Addis Ababa University School of Graduate Studies Comparative study of the psychosocial functioning of children with visual impairment in integrated and Special school settings Senait G /Medhin July, 2006 Addis Ababa University School of Graduate Studies Comparative study of the psychosocial functioning of children with visual impairment in integrated and Special school settings Senait G/Medhin July, 2006 Comparative study of the psychosocial functioning of children with visual impairment in integrated and Special school settings • A thesis submitted to the School of Graduate Studies of Addis Ababa University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts in Special Needs Education Senait G/Medhin July, 2006 Addis Ababa • • Addis Ababa University School of Graduate Studies Comparative study of the psychosocial functioning of children with visual impairment in integrated and Special school settings Senait G /Medhin Department of Psychology Approval of Board of Examiners Chairman, Department Graduate Committee ture ~ Acknowledgment I would like to express my gratitude to Dr.R.S.Kumar for giving me his valuable advice through out the year. I am very grateful to some of my class mates, measurement and evaluation post graduate student (Addis zemen Hawas) and Special needs post graduate student (Reta Kumsa) who helped me when I face difficulties in my work. Finally, my thanks also go to my families for their financial and moral support. Table of Contents Acknowledgment -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Table of contents --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- II List of tables --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- v • List of figures ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- VII Acronyms ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- VIII Abstract -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- IX Chapter One: Introduction -------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1.1. Background of the problem/study ------------------------------------------------------ • 1.1.1. Background of Efficacy studies _____________________________________________ 1 1.1.2. Characteristics of segregation --------------------------------------------- 2 I.I.2.a. Definition of segregation ----------------------------------------- 2 I.I.2.b. The concept of segregation --------------------------------------- 3 I.l.2.c. Rational for segregation / segregated education --------------- 4 1. 1.3. Characteristics of integration ----------------------------------------------- 4 1.1.3.a. Definition of integration ------------------------------------------ 4 I.I.3.b. The concept of integration -------------------------------------- 5 I.I.3.c. Forms of Integration ---------------------------------------------- 6 -- 1.1.3.d. Rational for integration -----------------------.::'------------------ 8 1 1.2. Concepts in psychosocial functioning ------------------------------------------------- 9 1.2.1. The conce 10 • 1.2.2. The concep 11 ~=:::;~-:- 1.2.3. The concept of psychological adjustment to handicap ------------------- 11 (lp. The concept of social skill ----------------------------~---------------------_c£I:D 1.2.5. The concept of independence ----------------------------------------------- 14 1.2.6. The concept of social adjustment to handicap ---------------------------- 15 1.3. Statement of the problem ---------------------------------------------------------------- 16 1A. Objectives of the problem --------------------------------------------------------------- 17 1A. 1. General objectives ------------------------------------------------------------ 17 1.4.2. Speci fic objectives ------------------------------------------------------------ 17 11 1. 5. ignificance of the study --------------------------------------------------------------- 18 1.6. Delimitation of the study ---------------------------------------------------------------- 18 1. 7. Limitations of the study ---------------------------------------------------------------- 19 1.8. perational definition of terms --------------------------------------------------------- 19 • t Chapter Two : Review of related literature --------------------------------------------------------- 21 2.1. Historical development of Education for the blind ----------------------------------- 21 2.2. Blind education in Ethiopia ------------------------------------------------------------- 22 2.3. Special versus integrated education -------------------------------------------------- 24 2.3.1. Efficacy Studies 24 • 2.3.2. The efficacy of special versus integrated education on the psychological functioning of children with visual impairment---------------- 26 2.3.2.a. Self- esteem ------------------------------------------------------- 26 2.3.2.a.l. Comparison of the self- esteem of Children with visual impairment in integrated and special schools --------- 26 tl 2.3 .2.b. Self -confidence -------------------------------------------------- 30 2.3.2.b.l. Comparison of self- confidence of children with visual impairment in integrated and special schools --------- 30 2.3.2.c. Psychological adjustment to handicap ------------------------- 33 2.3 .2.c.l. Comparison of psychological adjustment of children with visual impairment in integrated and special schoo I s -------------------------------------------------------------- 33 2.3.3. The efficacy of special and integrated education on the social functioning of children with visual impairment -------------------------------- 36 / 2.3.3 .a. Social skill --------------------------------------------------------- 36 2.3.3.a.1. Comparison of the social skill of children with visual impairment in integrated and special schools---------- 36 2.3.3. b. Independence ----------------------------------------------------- 39 2.3.3.b.l. Comparison of the independence of children with visual impairment in integrated and special schools --------- 39 111 2.3.3.c. ocial Adjustment to handicap --------------------------------- 42 2.3.3.c.l. Comparison of the social adjustment of children with visual impairment in integrated and special schools----- 42 • • hapter Three : Methodology ----------------------------------------------------------------------- 46 3.1. ources of data /subjects ---------------------------------------------------------------- 46 3.2. Instrum en ts -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 48 3.3. Data collection proced ure --------------------------------------------------------------- 54 3.3.1. The pilot study ---------------------------------------------------------------- 54 3.3.2. The main study ---------------------------------------------------------------- 55 3.4. Statistical treatment and analysis of data -------------------------------------------- 56 3.4.1. Independent variable --------------------------------------------------------- 56 3.4.2. Dependent variables --------------------------------------------------------- 56 3.4.3. Intervening variables --------------------------------------------------------- 56 3.4.4. Data analysis ------------------------------------------------------------------ 57 Chapter Four: Result ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 58 Chapter Fi ve : Discussion ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- 85 Chapter Six: Summary and Conclusion ------------------------------------------------------------ 103 Recommendation --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 104 References Appendices IV List of Tables Page Table 1: Form of integration adapted from Soder (1980) ---------------------------- 6 Table 2: Cascade model of integration by Gear heart and Weishahn --------------- 8 Table 3: Background information of children with visual impairment in the two • • schools----------------------------------------------------------------------------- 47 Table 4: Sex, age. grade level and the educational settings of children with visual im pairmen t- --------------------------------------------------------------- 58 Tabl 5: Severity (of the problem), age of onset and presence of other di sa b iii ti es------------------------------------------------------------------------- 60 Table 6: Data and result of t-test on self confidence between children with visual impairment in integrated and Special Schools ------------------------------- 62 Table 7: Data and result of t-test on self - esteem between children with visual impairment in integrated and Special Schools ------------------------------- 62 Table 8: Data and result of t-test on psychological adjustment between children with visual impairment in integrated and Special Schools----------------- 63 Table 9: Data and result of t-test on social adjustment between children with visual impairment in integrated and Special Schools----------------------- 63 Table 10: Data and result of t-test on Social skills (as perceived by their teachers) between children with visual impairment in integrated and Special Schools ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- 64 Table 11: Data and result of t-test on functional independence between children with visual impairment in integrated and Special Schools----------------- 64 • Table 12: Data and result of t-test on the psychosocial functioning of children with Visual impairment in integrated and Special Schools ---------------- 65 Table 13: Summary of the t-test result on self-confidence, self-esteem psychological adjustment, social adjustment, social skill functional independence and psychosocial functioning of children with Visual impairment in integrated and Special chools ------------------------------- 66 Table 14: elf-confidence of children in special and integrated school as perceived by their teachers and care giver ---------------------------------- 67 v t Tabl 15: elf-e teem of children in special and integrated school as perceived by th ir teachers and care gi vers -------------------------------------------------- 70 Table 16: Psychological adjustment of children in special and integrated school as perceived by their teachers and care givers ---------------------------------- 73 Table 17: Social adjustment of children in special and integrated school as perceived by their teachers and care givers ---------------------------------- 75 Table 18: Social skill of children in special and integrated school as perceived by their teachers and care givers -------------------------------------------------- 78 Table 19: Functional independence of children in special and integrated school as perceived by their teachers and care givers ---------------------------------- 79 Table 20: Psychosocial functioning of children in special and integrated school as perceived by their teachers and care givers ---------------------------------- 82 • VI •
Description: