ebook img

Delays in Juvenile Justice PDF

136 Pages·09.27 MB·English
by  
Save to my drive
Quick download
Download
Most books are stored in the elastic cloud where traffic is expensive. For this reason, we have a limit on daily download.

Preview Delays in Juvenile Justice

.. " National Center for Juvenile Justice 710 Fifth Avenue Pittsburgh, PA 15219-3000 .-.., Delays in Juvenile Justice Jeffrey A. Butts Gregory J. Halemba Delays ni Juvenile Justice Sanctions Project Final Report August 1996 Copyright 1996 National Center for Juvenile Justice ';7 ~ • I This report was prepared by the National Center for Juvenile Justice, the research division of the National Council of Juvenile and Family Court Judges, and was supported by grant #92-JN-CX-0002 from the Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention, Office of Justice Programs, U.S. Department of Justice. Points of view or opinions expressed in this document are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the official position or policies of the U.S. Department of Justice. k Copyright 1996 National Center for Juvenile Justice 710 Fifth Avenue Pittsburgh, PA 15219-3000 412-227-6950 .I . "? Table of Contents Page ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ........................................................................................................................... vii PREFACE .............................................................. : ....... : ........................................................... ~ ................. ix INTRODUCTION .......................... i ............................................ ~ ................. .......... ......... .......... . ................. xi CHAPTER 1. DELAY IN THE JUVENILE JUSTICE SYSTEM by Jeffrey A. Butts INTRODUCTION 1 , +, COURT DELAY ................................................................................................................ I Effects of Delay ...................... . .................. . ........................................ ................... 3 Time and the Effectiveness of Juvenile Court Sanctions 3 Adolescents as Defendants ..................................................................................... 4 CONTROLLING DELAY .................................................................................................. 5 Direct Inducements to Control Delay .................................................................... 5 Management Interventions to Control Delay ......................................................... 7 CONTROLLING DELAY IN THE JUVENILE COURT .................................................... 9 Constitutional Provisions ...................................................................................... 9 Legislation and Rules in the Juvenile Court ............................... ~ ........................ 11 Case Law and Juvenile Court Processing Time ................................................... 11 Time Standards in Juvenile Court ....................................................................... 15 Management Interventions in the Juvenile Court ................................................ 18 CONCLUSION ................ . ............................................................................................... 19- CHAPTER 2. THE CAUSES OF DELAY by Jeffrey A. Butts INTRODUCTION 21 THE CONCEPT OF DELAY ........................................................................................... 21 Measuring Delay ............................................................................................ . .... 21 CAUSAL FACTORS IN DELAY ..................................................................................... 24 Resources/Workload ........................................................................................... 25 Jurisdiction Size ............................................. . ............... . .................................... 26 Case Characteristics ............................................................................................ 26 The Role of Counsel ....................... . .................................................................... 28 Procedures .......................................................................................................... 29 Management and Organization .......... ..................................................... ............ 31 APPLYING ORGANIZATIONAL THEORY TO COURT DELAY ................................. 33 The Human Relations School .............................................................................. 33 The Environmental School .................................................................................. 34 CONCLUSION ............................................................................................................. .... 36 ' i Delays in Juvenile Justice CHAPTER 3. NATIONAL SURVEY OF DELINQUENCY DELAYS by Jeffrey A. Butts and Gregory J. Halemba INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................. 41 METHODOLOGY ........................................................................................................... 41 Study Sample .................................................................................... : ................ 41 Data Collection .................................................................................................. 41 RESULTS ........................................................................................................................ 42 Satisfaction With Case Processing Time ............................................................. 42 Case Processing Stages ....................................................................................... 43 ORGANIZATIONAL CHARACTERISTICS ................................................................... 44 Court Workload .................................................................................................. 45 Resources ........................................................... . ................................... :: .......... 45 Caseflow Management ....................................................................................... 47 Calendaring ........... . ........................................................................................... 48 Procedural Issues That Affect Case Flow ............................................................ 48 Staff Attitudes .................................................................................................... 48 Legal Environment ............................................................................................. 49 ORGANIZATIONAL PROBLEMS AND DISSATISFACTION WITH ........................... 49 CASE PROCESSING TIME CONCLUSION ................................................................................................................ 52 CHAPTER 4. CASE PROCESSING IN 3 JUVENILE COURTS by Gregory J. Halemba and Jeffrey A. Butts INTRODUCTION ............................................................ i ............................................... 55 BALTIMORE CITY: LEGISLATING DELAY REDUCTION ............... . ....... :. ............... 57 Delinquency Case Processing ............................................................................. 58 Ongoing Challenges ................................................................. ~ ..... ................... 58 CUYAHOGA COUNTY: LABOR-INTENSIVE DELAY REDUCTION ........................ 59 Juvenile Court Workload Statistics ..................................................................... 59 Delinquency Case Processing ............................................................................. 61 Improving the Management of Caseflow ..................................................... : ...... 63 Efforts to Facilitate Timely Processing of Detention Cases .................................. 64 Continuing Impediments to Timely Case Processing .......................................... 66 Conclusion ......................................................................................................... 68 MARICOPA COUNTY: CONTROLLING DELAYS WITH AUTOMATION ................ 68 Juvenile Court Workload Statistics ....................... .............................................. 69 Stable Leadership ............................................................................................... 70 Court Automation and Caseflow Management .................................................... 70 Studies and Experimentation .............................................................................. 80 Conclusion ......................................... ................................................................ 81 ) : , .L CHAPTER 5. NATIONAL PATTERNS IN DELINQUENCY CASE PROCESSING by Jeffrey A. Butts • . INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................ 85 SPEED OF THE JUVENILE COURT PROCESS 85 CASE PROCESSING IN THE JUVENILE COURT ......................................................... 85 Case Processing Stages 86 SOURCE OF DATA ........................................................................................................ 87 Sample Size .............................................. : ......................................................... 88 RESULTS ' " 88 Time to Disposition ............................................................................................ 90 Distribution of Processing Time ...................................... . .................. -- ............... 92 Jurisdictional Variations in Processing Time ....................................................... 94 CONCLUSION .............................................................................................................. 102 CHAPTER 6. IMPLICATIONS AND CONCLUSIONS by Jeffrey A. Butts CRITICAL MOMENTS 105 REDUCING DELAY 106 Juvenile Justice Standards ................................................................................. 107 Caseflow Management ...................................................................................... 109 CONCLUSION .............................................................................................................. I I0 REFERENCES .......................................................................................................................................... I l l COURT CASES CITED ............................................................................................................................ 118 APPENDIX ............................................................................................................................................... 121 iii Delays in Juvenile Justice . I iv Tables and Figures CHAPTER 1 Table 1.1: Time limits (in days) for juvenile court adjudication and disposition .... ..., ......................... 12 : • . - hearings in cases not involving proceedings for transfer to criminal court Table 1.2: Time limits on juvenile court handling of delinquency cases .............................................. 13 considered for transfer to criminal court Table 1.3: Time limitations provided by various juvenile justice standards ........................................ 18 CHAPTER 3 Table 3.1: Survey response rate by type of respondent 42 Table 3.2: Proportion of respondents expressing dissatisfaction with the timeliness ........................... 43 of case processing, by type of delinquency case, by type of respondent Table3.3: Proportion of respondents expressing dissatisfaction with the amount ............................... 44 of time needed to process delinquency cases, by stage of processing, by type of respondent Table 3.4: Proportion of respondents acknowledging a "moderate" or "serious" . ............................... 46 problem with organizational and procedural characteristics in their juvenile court Table 3.5: Correlation betweeh respondents' perception of organizational/procedural ....................... 50 problems and general dissatisfaction with delinquency case processing time CHAPTER 4 Table 4.1: Delinquency cases disposed in three jurisdictions, 1986-1993 .......................................... 56 Table 4.2: Cuyahoga County juvenile court workload statistics ........................................................... 60 Table 4.3: Disposition rate for official delinquency cases and unruly cases, 1986-1994 ...................... 61 Table 4.4: Time frames for processing of.detained and non-detained delinquency cases ..................... 62 Table 4.5: Maricopa County juvenile court delinquency workload statistics .................................... ...~ 69 Figure 4. I: Maricopa county juvenile court center delinquency calendar summary report .. .................. 78 Period: 09--01-94 to 09-30-94 Figure 4.2: Maricopa county juvenile court delinquency calendar detailed report (sample output) ....... 79 Period: 09-01-94 to 09-30-94 Delays in Juvenile Justice Figure 4.3: Maricopa county juvenile court pending petition information report .................................. 79 Period: 09-01-94 to 09-30-94 'Figure 4.4: Maricopa county juvenile court delinquency petitions pending 360+ days ......................... 80 detail report (sample output) Period: 09--01-94 to 09-30-94 i , CHAPTER 5 I Table 5.1: Characteristics of delinquency cases handled during 1991 and 1992 by ............................ 89 juvenile courts in 394 large LI.S. counties, compared with 1992 national delinquency estimates Table 5.2: Days elapsed between referral and final disposition for delinquency cases ...... : .................. 91 handled during 1991 and 1992 by juvenile courts in sample counties I Figure 5.1: Rate of disposition f6r 1991 and 1992 delinquency cases processed 92 by juvenile courts in sample counties (N=524,713) I Figure 5.2: Rate of disposition for 1991 and 1992 delinquency cases in sample ...................... ............. 93 counties, by county population Figure 5.3: Rate of disposition for formally adjudicated 1991 and 1992 delinquency .......................... 94 I cases in sample counties, by county population Table 5.3: Average median disposition times for sample counties, by annual ..................... i ............... 96 number of petitioned cases Table 5.4: Average median disposition times in sample counties, by annual ....... . .............................. 97 case rate and the presence of State controls (court rules or legislation) on the timing of case processing Figure 5.4: Median days to disposition for petitioned cases, by annual case rate ................................. 98 Table 5.5: Descriptive statistics for county-aggregate variables used in multiple ' 99 regression analyses of disposition time for petitioned delinquency cases Table 5.6: OLS regression of county-aggregate disposition time on demographic ............................. 101 case processing, and legal characteristics of county CHAPTER 6 Figure 6.1: Fictitious example of comprehensive, component-based, graduated case ......................... 108 processing time standards for juvenile justice agencies vi f . ~ • stnemgdelwonkcA This study was supported by funds provided to Hon. Sharon McCully--Third Judicial • District the National Center for Juvenile Justice (NCJJ), the Court, Salt Lake City, Utah research division of the National Council of Dr.Edward Mulvey--Law dna Psychiatry . L • Juvenile and Family Court Judges, by the U.S. Program, Western Psychiatriclnstitute and tnemtrapeD of Justice's Office of Juvenile Justice Clinic, University of Pittsburgh School of dna Delinquency Prevention (OJJDP) through Medicine tnarg number 92-JN-CX-0002. The OJJDP program manager was .rM Jeffrey Slowikowski. Ms. Joyce Wright--Chief, Juvenile Division, State's Attorney's Office for Baltimore City, The research described in this report was Baltimore, Maryland developed in consultation with the members of a yrosivdi~?lanoitan committee. Members of this Assistance was provided by staff members at committee included: the National Center for Juvenile Justice, including Ms. Eleanor Austin--Director of Court Services Imogene Montgomery, Hunter ,VI_tsruH Diane (Retired), Wayne County Probate Court, Malloy, Gail Rico, dna Angela Sanders. Legal Detroit, Michigan research was performed yb Linda Szymanski. Comments dna suggestions were provided by .rD Carol Burgess--Former Deputy Director, Hunter Hurst III, Melissa Sickmund, and Howard Maricopa County Juvenile Court, Phoenix, Snyder of .JJCN Arizona This work would not have been possible Hon. Cheryl Allen Craig--Family Division, without the cooperation of the juvenile justice Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas, professionals who were interviewed yb the project Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania staff, those who took the time to complete the project's mailed survey, sa well as those who .rM David Fishkin---Chief, Juvenile Division, regularly contribute data to NCJJ's National Baltimore City Office of the Public Defender, Juvenile Court Data Archive. Their efforts are Baltimore, Maryland gratefully acknowledged. .rM John Howley--Assignment Services Manager, Points of view or opinions expressed in this Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas, document era those of eht authors dna do not Cleveland, Ohio represent the official position or policies of the Ms. Kim Kelly----Juvenile Court Administrator, U.S. Department of Justice, the National Council Maricopa County Juvenile Court, Phoenix, of Juvenile and Family Court Judges, or the Arizona National Center for Juvenile Justice. vii Delays. in Juvenile Justice t l J .°° L VIII

Description:
from the Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention, Office of Justice Programs, U.S. Maricopa county juvenile court pending petition information report . Chapter 1. Justice System. INTRODUCTION 1. Among the many social reform . similar to the obstacles afflicting all human serviee.
See more

The list of books you might like

Most books are stored in the elastic cloud where traffic is expensive. For this reason, we have a limit on daily download.