Death and Afterlife in Ancient Jewish and Christian Literature Gorgias Handbooks Gorgias Handbooks provides students and scholars with reference books, textbooks and introductions to different topics or fields of study. In this series, Gorgias welcomes books that are able to communicate information, ideas and concepts effectively and concisely, with useful reference bibliographies for further study. Death and Afterlife in Ancient Jewish and Christian Literature Pau Figueras gp 2019 Gorgias Press LLC, 954 River Road, Piscataway, NJ, 08854, USA www.gorgiaspress.com Copyright © 2 0 1 9 by Gorgias Press LLC All rights reserved under International and Pan-American Copyright Conventions. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning or otherwise without the prior written permission of Gorgias Press LLC. 2019 ܒܝ 1 ISBN 978-1-4632-3919-0 ISSN 1935-6838 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data A Cataloging-in-Publication Record is available from the Library of Congress. Printed in the United States of America To the blessed memory of my beloved parents, Jacint and Joaquima TABLE OF CONTENTS Table of Contents ..................................................................................... v Abbreviations ........................................................................................... xi Introduction .............................................................................................. 1 Chapter One. Canonical and Deuterocanonical Books of the Old Testament ................................................................................. 3 The concept of ‘life’ ........................................................................ 3 Death and the Tree of Life ............................................................ 4 Death as a phenomenon ................................................................ 4 Sheol and the grave ......................................................................... 5 Funerary rites and contact with the dead..................................... 6 Ideological development ................................................................ 7 Resurrection of dead and immortality of soul .......................... 11 Chapter Two. Apocryphal Literature .................................................. 13 I Enoch (Ethiopic Enoch) ........................................................... 14 Chapters 1–36 .......................................................................... 14 Chapters 37–104 (The Parables) ........................................... 17 Chapters 106–108 (Apocalypse of Noah) ........................... 23 The Book of Jubilees .................................................................... 23 The Testament of the Twelve Patriarchs ................................... 25 Testament of Simeon .............................................................. 26 Testament of Levi ................................................................... 26 Testament of Judah ................................................................. 27 Testament of Issachar ............................................................. 27 Testament of Dan ................................................................... 28 Testament of Naphtali ............................................................ 28 Testament of Gad.................................................................... 28 Testament of Asher ................................................................. 28 Testament of Joseph ............................................................... 29 Testament of Benjamin .......................................................... 29 Genesis Apocryphon .................................................................... 29 The Sibylline Oracles .................................................................... 30 v vi DEATH AND AFTERLIFE Book III .................................................................................... 30 Fragment III ............................................................................. 32 The Psalms of Solomon ............................................................... 32 Apocalypse of Elijah ..................................................................... 33 Apocryphon of Ezekiel ................................................................ 36 Assumption of Moses ................................................................... 37 Apocalypse of Moses or Life of Adam and Eve ...................... 38 The Fourth Book of Ezra (chs. 3–14)........................................ 43 The Martyrdom of Isaiah ............................................................. 47 The Lives of the Prophets............................................................ 48 Isaiah .......................................................................................... 48 Jeremiah .................................................................................... 48 Ezekiel ....................................................................................... 49 Daniel ........................................................................................ 50 Hosea ......................................................................................... 50 Micah the Morashtite .............................................................. 50 Jonah .......................................................................................... 50 Habakkuk .................................................................................. 50 Haggai ........................................................................................ 50 Zechariah son of Iddo ............................................................ 51 Malachi ...................................................................................... 51 Nathan ....................................................................................... 51 Zechariah son of Jehoiada ..................................................... 51 Elijah .......................................................................................... 51 The Testament of Job ................................................................... 51 The Syriac Apocalypse of Baruch ............................................... 53 Greek Apocalypse of Ezra ........................................................... 58 Paralipomena of Jeremiah ............................................................ 60 Greek Apocalypse of Baruch ....................................................... 61 Apocalypse of Zephaniah ............................................................ 62 Apocalypse of Sedrach ................................................................. 64 Testament of Solomon ................................................................. 64 The Prayer of Joseph .................................................................... 65 II Enoch (Slavonic Enoch) .......................................................... 65 III Enoch (Hebrew Enoch) ......................................................... 69 Chapter Three. The Books of the New Testament .......................... 73 Synoptic Gospels ........................................................................... 74 The Kingdom of God (Kingdom of Heaven) .................... 74 Resurrection of the Dead ....................................................... 75 ‘Parousia’ ................................................................................... 75 TABLE OF CONTENTS vii Judgment ................................................................................... 76 Afterlife ..................................................................................... 76 Jesus’ Death .............................................................................. 78 Acts of the Apostles ...................................................................... 79 Pauline Epistles .............................................................................. 83 I and II Thessalonians ............................................................ 83 I Corinthians ............................................................................ 84 II Corinthians and Romans ................................................... 86 Pastoral and Captivity Epistles .............................................. 87 Gospel and Epistles of John .................................................. 88 Catholic Epistles and Hebrews ................................................... 91 Jude ............................................................................................ 91 II Peter ...................................................................................... 92 James.......................................................................................... 93 I Peter ........................................................................................ 94 Hebrews .................................................................................... 95 Revelation of John ................................................................... 96 Chapter Four. Early Jewish Literature .............................................. 101 The Dead Sea Scrolls .................................................................. 101 Death and the body ............................................................... 102 Faith in immortality ............................................................... 103 General eschatology and future life .................................... 106 Upper World and Nether World......................................... 110 Philo of Alexandria ..................................................................... 111 The souls of the righteous.................................................... 112 Exceptional Figures ............................................................... 112 The Condemned .................................................................... 113 Flavius Josephus .......................................................................... 113 Portion of the Souls according to the Romans ................ 114 According to the Indians ...................................................... 115 According to the Essenes and the Greek .......................... 115 According to the Pharisees .................................................. 116 According to the Sadduacees ............................................... 117 According to Josephus himself ........................................... 117 Rabbinic Literature ...................................................................... 118 Death and Its Religious Significance .................................. 118 Faith in Immortality and Resurrection ............................... 120 Messianic Age......................................................................... 123 The Coming Age and the Upper World ............................ 126 The World of the Souls ........................................................ 127 viii DEATH AND AFTERLIFE Gehenna .................................................................................. 129 Paradise of the Blessed ......................................................... 131 The Throne of God .............................................................. 134 Funerary Epigraphy ..................................................................... 137 The Grave ............................................................................... 137 Death ....................................................................................... 139 Resurrection ........................................................................... 140 The Dwelling-place of the Souls ......................................... 140 Chapter Five. Early Christian Literature ........................................... 143 ‘Didache’ or Doctrine of the Twelve Apostles ....................... 143 Epistles of Ignatius from Antioch ............................................ 144 Epistle of Polycarp to the Philippians ...................................... 146 Martyrdom of Polycarp .............................................................. 147 Papias from Hierapolis ............................................................... 148 Irenaeus’ Testimony (Adv Haer IV, 33, 3–4).................... 148 Jerome (De viris illustribus, 18) ........................................... 149 Philip Sidetes (The Christian History)................................ 149 Anastasius Sinaita (Hexaemeron, VII) ............................... 149 Phocius (Bibliotheca) ............................................................ 149 The Presbyters ............................................................................. 149 Epistle of Barnaba ....................................................................... 150 Epistle to Diognetus ................................................................... 151 I Epistle of Clement to the Corinthians .................................. 152 II Epistle of Clement .................................................................. 153 The Shepherd of Hermas ........................................................... 154 Visions ..................................................................................... 154 Precepts ................................................................................... 155 Parables ................................................................................... 155 Justin the Martyr .......................................................................... 156 The First Apology ................................................................. 157 The Second Apology ............................................................. 158 Dialogue with Trypho ........................................................... 159 Odae of Solomon ........................................................................ 160 Chapter Six. Excursus on Contemporaneous Foreign Religions ........................................................................................ 163 The Iranian Religious World ..................................................... 164 Pre-Zoroastrian Period ......................................................... 164 Early Zoroastrianism ............................................................ 165 The Religion of the Achaemenians..................................... 167 The Parthians ......................................................................... 167 TABLE OF CONTENTS ix Egypt ............................................................................................. 168 Death ....................................................................................... 169 The grave ................................................................................ 170 Afterlife ................................................................................... 172 The Hellenic World ..................................................................... 175 Classical religion..................................................................... 176 Orphism .................................................................................. 178 The Mysteries ......................................................................... 179 Rome ............................................................................................. 180 The legacy of Greece ............................................................ 183 Eastern cults ........................................................................... 185 Bibliography .......................................................................................... 189 Index ....................................................................................................... 201