Table Of Content

Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics The International Journal for Healthcare Ethics and Ethics Committees Volume 14, 2005 Author Index and Contents Cambridge University Press EDITORS Thomasine Kushner, PhD, Ur Steve Heilig, MPH, San Francis David C. Thomasma, PhD, Co-Editor, 1992-2002 THE DAVID C. THOMASMA INTERNATIONAL BIOETHICS RETREAT Doris Thomasma rdinator —_—_—_——— COLUMN EDITORS Cambridge Bette Anton, CQ Sour —__—_—_—_—— Courtney S. Campbell, Bi Quarterly of KennethV . Iserson, Abst quianiiandnnsitesieaiiontn Tes Andrew Jameton, Globa Greg S. Loeben, CQ Revieu Charles MacKay, Genethics Glenn McGee, Breaking Bioetl Robert Schwartz and Ben Rich Doris Schroeder, Health and H The International Tuija Takala and Matti Hayry Journal for Griffin Trotter, Bioethics and I Healthcare Ethics EDITORIAL BOARD and Ethics Chair: Tuija Takala Committees Akira Akabayashi, Kyot William Andereck Kenneth M. Boyd EAI OM AEE Daniel Callahan Arthur Caplar Andrew Dobson, k Veronique Fournier, Cent Amnon Goldworth, St Chris Hackler, D John Harris, Un Matti Hayry, Sc/ Paul Hofmann Albert Jonsen Gerrit K. Kimsma Helga Kuhse, Cent Glenn McGee, Cent Jonathan D. Moreno Edmund D. Pellegrino, G Rosamond Rhodes, Mount Gerd Richter, Philipps Lawrence J. Schneiderman Richard Selzer, Y Un Robyn Shapiro, ( Pavel Tichtchenko Griffin Trotter, Cent Evert van Leeuwen, Vr Baroness Mary Warnock, G EDITORIAL OFFICE: Editorial correspondence, including manuscript submission, should be addressed to Thomasine Kushner, PhD To facilitate review, Ip lease submit manuscriptFs as electronic copy} , Ip referably in MS Word, to [email protected] SUBSCRIPTION INFORMATION: Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics (ISSN 0963-1801) is published quarterly, in January, April, July and October by Cambridge University Press, 40 West 20th Street, New York, NY 10011-4211 /Cambridge University Press, The Edinburgh Shaftesbury Road, Cambridge CB2 2RU, UK. Annual subscription rates for volume 14 (2005): Institutional rate, print and online: $11 89 in the USA, Canada, and Mexico; £116 elsewhere. Institutional rate. online only: $158 in the USA, Canada, and Mexico; £97 elsewhere Institutional rate, print only: $170 in the USA, Canada, and Mexico; £102 elsewhere. Individual rate, print only: $75 in the USA, Canada and Mexico; £47 elsewhere. Single part: $46 in the USA, Canada, and Mexico; £28 elsewhere. Prices include postage. Subscription offices Cambridge University Press, 100 Brook Hill Drive, West Nyack, NY 10994-2133, USA; outside the USA, Canada, and Mexico: Cambridge University Press, The Edinburgh Building, Shaftesbury Road, Cambridge CB2 2RU, UK. Claims for missing issues should be made immediately after receipt of the next issue. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics and other Cambridge journals can be found at http journals.cambridge.org Periodicals postage paid at New York, NY and additional mailing offices. POSTMASTER: Send address changes in the USA, Canax and Mexico to Cambridg uarterly of I hea Cambridge University Press, 100 Brook Hill Drive, West Nyack, NY 10994-21 2 Send address changes elsewhere to Cambridg ( y Healthcare Ethics, Cambridge University Press, The Edinburgh Building Shaftesbury Road, Cambridge CB2 2RU, UK Copyright © 2005 Cambridge University Press. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics is indexed in Index Medicus and in the ASSIA ISI, MEDLINE, Philosopher’s Index, and Proquest databases *hotecopying information for users in the USA: The Item-Fee Code for this publication indicates that copying for internal or personal use beyond that permitted by Section 107 or 108 of the US Copyright Law is authorized for users duly registered with the Copyright Clearance Center (CCC) Transactional Reporting Service, provided that the appropriate remittance of $16.00 per article is paid directly to: CCC, 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923. Specific written permission must be obtained from the publisher for all other copying. The Item-Fee Code for this journal is 0963-1801/05 $16.00 ISI Tearsheet Service, 3501 Market Street, Philadelphia, PA 19104, USA is authorized to supply single copies of separate articles for private use only. Article reprints are available from the authors. For orders of 50 or more reprints, contact Cambridge University Press Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 2005 Author Index Akabayashi, Akira, 277 Jafarey, Aamir M., 249 Anton, Bette, 189, 298, 432 Keenan, James F., 416 Arnason, Vilhjalmur, 322 Kimsma, Gerrit K., 292 Brody, Howard, 141 Browne, Alister, 287 Ladikas, Miltos, 404 Callahan, Daniel, 424 McConnell, Terrance, 47 Churchill, Larry R., 389 Mills, Ann E., 57 Moazam, Farhat, 249 Davis, Walt, 57 Nagy, John D., 119 Denier, Yvonne, 224 Dudzinski, Denise M., 464 Nativio, Donna G., 47 Eckenwiler, Lisa, 306 Rhodes, Rosamond, 13 Elger, Bernice S., 329 Rich, Ben A., 27 Elliott, Carl, 379 Ross, Lainie Friedman, 191 Fins, Joseph J., 207, 434 Schenck, David, 389 Fournier, Veronique, 281 Schneiderman, Lawrence J., 235 Fox, Renée C., 361 Schroeder, Doris, 218, 221, 404 Scott, Rosamund, 65 Garchar, Kimberly, 147 Sevick, Mary Ann, 47 Gillon, Raanan, 100 Slingsby, Brian Taylor, 277 Giordano, Simona, 83 Spital, Aaron, 107, 195 Glannon, Walter, 191 Steinberg, David, 301 Goldworth, Amnon, 346 Sullivan, Bill, 287 Gross, Michael L., 444 Swazey, Judith P., 361 Gundle, Kenneth, 113 Takala, Tuija, 385 Hall, Mark A., 156 Takimoto, Yoshiyuki, 277 Halldenius, Lena, 455 Tereskerz, Patricia, 57 Harris, John, 93 [rotter, Griffin, 131, 316 Hawkins, Anne Hunsaker, 40 Turner, Leigh, 374 Hayry, Matti, 7, 199 Heilig, Steve, 214 van Leeuwen, Evert, 292 Hellsten, Sirkku K., 256 Waller, Bruce N., 177 Herissone-Kelly, Peter, 268 Wildes, Kevin Wm., 168 Iserson, Kenneth V., 125, 240, 352, 468 Young, Judith Schaeffer, 432 Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics Volume 14, Number 1, Winter 2005 CONTENTS Contributors Special Section: Open Forum From the Editors A Defense of Ethical Relativism Matti HAyry Justice in Medicine and Public Health ROSAMOND RHODES Medical Custom and Medical Ethics: Rethinking the Standard of Care BEN A. RICH Epiphanic Knowledge and Medicine ANNE HUNSAKER HAWKINS Genetic Testing of Children for Late Onset Disease Mary ANN SEVICK, DONNA G. NATIVIO, AND TERRANCE MCCONNELI Is Evaluating Ethics Consultation on the Basis of Cost a Good Idea? ANN E. MILLs, PATRICIA TERESKERZ, AND WALT DAVIS Prenatal Testing, Reproductive Autonomy, and Disability Interests ROSAMUND SCOTTI Respect for Equality and the Treatment of the Elderly: Declarations of Human Rights and Age-Based Rationing SIMONA GIORDANO [The Age-Indifference Principle and Equality JOHN HARRIS Departments and Columns Dissecting Bioethics TuljA TAKALA AND MattT1 HAyry Toleration and Healthcare Ethics RAANAN GILLON Perspectives Conscription of Cadaveric Organs for Transplantation: A Stimulating Idea Whose Time Has Not Yet Come AARON SPITAI Presumed Consent: An International Comparison and Possibilities for Change in the United States KENNETH GUNDLI CQ Review GREG LOEBEN Dicing with Death: Chance, Risk and Health, by Stephen Senn Reviewed by JOHN D. Nacy Abstracts of Note: The Bioethics Literature KENNETH V. ISERSON IV Contents continued Volume 14, Number 2, Spring 2005 CONTENTS Contributors Special Section: Patient Ethics Guest Editorial: Of Lotteries Lost and Partnerships Forged: The Perils and Promises of Patient Ethics GRIFFIN TROTTER Patient Ethics and Evidence-Based Medicine—The Good Healthcare Citizen HOWARD Bropy The Loyal Patient at the End of Life: A Roycean Argument for Assisted Suicide KIMBERLY GARCHAR The Importance of Trust for Ethics, Law, and Public Policy Mark A. HALL Patients: The Rosetta Stone in the Crisis of Medicine KEVIN Wo. WILDES Responsibility and Health Bruce N. WALLER CQ Sources/Bibliography BETTE ANTON Departments and Columns Responses and Dialogue Response to “Intrafamilial Organ Donation Is Often an Altruistic Act” by Aaron Spital (CQ Vol 12, No 1) and “Donor Benefit Is the Key to Justified Living Organ Donation,” by Aaron Spital (CQ Vol 13, No 1) Motivation, Risk, and Benefit in Living Organ Donation: A Reply to Aaron Spital WALTER GLANNON AND LAINIE FRIEDMAN Ross Reply to Glannon and Ross AARON SPITAL Dissecting Bioethics Tu1jA TAKALA AND Matti HAyry Precaution and Solidarity Matti HAyry Changing Places Everyday Disasters JosEPH J. FIns CQ Interview Stem Cell Science and Politics: A Talk with Elizabeth Blackburn STEVE HEILIG Health and Human Rights Editorial Doris SCHROEDER Contents continued Human Rights and Their Role in Global Bioethics Doris SCHROEDER On Personal Responsibility and the Human Right to Healthcare YVONNE DENIER Perspec tives The Perils of Hope LAWRENCE J]. SCHNEIDERMAN Abstracts of Note: The Bioethics Literature KENNETH V. ISERSON Volume 14, Number 53 , Summer 2005 CONTENTS Contributors Special Section: International Voices From the Editors Pakistan and Biomedical Ethics: Report from a Muslim Country FARHAT MOAZAM AND AAMIR M. JAFAREY Bioethics in Tanzania: Legal and Ethical Concerns in Medical Care and Research in Relation to the HIV/AIDS Epidemic SIRKKU K. HELLSTEN The Cloning Debate in the United Kingdom: The Academy Meets the Public PETER HERISSONE-KELLY Conflict of Interest: A Japanese Perspective AKIRA AKABAYASHI, BRIAN TAYLOR SLINGSBY, AND YOSHIYUKI TAKIMOTO The Balance between Beneficence and Respect for Patient Autonomy in Clinical Medical Ethics in France VERONIQUE FOURNIER Abortion in Canada ALISTER BROWNE AND BILL SULLIVAN Shifts in the Direction of Dutch Bioethics: Forward or Backward? GERRIT K. KIMSMA AND EVERT VAN LEEUWEN CQ Sources/Bibliography BetTE ANTON Departments and Columns Responses and Dialogue Response to “Special Section: Children as Organ Donors” (CQ Vol 13, No 2) A Critique DAVID STEINBERG Bioethics and Defense Ethics and the Underpinnings of Policy in Biodefense and Emergency Preparedness LisA ECKENWILER VI Contents continued What Jurisdiction? Whose Justice? A Response to Eckenwiler GRIFFIN TROTTER Dissecting Bioethics TuljA TAKALA AND Matti HAyry Sensible Discussion in Bioethics: Reflections on Interdisciplinary Research VILHJALMUR ARNASON Ethics of Human Research CHARLES MacKay Attitudes of Future Lawyers and Psychologists to the Use of Genetic Testing for Criminal Behavior BERNICE S. ELGER Perspectives Disease, Illness, and Medical Ethics AMNON GOLDWORTH Abstracts of Note: The Bioethics Literature KENNETH V. ISERSON Volume 14, Number 4, Fall 2005 CONTENTS Contributors Special Section: Quo Vadis? Mapping the Future of Bioethics From the Editors Examining American Bioethics: Its Problems and Prospects RENEE C. Fox AND JUDITH P. SWAZEY Bioethics, Social Class, and the Sociological Imagination LEIGH TURNER The Soul of a New Machine: Bioethicists in the Bureaucracy CARL ELLIOTT Demagogues, Firefighters, and Window Dressers: Who Are We and What Should We Be? TuryjA TAKALA One Cheer for Bioethics: Engaging the Moral Experiences of Patients and Practitioners Beyond the Big Decisions LARRY R. CHURCHILL AND DAvID SCHENCK Too Early for Global Ethics? Mittos LADIKAS AND DorRIs SCHROEDER Developments in Bioethics from the Perspective of HIV/AIDS JAMES F. KEENAN Bioethics and the Culture Wars DANIEL CALLAHAN Contents continued CQ Sources/Bibliography BETTE ANTON AND JUDITH SCHAEFFER YOUNG Departments and Columns The 2005 David Thomasma Lecture Baseball and Bioethics JosEPH J. Fins Bioethics and Defense GRIFFIN TROTTER Physician-Assisted Draft Evasion: Civil Disobedience, Medicine, and War MICHAEL L. Gross Dissecting Bioethics TuljA TAKALA AND Matti HAyry Dissecting “Discrimination” LENA HALLDENIUS CQ Review GREG LOEBEN Organizational Ethics in Health Care: Principles, Cases, and Practical Solutions, by Philip J. Boyle, Edwin R. DuBose, Stephen J. Ellingson, David E. Guinn, and David B. McCurdy Reviewed by DENIsE M. DuDZINSKI Abstracts of Note: The Bioethics Literature KENNETH V. ISERSON Author Index and Contents for Volume 14