Conservation Management of Freshwater Habitats CONSERVATION BIOLOGY SERIES Series Editors Dr F.B. Goldsmith Ecology and Conservation Unit, Department of Biology, University College London, Gower Street, London WC1E 6BT, UK Tel: +44(0) 171-387-7050x2671 Fax: +44(0)1713807096. email:[email protected] Dr E. Duffey OBE Chez Gouillard, 87329 Bussiere Poitevine, France The aim of this Series is to provide major summaries of important topics in conservation. The books have the following features: • original material • readable and attractive format • authoritative, comprehensive, thorough and well-referenced • based on ecological science • designed for specialists, students and naturalists In the last twenty years conservation has been recognized as one of the most important of all human goals and activities. Since the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development in Rio in June 1992, biodiversity has been recognized as a major topic within nature conservation, and each participating country is to prepare its biodiversity strategy. Those scientists preparing these strategies recognise monitoring as an essential part of any such strategy. Chapman & Hall have been prominent in publishing key works on monitoring and biodiversity, and with this new Series aim to cover subjects such as conservation management, conservation issues, evaluation of wildlife and biodiversity. The series contains texts that are scientific and authoritative and present the reader with precise, reliable and succinct information. Each volume is scientifically based, fully referenced and attractively illustrated. They are readable and appealing to both advanced students and active members of conservation organizations. Further books for the Series are currently being commissioned and those wishing to contribute, or who wish to know more about the Series, are invited to contact one of the Editors. Already Published 1. Monitoring Butterflies for Ecology and Conservation E. Pollard and TJ. Yates (eds) (Hb 1993 o/p, Pb 1995) xiv+274pp. ISBN 0-412-63460-0 2. Insect Conservation Biology MJ. Samways (Hb 1994 o/p, Pb 1994) xv+358pp. ISBN 0-412-63450-3 3. Monitoring for Conservation and Ecology F.B. Goldsmith (ed.) (HblPb 1991, Pb reprinted four times) 275pp. ISBN 0-412-35600-7 4. Evaluation and Assessment for Conservation: Ecological Guidelines for Determining Priorities for Nature Conservation I.F. Spellerberg (Hb 1992 o/p, Pb 1994 reprinted three times) xvi+260pp. ISBN 0-412-44280-9 5. Marine Protected Areas: Principles and Techniques for Management S. Gubbay (ed.) (Hb 1995) xii+232pp. ISBN 0-412-59450-1 6. Conservation of Faunal Diversity in Forested Landscapes R.M. DeGraaf and R.I. Miller (eds) (Hb 1995) xxi+633pp, with colour plate section and colour foldout. ISBN 0-412-61890-7 7. Ecology and Conservation of Amphibians TJ. Beebee (Hb 1996) viii+214pp. ISBN 0-412-62410-9 8. Conservation and the Use of Wildlife Resources M. Bolton (Hb 1997) xviii + 278pp, with colour plate section. ISBN 0-412-71350-0 9. Conservation Management of Freshwater Habitats N.C.Morgan and P.S. Maitland (Hb 1997) ISBN 0-412-59412-0 10. Tropical Rain Forests: A Wider Perspective F.B. Goldsmith (ed.) (HblPb 1998) ISBN Hb 0-412-81510-9, Pb 0-412-81520-6 11. Grazing in Conservation Management M.F. WallisDeVries, J.P. Bakker and S.E. van Wieren (Hb 1998) ISBN 0-412-47520-0 12. Wildlife Conservation by Sustainable Use H.H.T. Prins, J. Geu Grootenhuis and T.T. Dolan (Hb 2000) ISBN 0-412-79730-5 13. Coastal Conservation and Management: An Ecological Perspective J. Pat Doody (Hb 2000), ISBN 0-412-59470-6 Conservation Management of Freshwater Habitats Lakes, rivers and wetlands P. S. Maitland Fish Conservation Centre, G!adshot, Haddington, Scotland and N. C. Morgan 7 Route de !'Envers, 88290 Thiefosse, France SPRINGER SCIENCE+BUSINESS MEDIA, LLC British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data available ISBN 978-94-010-6475-0 ISBN 978-94-011-5858-9 (eBook) DOI 10.1007/978-94-011-5858-9 Catalog Card Number: 96-72121 Copyright «:> 1997 Springer Science+Business Media New York Originally published by Kluwer Academic Publishers in 1997 Softcover reprint of the hardcover 1s t edition 1997 This printing is a digital duplication of the original edition. Ali rights reserved. No part of this publicat ion may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, mechanical, photo-copying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior written permis sion of the publisher, Springer Science+Business Media, LLC. Printed an acid-free paper. Contents Foreword IX 1 Introduction 1 1.1 Freshwater habitats 1 1.2 Wetlands 3 1.3 Open waters 12 2 The value of fresh waters 25 2.1 Demands for fresh water 25 2.2 Manipulating fresh water 26 2.3 Using fresh water 29 2.4 The products of fresh waters 37 2.5 Other aspects 42 3 Human impacts 45 3.1 Threats to fresh waters 45 4 Evaluation of conservation interest 67 4.1 Introduction 67 4.2 Site selection 68 5 Protection and management 87 5.1 Establishment of reserves 87 5.2 Management plans 89 5.3 Monitoring 93 6 Wetland management 95 6.1 Introduction 95 6.2 Management techniques 96 6.3 Examples of management 108 7 Lake management 123 7.1 Introduction 123 7.2 Lake classification 127 7.3 Management techniques 130 7.4 Artificial waters 141 Contents Vlll 7.5 Catchment management 142 7.6 Examples of management 143 8 River management 151 8.1 Introduction 151 8.2 Scientific basis for river management 154 8.3 River classification 155 8.4 Management objectives 157 8.5 Recreation 162 8.6 River restoration 163 8.7 Catchment management 164 8.8 Examples of management 165 8.9 Conclusions 167 9 Species conservation 171 9.1 Conservation options 171 9.2 Fish conservation 172 9.3 Bird conservation 181 9.4 Invertebrate conservation 187 9.5 Amphibian conservation 189 9.6 Mammal conservation 190 10 Future prospects 191 10.1 Introduction 191 10.2 People and education 192 10.3 Sustainable resource use 193 10.4 Catchment management 194 10.5 Integrated water use 194 10.6 Climate change 196 10.7 Legislation 198 10.8 Information 198 10.9 Conclusions 199 Appendix A: Glossary 203 References 207 Index 225 Foreword There was a need for a book about the conservation management of fresh waters. It can be argued that there already is a vast literature on the con servation and management of virtually every kind of habitat in almost every part of the world. Moreover, thanks to the computerization of infor mation, this literature, or at least most of it, can be accessed easily and quickly. However, digging out what is wanted from this mountain of information is not so quick and easy. Further, what is accessed also has to be assessed. When two authors and old colleagues combine to write such a book, we receive a more unified text than is found in the great majority of multi authored works. Here, we have two authors with long experience of con servation and its management in Britain and elsewhere. In a relatively short handbook they have covered conservation management in such a way that it will be of value to the wide variety of people who and organizations which may play an essential part in one or more aspects of conservation and its management. Conservation is not simply preservation, like an exhibit in a bottle. It is an active process, which has to continue for an indefinite time. Hence the need for what might be called installation care and after care. The manage ment of both forms a major part of this book. Conservation management can be an unnatural activity when it holds the natural evolution of a habitat at a certain stage of its development. A common example is the prevention of a habitat from reaching the stage of woodland. Protecting shallow waters, swamps and bogs from further devel opment may be unnatural from the aspect of ecological evolution but what is conserved is a natural habitat with its own specific flora and fauna, part of which is not uncommonly in danger of extinction on a local or even world scale. Many of the diverse aquatic or semi-aquatic habitats, the man agement of which is described in this book, are indeed endangered habitats: moreover, time is not on our side. The authors give examples of the conservation management of a wide variety of aquatic or semi-aquatic habitats, ranging from the greatest and oldest lakes in the world to ponds, from great swamps to local marshy areas and outline the skills needed to conserve and manage them. Every case seems to have its own management problems, be it a major political one or a matter of local pressures or prejudices. It is not always a matter of x Foreword management of a given area; where migrating birds are concerned it may be the management of two or more separate, even widely separate, areas. This welcome book gives us both the scientific bases for conservation management and much about the art of management of little damaged or even unspoiled, seriously damaged or threatened fresh waters, nor are pos sibilities of reconstruction of habitats ignored. Along the way, we have interesting examples of conservation management in action - and several horror stories. John W.G. Lund - 1 - - - - - - - Introduction 1.1 FRESHWATER HABITATS Freshwater ecosystems represent a major group of habitats around the world. Not only are the habitats themselves important, for a wide variety of reasons, but the medium itself - fresh water - is of fundamental significance to human welfare everywhere. Fresh water is essential to humans for drinking water, transport, irrigation, energy and as a vehicle to eliminate waste material; the biota provide important food resources and utilizable materials. All freshwater bodies are dynamic systems: not only are their organisms affected by the physicochemical conditions (and thus by human activities), but also the plants and animals interact and may influence both the habitat and one another. They have a major influence on the physical and chemical conditions, while inter- and intraspecific relationships among plants and animals may be of critical importance to both water quality and the structure of communities (Maitland, 1990). Although the fresh waters of the world seem unimportant compared on an area basis to most land and sea surfaces (only 0.1% of the world's water surface is occupied by fresh water), yet freshwater fishes form 25% of all known vertebrate species. Some of the largest rivers (e.g. the River Amazon, Figure 1.1) and lakes (e.g. Lakes Superior and Tanganyika, Figures 1.2, 1.3) are of impressive dimensions and are of major importance in the general ecology and cycling relationships of the regions in which they occur. The Amazon discharges annually about one-fifth of the fresh water from rivers entering all the oceans, and is 6500 km in length (Goulding, 1989). Lake Tanganyika has a volume of 18.88 km3 and is 650 km in length (Coulter, 1991). Such immense water bodies are also of great economic importance to the surrounding regions, both in terms of communication and resources. On the other hand, because of the relatively small size of many wetland habitats, they are very vulnerable to human activities. They cannot be protected completely without control of the whole catchment area. For-