Table Of Content

CONSTITUTIONAL LITIGATION SEMINAR CASES AND MATERIALS VOLUME II PROFESSOR L. WEINRIB MS. MARY EBERTS SEPTEMBER-DECEMBER, 1991 FACULTY OF LAW UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO PREPARED WITH THE ASSISTANCE OF JULIE LAMB BORA MSKIR LAW LIBRARY AUG 2 2 1991 FACULTY OF LAW UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO BORA LASKIN LAW LIBRARY L UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO CONSTITUTIONAL LITIGATION SEMINAR CASES AND MATERIALS VOLUME II PROFESSOR L. WEINRIB MS. MARY EBERTS SEPTEMBER-DECEMBER, 1991 FACULTY OF LAW UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO PREPARED WITH THE ASSISTANCE OF JULIE LAMB © Printed on Recycled Paper Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2019 with funding from University of Toronto c https://archive.org/details/constitutionalli02wein_12 TABLE OF CONTENTS: VOLUME II 3. Charter Argument a) The "Rights" Argument Case Study of Borowski v. Attorney General for Canada in Supreme Court of Canada: Factum of Joseph Borowski, Appellant. 1 Factum of Attorney General of Canada, Respondent. 29 Factum of the Women's Legal Education and Action Fund, (LEAF) , Intervenor. 56 Factum of Real Women of Canada, Intervenor. 69 Factum of the Interfaith Coalition on the Rights and Well-being of Women and Children, Intervenor. 84 b) The "Limits" Argument Case Study of R. v. Keegstra in the Supreme Court of Canada: Factum of The Queen in right of Alberta, Appellant.... 91 Factum of James Keegstra, Respondent. . 135 Factum of the Attorney General of Canada, Intervenor. 155 Factum of Attorney General of Quebec, Intervenor. 179 Factum of Women's Legal Education and Action Fund, (LEAF), Intervenor. 194 Factum of B'nai Brith Canada, Intervenor. 204 Factum of the Canadian Jewish Congress, Intervenor. 212 Factum of the Intervenor, Interamicus. 224 Factum of the Canadian Civil Liberties Association. 235 Fact submissions in McKinney v. University of Guelph: Affidavit of W. Craig Riddell. 244 Fact submission in Kuhn v. York University, (S.C.C.): Affidavit of Tillo E. Kuhn. 249 4. Facts in Charter Argument a) A Case Study: R. v. Askov Affidavit of Carl Baar in the Supreme Court of Canada. . . . 257 Exhibit E to the Affidavit of Carl Baar (incomplete). 266 Supplementary Factum of the Appellants Askov and Hussey. 297 R. v. Askov (1990), 74 D.L.R. (4th) 355 (S.C.C.). 308 Newspaper clippings . 333 b) The literature McKay v. Government of Manitoba (1989). 61 D.L.R. 538 (4th) 385 (S.C.C. )... Eberts, "New Facts for Old: Observations on the 343 Judicial Process".. Pine, "Speculation and Reality: The Role of Facts 361 in Judicial Protection of Fundamental Rights".. . . Spitz, "Litigation Strategy in Equality Rights: 398 The American Experience". Remedies a) Imposing Fiscal Obligations on Government Eisenberg & Yeazell, "The Ordinary and the Extraordinary in Institutional Litigation" , (extract). 405 A.G. Nova Scotia v. Phillips (1986), 34 D.L.R. (4th) 633 (N.S.S. Ct. , App. Div. ).. .. 408 Mahe et al. v. The Queen in right of Alberta et al.f (1990), 68 D.L.R. (4th) 69.... 411 Schacter v. The Queen (1990), 66 D.L.R. (4th) 635 (Fed. C. A.) . 415 Case Study of Schacter v. The Queen in the Supreme Court of Canada: Factum of The Queen and Canada Employment and Immigration Commission, Appellant... b) Prospective Ruling R. v. Brvdges (1990), 53 C.C.C. 330 (S.C.C.). c) Narrowing or Broadening Criminal Liability R.v. Lucas (1985), 16 C.R.R. 1 (Ont. Dist. Ct. ). 457 R. v. Hess r 1990 1 2 S.C.R. 461 d) Structural Remedies Ref re Language Rights Under the Manitoba Act, 1870 (1985) 19 D.L.R.(4th)l (S.C.C. ). 467 Marchand v. Simcoe County Board of Education et al. (1986) 29 D.L.R. 598 . 477 Swain v. R.. unreported judgment of S.C.C., May 2, 1991... 489 e) Damages K. Cooper-Stephenson, Charter Damage Claims, (Toronto: Carswell, 1990), p. 9-21. f) Ini unctions A.G. Manitoba v. Metropolitan Stores (1987) 38 D.L.R. (4th) 321.