Climate change vulnerability of agroforestry

31 Pages·2012·3.45 MB·English

by  Betty Rabar

Climate  change  vulnerability  of  agroforestry
Henry  Neufeldt,  Ian  K.  Dawson,  Eike  Luedeling,  Oluyede  C.  Ajayi,  Tracy  Beedy,  
Aster  Gebrekirstos,  Ramni  H.  Jamnadass,  Konstantin  König,  Gudeta  W.  Sileshi,
Elisabeth  Simelton,  Carmen  Sotelo  Montes,  John  C.  Weber
!
!
"#$%&'(!)*&+,(!-.#+(/&0$#$'1!23!&,/232/(4'/1!
!
!
!"#$%&'"()"*+,-&./#&01&2/345#-&678"&9("+"*7#:-&;*(%"+"&<1&=>/%7-&?$/@%&A""+%-&=4,"$&
B"C$"87$4,54-&D/E#7&!1&F/E#/+/44-&05#4,/#,7#&0G#7:-&B(+",/&H1&I7*"4J7-&6*74/C",J&I7E"*,5#-&
</$E"#&I5,"*5&K5#,"4-&F5J#&<1&H"C"$&&
!!
&
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
9.K.?62&<.D<L9=?.;'&&

&
&
&
<5$$"@,&@7,/,75#M&'"()"*+,&!-&2/345#&.0-&9("+"*7#:&6-&=>/%7&;<-&A""+%&?-&B"C$"87$4,54&=-&F/E#/+/44&D!-&
0G#7:&0-&I7*"4J7&BH-&I7E"*,5#&6-&K5#,"4&<I-&H"C"$&F<1&NOPN&<*7E/,"&@J/#:"&Q(*#"$/C7*7,%&5)&/:$5)5$"4,$%1&
.<D=R&H5$87#:&S/T"$&'5&PUV1&'/7$5C7M&H5$*+&=:$5)5$"4,$%&<"#,$"&J,,TMWW+X1+5715$:WPO1YZP[WHSPNOPV1S2R&
&
?7,*"4&7#&,J"&H5$87#:&S/T"$&I"$7"4&/7E&,5&+744"E7#/,"&7#,"$7E&$"4(*,4&5#&/:$5)5$"4,$%&$"4"/$@J&/#+&T$/@,7@"4&/#+&
4,7E(*/,"&)""+C/@8&)$5E&,J"&4@7"#,7)7@&@5EE(#7,%1&;,J"$&T(C*7@/,75#&4"$7"4&)$5E&,J"&H5$*+&=:$5)5$"4,$%&<"#,$"&
7#@*(+"&?"@J#7@/*&K/#(/*4-&;@@/475#/*&S/T"$4&/#+&,J"&?$""4&)5$&<J/#:"&4"$7"41&
&
&
S(C*74J"+&C%&,J"&H5$*+&=:$5)5$"4,$%&<"#,$"&&
L#7,"+&'/,75#4&=Q"#("&
S;&A5X&VO[ZZ-&BS;&OOPOO&
'/7$5C7-&0"#%/&
?"*M&\NYU]O^NO&ZNNUOOO-&Q7/&LI=&\P&[YO&_VV&[[UY&
R/XM&\NYU]O^NO&ZNNUOOP-&Q7/&LI=&\P&[YO&_VV&[[U[&
6E/7*M&35$*+/:$5)5$"4,$%`@:7/$15$:&
H"C47,"M&333135$*+/:$5)5$"4,$%15$:&
&
&
&
a&H5$*+&=:$5)5$"4,$%&<"#,$"&NOPN&H5$87#:&S/T"$&'51&PUV&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
?J"&Q7"34&"XT$"44"+&7#&,J74&T(C*7@/,75#&/$"&,J54"&5)&,J"&/(,J5$]4^&/#+&#5,&#"@"44/$7*%&,J54"&5)&,J"&H5$*+&
=:$5)5$"4,$%&<"#,$"1&&
&
=$,7@*"4&/TT"/$7#:&7#&,J74&T(C*7@/,75#&E/%&C"&b(5,"+&5$&$"T$5+(@"+&37,J5(,&@J/$:"-&T$5Q7+"+&,J"&45($@"&74&
/@8#53*"+:"+1&'5&(4"&5)&,J74&T(C*7@/,75#&E/%&C"&E/+"&)5$&$"4/*"&5$&5,J"$&@5EE"$@7/*&T($T54"41&
&
=**&7E/:"4&$"E/7#&,J"&45*"&T$5T"$,%&5)&,J"7$&45($@"&/#+&E/%&#5,&C"&(4"+&)5$&/#%&T($T54"&37,J5(,&3$7,,"#&
T"$E74475#&)$5E&,J"&45($@"1&
&
?J"&:"5:$/TJ7@&+"47:#/,75#&"ET*5%"+&/#+&,J"&T$"4"#,/,75#&5)&E/,"$7/*&7#&,J74&T(C*7@/,75#&+5&#5,&7ET*%&,J"&
"XT$"4475#&5)&/#&5T7#75#&3J/,45"Q"$&5#&,J"&T/$,&5)&,J"&H5$*+&=:$5)5$"4,$%&<"#,$"&@5#@"$#7#:&,J"&*":/*&4,/,(4&5)&
/#%&@5(#,$%-&,"$$7,5$%-&@7,%&5$&/$"/&5$&7,4&/(,J5$7,7"4-&5$&@5#@"$#7#:&,J"&+"*7E7,/,75#&5)&7,4&)$5#,7"$4&5$&C5(#+/$7"41&

& 77&
&
&
&
&
56789!:;!":<59<5=!
!
?J"&7ET5$,/#@"&5)&/:$5)5$"4,$%&)5$&)55+&/#+&#(,$7,75#&4"@($7,%1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111P!
?J"&Q/*("&5)&,$""&@5EE5+7,%&@$5T4&)5$&4E/**J5*+"$4M&"XT*5$7#:&"XT5$,&,$/+"&+/,/1111111111111111111111111111111V!
!/$Q"4,7#:&/#+&@(*,7Q/,7#:&,$""&)55+4&,5&4(TT5$,&#(,$7,75#11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111Y!
A75*5:7@/*&Q(*#"$/C7*7,%&,5&@*7E/,"&@J/#:"111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111Z!
<5#4,$/7#,4&,5&T$5>"@,7#:&@*7E/,"&@J/#:"&7ET/@,4&5#&/:$5)5$"4,$%&4%4,"E4111111111111111111111111111111111111111111Z!
H5$8&5#&4%4,"E&@5ET5#"#,411111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111Z!
6ET7$7@/*&/TT$5/@J"41111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111PO!
L#@5Q"$7#:&T/4,&$"4T5#4"4&5#&,$""4&,5&(#+"$4,/#+&,J"&7ET/@,4&5)&@*7E/,"&@J/#:"1111111111111111111111111111PV!
L47#:&7#)5$E/,75#&)$5E&:"#",7@&,$7/*4&/#+&4,(+7"4&7#&#/,($/*&T5T(*/,75#4&7#&@*7E/,"&@J/#:"&/+/T,/,75#&
T*/##7#:1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111PU!
I5@75"@5#5E7@&Q(*#"$/C7*7,%&5)&/:$5)5$"4,$%&,5&@*7E/,"&@J/#:"111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111PY!
27$"@,&"))"@,411111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111P[!
.#+7$"@,&"))"@,411111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111P_!
D")"$"#@"41111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111NP!
& 777&
&
!
!"#$%&'%())*+,"($"&-#!
=RIS& =:$5)5$"4,$%&R55+&I"@($7,%&S$5:$/E&
=R?2& =:$5)5$"4,$""&2/,/C/4"&
=.2I& =@b(7$"+&.EE(#"&2")7@7"#@%&I%#+$5E"&
6'I;& 6*&'7c5W9/&'7c/dI5(,J"$#&;4@7**/,75#&
R=;&& R55+&=:$7@(*,($"&;$:/#7e/,75#&5)&,J"&L#7,"+&'/,75#4&
B=K& B"#"$/*7e"+&=++7,7Q"&K5+"*&
B<K& B"#"$/*&<7$@(*/,75#&K5+"*&
!BIR& !5E"d:$53#&I@J55*&R""+7#:&
!.f& !(E/#&.EE(#5+")7@7"#@%&f7$(4&
.<D=R& H5$*+&=:$5)5$"4,$%&<"#,$"&
.S<<& .#,"$:5Q"$#E"#,/*&S/#"*&5#&<*7E/,"&<J/#:"&
'6S=2& '"3&S/$,#"$4J7T&)5$&=)$7@/g4&2"Q"*5TE"#,&
'B;& '5#d:5Q"$#E"#,/*&;$:/#7e/,75#&
'HRS& '5#d355+&R5$"4,&S$5+(@,4&
TTE& T/$,4&T"$&E7**75#&
SD;I6=& S*/#,&D"45($@"4&5)&I5(,J&6/4,&=47/&
SD;?=& S*/#,&D"45($@"4&5)&?$5T7@/*&=)$7@/&
DL6& D/7#&L4"&6))7@7"#@%&
ID6I& IT"@7/*&D"T5$,&5#&6E74475#4&I@"#/$754&
L'.<6R& L#7,"+&'/,75#4&<J7*+$"#h4&R(#+&
LI2& L#7,"+&I,/,"4&25**/$&
f6<6=& f":",/,75#&/#+&<*7E/,"&@J/#:"&7#&6/4,"$#&=)$7@/&
H!;& H5$*+&!"/*,J&;$:/#7e/,75#&
HL6& H/,"$&L4"&6))7@7"#@%&
& 7Q&
$.+%"/0&*$(-1+%&'%(2*&'&*+#$*3%'&*%'&&4%(-4%-5$*"$"&-%#+15*"$3%
S$5Q7+7#:&/&+",/7*"+&T7@,($"&5)&,J"&Q/*("4&5)&,$""4&)5$&*5@/*&T"5T*"&7#&,J"&,$5T7@4&74&/&+7))7@(*,&
(#+"$,/87#:1&'5,&5#*%&+5"4&,J74&$"T$"4"#,&,J"&+7))7@(*,%&7#&/@@5(#,7#:&)5$&Q/*("4&5(,47+"&)5$E/*&E/$8",4-&
C(,&7,&/*45&$")*"@,4&,J"&E(*,7T*7@7,%&5)&,J"&4T"@7"4&7#Q5*Q"+&/#+&,J"&E/#%&+7))"$"#,&3/%4&7#&3J7@J&,$""4&
/$"&(4"+1&.#&,J"4"&@7$@(E4,/#@"4-&5#"&/TT$5/@J&,J/,&@/#&C"&(4"+&,5&:/7#&7#47:J,&74&,5&)5@(4&5#&/&
#/$$53"$&$/#:"&5)&4T"@7"4&4(@J&/4&,$""&@5EE5+7,%&@$5T4&@5EE5#*%&:$53#&C%&4E/**J5*+"$4-&3J"$"&E5$"&
+/,/&5#&"@5#5E7@&Q/*("&/$"&/Q/7*/C*"1&=#5,J"$&E",J5+&,J/,&@/#&C"&"ET*5%"+&,5&T$5Q7+"&/#&5Q"$Q7"3&5)&
(4"4&74&,5&4"/$@J&/#+&4(EE/$7e"&7#)5$E/,75#&)$5E&5#*7#"&+/,/C/4"4-&4(@J&/4&,J"&S*/#,&D"45($@"4&5)&
?$5T7@/*&=)$7@/&]SD;?=-&3331T$5,/15$:W^-&,J"&S*/#,&D"45($@"4&5)&I5(,Jd6/4,&=47/&]SD;I6=-&
3331T$54"/#",15$:WT$54"/W^&/#+&,J"&<=A.&R5$"4,&<5ET"#+7(E&]3331@/C715$:W)@W^1&&
!"$"-&,J"&/TT*7@/,75#&5)&5#*7#"&+/,/C/4"4&)5$&T$5Q7+7#:&7#)5$E/,75#&74&+"E5#4,$/,"+&C%&@5#47+"$7#:&
/#5,J"$&$"45($@"-&.<D=Rh4&5T"#&/@@"44&=:$5)5$"4,$""&2/,/C/4"&]=R?2-&
333135$*+/:$5)5$"4,$%15$:W$"45($@"4W+/,/C/4"4W/:$5)5$"4,$""^1&?J74&T$5Q7+"4&+/,/&5#&[YO&,$""&
4T"@7"4&,J/,&/$"&5)&7#,"$"4,&)5$&C5,J&T*/#,7#:&/#+&37*+&J/$Q"4,7#:&C%&*5@/*&@5EE(#7,7"4&,J$5(:J5(,&,J"&
,$5T7@41&?J"&+/,/C/4"&7#@*(+"4&7#)5$E/,75#&5#&3J"$"&4T"@7"4&:$53-&J53&,J"%&@/#&C"&T$5T/:/,"+&/#+&
E/#/:"+-&+5E"4,7@/,75#&J74,5$%-&,J"7$&(4"4-&T"4,4&/#+&+74"/4"4&T$5C*"E4-&/#+&/&@5ET$"J"#47Q"&
C7C*75:$/TJ%&5)&7#)5$E/,75#&45($@"41&.#&/++7,75#-&45@75d"@5#5E7@&+/,/-&4(@J&/4&,J"&"X,"#,&5)&@(*,7Q/,75#&
C%&4E/**J5*+"$4&/#+&,J"&@54,4&/#+&$",($#4&5)&T$5+(@,75#-&/$"&7#@*(+"+&)5$&/&4(C4",&5)&4T"@7"41&?J"&
/(,J5$4&(#+"$,558&/&E",/d/#/*%474&5)&,J"&+/,/C/4"&,J/,&7#Q5*Q"+&4,$/,7)%7#:&,J"&7#)5$E/,75#&7,&
@5#,/7#"+&C%&)(#@,75#-&5$7:7#&5)&,J"&,$""&/#+&,J"&:"5:$/TJ7@&$":75#&5)&(4"&]?/C*"&P^1&
?J"&/#/*%474&3/4&C/4"+&5#&PO&7ET5$,/#,&,$""&)(#@,75#4&/#+&47X&:"5:$/TJ7@&$":75#41&<5ET7*/,75#&$"Q"/*"+&
,J/,&,J"&E54,&)$"b("#,&(4"&*74,"+&7#&,J"&=R?2&3/4&)5$&,7EC"$&T$5+(@,75#-&)5**53"+&C%&E"+7@7#"&/#+&,J"#&
)("*&]T$7E/$7*%&355+)("*^1&K/#%&4T"@7"4&3"$"&7#+7@/,"+&,5&J/Q"&E(*,7T*"&(4"4-&C/4"+&5#&,J"&#(EC"$&5)&
E"#,75#4&4(EE"+&/@$544&)(#@,75#4&7#&/#%&5#"&$":75#&]"1:1-&i&NZOO&)5$&=)$7@/^&@5ET/$"+&,5&,J"&,5,/*&
#(EC"$&5)&4T"@7"4&7#&,J"&+/,/C/4"1&D"4(*,4&7#+7@/,"+&,J/,&*5@/*&T"5T*"&7#&*/$:"&T/$,4&5)&,J"&,$5T7@4&$"*%&
5#&/&37+"&$/#:"&5)&C5,J&7#+7:"#5(4&/#+&"X5,7@&,$""&4T"@7"4-&5Q"$/**&7#&/TT$5X7E/,"*%&"b(/*&T$5T5$,75#4-&
,5&E"",&,J"7$&#""+4&)5$&Q/$75(4&T$5+(@,4&/#+&4"$Q7@"41&&
& P&
5&0#(!>?&5*(!+.%0(/!23!'/((!4@()$(4!%(+'$2+(A!$+!'*(!6,/232/(4'/((!B&'&0&4(!&4!@/2-$A$+,!-&/$2.4!
3.+)'$2+4>!$+!A$33(/(+'!/(,$2+4C!23!'*(!'/2@$)4&
&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
P&?J"&=R?2&@5#,/7#4&+/,/&5#&/&37+"&$/#:"&5)&T$5+(@,4&/#+&4"$Q7@"4&T$5Q7+"+&C%&,$""4j&/&$/#:"&5)&PO&5)&,J"&E54,&7ET5$,/#,&)(#@,75#4&74&:7Q"#&
J"$"1&2/,/&/$"&T$"4"#,"+&5#&,J"&#(EC"$&5)&4T"@7"4&:7Q"#&7#&,J"&+/,/C/4"&/4&(4"+&)5$&/&T/$,7@(*/$&T($T54"&C/4"+&5#&3J",J"$&,J"%&/$"&
7#+7:"#5(4&].^&5$&"X5,7@&]6^&7#&5$7:7#&,5&/&T/$,7@(*/$&:"5:$/TJ7@&$":75#1&?J"&+/,/C/4"&@5#,/7#4&E5$"&4T"@7"4&7#+7:"#5(4&,5&=)$7@/&,J/#&,5&5,J"$&
:"5:$/TJ7@&$":75#4-&3J7@J&74&/&)/@,5$&+","$E7#7#:&,J"&:$"/,"$&#(EC"$&5)&,5,/*&$")"$"#@"4&,5&,J"&=)$7@/#&@5#,7#"#,1&
N&?J"&=R?2&@5#,/7#4&+/,/&5#&(4"&/@$544&,J"&:*5C"j&E"#,75#4&5)&(4"4&)5$&/&$/#:"&5)&47X&7ET5$,/#,&$":75#4&/$"&:7Q"#&J"$"1&?J"&$":75#4&5)&=)$7@/-&
;@"/#7/&/#+&I5(,J&=E"$7@/&3"$"&+")7#"+&J"$"&/@@5$+7#:&,5&
"#13787T"+7/15$:W3787W974,k5)k45Q"$"7:#k4,/,"4k/#+k+"T"#+"#,k,"$$7,5$7"4kC%k@5#,7#"#,1&?J"&$":75#4&5)&I5(,J&<"#,$/*&=47/-&I5(,J&6/4,&=47/&
/#+&H"4,"$#&=47/&/#+&K7++*"&6/4,&3"$"&+")7#"+&/@@5$+7#:&,5&3331#/,75#45#*7#"15$:W5#"35$*+W/47/1J,E&
& N&
?J"&7ET5$,/#@"&5)&4E/**J5*+"$&@(*,7Q/,75#&5)&"X5,7@&4T"@7"4&74&@5#)7$E"+&C%&/#&/#/*%474&5)&PNO&,$""&
4T"@7"4&7ET5$,/#,&,5&4E/**J5*+"$4&]+/,/&/*45&@5ET7*"+&)$5E&"#,$7"4&7#&,J"&=R?2^1&.,&$"Q"/*"+&,J/,&"/@J&
4T"@7"4&J/+&5#&/Q"$/:"&C""#&T*/#,"+&7#&NP&@5(#,$7"4&5(,47+"&7,4&#/,7Q"&$/#:"1&K/#%&5)&,J"4"&
7#,$5+(@,75#4&/TT"/$-&J53"Q"$-&,5&J/Q"&C""#&4(Cd5T,7E/*&)$5E&/&T$5+(@,75#&T"$4T"@,7Q"-&37,J&,$/#4)"$4&
)$"b("#,*%&(#+5@(E"#,"+&/#+&J/TJ/e/$+1&I($Q"%4&5)&+74,$7C(,75#&/#+&(4"&@*"/$*%&+"E5#4,$/,"&,J"&T/4,&
/#+&)(,($"&7ET5$,/#@"&5)&@$544dC5$+"$&,$/#4)"$&5)&,$""&:"$ET*/4E&,5&C",,"$&E"",&4E/**J5*+"$4h&#""+4-&/&
T57#,&"ETJ/,7@/**%&E/+"&3J"#&,J"&@/4"&5)&,$""&@5EE5+7,%&@$5T4&74&@5#47+"$"+-&/4&+"4@$7C"+&C"*531&=,&
,J"&4/E"&,7E"-&,J"&+/#:"$4&5)&#"3&7#,$5+(@,75#4-&+("&,5&,J"&3""+%&/#+&T5,"#,7/**%&7#Q/47Q"&
@J/$/@,"$74,7@4&5)&E/#%&,$""4-&/$"&/*45&5CQ75(4j&,J"4"&J/Q"&#5,&/*3/%4&C""#&4())7@7"#,*%&@5#47+"$"+-&/#+&
T5,"#,7/*&T$5C*"E4&#""+&,5&C"&:(/$+"+&/:/7#4,&]4""&,J"E/,7@&4,(+%&5#&7#,"$#/,75#/*&"X@J/#:"j&/*45&
63"*&!"#$%1&Plll^1&
&
5*(!-&#.(!23!'/((!)2%%2A$'1!)/2@4!32/!4%&##*2#A(/4?!(D@#2/$+,!(D@2/'!'/&A(!A&'&!
R=;h4&I,/,74,7@4&27Q7475#&@5ET7*"4&7#)5$E/,75#&5#&,J"&7#,"$#/,75#/*&,$/+"&5)&/&#(EC"$&5)&@5EE5+7,%&
@$5T4j&+/,/&5#&:*5C/*&"XT5$,&Q/*("4&)5$&/&$/#:"&5)&PN&,$""&@5EE5+7,7"4&,J/,&/$"&:$53#&T$7E/$7*%&7#&,J"&
,$5T7@4&/$"&:7Q"#&7#&R7:1&P-&/E5(#,7#:&,5&E5$"&,J/#&LI2&[[&C7**75#&C/4"+&5#&)7:($"4&)5$&NOOl1&.#&,J/,&
%"/$-&,J"&)7Q"&E54,&7ET5$,/#,&@5EE5+7,7"4&*74,"+&7#&,J"&)7:($"&/$"&T/*E&57*&])$5E&57*&T/*EV-&&%$!'(#
)*'+!!+('(^-&@5))""&]T$7E/$7*%&)$5E&,-..!$#$/$0'1$^-&$(CC"$&]2!3!$#0/$('%'!+('(^-&@5@5/&])$5E&@/@/5-&
45!-0/-6$#1$1$-^&/#+&,"/&]T$7E/$7*%&)$5E&,$6!%%'$#('+!+('(^1&?J"&E54,&#5,/C*"&)"/,($"&5)&,J"&:$/TJ&74&
,J"&$74"&7#&T/*E&57*&"XT5$,&Q/*("&7#&,J"&*/4,&,35&+"@/+"4-&,5&5Q"$,/8"&:$""#&@5))""&"XT5$,41&?J"&/@,(/*&
Q/*("&5)&5,J"$&,$""&@5EE5+7,7"4&4J53#&7#&,J"&:$/TJ&37**&45E",7E"4&C"&@5#47+"$/C*%&J7:J"$&,J/#&
$"T5$,"+&J"$"&C"@/(4"&E(@J&5)&,J"&@$5T&74&45*+&7#&*5@/*&E/$8",4&$/,J"$&,J/#&"XT5$,"+1&S"$74J/C*"&)$(7,4&
4(@J&/4&E/#:5"4&/$"&/&:55+&@/4"&7#&T57#,&]K5J/#&F/7#&/#+&S$7%/+/$4J/#&NOOl^1&'"Q"$,J"*"44-&"XT5$,&
Q/*("4&T$5Q7+"&/#&7#+7@/,75#&5)&,J"&5Q"$/**&7ET5$,/#@"&5)&/&@$5T-&37,J&5#&/Q"$/:"&47:#7)7@/#,&>(ET4&7#&
@5EE5+7,%&T$7@"4&"Q7+"#,&7#&$"@"#,&%"/$41&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
3 S/*E4&m&4(@J&/4&57*&T/*E&/#+&,J"&5,J"$&T/*E4&$")"$$"+&,5&7#&,J74&T/T"$&m&/$"&C%&+")7#7,75#&#5,&n,$("h&,$""4-&C(,&/4&T"$"##7/*&4T"@7"4&+"$7Q"+&
)$5E&)5$"4,4&/$"&@*/44"+&/4&,$""4&)5$&,J"&T($T54"4&5)&,J"&@($$"#,&+74@(4475#1&
& V&
&
B&'&!E(/(!(D'/&)'(A!3/2%!'*(!5/&A(=565!A&'&0&4(!23!;6:=565!F3&24'&'G3&2G2/,HIG!B&'&!32/!%&+,2(4J!%&+,24'((+4!&+A!,.&-&!&/(!/(@2/'(A!
'2,('*(/G!K&#.(4!$+)#.A(!/(L(D@2/'4!F$G(GJ!$%@2/'!$+'2!2+(!+&'$2+!32##2E(A!01!(D@2/'!'2!&+2'*(/IG!=2%(!)2%%2A$'$(4J!4.)*!&4!)233((J!)2)2&!
&+A!)2)2+.'J!&/(!(D@2/'(A!$+!%2/(!'*&+!2+(!32/%M!32/!(&)*!)/2@J!2+#1!'*(!%24'!$%@2/'&+'!32/%!01!(D@2/'!-&#.(!$4!,$-(+!*(/(G!
;$,./(!>M&B*5C/*&"XT5$,&Q/*("4&5)&/&$/#:"&5)&,$""&@5EE5+7,%&@$5T4&)5$&,J"&%"/$4&PllO&,5&NOOl&]@5EC7#"+&)7:($"4&
)5$&/**&#/,75#4&T$5Q7+7#:&+/,/^1&&
&
.#&.#+5#"47/-&/$5(#+&UOo&5)&T/*E&57*&T$5+(@,75#&J/4&C""#&$"T5$,"+&,5&@5E"&)$5E&4E/**J5*+"$4&].S;<&
NOO[^-&3J7*"&/TT$5X7E/,"*%&VOo&5)&*/#+&T*/#,"+&,5&57*&T/*E&7#&K/*/%47/&74&$"T5$,"+&,5&C"&(#+"$&,J"&
E/#/:"E"#,&5)&4E/**&)/$E"$4&]A/47$5#&NOOZ^1&K/#%&4E/**J5*+"$4&/TT"/$&,5&J/Q"&C"#")7,"+&
4(C4,/#,7/**%&)$5E&57*&T/*E&T*/#,7#:-&/*,J5(:J&$"b(7$"+&7#,"$Q"#,75#4&7#@*(+"&T$5E5,7#:&,$/#4T/$"#@%&7#&
,J"&E/$8",&/#+&@*"/$"$&*/#+&$7:J,4&]D74,&NOPO^1&K5$"5Q"$-&:$"/,"$&,J/#&,35d,J7$+4&5)&@5))""&T$5+(@,75#&
35$*+37+"&74&5#&4E/**J5*+7#:4&]33317@515$:W^1&.#&6/4,&=)$7@/-&)5$&"X/ET*"-&7,&74&"4,7E/,"+&,J/,&
/TT$5X7E/,"*%&ZOO-OOO&4E/**J5*+"$4&:$53&@5))""&7#&6,J75T7/-&/#+&UOO-OOO&7#&0"#%/&]S*/@"&!"#$%1&NOPN^1&
K(@J&5)&,J"&@5))""&7#&"/4,"$#&=)$7@/&74&)5(#+&7#&,J"&J7:J*/#+4&/#+&T*/%4&/&47:#7)7@/#,&$5*"&/4&T"$"##7/*&
*/#+&@5Q"$&,J/,&J"*T4&,5&T$5,"@,&J7**47+"4&/:/7#4,&457*&"$5475#1&
H7,J&#/,($/*&$(CC"$-&,J"$"&J/4&C""#&/&,$"#+&,53/$+&7#@$"/4"+&4E/**J5*+"$&T$5+(@,75#-&T/$,*%&C"@/(4"&
"4,/,"4&J/Q"&437,@J"+&,5&*"44&*/C5($d7#,"#47Q"&@$5T4&4(@J&/4&57*&T/*E&]4""&.'R;&<;KK&/,&
3331(#@,/+17#)5W7#)5@5EE^1&I5E"&"4,7E/,"4&4(::"4,&,J/,&E5$"&,J/#&,J$""db(/$,"$4&5)&$(CC"$&
T$5+(@,75#&C",3""#&Pll_&/#+&NOOV&3/4&5#&J5*+7#:4&5)&*"44&,J/#&UO&J/&]E54,&5#&4E/**J5*+7#:4&5)&NdV&
J/^-&37,J&/#&/Q"$/:"&/##(/*&7#@$"/4"&7#&4E/**J5*+"$&T$5+(@,75#&5)&Vo&5Q"$&,J74&T"$75+-&@5ET/$"+&,5&Po&
)5$&T*/#,/,75#4-&/*,J5(:J&*/$:"&4,/,"dE/#/:"+&T*/#,/,75#4&4,7**&T$"+5E7#/,"&7#&45E"&)5$E"$&@"#,$/**%&
T*/##"+&"@5#5E7"41&?J"&(4"&5)&J7:J"$&%7"*+7#:&$(CC"$&@*5#"4&$/,J"$&,J/#&,J"&@5**"@,75#&5)&4""+*7#:4-&/#+&
& U&
C",,"$&E/#/:"E"#,&T$/@,7@"4&,J/,&$"+(@"&7#T(,&@54,4&/#+&$",/7#&45E"&C75+7Q"$47,%&7#&$(CC"$&
/:$5)5$"4,4-&J/Q"&C""#&4(@@"44)(**%&T$5E5,"+&37,J&4E/**J5*+"$4&/#+&J/Q"&C""#&4J53#&,5&C"&E5$"&
T$5)7,/C*"&,J/#&/*,"$#/,7Q"&T$/@,7@"4&7#&.#+5#"47/&]H(*/#&!"#$%1&NOO[^1&
I7E7*/$*%-&E5$"&,J/#&lOo&5)&@5@5/&T$5+(@,75#&5$7:7#/,"4&)$5E&4E/**J5*+7#:4&,J/,&,%T7@/**%&@5Q"$&NdY&J/&
5)&*/#+-&/*,J5(:J&*/$:"&T*/#,/,75#4&@/#&C"&)5(#+&7#&45E"&@5(#,$7"4&]33317@@515$:W^1&H5$*+37+"-&,J"$"&
/$"&/TT$5X7E/,"*%&[&E7**75#&@5@5/&)/$E"$4&/#+&7,&74&"4,7E/,"+&,J/,&/$5(#+&PU&E7**75#&T"5T*"&+"T"#+&
+7$"@,*%&5#&,J"&@5@5/&@$5T-&37,J&E/#%&E5$"&7#+7$"@,*%-&7#&H"4,&=)$7@/&/*5#"1&D747#:&T$7@"4&E"/#&,J"$"&74&
E5$"&7#,"$"4,&7#&E/87#:&,J"&C"4,&(4"&5)&"X74,7#:&*/#+&C%&(T:$/+7#:&@5@5/&T$5+(@,75#&E",J5+41&<($$"#,&
35$8&,J$5(:J&T$7Q/,"dT(C*7@&T/$,#"$4J7T4&C",3""#&$"4"/$@J&7#4,7,(,75#4-&'B;4-&:5Q"$#E"#,&/#+&,J"&
@J5@5*/,"&7#+(4,$%&7#&.#+5#"47/-&<5,"&+h.Q57$"&/#+&"*4"3J"$"&74&7ET$5Q7#:&,J"&E/#/:"E"#,&E",J5+4&5)&
4E/**J5*+"$4-&+"*7Q"$7#:&47:#7)7@/#,*%&J7:J"$&%7"*+7#:&Q/$7",7"4&,5&$"T*/@"&5$&$"J/C7*7,/,"&],J$5(:J&
:$/),7#:^&5*+&@/@/5&,$""4-&/#+&7ET$5Q7#:&E/$8",&/@@"44&,J$5(:J&:$5(T&4/*"4&
]3331@5@5/4(4,/7#/C7*7,%1@5EW^1&=&+/#:"$-&J53"Q"$-&74&,J/,&J7:J"$&T$7@"4&E/%&*"/+&,5&/&E5#5@(*,($"&
,$"#+-&37,J&$748%&+"T"#+"#@"&5#&@5@5/&/*5#"&/#+&J/$+4J7T&C",3""#&T$5+(@,75#&4"/45#4&]6+3/$+&
K7**/$+-&D/7#)5$"4,&=**7/#@"-&3331$/7#)5$"4,d/**7/#@"15$:-&T"$45#/*&@5EE(#7@/,75#^1&.#&E/#%&@5(#,$7"4-&
,"/&T$5+(@,75#&74&/*45&E/7#*%&C%&4E/**J5*+"$4j&7,&J/4&C""#&$"T5$,"+&,J/,&/C5(,&ZYo&5)&,"/&7#&I$7&9/#8/&74&
:$53#&C%&4E/**d4@/*"&)/$E"$4&]3J5&/$"&+")7#"+&/4&J/Q7#:&J5*+7#:4&5)&*"44&,J/#&VY&J/^-&3J7*4,&E5$"&,J/#&
YOo&74&T$5+(@"+&C%&4E/**d4@/*"&:$53"$4&7#&0"#%/-&/*,J5(:J&7#&45E"&*5@/,75#4&T*/#,/,75#&T$5+(@,75#&
T$"+5E7#/,"4&]3331(#@,/+17#)5W7#)5@5EE^1&
&
N&/-(4'$+,!&+A!).#'$-&'$+,!'/((!322A4!'2!4.@@2/'!+.'/$'$2+!
K/#%&T"5T*"&7#&*53d7#@5E"&#/,75#4&4())"$&)$5E&T55$&#(,$7,75#-&37,J&/&*/@8&5)&E7@$5#(,$7"#,4-&5,J"$374"&
8#53#&/4&nJ7++"#&J(#:"$h-&*"/+7#:&,5&T55$&J"/*,J&@5#4"b("#@"4&)5$&J(#+$"+4&5)&E7**75#41&.#&=)$7@/-&
3J"$"&,J"&47,(/,75#&74&35$4,-&/$5(#+&YO&E7**75#&@J7*+$"#&/$"-&)5$&"X/ET*"-&/,&$748&5)&Q7,/E7#&=&+")7@7"#@%-&
,J"&@5#,7#"#,h4&,J7$+&:$"/,"4,&T(C*7@&J"/*,J&T$5C*"E&/),"$&!.fW=.2I&/#+&E/*/$7/&]A*/@8&!"#$%1&NOO_^1&
I5*Q7#:&E/*#(,$7,75#&$"b(7$"4&/&$/#:"&5)&7#,"$@5##"@,"+&/TT$5/@J"4&,J/,&7#@*(+"&,J"&C75d)5$,7)7@/,75#&5)&
4,/T*"&@$5T4&4(@J&/4&E/7e"&/#+&$7@"-&:$"/,"$&4T"#+7#:&5#&)55+&4(TT*"E"#,/,75#&T$5:$/EE"4-&/#+&,J"&
(4"&5)&/&37+"$&$/#:"&5)&"+7C*"&T*/#,4&)5$&E5$"&+7Q"$4"&+7",4&]L'.<6R&NOOZ-&'":7#&!"#$%1&NOOl^1&?J"&
)($,J"$&T$5E5,75#&5)&"+7C*"&7#+7:"#5(4&)$(7,4-&#(,4&/#+&Q":",/C*"4-&7#@*(+7#:&,J54"&T$5Q7+"+&C%&,$""4-&74&
/#&/,,$/@,7Q"&5T,75#-&/4&7,&/**534&@5#4(E"$4&,5&,/8"&$"4T5#47C7*7,%&)5$&,J"7$&+7",4&7#&@(*,($/**%&$"*"Q/#,&
3/%4&]0"/,7#:"&!"#$%1&NOPO^1&R($,J"$E5$"-&,J"&C75@J"E7@/*&T$5)7*"4&5)&,J"4"&7#+7:"#5(4&4T"@7"4&7#&
4(TT*%7#:&E7@$5#(,$7"#,4-&)/,-&)7C$"&/#+&T$5,"7#&/$"&5),"#&C",,"$&,J/#&4,/T*"&@$5T4&]9"/8"%&Plll^1&?J"&
#(,$7,75#/*&Q/*("&5)&E/#%&)5$"4,&)55+4&74&J53"Q"$&(#8#53#-&7#@*(+7#:&3J/,&:"#",7@&Q/$7/,75#&7#&
#(,$7,75#/*&b(/*7,%&74&T$"4"#,&37,J7#&4T"@7"4-&/#+&)($,J"$&,"4,7#:&/#+&@5ET7*/,75#&5)&+/,/&/$"&$"b(7$"+&
]<5*)"$&!"#$%1&NOO[^1&
<5EE(#7,7"4&7#&E/#%&T/$,4&5)&,J"&,$5T7@4&/*$"/+%&7#@5$T5$/,"&E/#%&"+7C*"&'HRS4&J/$Q"4,"+&)$5E&
)5$"4,4&7#,5&,J"7$&+7",4&/4&/#&7ET5$,/#,&@5ET5#"#,-&/#+&/&)"3&+"T"#+&5#&,J"Ej&7,&J/4&C""#&$"T5$,"+&
,J/,&,J"&$5*"&5)&,J"4"&T$5+(@,4&74&"4T"@7/**%&7ET5$,/#,&)5$&)7**7#:&4"/45#/*&/#+&5,J"$&@%@*7@/*&)55+&:/T4&
]=$#5*+&!"#$%1&NOPP^1&.#&/++7,75#-&)5$"4,4&T$5Q7+"&355+)("*&#""+"+&,5&@558&)55+&,5&E/8"&7,&4/)"&)5$&
@5#4(ET,75#&/#+&T/*/,/C*"-&/#+&7#@5E"&)$5E&,J"&4/*"&5)&5,J"$&T$5+(@,4&,J/,&@/#&,J"#&C"&(4"+&,5&
T($@J/4"&)55+1&<($$"#,&#(,$7,75#/*&+")7@7"#@7"4&7#&4"Q"$/*&T/$,4&5)&,J"&,$5T7@4&/$"&J53"Q"$&"X/@"$C/,"+&
C%&+")5$"4,/,75#&)5$&,J"&/:$7@(*,($/*&T$5+(@,75#&5)&/&)"3&4,/T*"&)55+4-&3J7@J&E"/#4&,J/,&*5@/*&
& Y&