Criminal law : cases and materials

6 Pages·1998·0.22 MB·English

by  Shaffer, Martha

CRIMINAL LAW
Y
R
A
R
B
LI Cases and Materials
W
A
L
N
KI
S Volume 2
A
L
A
R
O
B
Martha Shaffer
Hamish Stewart
"V
Faculty of Law
University of Toronto
1998-99
Prepared with the assistance of Nikki Gershbain
These materiais are distributed solely for use by students in the
Faculty of Law, University of Toronto
Storage
KF
9218
.M48
1998
2
V.
c. 1
L. ,A
J
i
41§*
{
1 , - , ^v" ■
\ • . ,' >.' «••. r< ' ► •
4» M.> J
i ;■ ; :\t •' ■: Z'VC -^Tfi
> ' .. f .■-■■’-.’'J
BORA LASION LAW LWRARY
UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO
CRIMINAL LAW
Cases and Materials
Volume 2
Martha Shaffer
Hamish Stewart
Faculty of Law
University of Toronto
1998-99
Prepared with the assistance of Nikki Gershbain
These materials are distributed solely for use by students in the
Faculty of Law, University of Toronto
Digitized by the Internet Archive
in 2018 with funding from
University of Toronto
https://archive.org/details/criminallawcases02shaf_8
Page ii
Table of Contents
4. MISTAKE 417
4(a) Mistake of Fact.417
4(a)(i)The Relationship Between Mistake and Fault.417
R. V. Beaver.417
R. Pappajohn 423
V. .
Note on Pappajohn.439
Sansregret v. The Queen.442
Note on Sansregret.449
Note: Failing to Take Reasonable Steps.449
4(a)(ii) Constitutional Considerations.451
R. Nguyen; R. v. Hess.451
V.
R. Darrach.459
V.
4(b)(iii) Mistaking One Offence for Another.462
R. Kundeus 462
V. .
R. Ladue.469
V.
Further Reading For Chapter 4(a).470
4(b) Mistake of Law.472
R. Campbell and Mlynarchuk.472
V.
R. Molis 476
V. .
R. Docherty.480
V.
R. Pontes 485
V. .
R. Jorgensen 507
V. .
Further Reading.516
5. PARTIES TO OFFENCES 517
5(a) Aiding and Abetting.517
* R. Dunlop and Sylvester.517
V.
R. Kulbacki 524
V. .
R. Russell 526
V. .
R. Popen 532
V. .
R. Madigan 537
V. .
R. Poitras 539
V. .
R. Greyeyes 544
V. .
5(b) Common Intention.553
R. Kirkness 553
V. .
Note: R. v. Jackson.569
6. INCHOATE OFFENCES 573
6(a) Counselling.573
Page iii
R. McLeod et al 573
V. .
R. Richard 575
V. .
R. Gonzague 575
V. .
6(b) Attempts: The Mental Element.578
R. Ancio 578
V. .
R. Logan.584
V.
Questions on the Mental Element for Attempts.591
6(c) Attempts: The Physical Element.592
R. Robinson.592
V.
R. Barker.595
V.
R. Cline.601
V.
R. James.603
V.
R. Sorrell and Bondett.605
V.
R. Deutsch.608
V.
6(d) Impossible Attempts.612
Note: The English Law of Impossible Attempts.612
United States of America v. Dynar.618
Further Reading on Attempts.640
6(e) Conspiracy.641
R. Gill.641
V.
R. Sokoloski.643
V.
R. O’Brien.648
V.
Questions on Conspiracy.658