Cover photo: Coconut palms and forest vegetation on La Digue Island, Seychelles. Forests on small islands may be particularly susceptible to some predicted but uncertain effects of climate change, including rise in sea level and increased frequency and intensity of storms. FAO Climate change, FORES! (TRY PAPER and forests 126 forest management An overview by William M. Ciesla Forest Protection Officer FAO Forest Resources Division Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations The designations employedandthe presentation ofmaterial inthis publication do not implythe expression of anyopinion whatsoever on the part of the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations concerning the legal status of anycountry, territory, city or area or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries. M-08 ISBN 92-5-103664-0 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying or otherwise, without the prior permission of the copyright owner. Applications for such permission, with a statement of the purpose and extent of the reproduction, should be addressed to the Director, Publications Division, Food and Agriculture Organization ofthe United Nations, Viale delle Terme di Caracalla, 00100 Rome, Italy. FAO 1995 FOREWORD Changes in the world's climate, due to increases in the concentration of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases in the Earth's atmosphere, have the potential to significantly affect forests and the practice of forestry. The probability of climate change is one of today's leading environmental concerns. The issue is complex and filled with uncertainties. Information available on the subject is often confusing and conflicting. Climate is the key factor which determines the distribution of vegetation. The relation of climate change to the conservation and development of the world's forests is therefore, an important issue to consider. Forests can contribute to the greenhouse effect, they can also be affected by climate change and they offer opportunities to mitigate its effects. It is important for foresters to have an understanding of the climate change issue and its implications. This document, which is presented in question and answer format, is designed to serve as a general reference on the subject of climate change and forests. The answers are based on the current world's literature including the most recent analyses by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). It is hoped that forest planners and managers will find it useful in the preparation and implementation of their programmes and in providing advice to decision makers. J. P. Lanly, Director Forest Resources Division Forestry Department ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The helpful and constructive comments provided by a large number of people who reviewed this document is gratefully acknowledged. External reviews were kindly provided by M. Fosberg, USDA Forest US USA Service, Washington DC, S. Brown, EPA, Corvalis, Oregon, and M. Hosny El Lakany, Desert Development Center, American University, Cairo, Egypt. Internal (FAO) reviews were provided by W.G. Sombroek, Director, Lands and Water Development Division and Chairman, Interdepartmental Working Group on Climate Change; R. Gommes, Coordinator, Agrometeorology Group, Remote Sensing Centre; J.P. Lanly, Director, Forest Resources Division; C. Palmberg-Lerche, Chief, Forest Resources Development Service; J. Ball, Senior Forest Plantations Officer, S. Braatz, Agroforestry and Land Use Officer; P. Vantomme, Forest Management Officer; D. Dykstra, Forest Harvesting Officer (Presently with CIFOR, Bogor, Indonesia); M. Trossero, Wood Based Energy Officer; C. Chandrasekharan, Non- Wood Forest Products Officer and D. Suparmo, Advisor, Tropical Forests Action Programme. Special thanks are given to J.B. Harrington, formerly of the Petawawa National Forestry Institute, Ontario, Canada, for his assistance with the technical editing of the manuscript and F. Monti, who FAO, Forestry Department Librarian, assisted in accessing the massive literature available on climate change. TABLE OF CONTENTS FOREWORD i ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ii TABLE OF CONTENTS iii LIST OF ACRONYMS ix LIST OF TABLES xii LIST OF BOXES xiii LIST OF FIGURES xiv INTRODUCTION 1 CHAPTER 1 - THE EARTH'S CLIMATE - A DYNAMIC ENTITY 4 HOWARE WEATHER AND CLIMATE DEFINED? 4 /. TO WHATEXTENTHAS THEEARTH'S CLIMATE CHANGED 2. DURING THE COURSE OF GEOLOGIC HISTORY? 4 WHAT CHANGES HAVE OCCURRED IN THE EARTH'S 3. CLIMATE SINCE THE BEGINNING OF RECORDED HUMAN HISTORY? 5 4. WHA T FACTORS CAN CAUSE CHANGES IN THE EARTH'S CLIMATE? 9 CHAPTER 2 - THE GREENHOUSE EFFECT 15 5. WHAT IS THE "GREENHOUSEEFFECT" AND HOWDOES IT INFLUENCE THE EARTH'S CLIMATE? 15 iv WHICH GASESAPE CONSIDERED TO BE GHGSAND WHA T 6. ARE THE SOURCES OF THESE GASES? 18 7. WHAT IS THE SIGNIFICANCE OF HUMAN SOURCES OF GHGS? 22 DO ALL GHGS HAVEAN EQUAL WARMING EFFECT? 22 8. WHAT EVIDENCE EXISTS TO SUPPORT THE IDEA THAT 9. GHG LEVELS IN THE A TMOSPHEREARE INCREASING? 23 WHICH COUNTRIES PRESENTLY MAKE THE GREATEST 10. CONTRIBUTION TO ELEVA TED LEVELS OF GHGS? 25 . . HOW CAN AEROSOLS COUNTERACT THE EFFECTS OF //. GHGS 25 CHAPTER 3 - PREDICTED CHANGES IN THE EARTH'S CLIMATE AND EXPECTED EFFECTS 27 12. IN GENERAL, WHAT ARE THE PREDICTED EFFECTS OF INCREASED LEVELS OF GHGS ON THE EARTH'S CLIMATE? 27 13. HOW ARE CHANGES IN THE EARTH'S CLIMATE PREDICTED? 27 HOW RELIABLE ARE PRESENT PREDICTIONS OF CLIMA TE 14. CHANGE? 30 15. WHAT CHANGES IN CLIMATE ARE PREDICTED WITH A DOUBLING OF C0 FROM PRE-INDUSTR1AL REVOLUTION 2 LEVELS? 31 16. IS THE CLIMATE OF SOME REGIONS OF THE WORLD EXPECTED TO CHANGE TO A GREATER DEGREE THAN OTHERS? 33 17. WHAT CHANGES IN THE LEVEL OF THE OCEANS ARE EXPECTED DUE TO CLIMATE CHANGE? 34 HOW 18. WILL PLANTS, INCLUDING TREES, BE INFLUENCED BY CHANGES IN THE LEVELS OF GHGs IN THE EARTH'S ATMOSPHERE AND RESULTANT CHANGES IN TEMPERATURE AND PRECIPITATION? 34 HOW 19. MIGHT SOILS BE AFFECTED BY CHANGES IN CLIMATE? 37 20. IS THERE ANY EVIDENCE WHICH INDICATES THAT CLIMA TECHANGESMA YHA VEALREADYOCCURRED DUE TO INCREASES IN GHG LEVELS? 38 CHAPTER 4 - THE GLOBAL CARBON CYCLE 40 21. WHAT PROCESSES EXIST FOR THE EXCHANGE OF CARBONBETWEEN THEATMOSPHERE, THE OCEANSAND THE LAND? 40 22. HOWARE EXCHANGES OF CARBON EXPRESSED? 41 . . 23. WHAT IS THE PRESENT LEVEL OF CARBON EXCHANGE BETWEEN THE A TMOSPHERE, THE OCEANS AND THE LAND? 45 CHAPTER 5 - TREES AND FORESTS AS SOURCES AND SINKS OF CARBON 45 24. HOW MUCH OF THE EARTH'S SURFACE IS PRESENTLY COVERED BY FORESTS AND OTHER WOODY VEGETATION? 45 25. WHAT PROCESSES OCCUR IN TREES AND FORESTS WHICH CONTRIBUTE TO CHANGES IN LEVELS OF GHGS IN THE EARTH'S ATMOSPHERE? 45 26. HOW MUCH CARBON IS RELEASED AND HOW MUCH IS TAKEN UP ANNUALLY BY FORESTS? 47 27. DO DIFFERENT FOREST ECOSYSTEMS VARY IN THEIR CAPACITY TO ABSORB AND STORE CARBON? 47 28. DO TREES AND FORESTS REMOVE CARBON FROM THE EARTH'S ATMOSPHERE AT DIFFERENT RATES DURING DIFFERENT STAGES IN THEIR LIVES? 49 29. WHICH HUMAN ACTIVITIES IN FORESTS AND WOODLANDS CONTRIBUTE TO INCREASESIN THELEVELS OF GHGS? 53 30. WHA TARE THE CURRENT RA TES OF DEFORESTA TION IN THE WORLD'S FORESTS? 55 HOW ARE FOREST SOILS AFFECTED BY 31. DEFORESTATION? 56 CHAPTERS- POSSIBLE EFFECTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON FORESTS 57 32. WHA T CHANGES IN GROWTH AND YIELD OF TREES AND FORESTS CAN BE EXPECTED AS A RESULT OF CLIMATE CHANGE? 57 33. WHAT CHANGES CAN BE EXPECTED IN THE NATURAL RANGES OF TREE SPECIES AND PLANT COMMUNITIES DUE TO CLIMATE CHANGE? 58 34. WHAT IS THE LIKELIHOOD THAT CLIMATE CHANGE COULD THREATEN SOME SPECIES OR PLANT COMMUNITIES WITH EXTINCTION? 64 HOW 35. MIGHT CLIMATE CHANGE INFLUENCE THE INCIDENCE AND INTENSITY OF WILDFIRES? 66