Cultural Heritage Rights

581 Pages·2015·24.1 MB·English

by  Anthony J. Connolly

Cultural HeritageR ights
The InternationalL ibrary of Essayso n Rights
SeriesE ditor: Tom Campbell
Titles in the Series:
SexualO rientationa nd Rights Genocidea nd HumanR ights
Nicholas Bamforth Mark Lattimer
Rights: Conceptsa nd Contexts LanguageR ights
Brian Bix and Horacia Spector Stephen May
Disability Rights Animal Rights
Peter Blanck Clare Palmer
The Right to a Fair Trial Gendera nd Rights
Thom Brooks DeborahL . Rhodea ndC arol Sanger
Global Minority Rights Economic,S ocial and CulturalR ights
JoshuaC aste/Uno Manisuli Ssenyonjo
Cultural HeritageR ights Health Rights
AnthonyJ . Connolly Michael J. Selgelida nd ThomasP ogge
IndigenousR ights CitizenshipR ights
AnthonyJ . Connolly Jo Shawa ndi gor Stiks
Migrants and Rights Theorieso f Rights
Mary Crock C.L. Ten
Refugeesa ndR ights Bills of Rights
Mary Crock Mark Tushnet
Civil Rights and Security EnvironmentalR ights
David Dyzenhaus SteveV anderheiden
DemocraticR ights The Right to Bodily Integrity
Ran Hirsch! A.M Viens
Group Rights Labour Rights
PeterJ ones Marley S. Weiss
Human Rights and Corporations ReligiousR ights
David Kinley Lorenzo Zucca
PrisonersR' ights
John Kleinig
Cultural Heritage Rights
Editedb y
Anthony J. Connolly
AustralianN ational University
R
OU Routledge
TLE
DG Taylor & Francis Group
E
NEW YORK LONDON
First published2 015 by AshgateP ublishing
Published2 016b y Routledge
2 Park Square,M ilton Park, Abingdon, Oxon OXI4 4RN
711 Third Avenue, New York, NY 10017, USA
Routledgeis an imprint oft he Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business
Copyright © Anthony .T. Connolly 2015. For copyrighto f individual articlesp leaser efer tot he
Acknowledgements.
All rights reserved.N o part of this book may be reprintedo r reproducedo r utilised in any form or by
any electronic,m echanical,o r otherm eans,n ow known or hereafteri nvented,i ncluding photocopying
andr ecording,o r in any information storageo r retrieval system,w ithout permissioni n writing from
the publishers.
Notice:
Producto r corporaten ames may be trademarks or registeredt rademark,s and are usedo nly for
identification and explanationw ithout intent to infringe.
Whereverp ossible,t heser eprintsa re madef rom a copy of the original printing, but thesec ant hemselves
be of very variableq uality. Whilst the publisherh asm adee verye ffort to ensuret he quality of the reprint,
some variability may inevitably remain.
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data
A cataloguer ecord for this book is availablef rom the British Library.
Library of CongressC ontrol Number: 2015932172
ISBN 9781472423245(h bk)
Contents
Acknowledgements ix
SeriesP reface xiii
Introduction XV
Bibliography andF urther Reading xxxii
PART I FOUNDATIONS
The Concepto f Cultural Heritage
1 John Henry Merryman (2005), 'Cultural Property Internationalism',I nternational
Journal ofCultural Property, 12, pp. 11-39. 3
2 JanetB lake (2000), 'On Defining the Cultural Heritage,' International and
ComparativeL aw Quarterly, 49, pp. 61-85. 33
The Politics of CulturalH eritageR ights
3 RosemaryJ . Coombe( 2009), 'The ExpandingP urview of Cultural Propertiesa nd
Their Politics', AnnualR eviewo fL aw andS ocialS cience,5 , pp. 393-412. 59
4 JonathanS . Bell (201 3), 'The Politics of Preservation:P rivileging One Heritage
over Another', InternationalJ ournal ofC ultural Property, 20, pp. 431-50. 79
PART II TYPES OF CULTURAL HERITAGE RIGHTS
Natural Heritagea s Cultural Heritage
5 Shabnaml nanloo Dailoo and Frits Pannekoek(2 008), 'Naturea ndC ulture:
A New World HeritageC ontext',i nternationalJ ournal ofC ultural Property,
15, pp. 25-47. 101
6 GonzaloO viedo andT atjanaP uschkarsky(2 012), 'World Heritagea nd
Rights-BasedA pproachest o NatureC onservation',In ternationalJ ournal of
Heritage Studies, 18, pp. 285-96. 125
Urban Landscapesa s Cultural Heritage
7 Lindsay M. Weiss (2014), 'Informal Settlementsa ndU rban HeritageL andscapes
in South Africa', Journal ofSocialA rchaeology, 14, pp. 3-25. 137
ArtefactualC ultural HeritageR ights
8 Michael L. Dutra (2004), 'Sir, How Much is that Ming Vase in the Window?
ProtectingC ultural Relics in the People'sR epublico f China', Asian-PacificL aw
and Policy Journal, 5, pp. 62-100. 161
vi Cultural Heritage Rights
UnderwaterC ultural HeritageR ights
9 SarahD romgoole( 2003), '2001 UNESCO Conventiono n the Protectiono f the
UnderwaterC ultural Heritage',J nternationalJ ournal ofM arine andC oastalL aw,
18,pp.59-91. 201
IntangibleC ulturalH eritageR ights
10 Michael F. Brown (2005), 'HeritageT rouble: RecentW ork on the Protectiono f
IntangibleC ultural Property',I nternationalJ ournal ofC ultural Property, 12,
pp. 40-61. 235
11 ThomasM . Schmitt (2008), 'The UNESCO Concepto f SafeguardingIn tangible
Cultural Heritage:I ts Backgrounda nd Marrakchi Roots',i nternationalJ ournal
ofH eritage Studies,1 4, pp. 95-111. 257
IndigenousC ultural HeritageR ights
12 RosemaryJ . Coombew ith JosephF . Turcotte( 2012), 'IndigenousC ultural
Heritagei n Developmenta nd Trade: Perspectivesfr om the Dynamicso f Cultural
HeritageL aw and Policy', in ChristophB . Grabe,r Karolina Kuprechta ndJ essica
C. Lai (eds), International Trade in Indigenous Cultural Heritage: Legal and
Policy Issues,C heltenham:E dward Elgar, pp. 272-306. 275
13 MelissaF . Baird (2013), 'IndigenousC ultural Landscapesa nd the Politics of
Heritage', InternationalJ ournal ofH eritage Studies,1 9, pp. 327--40. 311
PART Ill CONTEMPORARY ISSUESI N CULTURAL HERITAGE RIGHTS LAW
Repatriationo f Cultural Heritage
14 RobertK . Paterson( 2006), 'ResolvingM aterial Culture Disputes:H umanR ights,
PropertyR ights and Crimesa gainstH umanity', WillametteJ ournal ofI nternational
Law and DisputeR esolution, 14, pp. 155-74. 327
Illicit Tradei n Cultural Heritage
15 Patty Gerstenblith( 2007), 'Controlling the InternationalM arket in Antiquities:
Reducingt he Harm, Preservingt he Pas't, ChicagoJ ournal ofI nternationalL aw,
8, pp. 169-95. 347
Armed Conflict and Cultural HeritageP rotection
16 Hirad Abtahi (2001), 'The Protectiono f Cultural Propertyi n Times of Armed
Conflict: The Practiceo f the InternationalC riminal Tribunal for the Former
Yugoslavia',H arvard Human RightsJ ournal, 14, pp. 1-32. 375
17 FrancescoF rancionia ndF edericoL enzerini (2006), 'The Obligation to Prevent
andA void Destructiono f Cultural Heritage:F rom Bamiyant o Iraq', in
B. Hoffman (ed.), Art andC ultural Heritage: Law, Policy, andP ractice,
Cambridge:C ambridgeU niversity Press,p p. 28--40. 407
Cultural Heritage Rights vii
Tourism,E conomicD evelopmenta nd Cultural HeritageP rotection
18 Tim Winter (2008), 'Post-ConflictH eritagea nd Tourismi n Cambodia:T he Burden
of Angkor', InternationalJ ournal ofH eritage Studies, 14, pp.524-39. 421
PART IV FUTURE DIRECTIONSI N CULTURAL HERITAGE RIGHTS LAW
CulturalH eritageP rotectiona nd the Challengeo f ClimateC hange
19 Hee-EunK im (20 11 ), 'ChangingC limate, ChangingC ulture: Adding the Climate
ChangeD imensiont o the Protectiono f Intangible Cultural Heritage',I nternational
Journal ofC ultural Property, 18, pp. 259-90. 439
Cultural Expressionsa sC ultural Heritage
20 RachaelC raufurdS mith (2007), 'The UNESCO Conventiono n the Protectiona nd
Promotiono f Cultural Expressions:B uilding a New World Information and
CommunicationO rder?',I nternationalJ ournal ofC ommunication,1 , pp. 24-55. 47 1
The HumanG enomea nd Cultural Heritage
21 Pilar N. Ossorio( 2007), 'The Human Genomea s Common Heritage: Common
Senseo r Legal Nonsense?J',o urnal ofL aw, Medicine andE thics, 35, pp. 425-39. 503
BeyondR ights?R ethinkingt he CulturalH eritageP rotectionP aradigm
22 Jan Hodder( 20 I 0), 'Cultural HeritageR ights: From Ownershipa nd Descentt o
Justicea nd Well-Being', Anthropological Quarterly, 83, pp. 861-82. 519
Name index 541
Taylor & Francis
Taylor & Francis Group
http:// tayloran dfra ncis.com
Acknowledgements
Ashgatew ould like to thanko ur researcherasn dt he contributinga uthorsw ho providedc opies,
alongw ith the following for their permission to reprint copyrightm aterial.
Annual Reviews for the essay: Rosemary J. Coombe (2009), 'The Expanding Purview
of Cultural Propertiesa nd Their Politics', Annual Review of Law and Social Science, 5,
pp. 393-412.C opyright© 2009 by Annual Reviews. All rights reserved.
Anthropological Quarterly for the essay: Ian Hodder (2010), 'Cultural Heritage Rights:
From Ownership and Descentt o Justice and Well-Being', Anthropological Quarterly, 83,
pp. 861-82. Copyright© 2010 by the Institute for EthnographicR esearch( IFER), a part of
the GeorgeW ashingtonU niversity. All rights reserved.
Asian-Pacific Law and Policy Journal for the essay: Michael L. Dutra (2004), 'Sir, How
Much is that Ming Vase in the Window? ProtectingC ultural Relics in the People's Republic
of China',A sian-PacificL aw andP olicy Journal, 5, pp. 62-100.
Brill Academic Publishers for the essay: Sarah Dromgoole (2003), '2001 UNESCO
Conventiono n the Protectiono f the UnderwaterC ultural Heritage',I nternational Journal of
Marine andC oastal Law, 18, pp. 59-91. Copyright © 2003 Kluwer Law International.
CambridgeU niversity Pressf or the essays:J ohnH enry Merryman( 2005), 'Cultural Property
Internationalism,'I nternationalJ ournalo fC ultural Property,1 2, pp. 11-39.C opyright©2 005
InternationalC ultural PropertyS ociety, publishedb y CambridgeU niversityP ress, reproduced
with permission;J anetB lake (2000), 'On Defining the Cultural Heritage,' The International
and Comparative Law Quarterly, 49, pp. 61-85. Copyright © 2000 British Institute of
international andC omparativeL aw, publishedb y CambridgeU niversityP ressr, eproducedw ith
permission;J onathanS . Bell (2013), 'The Politics of Preservation:P rivileging One Heritage
overA nother',I nternationalJ ournal ofC ultural Property, 20, pp. 431-50.C opyright©2 013
InternationalC ultural PropertyS ociety, publishedb y CambridgeU niversity Press,r eproduced
with permission; Shabnaml nanloo Dailoo and Frits Pannekoek(2 008), 'Naturea nd Culture:
A New World HeritageC ontext', International Journal ofCultural Property, 15, pp. 25-47.
Copyright© 2008I nternationalC ulturalP ropertyS ociety, publishedb y CambridgeU niversity
Press, reproducedw ith permission;M ichael F. Brown (2005), 'HeritageT rouble: RecentW ork
on the Protectiono f IntangibleC ultural Property',I nternationalJ ournal ofC ultural Property,
12, pp. 40-61. Copyright © 2005 International Cultural Property Society, published by
CambridgeU niversity Press,r eproducedw ith permission;F rancescoF rancionia ndF ederico
Lenzerini (2006), 'The Obligation to Preventa nd Avoid Destruction of Cultural Heritage:
From Bamiyan to Iraq', in B. Hoffman (ed.), Art and Cultural Heritage: Law, Policy, and
Practice, Cambridge:C ambridgeU niversity Press,p p. 28-40. Copyright© 2006 Cambridge
University Press,© 2006lntroductiona ndC ompilation,B arbaraT . Hoffman, reproducedw ith