Table Of Content

Y R A R B LI W A L N KI S A L MUNICIPAL AND PLANNING LAW A R O B Casebook STANLEY M. MAKUCH PART 11 FACULTY OF LAW UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO , • i-.MOis.iiN LAW LIBRARY . UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO MUNICIPAL AND PLANNING LAW Casebook STANLEY M. MAKUCH PART II FACULTY OF LAW UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO e"l 4. ^ • \ y/iv ,M S':® ■orMorxGT 10 V '* iJiHavinU": ' . ' J i •V » ‘j . rt A •<' - . ’ • » <v^ »■ , ■^•« Hfc ' ^*’ ' , .. « • r ^ : t: ^ h . ,'■.,< ►rv’t}; ‘ 'V - * «»d ■'. r ’ ' ' ;Jy ' * ’* 0 i ^ ■ -- , ‘ w.. ‘l- -'* ’ . ■ i ' t IV • V‘ r . :i«-.'S’>X-r- .if- ” . i** * ♦ » ,'^jKfrif^t *' a • - , ■ , '1 w •- •> / . V; t** .'• 4 . » • ^ • I V • ... ■ •V*‘V- . ’•,.%‘t^; r.': '• -f* ■ 5 -' ■^'•r • -xJ’.'<;l ''I* '■' ■■ -i- . ' '^ 5 <■ ,1 V , . / • t *t ■iA>*-r'.’a A-y'/.r' Vi c,;^. , , MUNICIPAL AND PLANNING LAW Table of Contents PART II Chapter 5 Introduction to Planning Introduction. 1 W.I. Goodman, ed. "Principles and Practice of Urban Planning". 2 S. Proudfoot, "Private Wants and Public Needs: The Regulation of Land Use in the Metropolitan Toronto Area" . 9 Chapter 6 The Official Plan Introduction Ontario Economic Council, "Subject to Approval". 11 Conformity Re Cadillac Development Corporation and City of Toronto (1974) 1 O.R. (2d) 21 (H.C.). 15 The Limits of Official Plans Re Official Plan of Richmond Hill Planning Area (1980), 13 M.P.L.R. 87 (O.M.B.). 20 Re City of Brampton Planning Area Offiicial Plan Amendment 75 (1982), 14 O.M.B.R. 482 (O.M.B.). 21 Upper Tier Municipality Official Plans Campeau Corporation v. Township of Gloucester (1978), 6 M.P.L.R. 290 (O.H.C.) . 23 The Provincial Role in Planning White, "Ontario’s Land Use Legislation" . 26 (i) Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2018 with funding from University of Toronto https://archive.org/details/canadianmunicipa02maku Chapter 7 The Private Control of Land Uses Introduction. 31 Restrictive Covenants. 32 Re Sekretow and City of Toronto (1973), 33 D.L.R. (3d) 257 (O.C.A.) Building Schemes Hyett, "Restrictive Covenants: An Appraisal of Building Schemes".37 McGregor et al. v. Boyd Builders Ltd. et al. (1965) 54 D.L.R. (2d) 112 (O.H.C.) .40 Modification of Restrictive Covenants.42 Nuisance Bottom V. Ontario Leaf Tobacco Co. Ltd., [1935] O.R. 204 (C.A.).43 Fiss, "The Supreme Court - Forward".45 Rogers, "The Growing Significance of Environmental Issues in the Development Approval Process".46 Chapter 8 Zoning and Land Use Control Introduction to Zoning.48 Introduction Boston Globe, "Houston Looks for A Heart".48 Makuch, "Zoning: Avenues of Reform" .49 The Scope of the Zotung Power .51 Exclusionary Zoning and the Scope of the Zoning Power Village of Euclid v. Ambler Realty Co. Ohio. S.C.U.S. 1926. 272 U.S. 365 . 51 The Bell Case.57 Re Hutterian Brethren Church of Eagle Creek and Rural Municipality of Eagle Creek (1983), 21 M.P.L.R. 108 (Sask. C.A.).72 (u) ■^T /-?>■ -vV.,'^ > V. J s-’s ,. ■'?■'• ^-4-' ■: ^t.- . W.‘Jf • *J -v / • ' ■- _ t,'»»|.HCli A fr. ’"i -n. i '0'iU *» ^ 4T ' <1 . 1 t • • V* ' • ■“ - » r.- ff X)? *it^' Tt'' i • » « j. 4 , ■ J1^ nV ' '>»rvn>r.^d i II (..' :>:0) ^ vrtMp. .•i *c% ■- ■f' ■• -■ ■ A'-'i'.fts I EL. < ' '■. .i ’ j/HjitiMri Jn^un^'iA H;.*H' -t .' - \ 'j K 4^) '■| ( .51. : ■ •*5J*V . -siv .*. Vi - t)r>J . ,ti4• y,A”*"^ .i i.:*i; i/)! Ii> ;♦ ih***-!!)' <i o:-U»f**<!1 . . Ti=i ’^■» ^' *5 51 f. ! ,ia,U tO • ^vU I It ^ ,1 *- fl[^u/2 tfi' •‘--H csf ^ iR^rjolrt.aCf >if* u «>«• 1 ’^ynrl tfi T>ttjnft*vQi'. u«n vovO juT* H <?* * -J I - I I f - ^ V- .tf Ui*.ioait> sw’i loit i b/^ v»V'"lX I ' liT! aITi'. ". l n ; ' t t jUL»> L>oi Ht. • V*. iii/r b'M^i oh' k' ftr a‘ * •*"» ... ‘'uQa iV -I ^“a. • V, i^niwnSk* (JjWkr.J’t* *x J * « • « * »• ■? ■% -i. ^ ^ # A ..■■:'■* ■fc . , . . , . - , . , J., . »i , . • *■ ‘*V ^auwt.. usU io .>3co^ /5JT tt _ ^1 ■ ..V- .i. 4 ^ >ii; :./w<» lOblf/A A./ ’V.-'V'""' 'iV' ^ ;^.,U,>>;?- .UtT'» .li\ ' ''>! - x\ , I »■’ * i r • • • ) I. * . f /.i\tv^.A,.l' ii •*?» .<> vV^t 1 V akavitti^^Jk *% •» •' • # • • *^1 i u... ‘ Al’> ' "j J? J S .Ht *,i, '■. ^'viO tinu ^ •jll • 4* , i -i., .. ^ _. ;| ML -.%! Discrimination and Zomng dry of Toronto v. Mendelbaum, [1932] O.R. 552 (H.C.).73 City of Verdun v. Sun Oil Co. Ltd., [1951] S.C.R. 222 . 75 Scarborough Township v. Bondi (1959), 18 D.L.R. (2d) 161 (S.C.C.).76 Bad Faith Re Cadillac Development Corp. and City of Toronto (1974), 1 O.R. (2d) 21 (H.C.79) .... H.G. Winton v. Corporation of the Borough of North York (1978), 6 M.P.L.R. 1 (Ont. Div. Ct.) . 81 The Administration of Zoning By-Laws Polai City of Toronto (1972), 28 D.L.R. (3d) 638 (S.C.C.). 83 V. Prohibiting All Uses R. Gibson Kx Parte Cromiller, [1959] O.W.N. 254 (Ont. H.C.) . 85 V. Corporation of The City of Coquitlam v. Karamanolis (1978), 3 M.P.L.R. 112 (B.C.S.C.) .... 86 Planning and Land Value The Common Law Position Belfast Corporation v. O.D. Cars Ltd., [1960] A.C. 490 (H.L.) . 88 The Current Canadian Position Regina Auto Court v. City of Regina (1958), 25 W.W.R. 167 (Sask. Q.B.). 94 Re Simpson and City of Vancouver (1977), 65 D.L.R. (3d) 669 (S.C.C.) . 96 Hauff et al. v. City of Vancouver (1981), 15 M.P.L.R. 8 (B.C.C.A.). 101 The Charter The Queen in Right of New Brunswick v. Fisherman's Wharf Ltd. (1982), 7 C.R.R. 46 (N.B.C.A.). 104 Negligence Welbridge Holdings Ltd. v. Metropolitan Corporation of Greater Winnipeg (1970), 22 D.L.R. (3d) 470 (S.C.C.) . 107 < ■ ,r,i l'.».:v ^" kvi . .-\ :4'. i • “ ■'■ ■•' .' ‘J '* V .. ^ -’4*^ * '.. -#«c* > * ’• t •■f^'T ...» * »■■ • . ..„.• f r 4 ' •b- * ’ ' .^ •» - ' ^ >.'l ' . -- *u'/lA' jPl O ^-i^'■'"^uy yvA - ty .. S .*’■ 'S' ^ ^ ' ' V.' ' ‘V r»:iCirt.,r . ;n_,. vyv aH • . •' 4 . -V ^ .. (.'^3;^^ r^: itSSi ,;i.j n A. '* "‘■j' -■■ r-'" ^ »>-) ■•J, ' >■ -vf'' ' '■ . V ' t,, 't ‘A.rjwiT’’ 'Y^ ‘t>*i Wi) 't'* .1*'- V''’!f'?‘V ' ‘J’^*-*'*'**'’’ » . “ ** * . , ' p' •'_ i ..> i,‘VM 'c r'9\ t J.is'f * i> .45.H '* ** ■ • ‘ - •'.5'’> i' '. *0> • \ • ' •* T 1# ’ ‘ • ■ ^{v' ♦ ’ * >V('4. > >•’! '.‘!"*.r*% * * 'T.* c»*4:M*Mi4All, o T ‘ ■■ •.♦;■ . ' 4 J jJ f~ , *■' » nt * • I .?;• “, »‘i» .1 jl/ iiM f iu ■fy .,\1 .,. . AF -^SMWK# ^ .»4.vi /# .5^ 1 , i .' ^ .V e O H» - ‘ ^ ^ w i ) • V \w»»'W^>l - v» . . j ..n V «’ ..i»<t«wvO li-b;*/ I-n-t' i*nA 1 - ■•* ff. * *■ »' ^ *r;rtM^ '•' *'«J niTT ) ■f' ■f ■ ^ i ’•♦AO If . \x\X At.'l .CJ ’♦ P',A* ’ ♦v ' • ■•.r» ’# *1’..•.! '^» 1 •*4 (v»ii*'>' 'i -'Mihun,'^ t » -It* ai»T_ ( ^ try (,»i 0 ^ ^ ^ » '•• ''A V' •■' ^ I <N!» fUli A. i.A3 'VAi \rifrV:i V»^»v i> V " , . i.0.>O'?i S !v i u>*) ' \ } \ ( ■• i an ■ ♦ I ) 'i.X \,«4i\^ ’ if - ^ '/ V> u.* t n j -K* , ' . ;» .4, I.Au3 >*1^ H>>* i* ^ 4* :^r £: ^r _0 " i-i . * ..:Vjl'. ■t.,'. <4 11 iOVOn -.v.vi^^^.aolfv. .‘.■' ■’ "'• .*4<j«i'''-W'. .v.jcvtJk -JvdwnAhi^ ^ ■ • ., .. O' ! ■ ! i. ♦ m. 1 i ’ A 'v*l^ 'jS! » —A •- ■' ^■^ ' f |4i*. MM fll. .>. I*

ebook img

Canadian municipal and planning law PDF

22 Pages·1999·0.79 MB·English
by  Makuch, Stanley M
#toronto #university_of_toronto #boralaskin_casebooks #BoraLaskin
Save to my drive
Quick download
Download
Upgrade Premium
Most books are stored in the elastic cloud where traffic is expensive. For this reason, we have a limit on daily download.

Preview Canadian municipal and planning law

Y R A R B LI W A L N KI S A L MUNICIPAL AND PLANNING LAW A R O B Casebook STANLEY M. MAKUCH PART 11 FACULTY OF LAW UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO , • i-.MOis.iiN LAW LIBRARY . UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO MUNICIPAL AND PLANNING LAW Casebook STANLEY M. MAKUCH PART II FACULTY OF LAW UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO e"l 4. ^ • \ y/iv ,M S':® ■orMorxGT 10 V '* iJiHavinU": ' . ' J i •V » ‘j . rt A •<' - . ’ • » <v^ »■ , ■^•« Hfc ' ^*’ ' , .. « • r ^ : t: ^ h . ,'■.,< ►rv’t}; ‘ 'V - * «»d ■'. r ’ ' ' ;Jy ' * ’* 0 i ^ ■ -- , ‘ w.. ‘l- -'* ’ . ■ i ' t IV • V‘ r . :i«-.'S’>X-r- .if- ” . i** * ♦ » ,'^jKfrif^t *' a • - , ■ , '1 w •- •> / . V; t** .'• 4 . » • ^ • I V • ... ■ •V*‘V- . ’•,.%‘t^; r.': '• -f* ■ 5 -' ■^'•r • -xJ’.'<;l ''I* '■' ■■ -i- . ' '^ 5 <■ ,1 V , . / • t *t ■iA>*-r'.’a A-y'/.r' Vi c,;^. , , MUNICIPAL AND PLANNING LAW Table of Contents PART II Chapter 5 Introduction to Planning Introduction. 1 W.I. Goodman, ed. "Principles and Practice of Urban Planning". 2 S. Proudfoot, "Private Wants and Public Needs: The Regulation of Land Use in the Metropolitan Toronto Area" . 9 Chapter 6 The Official Plan Introduction Ontario Economic Council, "Subject to Approval". 11 Conformity Re Cadillac Development Corporation and City of Toronto (1974) 1 O.R. (2d) 21 (H.C.). 15 The Limits of Official Plans Re Official Plan of Richmond Hill Planning Area (1980), 13 M.P.L.R. 87 (O.M.B.). 20 Re City of Brampton Planning Area Offiicial Plan Amendment 75 (1982), 14 O.M.B.R. 482 (O.M.B.). 21 Upper Tier Municipality Official Plans Campeau Corporation v. Township of Gloucester (1978), 6 M.P.L.R. 290 (O.H.C.) . 23 The Provincial Role in Planning White, "Ontario’s Land Use Legislation" . 26 (i) Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2018 with funding from University of Toronto https://archive.org/details/canadianmunicipa02maku Chapter 7 The Private Control of Land Uses Introduction. 31 Restrictive Covenants. 32 Re Sekretow and City of Toronto (1973), 33 D.L.R. (3d) 257 (O.C.A.) Building Schemes Hyett, "Restrictive Covenants: An Appraisal of Building Schemes".37 McGregor et al. v. Boyd Builders Ltd. et al. (1965) 54 D.L.R. (2d) 112 (O.H.C.) .40 Modification of Restrictive Covenants.42 Nuisance Bottom V. Ontario Leaf Tobacco Co. Ltd., [1935] O.R. 204 (C.A.).43 Fiss, "The Supreme Court - Forward".45 Rogers, "The Growing Significance of Environmental Issues in the Development Approval Process".46 Chapter 8 Zoning and Land Use Control Introduction to Zoning.48 Introduction Boston Globe, "Houston Looks for A Heart".48 Makuch, "Zoning: Avenues of Reform" .49 The Scope of the Zotung Power .51 Exclusionary Zoning and the Scope of the Zoning Power Village of Euclid v. Ambler Realty Co. Ohio. S.C.U.S. 1926. 272 U.S. 365 . 51 The Bell Case.57 Re Hutterian Brethren Church of Eagle Creek and Rural Municipality of Eagle Creek (1983), 21 M.P.L.R. 108 (Sask. C.A.).72 (u) ■^T /-?>■ -vV.,'^ > V. J s-’s ,. ■'?■'• ^-4-' ■: ^t.- . W.‘Jf • *J -v / • ' ■- _ t,'»»|.HCli A fr. ’"i -n. i '0'iU *» ^ 4T ' <1 . 1 t • • V* ' • ■“ - » r.- ff X)? *it^' Tt'' i • » « j. 4 , ■ J1^ nV ' '>»rvn>r.^d i II (..' :>:0) ^ vrtMp. .•i *c% ■- ■f' ■• -■ ■ A'-'i'.fts I EL. < ' '■. .i ’ j/HjitiMri Jn^un^'iA H;.*H' -t .' - \ 'j K 4^) '■| ( .51. : ■ •*5J*V . -siv .*. Vi - t)r>J . ,ti4• y,A”*"^ .i i.:*i; i/)! Ii> ;♦ ih***-!!)' <i o:-U»f**<!1 . . Ti=i ’^■» ^' *5 51 f. ! ,ia,U tO • ^vU I It ^ ,1 *- fl[^u/2 tfi' •‘--H csf ^ iR^rjolrt.aCf >if* u «>«• 1 ’^ynrl tfi T>ttjnft*vQi'. u«n vovO juT* H <?* * -J I - I I f - ^ V- .tf Ui*.ioait> sw’i loit i b/^ v»V'"lX I ' liT! aITi'. ". l n ; ' t t jUL»> L>oi Ht. • V*. iii/r b'M^i oh' k' ftr a‘ * •*"» ... ‘'uQa iV -I ^“a. • V, i^niwnSk* (JjWkr.J’t* *x J * « • « * »• ■? ■% -i. ^ ^ # A ..■■:'■* ■fc . , . . , . - , . , J., . »i , . • *■ ‘*V ^auwt.. usU io .>3co^ /5JT tt _ ^1 ■ ..V- .i. 4 ^ >ii; :./w<» lOblf/A A./ ’V.-'V'""' 'iV' ^ ;^.,U,>>;?- .UtT'» .li\ ' ''>! - x\ , I »■’ * i r • • • ) I. * . f /.i\tv^.A,.l' ii •*?» .<> vV^t 1 V akavitti^^Jk *% •» •' • # • • *^1 i u... ‘ Al’> ' "j J? J S .Ht *,i, '■. ^'viO tinu ^ •jll • 4* , i -i., .. ^ _. ;| ML -.%! Discrimination and Zomng dry of Toronto v. Mendelbaum, [1932] O.R. 552 (H.C.).73 City of Verdun v. Sun Oil Co. Ltd., [1951] S.C.R. 222 . 75 Scarborough Township v. Bondi (1959), 18 D.L.R. (2d) 161 (S.C.C.).76 Bad Faith Re Cadillac Development Corp. and City of Toronto (1974), 1 O.R. (2d) 21 (H.C.79) .... H.G. Winton v. Corporation of the Borough of North York (1978), 6 M.P.L.R. 1 (Ont. Div. Ct.) . 81 The Administration of Zoning By-Laws Polai City of Toronto (1972), 28 D.L.R. (3d) 638 (S.C.C.). 83 V. Prohibiting All Uses R. Gibson Kx Parte Cromiller, [1959] O.W.N. 254 (Ont. H.C.) . 85 V. Corporation of The City of Coquitlam v. Karamanolis (1978), 3 M.P.L.R. 112 (B.C.S.C.) .... 86 Planning and Land Value The Common Law Position Belfast Corporation v. O.D. Cars Ltd., [1960] A.C. 490 (H.L.) . 88 The Current Canadian Position Regina Auto Court v. City of Regina (1958), 25 W.W.R. 167 (Sask. Q.B.). 94 Re Simpson and City of Vancouver (1977), 65 D.L.R. (3d) 669 (S.C.C.) . 96 Hauff et al. v. City of Vancouver (1981), 15 M.P.L.R. 8 (B.C.C.A.). 101 The Charter The Queen in Right of New Brunswick v. Fisherman's Wharf Ltd. (1982), 7 C.R.R. 46 (N.B.C.A.). 104 Negligence Welbridge Holdings Ltd. v. Metropolitan Corporation of Greater Winnipeg (1970), 22 D.L.R. (3d) 470 (S.C.C.) . 107 < ■ ,r,i l'.».:v ^" kvi . .-\ :4'. i • “ ■'■ ■•' .' ‘J '* V .. ^ -’4*^ * '.. -#«c* > * ’• t •■f^'T ...» * »■■ • . ..„.• f r 4 ' •b- * ’ ' .^ •» - ' ^ >.'l ' . -- *u'/lA' jPl O ^-i^'■'"^uy yvA - ty .. S .*’■ 'S' ^ ^ ' ' V.' ' ‘V r»:iCirt.,r . ;n_,. vyv aH • . •' 4 . -V ^ .. (.'^3;^^ r^: itSSi ,;i.j n A. '* "‘■j' -■■ r-'" ^ »>-) ■•J, ' >■ -vf'' ' '■ . V ' t,, 't ‘A.rjwiT’’ 'Y^ ‘t>*i Wi) 't'* .1*'- V''’!f'?‘V ' ‘J’^*-*'*'**'’’ » . “ ** * . , ' p' •'_ i ..> i,‘VM 'c r'9\ t J.is'f * i> .45.H '* ** ■ • ‘ - •'.5'’> i' '. *0> • \ • ' •* T 1# ’ ‘ • ■ ^{v' ♦ ’ * >V('4. > >•’! '.‘!"*.r*% * * 'T.* c»*4:M*Mi4All, o T ‘ ■■ •.♦;■ . ' 4 J jJ f~ , *■' » nt * • I .?;• “, »‘i» .1 jl/ iiM f iu ■fy .,\1 .,. . AF -^SMWK# ^ .»4.vi /# .5^ 1 , i .' ^ .V e O H» - ‘ ^ ^ w i ) • V \w»»'W^>l - v» . . j ..n V «’ ..i»<t«wvO li-b;*/ I-n-t' i*nA 1 - ■•* ff. * *■ »' ^ *r;rtM^ '•' *'«J niTT ) ■f' ■f ■ ^ i ’•♦AO If . \x\X At.'l .CJ ’♦ P',A* ’ ♦v ' • ■•.r» ’# *1’..•.! '^» 1 •*4 (v»ii*'>' 'i -'Mihun,'^ t » -It* ai»T_ ( ^ try (,»i 0 ^ ^ ^ » '•• ''A V' •■' ^ I <N!» fUli A. i.A3 'VAi \rifrV:i V»^»v i> V " , . i.0.>O'?i S !v i u>*) ' \ } \ ( ■• i an ■ ♦ I ) 'i.X \,«4i\^ ’ if - ^ '/ V> u.* t n j -K* , ' . ;» .4, I.Au3 >*1^ H>>* i* ^ 4* :^r £: ^r _0 " i-i . * ..:Vjl'. ■t.,'. <4 11 iOVOn -.v.vi^^^.aolfv. .‘.■' ■’ "'• .*4<j«i'''-W'. .v.jcvtJk -JvdwnAhi^ ^ ■ • ., .. O' ! ■ ! i. ♦ m. 1 i ’ A 'v*l^ 'jS! » —A •- ■' ^■^ ' f |4i*. MM fll. .>. I*

See more

The list of books you might like

Upgrade Premium
Most books are stored in the elastic cloud where traffic is expensive. For this reason, we have a limit on daily download.
DMCA & Copyright: Dear all, most of the website is community built, users are uploading hundred of books everyday, which makes really hard for us to identify copyrighted material, please contact us if you want any material removed.
Copyright @ PDFdrive.to, 2022 | We love our users