summarize recently published reports field. An understanding of including research findings, these traditions implications and recommendations, and facilitates technology information on how to order decision making and the complete report. places the decision Reprinted here with in a larger context. , permisson are excerpts from "Literacy and Machines: An As issues of access and equity Overview of the Use of Technology are debated in the fields of in Adult Literacy Programs," a literacy and technology, Brief released on March 10, 1995, practitioners need to provide prepared by Terilyn Turner of leadership in determining the IKey n.ecommenel 'Hams: Saint Paul Lifelong Literacy and future of technology in the Technology selection should be based on NCAL Technical Report adult literacy field. based on a previously TR93-03, March 1993, $9.00 identified need or problem (ERIC no. ED356 408) (ed.)] To order hard copies of this full within the literacy program, report or other NCAL reports, and instructional software Key nindings: call NCAL Dissemination should be selected for its (215) 898-2100; ability to address that specific The value of technology for Fax: (215) 898-9804, gap in the currciulum. adult literacy instruction is e-mail: ncalgliteracy.upemmedu. based on its provision of Practitioners need to teach privacy, individual control, Free electronic copy of the brief: adult learners how to access immediate feedback, and via NCAL's Internet Gopher, information rather than sound flexibility for learners. point your client at out words; technology becomes Htserver.11iteracy.upenmedu. The selection of appropriate the means by which o technology must take into information and knowledge can account the larger themes and be acquired. issues currently debated in adult literacy, such as the Allgernallyes ?or Cilteredry: nature of the learner, purpose of literacy instruction, and Technollogy For Mazy issues of evaluation and mild accountability. TOITPCMONf Context should be the primary o Adult Literacy and Technology Conference determinant for appropriate 5, 1995 August 4 technology selection since Philadelphia, PA there are marked differences Information: Tom Andrzejewski or Chris Hopey, among the programs for work National Center on Adult Literacy, force literacy, family literacy, Tel: (215) 898-2100; Fax: (215) 898-9804; adult basic education, GED, e-mail: [email protected] or corrections, libraries, and [email protected] English as a second language. The Centre for Lfiteracy Spring 1995 - Vol]. 11 No. 1 Literacy Across the Curriculum 7 6 ite ce ap@daD, Qi@ lo linte r tin U.K. has still moved further in training certification and integrating literacy/basic skills curricula and developed an sic into larger political and social inventory of foundational skills iii1s agendas than other Western that cut across school and 11) OP( countries have. workplace; it has created some According to Alan Wells, founder high-profile demonstration Education in the U.K. has turned and director of the Adult Literacy projects, devised program quality into a battlefield according to and Basic Skills Unit (ALBSU), the marks, and engaged in multi- Gunther Kress with competing agency has more status today agency consulting (partnerships visions of literacy fueling the fight than it did five years ago. Wells, in North American terms) which in the schools and in the who finds the word "literacy" have integrated basic skills into workplace. Further education problematic, would like to see it contexts they would not otherwise colleges are no longer overseen by dropped from the agency's name. have been. local education authorities and They use the term "basic skills" competency-based assessment is and are moving towards "core Two examples illustrate the way taking hold in vocational training. skills." Nevertheless, by in which basic skills have been But despite all the contention, the commissioning research that integrated into housing and makes links between basic skills health. Using census data, ALBSU and employment, health, housing has shown connections between and a variety of other social poor skills and inadequate issues, ALBSU has succeeded in housing, low income and poor positioning "basic skills" as a health. Other agencies are using necessary foundation for further their findings. education and retraining and for Housing nd basic skins social reform. A major regeneration project being The downside of the shift is that carried out over ten years at one ALBSU has moved further from of the largest housing estates students and practitioners, (British for slum) in England has aligning itself with the policy- included education and training makers and administrators who for tenants in its plan. It will see quantify whatever can be concrete highrises torn down and translated into numbers and SAP.2° replaced by self-contained G constantly call for townhouses similar to those that accountability. Wells argues existed before the 1950s. that the climate of the times ov,,Twzmoswel Recognizing the lack of basic is such that without that skills among the tenants, the move, literacy would have housing corporation has built in been lost as an issue on the educational assessment, basic national agenda by now. skills and vocational training. For Nobody funds good those who take up the offer, the feelings" in 1995. They corporation is committed to hiring want outcomes. 75% of the project workers from the estate. The years of work To its credit, building on experience is expected to wean the data it collects, them off welfare dependency and ALBSU has created a make them employable after the coherent vision, written project ends. The motivation is clear-language reports, the building of their own homes produced national instructor as well as their futures. Literacy Across Me Curriculum Spring 1995 The Centre for Literacy Voi. 111 No. 1 m[patmm auN Maw CCD@ itui read materials they might Health and b afic skffis otherwise have ignored. In Norwich, an East Anglian city in the county of Norfolk, Healthy Assessment is a concern at all Norfolk 2000 was launched in levels. In these projects, 1990 to improve the health and recognizing the impossibility of well-being of Norfolk residents, to measuring short-term gains in reduce inequalities in health and health in a long-term project, to encourage co-operation among planners have wisely built in all organizations with a qualitative measures such as responsibility for health. A basic number of schools, organizations skills consultant is involved in visited or contacted, numbers of every initiative. referrals, calls, materials distributed, etc., concentrating on Having experienced a false start in output rather than impact in the 1988, the project started anew in early stages. 1992 to build multi-agency cooperation around six key The Health Promotion Unit in targets in health of particular Norwich focuses on health import to Norfolk: Cancer, Heart education in the schools and the Health, Sexual Health, Accidents, community. They develop Food Poisoning and Disabilities. curriculum, consult and design The project also supports and rewrite documents for ease of initiatives apart from Healthy reading. They have worked in Norfolk 2000, such as a program health-education partnerships, in the town of Thetford which has drawing in advice from all parties held public focus groups to get at involved. Step-to-Health, another health concerns by posing a more HN2000 project, provides training general question: What is it like to and resources to help people a.via live in Thetford? From transcripts diet and change their lifestyles of recorded responses, planners prevention, smoking. All of these ep.ta have identified patterns and projects have limited resources. por 0 Bp issues and created a clear, concise document identifying the In addition to these larger citizens' concerns related to 44PfttrallIte. initiatives, there are many health, the agencies that might -itt."215e4PICE F71 smaller integrated efforts, such respond, the projects/changes as the presence of Dr. Richard that could be undertaken and the Redding, a community commitment required from key pediatrician in a lower-income players to carry out particular area nursery school. The actions. The emphasis is on nursery happens to be eliminating duplication/turf wars located in the same building and redirecting those resources to as the local family literacy new targets. project and Dr. Redding has a high level of awareness Literacy/basic skills is constantly that the parents of the addressed. There is awareness children he sees often have that client groups may have severe basic skills comprehension or communication problems. He has problems and that materials and accommodated his talk oral presentations must be and materials to reduce written or made dearly and the anxiety and increase graphically. A bonus has been the comprehension that highly literate but busy of these parents. people have also taken the time to Spring 1995 - Vol. 11 No. 1 Literacy Across the Curriculum The Centre for Literacy 9 ite mp@ffbfflm IDG LOEO EL family, it is now part of a that within a few years, they will Workplace basic multinational conglomerate, no longer need ALBSU ritish currently for sale to help finance a skills-two consultancy and will take full billion acquisition in North responsibility for basic skills c mpanies America. Laid out on a sprawling, provisions within the company's landscaped estate in Norwich that training program. previously housed the Colman Colman's of Norwich family home, the low-slung factory Robots at Ford Ford's Dagenham buildings are connected by Ford's Dagenham, in contrast to gardens and stone walking-paths. Colman's, is located on a barren The ALBSU Basic Skills at Work The training/education program expanse, almost the size of central Programme (1992-95) established is housed in a converted abbey on London, on the edge of a working 40 pilot-projects involving 300 the property. class suburb which provides most companies. With ALBSU funding of the 9000 employees who work now ended, about 70% of the Having been "down-sized" in in three connected plants. While projects are continuing with recent years as the consequence Ford used to be managed in each funding from other sources of technology and globalization, country where they according to ALBSU project the company currently employs manufactured, now all officers. about 700 local residents with management is centralized in little turnover; it has inherited the Detroit and quality standards In England, I visited two of the Quaker philosophy of benevolence are global. companies, radically different in toward employees. According to organizational structure, which their director of training, Peter Dagenham, producer of Fiestas are committed to maintaining Leggett, basic skills needs became and a van, is in the midst of basic skills as part of their apparent with the changes in technological reorganization; workplace education program. technology and organization; at robots have replaced workers in the time, Colman's assessed all the most tedious and physically A benevolent employer the employees and provided demanding tasks. Many Colman's of Norwich is the individual feedback with the workstations are monitored condiment and soft drink division option to take basic skills by computer. of Colman's & Reckitt. Founded upgrading. As employees have by the Quaker Colman recognized the increased The changes are most evident on demands, many have been the die presses which cut out motivated to take the option. Four large pieces of the cars. At one trainers at the company have point, standing between two become certified ALBSU production lines with our host, instructors who offer small-group we were told "You are standing classes and, for those employees between the past and the future." who want confidentiality, one-on- On the left, each section of the one tuition. massive presses was manned by 1-2 employees, a total of about 15 Colman's takes the long-term view per line. On the right, highly that the increased confidence and sensitive robots were carrying out self-esteem of workers who the identical tasks - with one achieve qualification benefit the employee at the head and one at company in both direct and the end reading printouts on a indirect ways - the workers are screen. The repetitive movements able to participate in new team were mind-numbing, the noise structures and they feel less deafening. At first, it seemed threatened by the continuing reasonable to use machines changes. The company anticipates instead of men. Yet the hidden Littracy Across ehe CurrIcagium Spring 1995 - Vol. 11 No. 1 The Centre for Literacy 10