Table Of Content

1UMI[¥1ES]IT¥ ©IF TOIROMT© IFACULTY ©IF LAW C^SsE OUTLINE CIVIL APPEALS & JUDICIAL REVIEW Analysis, Process and Strategy in Civil Proceedings Volume 1 JOHN A. CAMPION Fasken Campbell Godfrey d Box 20 Toronto-Dominion Centre Toronto, Ontario M5K 1N6 366-8381 41992 bora LASKIN LA'.V LTRhaRY UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO lUMn¥IEIRSiI‘ir'¥ ©IF irOIEOHT© IFACHJLTY ©IF LAW COURSE OUTLINE CIVIL APPEALS & JUDICIAL REVIEW Analysis, Process and Strategy in Civil Proceedings Volume 1 JOHN A. CAMPION Fasken Campbell Godfrey Box 20 ’ Toronto-Dominion Centre Toronto, Ontario M5K 1N6 366-8381 Spring 1993 Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2018 with funding from University of Toronto https://archive.org/details/civilappealsjudi01camp_6 CIVIL APPEALS & JUDICIAL REVIEW ANALYSIS, PROCESS AND STRATEGY IN CIVIL PROCEEDINGS TABLE OF CONTENTS VOLUME 1 Page PART I - CIVIL PROCEDURE IN A NUTSHELL CHAPTER 1 CHART OF STEPS IN AN ACTION AND AN APPLICATION Constitutional Framework for Court Structure and Process 1 CHAPTER 2 The Courts of Justice Act 5 Introduction to the Courts of Justice Act 6 Definitions Section 1 6 Court of Appeal Court Section 2 7 Jurisdiction Section 6 7 Ontario Court of Justice Court Section 10 7 General Division Section 11 7 Appeals to General Division Section 17 8 Divisional Court Section 18 8 Jurisdiction Section 19 8 Provincial Division Section 34 9 Rules of Civil Procedure Section 66 9 Page 2 Common Law & Equity Law and Equity Section 96 10 Declaratory Orders Section 97 10 Relief Against Penalties Section 98 10 Damages In Lieu of Specific Performance Section 99 10 Vesting Orders Section 100 10 Interlocutory Orders Injunctions and Receivers Section 101 10 Labour Disputes Section 102 11 Certificate of Pending Litigation Section 103 12 Procedural Matters Jury Trial Section 108 12 Constitutional Question Section 109 13 Set-Off Section 111 14 Interest and Costs Definitions Section 127 14 Prejudgment Interest Section 128 15 Postjudgment Interest Section 129 15 Discretion of Court Section 130 15 Costs Section 131 16 Appeals Judge Not to Hear Appeal from Own Decision Section 132 16 Leave to appeal required Section 133 16 Powers on Appeal Section 134 16 CHAPTER 3 RULES OF CIVIL PROCEDURE 27 Rule 1 Definitions Subrule 1.03 29 Interpretation Subrule 1.04 31 Rule 5 - Parties and Joinder Joinder of Claims Subrule 5.01 32 Joinder of Parties Subrule 5.02 32 Joinder of Necessary Parties Subrule 5.03 32 Misjoinder, etc. Subrule 5.04 33 Page 3 Relief Against Joinder Subrule 5.05 *-> Rule 14 - Originating Process Issuance Subrule 14.01 34 Generally Subrule 14.02 34 Actions Subrule 14.03 34 Petitions Subrule 14.04 35 Applications Subrule 14.05 35 Rule 16 - Service Originating Process Subrule 16.01 36 Personal Service Subrule 16.02 36 Rule 19 - Default Proceedings No Defence Subrule 19.01 38 Consequences of Default Subrule 19.02 38 Signing Judgment Subrule 19.04 39 Motions Subrule 19.05 40 Rule 20 - Summary Judgment Where Available Subrule 20.01 40 Affidavits Subrule 20.02 41 Factums Subrule 20.03 41 Disposition Subrule 20.04 41 Rule 21 - Determination of An Issue Where Available Subrule 21.01 42 Rule 25 - Pleadings Pleadings Generally Subrule 25.01 43 Forms Subrule 25.02 43 Rules - All Pleadings Subrule 25.06 43 Rules - Defences Subrule 25.07 44 •Rules - Reply Subrule 25.09 44 Rule 27 - Counterclaim Where Available Subrule 27.01 45 Rule 28 - Crossclaim Where Available Subrule 28.01 45 Rule 29 - Third Party Claim Where Available Subrule 29.01 45 Rule 30 - Discovery of Documents Interpretation Subrule 30.01 46 Page 4 Scope Subrule 30.02 46 Rule 31 - Examination for Discovery Form Subrule 31.02 47 Who Subrule 31.03 47 Scope Subrule 31.06 48 Rule 34 - Procedure on Oral Examination Application Subrule 34.01 48 Rule 37 - Motions Notice Subrule 37.01 49 Jurisdiction - Judge and Master Subrule 37.02 49 Before Whom Subrule 37.04 49 Content of Notice Subrule 37.06 49 Material Subrule 37.10 49 Disposition Subrule 37.13 50 Rule 38 - Application To Whom Subrule 38.03 51 Content of Notice Subrule 38.05 51 Material Subrule 38.10 51 Disposition Subrule 38.11 52 Rule 39 - Evidence on Motion and Application Affidavit Subrule 39.01 52 Cross-Examination Subrule 39.02 53 Evidence By Witness Subrule 39.03 53 Evidence - Discovery Subrule 39.04 53 Rule 40 - Injunctions and Mandatory Order How Obtained Subrule 40.01 54 Undertaking Subrule 40.03 54 Rule 47 - Jury Notice Notice Subrule 47.01 54 Striking Out Subrule 47.02 54 Rule 49 - Offer to Settle Where Available Subrule 49.02 54 Withdrawal Subrule 49.04 55 Disclosure to Court Subrule 49.06 55 Acceptance Subrule 49.07 55 Cost Consequences Subrule 49.10 56 Rule 50 - Pre-Trial Conference Page 5 Where Available Subrule 50.01 57 Memo or Order Subrule 50.02 a— / Rule 51 - Admissions Interpretation Subrule 51.01 57 Fact of Documents Subrule 51.02 57 Rule 52 - Trial Procedure Exhibits Subrule 52.04 58 Exclusion of Witness Subrule 52.06 58 Order of Presentation - Jury Trial Subrule 52.07 58 Rule 53 - Evidence at Trial Witness Subrule 53.01 59 Affidavit Subrule 53.02 59 Expert Subrule 53.03 59 Rule 57 - Costs Factors in Discretion Subrule 57.01 60 Rule 59 - Orders Date Subrule 59.01 60 Preparation and Form Subrule 59.03 61 Rule 60 - Enforcement General Subrule 60.02 61 Rule 61 - Appeals Leave to Appeal Subrule 61.03 62 Commencement Subrule 61.04 63 Rule 62 - Appeals from Interlocutory Orders 63 Rule 63 - Stay Pending Appeal 65 Rule 68 - Proceedings for Judicial Review How Commenced Subrule 68.01 67 Rule 70 - Divorce Actions Petition Subrule 70.03 68 Answer Subrule 70.07 68 Page 6 CHAPTER 4 JUDICIAL REVIEW PROCEDURE ACT 69 CHAPTER 5 - Case Study #1 THE CAUSE OF ACTION 74 CHAPTER 6 - Case Study #2 "ITS NOT OVER ’TILL ITS OVER" 170 CHAPTER 7 - Case Study #3 APPEAL FROM ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL 269 CHAPTER 8 - Case Study #4 JUDICIAL REVIEW 295 CHAPTER 9 THE ESSENTIAL TOOL FOR ANALYSIS - THE CAUSE OF ACTION Article: John A. Campion A Survey - Elements of Causes of Action - 355 Part I - Contract 357 Part II - Torts 361 in Part - Restitution 414 Part IV - Property 416