Coercion, Capital, and European States, AD 990-1990 - FriendFeed

277 Pages·2010·8.53 MB·English

CoerciCoanp,i taanld,
EuropeSatna tes,
990-1990
AD
CHARLES TILLY
BasBilla ckwell
:s- ��L/
.A�T540
111eto
C.Ol
CoprighCth a©r lTeisl l1y9 90
Harp
FirpHutb lis1h9e9d 0
BasBilla ckwIenlcl.,
3 CambridCgeen ter
CambridMgea,s sachu0se21t4t2sU, S A
BasBilla ckwLetldl
108Co wleRyo adO,x forOdX,4 I]F,U K
Alrli ghrtess erveEdx.c efpottr h eq uotatoifso hno rpta ssafgoetrsh ep urposeosf
criticainsdmre viewn,o p arto ft hipsu blicamtaiybo enr eproduscteodr,ie nda
retriseyvsatle omrt, r ansmiitnta endyf, o romr b ya nym eanse,l ectrmoencihca,n ical,
photocopyriencgo,r doirno gt herwiwsiet,h otuhtep riopre rmissoifto hnep ublisher.
Exceipntt h eU niteSdt atoefsA meriellt,h ibso !.o.i ss olsdu bjetcott h ceo ndittihoant
its hanlotl,b yw ayo ft radoero therwibseel ,e nrte, -sohlidro,eu dto ,ro therwise
cicrultaed witohutth ep ublis'hsep rricoorn seinnat n yl oromf b indionrgc oveort her
thatnh aitnw hicihti spu blished andw ithoaus ti micloanrd itiinocnl udtihnigs
conditbeiionngi mposoendt hes ubsequpeurnchta ser.
Lih11rC.aO/,)l 'l Cplelsl$ill PllIloI pi/IllimlDl/JPiI llIlIi
TillCyh,a rles
Coercicoanp,i taanldE, u ropeSnlnat e.s�,) 9)9 0-I990/CThialrllye.s
p.c m.- (Studiines so cidaisclo ntinutyi)
"20M ay1 989."
Inclubdiebsl iograrpehfiecraeln ces.
ISNB 15-75116-067-X
I.E urop-eP olitaincdgs o vernme2nt.E.u r oep- Economic
conditinos.3 Capialtism -Europ-el listIoTry.i. d e.
IIS.er eis:S tudieisns ocidails cont.i (nBuaisBtyil la ckwell
Publishers)
JN94.A2T541 990
940- dC20 89-177C3I0P
BrilisllC llUlltmtlil(lI',ll"l' Mg i"mill/)il/,/g1m / /
AC IPc alalroecguored titlhri bso oiks a vailaIbrmlo eht e Brisht iLibrary.
Typesient1 0 on 1E2h rphaIr dl
byI l opSee rvic(eAsb ingdI.oldn.)
PrintienGd r eaBtr itabivn
T.J. P resLst dP,a sdtow,C ornwall
Tot hmee moryo fS teRionkk an
Itnelleecntthuuasilim apsrte,cs raeraiatono,fdr re ,in d
Contents
Praecfe ix
I Citieasn dS tatiensW orldH istory
SattiensH istory 1
AvabillAean swers
.i
Logicosf C apitaanldC oercion 16
WarD rivSaettsFe o nnatainoTdnr aonrsmfation 20
LonTgr esna dnIdtn eractions 28
Proescpts 33
2 EuropeaCni tieasn dS tates 38
AbseEnutr ope 38
SattaensCd o ercion 45
CitiaensCd ap ital 47
CitySt-aIttnee raction 51
SattPehy sigoeilso 54
LiaiDsaonnegsr euses 58
AtlenratiFvoer mso fSa tte 62
3 How WarM adeS tateasn,dV icVee rsa 67
A BiufrcaotifVo ino lence 67
HowS attCeosn otlrlCeodec iron 68
Wars 70
Transitions 76
SieziMnagki,n ogrB, u yiCnogec iron 84
PayitnhDgee bts 87
viiiC ontents
TheL onSgrt,o nAgr mo fE mpei r 91
" Stataens dt heirC itizens 96
FroWma sptsoL ocomotives 96
BargaiRniig,nha gtns,Cd o lilveAecc ttion 99
TheI nsitiotuontfD irRecutl e 130
TheF renRcehv toil:ouF nroImn idretcoDt ie rtcR ule 170
SattEex pnasiDoinr,Re uc,lta e nNda tionalism 141
UnienntdBeudr dens 171
MilitarizCavitiiloina nization 122
=
"'
S :Lineageosf t heN ationSatl ate 172
Chinaan dE urope 172
SattaensCd i tRieeesx amined 103
Coecirvee coTtrriaejs 137
CapaliitTsrt ajieecst or 134
TreacjotireosfC apitaCloiezrecdi on 151
6 TheE uropeanS tatSey stem 161
TheC onnecteodfEn uersospS eatatne s 161
TheE ndosf W ars 165
Membeorfths e S ystem 107
TheC reaotifoaS n at et-LinWkoerdl d 181
HowW arBse agn 138
,�-,iLS.alienLQg�s.ti_Qns 178
7 SoldiearnsdS tateisn 1990 129
PoliMtiiscdaleplovm eent 129
TheI mpaancdtH eriotfaWg oer Wladr I I 179
TheA scenotfM itlaiMrye n 203
TodaMyili'tsa irynH isitcoParelr sipveec t 250
MilaryiB tuildup 209
SoiledirnPs o wer 211
HowD ithde M ilitGaaryiP no w?e r 217
Envoi 224
Reefrneces 226
Index 261
Preafce
Craetivnee ousriIcs a,il ttl:h a ero tfd r iectoinnecg'o spm ulsainofdnae srt so
prodiuvoceut tcso.Tmh eibso oikls lturaittaespls pi cattiowo rni tiInnthg i.s
ca,sm eyc ompultsods iicoonov rei rn vseinmtsp ylmem eitncry o mpelveexn ts
combiwniethad n u rgteoe scaabp eud rensormees pboinlbsiyitty a koinn g
anothtearst kh awta sn oqtui taesd auntiAnngy. reoafthd iebsro owki ll
recnoizgthee s ignosfm yc ompulsoirodanen rsdt i om pTlhiesfy e.c ounr,dg e
howevtearka,el si tetxpllea iMnaniyntim g.e sb eforhea vfIeuo ndm yself
plungiinngtd oic ffiuwlotkr i no rdteoar v ooitdh weorr tkh awatps roving
paiunlof rd ifficuTlhtiti.sm eh,a visntga rtteocd o blolraawtietW hi m
Blcokmanisnt hrece ruitomfaec notl leocfpti aopsnoe nri natcetrioofcn ist ies
ansdt atEesu rpoeiI,nb eagn eatnr emaemlbyi tiboouocsko mpatrhien g
x
articuloafpt raiitocnu lara ncsdit taiitnees sser vaeplra tosfE uorpse ince
AD 1000.
Im eatnhtbe o otkor espaodnedtq eutlaoPy e rAryn dergsroenca'htsa lel:e ng
"Toyd,wa he'nh isftorombry e wl'ho abse coamw ea tchwoborthdM airxni st
anndo n-rMxiasctic rleasnd, phoradsu cmeadjg oarii nnos uu rn dsetranodfi ng
thep asitti, sn ervtelheensesc seasryt or ecoanloelf th eb asaixci oomfs
hiosrtimcaatle srmi:tha altsi ecusltraurg bgeletwee cnl asissue lst eilmya t
resoalttv hepedo /intoiatct a eltc-hoen oomrci utclu r-alle voefsl co ieItyn.
otehrw oriditsts ,h ceo sntrtuiaconndd se trucotifSoa tnt wehsi scehta hlbe a sic
shtisif nt hrele atioofpn rso ducstoli oonangs,c lasssuebss( iAsntsd"oe nr
1974:I I.)T heb ooIkh ,o pweodu,ml edr thgree oefm yc areecro-nlncosen:rg
the hiasntddoy ryn amoifcc osli lveaecc ttithonep, or ceosfus r batniioaznna,d
thfero matioofnn a tisotnaatle s.
Sucahb ooaksI, u ndsetroiotrd,e quaim raesdt oefery x ostoiucr acneds
launaggneostt,om entthieoc no mpilaltagireco ant saao lnfosd gt atisseitreisc al
thawto uolndfl layil n ptloa acnie t eamatti m.eI b eagnw rni,gtb iusto ofnuo nd
mysldefgi ginfgron wem atieairlno bscpulreaesca ,n dt itmneygsa bihloittyh to
x Preface
lenan relwa ngaunardge etsro iloednsv eC.eo rnUenvlielr gsaivmtyee t he
chatntryoc oeu sto motef h beo ookra'gnsi izdiaenisagtM s se sseLnegcetru res
fro1 897a;hl othut ghe sdsiiisonIchn tua pcrao hvoerwda gged those ideas
we,ri eatol c soncvemident hthaett opwiaicsm poratnwadon rttt,hlh eo ng
effroitwt o udledm and.
AsIw awso rnkgoi nt hati Fnbe obaorrakuyn M da r1c89h8I g, a avs ee roife s
lectauttr hIeens s dtEi'uttduePtso i lqiuitenPs a r(iaIsm g. rt aueltf oA lain
LancaenPldio etBr ibrrnea ufmoa rr riantnghgo aptp oiyrtta,un ntdCo lemens
Helflrote hre soutfph peo rMdtaeS iscs ioendn eIHc 'oemsmd eu rimnysg t ay
iPnr a.iM)sy p lwaants wo o irPnka riasricahin inbv eetwset ehlnee ctBuurte s.
ealirytn h see rIai geasli euncrd toe nE urocpietaainnsed ts a AtsIer se.fl ected
ont hlei vqeeulsytig ot nhipanrte asteihnoatpndor vodkI,se udydr eenallized
thIah ta adn otbhoeowrke u lnld ae:yarw m uch smcohreems nayhtteiitcc,,
con,ca infsdaee slibebo tohkta hnoe nI eh aadl rbeeaugdnWy.r i inttgahb to ok
wouallldom wea nh onbolrieatf,e mpoerxafiorrytm,t hfermo idabbilge
preocjItne.sa otdfg oingt hatero c shI,is vyteeahdo maemt y k eybaonadr d
begtapanp ianwgae yx cdyila ttte he newR evwoolvrurekmseeidoo. fmn ys
CorneIlsnlti tlcauetntudfi r tetisoen t dthp el, sa tonh atI r wehteutnrnNo ee dw
Yoraktteh e nodMf a rIch had dr taemfda jor octfhh bueon okks.
Negleochttienrog ej cpftrrosw hitchhRe u ssSgeaelF luo ntdiahoand
griaocussployn asy oeraerd' Isr uhlsetedmoa y cv oem,p auntcdeo nrnu tietdo
wri.t( eDurtihtnaigtmP uealin,e R ohtstaenihdne ar s siasRttu aslnSs taesgl e
priodviendpd einbslsineat,e lhleiwlgipetl nhit b sroauryr Ccmeailsl,Ye e zzi
maddeia lryo utienaesEsyr ,Wi acn naenrd dPeeJ taenoroeff srige nedi al
suppwohriRtlo,eb Meertrt aonnVd i vZiaenleain zceaorgu emryde ofrfttos
dewailbt ihsg t ruurlceratsgp,er ocaenshdsu ecgsoe,m i psa.orB)nyJ s u1l89y8a
comep,lu enitefvd ertna ,fwi acnsi rocnuI.lat an stidu cvcede rstaswsfie nthte
ronudusdn etreht lieSttsa tCoesre,ci on,a nda piCtl,aS ilvSewro,r d,S cepatnedr ,
antdhl eem sesl libflumutoo raucecsru aCtoeer ciCoalpli(l,tl aEIlud,r opSetaant es.
(Thbeok o'psr evseernistni pcoooanrrt aensad ad pmtast etarhptir aelv iously
appeian"r TheeGd e roagpohEfyu roSpatetaenm aankiCdnpa gi taSliinscme
1050",i nE uegne GeannoLdve eaosrneHd o cehgrb,( e,dG se)opghraic
PerspectiviesnH i st(oOxfryo': rB daBslila c1kw8e99l")lW,,a rmaakneCdri sti zens
itnh Ceon tempWoorra(lryCdS S"C [CfreoS ntudtieoerSfs o cialN eCwh ange,
ShcoforolS oacRlie asrecWho]r kPianp4ge1 1r,89 7,") HoWwa Mra dSet ates
anVdi Vceesr a("C SWSoCr nkigP ap4e2r1,8 9 7,") tSastC,eo ceiroann,d
Capi(tCaSlS"e WPopare7kr51i ,8n9 8,ga) n"dSa ttaenC do turenreuvtiooln
iFn rcae"nS, ociRale sea5r6(1c 8h9 97)-1,89 .)
Durithneegn sgum iohnnstm anfyer nidasnc do lleraegoaudrhe esa rd
varsieomguesno tftsh beo omkyc; o mlpsuitootn aa lbko uatnt dori etv ise
inscaenstkleyp tv ethbryeuy msJ. a enAtbu -uLhgoWdi,mB lkmoacnBsr,u ce
CraoetrhSsa,m uCaelrlBk r,i Daownn in,Cg armGeanlzTlaho o,rv Garladn ,
Marj'otHl aerPintee ,tKr a tnzsetAenidnrK,ei wrJ boyhL,nyn , nP erryM a,r s
Prefacex i
MaarteSni dPTnrarearykoW ,wa ,y nBer atakene Bd,i W no ngga mveea n
iniemsatgbiltfehtc e:ry i tiecraildzyrte aosdftf h weh omlaesn curtihgpohtuut lfly,
whiRilceh aBreden lRs,o bJeerirvtsJ ,oH uasdnbsa,n Dda dvL iaiatdidne d
shpac rommsoe nnp tairctuslcetanirslo o.w Aed eRloet mwaanrmth anfksro
suggestioonhn ostwgo emtyi edaasc r.No kiskAsid uebdait tehme adun script
wictho nmsmuactaear neid n telLloiugTieisnlwecla ebys.uy fis nishheirn g
owbno oakIsws o roknet dho insbe u,st hg ene eorustleoayrlt meydo bssseion
anodfe efrds traatdeevg.ii cc
Audiaettnh cUeeni sv eireossBfir e etgnC,ao lri-nfIirveaCin,hi coa,gn eGvea,
LeidaenWnde, s tOenarntr aittoh ,Ce iy Ut nivoeNfre sYwio tryCk ol,u mbia
UnvieyrH,sa irvtaUrnvdire siatntydh,E e s toniaonSf cA iceaandscekmeeysd
ponitqeeuds tiaobnopsua tort tfsh aean lsyT.sh iNee Swhc ooplr'mosis neoanr
stafrmotaeti oannc do lilvaeecc tthieolnmp eer de peyia fntrmo eudllathtien g
booakru'gmse sn.Ita md eepilnyd etboHt aerdr Whiistoaenn hdi cso ­
copniastroarCtso luUmnbirivsyaei 'Ctset nefrrot hSoec Sicaile (nnacobetlsy
LiAnsdae rsDoanvCi,ad n naMdairnGtieani,r u gDleosn,Jei c akosnG,e rald
MarweSllalv,aP tiotrurezelzK laoRt,oe b tesHr,ec tSocrh aKmiasmS,ah le hadi,
JaScynkd eCarli,Ur lel maRno,n VaaanRnn od s sfero mda)eh ltisfgeulm inar
thoegrya nitzose cdr udtirntaci fhzaep ftoremtr hsbi oso Nko.no efth ese
heulclpr fihtiascses ae c no mpdlreoattffteeh b oocku'rsr enatn dv enrosnieo n,
theroerbfeae rrsep sonistfiryobm iyml iasktes.
Misttaehkrseeus ra er.Sle rtye tcahciranmo gis lsl eIhn anuvineud mto,euy d bl
fialteodc onsmiadjeiordr e maiss,sc erdu ecevinsat,iln g oriemdp ortant
contragdoitcsttiieognnn sif,cafi tcwsar noatnn ged,x ipnlseaodm ceh aensg
inrceocrIht loyop.net l hyra etas wd ieilronlrmf m e aonefyrr oorrosm issions,
antdh thaetwy irlelflo enhc otw gmryme iaastktaleefysfc th teo vreaalrulgm ent
beofrree jeicottu oithfn a g.nI dmny o ptimmoiosIdtih sco, pt ehtha itbs o ok
wiclolinu ntet hweo rbke gbuythn el aStetei n Rtoahkitwkt ia blnul,io lnthd e
setrntghasnc do rthreee crotrro sfa w oroknw hiScethia nn Idc oblolrdaa,t e
ThFeO n/laotfiN oant ioSnatla tileW1se t semE uroep,t ahtiw ti elxle fYm tphlei
porgroahfmi sitcoarrolulnyid-negiqdriu yonl tgaers-cparloec oecfsh saeen sgI
havaed vodic nae taerbloioeskrus ca hsBi Sgt ructaurgrePe roscs,es eHLsu,ge
ComparisoannsA dsS ocig)%'M eeHtists orayn,td h iawtti cloln trtiotb huet e
efofrttow orokut teh roioefhs i stcoorininetccgnayel x eimfipbelydr ecent
wristio nAnfgt hoynG iddAelnlPsar,neA drh,tuS rit nchbceao,nHm da rrison
Whit.Ie sfo c,o mpualnpsdhi oowbnii olanl ac gea hianmv aed ace o nstructive
cotnruitibotknon oewdelgN.o wo,cf o uIrf csaeea, bp lreotmhb:ai btgo sotki ll
awamiet.s
CHARLETSI LLY
I
Citieasn dS tates
inW orIHdi tsory
STATES IHNI STORY
Som38e,0 y0e aarg,so rtuholeafe s rm laM lesoapmoictainty -csotnaeqtdue e r
althler eogino'htsec ri ttayst-a,esn mda dthee ms ubtjMoea crtd huioksw, n
citgydo'.Hs a mmurraueblroi fB, ba lyobne,ac meth seu prkeimneg of
MesopoBtyca oqmnuiiean,r.hg eg aeidtn hrei ghotb liainotgdnoea sttablish
lwasf roa lthlep eo.Ip nlt ehien dturcotitooh nif sma oulsa wHsa,m maubri
claiimnresudtc ftioromtn eh g regaotAd nsau n Edn :l il
thend id AnuE nalncidal lm let oa fofrdw ell-bteoi ntpghe eo ple,
me,H ammuarbit,h oeb deie,ng todfeaprriinncgte o,c ausreih gteousness
toa ppeianrt h el and
tod ersotyt hee vialn dt hwei cekdt,h atth set rohnagrm n otthe w eka
and that It hresi usne othlveieb krle a ceka-dhepde ople,
lihgtiungpt hel and.
(Frankl19o4r6t1:9 3)
Wrappienadd iivncea lHlaimnumgr,ac boiuc lofidnd leycn attlhlow sheo
oppohsiresud" l eeva in"ldw" ie cdVk.i"l ivfyiicntagimn snl,ia htiainlgla ineds ,
razriincvgiia etlhs ec, l athiamdteii dvnj seut sitcobeoe dhh iinHmda. m umrabi
wabsu iltdhpieon wgoe fhr ic si atnyfd,uo ndais ntgah tigesdo; sa ntdh eir
particuloajfsru t wivociuesl ido np revail.
Sattheasvb ee etnhw eol rdl'asr agnemdso tsp to wuelor rfganifzoar tions
moreth anfi vteoh usyaenadLr esut.sd efisntea atsce ose r�eilodni-nwgi
·
o!Kllniznatstih aoardtei sftinorcmht o useahnkodil ndgssorh uiappns xd eercise
clepariirotyi r ns omreee scspo tvero thaoelrrlg aniwziathstiuinbo sntsa ntial
teorririetTsh.te e trhm eorrieenf clcuidtye-ssse, tm aptitereheosc,ra ancdi es,
2 Cities ain"Wd o rSHldt, :a�tteso rJ'
manoyth efro rmso fg overnmbeunettx ,c lutdriebsel si,n eafigremssa,,n d
churcahsse usc Shu.c ahd efiniitsai,lo ancs o,n trovwehrimslaiena sylt ;u dents
ofp oliutsitech ste e rimnt hoirsg anizwaatysi,oo mneeaxt le nidtt o w hatever
strucotfpu orweee xirs itnasl arcgoen,t igpuoopuusl aatinoodnt ,h erress tirti ct
tor elatipvoewleyrc feunlt,r aalniddz iefdf,e resnotviearotereigdga nn iz-ations
rougtholw yh aItw ilcla lal n atiosntaalItw ei.l flu,r theremvoernetu,a lly
comprothmeid seefi nibtyii onnc lusduicnehgn titiase tso daMyo'nsa caon d
SanM arindoe, sptihteeli arco kf" substatnetirarli"ot ontr higeer so,ut nhda t
9_tuhnearm big!Jsotuastt reesta hte amsf ellow.- states
Forth em omenlteu,ts s tiwciktt hh oer gatinoinzdaaelfi nitBiyso unc.ah
standaarrcdh,a eolroegmiacifianrlsss ti gnthael e xistoefns cteas t aeso f
600BC0,a nwdri tteonrp ictroercioatrled sstt oit fyh epirre setwnocm ei llennia
latTehrr.o umgohs otft hlea esitg mhitl lesntnaihtaae,vs oe n loyc cupai ed
minoritoyfth ee arthi'nsh absiptaecBdeu .wt i thth ep assoafmg iel lethneniira
dominahnacgrseo wn.
Citieosr igiinnat theseda meer aS.o mtei mbee twe8e00n0a nd7 060B C,
the-settlemleanttce arl Jleerdi ccohnot aait neemdpa lnesd t ohnoeu sweist;h in
thnee xthto usayneda iratsc ,q uiatr heidwc akla ln d diffebrueinltdBiiyan tgesd.
thatti moen,ec ourleda soncaaJblellry i acc hiotya ,n do thMeird dElaes tern
settlewmeernbete sgi nntiona gc qutihrseei gonfsu rbanizaaswt eiloIlnn.
Anatoc;laitaaHl,ii yiikr'esm aiinncsl ruidcheho uses, asnhwdro irnokefsas r,t
datintgow elble fo6r0e0B C0.F ull-flceidtgaienedrds e cogniszatabtletesh ,e n,
appeaarter do ugthhlseya mpeo iinntw orlhdi stao mryo,m enotfgr eat
expansiino hnu macna pacfioctrry e atiavintydf rod estructiFoonr.a few
milleninnidaet,eh dse,t atienqs u estwieornee s senticailtlyy- sotfatteens ,
consiosfta pi rinegs t-crauplisetudar lr oubnyad t erdi buteh-ipnatyeirnlga nd.
By2 500B C,h owevseorm,Me e sopotacmiitaiinne csl,u Udria nngdL agash,
werbeu ildi�n!Dgp irurleesbd yw arrainohdre sl tdo gebtyhfe orrca en tdr ibute;
Hammuraubniifi'csa tioofsn o uthMeersno potcaammsieea v ceenn tuarftieers
thefi rset mpifroermse tdh eFrreo.thm a poti notn t,h ceo existoefsn ucbes tantial
staatnendsum erocuisti haessm arktheedgr eactiviliz ationfsr,o Mme sopotamia,
Egypt,a ndC hintaoE urope.
Ovetrh eei gohrtt emni llesninnitcahe ce o upfilrseta ppeacrietdai,ne ds
stahtaevsoe s cilbleatwteeeldno vaen dh atAer.m ecdo nquehraovroesft en
razceidti aenssd l aughttheeirinerhd a biotnaltnyort asi,ns eewc apiitnta hlesi r
placCei.typ eophlaeevb olsttehreeiidnrd epenadnedrn acieal geadi rnosyta l
interfine urrebnaacffnea ,io rnsltyos eetkh ekiirn pgr'ost eacgtiaoinbn asntd its,
piraatnedrs i,v graolu posfm erchaOnvtestr.h l eo nrgu na nda ta d istance,
citiaensds tahtaevspe r oviendd ispetnoes aacbohlt eh er.
Throumgohs otf h istonryaw,nt aslt at-esst atgeosv erning multiple
contigrueoguiason ntdsh eciirt biyme esa nosfc entralized, adnidf ferentiated,
autonosmtruocutsu -rheasv e apopnelrayar reeMdlo yss.tt ahtaevsbe e emnm­
natioenmapli:rc eisty,- stoarst oemse,t heilnsTgeh .e t ernma tionsatla te,