CAUT Bulletin November 2009 (Volume 56, Number 9)

2009·3.1 MB·English

by  Canadian Association of University Teachers

PRESIDENTSCOLUMN ACTUALITES BOOKSHELF Letters/Courrier A2
I
PenniStewart: Un rapportsur MatthewReisz: Studentspayingmore,gettingless À9
Reportreveals l'intégritéen recherche Topscholarsshould r ---- - =----
injusticestomideast soulèved'épineuses head research ^AUTDenefltstrustreadvtoro11 All
academicstaff questions universities UBC:appel rejetéd'uneétudiante ÀÏ3
SeePageA3 VoirPageAU SeePageA14 Careers/Carrières Bl
I
Bulletin
Canada'sVoiceforAcademics
Lavoixdesuniversitaires
duCanada
VOL56INO9INOVEMBER2009NOVEMBREICANADIANASSOCIATIONOFUNIVERSITYTEACHERSIASSOCIATIONCANADIENNEDESPROFESSEURESETPROFESSEURSD'UNIVERSITE
Academic
Federal Plan Shortchanges Research Freedom
Fund Donors
GAUTanalysisofknowledge FacultyAssociations
infrastructurefundingreveals Knowledge Infrastructure Grants Unlv
mostmoneynotgoingfor uS$82S_..7_L_
researchfacilities. TNootna-lrepsleedagrecdhtporodjaetcets $1.75bi3l.li6o%n SCaa((ipCSnBeMtUUMBFFraAUer))tyo'$$ns121UU5,nn.ii06vv0ee00rr0ssiittyy
1ESSthanhalfofwhatthefederalgovern- Un$i3ve2r.s0it0y0otVictoria(UVicFA)
mentsaysit'sinvestinginuniversityand Mc$M2a5s.t0e0r0University(MUFA)
Jcollegeresearchinfrastructureisactually Mo(uMnStVUSFaAi)nt$V1i4n,c7en2t0University
goingtoresearch-relatedprojects,accordingto Un$i2ve5r,s0it0y0ofWaterloo(FAUW)
aCATJTanalysisofthegovernment'sspend- Un$i6ve2r,s0it4y0olCalgary(TUCFA)
irIlinenofcgTnrehaaiesenvtcinronaougnnucaotnflumecyrdsieeeimcrsePasnlsrtthoifsogmu.wurnsladuimtsnh—gamteftamrhsooeusmtrtwteooh-feaynteKnhaneroo,upwnr$loc2ejeedbdciglt-es AAUMUsnnloU$($iisnguM81vvoioAn,ee0cvrrFmt0i,essAara00iiAts)00ttliiUyyl0to$niynooi1sffvoT6oeneW,Rfraise0UNcingn0tohnii0yvevinera(oprsAesS(Ugi$cUtFo1Ry(At.FU)iA0Wa)0F0A)
f;I[i='•iltpfdaanurelcrBfeiBeplecyu"riretodrfitdjgeeoheesredecnttoptmsenoe.a2nsd0idct0na-i9tosnm,efevpnceuaOaossncnntedtcdmsoeae,wb,rnieytadurenip,ilndngsyortrofaietttdsothuehueeteatsirreomncgdosheofanr—igseenerfaanarrntelaehrs"aactfuarnlonpuric--- CAFNQMetacu$$(SE3$$dGhnedC1112C2ieaaeuM,,005lrAbdncC00i.a,,Dai'aFt00000tsasUiA00000Uoncno)n0U0i0raninvsM4vieioUevr1lofnresif2isritPv,istBaoeti0r.yrsytyC0st(y.i(0C-Mt$(FoSAyQl1UeUlU(c0NTeFAo,S)gAUn0Ce)Fd0AsAa0D)r)y
I$1.7billioninprojectspendingonly$718mil-
1 lionor41.4percenthadgonetoresearch-
riasenlbdaetiuepndggirndafidrseatssr.tirbuuctteudref.orThgeenebruallkmoafiKnItePnfaunncdes "vaetsHttemheeandtsdaienmderetstheiaamtrewchhaasitnm'fsiraswsrtoerrpuscrete,usrehen,otwtiehnevgye'rtr,heeitisarktiihnna-gt fMuonTrduesrkstohsafanayrs$a2hn3en'smoiualnllsciooendcohfnaoscrepfrrlniovewadetdeabitnoosutatittKulteIiaoPsnts. AUnc(F$iaaA2vdce3Biur,Plas4tPiyU0tUné0MAis)vdseeor$scM1iio4tany,tc2i(to5Ano0UsnF$A1,000
"It'snotthatwedon'tthinktheinfrastruc- moneyawayfromCanadianresearchers." 14privateinstitutions.
stauiredaCtAunUivTeresxiteiceustiavneddciorlelcetgoersJnaemeedssTfuirxkin.g," anInnouBnucdgeedtcu2t0s09oftahlemfoesdter$a1l4g8omvielrlinomnentottahleso fac"iGnigvoeunrtphueblcihcr,onpiocstu-nsdeecrofnduanrdyinignsstiittuutaitoinosn Si$(mS1Fo0Un,F0AF0)r0a$s1er0,U0ni0v0ersity
c"lBauitmitt'hsisdsispienngdeinnugoiussanfoirntvheestgmoevnetrinnmreensteatroch tohfrreeesegarracnhtifnugncdoiunngcialtsCtahnaatdpar'osvicdoleletgheesbaunldk aecrrnomsesnCtainsaddiav,eritt'isngunpaucbcleipctfaubnldestthoatprtihveagteov- TBrr$$eo21nct50k,.U00Unni00iv00veerrssiittyy((TBUUFFAA))
whenitisn't" universities. collegesanduniversities,"hesaid. UUnn(IiisUvvlSeeaFrrnssAdii)tt(yy$U2Poo4ffE,lPSF0raA0is)n0kc$ae4t.Ec0dh0we0awradn
University
$59,50<_
La plan de relance fédéral fait obstacle au secteur SAtu(.gSFutrFsaXtnAacUniTsa)XU$anv2iiv5ee,rr0sUi0nt0iyveCroslilteyge
(AUCFA)$3,000
de la recherche académique ULna$iu3vr.eer6ns6til0taynofUnLievtehrbsirtlydg(eLU(FUAL)FA)
$7.000
Blshoja'sUniversity(APBU)
MOINveSrnedmeelnatmofiétdiééradlepsrféotnednsdqiunevelsetigrou- mtreanvtaupxosd'tesnetcroentdiaeinrqeui—avsaoinetnrtéésteérvréespoprtoéusr,ddeess ugnéinvéerraslitdéesle'tAdeCsPPcoUlJlaègmeess»,Tuprrékc.is«eCleedqiureecntoeuusr SDta$$.l43Th,0oh0,uo00sm00iae0sUnUinvievresristiyty(D(FFAA)UST)
dansl'infrastructurederecherchedes travauxdemodernisationdesinstallationsgé- déplorons,c'estquelegouvernementlaisse y$e2r0s.o0n0I0
universitésetdescollègesserventenfaità néralessurlescampusetd'autresprojetsd'im- faussementcroirequecesfondssontinvestis Wi(lWfrLiUdFLAa)ur$i1er5.U0ni0v0ersity
fli'nAaCncPePrUddeasnpsrosjoentsandaelyrseechdeerschdeé,pceonnscelsutan- mobAilliasfaitniodn'socgtéonbréer,ausxe.ulement700millionsde danMsailsarceecqhueircehset.pi»re,àsonavis,c'estque, BUnr((ieBAvsFePcArPi)saBi$UtUé5SniA0Sv)0aeir$ns2tite.y0A0Cn0onlelege
noncéesdanslebudgetfédéral. dollars{soit41%)surletotaldedépensesde «parallèlementàcetteprésentationfallacieuse Un(iUveWrOsFitAy)o$f4W5e,s0t0e0rnOntario
L'analyserévèlequelamajoritédesprojets plusde1,7milliarddedollarsavaientservi desfaits,legouvernementpriveleschercheurs Un$i5ve0r0sitédeHearst(APUH)
bdé'innéffriacsitarnutctduerefdonudssavdouirP—rougnreammemseurfeédédrealre- càhfeirncahnec.erLadepslupsrogjreatsndde'ipnafrrtaisetrduecstufroenddesrper-o- canDaadnisenlseBdeusdgfeotnd2s00d9o,ntleilgsoounvtebrenseomiennt».fé- Nl$p2l,s0s0l(n5gUniversity(NUFA)
lanceéconomiquede2milliardsdedollarset venantduProgrammed'infrastructuredusa- déralaannoncéégalementdescompressions
d'uneduréededeuxansannoncéedansle voirestaffectéeàl'entretiengénéraletàla deprèsde148millionsdedollarsdansles
Btdiuesdsrgeeemctehne2tr0c0sha9enest»pvdraeénsctééédeteacnbtolimdsamsneesmeélnt'taisnntfdr'«aesuntnsrueicintgvunerese-- mpoads»<elCraneinsénca'etessistoinpt.aésdqeureénnoovuesrnle'inrfercaosntnruacitsusrieodnses budgetsVodiersLAtroPiLsAoNrDgEanRiEsLmAeNsCEsuàbvlaenftionnaires SAtt(((.lASUaTnSTNhtTM8ioFCFcAmUF)SJAac)s$h$5o2$M0o.4ol00,r05eo0(0C0Tohleloelgoegy
CoBlolneiefeacunei(veArPsCitUaSiBr)ed$e5,S5al0n0i-
KingsUniversityCollege
(KTJCFA)$4,000
HTThe Academic Co$n2c0o.r0di0a0University(CUFA)
Mortgage Workxa
Centre SCta((.pSSiMTTlaMMarUUn.yjFFo'AA_Ul)nUinS_vi4evr1e_sr0istiyty(CCFoAl)lege
$1,000
CAUT'sCareerSitefor Ro(yRaRlUFRAo)ad$s4.U0ni0v0ersity
DiscountRatesPageA6 HigherEducationJobs
PledgedtoDate:$976,345
A2OUTBUUfTINIWJVEMBtfl2009
COMMENT
Bulletin
OPINIONS
CanadianPAusbsloicsihaetdiobnyoftPUunbilvieérspitayrTeachers
Associationcanadiennedesprofesseureset
professeursd'université
2705,promenadeQueensvïewDrive,
Ottawa(Ontario)K2B8K2;Tel:613*20-2270;
Fax:613*20-2417;Email:duhaime@cauLca
LETTERS/COURRIER
PresidentIPrésidente
PenniStewart
ExecutiveDireJcatmoersITDuirrkecteurgénéral 'aOnbsocmeenen'compensation Tshhoirst"omradrekretf"ropmerascpceocutnitvaebihlaistyletdoianc- tmhiendwsoreldx,paitnidssaenedrntihnegilryeeyaessyotpoesnhtoow
ManagingEdLiitzoarDIuRhéadiamcetriceenchef AnarticleintheOctober2009issue wcohuenltminign.gInneeotdheornwtohredsp,arttootfhiensotvietur-- seruecccteesds.wShaedlny,shwienyarneewallbcuailudgihntgsinatrheis
AdveRrotsiasiLnagboIcPcuebtltiacité o"fobtshceeCneA"UcTomBpuelnlseatitniornefedresaltofotrhethe toifonpseorffhoirgmhaenrcleeatrhnrionuggthoparnovairdreayproofofs pinetrove"rbsieglbougsiicnewshsi."chturnsuniversities
([email protected]) UniversityofCalgary'soutgoingpresi- indicators. TheUniversityofCalgaryissearch-
CircRualcahteilonNe1wDimfafnusion WdhenitlewhsuochwilclomrepteinresaitniJoannusatrriyke2s01m0a.ny meaHsowuerveewrh,atthiessemeiansdiucraatbolrsecoarnquoannltyi- irnargefiorndaivnieduwalpriensdiedeedntwhItowiwlilllbebea
(newman@cauLca) assurprising,excessive,orevenout- fiablewhiletheintangible,thehuman abletosimultaneouslysatisfythewishes
GraphicKDeveisnigAnlbIeGrrtaphisme rCaagneaoduas.,Idoubtthatit'suniquein facAtosr,unrievmearsiintsieassceolmupsievteeaseveevrerm.ore sopfiraitgoofvearncianmgpubosacrodmamnudniratiysewhthiech
Inalettertotheuniversity'sboardof intenselyforscarceresourcesinacon- isincreasinglybecomingcynicaland
EditPoerninailStBeowaarrtdIComiJtaémdeesrTéudrakction gcuolvteyrAnsosroscithaetiUonnivaesrkseidtysoofmCealpgoairntyeFda- ttehxetpiunrswuhiitcohfvkanlouwelsesdugceh,atshelefaorrnimnign,g Mostofusremaincommittedtoreach-
GregAllain DavidRobinson questionsaboutthedeal.Butthearticle ofminds,andtheeducationofcitizens ingoutforexcellence,butthepreva-
WaynePeters LizaDuhaime intheBulletinavoidstherealissue,which havebeensupplantedbytheneedto lentcultureofperformativitywithits
istheincreasingtrendinCanadianuni- secure"customers"andtobuildafinan- associatedrequirementstoconstandy
LetterstotheEditor versities—Albertabecauseofitsparti- cialbaseinordertoensuretheirown provideproofsofeffectivenesshasin-
Ldpaerreteeatsresleriadsmisfitponeerdctiphftuieobclp3aia0rctp0aiectlrwieoo,onrcrdoasbrmeemaenwbndeetld,mctaooomyrerl.ebetcetLeeenrettdttiheetarvetsednrstefshco.oernuLtlleledtyntgaaetdpr--hs tcelhuselamorfocvguoelvmteuerrnentab—necitenogawdahtoeprttheecotfraopkroiernfagrtorenitsmkoosf,d- ssauenrldvvietvshalea,tviaitri"tsvunaelouoewf-oafnotdrekea"rcbhtiehntegwyerfoeilnnedgwltihhteezrme- fwalihlletprtaahrteetdroawfllethliresevecclouslgtnouifrzeue.niitveorrsintoite,s.wAenadre
gltabteiiehntosradn.hsteAaeodcl.rqfnaeuroWCainctlAeyoy.UcnmroTIsoneni.saucdidlesIdurfeedleryveedaotettyurpeioroyrostunlelr.weneitttnPlttilaueearbrmnlloeliwisty,ceaablactiredbicedeoecarlnpecleitcoisveesusepsdatatawefnindotldr.hdleppSneusuhovbobotllemneiribceysdeaistnlspiieuctuoormtnbnee,--s-r plivtsoeahgnssiitsencagectncatipaoaoinsmntgasmiplibeaglrcnneaskdiatsosgoifnegscgs,oho.oomadmwnedlfneosahrduaoevrnriaesnt'hgsiepsa.ccooStmimueo-c-nhs miltnaehgyeIatetsidoiumsrhapneoanocdwttthmdseiiuusvfrcafpmulrhosuieresmdieo.onfngoafettyhpearnhteastisithdiabesneneetnanosaitcrecadroierst-edod- UPFnirieevrnercrehs-,iYtvIyteasolfiMaConac&lqguSaaprlyasnish
yreotuurwnilmlaible.cLoetnttCeaOrcsUtResRdhIobuEylRdpDhbEoeSnseLe,EnCteTltEeocUtdRruSohnaicimmea@ilc,aufaLxcao.r sLlyioWpthpaearrtdyhosalusogphcetalotlfoewdbhe"aptienJrfeqoauinem-saFttriiaovnniçtioysi"sth—e vucarnladuneeersohftiospw/rheoefrreoswsvaoetrrscchwahamnopdusshpeeosnwdthmcaaonnnstyihde- oRneapdagmeorAe4.letters
LoLoneautsru(lénreadteiatlrcleàetstitdodreenosipdvraeuécntcuitBasupllqioltureéittseisrnroénsictunervnpitauterensu.lsaerLstdeialscnelecst,telxeuetunerBssu,cloàldmeoltmnuieitnnéoltcauarliiroqrenue.-i tbthhyeekmcnsyoecwlllveeeisdngiwenhc(rieecdahusciuanntgiilvoyenr,csairtueigseehsatrfcwihhn,edretec-.) etruarIbiflnitegiststiduimfdefeinfcteuslr.tvetnotslyhoawndthpeattireanntslfyornmuar-- SàuilatepadguecAo4ur.rier
gsouuecuirdeestcllairmtéiteétedàe3co0n0cimsoitosn.,Vpeouuilrlreoznitndêtirqeuerrévviossésnopma,r hastoshowithasimpact,or"relevance." tiontakingplaceinstudentsastheir I
adresseetnumérodetéléphone.Nousnepublieronsniles
lettresanonymesnilestextesquenousestimonspoten-
tiellementdiffamatoires.Nouslisonsavecunemêmeat-
tentiontoutesleslettresquenousrecevons.L'ACPPUse
réserveledroitdechoisirleslettresquiserontpubliées.
Nouscommuniqueronspartéléphone,courrierélectro-
nique,télécopieurouretourducourrieraveclesauteurs
deslettresquiserontpubliées.Leslettresdoiventêtre
envoyéesàl'[email protected].
TheCAUTBulletinispublishedeachmonthSeptember
throughJune.Averagedistribution44,000.Indexedinthe
CanadianEducationIndex.ISSN0007-7887.Availablein
mOiNcrMof5oCrm2fNr8o.mCMliacsrsiofmieeddiaad,s2a0nVdicatosreilaecSttrieoent,ofToarrotinctloe,s
areavailableatwww.cautbulletin.ca.Careeradsareavail-
ableatwww.academicwork.ca.
CopyrightReproductionwithoutwrittenpermissionby
thepublisherandauthorisforbidden.Copyrightinlet-
tersandothermaterialssubmittedtothepublisherand
acceptedforpublicationremainswiththeauthor,butthe
publishermaychoosetotranslateand/orreproducethem
inprintandelectronicform.Allsignedarticlesexpressthe
viewoftheauthor(s).
LeBulletindel'ACPPUestpubliéchaquemois,desep-
tembreàjuin.Tiragemoyen:44000exemplaires.Réper-
toriédansleRépertoirecanadiensurl'éducation.ISSN
0007-7887.LeBulletinestdisponiblesurmicroformeau-
pMr5èsCd2eN8M.icLreosmpeedtiiate,s2a0n,nrouneceVsicettoruina,cThooirxondt'aort(iOclnetsarsioon)t
reproduitsdansleBulletinenligne,surlesitewww.acppu
bwuwllwe.tint.rcavaa.ilDaecsadoeffmriesqude'.ecmaploisontpubliéessurlesite
Droitd'auteur:Hestinterditdereproduiredesarticles
sansl'autorisationdel'éditeuretdel'auteur.L'auteurcon-
serveledroitd'auteurpourleslettresetautresdocuments
soumisàl'éditeuretacceptésauxfinsdepublication.L'édi-
teurpeutcependantchoisirdelestraduireoudelesrepro-
duire,oulesdeux,sousformeimpriméeetélectronique.
Touslesarticlessignésn'engagentqueleursauteurs.
CanadiaMnemAbsseorcioatfioInMeofmbLraeboduerMedia
L'Associationcanadiennedelapressesyndicale ACAUT BookSeriesTitle
UNIVERSITIES AT
PrintedPienrfCoarnmaandcaebPyrinItIimnpg,riSmméitahusCFaalnlsadapar PCaalpletrolblafcrkee$[e-mail]
Leammoreatwww.lorimer.ca
NOVEMBRE2009\BULLETINACPPUA3
PRESIDENTS COLUMN
Report Reveals Injustices to Mideast Academic Staff
Robinsonmetwithacademic promptedmanyacademicstaffto ityofstudents.Theglobalfiscal securitybarriereffectivelyprevents
BEyDPUECNNAITSTIEOWNARTInternationaland smgBhtiaaaannfndiifk,szt.taourtDnariiteuolooneyrsnsotioonanffntItirdsceairlvaaheleeuspll,hmraoseanntsntuderdiiertcnnihttgteihseot,rWnsvsea,iosderht-w-es fiIaascilcransaanodedtlewe.sromhoIirodnrckictfrnsaaegtblaalrwfsfooioaranfdkgn,aidecnlqagteudhaacrevloemiinainzdtgcaiettnasiistoosaainnfgcsfniaiisfdfno--r nusctaoratWuufifsnoocnrasshrki,eithufngaaugestrnitcoelhonree.nadrdlitletoyxiaaopcnodesoerfrcbolariatnaniecndgaiwdnaaedgmtoeei-nsc- mvidinieentcnrtotesysrIdi-siancrfanaftemidhlcpeuuaflsoWctraeftdrsorereatvsmPeeBialaaclrfencosskhrttaifmoanfran.iadnsEntyntutahdcrsetyayrude-ies-
rsteapfofCritAnoUInsTratehaler,estthaaebtouWsuetosfttoaBcraealndekeamsaeincad waitinwtdihlrlcebocleolpemramegeusneedsnatitenidGotanozsaC.fAlToUhwTiengrCeofpruoornmt iecmTifhcreeferldeaoermgdeohrmo.cwheavlelre,ngdeertioveascafdreomm- addienfpdfricseutslastf,efdiwn.igtTshehaohrcethaaigvneygs.tceRoaencdshieitanirgocnhlsoaaandrdse atirneegndmcioanlgnlaycbooinrmfaeptrievedenicmreeessnetaasnrdcthodeotuhveteislriodpaet--
Gtiaozna.anEdIaisnaadglvoobcaalteunfioronthfeedreirgah-ts cilTthhiescmoonnttehx.tforRobinson'sre- pdaetbiaotneowfitthheinWIessrtaelBaonvkeratnhdeGoaczcau.- tIseraacehliin-gimaproesseedvreersetlryichtaiomnpseornedavbay- ohfavtehegernegeiroanl.lyStbuedeenntdseninieGdatzhae
ofacademicstaffinmorethan172 portliesintheobligationofmem- WhilemanyIsraeliacademicstaff rietyofimports,amongthemsci- righttostudyoutside,eveninthe
couEnItrrioeustianenldytceorrnidtuocritess.reviewson ibnerthsetat1e9s97toUmNeeEtSsCtOandraercdosmsmetenou-t ssupee,akthoeurtefhraeveelyboenenthiasnpuolmibtiecraloifs- epnuttiefrisc,alnadborreasteoarrychemqautieprmiealnst,,caonmd- WeAstmoBanngk.itsfindings,Robinson's
theimplementationofthe1997 dation,whichrecognizestheteach- casesofinstitutionalandexternal evenchalkandtextbooks.Notsur- reportdescribesarbitraryarrests
UNESCORecommendationCon- ingprofession'srighttoacademic reprisalsagainstthosewhoexpress prisinglythereisa"braindranVof anddetentionofacademicstaff
ccuaemtreinnointngTCetAahceUhSTitnapgtluPaseyroesfdoHnaincgeehlnet—rraaElddruoo-cle- fmtoryeaecadhniodemvaeaccnfodauinirtnnasebtsiistluiattniyodnaaaslceaasudsteenomtniioac-l tbcioevniettnireossveeavrnesdriealdlyeomproeinsnstitroirncast.teidPooanltsitsihcoaamvleeac- AacrOaavdbeermstriaictdessi.tnagfftthoeJeofrfdecatnoafntdheosteher afoonnrgdcoessi.tnugIdnepnoatldisdtiibtcyailotnch,oeniftIlsniroacettleibsemttihlweieteanry
incrafting.Therecommendation freedom. universitiesandcollegesandsome workingconditions,whicharecom- HamasandFatahhasalsoresulted
laysoutprinciplesoffairnessinthe Robinson'sreportrevealsthat protestershavebeenarrested. moninpoorcountries,Robinson's indetentionsandharassmentof
wtoerrkm,saacnaddceomnidcitfiroenesdoofm,acpardofeemsi-c gfoorvIesrrnaealnicaecahdaesmibcesc.oAme20a01cornecpeorrnt higIhnetrheedWuecasttioBnaniskparnodviGdaezda,by orfeptohretInsorateelsitbhleocdkevaadsetaotfiGnagziampaancdt stuTdheentrseaponrdtsctaofnf.cludesthatthere
sionalresponsibilityandselfgov- recommendedreformsthatmany publiclyfunded,nonprofitand thetravelrestrictionsimposedon aregraveviolationsofUNESCO
ernanceforacademicstaff. feltwouldseverelyconstrictcollé- autonomousinstitutions,govern- WestBankresidentsthathavemade principlesintheWestBankand
Theresultsofthesereviewsare gialgovernanceanduniversityau- ment-sponsoredinstitutionsand normalacademicroutinesnearly Gaza.Iurgeyoutoreadhisreport
ptiuobnlalilsyh.eTdhaenmdodsitstrreicbeunttedreivniteewr,nao-n tforneoedmoym,.aTnhderthereaarteenalasocacdoenmciecrns psriitvuaattieonunoifveurnsiivteiressi.tiTehseanfdincaonlclieagles impDoeslsaiybslea.ndclosingsofcheckpoints wwihlelnsuitppisorretlCeaAseUdTasndacIthioonpewiytohu
IbsyraCelAaUndTPaalsessotciinaet,eweaxsecuuntdievretadki-en taiboonsu.tFwaocrulsteyniunngiownosrkhaivnegcaorngduie-d siuslitnpcrriivsaist,ehfoiwneavnecrin,gahnadsaisncareraes-ed irloiutytifnreolmyprreeavcehnitngsttuhedierntcsaampnudsfeasc- 'doruerssIinntgertnhaetsieonias]suceos.lleaguesinad-
rectorDavidRobinson,whovisited thatlowersalaries,comparedto dramatically.Tuitionfeesarerising tostudyandteach.Travelrestric-
theareaearlierthisyear. academicsinNorthAmerica,have beyondthemeansofthemajor- tionsforceearlyclosingsandthe
LE MOT DE LA PRÉSIDENTE
Un rapport met au jour les injustices faites aux
universitaires du Moyen-Orient
ParPENN1STEWART del'ACPPU,quis'estrendudans recommandaitdesréformesqui, etuniversités,lesactivitéspolitiques derecherche,lesordinateurs,lesap-
lldqaqGLeaiuacu>aizaesp>laiodtedIt.eiéiéundnnomafLttentieITeiqndsso(rErdueTnyanEenëe)lapddlseu,itdutsebcaiteuladpnoninrtlesnoeser'iCrapsAtidfllosusC'éunejnedPdsnonéPuderrsrdUledeaaepaiptaelsngip1'croinoo7Énsaean2rdtodntuemnéptstconsamsuaeuàyinr-rls-- msdMscadeieeyne.ntnsnnsSttiidéReas,deieontrnc.rebtrosaénisaieugttnixisdIegs,os'unodrnoraadensrnëdegtlasalusaaie,npnégtpistuldieesuoerdmnsbqsis'eeuaeoCspnneniptetsdnlsrrdjee,ueemo,tsrsaedddinntéelraiôfesentraenpiancatreddesvé,sût-e-e,tce mfmddddcdaie'éeeeoittemnbitnmvpilotrtirenmqarvossuleieefaesseedaen.sgleliutseoanxLeituqec,uraruvrenraisaeevsd,éinapértiégtstnplurnroéaadiaaursrlneivtiusceeosilr.nrecreaataianpLltitcnpbeieeoieboslnooneérltnntrgtsétsgydaqéniéàneluaordsaelcieimcmeeeccabuelaou-eserntnxtseste-- lnédcmoe'taeotnEeatsttEmlnbiaeenltotéésinsttesmCélatssiaibeuampenstlripimajirtséfeorsêéarenrstendsitdésesetesas,mas.unebestrinutuiueettnobdsineevelvstsepusetucnàrorbdtmsnaliGaiittistnaiocfépizéns,sfetan,eéné,ppssrsaastéliuréa'epvtvnééoadèpdte-errussase-.r- rpcpsplcaeaoaorusnrranrrMittedtpa.eiieiursrlsqttesRueierndtooeednaanlsbenneslmistseplansdmadasslaeycbeesonsooseutnvrnreapoasaplrniatvéasroooyaqb.iituslluereerA,seespu.ndalquseaucaunstJvieinimrovssenserê'rosddsesnm,saeoittnn-etpitiacleerieolrlparlu-eapeees-s-sst
etLteTrrEitpoirroecs.èderégulièrementà àtéGlaézpah,onmeeennerraisseosnednetsrerveusetrsicptairons vqeuresédsuauNxorudn,ivperosuistsaeinretsdeennAommé-ri- Ltreosuvuennitvetrosuitteéfsoiestdlaensscuolnleègseistusaetion dpoernttaduexleefufretismdpéovratsatantceeurpsardurabpl-o-
cdaetsiéovnadlueatlaiornescdoemmlaamnidsaetieonnapdpeli- mdiessdiéopnlaectelmesenrtesc.omSmoanndraatppioorntsdqeui bdréemuixqumeemàbarlleesrtdruavapielrlseronànel'létarcaan-- fpianratndciuèrfeincraintcieqmueenett,pdreivcées'faeistt,la ctiuosnsisdraeéldiéepnldaeceGmaeznatsetidmepsosréesetsric-
rstUatNutEdSuCpOerdseon1n9e9l7ecnosneciegrnnaannttdele meonisd-éccioualueCnotnsseeriolntdeprlé'sAeCnPtéPsU.ce gd'eerf,feccrtéiafnstdaainnssiluesneétgarbalviesspeémneuntrsie adrcocirtusededescfoalçarointéspseocnttasciuléalierveé.sLqeuse raeunxderénstidqeunatssidmeenltaiCmipsojsosridbalneiselqeusi
l'enseignementsupérieur—undocu- M.Robinsonsituesonrapport d'enseignementisraéliens.Etcela lamajoritédesétudiantsn'ontpas activitésacadémiquesnormales.
mentdansl'élaborationduquel danslecontextedel'obligationfaite sanscompterlaprécarisarionqui lesmoyensdelesacquitter.Lacrise Lesdélaisd'attenteetlesferme-
l'ACPPUajouéunrôlemoteur. auxÉtatsmembresderespecterles necessedeminerlesconditionsde financièreglobaleaentraînéune turesdespointsdepassageem-
Cetterecommandationénonceles normesénoncéesdanslarecom- travaildupersonnelacadémiqueet chutedesdons,exacerbantdavan- pêchentrégulièrementlesétudiants
principesd'équitéauxquelsde- mandationdel'UNESCOde1997, quifragiliselalibertéacadémique. tageunesituationdéjàprécaire. etlesprofesseursdeserendresur
vraientêtresubordonnéeslescon- quiconsidèreledroitdupersonnel Néanmoins,laplusgrandeme- Lesconditionsdetravailduper- leurscampus.Lesétablissements
ditionsd'emploidupersonnelaca- enseignantàlalibertéacadémique nacequipèsesurlalibertéacadémi- sonnelacadémiquesontgénérale- sontforcésdefermertôtenraison
démique,lalibertéacadémique, etl'autonomiedesétablissements querésidedansledébatausein mentmauvaisesetlessalairessont desrestrictionsdedéplacements,et
laresponsabilitéprofessionnelle d'enseignementsupérieuretleur d'Israëlsurl'occupationdelaCisjor- inférieursàlanormale.Lescondi- bonnombred'étudiantsetdemem-
etl'autogestionpourlepersonnel obligationderendredescomptes danieetdelabandedeGaza.Bien tionsd'enseignementsontdifficiles, bresdupersonnelacadémiquene
académique. commedesélémentsessentielsau quedenombreuxuniversitairesis- leschargesdetravailsonténormes peuventsedéplacerd'uncampusà
Lesrésultatsdecesévaluations maintiendel'équitéetdelaliberté raélienss'exprimentlibrementsur etleseffectifssontinsuffisants.La l'autreàcausedesbarrièresdesé-
sontpubliésetdiffusésàl'échelle académique. cettequestionpolitique,uncertain rechercheetl'enseignementsont curité.Ilesttrèsdifficilepourles
internationale.Laplusrécented'en- Lerapportrévèlequelagouver- nombred'entreeux,dufaitdeleurs sérieusementfreinésparlesrestric- universitairespalestiniensdelaCis-
treelles,quiportesurIsraëletla nanceestdevenueunsujetdepré- opinionsprêtantàcontroverse,ont tionsqu'imposentlesIsraélienssur jordanied'entrerenIsraëlpoury
Palestine,aétéconduiteparDavid occupationpourlesuniversitaires étévictimesdereprésaillesinternes unevariétéd'importations,dontle
Robinson,directeurgénéralassocié israéliens.Unrapportpubliéen2001 etexternes.Danscertainscollèges matérielscientifiqueetautresoutils VoirUNn&PWffiàlapageA10
COMMENT
OPINIONS
LETTERS/COURRIER
Academicfreedom TheUCUgeneralassembly,whenfaced schildwrotein11)02.However,heneglects Boydell&Brewer,SixteenthCenturyJour-
defenceinconsistent swuitphpoarmtotthieomnottoisounppbourttdaidbosyucgogtet,stretfhuesiesdsuteo mtoymceinttaitioonnIofprfoovrimdeerdIstrhaeeliqueodtuecaatsiopanrmtionf- noafl,ScCizeneccehso,slCoavmabkri[dngoweCUnzievcehr]siAtcyaPdreessm,y
CAUTpresidentPenniStewartspeaksof shouldbedebatedandthatUieunionwould isterShulamitAloni'sJune4opinionpiece CollegiumCarolinumofMunchen,Journal
CAUT*s"mandateandroleindefendingcol- arrangeregionalmeetingswithrepresentatives inHaaretz. ofMedievalHistory,OsterreichischeAka-
leagueswhose[academic]freedomhasbeen ofbothsidestodebatetheissue. InresponsetotheNakbaLaw,Aloniwrote demiederWissenschaften,andtheUniver-
infringed"{Bulletin,October2009)andin- Itwas,andis,CAUTsviewthattheaca- aboutthe"transformationofIsraelintoa sityofToronto.Theeditorsandtheirselect-
sists,rightly,that"wemustpayseriousatten- demyisaplacewhereweshouldencourage totalitarianethnocracy."AndIincludedthe edexternalreaders,wouldnothaveagreed
tiontoeachincident,becauseeachpoten- debateofcontroversialissues,nottrytosup- quotetoshowthataZionistlongtimeKnes- topublishingmyworkhaditbeenmarked
ftioarlldyaensgteabrloiusshes...pcrheacnegdee.n"tsthatpavedieway pPreensnsiSttheewma.rt sceotmme,emwbhielreiaslsloamcealnltiinnggfowrhaatchIasrnageel.hSausrbeel-y byTdWocUtriwnialllbnleienkdertso.continueitsvigilance
Moreproblematically,shefindsinthestate- President Aloniwouldnotbesuspect,ofquestioning asmarginalgroupsassociatedwithitseek
mentofYorkUniversitypresidentMamdouh CAUT Israel'srighttoexistjustbecauseshequoted tointerfereinacademicfreedom.Neverthe-
Ssuhroeuktrhiedrieaslpeucntifvuelrseixticehsanargee"oofbibd'egaesdbtaoseend- Naivesupportfor RIsortahelsicshwilhdo?aNtotrenwdoeudltdhethceonmfaerneyncZeio—nitshtere rleescsogitniwzoeutlhdatbaettahpisprstoapgrei,attheefwoorrCkAofUTTWltoTs
noonusrleyseaatrcthh"e—cusrtoamieltmheinntgotfhaatca"dhienmtiscofmrie-e- anti-Israel conference ttohepronoem-osttaeteaotpwtoi-osnt.atesolutionanddebate qfuacaullitfyi,ewshiettahsearninatuhtehecnltaiscsrmoeomm,blearboorfotffhiece,
dom."Doessheadvocatethedisrespectful DoritNaamanrightfullycondemnstheat- Theclaimthattheconference"willshow- globaluniversitycommunity.
exchangeofideasbasedonpersonalpoliti- temptbyjewishorganizationstostifledebate caseacademicdiscoursethatismotivated, Ithinkagreaterdangertouniversities'
calpredilectionordelusion? inCanadaonthefutureofIsraelandPales- atleastinpartbyprejudice"needssolid detachedandimaginativestudyofthearts
Stewart'scalltoarmsispitchedtowards tine,adebatethatislivelyinIsrael,perhaps groundingandsupportonethatismissing andsciencesisthetendencyofCanadian
CAUFsongoingcondemnationofGary moresothanhere(Bulletin,October2009). fromFischler'sletter. andworlduniversitiestogiveprioritytodis-
Gteocohdnyoelaorgy,,mfionrishtiserinotfesrtvaetnetifoornswciitehncSeSaHnRdC BofutIshreareloawrneccoormremcetnitnsseheoiwnsgwthheypdleafnenndeedrs ADlolriiatnNceaAatmlaanntisProfessorofFilm&Media acinpdliinnetsertehsattseomfpshoacsieitzye.TUiheesperacftoirccaelsnaereedisn-
regardingaconferenceontheIsraeli-Pales- YorkUniversityconferenceaspartofawider Queen'sUniversity clinedtoseeeducationasthelearningof
tinianconflictCAUTdeemsthisproblem- efforttodenyIsraeltherighttoexistasthe arepertoireofskillsandknowledge.They
aticinterventionapoliticallymotivatedas- homelandoftheJewishpeople. Trinitydefended aretemptedtocutfinancingtodisciplines
saultonacademicfreedom. NotcontenttodiscussthereactionofJew- perceivedasnotaddressingthesegoals.Such
ersEvatenthleeacvoinnfgearseindce,ehionwqeuveesrt,iotnhaitntchleusdpeedak- iosnhoarcgaadneizmaitciofnsr,eetodoamnaalynzdetitosproespsoirbtleonefftehcets eIwmouUlnidvelirkseittyocreopmomrtenbtyoWniltlhieaTmriBnriutnyeWaeust- stohotrhtesitgrhatdeidtinoensaslrienpnroevsaetnitvseawgorrekatoefrutnhirveeart-
tahneifnotreermnaotsitolnealadbeoryicnotatmoonvIesmraeenlitatcoaidmepmoisces ompaennnmeussstofalpsuobhliigchldiigshctouarswearinninIsgr,aeml,adNaea-in a2n00d9TahnodmaonsliFnreieatdmwwawn.(cBauulLlectai/n,upSleopatdesm/ber siiatniefsatithhanofisTtWheUcofamcmulitty.menttotheChrist-
d—eim.ei.c,afmreoevdeommeonftatoceurtttaeirnlygsruopuppreosfsstchheolaacras- p1e9t0t2y,..t.hoatrtaJheowdiosxhasntadteilwloibuelradl,b"eex"cslmualslio/naanrdy/ TWCUA_RUeTpohratspadfle)g.itimateinterestinthesta- EnJdanoefFIlnanxo,ceinnchee,r"bproililnitasnto1u9t9h2oewssaacya"dTe-he
ssaitohcsloAaesudlellyefedmecotiwnnicovyittetfheayre.rtesbheaaadstgoiosCm,AoiwfsUhteTehxenstirraeonmcwaeatnldiyeodnmteairlfcoieutnabycsles—ioncogwifaei-n aboalfnylTdwyhaheinnaxsaitasrsitrshssi;oenmwoiitttmloaiiosatnkitdcohrnteeiiodstbtibiiqJenuaeesitwtehosdefpoorfeIlessiaprscraeiceeenlesscne.aentstuoarifttyiatoachngte,uo-, TTtaItunWsWwdLaoUPCfsosajlaoclnciaeondgimeeemdmsmpioitotrchftemCafeAnarnstentseaostdctdoioeaapmitniiitanneotltnelthenheoccefteouuUauannrlriilavvyfegerrri1ess9niei8gtdt0yios.em.s. mltpoehfhinieargnreegsaassnaoosodrnfi,sotnctnoinhoedoenatctryeist.snhtoteSsuhktagenhrheogtaowurllitgonoeuggdeicgsfaoennrt.fohcrmeNloraonteithtmeiipstahnhnuiegoltaohccssohcoarule-ic-sthsy
antAoicusoossaunlodnsyceciwimdaonietrgcifloeadinnnwpsdiortedifodtepUu,otnaiisciovenanedscdr,lesBuCirmditiAitycinUsgPhfrTtrobhfeodeeyeescdAcsooolmtrimetsnr,beoidfyvciItagdsoroenar-de-el-i JtsmPeoiaewolncientssoothmwifenepdireiaieosnnpdtqslaotuieabnoteateia,ennnddigdt.iownbfIoitauagiolJstt,deerxwiytbn.iesafIhabfccotsosu,tuntacatdhnete,hameewxnsefpteruratdeetuesr--iet TismttthhaaeiMnysyaeyedinasoyrasftsueifTtaashcnWaufdaslUctwuybleehtmyeaeh,ndmasvbtataehefmefrha,oustanntienwevsdroeturolsslfytidutcadyodnendonncrtotsteehsroatsnvaveeketdreon tapeosrdsiIgtevnerriatlaainewonsgnocedredtnlwopddilepsatnodchtsoerasmleei.asnrsteetvknheneelodaitwbinlyoqenuda,ingrnneyiohricinalatanontyiekoxnnop,otewhFcleltr-axa
nouncethisdangerousprecedentdespitespe- asracist itseriously. invitesalltoanopendiscussion,saying:"We
cifTichirseqiunecsotnssitsotdenocysoi.nthedefenceofschol- ligNhtasampraenc'isselcyowmhmaetntoaprpyonuennwtisttoifngtlhyehYiogrh-k thaTthTeWBrUun"evaioul-aFtresietdhmeacnormempiorttmeconntcltoudes noteheedrst'obleehaarlnftaonmdatkoelicsltaenimtsoothnoosuerwohiwcnhadnifd-
arswhoseacademicfreedomisthreatened Universityconferenceunderstandtobeits academicfreedomthatisthefoundational ferfromours,knowingthatultimatelythere
raisesthedisturbingsuspicionthatCAUTs disingenuouspremise:themeetingwillshow- bedrockoftheuniversitycommunityin isnothingthatjustifiesthembeyondeach
ongoingcallforGoodyear'sheadisitself caseacademicdiscoursethatismotivated, Canadaandinternationally."^.4)Ibelieve person'sdesireandneedandthediscursive
mAOCErRceoiUtncr-itlnerLsgearaDwfaioeemrrleeaJct&ettowGeriorslhdoSaftpKuoodlsiicethsiictszktyhanprinciple. mttaiutanrtIlieteeaainosssfatontainhdnneediportafwhrsiitttl,nhalgtebeefypxoirarnpicrcIlteseijrgiauhintetdliieiocnxsfecat.trcohetesapsocfinunrrdgoremiernnPtttaehlnseetssaifl-teuy- trfaehenseaAdsdtoriureTnsnpgdodWeroortUfsrrtteehtafsehnleeedaercirvetncisghadarseaennoncaafdeïwtvtohieefedaaechChnhov.drawirusiTntecitWrayinUtoiffcaapvilrtihoe.-ws pbJTErromeiaehndcirntdtiyiKteWcludaeesssssaPteirnernordtfnwelhsUesingoicirvhteoirfmtsaihHttieyesstdeo.r"ayredeveloped,em-
YorkUniversity from(Jewish)Israelis.Itisanotherthingal- TheinformationBruneauandFriedman
CAUTreplies taongdetahneirmofsoritpyeotopluesemoatnivaactaeddembiycprfeojruudmicteo gofatthheeriredinfvreostmifgaactuilotnyrmefelmecbtesrbsotinhtihtsedciovuerrs-e TmhicesBtraufnfeaatuT-rFinriiteydWmeasnterrepnorUtninvoertseidtythaarteawcealld-e-
bIaofsttrapatofititeorffehyeecitrcvfarrriTvcGcysCaoiuascseeO.eoihactrutannAaiupeseoorieiBrccntmnewffgecUyeeetedtpefetekosihniTorydobGnpintoreQnr-onenevhoeooddgtudfrdaicaaofweaneeiettktIabdafclnvdeeveseeuoeiyaetHdirinnrgrswsiseraaedessri'enesetalawwgoafislfopgrlslttaennetuueo,t'm.dgtamhsUsnaLsoeiiteetannkcdwadtslhniheuyidicteemtagwvrettn,thnhcitesPthghi2einccor.SaaCees5iofoswclfIcfisfuinaAsohefmhptonltorfrasofieeenlaUcycfetnouerSrtiniriltnltTss-lnosSe,idotdcetsaianieoHdaiftstefYcnsnvsflemhrcrRuoegteipiaennatnrkCrhnioorhododfekfiganetrsfoeuiashsbfsrreaUmtntsptlieoanpetiecnarheccrteircvceeetoae'eevtctessinsrunedhpoeerom--rseoendnue-lde--r- jdioatpfmaIRSMvNRteoorsececcesaonacsrgrGrThanpadtraivapaIesohdnihyeteenIhinovaosleiaIetircaletëtvamyzyedlafëUelhoaim"taynmrlcefrmteccminFooreiisavaooaiUgFgnmofelmstorceihywrfnrciinrbostbrsstehhegvdcaioolhberonettahianreueeeoeydrsltgrndrsndPeoaieamie,dcelrimostnxaweaentn.seaipbapinpsastsdtertntstlBl.ateegichohoutctidnuafroethoageteudaucesfmhsibslastoapeYtledmitmiaoheshepeimerbiafataagkfetUpisilionssanUrotgs,"ratginhtentsindietheiocevteenocafYseahdiflparetopp"ttisrrrgNraaaitaoenriaskcstes-tstokyuIsmppUiutsr,aonuocpohrernionosaenct-snbsoehe--lf TsarbTihpaBC"stdpotitibiuieefhhrmatsAveWzhlssrrTfLyueeoeTnztefcaaiUchnca,yBlUoarshskiWerueiesnriTiaeed,lnfoypvaeslssUlewpgattaixuuetpeirll.paoidpigoltrhllooravnneaeifveglehfeyterdnarndineee.syottcxicacsrifdchututmpseSseidosorelooteonao,Fegretltlrcfncnnaymrdqhtuim,tetrttaoanueihcmudhtsoyirilsoydaeneP.elfmresliwid:eayacarmiedereTmncnfoenenWorphianhacvixdguednrrhcetiihnenptdauaieTnaioirieihlcnorSgnvnihsttWrentamstetycaliifrtatlre'hoeqarycoeihefssnwansTuevctrnepiraindluteeaimswcotstroooysrsdayre.oi3tfmrttcleotecr0aeihEenaamaimodiskosasdcvlnincyinnp.enseaeere"cctadhaacchtnuaelnadrstaoneahdfrruriscensrhidlasfrtseohskmsiooresiehniOteieazgurowieohdrcdslxcueesnoaneduattnpes-nrsbaovgoce.-yme-eh- qOpb"MassfdpaacdiUWpikl.sutielnyoeaStennneeelearpsil.fssotaosmdmml,armlisvostptwattiiibriieiewwie-thllsteefncnlcroeiootseemietermfesentrneecsodadifmnvaebGhoaspdrcogtlanernoioettaahoymdnenndeaudthensrnbnitematcn'ei,esadpdsosubpfsarawsdpisafaocalno"rdarocoiocrfrrheirpnoaenerfsamyoiaaa,vetusaFcmrdmibimnoimynparteoaitaneeppnfidoeo,sepdndcndctsetmna,ts"lloutcistheersisyytepschai,on,cetaimocsrtl"eaetemcdb"halinsiscitpsliofeemafnlccdoaotialecirmrunocn.rifsnryo.n.aofm"teonan.dvre"naamdcolarnsieey[ioptssswta,eindtnfaIotadeuiininatdreotfayi"tpnsagtttosmedeshidRnrsatiulcmtt.omdoiecitneoclsetaasnsaTauimiaoonnnchtcctcpdpthrwycatntceeieioaorleseldmeyppdppnlwe:ecbJmoladlsetirac-uetboeoeiperi"nautnomojofdtssmebcddathibWage,hguritmwahsvnoklcneafsltsjrohrehuftiidetpuiarrhr,eaiinnzsaCetiJsepeTvcbcmtgheiCrictTiepee,oWrhrseemittehtcsarniideysUiuotdecycunataso-s'ovihrn'iassootch.svsaeom-tc-sfae-tme,yfho]-de,f
BUbfronoiriytociasnonh,tcatoocuvTanehdtreeemritpfisaaccrattlb,lioesytghcteeohdteUtcnaUilovlCferfUIsosrirnataeyelnv.aenardcacCadolellmleiedgce AoemxfsyiasetcwvaoiismddmteehnreecneethffaohormeryetultsfaoernsoddmeanoaqyfultoIehstterteaeJereilwLnticohslrehuddrpeRiedgoohtpithln-eto." amrseeesacntrotecgahnadinyizdneccdfolrumtedhmeieisd.tCoTmmo.hleuenOmtupbrutiobaslaciUhcsonhaliedavrereslmrysioifcptemydeyerPtsraerhcse-sah,-ve CaoWhfnordrtishdtse,co"BhfioabGlnloaeddr,.stt"hhhia-eptewt"hdAaloklleltyepalacauhctiehnogur,nitdlaeetarirvtneihneagn,dditrhteircnutktiihofnnugl,
Therightsoftheworld'spoorandpowerlessextendfromthedarkestprisoncelltothehighestmountain.AtUBCyou'llfind
professorswhohavechairedtheUNCommitteeAgainstTorture,workedforAboriginalrightsandevenbeennameda"Hero"
bytheUSgovernmentforworkagainsthumantrafficking.Medicalstudentsworkforfaireraccesstodrugs,journalismstudents
givevoicetotheoppressed,andlawstudentsfightforthewrongfullyconvicted.Fromourvantagepoint,there'snohighercalling.
w
A6CAU7BULLETININOVEMBER2009
Never before have CAUT NEWS ACTUALITÉS
members had such power!
Rocher Speech Available Online
Relax and let Canada's leading
lenders compete for the opportunity A
to fund your mortgage. COPYofGuyRocher'srecent ships,conflictsofinterestandcon-
speechtoCAUTCouncilis flictsofvalues.Politicalandecono-
•Wetakecareofallthe Mortgage Rates* availableforviewingonline. micpowerscanbetheguardians
mortgageshoppingdetails In"TruthasaValueandaPrac- andprotectorsofacademicfree-
foryou. Variable 2.25 tice:APerpetualIssueinPost-Sec- domoritsenemies'1andwhilein-
•fWreomfiandwyioduetchheoibceestofdelaelnders. 2lyyeeaarr 22..9314 doCenAmdTiaJcrTysAEwd2au0rc0da9tisDoaiynss,t"itnhtgahuteiaswhcieanddneeAmrciaoc-f sattanikteauttoitvoeenmsrptsoshrobhuiyljdapcorkewskeinsrtowianlllteed"rugetseitl,si"tatraoid--
•Personalservice. 3year 3.41 staffassociationsmusttakerespon- ministratorshavenotalwaysbeen
Specializedknowledge. 5year 4.09 sibilityforsafeguardingtheculture abovethefrayoflate.
Unbiasedadvice. 7year 4.60 oftruth. "Authoritiesandmanagersof
"Truthisthefundamental,essen- ouracademicinstitutionsarenot
lOyear 5.40 tial,ontologicalandepistemologi- alwaysthebestpromotersandde-
TheMortgageCentre clldyiaessldicsgvi,eap,lleiuvlneeeersaoyrrntnehiswitnhsngi,g,"chtRoh,ouacrtihnwsetecrhiesceaanfilicdlne.aksl"naaTonnhwade-- TaRrvouactihhleaarbslSepaeaeVtcawhlwu2we0.0ac9na.udptda.fc.Par/aucptlicoeadiss/ Rtsfaheoyenc,dhmepieresrsrshiosaaofpindtss,he—taihrdeIdaiwmcnoaaguidlne"dimtmiivicssesnsoittnaouefnrfeso—,f"to
We workforyou,notthe lenders. greatnessofthemissionofourcol- forintelligenceandtruth.Itistheir ofourassociationsandunionsto
legesanduniversitiesliesinthepur- responsibility,andthatofacademic protectindependenceandfreedom
1.888w.2w16w.7.77c0aexut.t22.7cFaa»/1.m88o8.r21t6g.7a77g1eEm_ailcjeilnlcrtairg@beel/lnet.ca stfuooidrtamoysf',starsnuotdchietathnyedarsoefsipnterctutitmhfseosrinptaarslutlt,ht.hceoIilnr- sptraeBffsu,etrthvoeefuialtfdiadlnlsdtthhaiasstsre"orloteu,irt.d"peofste-nsdeciot,n- rsioincgriheettsyte.oa"rfcrheeainndvotlevacehmienngtainndouorur
legesanduniversitiesarethetangi- daryinstitutionsandprofessions
ble,livingrepresentativesofrespect existinthemidstofpowerrelation- VersionfrançaiseàlapageA12.
CAUT Censure: First Nations U Deux collèges d'Alberta accèdent
T(hNeovFeirmsbteNrat2i0o0n8s}.UnCiveenrssuitryeomfeCaannsadtahahtaCsAbUeTenhacsencsounrceldudbeydCtAhUaTtaCouunnic-il au statut d'université
versityboardandadministrationhavebreachedoneorseveralofthefun-
damentalprinciplesofacademicfreedomandgovernancewhichCAUT
believestobeindispensabletotheproperfunctioningofauniversity.It IEgouvernementdel'Albertaa L'universitéoffreàl'heureactuelle versitaire.Lechangementdenom
salosnoabmleeasnusggtehsetuinoinvserfsriotymbCoAaUrTdafonrdaardemsionliusttiroantioofnthheavdeisrpeusties.tedallrea- RoyàaclondfeérCéalaguarCyoleltègaeuMCoolulnètge sdeeptbapcrcoaglaruarmémaetsetme«nlaesntétauudigarnatsde càrlit'UdnaivnesrsliatéliGgrnaéentdeMancotErweaénvosl'uin-s-
CensureisanoticetoallmembersofCAUTthattheyshouldinformthem- GrantMacEwand'Edmontonle diplômésaurontmaintenantaccès tion»,affirmeM.Byrne.«Mac-
selves,intheirdealingswithacensuredinstitution,oftheissuesinvolved statutd'universitéles3et24sep- àuneplusgrandevariétédepro- Ewanoffremaintenantcinqpro-
aaoinrcpcptaeohtpiettnectnaedmnnesyanuctdraisesd.taeitmInniactcpicaoercntnoisnocurfurlehaerrode,nnouacnuecirsavedtarehtsiamattiyc,cmiesngntohsatftuftrobeaeadrceoucfanefispevktreeerisddnivtbniyyot,taaattincoodenasncnstocuoterpsettpodeak tUneimvberresirteésMpeocutnitveRmoeynatl gssiorduaelnmitgmnedéseDald''vaéistdsuodHceyisatttsieounnpréadruuicehpu,errelsseop»nr,-éa- gndaornmasbmrmleeesseasntdneséusepcsreepàmtiivbeelnreircd.y'cNaleuo,gumseetnrctée-er
administration.Academicdisciplinaryassociationsareencouragedto Levice-recteuràl'enseignement, nelacadémiquedeMountRoyal pondonsauxbesoinsàmesure
refusetocarryadvertisementsfororholdeventsatcensuredinstitutions. RobinFisher,adéclaréquelare- dansunedéclarationfaiteautélé- quenousévoluonssanstoutefois
Apnvoecarccateadsneastmniidtiyncafussonstriiavsfaetfrseseeifmttfptiolerlotsesymueetndnodteactroofnacvteiuhnnnesciuvdeeirrtseshpiueattrybee.ounanAorddtdevcreaarncrterdiinseasdedummrieinenntitahssretefroCaartAsikpUooeTnsdiBottutiololtsnehustepi-n RmcoootnyinafalidcsesoafmniemcreetéoufpnfoiivuceirerlsulienteédeeésctMooulenunqrutéie,l jpoouu«rJrnualsleqsudd'eàipCplBrôéCms.eénst,deilacoéltléègdeisffiecnile mcihsDasnirgoeenc.ronl»n'easîstenqcueemlêamdéecidseionnotdree
noratCAUT'scareerboardwww.Academicwork.ca. àseshumblesdébutsen1911en généraldepoursuivredesétudes seconcentrerdeplusenplussur
CooffAttUhhTeeraaesccsaoodgcneiimaztieicso,ns,toafhfofcwoaeunvrdesres,,tutthdhaaettntccseennastsuucrreeen,siaumnrpdeodstehusneivasearbnsucirttiideoesnn.soItansissmotechmieabvteieredsw tacacnLuteeqiulm'laiannistdtia1tt7u9tdieoéntMumodéiutanhnottsd.iRsotyealpraivtéoeu,- sad-'utu-pinélirvpiereréuscriiestséé.dn«aenLmseoldneisofuiuenviepvaeaurssisvttéaértisutta»-, glto'rueatnmsemeniegscnoenmmteeinnnatunaatnutàpd'uronefmfdriiierprdlceôysmcelperoou-
withit,isnecessarybothtopublicizetheunsatisfactoryconditionswhich tefoischangéaufildesannéeset blementlesprogrammesquenous àuncertificatn'apasétéprisein-
eaixndimtsihtneiinsCtatrhnaeatdicoienannsthuaarcteadtdheuenmyiivscehrocsuioltmydmauannddihtetyro.epteorsstuaanddeatrhdescneonwsuwrieddelbyoaacrcdepatnedd «urinreivnleerfnsaiioLtémnao»vu,asenxtéptmliioêqnmsueedeMdv.'eenFnuissahceuqrn.ueé- olàafflr'reéoccnhsoe;nlnlcaeeisnqasutaeinoccneealldaeecanhioantsnrigeeq,puo'csa'ieutsiton clsauolnqtusaetisidtoénirsoéne,mtemfnaeLinree«ruDndaeesfxatlaalmsuecdnreepucrsooensr--
Sanction de blâme UPNC «Nousavionsdéjàétabliunegamme regarddesautresétablissements pectifrigoureuxavantdedéter-
: deprogrammesconférantungrade d'enseignement» miners'ils'agissaitvraimentd'un
LPereCmoinèsreeisldnaetilo'nAsCPdPuUCaainmapdoasé(UuPnNeC)saennctnioonvedmebrbelâ2m0e08à.l'LU'nAivCePrPsiUtépdreensd entounvoeulsleavsitrouncstumriesdeengpoluavceerunnaence UniversitéGrantMacEwan préaasctdiaonnsdleasbéotnundieandtisr,ecdtuionc.orLpas
unetellesanctionlorsqu'elleconclutqueleconseiletl'administrationde universitairechargéedel'encadre- Pourleprésident-directeurgénéral professoraletdupersonnelaété
l'universitéencauseontvioléunouplusieursdesprincipesfondamen- mentdesquestionspédagogiques.» deMacEwan,PaulByme,l'attribu- despluspositives.»
tauxdelalibertéacadémiqueetdelagouvernancequel'ACPPUestime Autoriserl'écoleàs'appelerdoré- tiondustatutd'universitévientélar- Lechangementdenom«n'est
imlenesdnitrs,epceeotnmsqamubaelnedcsaetasiumobênosmnerfsaoinscoconntsnieaoibnllneeestmeafndotmrimdnu'ilusénterséattpaiabornlilos'nsAteCmPrePenUptopudos'uesrnésatesoisugutnreees-r nc'aevsatnrteclo'nUnnaiîvterresidteéfMaoçuonnjtudRiocyiaelu,se gqiurelal'péetrasbpleicstsievmeendtuofpfurbeliàcl'shuerurcee qtruaevaillarqeuceonnnoauisssaacnccoempolffiiscsioelnlseddeu-
lerèglementdudifférend. sacroissancerécente,estimeM.Fis- actuelleetcequ'ilaengendrédepuis puispasmallongtemps»,aditau
daDvaaenncssullneeqmuéetêlambelelilestselememupersn,rtelfc'rAoaCmpPpmPéaUndtd'rueanndsbelmâesmt'ieàn,ftosorumuresrl,seseasuprmmoeobmlmbèermneetssdàuenl'taorvraiiigstienre hnpeeorlp.,ul«dauTtoicuoosnrpléestsupmdrieoafmnebtsresoesrsoanldtueàtpdle'erosrlio-an- qdui'a«inltNasoaiulcscyueaaivloclienlssaefspari4tè0sn0odpserep4mr0ieeuarvnses.sétu- Elm'idaqmsuoseonc,tiJoaentriJoronyudrZnudarilplel.resroensnpeolnsaacbaldeé-de
delasanction.Plusparticulièrement,lesmembresdupersonnelaca- gined'untelsuccèsetdoivents'en endéveloppantdepuislongtemps
démiquesontinvitésànepasaccepterdeposteàl'établissementainsi féliciter.» desolidescursusdeniveauuni- EnglishonpageA10.
sanctionné,àdéclinerdesinvitationsàparlerouàparticiperàdescon-
férencesquis'ytiennent,etàrefusertouthonneuroudistinctionqui
peuventleurêtreofferts,Lesassociationsdisciplinairesuniversitaires
sroénttabIlnivsistéeemsenàtrseafnuscetriodn'naénnoouncd'eyrtleensirédveésneamcteinvittsésq.uiOnaudreonmtanlideeuàégale- Vingt ans après la tragédie
mentauxmembresdupersonnelacadémiquedel'universitéfrappéed'un
dbnialsnâtsmraestiodon'naBpdupelulyleaetirnnélceeetssessfuifrtoérstodsn'eusxnietrrecèwégwslewpm.oetunrrta.vcaoLin'lvAaaCciPnaPcdUreemrileqefuuceso.encrsaeaildle'seatnoflnf'oranedcsmei-r TeJ6ded2é5ceamnsb,reMa1r9c89L,éupninhe,omamfaeit anianlsiitéqsu'féumnienliinsteesdequdéibxé-cnoeiufsepserqsuoin- gDaensisaéssàoctiraatvieornsslefépmaiynsidneessvoenitlloére-s,
d'emploiderétablissementsouslecoupd'unetellesanction. irruptionàl'Écolepolytechnique faisaientcarrièredansdesprofes- desmarchesetdesactescommé-
aLu'xACmPePmUbrreecsondnuaîptecresrotnenselleafcaarddéeamuiqquueeeltaapurxocéétduudiraentdsedbelsâmuneiviemrpsoitsées dauetMoomnattriéqaule,.aOrumvréadn'tunleffuseiuldsaenmis- slaiiotnésgnaolnemtreandtittiuoenrn.ellesetqu'ilvou- méodruactaitfisf.sLe'taapupxuireasusxouprrcoesgrpaomumres
sanctionnées.Ellecroittoutefoisqueleblâmeetlessanctionsquiysont touteslesdirections,ilaabattuqua- Les14femmesassassinéesdans réduirelaviolenceàl'égarddes
srfcuoaenaniitvcssteeaoarinncslthfieéoteseatrisqmrluese'iroadndeamutxuiinnsxCiétasecnntneoatrsradsdtmaaaie.ionsrnserdsleeepcsocouuennrsniuvréeeetrsnasdbiprltaeéirsspslue'ebnemlneicsnqaetuumsesbseqlule'eeitsdlsepcooolnunadrticptloeiemordmnsesuuvaoniidnarseuardttielése- tp—oerraMzsvaeoarnnfcnteemLdséme—pesis9eneefdteocbmnrlomneyeseasrsiétletatqrue4m'iiohzlreotna.m'uamtvreaeisst cwSbeaatrr-mdaAa,msDesaAaaincgunrnleeeL-aéuMAtlaantrin,eiineBetaALrTneubnrmaecaro-yatM,tKaelrA,uinceBnzainEreid-k- fnslaoeenmvmtiemoneeltnsesgnascf'geeéésdcstéoriànanttlmreeneesttiltfperisreéo.fuveLinmenmscteiegsaro.umuxevEesnàre-
pasétéadmisàl'écoledegénieà Widajewicz,GenevièveBergeron, 1991,legouvernementcanadiena
causedespolitiquesd'«actionaffir- HélèneColgan,MaudHaviernick, proclaméle6décembreJournée
Subscriber Services: [email protected] mniasttiesveet»lesuorustseynmupeatshipsaarntless.fAéumim-o- MMiacrhyèsleeLRaigcahnairèdr,e,NaMtahralyiseeCLreoctleaairu, ntiaotniocnoalnetrdeelcaovmimoélmeoncreatfiaiotneeatudx'ac-
mentdesamort,ilportaitsurlui etSoniaPelletier. femmes.
CANADA'SVOICE Bulletin unenotecontenantune diatribe Cesfemmessontdevenuesdes
FORACADEMICS contrelesférninistesqui,selonlui, symboles,desreprésentantestragi- EnglishonpageA7.
luiavaienttoujoursgâchélavie, quesdel'injusticecontrelesfemmes.
NOVEMBRE2009|BULLETINACPPUA7
1 ACTUALITÉS
In the Massacre's Wake Censured Administrations
^XTTH25V-EyNeaTrY-oyledarMsaracgoLeopninDeecw.al6k,ed WHiédlaèjneewiCcozl,gaGne,neMvaiuèdveHBaevrigeernriocnk,, in the UniteMd StaPtes
intoMontreal'sÉcolePolytechni- MaryseLaganière,MaryseLeclair,
qbeuOgeanwncieathsihnaosoistdeiemnigt-hsaepurstecoehmodaoutlri,icnLgreiwpflhiein.ech MainTcdhhèSelosneeiRawiocPehmlalerendti,ebrN.eacthaamleiesCyrmobtoelasu INVAEsSsoTcIiGaAtiToInONoSfUbnyivtehresiAtmyePrriocfeasn- finrsotimtuatcicoenpstoinlgonagppaosiinttrmeemnatintsoaonn
AptamctaHfhmhc1rlohianiricae3easreemsTsuconndiossmsosemhreir,etsaueptuphi-lehucsritifnrobMeirooynde.eeropcan1femidesfina4merpLn:od"wrltotiadegewareeottnepofreQodhhtincefiteuioinomLihc:tnds1ezreteeuueek4Ameebirplmbewnnlaiwrnabealyfntbns.ioeetocyigewlnlifmvmi,at-giaoehewnhneeMemnmoaetAodivaasnntehennecrmerddilwtnhdaiaeiiisiiegehnsnftenionettudesgdnodwEemnw"ddiasiSmiaiafntcwnnsnnopo-1shjiaonhdun9osutlnroerobtirhodn'l-seeet,d-.-d j—pmweaWgnapratulrhgeioirrnoossoeasrzt.ontdmtmviotemriumNeiTneuadceApaensfhngrencntscotnivce.ttrii.ciaterwgiaasogsieIelrcoonaplndertansitmrguwop,olon1eoocrsaos9mcaevrnDesstn9talseen.a1ietwardrd,aVynohicunoBnitentmvhcmmoooahaieieeeftltceelondsniehonRlcvCvptnuer.ieDaeafrcnsenosemnenetoaclWmddcerasgee—eoAayedemrnrgmamcidamaboiaogeeelamefnbrraimnnsgineaaioscna'nsrngunras--otspoditcnm6-v-de-- rvsiatdAspnAp(1ainosihreeamuc9tlsrzoevidTmrlet4aesafeayyihpi0srtedvit,bioocisliiuaresSyofssatracedmntbiiefecenatlsioloAarionhndnenostcnAeswegtcafeoneaUhlemCimtFlaitisdidPooiecrnazcsoolwprln,feetnbhlmbmwuteeodedieyswbdrthndgaeo.lmhptibeaeafroniaeirhsdevsvsadmintaPupelihAunrgnrcaanoecsaptiaasenAtigdswe.n2tntinpdocno0iAdoldtficsuvro0neohpoUiUirhgnsrTseloanreao)oPeeltistlto.owsganviahefhftemeuopeodeointrtnrprearohne-hgcretnam-eoaaoth,-f--,e- iacatcwfsnfaileenhsfconunTodPteuntdisclllhtettuatoeaeuysrchdtnt,eeiiomhttonbfitehegninguhset.oriitehstsvvmlaTeshitieldhpgseri"rimeiiisaanntcbitsntsdiiniedtilamfdiincooiiitsmtgenceenuty.aentsiirlbistosaloouhnofttyneraofrirneutraovatropedumndionpuooeoonimofpnefanf"neossinitttnmcshiitnente-tphrot-uhres-thaeet- ppS3ttdttdAaifsatohri4ioethenslAfetsr6Teonefimes5cupuNkhUecodeeo)rne.rnaeeiPlsieqmrWscsnlwasnub.cclsefiefadnoidr,eeuasedoldrfdeotprrgcireotWeteuacisofmlimpasieoscfi;aoylrssnniaeitnAo.nttgohsdifidsthonatiAoorepaAe.itonfSdneopmUnbigAocfpamtislnotPaetsohUcicconsisoceigteenPvnas(nafrp,e,ulsi5ctttrrnre0yiimltedeDdg0orteeoseaiet-nehcanCdveodp1amuvtimnett0aoemascdihxt12srsma,aiusnk20tttssaciuie0,aatemtltosc10s,nn,hetnhb4t5tcerd-nfoeti-eyaro--hse-r
ADranieganuelatu,ltA,nBnairebaTurracoKtltuec,znBiakrbara VersionfrançaiseàlapageA6. tbheres,putbhleicprtohfaetsusnisoantiastflaacrtgoer,yacnodn- bneorrsdfooersmietmabffeerctshtihepiinndAivAiUduPa,l t(imoansnywhoitchherasrheasvtiellbuenednerrecmeonsvuerde
ditionsofacademicfreedomand rightsofmembersattheinstitu- fromthelistafterimprovingtheir
tenurehavebeenfoundtoprevail tioninquestion. practicesandprocedures)."'Academe
Socrates in the Boardroom aptlatcheedseoinnsotriturteiomnosv.eNdamfreosmatrheis coMnseimdbeererdsitoftoAbAeUtPheihravduetyo,ftienn cviotlatuimoen"irnefwehriscthoaAAreUpPo'rstaAbcoaudtemthee
-FromPAGEA14 Idobelieve...theyhavetohave cnueanlsumreeetliisntgb.yvoteofAAUP'san- othredeprritnociipnldeiscavtieoltahteeidr,stuopproefrrtaionf institutionappears.
morepower.Idon'tbelieveinthe
tobetransferable,andthatthey democracyargumentandbigcom-
wainlyltfieenlddttoheeyxcdeelciidneprteotttyurmnutchheir mwihtoteefso.u"nTdhtohseetsiumcehtoassuGbimdidtenrse- AAUP List ofCensured Administrations
haTnhdasttios?nodoubtpartofitBut stheeairrchinsttoittuhteioRnsAmEakwehiplaertriucnunlairnlgy INSTITUTIONNAME ACADEMECITATION YEAR
Goodallandthemanyuniversity inspiringrolemodels. GroveCityCollegePennsylvania March1963(15-24) 1963
leadersshecitesplacetheempha- Inmakingsuchapowerfulcase FrankPhillipsCollegeTexas December1968(433-38) 1969
siselsewhere. forleaderswhohave"acquired ConcordiaSeminaryMissouri April1975(49-59) 1975
Anumberofthemesrecur.One adeep,inherent,instinctiveun- MurrayStateUniversityKentucky December1975(322-28) 1976
iscredibility."Beingagoodscholar," derstandingofthecorebusiness," StateUniversityofNewYork August1977(237-60) 1978
PG"uomloeidatzanelsrltpihrsaittzoeIlwdcibannyneloronoiekniatnhtNeeorevbyieeel.w"eoer, YlGeeotnogdteahletlorpeorwuearsrerdnestssecaaarnscuhbbesutnaeinvqteuriasalilltyicehsa.l- NPhioicflhlotilhpsseCCUoonlimlvmeeurgseniitMtyaysosfCaoAclhrlukesagenetstass MMaayy119987081(29037--9182)) 11998708
Anotherisexpertknowledge."Be- substantial. YeshivaUniversitynewyork August1981(186-95) 1982
causeIamanacademic,"another TakethecaseoftheRockefeller AmericanInternationalCollegeMassachusetts May-June1983(42-46) 1983
intervieweesays,"Iamdrivenbythe UniversityinNewYork,whichhas MetropolitanCommunityCollegesMissouri March-April1984(23a-32a) 1984
academyandthedevelopmentof beenledsince2003bySirPaul TalladegaCollegeAlabama May-June1986(6a-14a) 1986
ideasandknowledge.Itismybusi- Nurse,theBritish-bornNobellau- PontificalCatholicUniversityofPuertoRico May-June1987(33-38) 1987
ness.Itisnotpossibleforsomeone reate.Therewerecrucialmoments HussonCollegemaine May-June1987(45-50) 1987
esxttaenrdnathlist.o"tAhethaicraddiemmpyorttoanutndfearc-- sianytsh,ewihnestnitu"ittiotno'sokhivsetorryy,clGeovoedrall SHoilultshdeaalestCeorlnleBgaeptMiiscthiTghaenologicalSeminary MMaayy--JJuunnee11998898((3259--4353)) 11998898
toristhesignallingeffect:puttingan people,withdeepexpertiseinthe NORTHCAROLINA
hvcaatleihoclrgaAasthniidhs-cteeffeysilml'ywnylsiaomioclrpnrrlegaiiaadtnslss,hsccsuevhhateatoaanllirinudacsgdereastsctr.,rhosduee-catnbirbhedaoeoasllurleRaetyrAomtt.fEoehG,esvooistcuoaahentdg-ei-e-r wipswrfleoohaylrmoceokeevu.ka"tnonphtfueetrtswech.tietehhnTseatchtimhfeoisyaclplaalawrrresikenrsatesotw,htcoethuooeslmpadoeimncfeeaklsnyd TDBCNLhaloeDoelIaramStrtnTaCikhRamsICtoCLGoohTrrinloeenOlleCdFeinCoagcivCletiUOlyUlnLeMnliUgCaievMeovseBesCmrNIraosmeAscliubihtlrtnyueyaisgsCeetoaktfylastiAosfCmuooterlnhrliieaCcgaearoMlairnayland MMSMMMaaeaaapyyyyyt-----eJJJJJmuuuuubnnnnneeeeeer-11111O99999c99999t21233o(((1(b32445e77264r-----434561129349)))))89(27-40) 111111999999999999223230
glceioavnsistnegiqnulaeesandmceuer,cshimnaotsreientdhpeaodswoehrrand—ot",athnoefd McmaiatstistoinhoenwwroiftReeTri.ismRzeeispsraHoiTdgiuhmceeersdEdHwuiictgahhtekirionnEd.dupe-r- BSUneainvveaedrnisnciatthyCooCflollBelrgeiegdegseoopufotArhrttCCaaornnondleicnDateisciugtnGeorgia JMNMaaoanyvyu-e-aJJmruubynne-eeFre-11bD99re9u9ca34er((my63b752e--0r4706051))(95913-(5347)-45) 2111099909993544
BenningtonCollegeVermont March-April1995(91-103) 1995
January-February1998(70-75) 1998
AlaskaPacificUniversity May-June1995(32-39) 1995
St.BonaventureUniversitynewyork July-August1995(65-73) 1996
NationalParkCommunityCollegeArkansas May-June1996(41-46) 1996
SaintMeinradSchoolofTheologyIndiana July-August1996(51-60) 1997
MinneapolisCollegeofArtandDesignMinnesota May-June1997(53-58) 1997
BrighamYoungUniversityUtah September-October1997(52-71) 1998
UniversityoftheDistrictofColumbia May-June1998(46-55) 1998
LawrenceTechnologicalUniversityMichigan May-June1998(56-621 1998
JohnsonandWalesRhodeisland May-June1999(46-50) 1999
AlbertusMagnusCollegeConnecticut January-February2000(54-63) 2000
CharlestonSouthernUniversitysouthCarolina January-February2001(63-77) 2001
UniversityofDubuqueiowa September-October2001(62-73) 2002
MeharryMedicalCollegeTennessee November-December2004(56-78) 2005
Make Protecting Academic VUinrigvienrisaitSytaotfethUeniCveurmsbietyrlandsKentucky MMaaryc-hJ-uAnpreil2020050(54(79-96-2)113) 22000055
Freedom part ofyour legacy. OBausrtyLradUyniovferHsoiltyyCWraosshsinCgotlolnegeLouisiana JMaanrcuha-rAyp-rFielbr2u0a0r7y(2100067-(16200-)68) 22000077
UniversityofNewOrleansLouisiana May-June2007(74-80) 2007
LoyolaUniversityNewOrleansLouisiana May-June2007(88-100) 2007
TheHarryCroweFoundationasksyoutoconsidermakinga TulaneUniversityLouisiana May-June2007(101-108) 2007
bequesttothefoundationtohelpdefendacademicfreedomand CedarvilleUniversityOhio May-June2009(58-84) 2009
scholarshipinCanada. NNiocrhtohllIsdaSthaotCeoUlnlievgeersityLouisiana NMoavye-mJbuenre-2D0e0c9e(m8b5e-r922)008(60-69) 22000099
Email:[email protected] HarryCrpwe StillmanCollegeAlabama March-April2009(94-101) 2009
www.crowefoundation.ca
A8CAUTËULi[TinINOVEMBER2009
BOOKSHELF
COIN DES LIVRES
An
Enlightening Self-Portrait of Isaiah Berlin
Isaiah Berlin inthemostironical,hostilemannerimaginable.Hesaid,'Here
Enlightening:Letters 1946-1960 wehavethePaganiniofthelectureplatform'—thatsortof
ma thing;wentoninthisstyle...forsomethingliketwelvemin-
HenryHardy&JenniferHolmes,eds.London,UK: utes...Thisratherrattledme:Iwasnervousanyway.Ihad
Chatto&Wlndus,2009;880pp;ISBN;9-780-701178-8-95, fortypages,Icouldn'tbegintogetthroughthem,andhalf
BhyarWdIcLoLvIeArM£3B5R.UNEAU wkbieangydasInogrfoetpaemdoyipsnlegel,ofnHieantysoeanaktte—ontcaalelltfitrzhzoeyms,eIepasecarhwsopPnaosgpeps,eitrat,innRdgottbhhbeeirenw,sh,oalnaledl
tSITYpeoplehavecriedforcenturiestoexplain thingendedintotaldisaster."(fromaninterviewofBerlin
tootherpeoplewhattheydo.Untilrecently,oneuse- withLondon-basedjournalistMichaelIgnatieffbeforepub-
•m^Jfillmethodwastowriteletters,sometimestolaypeo- licationofIsaiahBerlin:ALifein1998).
ple- usuallyfamilymembers,sometimestocolleagues,or s Hewasassailed,asmostofusareatonetimeorother,by
secularorreligiousrulersandleaders,ortogreatorwealthy self-doubt("Iamlittlemorethanadabbler"),bythesense
peopleinneedof"enlightenment"Thisvolumeisacase thatheproducedtoolittle(aridiculousideainBerlin'scase),
inpoint andbythedepressingpossibilitythathis"energeticandex-
InIsaiahBerlin'sselectedcorrespondence,ofwhichtwo haustingteaching"ofundergraduatesmaynothavelead
offourprojectedvolumeshaveappeared,wehavetheletters totheirtotaltransformation.Andyet,asmostofusdo,he
ofastudent(theopeningsectionofLetters1928-194-6)and wentahead.
thecorrespondenceofalifelongacademic,amanwhosein- Foruniversityteachersandresearchers-bedevilledby
fluentialgalaxyoffriendsandacquaintancesspannedthe managersandbotheredbyadministratorswhocaremore
worldandthecentury.Theeditingisimpeccable,theindex- aboutoutputthanthebestinterestsoftheacademy—and
ingandreferencingalmostfaultless,andtheproductionstan- badgeredbyill-informedgovernments—Berlin'scorre-
dardsarehigh.Weareleftthereforetocontemplatenotthe ISAIAH BERLIN spondenceisareminderthatourproblemsarenotnew,
form(whichisexcellent),butratherthecontentofBerlin's andthatthecaresoftheprofessoriatehavenotchanged
epistolarylife. muchinthepastcentury.
Berlin'sstudentcareercoincidedwiththebeginningof Enlightening In1953,BerlinwasstillafellowofAllSoulsCollege,a
theGreatDepression.From1932,asanOxforddonand kindofShangri-Laforacademics.Arecurringproblemin
eventuallyacollegehead,hebecameknownasafluent thelifeofthecollegewasthechoiceofahead,decidedby
serpteya,kienrclounditnhgehhiisstLoarkyeoofnidaecaasd,etmhieccforneceedpotuma,lalnidmitastorfusltibe-d LETTERS 1946-1960 ebleeccatimoenhbeyatdheducruirnrgentthefeplelroiwosdocfotvheerceodllbeyget.hJisovhonluSmpea,rraonwd
publicfigureduringandafterthewar.Hehadeasyentry Berlin'sdescriptionsofhisendlessconsultationswithfellows
totheworldsoftheRothschilds,oftheAmericanSupreme EditedbyHenryHardyandJenniferHolmes andpunctiliouscommitmenttodueprocessmakeforan
Court,oftheBritishdiplomaticcorps,andyetalsoofordi- informativeread.Thiswas,afterall,anapproachtouniver-
naryeducatedfolk.AlleagerlytunedintohisfamousBBC sitygovernancewithnoobviousparallelsintheacademic
cwtrAWiracaofmbpfpscntnllbtbtmecemeo1saieifunlieatOolcioAaehtunoaoeroohuotnlxef9lenraattergxdTrtnaxnelbiaamyceatdcHtuirn,fl6scWactethe,.jnk-elntnltulMfryhdmisdet0sletoniotsgleevtfrBohiimtetoBctsifoiyuoesdeofreoreuplrrapeanidocnarrheo,eodiersom!sedrfcnystgrnmiieresaornrueeretnaynfogaaepscbhedptdmraTinhlacyrtsousaluerbstnptnrtdabeootrnofaluoi,eihiiltnirea,bleco,eehsosdlrherwynllEaoitodoiannnaiMedycnldlikm1iliyeteiooesontrentkdsptBgbsr.isonetawo9oevawtrretunannereche:.iYnsuhtaeniga.ctigen7cwhhntnemnwairndkpoees.eidnttiohnmritaoaaai5etshrnrlwstakafrn"rsst-PansilatuahglvisttitoIOiamo,ateven,gstahilgezntvefiblatTits(nfrtxenhcetslsinetM-eiuiol,sarppamiuoaoasneru,eorcfibChigyongcn.iasdl:rlb4tiiabnutrnvibrslnbhreeohdigyoihwi/acylnoaastg0eoudttg3dasneaneoebvrdeiut/ntittheehwmsiihnh0n.etu2eiheeocenngrbnydcdfh.1mhasnaiaiiona,rfri6odrtdwoecivedtfeio:aBs9a)oArvweanialp.on)ssrtirionosomiteteagb5lleocotnilhVnlrdrhshoeddmotrrmio"rnyiarouarl2dtr(caiiitiybafaifelatifeoaPneitssun,taeonsy,lTovdhcwcynntaiytoccnirhwptnhf.crlaaW.heRevesaoehdngdftltNopryfiwegeqpmalneatoeren,,iemns-yipthitiouwnlBlcrlrfuirhetAcnyrinlirshcteolsdvhetby,etoodhaineaeoHorausenaandenffsweiecl1ocires'ooia-sfslcmeayttwi.hliasonsaloilpdlvotksrunu1thrtwdoasinrooimtligBYicuvoeaunrtpioiwtehxis9voa.tdsntilhAeoddrnuteonnanimh.atiiriavln4iteroebr,vltdwietrernratmdncwyeyeorenm'aalt6luirprsluai)hraaceegmaCegdaksiresottc-slee,mhoeowcl-.edtUatdloln,Syio,.k1emdc1dtfuatelu-oiiaemed'rakpmslosr9ssormM9nktrbseateoosrnslitdamahu7sien,Ogsii/e6adob,isbnoveeahnumt8plcrwianne;nesrxt0onnrflsesgeseunh.linnsdaiakaievd1ndp,fyli.tnxwieogrotatpatlslpdvla9meteoogsoado,Cif,hiytBieittTadop5tabtaaotuerrdeNrtoterehanoOmoero7oebhtclthn-,ertayOrndThHhrlidngrpxioniifehaeteleenetdokiexoettaltteeovrioeoaofieewntrlhooheitu,fieyrhtsrbstursnentossrtawiosicfhtrneogihvty'msstfutrsctfttmhwfaolhrhr,essine-ersyaBohoaooyho,elhteinueBaonaaudkrbbteeBdbrleyerdenslrelsradiirngtrrhanbotkal.td,dcpeaterschandiiinigg,leeflsnoeothtdeels,loiB(orgtntttiiegteiuwtweeaiifBkisOetEstloiievainneBtsfrnecnehtneiBgdntiroPos,inxresurleroikoiettterieenrl,renrglsnshaohfwirewrnsedn.zrlosihiel1yildscwiatadseoaotagoglnnfnoninnenai9aloiifiawegeoridPie'oouadnfrlecscads6snventrnao-ultnnfsardrnlfvhe-heylo-6.-hefmy'lihedwo.d-,---si-std.ms'-ess-.-s gtttcnseteihoamohanhrioaBtflfhhaifHbesaIeHhoheilhdsrcfovtforierehaoonmioniitirnxcmfassseeoeettgeaeoarmeraITanrsengTrrmhplstohoHindTacitt-slranObdedtepdihod;o.ilsIhoeitaLsgmtoqlkdiyndhucwohxsncihrrhnsb,ailoaisihurcnne(sgotbcitiecaiaretgmfBmmeoe(fyinyetwlirialcwadsroniahainefernshinvssmoeremtaeylawtaepnionddagiomiaoradldeeas,sdoedeoeasrboltis)sicklyydceurllifBatfnie-raslohntouwoUidoit.tctiiresenusfanncokfypiliewytKwtydftngeoehnnsltronsseenfvttodfn,hhaaathroiirseaAirlnai(mFtrpiiicotniet(l:ststhairttvteckfilthrc11SvthrttiaokUhlsfmihrheidonromtenlaoiabain99dae)nsbkhcvaOeoxateyoret't'irlsmnm,u5iynde2inelvshnaRekaoatstMndtdsseet0s,ptr8eShhieodoAoonkbshughytiweninmceal.twsosMn-hBpnitfm,aieotupoeusehwdllathpfhrtroioio1eihedenpsiiallpiefnbtsysgmhelrumnahr9sxe1l"crrlnelvwsiUPataeo.clhhitdueoetl9mre3tlhp,pnguashcaosooneltaaowam5si;rht2rnoiireesuiAfeafsplhainarri3ndntiha)ttftoneraalals,crozfJneusvttb)susiijoetcoy,yEt'ltusnownetenhbtl,hemeneomescd,dhC,uey'siiecmofwtdnelridwliagabmtidaou,cuwasw,eloooainoarmeubyOsilanalneinpenoctmlpibniathiy,nnesmnssusamnoKainsasnd-,nneoiainsdebhlteodoahtsvdttltklturoitnbdsdoniouirtehei"oLrhlnmeleoanmohdsftet,aft,edndrdneginpacioalohr-hdiveeictnyintcsoateoeindltrldhjsoitnlevgatnmchahdteoohwhMusfehaunvshoudiswsiieeedmiiaevhi.sdndnilascistobseee,htnpoahbfs.wtraepnRestu.nslotrettiohfytyamnmoltdmlfteoeruloyeurahsibienhsosritmrebniounoIaditachTstscobjheeofk,istpsaswwhudlsohmsnrgetetlsiiomchreerewialiBncwomieoeheoaneahidiiianrcenatispamfueeowrectiaimc.neaiosdkneftegltaoaohrsntpnr-sotodlth:enrcnoutslpsnnlloilqhiaeodkseBchutirCsntreis,pateulhtsijniui"fshi,odun,enfeuheodribkhsichtnoiicceoLchsaefgigetHtrbdtrytltoe(ttomkyaudiwftaewain,iawga,aegiieea2hlgisu-eetlycricfwtwooeitenlocsaBcs--0rmmeoaeomlsartatssdheehsfuaeiniekhp0mdarlaalrwavdtleeuhtrnnrak.eiiis4ndalolyugwtdfkkatecttdrcltnestinw)dirtreWednsifaobiieauairhLtshieohatgrmneroheraaloneenntkemiaetirnrssooeegmdewnhploTemhe'lureesg:eonnrpcekttiuoaeieitnilsaiitadhhtc,dirlfuqetoagrectosrfvzegscohldehBwouveear,teymtiuwdkrhscsfnehsefy.remoncraa1eiamhpuisaitseotHisr(eiuywaeiutq9einuahtsmITrttrdn(oaantl1euaaawlnml,cuoo,da5sscfau1aadeefia9hnndsfpneadnnlrirfrao93idllntienn2tbodtbegslamnceaatitl0ndnikniy'hcc0oidhoyhdteonulier-eer9ehkiaetsy)oee.eoailfohrtrt-s)esee-tsy-,,-a.rt,fsdof'e, gtiaeiEt2vsb-v"aMwmsRpawtcqmtbtw"o.cuinwlmtrnaoneviian.loeoaioerahhauohIufrz.ruehuolkngnnercleIrlomdlrewBune,TctinueatspgeontireeiedanBtlnntmcinoeyehgtprhdteergthlpotreynhamhreutbapprsetrhrhhre,eooyhuduittaeceipaewrcetlrusieteode,tedpdttitss.nhwelhecenptnioobsooBsmeahearceet,tsjlai9BltnctteattlpoustBeipastIinpoedooottn,lir"nnoie0ohuiofteerlidiynlincoonaahyhhsipnmlsrerBi0crnlronHedl-nsawee.tabaeetgsmInhebanedsnlaienasolnii,tsgcaardxtahdueie-topdrlgeeitdbn.attykswoewrdtrepiaoseaepnrtlasmibpesoimuuoivtdmovfhrgPadUnemngptoagocunaasontvicplrofnsao1aleoa,,eahrlfeaaiinodhebdsfntwoakk*asla9redwnifseiannewrvajliscesre.olWl5teeatetvlttntitttiyvooeeeldidgdoPrva,3luhsorhlhscnhceareznercseepororr,okynosemuleelie.o)rgootodermotsarmfinpssl.flconn-peiltfHf.h-wyelvegp.iaBhhetuiuiiomtidaiu-et"t,ailttesiyeiesttaeeuiotnntevnhlew"ahNaoticnwccocredisns(otinilenluifgfkdeumtBawhepwscotllaevfhs™ndvrctootoeltil.foel,rstromaihiiaeeneeessehrlefhf.nsdtrlfaeovnronrbeo4CnryisetketeneetcyhslicodfsnsotTW1omtob,rooetbtoomedienatdeuwnipitp7yalarlivshecuuelrnateulheuertotoharer)t,lbci.ielgrunmnctyerydrnerehd,ptryodasheewudhg,ev.buasamdniow"aimerf—sieggMwreietoaehtoustmpwtUechahealretaesourawr.atohmhStwirrsleucbsad,tai..nlelwe,iioeoeesrs.orelsh-aruesaysioc.ws*tIdmo(mrudafrNomeurTRoemnfrhsahch1ipsntuaeuroerromepctgotuhwuettk09yauooswithffslC,erthat1rlpwh6siishgcernaastfaecohaheog0sdpsah6nhreuo,srsetotsbiditdildenaiatri)phiaorwaaemgUhrhumrhehnomdssldrittdtrifnnrnaedtpleee,iolueb™isetbedntcMpooinmtlon.lboudnduoicoidtstegyghl™eiratveyttoeeoiaaianrlmhntanevueotElnei(cres™sftrelflgrtdeyravcwcgiiluteaiavamtduonetoradt<^iaoaatesfeenldsaosactnrlrepeegklhsetaofhmryfoe-tnnioyihhdan,crtdsehonoxaoeiomfbevlaeniynatttdeootdiarf1ufspoegdntstonfgioyhelfuatrm9lfreatigueeetbfgavWuoTtlechnpdhsc3ehpesimsaashrshahct-ehortaersnshB7rideevehiaestcegaitrersgsehot,dBpe-ythieroaefemsiotdinaetoheiyvrrepskoenntwneuottpsnoetafgeso..ofbdosroittmtororsrilccuohsooeaowennmsurfahrele,omtcpmtBTdrnheuyianuauifoecrmditeaef-aehaiaenenorttdrlnhfsttlrlecacatrsusehkrbonsgcoata-s-idlrcieoediaotoneleftehrd-cch-oy--a-a-itmrfildllhlt,hslln---
NOVEMBRE1009jBULLETIN«PPUA9
NEWS
ACTUALITÉS
Students Paying More, Getting Less Student Loses Appeal
THiEngeecnornoolmmeinctduopwnattuCrannaisddirainv- Bid in BC Courts
universitiesatatimewhenfunding
forpost-secondaryeducationis
beingslashedandtuitionfeesare BRITISHColumbia'shighestcourt Legalrepresentationthroughout
tydpdroieeersanroAfitrgnigbsgrgro-.uaaeurdmneaturssnao3trlfi8eelrn,leco0aedrm0ane0isdalneasmds9euot,nbro0yiyfev0eae02trrf9s,hiu,ienlta0ligAc0-esrtc0ssiaomoidrtecnhudiiasius-ttnnueg-- fhsamuteoeierrImtnmsblahete2ogarua0rnsdi0gsUen2d.nnsriittuMsvnemaCUnriyuBsisnginstCtheghydaia$noant1fhd8fMeBiamlf.aeiouCdplu.glprahiegofcaaranilanvcidullouliaft-nawyc- mfawotsohfaasueIstonrnphcrppei2rorrai0cUotoge0fivhBs3eotissnsCdsMfeoacoadFrronuasmtdb,cghpuyehClUlafaAtCBaiynUcCAnuAT,tlbUst.rsayTtoogrhcuaeeoiigsannhfptsatoitbcnoueadntlhe.hthaneyult-fs
oaftiTCohnaenoafadsUasn.oicvieartsiiotniessayasndit'Csotlhleegbeigs- itCinhoarnitseatdlilaaenggaifinangiststh.hoeTnhhaethdeB.bbCea.esinSsudoipfsrcheremirme- sBeigdIhntMjsaauTngruhiabarunyn'2as0l0cs6oumtmphmleaaBri.inClt.yHTduwismomiasn-
JgsaeemcsBtteuostirnTCcsuirArnecakUesseTa2y0iesn0x3ite.fhcseuntpoiovsseutr-dpsirerisececotnmodorarrey riCtnehoaeufrsraeovtnowaruaburlslyoenfidontsihetnervJuiascdtnteueunddacjereunyrtoy2nc0o0wu8hlidtchfhaitnad mcsaaipolap,nletbarhlue.tsvihleaawtseorn,fostthheyeefttirlpiebudurnsfaolur'esaddjtiuhsdamiti-s-
i iopdspeapiornopyrslteueudcnuahicrtaetituetirsuomronanirwielhnasgiclntaedorctepeho.mesptel-cosoeycnmooenmn-yt adoipfrp"AelWpcietcpoa'ertraJieloandmh,eae"lssisdgaTihiustdrmekCdi.sAts"heUTedhTiBMs.aeChux.ageschCuabotenuie'rvnste MotofaAuCatapgpnhpearaadenlass.twoitliltmhebe,eSCsuAepeUrkeiTmngelelCaeoraunveerdt
g§Imboeo"nIsttt'shfjauussnntd'ditinrsgeacptoopgotnihnietziepndrgottvhhieenncgeeosveedfrontr-o afalcuolntgyannadmedidffibcyulMtaourgdehaaln.fo"rthe VersionfrançaiseàlapageA13.
Ipost-secondaryeducationtohelp
1teac$omfbceehdeov4ndeenrernuTe0udisCnotcrch0upnnwtaAmarBogeoemtdtatesftUiheieiictooledsooGnTd-rrlttnntisDgniaut,lnaeaohePdomemcinncaxea.croniimosmtnitenznrtenuaatdactdsresdhktathaeerehltiraeraeilhorehyttcneaaeneprnhctdtletaoeeelgoyidntssssxoeesc,ushatttnaaf"acitle-lrRebbisaryssshtrunlhteoehedgeaaiatecgtsrtdooaosbteregyn0anrantryqo.iden'a,uovdb5ssatiaev.eyfsasrpljSxereienyiure-rnnst-drsg-tyUhucroAffpPtraenibanaParcensmd"o"ndnoaoairAeEcndvtlgsivreydcoeiierPgegeuierndfiaarabrcsyoglnrmaeaa,braag"dttOaytsilaneiuhsTontcdeosa3usuctpi.anttdeuCrrs6Rtueseirtaokhidstnpsaoeveinsitesnwinobtksaacpr,Tnltdueyedr"esfedsyfc.o.a.refeehavnooetnBdSiertsomtdustsiiafstuelfltaoohdolcoieirnraeFdwoodqnfv.n-unuotuteaciahfolllOealnGmfii-tcaurnitsfsil-oaieicsloRmmciennes-edt- meVibmtemeteuhneidyroraioucasn"trlaNcriSnmdenagaomtiecdnrtuonsntfoidEgfuhoitawoerroosctnaonncsunhttueçldeiuW,issrasdiesesitebaimisaneiterbts'noecikisnàdelloentniodalyogntpoaaenyodatrpspddsFyimetaar.licugywtl"epdoneohacreggrAsiioAnmnhlogomtUiareonfsiz.oukiCtetelrwyzehdc.eiitenotnhqRU'naghaugteotoan--lvd--LcTvdrqafrLeuoeunrlpaPicSsnelaaahYiauoiorntercincétrtsttacscrieéphqdholdseluieodueleseeejunabruCtfapuslrsaoa,lqlxsnnnu'uPcMedsa'ctAs.sidosOhdclaead!idTeln.teèuuAaicg2erliee3Plekslnradmjteoeierutslgégcltareefiéuaoaoapxlvnnmredsméudruaso-nedicdené--escm,1Iteedqfbmlipsaoulèreceinngeis«nqsdesvfttssésàlCteseéuoceope.magtuuhemudtobneruupltuomlnétisenvirocevieppriseaqornrtysaupnssdesteoie,nsltu1meuqeéir4elcusdnoieéfpsnutitrtaldnaifasaipbvTaionnllérurcisiaesgee.scne-srscn»feenpliempeounetsbaslnalnectbséciosltelcae--s-
Being recognized and valued
"Windsorisasmalleruniversity,whichpresentswonderfuladvantagesforfacultywhojoinouracademic
community,"saysDr.RanjanaBird."Theintimateatmospherecreatesamorefertileenvironmentfor
innovativeinterdisciplinaryresearchandourfacultyaremorecollegiallyinclined,"sheadds."They're
genuinelycommittedtohelpingnewcomerssucceed-ineverythingfromnetworkingandcollaboration
tothefinetuningofgrantapplications."
ForDr.Bird,beingthecatalystofthatvibrantinstitutionalresearchethosistremendously
rewarding."Oursmallersizeallowsmetostayintouchwiththeentirefacultyandtomaintain
ahigh-level,informedviewoftheinstitution'srapidlygrowingresearchactivity.Thatputsme,"
sheadds,"inanidealpositiontofacilitateinterestingconnectionsbetweenresearchers.It
allowsmetoofferournewfacultystreamlinedaccesstoourentirecreativepotential."
Tolearnmoreabouthowwerecognizeandvaluenewfaculty,andaboutthesupportive
culturethathashelpedustripleourresearchactivitywithinthelastdecade,please
contactDr.JaniceDrakich,DirectorofFacultyRecruitment
tollfreeat1-877-665-6608orvisitusonline.
University
of Windsor
thinkingforward
uwindsor.ca/facultypositions
A10CAUTBULLETIN|NOVEMBER7009
NEWS
&
Mount Royal
Grant MacEwan Named
as Universities
TWOAlbertacollegesofficially
becameuniversitiesinSeptem-
ber.MountRoyalCollegeinCal*
garywasgrantedtherighttouse
thenameuniversitybytheGovern-
mentofAlbertaonSept3and
GrantMacEwanCollegeinEdmon-
tonwasallowedtochangeitsname
touniversityonSept.24.
MountRoyalUniversity
RobinFisher,MountRoyalprovost
andvice-presidentacademic,said
theswitchtouniversitystatuswas
aproudmomentforaschoolwith
humblebeginningsin1911asapri-
vateMethodistinstitutionwith179
students.
ButthemandateofMountRoyal
changedovertheyearsand"thereal-
ityiswebecameauniversityahead
ofthename,"Fishersaid."We'veal-
readyimplementedarangeofde-
greeprogramsandwe'vesetupa
newsystemofacademicgovernance
tooverseeacademicmatters."
BeingnamedMountRoyalUni-
versity-isafittingrecognldonoïthe
school'srecentgrowth.Fishersaid.
"Eachandeverystaffandfaculty
memberandstudentshouldbecon-
gratulatedonthissuccess."
MountRoyalnowhassevenbach-
elor'sdegreesand"graduateswill
havemoreopportunityasaresult
ofthenewstatus,"saidDavidHyt-
tenrauch,presidentoftheMount
RoyalFacultyAssociationinastate-
menttoCBCNews.
"It'sbeendifficultovertheyears
forgraduatesofcolleges,generally,
tomoveontograduatestudiesat
uunniivveerrssiittiyens,a"mheedoseasidn.'t"rHeaalvliyncghatnhege TMhoeunntewRoAylablerUtnaiveurnsiivteyrs(ittoipe)s&—
theprogramsweoffer,butitchanges GrantMacEwanUniversity
thenationalrecognitionandour
statusamongotherinstitutions." Hesaidthedecisiontoconcen-
GrantMacEwanUniversity ttreaatcehiinncgrewahsiilneglcyoonntiunnudienrggtroadouffaetre
PaulByrne,presidentandCEOat diplomaandcertificateprograms
MacEwan,whichopeneditsdoors didnotcomelightly."Ittookalot
nearly40yearsagoto400students, ofresearch,consultationandsoul
saidtheuniversitynameenhances searchingtodetermineifthiswas
thepublicperspectiveonwhatthe trulyastepintherightdirection.
institutionoffers. Thereactiontothenamechange
"We'reveryexperiencedinof- fromstudents,facultyandstaffhas
fleurmin—gathueninvaemrseitcyh-caanlgiebrreefcluercrtisctu-he beTehneovnearmweheclhmainnggelyisp"ojsuisttivfeo.r"mal
nextstepinourevolution,"Byrne recognitionofwhatwe'vebeendoing
said."MacEwannowoffersfive forquitesomelime,"JerryZdril,head
undergraduatedegreeswithpoten- ofMacEwan'sfacultyassociation,
tialtoaddmoreintheyearsahead tolddieEdmontonJournal.
o..u.rweDeNvAolvsetaaysndthweesarmees.p"ondbut VersionfrançaiseàlapageA6.
AthabascaUniversitytransfercreditsincreaseacademicchoices. Un rapport met au jour les
injustices faites aux universitaires
•AtAthabasca University, our large selection of online post-secondary courses adds to the du Moyen-Orient
academicchoicesyoucanofferyourstudents. . Havingextracourseoptionshasbeenanideal
fitforMagdalena, who'sattendingauniversityinOntario. Inaddition totakingcoursesather SuitedelaIW(GEAG3 forcesmilitairesisraéliennes.Dob-
chtoooumcreosemuspnlideveetlreisivtheyer,redsdheoeng'lsrieanelesaoantydaekaiarntgeaasrdloyim.seta.andcAdeiU.tiho.ansaTrlmancosorfueerrsatebhsialanitty3A.7t,hA0an0bo0atshscetarudUreneniatvsesornsaintwdyh,yoafAnfeUdrsisstoaovnnedrstr7oa0uct0k sfiltasiarcseleedsheeluolrratsqerune'tcihlàserdsceohuehnaooimutbeénrtteuduaisxesrio,stbee-rt sddFieéaarttnveatenhstecientooncdmoemeutemrnlseetmehnbltarerreaccîsoènnlefdeluéimgtepaneHltraesmmdoea'nénnstte-ul-l.a
asagloballeaderindistancelearningexcellence. àdesconférencesetmenerdestra- Lesconclusionsdurapportmettent
vauxderecherchecoopérativeà enévidencedesérieusesviolations
l'extérieurdelarégion.Lesétudiants desprincipesdePUNESCOen
deGazan'ontgénéralementpasle CisjordanieetàGaza.Jevousre-
standout w1-w8w00a7t0H8a9b0a4s1cauca'itandoui AthabascaUniversity^ drirtooiitred,'métêudmieereànlC'iesxjtoérrideaunried.uter- ccuommemnatnddèesvqui'vielmseenrtadpueblliiréecetej'deos--
Entreautresconstatations,M.Ro- pèrequevoussoutiendrezl'action
binsonattirel'attentionsurdescas quenousmenonsavecnoscollè-
d'arrestationarbitraireetdedetention guesdesautrespayspourcorriger
d'étudiantsetdeprofesseursparles cesproblèmes.