Covenant Causality in Medieval Thought - Studies in Philosophy, Theology, and Economic Practice

337 Pages·1984·24.578 MB·English

by  William J. Courtenay

WillJi.Ca omu rtenay
CovenaannCdta usality
inM edieTvhaolu ght
StudiinPe hsi losTohpehoyl,o gy
anEdc onomic Practice
VARIORURME PRINTS
Lond1o9n8 4
r f 1si llri .a om urnta v
.J
BritLiisbhr ardya tCaJC Po urtenayJ,. William
Covenaanncdta usianlm ietdyit ehvoaulg ht.
--(Collsetcutdseieder CsiS e2s0;6 )
1.PhilosMoepdiheyv,a l
I. Title
190'.9'0B2721
ISB0N- 86078-154-2
Copyr©i g1h9t8 4 VarioRreupmr ints
PubliisnGh reedBa rti tbayi Vna rioRreupmr ints
20P embrMiedwgLseo ndWolIn 3 EQ
Prinitne dG reabty BPrairtaaidPnir gimn t
GatesThyenaaedn ,Wd e ar
VARIORURME PRICNST2 06
CONTENTS
.
.
Preface.
LX-Xl
1'HDEE VELOPMENATNI DOEFA
1 NeceasnsFdir teye dom
396-4
iAnn se'Chson n ceopfGt oido n
DiWei rkungsgAensscevhloimncs h te
CanteArkbtuderenyer :r sltnetne rnationalen
Anselm-TaWgiumnpg/S,ee npB,ta ed1n 9·7i0b.e r
AnalAencsteal m4i.a2n.a
Frankfu1r9t7/5M ain,
II SacraSmyemnbtao,nCld a usality
inB ernoafCrl da irvaux 111-122
BernoafCr ldo irSvtauudxi:e s
PresetnDoto erJdne aLne clercq.
CisteSrtcuidSaiener 2si3 e.s ,
WashingCt.Co:in s,t ePDru.cb ilainc1 a9t7i3o ns,
Ill Natuarntedh Nea tural
iTnw elfthT-hCoeungthutr y 12-6
LondVoanr:i oRreupmr1 i9n8t4s ,
IV
ThDei aloefDc itvi0ic1n nen ipotenc1e-3 7
LondVoanr:i oRreupnr11i9 n8t4s ,
VI
V The Critique on Natural Causality
in the MutakaJlimun and Non1inalism 77-94
The Harvard Theological Review 66.
Cambridge, Mass., 1973
Tf-SlOEC IAL-ECOCNOONMTIECX T
VI The King and the Leaden Coin:
The Econo1nic Background of
18250-9
'Sine quano n' Causality
Traditio XXV/11.
NeYwo rk, 1972
VII Token Coinage and the Administration
27259-5
of Poor Relief during the Late Middle Ages
1/1.
The Journal ofI nterdisciplinary History
Ca,nbridge, Mass., 1972
CONSEQUEINNCL EATS E M EDIEVTAHLO UGHT
VlllaJo hn of Mirecourt and Gregory
of Rirnini on Whether God
22245-6
Can Undo the Past
Recherches de theologie ancienne
er ,necUr!vale XXXIX.
Louvain, 1972
VlllbJo hn of Mirecourt (continued) 147-174A
Ibid. XL.
Louvain. 1973
IX Covenant and Causality in Pierre d'Ailly 94-l 19
Specu!uVrIn. XL
Cambridge. Mass., /()7/
..
VII
X CranamseaN ro 1ninalist­
36378-0
Sed contra
TheH arvTahredo logi5ca7l. Review
C,1mbMraisdsg1.e9,,6 4
NOMJNALAINSDMA SCRIBVEADL UE
XI 265-9
NominaaJnids mML eadtiee Rvealli gion
ThPeu rsoufHi otl iinnLe astMsee dieval
anRde tlaiRs·seafnicgei on.
Papferrostm hU en iveorfA1s iicthyi gan
ConfereedCn.hc aer,Tl reisn wkiatuhs
HeiAk.oO berman.
LeidBerni1:l9 l7,4
XII Nominaalnids nL1a teT hMoeudgihetv:a l
aB ibliogErsaspahyi cal 716-734
TheolSotguidc3ia3el.s
BaltiMldn.1o,9r 7e2,.
Xlll LatMee dieNvoamli naRleivsims ited:
1972-1982 l596-4]
Jouronf1a hflel isorfo rIvd eas X LIV.
Philadel1p9h8i3a , Pa.,
Index
1-8
'fhis cvoonltu,an\ti, �ne)os tfa l3 50 pages.
PUBLISHNEORT'ES
The articles in this \'.Olume, as in all others in the
Collected Studies Series, have not been given a new,
continuous pagination. In order to avoid confusion,
and to facilitate their use where these same studies
have been referred to elsewhere, the original pagination
has been maintained wherever possible.
Each article has been given a Roman number in
order of appearance, as listed in the Contents. This
number is repeated on each page and quoted in the
index entries.
PREFACE
"' Twoi nterrtehleamatereesedx plionrt ehdee sses aOynsei. s
thteh emoefd ivoimnnei poatnecdna cues aelsipteyct,ih ael ly
scholdaissttiiocnfa c btsiooalnnu odtr ed apionwecedrr e attoe d
handtlhpeeo tenctoinaflllniyoc ttioiofnn gs d firveienadeno dm
three liaobfti hlleai wotsfyn ataunrgder aTchese.e cotnhde me
itsh ied eofaa scrviabletudhe sa:ot m e tihnti hwniogsrs (l bdo th
objeacnhtdus m aanc tinoenensdo)b t ec auseaflfleyoc ntt ihvee
basoifss omien her"ennatt ubruect"o uolpde riantset ead
throvuaglhau sec rtiotb heedim na c onvenoarcn otnatlr actual
system.
Botihd edarseu wp otnh seo clieaglaa,nl ed,c onovmailci djty
ofc ontraagcrteueamlae nncdrt esid nistt ruamste hnetys ,w ere
develionpt ehdte w elafntdth h irtceeennttuhBr uitte hse.
theolaongpdih ciallo svoeprhsoiiftco haneli s deed aesp enldeesds
ont hlee geanlf orcoefcm oennttar namdco trsoe nt hveo luntary,
seblifn-dniantguo frt ehr ee latioofGn osdah nimdpa no,fG od
ancdr eaItniiotnti.hai edl eltayhs ca otn trtiotb huceto endc eption
ofc ovencaanutsaawlJe irwteoy r koeudt by tfhreooml ogians
widedliyf fetrreandti Bteinoendsi:cC tiisnteesrA,cu isatnisn,
Canonsse,c uplraire asntdsD ,o miniTchaenc so.n ceptual
frametwhourcskr eahtoewde,v eevre,n tcuaamltelob y e t he
specpiraolpo efrF trya nciasncadau tnhsao srsso cwiiatlthae tde
medineovamli nalism.
Ino ritghien egsrseoawuyo tsfa ni nteirnte hmseet a nainndg
widiemrp licoafatt ihoenoosfrs ya cramceanutsabalals ioetndy
ascrviablewudhe i,ic nth u rn ilnemtdo on meett ahreyos royc,i al
welfpaorlei,tt hiocuaglha ct o mapnadr haitsitovofter hc yee ntral
themEeassa,tn W de sAtl.bl u t three bweetrwete hewenr itten
�proif1n 9g6a 9nt dh e sp1r9i7Mn2ug.c hot fho tafit mw eas sp ent
int hcel assartMo aodmi wsiotnsh t udwehnotissne t earneds t
questsitoinmsus loa1otnftee hd ie d eaansad p proparcehseesn ted
herBeu.tt hree searcwhr itawinendrgf e a cilaittt ahtee d
beginanniednn bgdy g rafnrtosTm h Ne atiEonndaolw mfeonrt
the
Humani(1t9i6e8sa- nf6dr9 o)Tm h Ien stfiotRrue tsee airnc h
X
thHe umanities at oftW hies coU(nn1si9iv7ne1 rt-so7i 2t)y,
whoIma me specgiraaltleyf ul.
Thaer rangoefem sesniatnty hsvi osl uimcseh ronoalnodg ical
themabtuiitmtc a,yb eu setfou lk tnho·ewO ridnwe hri tchhe y
werceo nceivwerdi t(atsneodnn 1tehtpehu ibnlgi dcaattei odno es
(1969);
noatl wrayesv eTahlpe)a .p oenrP iedr'rAei wlaflsiy r st
follboyw" eTdh Kei nagn dt hLee adCeoni n("1 96f9ot)rh e
AmeriHciasnt oArsiscoaclim aeteitioinnNn egw Y or"kT;o ken
Coina(g1e9"7f 0ot)rh Ree naisSsoacniceet y imnSe aent ing
Franc"iNsactoau;nr tdeh Nea tu(r1a9la7"t0 ) the rtehqeu est of
MedieSvtauld Pireosg raatRm o chesttheAern ;s eplanp1e r
(19f7ot0rh) Ae n seClomn garBtea sds WiGmeprfmeaannn,yd ;
the estshaMeyu toank alalnidNm oumni na(l1i9sf7mo0 tr)h e
AmeriHciasnt oArsiscoacli maeteitoiinnn B go stTohno.s e
findingtsh eanwp eprlteio e dbt rhoea pdreorb loefdm i vine
omnipoatnedvn oclei atliroenta.od,uy c ohnei dnt hAen selm
papeTrh.ar te suilntt ehade r tiocnMl iesr ecaonudRr itm ini
(19)7B,1e TnoafCr lda ir(v1a9u7ax2n i)dn. i ttiharete esdeo anr ch
thdei aloefdc itvioicmn nei potewnacesev etnhtwaurtai ltaltsye n
a papefro rt hec onferoenno cmen ipotaenndfc uet ure
contianOtgh einot siS n1t 9a8tT2eh. e vetrhsiaisto pnr hienrtee d
asa rtliVc laise sl i gahlttleayrn eeddx panvdeerdso ifto hnte e xt
thawti lalp peiantr h e voolfcu omnef erpeanpceterob s e
publibsyRh eeiddi enDl o rdreHcohltl,aI ntids i .n clhuedreed
becaiutscseo ntpernotv iadnie msp orptaarontfto neo ft he
centtrhaelmo efts h beo oFk..i niantl hlweyi .n toef1r 9 71I- 72,
\Vas reqpureesptaaerrdte i otcnol etbshr eo abduertre lated
theomfeN ominafloiThrse mol ogicala nfSdto u.rd Aitnehnse
Arbcoorn feroenln actmeee dieavnadRl e naisrsealnicgei on,
organbiyCz headr Tlreisn kaus.
Nowm.o rteh aand ecaldaet er,e sstaahryejseso ei niendt o
l
onsee quesnpcaen ntihenelg e venth tcoe nstiuxrati1eenes n.t h
indebttote hdoe r igpiunballi asnhdte orVs a riofroutrmh e
opporttuon ihtayv ea sstehenhm1e brlaeeso d n ec ollection.
Despoictcea sioovnearlal nadpr epetoifti inofno rmation
originneaeldlteyodm akeea cphi eicned ependsenetl f­and
suffitchiceeo nmtb.i enfefdre ecvte aa plisc tcuornes iderably
diffefrreontmtr aditaicocnoauTlnh tese .s says tchlea rify
backgraonu1dnn de aonfci onngc celpotssae slsyo cwiiatlthae tde
medienvoamli nacloinscme•.pw thssit ctihol dlaa ryse u bjteoc t
XI
miusnderstPaenrdhimanopgrsi.e m porttahnertyel vyte,ha el
"anti,qt uhiet beyaa"crklgyro oftu hneidsd eet ahsbe,r o raadn ge
ofw ritwehrocs o ntritbotu htedeiedrv elo(ppmaerntti cularly
Dominiicnta hsnees c oqnuda rttehtreh iorft ceeennttauhnr dy ),
thseo cainaedlc onoimnifcl oufeo nnocefet he fmaosscti natjng
conceipntnuoavla ttihhoein gashn ldoa fMt ied dleF oAarg es.
peritohdam ta nhyi stohraivaen sd eisnc rtioebfcre lmdos s ing
fronthiaerrdse,cn lianlsgis n aensd,s hriniknitnegl lectual
horiztohwneis d,e -sapdroepatodfic oonn vencaanutsaialnl ity
thfeo urtaenefdni tfht ceeennttpuhor iitneotts hs ae b iolfmi etny
oft haagtte o sleicviuenar w eo rolpde nd itvopi onweea wr o,r ld
off uteuxrpee ctbaatsoienodc n o ncoefpc trsea dniadts signed
value.
WILLIJAC.MO URTENAY
Madnis,Wo isconsin
Marc1h9,8 4