Discourse on the Move: Using corpus analysis to describe discourse structure (Studies in Corpus Linguistics)

304 Pages·2007·11.97 MB·English

by  Ulla Connor, Douglas Biber, Thomas A. Upton

Discourse on the Move
Studies in Corpus Linguistics (SCL)
SCL focuses on the use of corpora throughout language study, the development
of a quantitative approach to linguistics, the design and use of new tools for
processing language texts, and the theoretical implications of a data-rich
discipline.
General Editor Consulting Editor
Elena Tognini-Bonelli Wolfgang Teubert
Te Tuscan Word Center/ University of Birmingham
Te University of Siena
Advisory Board
Michael Barlow Graeme Kennedy
University of Auckland Victoria University of Wellington
Douglas Biber Geofrey N. Leech
Northern Arizona University University of Lancaster
Marina Bondi Anna Mauranen
University of Modena and Reggio Emilia University of Helsinki
Christopher S. Butler Ute Römer
University of Wales, Swansea University of Hannover
Sylviane Granger Michaela Mahlberg
University of Louvain University of Liverpool
M.A.K. Halliday Jan Svartvik
University of Sydney University of Lund
Susan Hunston John M. Swales
University of Birmingham University of Michigan
Stig Johansson Yang Huizhong
Oslo University Jiao Tong University, Shanghai
Volume 28
Discourse on the Move. Using corpus analysis to describe discourse structure
Douglas Biber, Ulla Connor and Tomas A. Upton
Discourse on the Move
Using corpus analysis
to describe discourse structure
Douglas Biber
Northern Arizona University
Ulla Connor
Tomas A. Upton
Indiana University – Indianapolis
John Benjamins Publishing Company
Amsterdam / Philadelphia
TM Te paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of
American National Standard for Information Sciences – Permanence of
Paper for Printed Library Materials, ansi z39.48-1984.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Biber, Douglas.
Discourse on the move : using corpus analysis to describe discourse structure / Douglas
Biber, Ulla Connor, Tomas A. Upton.
p. cm. (Studies in Corpus Linguistics, issn 1388-0373 ; v. 28)
Includes bibliographical references and index.
1. Discourse analysis--Data processing. I. Connor, Ulla, 1948- II. Upton, Tomas
A. (Tomas Albin) III. Title.
P302.3.B53 2007
401'.41--dc22 2007029145
isbn 978 90 272 2302 9 (Hb; alk. paper)
© 2007 – John Benjamins B.V.
No part of this book may be reproduced in any form, by print, photoprint, microflm, or any
other means, without written permission from the publisher.
John Benjamins Publishing Co. · P.O. Box 36224 · 1020 me Amsterdam · Te Netherlands
John Benjamins North America · P.O. Box 27519 · Philadelphia pa 19118-0519 · usa
8
Table of contents
Preface xi
chapter 1
Discourse analysis and corpus linguistics 1
1 Discourse and discourse analysis 1
1.1 Discourse studies of language use 3
1.2 Discourse studies of linguistic structure ‘beyond the sentence’ 4
1.3 Discourse studies of social practices and ideological assumptions associ-
ated with communication 6
1.4 “Register” and “genre” perspectives on discourse 7
1.5 Identifying structural units in discourse 9
2 Corpus-based investigation of discourse structure 10
3 Top-down versus bottom-up corpus-based approaches to discourse
analysis 12
3.1 Examples of top-down analyses of discourse 14
3.2 Example of bottom-up approach 16
4 Creating a specialized corpus for discourse analysis 17
5 Overview of the book 19
Part 1. Top-down analyses of discourse organization
chapter 2
Introduction to move analysis 23
WITH Budsaba Kanoksilapatham
1 Background 23
2 Swales’ move analysis of research articles 25
3 Move analysis of research articles applied across genres 29
3.1 Description and examples 29
3.2 Summary of previous research on move analysis 32
4 Overview of the methods for move analysis 32
4.1 General steps of a move analysis 32
 Discourse on the Move
4.2 Inter-rater reliability 35
5 Using a corpus-based approach to move analysis 36
5.1 Corpus-based move analysis 36
5.2 General advantages of corpus-based approaches to discourse analysis 37
5.3 Specifc advantages of a corpus-based perspective for move analysis 38
5.3.1 Identifying linguistic features of moves 38
5.3.2 Move frequencies and lengths 39
5.3.3 Mapping move use and locations 39
5.3.4 Genre prototypes 40
6 Summary 40
chapter 3
Identifying and analyzing rhetorical moves in philanthropic discourse 43
1 Background 43
2 A specialized corpus of fundraising texts 44
3 Determining and analyzing discourse moves: Direct mail letters 46
3.1 Previous analysis of direct mail letters 46
3.2 A move analysis of fundraising letters: Background and methodology 46
3.2.1 Move types 46
3.2.2 Structural elements 52
3.3 Analysis 54
3.4 Results 55
3.5 Discussion 57
3.6 Letter prototypes 58
4 Linguistic analysis of moves: Tracking the use of stance structures 61
4.1 Identifying grammatical stance devices 62
4.2 Interpreting the use of grammatical stance devices used in moves 63
5 Final thoughts 68
chapter 4
Rhetorical moves in biochemistry research articles 73
BY Budsaba Kanoksilapatham
1 Background 73
2 Description of the corpus 75
3 Determining the move categories in the genre of biochemistry research
articles 76
3.1 Te introduction section 77
3.2 Te methods section 78
3.3 Te results section 79
Table of contents 
3.4 Te discussion section 81
4 Coding moves in the corpus of biochemistry research articles 83
5 Distribution of move types within texts from the biochemistry
corpus 84
6 Linguistic characteristics of rhetorical moves in biochemistry research
articles 87
7 Linguistic variation among move categories in biochemistry research
articles 90
8 Multi-dimensional variation among move types within the same
section 103
chapter 5
Rhetorical appeals in fundraising 121
WITH Molly Anthony & Kostyantyn Gladkov
1 Elements of persuasion 121
2 Determining and analyzing rhetorical appeals 124
2.1 Rational appeals (Logos) 125
2.2 Credibility appeals (Ethos) 129
2.3 Afective appeals (Pathos) 131
3 Analysis, segmentation, and classifcation 132
3.1 Results and discussion 133
4 Linguistic description of appeals 136
4.1 Wordlists 137
4.2 Keywords 138
5 Appeals and discourse structure of letters 141
6 Conclusion 143
Part 2. Bottom-up analyses of discourse organization
chapter 6
Introduction to the identifcation and analysis of vocabulary-based
discourse units 155
WITH Eniko Csomay, James K. Jones, & Casey Keck
1 Conceptual introduction to VBDUs 156
2 Automatic identifcation of VBDUs in texts 161
3 Perceptual correlates of VBDUs 163
4 Using VBDUs to analyze the discourse structure of texts 169
5 Going one step further: Identifying generalizable VBDU ‘types’ 170
 Discourse on the Move
chapter 7
Vocabulary-based discourse units in biology research articles 175
WITH James K. Jones
1 Constructing the corpus of VBDUs 176
2 Analyzing the linguistic characteristics of VBDUs: Multi-dimensional
analysis 178
3 Comparing the multi-dimensional characteristics of research article
sections 184
4 Te multi-dimensional profle of VBDUs within a research article:
Tracking the movement of discourse 186
5 Identifying and interpreting the multi-dimensional text types of biology
research articles 190
6 Using VBDU text types to describe the discourse organizational patterns
of biology research articles 194
7 Starting and ending research article sections 196
7.1 Describing the typical discourse organizations of introductions 197
7.2 Describing the typical discourse organizations of methods sections 199
7.3 Describing the typical discourse organizations of discussion sections 201
8 Preferred text type sequences across research article section
boundaries 203
9 Comparing the preferred discourse styles of research journals 205
10 Conclusion 208
chapter 8
Vocabulary-based discourse units in university class sessions 213
BY Eniko Csomay
1 From constructing a corpus of VBDUs to identifying VBDU
text-types 214
1.1 Constructing a corpus of VBDUs 214
1.2 Analyzing the linguistic characteristics of VBDUs applying MD analytical
techniques 215
1.3 VBDUs and dimension scores: the multi-dimensional profle of the frst
three VBDUs of a business management class 217
2 Dimension scores and VBDU text-types 222
2.1 Interpreting the clusters as VBDU types based on their linguistic
characteristics 224
2.1.1 Cluster 1: Personalized framing 225
2.1.2 Cluster 2: Informational monologue 227
2.1.3 Cluster 3: Contextual interactive 228
Table of contents 
2.1.4 Cluster 4: Unmarked 229
3 From VBDU text-types to discourse structure 230
3.1 Functional interpretation of VBDU types 230
3.2 Text as sequences of VBDU types 232
4 Summary and conclusion 237
chapter 9
Conclusion: Comparing the analytical approaches 239
1 Overview 239
2 Comparing the top-down and bottom-up descriptions of biology
research articles. 242
2.1 Discourse units in biology research articles 243
2.2 Te dimensions of linguistic variation in biology research articles 244
2.3 Te functional and linguistic characteristics of the discourse types
(move types vs VBDU types) in biology research articles 249
2.4 Description of the typical discourse organization of biology research
articles 253
3 Summary and prospects for future research 258
Appendix 1 261
A brief introduction to multi-dimensional analysis 261
A.1 Conceptual introduction to the multi-dimensional approach
to variation 261
A.2 Overview of methodology in the multi-dimensional approach 262
Appendix 2 267
Grammatical and lexico-grammatical features included in
the multi-dimensional analyses 267
References 273
Index