Depressive Disorders, Volume 1

501 Pages·1999·2.645 MB·English

Depressive Disorders. Edited by Mario Maj and Norman Sartorius
Copyright © 1999 John Wiley & Sons Ltd
ISBNs: 0471999059 (Hardback); 0470842342 (Electronic)
VOLUME
1
Depressive Disorders
WPA Series
Evidence and Experience in Psychiatry
DepressiveDisorders.EditedbyMarioMajandNormanSartorius.
1999JohnWiley&SonsLtd.
Depressive Disorders. Edited by Mario Maj and Norman Sartorius
Copyright © 1999 John Wiley & Sons Ltd
ISBNs: 0471999059 (Hardback); 0470842342 (Electronic)
Forthcoming Titles in the WPA Series
Evidence and Experience in
Psychiatry
Volume 2—Schizophrenia
Mario Maj and Norman Sartorius
Volume 3—Dementia
Mario Maj and Norman Sartorius
Depressive Disorders. Edited by Mario Maj and Norman Sartorius
Copyright © 1999 John Wiley & Sons Ltd
ISBNs: 0471999059 (Hardback); 0470842342 (Electronic)
VOLUME
1
Depressive Disorders
Editedby
Mario Maj
UniversityofNaples,Italy
Norman Sartorius
UniversityofGeneva,Switzerland
WPA Series
Evidence and Experience in Psychiatry
JOHN WILEY&SONS,LTD
ChichesteržNewYorkžWeinheimžBrisbanežSingaporežToronto
Depressive Disorders. Edited by Mario Maj and Norman Sartorius
Copyright © 1999 John Wiley & Sons Ltd
ISBNs: 0471999059 (Hardback); 0470842342 (Electronic)
Copyright1999byJohnWiley&SonsLtd,
BaffinsLane,Chichester,
WestSussexPO191UD,England
National 01243779777
International([phone]
e-mail(forordersandcustomerserviceenquiries):[email protected]
VisitourHomePageonhttp://www.wiley.co.uk
orhttp://www.wiley.com
AllRightsReserved.Nopartofthispublicationmaybereproduced,storedinaretrieval
system,ortransmitted,inanyformorbyanymeans,electronic,mechanical,photocopying,
recording,scanningorotherwise,exceptunderthetermsoftheCopyright,DesignsandPatents
Act1988orunderthetermsofalicenceissuedbytheCopyrightLicensingAgency,90
TottenhamCourtRoad,London,UK,W1P9HE,withoutthepermissioninwritingofthe
Publisher.
OtherWileyEditorialOffices
JohnWiley&Sons,Inc.,605ThirdAvenue,
NewYork,NY10158-0012,USA
WILEY-VCHVerlagGmbH,Pappelallee3,
D-69469Weinheim,Germany
JacarandaWileyLtd,33ParkRoad,Milton,
Queensland4064,Australia
JohnWiley&Sons(Asia)PteLtd,2ClementiLoop#02-01,
JinXingDistripark,Singapore129809
JohnWiley&Sons(Canada)Ltd,22WorcesterRoad,
Rexdale,OntarioM9W1L1,Canada
LibraryofCongressCataloging-in-PublicationData
Depressivedisorders/editedbyMarioMaj,NormanSartorius.
p. cm.—(WPAseriesinevidenceandexperiencein
psychiatry;v.1)
Includesbibliographicalreferencesandindex.
ISBN0-471-99905-9(alk.paper:cased)
1.Depression,Mental. I.Maj,Mario,1953– . II.Sartorius,N.
III.Series.
[DNLM:1.DepressiveDisorder—diagnosis. 2.DepressiveDisorder–
therapy. 3.Evidence-BasedMedicine—methods. WM171D424251999]
RC537.D445 1999
616.85027—dc21
DNLM/DLC
forLibraryofCongress 99–14217
CIP
BritishLibraryCataloguinginPublicationData
AcataloguerecordforthisbookisavailablefromtheBritishLibrary
ISBN0-471-99905-9
Typesetin10/12ptPalatinobyLaserWords,Madras,India
PrintedandboundinGreatBritainbyBiddlesLtd.,GuildfordandKing’sLynn
Thisbookisprintedonacid-freepaperresponsiblymanufacturedfromsustainableforestry,
inwhichatleasttwotreesareplantedforeachoneusedforpaperproduction.
Depressive Disorders. Edited by Mario Maj and Norman Sartorius
Copyright © 1999 John Wiley & Sons Ltd
ISBNs: 0471999059 (Hardback); 0470842342 (Electronic)
Contents
ListofReviewContributors xiii
Preface xv
CHAPTER1 DIAGNOSISOFDEPRESSIVEDISORDERS 1
DiagnosisofDepressiveDisorders:AReview 1
C.N.StefanisandN.C.Stefanis
COMMENTARIES
1.1 MuchDiversity,ManyCategories,NoEntities 52
R.E.Kendell
1.2 CategoricalandDimensionalPerspectives
ofDepression 54
J.Angst
1.3 ModelsofClassificationofDepressiveDisorders 57
P.Pichot
1.4 FlawsofCurrentDiagnosisofDepression 59
H.M.vanPraag
1.5 ApproachestoDiagnosingDepression,andthe
ReciprocalRelationshiptoDepressionResearch 63
R.J.BolandandM.B.Keller
1.6 ThePracticalImportanceofTemporalSequencing
andSecondaryDepression 65
W.Coryell
1.7 Depression:theComplexityofitsInterfacewith
SoftBipolarity 68
H.S.Akiskal
1.8 ContextualizingtheDiagnosisofDepression 71
J.E.MezzichandM.R.Jorge
1.9 Age,LossandtheDiagnosticBoundaries
ofDepression 73
S.Zisook
vi CONTENTS
1.10 DepressionAmongElderlyandPostpartum
Women 75
P.S.F.YipandD.T.S.Lee
1.11 Self-ratingDepressionScales:Some
MethodologicalIssues 77
T.Kitamura
1.12 UnderdiagnosisofDepression:ItsImpact
ontheCommunity 79
A.Okasha
1.13 LimitedOptionsonDiagnosingDepression 82
S.K.Chaturvedi
1.14 DiagnosisofDepressiveDisorders:Taxonomical
SystemsandClinicalPractice 83
A.A.OteroOjeda
1.15 TheIdentificationofDiagnosticSubtypesof
DepressiveDisorders 85
N.Kornetov
CHAPTER2 PHARMACOLOGICALTREATMENTOF
DEPRESSIVEDISORDERS 89
PharmacologicalTreatmentofDepressive
Disorders:AReview 89
P.Bech
COMMENTARIES
2.1 Antidepressants:FortyYearsofExperience 128
E.S.Paykel
2.2 TargetingAntidepressantTreatment:TheEvidence
isWeak 130
C.Thompson
2.3 TheSelectionoftheAntidepressantinClinical
Practice 132
S.H.Preskorn
2.4 GenderandAntidepressantResponse 134
A.F.SchatzbergandS.G.Kornstein
2.5 ValidityofAtypicalDepression:Evidence
ProvidedbyPharmacologicalDissection 137
F.M.Quitkin
2.6 IncreasingOurUnderstandingoftheWorking
MechanismofAntidepressants 139
J.A.denBoer
CONTENTS vii
2.7 AretheFirstGenerationMonoamineReuptake
InhibitorsStillNeededintheTreatmentofMajor
DepressiveEpisode? 141
A.Gjerris
2.8 AntidepressantsinBroaderContext 143
C.Ho¨schl
2.9 AntidepressantsforBetterQualityofLife 145
S.Kasper
2.10 WouldRationalPolypharmacyImproveQuality
ofLife? 147
S.K.Chaturvedi
2.11 ComplianceIssuesandtheEfficacyof
Antidepressants 149
K.Demyttenaere
2.12 TheParallelNeedforMedicine-basedEvidence 151
D.S.Baldwin
2.13 WhatisaLotofAntidepressantsforsoFew
CriteriaofChoice? 154
F.Rouillon
2.14 DepressionanditsTreatment:aGeneral
HealthProblem 156
A.Okasha
2.15 AntidepressantDrugs:TheIndianExperience 158
R.SrinivasaMurthy
CHAPTER3 PSYCHOTHERAPIESFORDEPRESSIVE
DISORDERS 161
PsychotherapiesforDepressiveDisorders:
AReview 161
A.J.RushandM.E.Thase
COMMENTARIES
3.1 LatestDevelopmentsinPsychotherapy
forDepression 207
M.M.Weissman
3.2 IndicationsandPlanningofPsychotherapies:
‘‘MuchAdoaboutNothing’’? 209
B.E.Wampold
3.3 TheStateofAntidepressantPsychotherapy:
GrowingStrengths,StillUnansweredQuestions 212
J.C.Markowitz
viii CONTENTS
3.4 ResearchonHot-housePsychotherapy 214
T.B.Karasu
3.5 PsychotherapyforDepression:AreAdditional
ControlledTrialsStillWarranted? 216
C.Perris
3.6 Depression:TheEvidenceforWhatWorksand
WhatDoesn’t 219
J.S.McIntyre
3.7 PsychotherapyofDepression:Research
andPractice 221
R.Michels
3.8 Nosologyvs.PersonalityDirectedPsychotherapy
andtheGapBetweenResearchandPractice 223
C.Mundt
3.9 TheSequentialUseofPharmacotherapyand
PsychotherapyinDepressiveDisorders 226
G.A.Fava
3.10 IntegratingPsychotherapiesinClinical
Practice 228
R.Mac´ıas
3.11 BuildingontheFoundations:WhereNextin
TherapeuticOutcomeResearch? 230
J.C.Nemiah
CHAPTER4 DEPRESSIVEDISORDERSINCHILDRENAND
ADOLESCENTS 233
DepressiveDisordersinChildrenand
Adolescents:AReview 233
R.Harrington
COMMENTARIES
4.1 TowardsanUnderstandingofEarlyOnset
Depression 267
J.F.Leckman
4.2 DepressionInYouth:TrendsinDiagnosis 269
S.V.Faraone
4.3 DepressiveDisordersinChildhoodand
Adolescence:StateoftheArt 271
P.M.Lewinsohn
4.4 ‘‘Atleastintheformseeninadults.’’A
CommentaryonMajorDepressiveDisorder
inYouth 273
G.A.Carlson
CONTENTS ix
4.5 The‘‘Atypicality’’ofDepressioninYouth 276
J.BiedermanandT.Spencer
4.6 HowtheStudyofEarlyOnsetDepression
ChallengesUstoProduceaNewParadigmfor
UnderstandingMoodDisorders 278
S.P.Kutcher
4.7 AdultandChildhoodDepressionsMayinFactbe
DifferentIllnesses 281
A.A.Rosenfeld
4.8 TakingStockandMovingon:CurrentIssuesand
ChallengesConcerningChildandAdolescent
DepressiveDisorders 283
C.A.King
4.9 IncreasingAwarenessofDepressiveDisordersin
Childhood:ImplicationsforWorldChildand
AdolescentMentalHealth 286
J.A.Corbett
4.10 SomeUnsolvedProblemsinChildhood
Depression:AClinician’sView 289
H.Remschmidt
4.11 ChildhoodDepression:SomeUnresolvedResearch
Questions 292
E.Fombonne
4.12 ResearchTrendsinDepressiveDisorders
ofYouth 295
B.Vitiello
4.13 TheNatureofFirstEpisodeMajorDepressionin
ChildhoodandAdolescence 297
I.Goodyer
4.14 ClinicalUpdateofChildandAdolescent
Depression 299
S.Tyano
4.15 TreatmentControversiesinChildhoodDepression 302
C.M.Borchardt
4.16 PsychotherapyforChildhoodDepression 304
I.Kolvin,J.Trowell,J.Tsiantis,F.Almqvistand
H.Sadowski
4.17 RoleofNeurobiologicalandGeneticFactorsin
TreatmentofChildhoodDepression 306
B.Geller
4.18 DepressionintheFamily 309
R.Todd
x CONTENTS
CHAPTER5 DEPRESSIVEDISORDERSINTHEELDERLY 313
DepressiveDisordersintheElderly:AReview 313
E.Chiu,D.Ames,B.DraperandJ.Snowdon
COMMENTARIES
5.1 DepressioninOlderAge:DiagnosticProblems,
NewKnowledgeandNeglectedAreas 364
J.R.M.Copeland
5.2 DepressionintheElderlyisUnderdiagnosed;
EtiologyisMultifactorial 366
C.G.Gottfries
5.3 DepressionintheElderly:IssuesinDiagnosis
andManagement 369
D.L.Dunner
5.4 DepressiveDisordersintheElderly:AFresh
Perspective 371
M.Nowers
5.5 DepressionintheElderly:AreasOpento
Research 373
C.Ballard
5.6 FillingintheGapsaboutDepressionintheElderly 376
D.Blazer
5.7 AClinicalPointofViewaboutDepression
intheElderly 377
J.Wertheimer
5.8 GeriatricDepression:ALooktotheFuture 379
C.F.ReynoldsIII
5.9 DepressioninLateLife:DirectionsforIntervention
Research 382
B.D.Lebowitz
5.10 TreatmentofDepressioninthe‘‘Old-old’’ 384
S.H.Preskorn
5.11 SuggestedPrioritiesforResearchintoDepressive
DisordersintheElderly 386
P.W.Burvill
5.12 ComorbidityofDepressioninOlderPeople 388
C.Katona
5.13 MythorRealityofOldAgeDepression:The
ExampleofTaiwanStudies 390
M.-Y.Chong
5.14 DepressionintheElderly:Predictorsand
PrognosticFactors 392
S.-L.Kivela¨