Conducting Research Literature Reviews: From the Internet to Paper

281 Pages·2014·13.441 MB·English

by  Arlene Fink

CONDUCTING RESERACH
LITERATURE REVIEWS
FourtEhd ition
Thibso oki sd edicattoet dh eo neIs loJvoeh:n C .B ecka ndI ngva rd.
CONDUCTING RESERACH
LITERATURE REVIEWS
Fromt heI ntertnoeP ta per
Fourth Edition
ArlenFei nk
UniverosfCi atyl iforantLi oas A ngeles
TheL anglReeys earIcnhs titute
ISAGE
LosA ngelIeL so ndoIn NeDwe lhi
SingapoIWr aes hingtDoCn
�SAGE
LoAsn gelILe osn dIoN ne wD elhi
SingapIWo arseh ingDtCo n
FORI NFORMATION: Copyri©g h2t014b yS AGE PublicatIinocn.s ,
SAGEP ublicaItnico.n s,
Allr ighrtess ervNeodp .a rtt hoifbs o okm ayb er eproduced
245T5e lRloeard
oru tiliiznae ndy fo rmo rb yan y meanse,l ectroorn ic
ThousanOda ksC,a lifo9r1n3i2a0 mechaniicnacll,u dpihnogt ocopyriencgo,r doirnb gya, n y
E-maoirld:e [email protected] information asntdro ertargiese yvsatle wmi,th oupte rmission
inw ritifrnogm t hpeu blisher.
SAGEP ublicaLttido.n s
1O livYearr'ds Printientd h eU niteSdt atoefsA merica
55C itRyo ad
Libraoryf C ongreCsast aloging-in-PDuabtlai cation
LondoEnC 1Y1 SP
UnitKeidn gdom
FinkA,r lene.
SAGEP ublicaItnidoPinvast L .t d.
Conductriensge alricthe rarteuvriee :wfr so m the
B 1/M1o1h aCno operaItnidvues tArreiaa l
internteotp apeIrA rlene FUinnikv,e rsoift y
MathuRroaa dN,e wD el1h1i00 44
CalifornaitaL osA ngeleTsh,eL angley ResIenasrtciht ute.
India
- Fouretdhi tion.
SAGEP ublicaAtsiioan-sP aPctieLf.ti dc.
pagecsm
3C hurScthr eet
Inclubdiebsl iograrpehfeirceanlca ensdi ndex.
#10-S0a4m sunHgu b
Singap0o4r9e4 83
ISBN9 78-1-4522-5(9p4b9k:-a. 9l kp.a per)
ISBN9 78-1-4833-0(1w0e3bp- d7f)
1.R esearch-Method2o.lR oegsye.a rch-Evaluation.
3.B ibliography-MethoId.To iltolgey..
Q180.55.M42F05164
001.42-dc23 2013009315
Thibso oki sp rintoenda cid-free paper.
AcquisiEtdiiotnoVsri :c Kknii ght
AssisEtdaintto Kra:l Kioes cielak
EditoArsisails taJnetss:i Mcial ler
ProducEtdiiotno Srt:e phaPnailee rmini
CopyE ditoLra:u rPiiet man
TypesetCt&eMrD :i gi(taPLl)ts d .
ProofreaBdaerrb:aJ roah nson
IndexeJre:a Cna salegno
CoveDre signAenru:p amKar ishnan
MarketMiannga geNri:c oEllel iott
PermissEidointsoK ra:r eEnh rmann 131 4 1156 1 71 09 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Preface xiii
Aboutth eA uthor xvn
1.ReviewitnhgeL iteratWhuyr?eF :o rW hom?H ow? 1
2.SearchainndgS creeniTnhgeP: r actiSccarle en
andM ethodologQiucaalli( tPya 1r-tR esearDcehs ign
andS ampling) 47
3.SearchainndgS creeniMnegt:h odologQiucaalli ty
(Pa2r-tD ataC ollectIinotne,r venAtniaolnyss,Ri ess,u latnsd,
Conclusions) 99
4.Dointgh eR evieAw R:e aderG'usi dCeh apter 147
5.WhatD idY ouF indS?y nthesiRzeisnugl ts 187
AuthoIrn dex 243
SubjeIcntd ex 249

Preface XIII
Aboutth eA uthor XVII
1.ReviewtihnegL iteraWthuyr?eF :o rW hom?H ow? 1
A ReadeGru'isd e
PURPOOSFET HICSH APTER 2
WhatI sa ResearLciht eraRteuvriee Wwh?y Do One? 3
WritPer oposfoarlF su nding 5
WritPer oposfaolArsc ademiDce grees 6
Descriabned E xplaCiunr reKnnto wledtgoe
GuidPer ofessiPornaaclt ice 7
IdentEifffeyc tiRvees earacnhd D evelopmeMnett hods 8
IdentEixfpye rttsoH elpI nterpErxeits tLiintge rature
andI dentUinfpyu blisShoeudr coefsI nformation 9
IdentFiufnyd iSnogu rcaensd W orkisn P rogress 9
SatisPfeyr sonCaulr iosity 1 0
GainiCnogn trEoxlp:e rimeanntdOs b servations 12
13
An ExperimeSnttuadly
13
An ObservatiSotnuadly
SystemaEtxipcl,i Ccoimtp,r ehensainvdeR ,e producible:
FouKre yW ords 14
ChoosianngO nlinBei bliogrDaapthaibca se 15
OnlinBei bliogrDaapthaibca ses 15
WhatE xactDloy Y ouN eedt oF ind? 18
How Do YouS earcfohr WhatY ouW antt oF ind?
KeyW ordsD,e scriptIodresn,t ifainedr s,
theT hesaurus 20
How DoY ouA skf oIrn formatSieoanr?c hWiintgh
BooleOapne rators 24
ThreEex amploefsB ooleaLno gic 25
PausiDnugr intghe Search 25
Changitnheg C oursoeft heS earch 26
ChangitnhgeC oursoefa LiteraRteuvriee Swe arch:
ExpanditnhgeS cope 26
Supplementthei nOgn linSee arch 27
ReasotnosS upplemeEnlte ctrSoenaircc hes 27
ReviewiRnegf erenicnHe isg h-QuaSltiutdyi es 28
IsE verythWionrgt hwhPiulbel ished? 29
Brinignt heE xperts 30
CautiouAsplpyr oacthh eW eb 32
OrganiztihneRg e searLciht erature:
BuildiaVn igr tuFaill iCnagb inet 33
Summaroyf K eyP oints 36
Exercises 37
Answers 40
OnlinLei teraRteuvriee ws 42
SuggesRteeadd ings 45
Notes 45
2.SearchainndSg c reenTihnePg r:a ctSiccraelae nnd
MethodoloQguiaclai(ltP ya 1r-tR eseaDrecshi gn
andS ampling) 47
A ReaderG'usi de 47
PURPOOSFET HICSH APTER 48
SearcShc ree1n:T h eP arcticSaclr een 51
IncludainndgE xcludSitnugd iTeysp:i cParla ctical
ScreenCirnigt eforriL ai teraRteuvriee Swe arches 51
PractiSccarle enCirnigt eUrsiian:Ig n clusainodn
ExclusCiroint eria 52
SearcShc ree2n:M ethodologQiucaalliS tcyr eening
CritePraira1t,- ResearDcehs igann dS ampling 54
CriterfoiroQ nu aliRteys:e arDcehs ign 55
RandomS electainodnR andomA ssignment:
TwoE xamples 57
ParalCloenlt roblustN o
RandomA ssignment 61
Self-Controls 63
HistorCiocnatlr oolrEs x istDiantga 65
ObservatiDoensailg innsB rief 66
CohorDte signs 66
CaseC ontrDoels igns 70
A Noteo nO theDre sigannsd S tudies:
Cross-SecStuirovneaaylns d C onsensSutsa tements 73
Cross-Sectional Surveys 73
ConsensSutsa tements 76
77
Books
InterannadlE xterVnaalli dity 77
CriterfiooQrnu aliStaym:p ling 81
WhatI sa Sample? 81
InclusainodnE xclusCiroint eorriE al igiboifPl airttyi cipan8t2s
MethodosfS ampling 83
SimplRea ndomS ampling 84
SystemaStaimcp ling 84
StratiSfaimepdl ing 85
ClustSearm pling 85
ConvenieSnacmep ling 86
TheS ampliUnngi t 86
TheS izoef t heS ample 87
ResponRsaet e 87
NonresponSsueb:j ecatnsdI tems 88
Summaroyf K eyP oints 90
95
Exercises
Answers 97
SuggestReeda dings 98
3.SearchainndgS creeniMnegt:h odologQiucaalli ty
(Pa2r-tD ataC ollectIinotne,r ventAinoanlsy,sR iess,u lts,
andC onclusions) 99
A ReaderG'usi de 99
PURPOOSFET HICSH APTER 100
DataC ollectainodDn a tSao urceMse:t hodasn dM easures 100
10 4
Reliability
Validity 10 6
IntervenatnidoP nrso graRmesv:i ewitnhgeR esearch
LiterattouF rienO du tW hatW orks 109
TwoV ersioofna s P rograDme scription 110
DatAan alysSitsa:t isMteitchaoldi snt heR esearch Liter1a1t2u re
StatisMteitchaold asn dW hatt oL ookF orA:n Overview 112