Derrida on the Threshold of Sense

150 Pages·1986·10.149 MB·English

by  John Llewelyn

DERRIDA
ON THET HRESHOLD OF
SENSE
JohLnl eywne l
M
MACMILLAN
©JohnL lewe1l9y8n6
Allr ighrtess ervNeodr .e producctoipooynr, t ransmission
oft hipsUb ilcaotni mabyem adew ithout wpreirtmtiesns ion.
No paragprha otfh ipsu blicamtaiyob ne r eproduced,c opied
ort ransmistatvewedi twhr ittpeernm ission ori na ccordance
witthh ep rovisiooftn hseC opyrigAhctt1 956( aasm ended.)
Anyp ersownh od oeasn yu nauthoraicstie ndr elattioo n
thipsu blicmaatyib oeln i abtloec riminaprlos euctoin and
civcilla ifmsod ra mages.
First published 1986
Publishedb y
THE MACMILLAN PRESLST D
HoundmilBlassn,ig sto,kH eampshiRrGe2 12 XS
and London
Companiaensd r epresentatives
throughoutt hew orld
PrintiendH ongK ong
BritiLsihb raCrya tloaguign inP ublicaDtaitoan
Llewelyn,J ohn
Derriodnat h et hreshoofls de nse.
I.D erriJdaac,q ues
I.T itle
194 B2430.D484
ISBN0- 333-38749-X
Thibso oiksd edictaotm eybd r othDearvsia dn dHoward)
the mothfeart)her) aunts
andt o grandmother) unclaensd
whod edicattheedm setlouv se.s
Thec entirse tthher eshold
EdmondJa bes
citebyd
JacquesD erriad
LE)c ritluadr ifeef reetn ce
. (EdiitonSseu il)
Iti sa lwayas s igfincianqtu etsiotno ask aabnoypu htil os­
opher:w hati sh ea rfaiodf?
IriMsu rdoch
ThSeo veroje Giogonryd
Contents
Acknowledgements IX
Preface X
1 DialectSiecmialo logy 1
I Thresholds 1
IIW hati st hea boslutdei ffeenrec? 4
IIIW hati st ranrsegssion? 10
2 TranscendePnhteanlo menologSiecmali ology 16
I Husserl anpdr eetnshceeo fB rentano 16
IID erirdaa ndt hep resceeno fH usesrl 19
IIIR eefreen acndi ndication 27
IV Telaondse idos 29
3 FundamentaOln tologiSceamli ology 32
I Whati st hes nese ofb eing? 32
IIW ho arew e? 34
IIIA depe neceistsy 39
4 StructurSaelmiisotl ogy 43
I Postiin os/o ppostii ons 43
IIS ynchr/od niayc hrony 47
IIIB riceeo/nl gaieengring 49
IV Truth/method 51
V Froms ounsden set og rahpemaitcvsi a
grammtaology 52
VI Thew ritionngt hew all 55
VIIO fd ecotnrscuiton 57
5 RhetorologSiecmailo logy 60
I Paraictiaotn 60
IIW ho isJ acquDeesr rida? 70
IIIM etpahor 74
6 Anasemiology 83
I Theg endeorft ruth 83
Vll
Contents
Vlll
IIT hem iddvloei ce 90
IIII nseiodutness 94
7 ThDei vided Line 100
I Thes ftonesosft hleo cgaimlu ts 100
II stDienerrance 109
IIIT hem otss hcokitnhgi anbgo Duetrir d'awso kr 114
119
Post-scriGplta:s sification
NotaensRd efe rences 124
Biblpihyo gra 130
Index 134
Acknowledgements
ChapIta endrS cetioInIo fC hap6t oe(rit sbh okoa raed atped
witkhi npdre misfsorimor,ne esticpvel'yT,h ress'ph,uo blldished
inDe rraidnDad if efra(nUcnei veornst\Tiatyr wPiacurkos:iP rae ss,
1895,)a nd' HeeiggderK'asna tn tdh Mei ddVloceie p'u,ib slhed
inT imaen d.Me taphys(iUicnvse rosfV\iT aty r wiPcakr:io auPs rse,s
1928)b,oh t eidtebdyD avi"Wdo oda nRdo beBrernta cso.n iI
thnakt ehm,a]c quDeersira dD, aviFda rrKerell,ll DaRvoibdi n­
soann do]h Snal lfirosh lepw itmhat tebrisob glriacpa,hpl ihilo­
sopahlio crn gluitcii,s] .H ilMliils lfero rth vee rpyrc atli ca
manneirnw hihcehc ontitnosu heoidwn teirnme yps rtjo cett,h e
BiritsAhc ade(mSyml aGlr anRtessr ecaFhu nidnt hHeu mani­
tei)st,h Uen iveorfsEi dtyi nbuarngtdhh D ei reacntsdot rffao f
thIesn titFurntac ophodnePe ar ifsro e nablmient gog ot o
Fraen tcoc omteo m'e. I amg rautlte ofM argToa ylforor
praerpitnehgi ndaenxdt oT imF armialnodMe a rgaLreeatc h
frot heeixerpr gtui dnacaec rtoehst sh resbhewoteletdnpy ecsritp
anpdr iAnbto.va elI la mi nd ebttom y drwe iaefM agegf iroh er
cosnitsenhtlep w it'hlat loh sleil temt aetrtsw hocinht hdeai ly
happinoefps rsi vlaeitd fee pdesn'.
].L.
IX
Preface
Itwi llth eeofrrbee n ecaerstyso m akaed teairleeocdn nais­
snacoeft hfeor ntier.
JacqDueerisrd ,l)a issemination
Thew ritoiJfna gcsq Dueerisrd aar pear aisciC.tha pte5ro f this
epxosiioontf s omoeft ohswer itiisna gbso wuhta itss iadi n
syaintgih. sS ufficiett os ya att hpirsi emlinsatrgayet hahti s
writairnaegn su nrvaelionftg hw er tiinogfos ht erask ,i nodf
lecetxuprleIi a qiutmCeo e. px liciantt uerh nir sae dinogfss o moef
thtee xotfHs e geHlus,se rHIe,ie dggSeruas,sr ueL,e -vtSirasu,s
Autsiann Sde raelO.n t hsoera edintgheset sexatrsseoh wnn ot
tom akec omplsenetese.T hedyi esm-isaentt heemlsvTehse.y
aer,a sg ramamrisaynao sfc ertsaroitnsi loolrf-m fesndet ences,
brokaecnk-ebtdhy;e d on octo tnrseu.B oht bceauosfet hem­
selavneidsn s piotfte h eemlsvtehysed -ecotnrtsut cheemlsv.e sI
attetmoep xtp lwahiyDn er irdhao ltdhsat thdi esoc nstruicst ion
srtuctunreaeclsalsrywy h,y ii tns o mte erlaym attoefcr h anac e,
hapahzatrhdr ooftw hdei ce.
Iti sam atrto ef' mtat.eN ro'otf m attaesor p opsetdof rom,
buatsw hamtak ehsy lmoop-rhipsoms s.Ai tbl leteaa ssa p erlim­
inairitys h, le puflt op laDcereir daw'rsi tiinnt ghcseo nxtto ef
tohsienw hiAcnha xidmearAnn,a ixmenaensdH eratculfsiro,
intsancter,eo afpt r immeat tera,nd o fP lattoer'astm etno f
apeitrhoaeno ,r tihsitem, ep refcatn udn limiintt hPeehd i ltehbeus ,
Rpeulbitch,Se o phainstdth ,pe ar sto fth eT ima:wushc ihs pkeo af
tehc oslmoogircepactlea ec,l cThheO' ralP.ta on'bi acckgurnoids
crcuibaecla utshete o poiftc hu en ltiemadin idn ednfiiotveer laps
witht ehq useftro d enfitiioonras n yaslseA.c cortdoDi enrigard ,
nod efiiintoann ndo l aessts ieaanlnt aliytsso bi esfu on.dS oc an
Derrai'dpsrg oramebm e assitmotil haietn evtdei sgaotioftn hse
ltaeWri tntstgeewihne iritesb rohutog utth atths emi ialriotfy
instaonftc hesesa mceo nciespu stu aplelhryas,pu litmtaely
alawy,so nloyn oeff amilrye senmcbeWl?ea s hlanl otteh e risk
x
Preface
Xl
inucrriensdy a ing tthheariteas famrieelsym blabntecweet ehne
porjcetosfD errdiaa nWdi tnttsgeeibnuw,te lsnlho adtne yt hat
theirsae r emtoerree smbalncTeh.e riesa s loa r eesmblance
bewteeDner irado ns en,Ps eiercoens igannsdQ uieno nt he
indeertmaicnoyfr da ciatlr atnisnol.Tah iwsi alls stihseato s fu s
whoc omteaD erraiw ditthhp eh ilpahcsiaaelht apsr edominant
inE nghl-ipsseakcionnugte rsti ofee ll essi nlniakcaeeb nrtosa d.
YeItd abutt haDter raic dabne d omiecseatdtW.e h aven ot
senei tal blea freO.n e tohfteh insgasm.o efu sh avneo te ns e
beafriehs o w' Canttia.onlue'rrn e ecnatn lgpohaepn hislaoypi hs,
anndo otn loyna ccaouftnh Jtee iwsehx odforumst hCeon itnent
orb eucsaFer ewgaesG ermaannvd Vl tgtesnetin nVeieseT.nh e
philoslac mapmhoinmc aakreitsa n e xchaTnhgameto. s ptr op­
elrya cadeomOfixocn iaJnonshA ,u sttirunno,su otnD erriad's
potrrayoafhl i mt ob et hsep titiinmagg eo fN izecsthet,h e
'ifrovlo'u',sif nanitel'',pu elntatC'o ntnitnaleli ttesroamtoeef u r
us are obngeliynn tniotna agwks reei oyu.s lNosro modefou s
takvee rsyreo iusAlusyin t'osw nd elcaratthiaohtnei s doing
liunigiscpt henomaeg.nyW oels hlals eheo wD erriednads eosr
thdieslc araatnihdoo nwh es uptpsho ircsl atihmas to me of the
presuipoponoJfsso ihtSnae lret'hsey oo fsr peecahc atrsse h raed
witthh eera nespth eneonmolcoatglhi eoorfim eesna inagd ­
vancbeyHd e geHlu,se sdH,e idgeeagrn dS uasrseua ndw ith
theainrhd i fsir vloouPsar iinsad eacnstruJcatcoqrDu eerrsi da.
Wes hlasle et hwihse wne h aver edas omoeft hGee ramna nd
Frehn tcexattDs er rai'dpsr otmipnBgyt. h ewnem ayb ep re­
paretdob eu ncaeirantb owuhta itss r eiuosa nwdh aitsf ir vol­
ausw,h apth islohopya nwdh atl irtaet.uI rneededb,yt hewne
shlalh aveb eocmea cquaiwnittDehed rr iad'espx osuroefa n
uncerytp ariinnltceui ndpret hfeuo nadtisotno onfee v erything
hed ceotnrsucTthseu. n cteariinastn yu ndeicadbiitloyv ewrh at
isi nsaindwdeh ati so u,to vetrh rheassld.It i sd icsovetroeod
undtehrte h srheowlhdi icsch a ltlhepedr aecfoefa b aoTkh.i s
wasd eetctbeydH egaenld d ersbiceidn m orteh aonn oef t he
praecfetsoh iasw nb oko.sS intchece h atpetrh artae ists he
curtoafti hnbi oosk i asn i ntrcotdituaoHn e g'esslme iooglayn d
toD erirdad'ausb lreed ainogfi tt,h pirsae cfweo usledem t ob e
thper orp pealcfero somper aetfo-rrye maornHk esg ealnd
Derriado np ref.a ces
Them intuioref D eirdras'tsa tnetom fte hpea raodfot xh e
Hegelpiraenf aarcdeete alieidn ' HarLsi v-rPer aecfeosf'