Chuetal.BMCOralHealth2013,13:8 http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6831/13/8 RESEARCH ARTICLE Open Access Dental prosthetic treatment needs of inpatients with schizophrenia in Taiwan: a cross-sectional study Kuan-Yu Chu1*†, Nan-Ping Yang2,3, Pesus Chou2, Lin-Yang Chi4† and Hsien-Jane Chiu5† Abstract Background: The need to obtain information onthe dental prosthetic treatmentneeds (DPTNs) of inpatients with schizophrenia is unrecognized. This study aims to assess the DPTNs ofthis population and investigate the association between theseneeds and related factors. Methods: The results ofan oral health survey involving 1,103schizophrenicadult inpatients in a long-term care institution inTaiwan were used. Chi-square tests and multiple logistic analyses were used to measure the independent effects ofthecharacteristicsof each subject on their DPTNs. Results: Ofthe subjects, 805(73.0%)were menand 298 (27.0%) were women. The mean age was 50.8 years. A total of 414(37.5%)required fixed prosthesis, whereas 700 (63.5%) needed removable prosthesis.Multivariate analyses show that fixed prosthesis is associated with age only after adjusting for otherpotential independent variables. Older subjects who had a lower educational attainment or a longer length of stay required removable prosthesis. Conclusions: The findingsof this study show that theDPTNs of schizophrenic inpatients are not being met. Therefore, a special approach to thedental prosthetictreatmentof these patients should be developed. Keywords: Fixed prosthesis,Removable prosthesis,Treatment needs, Schizophrenia Background The factors that affect dental prosthetic treatments Dentalprosthesisisveryimportantforpatientswithpost- have not been appropriately recognized. Researchers endodontic therapy and who are partially or completely have reported that gender has a significant influence on edentulous because it improves their chewing ability, di- the need for a fixed or removable prosthesis [9]. Studies gestion, aesthetics, and quality of life. The need to obtain have also indicated that age, educational level, and information on the dental prosthetic treatment needs length of stay (LOS) in institutions are important factors (DPTNs) of handicapped individuals in general [1-3] and that determine dental treatment needs [8,10,11]. Schizo- of inpatients with psychiatric disorders in particular has phrenic patients that require dental treatment often beengainingrecognition[4,5]. come from poor families with limited access to dental Schizophrenia is a severe psychiatric disorder that has care. Moreover, the dental care provided to patients who a significantly negative effect on the self-care ability of stay in long-term-care institutions for a considerable patients,whichleadstopoororal hygieneaswell ashigh amount of time is insufficient [6,12]. Furthermore, some DPTNs [6,7]. Previous studies found high levels of den- schizophrenia medications, such as the typical anti- taltreatmentneedsinschizophrenicpopulations[8]. psychotic drugs, may have side effects that can lead to increasedDPTNs[13,14]. Professional clinical examinations are reportedly more effective than self-assessment or questionnaire-based *Correspondence:[email protected] †Equalcontributors screeningsin assessingindividual dental treatment needs 1DepartmentofDentistry,Tao-YuanGeneralHospital,DOH,Tao-Yuan,Taiwan [3,15], particularly if done with the aid of radiographs Fulllistofauthorinformationisavailableattheendofthearticle ©2013Chuetal.;licenseeBioMedCentralLtd.ThisisanOpenAccessarticledistributedunderthetermsoftheCreative CommonsAttributionLicense(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0),whichpermitsunrestricteduse,distribution,and reproductioninanymedium,providedtheoriginalworkisproperlycited. Chuetal.BMCOralHealth2013,13:8 Page2of5 http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6831/13/8 [16,17]. The planning of preventive oral health improve- tooth for the bridge follows Ante’s Law, which states that mentstrategiesbasedonDPTNsaswellasonrelatedfac- the root surface area of the abutment teeth should equal tors associated with a population is important. However, or surpass that of the pontics [22]. An FP with cantilever few studies have been conducted on the DPTNs of hos- extension units usually has higher failure rates than con- pitalizedpatientswithschizophreniabasedonclinicaloral ventional designs [23]; thus, a bridge with an end abut- examinations via periapical radiography. Schizophrenic ments was used in this study. Dental implants were inpatients probably belong to a disadvantaged minority excluded from the treatment plans because of financial and thus receive inadequate dental care. The aim of this limitations. study is to obtain descriptive epidemiological information On the other hand, an RP is recommended for patients on the DPTNs of hospitalized schizophrenic patients and whoseremainingteethlackthestrengthtosupportafixed toidentifytheassociationbetweenDPTNsandseveralpo- bridge. RPs are classified into partial dentures and tentiallyrelatedfactorsthataffectthesepatients. complete dentures. RPDs that do not cross the midline areclassifiedas0.5units. Methods Participants Independentvariables This study involved a sample hospital that offers long- The independent variables included age, educational at- term medical care for chronic psychotics. The hospital is tainment, marital status, grade of disability, use of anti- locatedineasternTaiwanbutreceivespsychiatricpatients psychotic medication, and LOS. Age was classified into from all over the country. As of mid-2006, the hospital four strata: 20–44, 45–54, 55–64, and over 65 years old. had admitted 2,330 patients. In recruitingsubjects for the Educational attainment was divided into two categories: study,allhospitalpatientswithschizophreniaas themain 6 years and below, and above 6 years. Marital status was psychiatric diagnosis (ICD-9 code: 295) were selected to classified into three categories:single, married,and sepa- undergoastandardizedDPTNassessmentinthehospital’s rated/divorced/widowed. Disability was divided into Department of Dentistry. A total of 1,468 schizophrenic three grades: mild or moderate (moderate), severe, and patients were involved in the study. Of these, 1,103 profound. These grades are in accordance with the dis- (response rate: 75.1%) participated and completed the ability certificate issued by theTaiwan Ministry of Inter- DPTN evaluation. Ethical clearance was obtained from the ior. The use of antipsychotic medications was stratified Ethical Committee of Yuli Hospital, Department of Health into two categories based on records obtained for six (DOH),Taiwan,andallparticipantsgaveinformedconsent. months prior to the study period [24]. Antipsychotic medications comprised first-generation antipsychotics DPTNassessment (FGAs, e.g. chlorpromazine, clopenthixol, flupenthixol DPTN assessment was performed under standard condi- HCl, haloperidol, loxapine, sulpiride, and thioridazine) tionsusingadentalchairwithadequatelight,properden- and non-FGA medications. Non-FGAs included second- tal instruments, and periapical radiographs, as needed. A generation antipsychotics (SGAs, e.g. clozpaine, olanza- trained dentist performed all oral examinations with the pine, risperidone, and quetiapine) and third-generation helpofanexperiencedassistant,whorecordedtheDPTN antipsychotics (TGAs, e.g. aripiprazole). The length of dataaswellasinformationonindependentvariables. stay (LOS) cut-off point, which refers to the number of TheDPTNitemsusedwereconsistentwiththoserecom- yearssince admission tothehospital,was10years[13]. mended by the World Health Organization, [18] which included (1) fixed prosthesis (FP); and (2) removable pros- Datacollectionandanalysis thesis (RP), such as a removable partial denture (RPD; DatacollectionwasconductedfromJanuarytoDecember those crossing the midline were defined as bilateral RPD) 2006. The DPTN items werethen prepared and summar- andcompletedentures. ized. The data files were then designed using MS Access The principle behind dental prosthetic treatment is the and analyzed using SPSS software version 15.0. Propor- restorationorreplacementofalllostteeth,excludingthird tions, group means, and standard deviations (SDs) were molars. An FP is generally preferred because the reported calculated. Univariate analysis using the chi-square test survival rate of patients with FPs is higher than that of compared the differences between the independent va- patients with removable RPDs [19,20]. Thus, FPs are the riables and the DPTNs. Statistical significance was set at firstchoiceforreplacingmissingteethinpartiallyedentu- theP<0.05level. louspatients. Multiple logistic regressions were used to estimate the An FPconsists ofa single crown and a bridge. The sin- association between the independent variables and glecrownisacementedveneerrestorationthatreplacesa DPTNs of the participants. The independent variables tooth suffering from deep decay or undergoing post- were included in the multivariable logistic models, with endodontic therapy [21]. The selection of the abutment a cut-off of P < 0.05 from the univariate analyses. The Chuetal.BMCOralHealth2013,13:8 Page3of5 http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6831/13/8 odds ratios (OR) of the independent variables (as com- Of the subjects, 414 (37.5%) required FP, with 1,854 paredtothereferencecategory),thesignificance(P-value), units and a mean unit of 1.7 (SD = 2.89) per person. On and 95% confidence intervals (95% CI) were estimated theotherhand,700(63.5%)patientsrequiredRP,whereas from the multiple logistic regression models. Areas under 645 (58.5%) required RPD, including 28 (2.5%) unilateral, a receiver-operating characteristic curve (AUC) were also 240 (21.8%) bilateral, 26 (2.4%) unilateral combined with calculatedtodeterminethepredictedprobabilityofthelo- bilateral, and 351 (31.8%) two bilateral arches. Moreover, gisticmodels. 145 (13.1%) patients required complete dentures, with 93 (8.4%)requiringa singlearchand52(4.7%)requiringtwo Results arches. Table 1 shows the numbers and percentages of Descriptivestatistics DPTNsofthesubjectswhorequireFPorRP. Ofthe1,103schizophrenicinpatientsevaluatedforDPTNs, 805 (73.0%) were men and 298 (27.0%) were women. The Univariateanalysis meanagewas50.8years(SD=10.8),andtheaverageLOS Thechi-squaretestshowsthatage(P<0.001),educational inthehospitalwas8.4years(SD=5.7).Atotalof55(5.0%) attainment (P = 0.032), and LOS (P = 0.011) were asso- inpatientswerefoundtobeedentulous. ciated with the need for FP treatment. In other findings, Table1Numberandpercentage(withinparentheses)ofdentalprosthetictreatmentneedsamonginpatientswith schizophreniainTaiwan Variables Total Fixedprosthesis Pvalue Removableprosthesis Pvalue Total 1103(100) 414(37.5) 700(63.5) Sex Men 805(73.0) 302(37.5) 1.000 518(64.3) 0.325 Women 298(27.0) 112(37.6) 182(61.1) Age(yrs) 20-44 301(27.3) 142(47.2) <0.001 127(42.2) <0.001 45-54 425(38.5) 183(43.1) 272(64.0) 55-64 257(23.3) 67(26.1) 191(74.3) 65+ 120(10.9) 22(18.3) 110(91.7) Education(yrs) >6 468(42.4) 193(41.2) 0.032 250(53.4) <0.001 ≤6 635(57.6) 221(34.8) 450(70.9) Marriage Single 848(76.9) 320(37.7) 0.657 538(63.4) 1.000 Married 115(10.4) 39(33.9) 73(63.5) Separated 140(12.7) 55(39.3) 89(63.6) Disability Moderate 237(21.5) 99(41.8) 0.250 131(55.3) <0.001 Severe 744(67.5) 274(36.8) 474(63.7) Profound 122(11.1) 41(33.6) 95(77.9) Lowincome No 240(21.8) 91(37.9) 0.940 137(57.1) 0.023 Yes 863(78.2) 323(37.4) 563(65.2) FGAusing No 692(62.7) 272(39.3) 0.123 424(61.3) 0.053 Yes 411(37.3) 142(34.5) 276(67.2) LOS(yrs) ≤10 517(46.9) 215(41.6) 0.011 272(52.6) <0.001 >10 586(53.1) 199(34.0) 428(73.0) Abbreviations:FGA:firstgenerationantipsychotic;LOS:lengthofstay. Chuetal.BMCOralHealth2013,13:8 Page4of5 http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6831/13/8 age(P<0.001),educationalattainment(P<0.001),disabi- $18,000; bilateral RPD, NT$24,000; and a complete lity (P < 0.001), low income (P = 0.023), use of FGAs in dentureperarch,NT$27,000.Hence,theaveragebudgetfor borderline cases (P = 0.053), and LOS (P < 0.001) deter- the prosthetic treatment needs of an inpatient is calculated minedtheneedforRPtreatments. as follows: [1,854 × NT$4,000 + (28+26) × NT$18,000 + (240 + 26 + 351 × 2) × NT$24,000 + (93 + 52×2) × NT Multivariatelogisticanalysis $27,000] ÷ 1,103 subjects = NT$33,490. In other words, Basedonthemultivariatelogisticanalysisresults(Table2), the cost of providing the prosthetic treatment needs of an age was negatively associated with FP. The analysis also average schizophrenic inpatient in Taiwan is approximately revealsthattheneedforRPwasassociatedwithage,edu- US$1,158(USD). cationalattainment,andLOS. In terms of human resources, as of July 2010, the ratio of the general population to dentists in Taiwan was Discussion 1,995: 1. The availability of only one full-time dentist for This study investigated the DPTNs and several poten- 2,300 inpatients with severe psychiatric disorders in this tially related factors that affect schizophrenic inpatients hospitalisclearly insufficient. using a large sample from a specific psychiatric hospital The acceptance of dental prosthetic treatment for inTaiwan.Thestudyobtainednotonlydescriptiveinfor- missing teeth would seem reasonable. However, studies mation on DPTNs, but also indicated that age, educa- proposed a compromise that involves a shortened dental tion, and LOSare associated with DPTNsinsome of the arch. In this treatment, the restoration of four occluding subjects. These findings may help oral health policy pairs of premolars can provide sufficient occlusal stabi- decision-makers in allocating adequate resources and in lity andmasticatory function [29,30]. developingeffectivestrategiestomeettheDPTNsofthis Discussion on extended issues such as costs of various specialneeds population. prosthetic treatments is beyond the scope of this study, FPwasassociatedwithageonlyafteradjustingforother since it entails the value discount, different prices of independentvariables.Oldersubjectswhohadloweredu- prosthetic treatments between urban and rural areas, cationalattainmentorhadlongerLOSrequiredRP.These andthosebetweenfixedandremovableprosthesisofdif- findings are only partly consistent with those of previous ferent materials. Furthermore, some limitations of this studies on the oral health of inpatients with psychiatric study should be noted. First, the sample may not be rep- disorders. However, these data sets do complement one resentative of all schizophrenic inpatients in Taiwan. For another[5,25-28]. practical reasons, only a selected number of inpatients We estimated the average budget of prosthetic treat- were examined. Given that the survey design focused ment needs for schizophrenic in-patients. Based on the only on schizophrenic patients with DPTNs in a public feecollectionpoliciesofYuliHospital,DOH,abase-metal psychiatric hospital, patients with very limited life ex- crown treatment costs NT$4,000; unilateral RPD, NT pectancy and those not hospitalized were excluded. Table2Multivariateanalysesoffactorsassociatedwithdentalprosthetictreatmentneedsamonginpatientswith schizophreniainTaiwan Variables Fixedprosthesisa RemovableprosthesisRPb B OR P 95.0%CIforOR B OR P 95.0%CIforOR Age(yrs) 20-44 1(r) 1(r) 45-54 −0.16 0.85 0.297 0.63-1.16 0.72 2.06 <0.001 1.50-2.83 55-64 −0.93 0.40 <0.001 0.27-0.59 1.04 2.82 <0.001 1.91-4.18 65+ −1.37 0.25 <0.001 0.15-0.44 2.28 9.75 <0.001 4.78-19.87 Education(yrs) >6 1(r) ≤6 0.40 1.49 0.004 1.13-1.95 LOS(yrs) ≤10 1(r) >10 0.36 1.43 0.016 1.07-1.91 AUC 0.62 0.71 Abbreviations:LOS:lengthofstay;AUC:areaundercurve;r:reference. Variablesentered:aage,education,LOS;bage,education,gradeofdisability,lowincome,useofFGA,LOS. Chuetal.BMCOralHealth2013,13:8 Page5of5 http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6831/13/8 Second,despiteourbestefforts,anumberofpracticaldif- 8. BarnesGP,AllenEH,ParkerWA,LyonTC,ArmentroutW,ColeJS:Dental ficulties regarding DPTNs were encountered during the treatmentneedsamonghospitalizedadultmentalpatients.SpecCare Dentist1988,8(4):173–177. assessment. In addition, a large number of schizophrenic 9. Al-GhannamNA,Al-ShammeryAR,WyneAH,KhanNB,Al-GhannamNA,Al- patients were unaccounted for during the process. Third, ShammeryAR,WyneAH,KhanNB:Prostheticdentaltreatmentneedsin weacknowledgethattheevidencesupportingthisassump- Eastern[corrected]SaudiArabia.[ErratumappearsinSaudiMedJ.2002 Nov;23(11):1427].SaudiMedJ2002,23(8):975–980. tion is limited and that further research on the develop- 10. AngelilloIF,NobileCGA,PaviaM,FazioP,PucaM,AmatiA:Dentalhealth ment of an effective preventive program for the unmet andtreatmentneedsininstitutionalizedpsychiatricpatientsinItaly. DPTNsofschizophrenicinpatientsisurgentlyrequired. CommunityDentOralEpidemiol1995,23(6):360–364. 11. ChuK-Y,YangN-P,ChouP,ChiuH-J,ChiL-Y:Factorsassociatedwith dentalcariesamonginstitutionalizedresidentswithschizophreniain Conclusions Taiwan:across-sectionalstudy.BMCPublHealth2010,10(1):482. 12. KilbourneAM,Horvitz-LennonM,PostEP,McCarthyJF,CruzM,WelshD, The considerable unmet treatment needs of hospitalized BlowFC:OralHealthinVeteransAffairsPatientsDiagnosedwithSerious schizophrenicpatientsinTaiwanwereobserved.Age,edu- MentalIllness.JPublicHealthDent2007,67(1):42–48. cationalattainment,andLOSarethethreemostsignificant 13. ThomasA,LavrentzouE,KarouzosC,KontisC:Factorswhichinfluencethe oralconditionofchronicschizophreniapatients.SpecCareDentist1996, factors associated with the need for RP treatment. The 16(2):84–86. results reveal the need for the development of a prompt 14. SzabadiE,TavernorS:Hypo-andHypersalivationInducedby oral health care delivery service model for patients with PsychoactiveDrugs:IncidenceMechanismsandTherapeutic Implications.CNSDrugs1999,11:449–466. specialneeds. 15. RobinsonPG,NadanovskyP,SheihamA:CanQuestionnairesReplace ClinicalSurveystoAssessDentalTreatmentNeedsofAdults?JPublic Competinginterests HealthDent1998,58(3):250–253. Theauthorsdeclarethattheyhavenocompetinginterests. 16. BeckerT,LevinL,ShochatT,EinyS,BeckerT,LevinL,ShochatT,EinyS: HowmuchdoestheDMFTindexunderestimatetheneedforrestorative Authors'contributions care?JDentEduc2007,71(5):677–681. KYCcarriedouttheDPTNassessment,participatedinthesequence 17. HeyesG,RobinsonPG,HeyesG,RobinsonPG:Pilotstudytoassessthe alignmentanddraftedthemanuscript.NPYparticipatedinthedesignofthe validityofthesingleassessmentprocessasascreeningtoolfordental studyandperformedthestatisticalanalysis.PCandLYCconceivedofthe treatmentneedsinolderpeople.Gerodontology2008,25(3):142–146. study,andparticipatedinitsdesignandcoordinationandhelpedtodraft 18. WHO:OralHealthSurvey:BasicMethods.4thedition.Geneva:1997. themanuscript.HJCparticipatedinthesequencealignment.Allauthorsread 19. GlantzP-OJ,NilnerK,JendresenMD,SundbergH:Qualityoffixed andapprovedthefinalmanuscript. prosthodonticsafter15years.ActaOdontolScand1993,51(4):247–252. 20. VermeulenAHBM,KeltjensHMAM,van'tHofMA,KayserAF:Ten-year evaluationofremovablepartialdentures:Survivalratesbasedon Acknowledgements retreatment,notwearingandreplacement.JProsthetDent1996, WeacknowledgeMissHui-MeiYewhocontributedtowardsthearticleby 76(3):267–272. makingsubstantialcontributionstodatacollection.WealsothankYuli 21. ShillingburgHT,Jr,HoboS,WhitsettL:FundamentalsofFixed Hospital,DOH,whichcontributedmaterialsessentialforthestudy. Prosthodontics:DiagnosisandTreatmentPlanning.vol.1,2ndedn. Chicago:QuintessencePublishingCo.;1981:13–53. Authordetails 1DepartmentofDentistry,Tao-YuanGeneralHospital,DOH,Tao-Yuan, 22. AnteIH:Thefundermentalprinciplesofabutments.MichStateDentSoc Taiwan.2InstituteofPublicHealth&CommunityMedicineResearchCenter, Bul1926,8. NationalYang-MingUniversity,Taipei,Taiwan.3DepartmentofGeriatrics, 23. KarlssonS:Failuresandlengthofserviceinfixedprosthodonticsafter Tao-YuanGeneralHospital,DOH,Tao-Yuan,Taiwan.4Departmentof long-termfunction.Alongitudinalclinicalstudy.SwedDentJ1989,13 Dentistry,NationalYang-MingUniversity,Taipei,Taiwan.5Departmentof (5):185–192. 24. JansenENH:ClozapineinthetreatmentoftremorinParkinson'sdisease. Psychiatry,JiananMentalHospital,DOH,Tainan,Taiwan. ActaNeurologicaScandinavica1994,89(4):262–265. 25. KenkreAM,SpadigamAE:Oralhealthandtreatmentneedsininstitutionalized Received:5November2012Accepted:16January2013 psychiatricpatientsinIndia.IndianJDentRes2000,11(1):5–11. Published:19January2013 26. RamonT,GrinshpoonA,ZusmanSP,WeizmanA:Oralhealthand treatmentneedsofinstitutionalizedchronicpsychiatricpatientsinIsrael. References EurPsychiatry2003,18(3):101–105. 1. WhymanRA,TreasureET,BrownRH,MacFadyenEE:Theoralhealthof 27. TangWK,SunFCS,UngvariGS,O'DonnellD:OralHealthofPsychiatric long-termresidentsofahospitalfortheintellectuallyhandicappedand In-PatientsinHongKong.IntJSocPsychiatry2004,50(2):186–191. psychiatricallyill.NZDentJ1995,91(404):49–56. 28. ZusmanSP,PonizovskyAM,DekelD,MasarwaA-e-S,RamonT,NatapovL, 2. LesterV,AshleyFP,GibbonsDE:Therelationshipbetweensocio-dental GrinshpoonA:Anassessmentofthedentalhealthofchronic indicesofhandicap,feltneedfordentaltreatmentanddentalstateina institutionalizedpatientswithpsychiatricdiseaseinIsrael.SpecCare groupoffrailandfunctionallydependentolderadults.CommunityDent Dentist2010,30(1):18–22. OralEpidemiol1998,26(3):155–159. 29. WitterDJ,vanPalensteinHeldermanWH,CreugersNHJ,KäyserAF: 3. HennequinM,FaulksD,RouxD:Accuracyofestimationofdental Theshorteneddentalarchconceptanditsimplicationsfororalhealth treatmentneedinspecialcarepatients.JDent2000,28(2):131–136. care.CommunityDentOralEpidemiol1999,27(4):249–258. 4. VelascoE,BullonP:PeriodontalstatusandtreatmentneedsamongSpanish 30. KannoT,CarlssonGE:Areviewoftheshorteneddentalarchconcept hospitalizedpsychiatricpatients.SpecCareDentist1999,19(6):254–258. focusingontheworkbytheKäyser/Nijmegengroup.JOralRehabil2006, 5. KumarM,ChanduGN,ShafiullaMD:Oralhealthstatusandtreatment 33(11):850–862. needsininstitutionalizedpsychiatricpatients:oneyeardescriptivecross sectionalstudy.IndianJDentRes2006,17(4):171–177. doi:10.1186/1472-6831-13-8 6. FriedlanderAH,MarderSR:Thepsychopathology,medicalmanagementand Citethisarticleas:Chuetal.:Dentalprosthetictreatmentneedsof dentalimplicationsofschizophrenia.JAmDentAssoc2002,133(5):603–610. inpatientswithschizophreniainTaiwan:across-sectionalstudy.BMC 7. YaltirikM,KocaelliH,YargicI,YaltirikM,KocaelliH,YargicI:Schizophrenia OralHealth201313:8. anddentalmanagement:reviewoftheliterature.QuintessenceInt2004, 35(4):317–320.