Environmental Law 1996: Vol 26 Table of Contents

329 Pages·1996·54.3 MB·English

ENVIRONMENTAL LAW
Northwestern School of Law
of Lewis & Clark College
TWENTY-FIVE YEAR INDEX
TABLE OF AUTHORS
TABLE OF THELES, is”
DIGEST
Supplement to
Northwestern School of Law
of Lewis & Clark College
Environmental Law
Volume 26, Number 4
Environmental law.v.1-
spring 1970-
Portland, Or., Northwestern School of Law
v. 28 cm.
1. Environmental law—U.S.—Periodicals.
I. Northwestern School of Law.
K5.N85 344’.73°04605 75-31918
ISSN 0046-2276
Cite as 26 Envri. L. __ (1996)
Fam Use Copyricut PERMISSION
Except as otherwise expressly provided, the author of each contribution in this issue has
granted permission for copies of that contribution to be made and used by nonprofit educa-
tional institutions provided that: (1) copies are made at or below cost; (2) the author and
Environmental Law are identified; (3) proper notice of copyright is affixed to each copy;
and (4) the user gives notice to EnvironmentaLalw of each use.
Manuscript SUBMISSION
Environmental Law welcomes responsible comment from all sides of any environmental
legal issue. Manuscripts submitted to Environmental Law will not be returned unless
accompanied by a self-addressed, postage paid envelope. All manuscripts submitted must
be submitted in hard copy with footnotes. Citations should conform with THe BLUEBOOK:
A Unirorm System or Crration (16th ed. 1996). Send manuscripts to Articles Editor,
Environmental Law, at the address below.
SUBSCRIPTION AND Back Issue INFORMATION
Send subscription requests with payment to the address below. Rates are $30.00 per year,
$10.00 per issue in current volume, and $12.00 for current symposium issues. Foreign rates
are $38.pe0r y0ea r, $12.00 per issue, and $14.00 for current symposium issues. Subscrip-
tions are renewed annually unless cancellation is requested. Change of address notifica-
tions should include old and new addresses, with zip codes. Please notify our office one
month in advance of effective date to ensure delivery. Order back issues from Fred B.
Rothm&a Cno. , 10368 W. CenteRoand, nLiittlaetoln, CO 80127, phone number (800) 457-
1986. Back issue rates start at $14.00 per issue. For bound volume rates inquire to Roth-
man directly.
GENERAL INFORMATION
EnvironmentaLalw is published quarterly by the students of Northwestern School of Law
of Lewis & Clark College, 10015 SW Terwilliger Blvd., Portland, OR 972in1 the9 Sp,rin g,
SumFmalle, anrd W,int er. The views expressed in this volume do not necessarily reflect
those of the editoriboaarld .
The cover is a scene along the northern Oregon coast, looking south from Ecola State Park
toward Cannon Beach and Haystack Rock.
EnvirLoaw nis mprinetedn ont unablelache d, 100% recycled, 50% post consumpeapre r
wistoyh in k.
Application to mail at second-class postage rates is pending at Portland, OR and additional
mailing offices. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to Environmental Law, 10015 SW
TerwiBllvd.l, iPorgtlaendr, OR 97219.
Copyright © 1996 by Environmental Law.
10015 S.W. Terwilliger Blvd.
ay Portland, Oregon 97219 ZB [PRINTED WITH
ee phone [phone] Olsoy ink
fax [phone]
e-mail [email protected]
Member of the National Conference of Law Reviews
ENVIRONMENTAL LAW
Northwestern School of Law
of Lewis & Clark College
ENVIRONMENTAL LAW
Northwestern School of Law
of Lewis & Clark College
25 Year INDEX
EDITORIAL BOARD
Editor in Chief
Dover A. Norris-YORK
Notes and Comments Editors
Articles Editors Joan M. NocKELs
Cart E. Brucu R. CaMMON TURNER
Roem K. Craic Ninth Circuit Review Editor
Form and Style Editors Kuen
JENNIE BRICKER** Current Materials Editor
ALAN L. MrrcHELL CHap W. MILLER
Associate Editors
Davip AMAN MICHAEL KING
R. CHRISTOPHER BECKWITH Joun M. Lotz
Ciare E. BENDER Kirstin E. Lurtz
Bruce A. BRADLEY Douctias D. Morris
MICHAEL CRAWFORD* JENNIFER PEET
Sraria K. Di Douc PEeTrRINA
Patrick M. EsBEetr ANDREW REILLY
DEBORAH FITZGERALD Kurt Rouirs
Lee A. FrrEDMAN JosHuA SASAKI
Steven HuLi MIcHAEL A. SCHOESSLER
MICHAEL JONES Jason T. WILSON
MICHELE KAMINSKI
Members
JAMES ABNEY Sara DENNISTON Danie. J. MUNLEY
CHRISTINA AUSTIN Connie DUGGER DEBORAH NELSON
MrrcHE.t C. BAKER Dan L. Duyck ANDREW H. OGNALL**
K.C. BECKER JAMES EAGER** MrrcHELL OLSON
Prur M. BENDER MicHELLE D. HotMAN Karta Raetric**
Garry Brecxon** Linpa A. HoLMEs Jason Rinc**
JENNIFER ByRNE** Curis JAYARAM Ho.ty J. Somers**
Davip A. CHRISTENSEN Smcoo LEE Mike SuPANCICH
Paut CONABLE Rossin D. Levy RICHELLE Tustin**
MicuakEt D. CorRIGAN Ketity MELTZER Herp: Van Kirk
Aptna CUNNINGHAM Juure Weis**
Faculty Advisors
Micuae. C. BLumM James L. HUFFMAN JANET C. NEUMAN
WituaM F. Funk Craic N. JOHNSTON JANICE L. WEIS
Law Review Program Assistant
THERESA EDWARDS
* Recipient 1995-96 Law Review Excellence Award
** 1996-97 Elected Editorial Board Members
ENVIRONMENTAL LAW
Northwestern School of Law
of Lewis & Clark College
25 Year INDEX
EDITORIAL BOARD
Editor in Chief
Kara A. RAETTIG
Managing Editors
Ho.ty J. Somers
RICHELLE M. Tustin
Articles Editors Notes and Comments Editors
JENNIFER L. BYRNE Garry BRECKON
JuuIE WEIS
Ninth Circuit Review Editor
Jm EaGarR
Form and Style Editors
JENNIE BRICKER Current Materials Editor
ANDREW HAMILTON OGNALL Jason R. Rinc
Associate Editors
JAMES ABNEY Linpa Homes
Curistina A. AUSTIN K. CHRISTOPHER JAYARAM
Pumur M. BENDER Sircoo LEE
Pau. CONABLE MrTcHELL R. OLSON
Dan L. Duyck MicHAEL SUPANCICH
Candidates
PETER ALLEN JENNIFER LANFRANCO
Ivan J. LIEBEN
ALEX CHEN STEPHEN Lowry
Topp B. WESTERSUND
Faculty Advisors
James L. HUFFMAN JANET C. NEUMAN
CraiG N. JOHNSTON * Janice L. Weis
Law Review Program Assistant
THERESA EDWARDS
‘
NORTHWESTERN SCHOOL OF LAW
OF LEWIS & CLARK COLLEGE
ADMINISTRATION
Michael Mooney, A.B., S.T.L., M. Phil., Ph.D., Lee Gadinas, B.S., J.D., Assoc. Dean, Admin.
President, Lewis & Clark College Afirs.
James Huffman, B.S., M.A., J.D., Dean, Prof. Scott W. Staff, B.A., J.D., Ass’t Dean, Dev. &
of Law External Rels.
Martha Spence, B.A., J.D., Assoc. Dean, Acad. Susan Galyen, Registrar
Affrs. Stella K. Manabe, B.A., J.D., Dir., Affirm.
Peter NycuB.Am. ,LL. B., M.L.S., Prof. & Action/Acad. Support Prog.
Assoc. Dean, Library & ComputeSerrv . Paula Roucka, Dir. Adms.
Natura Resources & ENVIRONMENTAL Law PROGRAM
Janice L. Weis, B.S., J.D., Dir., Natural Brett Swift, B.A., J.D., Research Atty. for
Resources & Envil. Law Prog. NRLI & NW Water Law Proj.
Eric Lemelson, B.A., J.D., Ass’t Dir., NW ——. BS., J.D., NRLI Sr. Advocacy
Water Law Proj.
Myri Duncan, B.A., J.D., LL.M., J.S.D., NRLI Chris Wold, B.A., J.D., Natural Resources
Annual Fellow Student Advisor
FACULTY
Paula Abrams, B.A., J.D. Arthur LaFrance, B.A., J.D.
James Bailey, B.S., M.A., J.D. Ronald Lansing, B.A., J.D.
Assistant Professor Donald Large, B.A., LL.B.
Susan Mandiberg, B.A., M.S., J.D.
Laurie Mapes, B.A., J. D.,
Visiting Prof., Spring
Bart McGuire, B.A., J.D.
Visiting Prof., Spring
Robert Myers, B.S., J.D.
Prof. Emeritus
Janet C. Neuman, B.A., J.D.
Douglas Newell, B.A., J.D.
Gordon Smith, B.S., J.D.
Janet Steverson, B.A., J.D.
Lewis & Ciark Lecat Cumnic Facutty
Richard A. Slottee, B.S., J.D., Director
Gerald Brask, Jr., B.A., J.D.
Sandra A. Hansberger, B.A., J.D.
Mark A. Peterson, B.A., J.D.
Theresa L. Wright, B.A., J.D.
ApsguncT FAcuLty
Yvonne Lawson, A.B., J.D.
Frederic!
Larry Sokol, B.A., J. D.
Micah Stolowitz, BS., J.D.
Edward Sullivan, BA, J.D.
John Thomas, B.A., J.D.
Honorable Richard L. Unis, B.S., J.D.
Lawrence Watters, B.A., J.D., LL.M.
Kenneth Weber, B.S., J.D.
Chris Wold, B.A., J.D.
TABLE OF AUTHORS
America’s Waters: A New Era of Sustainability: Report of the Long’s Peak
Working Group on National Water Policy
Colloquium on Dolan v. City of Tigard
Colloquium on Lucas
Federal Land Use Planning Conference, March 20-22, 1975
In Memory of Rose Gangle, 1986-87 Form and Style Editor
Long’s Peak Report: Reforming National Water Policy
Northwest Power Act Symposium
Nuclear Power Symposium
Oregon Land Use Symposium
Panet Discussion, Colloquium: Who Runs the River? ...........cceeeeeeees 25:417
Pane. Discussion, The Takings Clause and the Future of Environmental
Regulation
Symposium on Columbia River Resources
Symposium on Effects of Fasano on Land Use Decision-Making
Symposium on Federal Forest Law and Policy
Symposium on Federal Lands Forest Policy
Symposium on Federalism and the Environment: A Change in Direction . 12:847
Symposium on Health Hazards in the Environment: The Interface of
Symposium on Integrated Pollution Control
Symposium on NEPA at Twenty: The Past, Present and Future of the
National Environmental Policy Act
Symposium on Salmon Law
Symposium on the Clean Air Act Amendments of 1990
Symposium on the Endangered Species Act at Twenty-One: Issues of
Reauthorization
Symposium on the Public Trust and the Waters of the American West:
Symposium on Waste Management Law and Policy
Aaron, Ricuarp L., Bankruptcy Stays of Environmental Regulation: Harvest
of Commercial Timbeasr a n Introduction to a Claof sPolhici es
ACHTERMAN, Gat, Strategies for Minimizing Hazardous Wastes in
Oregon
ACKERMAN, Bruce A., The Jurisprudence of Just Compensation
ACKERMAN, Stark, Forest and Range Policy: Its Development in the United
ACKERMAN, Stark, Observations on the Transfoofr tmhe aFortesit Soernvic e:
The Effects of the National Environmental Policy Act on U.S. Forest
Service Decision Making
Apter, Rosert W., Addressing Barriers to Watershed Protection
(1)
2 ENVIRONMENTAL LAW [Vol. 26:1
Auesst, Diane L., MarciaJ . WRIGANHD TMar,y P. Trewer, Shifting the
Burden of Proof in State Environmental Protection Acts: A Blessing to
Environmental Plaintiffs
ALEXANDER, JAMES E., Aluminum Co. of America v. Central Lincoln Peoples’
Atston, Ricnarp M. anp Con H. Scuattau, The Commitment to Community
Sembetite: A Pabices OF GRABBCNGP 6 aoc iccccctacccccscssccccccccevecesese 17:429
Atsup, Lauri, The Right to Protect Property
ALTERMAN, DEAN N., Reflected Sunlight Is a Nuisance
Avusuin, Micuast S., Enforcement of the Clean Air Act Amendments of
ANDERSON, ANTHONY A. AND WiiuiaM L. Kovacs, States as Market Participants
in Solid Waste Disposal Services—Fair Competition or the Destruction of
I org ek ek eh ek sels nanine ne haawne aae'ss 18:779
ANDERSON, H. Micuaet, Water Quality Planning for the National Forests ...17:591
Anton, Donan K., JENNIFER KoHout, AND Nicota Pawn, Nationalizing
Environmental Protection in Australia: The International Dimensions . . 23:763
APPLEGATE, Rick, The Multiple Use Planning Process: Descent into the
SET 54 wal iiredeensadaspt de eNatenietnik ne tna delaeSitnne a6 8:427
Arp, Beverty JANE AND Micuaet B. Huston, The Public Trust Doctrine in
Oregon
ArmiraGE, Saran, Federal “Consistency” Under the Coastal Zone
Management Act—Promise Broken by Secretary of the Interior v.
ARMSTRONG, JAMES J. AND JAMES A.R. Narzicer, The Porpoise-Tuna
Controversy: Management of Marine Resources After Committee for
Humane Legislation, Inc. v. Richardson :
ATCHESON, JOHN, The Department of Risk Reduction or Risky Business ....21:1375
AXELSEN, Kaarin L., Problems of Punitive Damages for Political Protest and
Civil Disobedience
Axuine, Micnaet, (Out) Back in the USSR: A Review of Charles Zeigler’s
Environmental Policy in the USSR
Bassrrt, Bruce E., The Endangered Species Act and “Takings”: A Call for
Innovation Within the Terms of the Act
Bassirt, Bruce E., Federalism and the Environment: An
Intergovernmental Perspective of the Sagebrush Rebellion
Bassrrt, Bruce E., The Public Interest in Western Water -
BapEN, JoHN A. AND Ricuarp L. Stroup, Response to Krutilla and Haigh.... 8:417
Bamey, J, Sustainable Development: Searching for the Grail or a Wild
?
Batpock, Davin anp Epwarp Keene, Incorporating Environmental
Considerationsi n Common Market Arrangements
Batt, Muner S., Good Old American Permits: Madisonian Federalism on
the TerritorSeiaa aln d Continental Shelf
Batmer, Donap, From Symbiosis to Synergy: A Case Study of Public and
Private Electric Power in the Pacific Northwest
Batmer, THomas A., Of Energy, Antitrust and Institutional Competence: A
Note on Alabama Power Co. v. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
BatmMerR, THomas A., RecombinanDNtA : Legal Respontso ae sNe w
1996] ' 25 YEAR INDEX
Baram, Micuaet S., Multinational Corporations, Private Codes, and
Technology Transfer for Sustainable Development
Bartow, Tom, Evolution of the National Forest Management Act of 1976 ... 8:539
BarnetTT, Pour S., THE HonoraBLte Henry A. WAXMAN, AND GrEGorY S.
WetstToneE, Cars, Fuels, and Clean Air: A Review of Title II of the Clean
Air Act Amendments of 1990
Barnett, Puiu S., THE Honoraste Henry A. WAXMAN, AND Grecory S.
WetstonE, Roadmap to Title I of the Clean Air Act Amendments of 1990:
Bringing Blue Skies Back to America’s Cities
BarkETT, JANE, Sentencing Environmental Crimes Under the United States
Sentencing Guidelines—A Sentencing Lottery
Barry, Donatp J., Amending the Endangered Species Act, The Ransom of
Red Chief, and Other Related Topics
BarRTFELD, EstHer, Point-Nonpoint Source Trading: Looking Beyond
Potential Cost Savings
Barton, Grecory P., RCRA Leachate Testing Regulations: Is the
Groundwater Safe? Are We Safe? ........cccecccccccccccccccceccceeceees 22:387
Bauman, JuprrH C. anp Joun C. Piatt, May a State Say “No” to Nuclear
Power?:Pacific Legal Foundation Gives a Disappointing Answer
BaureEr, THEODORE, Love Canal: Common Law Approaches to a Modern
Baum, Victoria SHortT, Dave Canary, EviaBetH K. REEVE, AND C. BRIAN
Scott, Negative NEPA: The Decision Not to File
Bean, MicwacEt J., Review of The Endangered Species Act: A Guide to Its
Protections and Implementation
Beauralt, KATHLEEN AND JACK G. Co.uins, Financing Pollution Control
Facilities: Oregon’s Constitutional Amendment
Beuan, R.W., Political Popularity and Conceptual Nonsense: The Strange
Case of Sustained Yield Forestry
Bett, D. Craic AND Norman K. Jounson, State Water Laws and Federal
Water Uses: The History of Conflict, the Prospectfso r Accommodation ...
BENFIELD, F. Karp, The Administrative Record and the Range of Alternatives
in National Forest Planning: Applicable Standards and Inconsistent
Approaches
BENFIELD, F. Kaw, Running on Empty: The Case for a Sustainable National
Transportation System
BENNETT, Kya SELIGSOHN, Mismanaging Endangered and “Exotic” Species
in the National Parks
BENNETT, JOHN A., Introduction
BENNETT, Laurie A., Prah v. Maretti, 108 Wis. 2d 233, 321 N.W.2d 182
BENNETT, LauRIE A. AND JENNIFER J. JoHNSON, Introduction
Bere, Emu R., Private Ocean Ranching of Pacific Salmon and Fishery
Management: A Problem of Federalism
Bercer, Apam, An Insider’s Perspective on Northwest Resource Information
Center v. Northwest Power Planning Council
BERNSTEIN, JAMES E., Penny HazELTON, AND Dennis J. HuBet, Clearcutting:
Can You See the Foresfto r the Trees?
Bwen, Jr., Joserx R., The Environment and World Trade
Breser, James, Calvert Cliffs’ Coordinating Committee v. AEC: The AEC
Learns the True Meaning of the National Environmental Policy Act of
dq ENVIRONMENTAL LAW [Vol. 26:1
Bisaccio, Gary A., Goose Hollow Foothills League v. Romney: When Is an
Environmental-Impact Statement Required?
Back, Tom, Population Criteria of Oregon and the United States in the
Siting of Nuclear Power Plants
BLACKMAN, STEPHEN Epwarp, Bad Faith and the EAJA: A Proposal for Strict
Scrutiny of Government Fee Litigation Under the EAJA
Buarr, Jr., Bowen, The Columbia River Gorge National Scenic Area: The
Act, Its Genesis and Legislative History
BLANCHARD, Dona.p H., Clearcutting the Bull Run Watershed: A Standard of
Reasonableness in Forest Service Decision-Making :
Biank, Linpa D., Seeking Solutions to Environmental Inequity: The
Environmental Justice Act
Biocn, Ivan, Nuclear Power Plant Proliferation: A Citizen Continues to
Bock, JosepH G. AND Nancy A. Voisin, The Responsible Corporate Officer
Doctrine—Can You Go to Jail for What You Don’t Know?
Biomauist, Rosert F., Beyond the EPA and OTA Reports: Toward a
Comprehensive Theory and Approach to Hazardous Waste Reduction in
Biomauist, Rosert F., The EPA Science Advisory Board’s Report on
“Reducing Risk”: Some Overarching Observations Regarding the Public
Bium, Brian, NEPAWOCKY, A Panegyric Verse
Buiumm, Micnae: C., Aluminum Co. of America v. Central Lincoln Peoples’
Utility District and Some Myths About Northwest Electric Power
Policymaking: A Call for Continued Judicial “Hard Looks”
Biumm, Micnaet C., Columbia Basin Salmon and the Courts: Reviving the
Biumm, Micuaet C., Federalism, Hydroelectric Licensing and the Future of
Minimum Streamfiows After California v. Federal Regulatory Energy
Biumm, Micwaet C., Fulfilling the Parity Promise: A Perspective on
Scientific Proof, Economic Cost, and Indian Treaty Rights in the
Approval of the Columbia Basin Fish and Wildlife Program
Biumm, Micnae.C. , Hydropowervs . Salmon: The Struogf tghe lPaecif ic
Northwest’s Anadromous Fish Resources for a Peaceful Coexistence with
the Federal Columbia River Power System
Biumm, Micuast C., Implementing the Parity Promise: An Evaluation of
the Columbia Basin Fish and Wildlife Program
Biumm, Micuaet C., Pinchot, Property Rights, and Western Water: (A Reply
—_ Micnagt C., Property Myths, Judicial Activism, and the Lucas
BRc n aN 8 A CT as of Western
Water Law: A Modern View of the Public Trust Doctrine
Brum, Micuaet C., Reexamining the Parity Promise: More Challenges
than Successes to the Implementation of the Columbia Basin Fish and
Buumm, Micuaet C., Risk Management and Northwest Electric Power
Planning: Some Lessons from the Rearview Mirror