Table Of Content

Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics Volume 11, Number 1, Winter 2002 CONTENTS Ge” st * CEUdlirtoorriidqi Moral Consensus in Bioethics: Illusive or Just Elusive? GRIFFIN TROTTER Contributors Consensus Formation: The Creation of an Ideology H. TRISTRAM ENGELHARDT, JR Narrative as Bioethics: The “Fact ocial Selves and the Function of Consensus D. MicAH HESTER Iwo Models of Ethical Consensus, Or What Good Is a Bunch of Bioethicists? MARK KUCZEWSKI Bioethics and Healthcare Reform: A Whig Response to Weak Consensus GRIFFIN TROTTER Keeping Company: Ethics and the Talk in the Commons LAURIE ZOLOTH Making Sense of Consensus: Responses to Engelhardt Kuczewski Irotter, and Zoloth JONATHAN D. MORENO \ UO Sources/bil BETTE ANTON , Response to “Cutting Bodies to Harvest Organs by John Portmann (CQ Vol 8, No 3) Autonomy as Scapegoat in the Organ Shortage Debate: A Reply to Portmann .. L. ZUTLEVICS Response to “Autonomy as Scapegoat in the Organ Shortage Debate \ Reply to Portmann” by T. L. Zutlevics The Paths of Our Organs JOHN PORTMANN Response to “May a Woman Clone Herself? by Jean Chambers (CQ Vol 10, No 2) and “Entitlement to Cloning’ by Timothy F. Murphy (CQ Vol 8, No 3) Clone Alone CARSON STRONG I\ Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics Volume 11, Number 1, Winter 2002 CONTENTS Ge” st * CEUdlirtoorriidqi Moral Consensus in Bioethics: Illusive or Just Elusive? GRIFFIN TROTTER Contributors Consensus Formation: The Creation of an Ideology H. TRISTRAM ENGELHARDT, JR Narrative as Bioethics: The “Fact ocial Selves and the Function of Consensus D. MicAH HESTER Iwo Models of Ethical Consensus, Or What Good Is a Bunch of Bioethicists? MARK KUCZEWSKI Bioethics and Healthcare Reform: A Whig Response to Weak Consensus GRIFFIN TROTTER Keeping Company: Ethics and the Talk in the Commons LAURIE ZOLOTH Making Sense of Consensus: Responses to Engelhardt Kuczewski Irotter, and Zoloth JONATHAN D. MORENO \ UO Sources/bil BETTE ANTON , Response to “Cutting Bodies to Harvest Organs by John Portmann (CQ Vol 8, No 3) Autonomy as Scapegoat in the Organ Shortage Debate: A Reply to Portmann .. L. ZUTLEVICS Response to “Autonomy as Scapegoat in the Organ Shortage Debate \ Reply to Portmann” by T. L. Zutlevics The Paths of Our Organs JOHN PORTMANN Response to “May a Woman Clone Herself? by Jean Chambers (CQ Vol 10, No 2) and “Entitlement to Cloning’ by Timothy F. Murphy (CQ Vol 8, No 3) Clone Alone CARSON STRONG I\ Contents continued Response to “May a Woman Clone Herself?” by Jean Chambers (CQ Vol 10, No 2) Are There Limits to the Use of Reproductive Cloning? TrimotTHy F. MURPHY Breaking Bioethics Successes and Failures of Hospital Ethics Committees: A National Survey of Ethics Committee Chairs GLENN MCGEz, JOSHUA P. SPANOGLE, ARTHUR L. CAPLAN, DINA PENNY, AND Davip A. ASCH Patient Productivity as a Value and a Variable in Geriatric Healthcare Allocation KATRINA A. BRAMSTEDT CQ Interviex Chris Shaw on Ethical Issues in Biotechnology THOMASINE KUSHNER CO Revieu GREG S. LOEBEN Genetic Dilemmas: Reproductive Techn Futures, by Dena Davis Reviewed by JEFFREY R.> BOTKIN Abstrac ts of Noté I } I 1 ethics Literature Kenneth V. Iserson Announcement: 5th International Bioethics Retreat Volume 11, Number 2, Spring 2002 CONTENTS Constructing the Human Dance of Meaning KATHERINE H. BROWN Contributors Sp} ecial Section: Meanings andsa Contexts: Anattlh ropologic; al; Per> spec> tiv; es> in Bioetofh] ics Ambiguity and Hope: Disclosure Preferences of Less Acculturated Elderly Mexican Americans Concerning Terminal Cancer—A Case Story GELYA FRANK, LESLIE J]. BLACKHALL, SHEILA T. MuRPHy, VICKI MICHEL, STANLEY P. AZEN, HAYDEE MABEL PRELORAN, AND CAROLE H. BROWNER Reading Futility: Reflections on a Bioethical Concept DONALD JORALEMON What “Race” Cannot Tell Us about Access to Kidney Transplantation ELISA J. GORDON Contents continued Denying Culture in the Transplant Arena: Technocratic Medicine’s Myth of Democratization LesLEY A. SHARP CQ Sources/Bibliography BETTE ANTON Articles Do Genetic Relationships Create Moral Obligations in Organ Transplantation? WALTER GLANNON AND LAINIE FRIEDMAN Ross Adults Are Not Big Children: Examining Surrogate Consent to Research Using Adults with Dementia MARK YARBOROUGH Departments and Columns Responses and Dialogue Response to “Clone Alone” by Carson Strong and “Are There Limits to the Use of Reproductive Cloning?” by Timothy Murphy (CQ Vol 11, No 1) Equal Access to Cloning? JEAN E. CHAMBERS The Caduceus in Court Moral Conundrums in the Courtroom Reflections on a Decade in the Culture of Pain BEN A. RICH Perspec tives Compassionate Utilitarianism The Unknown Bentham Revealed AMNON GOLDWORTH CQ Reviews GREG S. LOEBEN Return to Reason, by Stephen Toulmin Reviewed by GILES SCOFIELD Culture of Death: The Assault on Medical Ethics in America, by Wesley ]. Smith Reviewed by RusseELL BuRCK Global Bioethics Healthcare without Harm: An Ethical Imperative a ‘ os ih. ’ piesns Abstracts of Note: The Bioethics Literature KENNETH V. ISERSON Volume 11, Number 3, Summer 2002 CONTENTS From the Editors Contributors VI Contents continued Special Section: Autonomy: The Delicate Balance Walking the Moral Tightrope: Respecting and Protecting Children in Health-Related Research PAUL B. MILLER AND NUALA P. KENNY Mental Competence, Caregivers, and the Process of Consent: Research Involving Alzheimer’s Patients or Others with Decreasing Mental Capacity Davip E. GUINN Genetic Testing MICHAEL BOYLAN The Psychological Structure of Patient Autonomy Bruce N. WALLER Can There Be a “Duty to Die” without a Normative Theory? GARY SEAY The Virtue of Moral Responsibility in Healthcare Decisionmaking CANDACE CUMMINS GAUTHIER Relational Professional Autonomy CHRIS MACDONALD CQ Sources/Bibliography JUDITH SCHAEFFER YOUNG Departments and Columns The Caduceus in Court The Tyranny of Judicial Formalism: Oral Directives and the Clear and Convincing Evidence Standard BEN A. RICH Health and Human Rights Asylum Evaluations—The Physician’s Dilemma HARVEY WEINSTEIN AND ERIC STOVER When Ethics, Healthcare, and Human Rights Conflict: Mental Healthcare for Asylum Seekers ANNEMIEK RICHTERS Abstracts of Note: The Bioethics Literature KENNETH V. ISERSON Volume 11, Number 4, Fall 2002 CONTENTS Dedication: David C. Thomasma, Ph.D. Editorial Reflections David C. Thomasma Contributors Contents continued pec ial Section: First Voices Van Rensselaer Potter: A Memoriam GERALD M. LOwER, JR. Van Rensselaer Potter: An Intellectual Memoir PETER J]. WHITEHOUSI Early Bioethics DavipC . THOMASMA The Birth of Bioethics: Autobiographical Reflections of a Patient Person ROBERT M. VEATCH Harmless Error and Other Forays into Bioethics JOHN J. PARIS The Accidental Bioethicist LAURENCE B. MCCULLOUGH From Metaethicist to Bioethicist ROBERT BAKER As Time Goes By: Twenty-Five Years of Bioethics KEVIN O’ROURKI Bioethics: Past, Present, and an Open Future EricH H. Loewy CO Sources/Bibl« BETTE ANTON Art ici¢ Reproductive Technologies as Instruments of Meaningful Parenting Ethics in the Age of ARTs D. MIcAH HESTER Departments and Columns } Bioethics and Defense Of Terrorism and Healthcare: Jolting the Old Habits GRIFFIN TROTTER CO Review GREG S. LOEBEN Anatomy of Anatomy, by Meryl! Levin Reviewed by JACK COULEHAN Perspectives Will Social Values Influence the Development of HMOs? JOHN B. DAvis JOSEPH C. D’ORONZIO The Case: The Suicide Note Commentary: DAavip LOWENTHAI Commentary: CATHERINE A. MARCO Commentary: ROBERT S. OLICK What Actually Happened VIII Contents continued Bedside Story Reflections on a Hospice Memorial Service STEVE HEILIG Abstracts of Note: The Bioethics Literature KENNETH V. ISERSON Author Index and Contents for Volume 11