ERIC ED437647: The Role of Phonics in Reading Instruction: A Position Statement of the International Reading Association.

7 Pages·1997·0.28 MB·English

by  ERIC

DOCUMENT RESUME
CS 013 860
ED 437 647
The Role of Phonics in Reading Instruction: A Position
TITLE
Statement of the International Reading Association.
International Reading Association, Newark, DE.
INSTITUTION
1997-00-00
PUB DATE
NOTE
10p.
International Reading Association, 800 Barksdale Road, P.O.
AVAILABLE FROM
Box 8139, Newark, DE 19714-8139 ($5 per 10 copies plus $3
shipping/handling, or $0.30 each for 100 or more copies plus
$3 shipping/handling). Tel: [phone] (Toll Free); Web
site: http://www.reading.org.
Opinion Papers (120)
PUB TYPE
MF01/PC01 Plus Postage.
EDRS PRICE
*Beginning Reading; *Instructional Effectiveness; *Phonics;
DESCRIPTORS
Primary Education; *Reading Instruction; Reading Programs;
Teacher Behavior
ABSTRACT
Noting that the role of phonics in reading and writing has
become as much a political issue as it has an educational one, this pamphlet
offers a position statement regarding the role of phonics in a total reading
program. It begins with three assertions regarding phonics and the teaching
(1) the teaching of phonics is an important aspect of beginning
of reading:
(2) classroom teachers in the primary grades do value
reading instruction;
and do teach phonics as part of their reading programs; and (3) phonics
instruction, to be effective in promoting independence in reading, must be
embedded in the context of a total reading/language arts program. The
pamphlet concludes with an outline for a professional stance towards phonics.
(RS)
Reproductions supplied by EDRS are the best that can be made
from the original document.
The Role of Phonics in Reading Instruction.
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF
EDUCATION
Office of Educational Research
PERMISSION TO REPRODUCE
AND
and Improvement
EDUCATIONAL RESOURCES
DISSEMINATE THIS MATERIAL
HAS
INFORMATION
CENTER (ERIC)
BEEN GRANTED BY
I24his
document has been reproduced
as
received from the person
or organization
originating it.
BEST COPY AVAILABLE
00
Minor changes have been
made to
improve reproduction
tr't
quality.
TO THE EDUCATIONAL
Points of view or opinions
RESOURCES
stated in this
INFORMATION CENTER
document do not necessarily
(ERIC)
represent
1
official OERI position
or policy.
2
n
S
4
l
a
o
e
g
n
C
h
n
n
f
i
o
t
n
o
o

i
t
i
f
o
d
I
t
i
o
c
a
e
t
i
a
N

a
t g
n
t
l
u
i
i
e
n
n
o
r
s
c
e
R
e
i
o
o
r
O
R
t
m
t
c
P
s
n
t

a
s
n

e

s
I
e
e
A
A
H
t
i
R
a
n
h
t
S
T
P
I
7
8
9
1
/
0
9
1

V
A
E
.
6
R
S
n
m
6

U
e
7
o
0
a
2
9

h
o
i
/

3
0

3
,
t
t
t
.
r

c
a
.
0 t
0
9
B
f
t
0
x
u

a

.
U
0
3
n
e
d
3
$

r
P
.
1

t
o
$
e

t
3

,
L
n
f
s 6
8
D
i
s

$
o
1
n
e
t
s
-
a
-
a
A

u
m
7
I
4
A
h
s
t
i
9

l
s
c
u
E
1
g
c
p
t
o
o
r
7
l
n
r
R
N

a
p
c
n
u
s
s
9
i
N
-
p

e
d
s
p
1
a
6
s
A
e
O
i
d
a
O
o

e

3
p
D
e
t
e
e
a
i

3
a
o
I
b
p
g
R
r
o
I
T

i
-

c
a
r

o
n
r
0
R

y
A

e
g
t
o
w
n
c
i
0
0
d
a
T
d

a
M

i
8
1
,
e
m
n
a
e
r

.
a
g
s

9

g
O
l
r
l
l
e
r
R
A
i
c
n
a

l
e
o
3
n
i
e
R
t
a

i
i
O
d
c
D
m
e
n
1
i
p
d
n
c
l
l

N
s
h
d
8
e

F

d
o
l

0

r
k
o
a
a
t
n
m
,
r
n
h
N
o

0
x
k
n
o
r
a
o
R
a
P
e
a
.
e
I
o
o
w
r

h
s
t
h
5

0

a
t
B

i
G
B
f

R
s
a

$
o
t
E
0
&
w
s
o
&
r
a
t
l
S
N

1
e

s
e
n
0
O

e
e

A
U
d

b
I
g
T
g
r
0
n
r
l
N
R
k
r
P
e
n
o
o
n

8
s
o
o
f
t
E
R
i
s
f
i
N
o
n
i
n

p
p

e
t
D
d
h

I
i
p
r
p
w
t
e
n

s
o
d
c
s
R
I
e
i
i
h
o
e
o
h
a
d
h
h
O
T
S
p
t
e
c
a
s
s
t
E
L
B
A
L
I
A
V
A
Y
P
O
C

T
S
E
B
3
s
e
-
e
e
-
u
y
h
s
W
c
y
t
d
t
t
-
o
s
s
n
n

t
n
u
n
i
e
n

t
l
a
e
.
d

i
t
a
i
s
a
e

h
s

v
c
d
e
u
t
s
u
c
c
d
e
a
e
m
S
q
a

d
u
a
r
h
-
e
t
n
-

U

d
r
f r
r
m
t

e l
.
t
A
e
w
s
o
o
e
o
o
a
a
s
:

m
r
-

s
g
h
n
l
c

i
y

a

n
-
n
v
p
f u
r
p
e

s
t
t
k
.
s
r
n
a
t
w
l
a
o
a
g
c
r
n
o
y
g
s
o
o
e
o
i
m
v
e

e
g
c
i
e
t
e
i
r
g
r
f
l
n
u

l
l
e

e
h
o
n
e
i
h
r
d
p
p

e
t
a
a
l
e
g
n
t
g
v
s
r
.
o

u
n
s
a
i
r
f
a
r
r
c
l h
u
p
n

u
n
l s
t
t
o
l
o
r
o
i
t
E

n

c
a
c
e
n

u
f
i
i
d
d
a
s
e
n
c
e
s
a

a
e
v
l
l
e
o
s
g

r
a o

f n
d
i

p
h
a o
n
g
a
n
e
c

h
a
p
i
o
g
o
h
. m
s
h
i

e
s
d
c l
i
i
e
d
t

t

l
i
:
n
a
e
i
t

t
f
e

n
r

p
c
t
v

t

s
c

a
r s
h
e
e

g
n
e
s
e
a
i
a
g
p

s
i
e
: m
r
e

d
-
c
f
u
i
e

i
h
o
s
i
h

t
m
g
r
e
e
s
n
f
t
c
i
r
e
e
h
n

m
v
e
c

h
h
n
i r
e
a
t
c
e
g
t
t

o
n
i
c
a
a
v
d
i
a
r
i
v
t
w
i

e
u
t
)
v

d
t
t
t
a
s
a

d
s
i
n
d
e

i
e
a
i i
r
6
c g
l

a

i
o
t
t

o
v
i
s
s
p
n
a
t

g
w
e

e
n
n
i
S
n
h
t
i
e
h
d
p
s
e
9
p
d
n
l
c
o
w
d
i
c
n
t

i

i
e
n
h
t
i
t u
i
t
t

g
:

e
b
o

s
f
e
e
9
i

n
e

g
a
e
a
e
u

n
h
d
e
d
f
r
t
r
g
i
P
t
e
e
o

r
n
t
a
e
h

h
d
d
1
c

o
a

l
f
e
e
h
b
r
n
t
c
h
o
e
e
f
s
n
h
d
o
l
r
f
i
i

a
t
s r

a o

e
r
w
m
e
h
a
r
e
i
r

g
d
f
t
h

i
o
,
d
a
t
i

t
a
t
r

g u t
e

e i
o
g
d
s

t
n

l

t
r f
t
n
n
o
n
n

t
w
d
n
n
d
g
o
f
m
y
r
r
e

o
t
e s
p
f
l
r
m
d

n
a
e
e
e
o
a
U
o

i
a
o
n
f
p
a
i
n
e
a
t
c

t

t
n
s
l
m
e

i
i
e
r
m

t
e
i
f
g

f
r

d

i

a
s

i
i
r

w
a
r
e

e
a
d

t
e
t
e
r
s
n
l
n
v
k
y
s
r
e

s
w r
t
n
s
i
l
e
r
o
e
i
a

p
a
n
i
v
i
l
a
n
x
r
r
l
-

u
o
r

s
l
a
g
l
h
:
u w
f
g
a
l
i
h
c
e
c
a
d
p
t
g
e
e

s
a
i
o
o
i
e
h
g

a
e
t
i
e
g
W
e
d
d
t
c
w
n
p
i
.

t
g
h
a

l

n

t
c
v

h
t

l
t
c
o
e

,
c
i
r
s
t
s
r e
e
i
t
e
n
e
m
c
t
i
n

h
r
d
n
i
e
t
r
a
p
t
o
a
o
n
a

x
e
u
c
e
h
r
t

a
r
W
r e
a
v
a
m
y
t
c
e
n
o
l
u
e

h
l
r
a
p
e
n

e
o e
c
h
r
r
o

e
l
t
e
r
e
t
e

t
w
u
p
d
t
e
c
a
t
t
t
p

i
s
t
g
e
i t
p
g r R

t
n
s
h
a
a l

s
g
d
h
v
c
n

.
.

f

y

c
n
d

d

u
T

n

e
o
d
n
s
s
n r

e
e
l
t
p
e
r
e

d
i
i
e

t
t
c
o
a
i
e
s
u
e
u

t
l
a .
s
e
g
i
s

r
i
h n
n
i
l
i
h
m
b
n
l
n
a
r
v
e

d
i
p
l
b
s

t
c
r n
l
e

t
v
t
t
e
o
n
e
t
c
.
n
t
s
a n
o
k
t

n
u
u
c
a
s
a
i
m
s
n
i
a
e
s
l

o
o
e

h
l

r e
o
f
b
c
n
e
n
i
n
e
s
t
e
r

o
d

c
p
i

h
o
o
t

d
e

d
:
a
i
u

v
e

t
s
-
r
i
i
h
n
y

o
i
i
h
i
s
i
r d

i
d
n
t
s

t
n

h
l

r
H
f

a
o
r

i
t
e

l
f
g
e
d
a
c
a
e
l
e
l
t
r
e
o
s
s
s
t
a
t o
a
s

u
n
o
e
e
u
d
o
w
n u
e
f

t

i
f
n
h
a
h
(
i
h
W
c
e
r

d
e
h
n
g
o
s
i
p
n
o
t
c
i

w
t
o
n
h

n
i b
e
c
r
e
a
s
r
i
c
t
t
r
i
t

y
f
v

u
c
i
t
n
o
m
i

l
n
s
f

o
i
e

o
p
l
g

o

s
t

h

h

g
t f
u
l

t
u
d
n
i
a
s
s
a
t
r
h a
i d
s
.
b
t
n
o
a s
t n
o

s
b

u
-
r
n
s
t
c
O
n
o
a
s
d
a
h f
u
i
i
e
e

s
y
e
p
i c
e
m
:
e

s
e

h
s
m

e

w a
r
i
n
e
c

e
o
n
w
i
t
s
c
A
r t
t
v
i
r
l
t
i
f
r

a
g
A
t
s
m
s
m
a
r
p
l
r
s
h

e
r
e
a
e
i
i
i
g
r
v m
o
a
t
a
i

u
S
t
s

n
e

a
a c
l
e e
a
t

h
d

n

n
t
d
e
n
t
a
m
g
h
i

p
c
c
e
s
p
g

n
o
n
n

i
i
t

i
l

l c
-
i
e
t
r
l
o

n
u
h
c
v
a
r
h
o
y

n
n
r
t a
e

r
o
y
i
n
o

o
o
n
t

o

:
n c
i
o
t
h
.
e
h
h
e
n

i

o
e
b
t
r o
o
n
t
i
i
o
n l
f
n
r
n
i l
l
t
i
o
l
d
s
n
l
d
t
i
u
f
c

i p
d
p
e
f
c
e
t
h
a
t
t
h
c
a
o
w
h
h
c

c

r
o
s
i
i
o
e
e
s
i

i
i
e
a
o
a

e
s s
n
t

b
a
p
v
w
v
r
u
t
t
m
r
c
t
i
u

p
t e
e
i
a
s
f
e
l

i

m
a
t o
a
o
t t
r
o
t
e
i

d
o
l
t
e
o
e
e

d
u
o
a
r
a
t
r
a
n g
c
a

n n t
d
e
n
n
c
g
e
c

i
p
t
n
t
R
f
f
a
t
a
s
i
R
d
d

e
s
t e r
e
c d
u
s
r

e n
u

t

o
i o
i s
h
g
r
u
s
g
n
p
m

v
e
e
d
s
c
r
e
r
m

i
e
u

v
n t
n
r
o

h
n
d i
r

i
r t
u
f
d
o
m
u
e
e
a
l
i
o

e
l
r
u
t
d
t t
h
g
g
t o
s
a
e
e
t
d
a
a
i e
.
o
t r
i
s
u
t
e
s
s

e
f
r
c
b
h
h
n

r
g
b
r
w
o
a
t
i
g
o n
n

n
u
.

i
b
i
u
n
e
s

n
s
r
t

n
p
c
t

h
t
c

h
l
n
s

t
c
i
s
n

a
s
s l
i
n
n
a
r
t i s
e
o
l
o

m
c
s
o
o
o
c
i
e a

u
i
t a

t
:
u
s
c
s
r c
o
e
s
e

t r
a

i

l s
m t
t
n
a
i
x
i
:
e
i
i
t i
a
i
c
s
n r
d
a
s
o
f r
q

h
i i n
a
a a
t
e
n
s
c
i n
t
t
h
s

u
h

g d p
o m
e
e
t
a
o

i
a
r
b
n
c
o
e
c
l
e
t
a
n
c
h

a
i
e
t
c
i
h

r
e
c
o
o
c
l
o
n
t
o
r

g

h
i
n
g

e
i
e n
i

o
e
d
s
i
r
e
u
o
w
r
t e e e e
o
s
e
r
c
n
r
a
n
t
s
t
h
h
e
n
p

r
n
a u
n
r
g
t

n
u
w

r

e

g
r r
e
u
i o
h h h h
,
r r
h
o
e
o

e
d
e
o p t
p
v
e
e
t
f

p n
t

l
t
p a

o
i
g
c
e i F
a
r
a
c
s
n
a
e

t
d
s

s
t t t t
t
d f
t
h
h
r
a
h
t
u

t

l
u a
s
a
s
o
r
o
n
n
h
b
n
n
f h
c
u f

h
i
n
r

n
a
a
p
p
p
p
h
a
o
o
s
s
a
s c
a
m
t
r
a

I
i i
c
i
I
t
t
t
i
r n
e
e a

t
a

l
r

e
a
e
p
e
n t
i
e
e
r
r e
a
e
a
P
t
e
h
h
p
e
m
W
n
r
f
f h
r
l
T
T
T
a o
o a d
c
c
i
t

A
i
I
:
4
.
-
6
I
:
'
.
F
0
.
'
"
.
I
O
'
I
I
:
6
I
,
.
'
.

.
-
I
-
D
.
-
.
'
-
l
l
I
.
r
.
.
-
'
,
6
.
I
1
r
:
"

I
1
r
"
I
-
.
.
Z
6

.
,
6
:
.
-
-
1
0
-
1
1
.
-
.
6
.
.
I
!
-
0
1
1
'
6
0
6
6
.
.
0
i
6

.
l

e
:
'
.
o
6
D I
I
"
.
-

s
"
6

.
.
.
!

.
.
1
.
.
0
"
4
1

-
.
I
"

-
-
D
.
'
.
*
-
I :
:
.
.
I
.
V
:
I
.
:
S
4
D
I
.
"
V
'
.
.
"
"
.
.
-
6
6

-
-
8
.
'
e
s
6
O
O
B
4
.
S
6
.
-
l
-
d
-
a
r
s
n
u
s
a
n
7
i
.
.
e
8
o
o
g
m
t
:
r
e
o
e
t
n
9
C
1

t
-
h
n
n
i
r
.
r
h
o
n
a
e
t
9
"
s
i

D
p
i
a
a
g
u

m
o
d
i
e
m
i
4
1

r
t
N
m

,
q
n
t
r
e
.
r
h
.
.
g
o t
e

n
e
d
.
o
1
n
e
n

i
y
g
r
R
l
C
n
F
r
h
e
o
l

v
o
1
p
o
i
r
p
a
n
r
e
i
h
r
h
t

o

i
d
1
m
a
t
m
p

.
t

d
d
i
b
T
n
g
t
e
.
a
n
o
r
r
.
a
u

s
o
l
n
p
)

y

n
i
f
1
i
b

r
t
e
e
R
.

e
c
e
n
o
g

o
a
l
m
a
V
e
i
n

l
e
h
r
o
h
k
l

A n
l
a

w

e

d
C
h
g l
0
T
u
y
I
x
s
g
i
s
i
i
J

l
w
l
i
t
n
t
e
b
c
I
n
s

e
:

d
S
n
a
i

r
.
A
s
n
c
i
a
l
m
A
a

)
C
i
l
n
i
W
t
g

t
o
n
p
h
:
r
i
e
M
d
r
n N
m

a
e
l
n
o
e
h
c
o
m
s
g
l
e
e

o
I

b

i
E
a
.
r
t
P
W
t
i
n
h
i
M
.
t
)
1
t
c i
n
m
n
f
o
s
i
e
l
8
u

i

c

n

1

d
.
e
r
s
t
c
:

f
t
l
r
e 5
n
l
h
s
l
a
:
U
l o
0

a
o
e

a
d
a
i
s
f
c
r
2
e
e
g
w
e

o

e
.
s

u
c
e
e
u
r
d
l
e
3
e
-
r
i
r
l
a
a

R

e
r
n
d
s

6
t
d
e
a
s
D

e
n
h
u
d
s
o
w
.
H
e
n
a
s
9

y
l

p
o
l
t

i

e
l
o
g
e
p
u
h
R
.

A
a
e
n

f

i
6
n
g
o
t
S
s

m
c
t
c
m
.
c
w
r
e
a

n

a
4
9
i
n

e

e
o
a
l
E

t
f
e
a
a
o

i
9
s
1
c
i
g
S
o
i
f
r
h
f
e
c
s
d
C

r
n
h

m
'
a
1

n
s
l
t
o

v
d
e
u
.
a
n
a

o
d
n
n
(
r
N
y
e
i
i
t
s
m
n
w
l

e
b
e
t
o
d
a
i
e
i
i
a
o
i
.
c
s t
s
a

t
A
a
l
t
i
r
n
a

e
i
.
d
o
i

e
l
n
l
A
v

d
s
f
l
o
n
s
a

l
c

e
N

o
c
f
.
i
o
,

m g
e

e N
t
u
1
f
H
s
y
u "
h
n
g

c
t
e
c

n
t
n
r
h

f
7
e c
.
d

a
n

T
e
n
o
f
;
s

u
d
t
i
a
i
u
o
t
t
e

i
E
d

r
f
e
l
i
i

g
,
i

o d
a
t

V
b
d
o
D
.
r
f
u
f
t
n
a
n
g
s

)
r
o
a
o
e
p
o
a
p
f
\
i
t
e
r
e
e

e
e
n
o
o
d
s

a
m
e

r
&
e
o
r
e
e
e
m
v
s
n
r
R

i
r
i

a
p
h
r
m
h
l
0
p

d
R
R
e
r
. h
o
e

m
e

e
,
C
e
p

o
y

t
o
1
m
.

t
A
c
t
i
.
e
t
o
n

1

r
n
o

d
h
R
t
)
i
S
s c

l
/
(
.
i
e
f
a
c
h
c
a 6
i
.
e
f

e
n
e
l

o
u
c

l
n
e

e
f

g

'
p
e
s
f
e
l
T
9
n
,
t
r
O
?
v
.
d
o
a

t
c
r
t
o
n
v
o
i
n
u
e
a
g n
s
r
B
c
a
9
o
o
s
i

i
i

e
i
o
s
i
o

f
t
.
h
P n
o
i
e
D
D
d
t
r
n
r
1

i
N
o
/

e
n
d
d
e
o
t
a
t
.
t
e
l
t
n
g
i
t
e

a
s
)
o E
(

t
t
m
s

e
e

r
/
M
.
n
e
e

y
s

g
i
n
I
.
e
t
f
r
s
P
n
i

t
/
e
-
.
.
I
t
d
n
a
t
r
e
o
'
n
v
a
e
o
g
s
t
T
n
I
i
t
i
l
m

o
a
a
r
u a
n

d
I
r
a
i
o
.
T
r
i
e
s
b
l
m
e
l
O
e
2
i

u

a
.
t
m
v
c

e
p
e
b
n u
a
d
.
J
o
i

u
e
d
e
o
c
t
(

h
t
g
s
o
u
r
d
I

c
i n
x
g
n
e

t
c 3
r
o
c
r s
i
S
t
i
h
u
e
t
,
m
C
s
i
s
a
V
N
d
n
P
a
E
a
a
c
g
n
s
I
u
R
g
e
/
r
.
t
o
h
S
e

i

E
s

3
o
c
e

o
O

J
a

m
a
a

e
r
n
x
.
s
.
e

.
t
r

T
n
C
g
.
t
)
s
T
r
e
1
c
m
.
m
B

t
P
E
r
o
i
h
x
1
e
s
P
0 .

h
t
)
f
l
r
o
I
n
a
n

c
o
2
1
7
.

l
a
- n
w
o
l
3
e
M
t n
e
e

l
c

i
9
6
.
1
o

r

s
f
n
t
n
l
l
,
i

W
)
.

9
.
) t

a
l
o
e
e
i

C
d
g
6

a
1
. i
v a
r
,
p
o
i
f
l
(
s
9
9
w d
9 c
a
t
e

.
.
k
d
i
l
p
9
a
:
H
1
m
k
h
s
n
:
c
n
a
s
9
w
i
s
l
r
.
n
f
M
u
r

e
1
9
m
e

8
s
r
A a
d
n

n
I
m

e
l
1
'
)

r
c
&
c
t
e
d
i
e
e
1

n
a
e
a
W
r
t
l
r I
t
n f
1
(
1

9
l o
H
a
e

.

u
M
e
C
a
(
s
u
v
t
l
n
f
i
o

f
m
i
o
.
n
r
W
(

i
w
y
R
u
A
n

s
o
g
o
(
1
M
n
.
k
l
I
.
D
V
O

u

a

e
-
d
e
.
n h
J

t
i
.
t
A
s )
b
. r
c
o
i
s
1 H
e

(
,

i
o
.
, t
.
m
S
.
M

B
P

M
n
B

m
w

s
a
t
l .
5
o
. e w .
n

r
I
e
i
y
c
.

n
.
c

i
E
h
c
C
A
L .
F
M
.
h
.

a
J
a
V
e
f
T

E
d
G
1
n
C
M
e
.
.
M
D
R
g
l
.
o

i
.
i
.

n

u
p
l

o
N
.
n

!
t
t
V
g k

p
,
1
r
F

,

2
e
1

d
e
k

.
a

n n
d

h
g
V
H
.

e
s
d
.
p

r

:

,
i
l
.

o
.
e
d
V
I
e
n
e
1

.
u
w
1
k
g
t
.
M
E
y
r
r
t
s
1
E
N
c e y
i
d
n
r
s
e
r
.

s
.
n
C
a
r
s
p

a
a
b

r
\
D
n
i
s
e
r
s
a
h
e
;
a
r
n m
1
r

b r
i
c
.

e r
r
l
e
a

i
U
2
e
1
d
c
n
r
a
b
h
n
h
h
n
o
P
1 n
l
o
l
I
k
n
h
s i
n
1
l
t
a
i
w
i

m

u
:
m
u
v
k
s
w
m
d
t c
p i
a
i
e
a
r
i
t
.
e
R
t
c
n
c
r
I
2 h
r
d c
e
1
a
A
m

n
o
i

a
S
a
a
k
l
:
r
e
l
q
u
a
t
:
a
e
a
s
i
s
i
a
a
d
e
l
i
m
o
3
i
o
)
a
:
l
e u
2
A
I
h

i
R
B
R
i
i
K
K
B
M
1
n
A
L
0
e
. w
0
D
Y
N
n
f
R
e
S V
B
P P
c
B
C
A
1
T
J
J
l
1
s s
c
.
.
.
i
l
i
r
e
i i
l
R
:
.
f
-
"
0
:
I
.
!
4
.
O

.
-
"
D
I
:

'

0
M
.
0
.
:
-
-
.
:
-
0
D
0
1
.
I
I
:
I
"

1
-
1
,
1
s
:
.

.
.
.
.
.
:
:
.
:
4
.
.
I

4
.
.
.
.
-
:
.
:
-

-
.
4
'
:
.
.
.
.
:
-
0
-
.
0
I
: :
.
e
:
.
0
4
-
1
o
1

.
1
1
e
0
-
D
l
1
.
"
s
*
4
:
.
:
0
s
.
:
-
.
.
D
.
1
0
r
.
.
-
1
l
0
e
:
.
1
:
.
.
.
I
.
.

s
.
8
I
i
-
5
,
-
.
0
.
4
.
-
.
O
.
-
-
:
0
:

/
0
/
I
1
"
0
a
-
I
1
I
-
.
1
'
.
-
1
S
A
.
1
.
"
1
.
-
O
I
1
,
s
:
1
.
!
i
.
e
D
I
,
I
.
:
'
-
-
:

.
6
.
'
O

-
A
-
-
-
I
.
1
:
:
4
.
,

l
D
:
O

.
J
A
:
.
4
:
-
1
:
1
1
:
.
'

.
.
:
'
.
4
e
S
.
.

1
.
e
.
0
0
1
s
-
.
0
4
:
'
I
I
0

:
-
a
.
s
1
-
-
.
0
.
1
0
O
:
D
.
a
4
0
A
.
.
:
.
-
D
.
e
-
-

D
.
.
O
.
0
1
E
L
-
s
B
e
n
h
r
A
.
e
l
n
e
g
y
L
e
e
o
s
f
I
r
a
A
n
u
s
f
l
c
r
f
s
d
V
o

r
o
o
o

o
i
n
a
h
A
e
l
e
n
e
r
f
r

i

I
Y
t
v
h

n
l
n
o
s
e
h
h
t
o
i
e

P
a
a
o
t
u
w
o
.
m
e

c
t
h
O
h
n
e
e
t

r
i
c
e

,
C
d
s
p
t

t
m
o
t
t
h
y
o

b
o

e
a

n
a
e
T

g
c
i
a
,
c
g
d
i

f
S
t
t
o
a
t
o
n
d e
a
c
e
s

a
E
a
n
u
i
c
e
h
o
e
i
v

o
B
b
b
c
d
i
d
t
l
h
t
s

a
d
T

n
c
u
e
e
e

r
e
s
s
t
.
h
o
n
d
r
.
e
d
a
m
m

h
a
A
h
m
a
.
e
t
r
o
g
e
y
h
t

t
t
n g
a
r
m

w
e
c

a
s

r

g
e
u
r
s
n
e
e
d
g
u
i
r

h
g
h
n
o
a
o
c
l
e
e
r

a
n
t
n
a
t
t
o

i

t

n
c
W
b
h

n
s
y
d
e
a
i
n

s
s
r
e
e
t

n
n
e
h
a
p
a
n
t
o
r
e
i
b
c

s
i
o
m
r
o
,
e
h
t
v
.
i
i

s
w
e

.

g
s
t
i
R
h
f
t
g

e
a
r
t
u
e
t
u
s
t

u
n
c
o
t
r
v

n
h
s
i

t
e
0
r
q
d
o
l
e

i
i
a
e
f
i
a

c
f
a
s
r
d
2
e
n
d
s

e

t
h
o
h
t
a
s
n
s
d
s
a
s
r

t
a
s
a
c

r
e
n

o
i

a
e
e
i
c
e
e

s
p
n
y
r
a
h
r
d
g
i

r
y
w
r
i
l
u

o
o
e
t
n
e
t

l
o

n
r
a
a

f
s
l
b
l
e
c
i
r
a
o

f
o
n
a
i
o
o
t
s
l
p
d
r
o
n
m
u
d
i
f
p
t
h
r
i
o
h

s
p
n

o

o
p

g
a
e
l

h
o
c
l

h t
a
a
s
l
t
t
c
e
e

n
a

c
s

a
p
n
d
c

h

i

r
a
h
c
t
i
d

u

c
f

I
s

e
t
s
h
d

s
i
g
t
n
o

a
i
m
n

e
t

t
c
e
a
c
n
w
,
n
o
i
e
i
n
i
s
b
h
i

l
a

a

n
i
r
t
d
e
n
e
s
o
t

s

t
w
e

n
u
e
o
c
r

c
n
d
o
o
p
s
e
t
,
u
h
o
i
i
i
o
i
d

r
a
e
t

s
h
g
n
s
n
e
t
e
a
l

e
c
n
s
a
p
e
s
o
h
o
l
h

v
e
e
o
o
h
l
r
b

h
h
t
c
s
i
r
i
r
r
f

p
c

e
p
a
p
i
d
e
p
a p

e
u
g
s
e
c
f

v
e
n
x
n
W
f
f
e
f
h
e
m
e
T
o
o
a
e
a
u
o
r
r
l
t
ERIC
U.S. Department of Education
Office of Educational Research and Improvement (OERI)
National Library of Education (NLE)
Educational Resources Information Center (ERIC)
NOTICE
REPRODUCTION BASIS
This document is covered by a signed "Reproduction Release
(Blanket) form (on file within the ERIC system), encompassing all
or classes of documents from its source organization and, therefore,
does not require a "Specific Document" Release form.
This document is Federally-funded, or carries its own permission to
reproduce, or is otherwise in the public domain and, therefore, may
be reproduced by ERIC without a signed Reproduction Release form
(either "Specific Document" or "Blanket").
EFF-089 (9/97)