PROC. ENTOMOL. SOC. WASH. 101(3), 1999, pp. 514-521 BIOLOGY AND IMMATURE STAGES OF TWO SPECIES OF HYDROPTILA DALMAN (TRICHOPTERA: HYDROPTILIDAE) WHICH CONSUME CLADOPHORA (CHLOROPHYTA) J. B. Keiper and B. a. Foote Department of Biological Sciences, Kent State University, Kent, OH 44242-0001, U.S.A.; (JBK) current address: Department ofEntomology, University ofCalifornia, Riv- CA erside, 92521, U.S.A. (e-mail: [email protected]) — Abstract. Adults ofHydroptila armata Ross and H. perdita Morton (Trichoptera: Hy- droptilidae) are often taken near streams, but information on their immature stages is lacking. Field-collected females laid eggs in the laboratory, and the larvae were reared to the adult stage. Larvae of both species consumed the liquid contents of individual cells of Cladophora (Chlorophyta) by piercing cell walls with their asymmetrical mandibles; early instars of H. armata also occasionally removed epiphytic diatoms and consumed them. Final instars of both species used algal filaments and silk secretions to construct cases, and H. perdita incorporated mineral and detrital material as well. Hypermetamor- phosis was exhibited by each species; instars 1-4 were completed rapidly (2-6 d each), whereas the final stadium was of longer duration (9-16 d). Cases were attached to rocks and sealed prior to pupation. The total duration of the immature stages (egg, larva, pupa) under laboratory conditions (~20°C; 12:12 L/D) was 43-54 d for H. armata and 36-47 d for H. perdita. The immature stages are described. Key Words: Hydroptila armata, Hydroptila perdita, microcaddisflies, aquatic insects, streams, algae, Cladophora, rearing The immature stages of most species of lian (Wells 1985), European (Nielsen 1948, Trichoptera are unknown despite ample at- Lepneva 1964, Solem 1972), and Japanese tention by aquatic entomologists (Wiggins (Ito and Kawamura 1980) hydroptilid fau- 1990, 1996). The species richness ofmicro- nas are somewhat better understood, caddisflies (Hydroptilidae) is second only to Hydroptila Dalman contains over 100 the Limnephilidae, with some 311 species species from North America (Morse 1993). reported from North America, Mexico, and Ross (1944) gave brief descriptions of the Greenland (Morse 1993). A number of fifth instars of a number of species from studies of larval biology and morphology Illinois, including H. armata Ross; the lar- of Nearctic species have been conducted va ofH. perdita Morton was previously un- (Ross 1944, Flint 1962, Flint and Herrman known. Adults of both species have been 1976, McAuliffe 1982, Vaillant 1984, Hu- collected near streams (Ross 1944, Huryn ryn 1985, Resh and Houp 1986, EngHsh and Foote 1983). Herein, we give biological and Hamilton 1986, Keiperet al. 1998, Kei- and morphological information on H. ar- per and Foote 1998), but descriptions ofthe mata and H. perdita obtained during labo- immature stages which include the early in- ratory rearings initiated from eggs laid by stars have not been published. The Austra- field-collected females. VOLUME NUMBER 101. 3 515 Materials and Methods water, small rocks, algae, and mineral and detrital material to facilitate case building. To initiate rearing, adult females were Illustrations of the immature stages were taken with an aspirator from a sheet illu- initiated by obtaining a tagged image for- minated with an ultraviolet collecting light. mat (TIF) computer file using a low light Collecting vials (containing live females) camera (Optronics Engineering DEI-470) were placed in a cooler with ice for trans- mounted on the Wild scope or a Leica com- port back to the laboratory. Hydroptila ar- pound microscope, and Image Pro Plus im- mata was taken at the Hocking River, 1 km age analysis software for IBM. To acquire west ofNelsonville, Ohio (Athens Co.), and images at high power (lOOX), larvae were H. perdita was collected at the Little Miami placed on a microscope slide to which a River near Fort Ancient State Memorial drop of glycerol was added and viewed (Ohio, Warren Co.). with the compound scope. TIF images were In the laboratory, adults were narcotized printed and traced or used as a reference. with CO2, and females were pierced Measurements were obtained using the Im- through the mesostemum with a number 3 age Pro Plus software. Physical descriptions insect pin when signs ofrevival were noted. and head capsule width measurements were This caused some females to dump their taken from 10 specimens for each instar, eggs in a mass or chain, and we transferred and other measurements were obtained these adults with their eggs to individual from one specimen per instar. Petri dishes containing stream water. Fe- males were allowed to float on the surface Results overnight until the completion of egg lay- Biology of Hydroptila armata Ross ing, and then preserved in 70% ethanol. Eggs were also allowed to float on the sur- Approximately 100 eggs were obtained face until larval eye spots appeared. Small from the single H. armata induced to ovi- masses of the filamentous alga Cladophora posit. Eggs were ovoid, colorless, without w(Cehrleorroipnhsyetda)gecnotlllyecwtietdhfrdiosmtillloecdalwsattreeramtso 0su.r1f3a5cemmmark(inng=s, 1a5n).d Emgegassurweedre0.l1a5i0d iXn remove any invertebrates present, placed in chains, but spread singly over the surface the dishes, and the eggs submerged among of the water when the female was placed in the Petri dish. After 5 d of incubation, the the filaments. All Petri dishes were kept at —20° C, and a 12:12 light darkphotoperiod developing embryo was observed clearly : through the chorion, and dark eye spots be- maintained. came apparent after 6 d. After 7 d, dark Larval behavior and feeding habits were setae were seen pressed against the inside observed at 6-50X with a Wild M5 dis- of the chorion, and the first hatching oc- secting microscope. Early instars (1-4) curred approximately 12-24 h after these were determined by direct observation of setae were first observed. The remaining molts. Ifenough larvae were available, rep- eggs hatched after 8 d, giving an incubation resentatives ofeach stadium were collected, period of 7-8 d at ~20°C. fixed with Kahle's solution, and preserved First instars moved among filaments of in 70% ethanol following the methods of Cladophora, and appeared to feed almost Wiggins (1996). The water was changed exclusively on the apical cells of filaments. every other day, and the algal food source Larvae consumed the contents ofalgal cells was replenished when necessary. Upon at- by piercing them with their mandibles and taining the fifth (and final) instar, larvae removing the fluid protoplast. Early instars were transferred to aerated rearing cham- executed up to 25 bites before piercing a bers (Keiper and Foote 1996) with stream cell and obtaining its contents. One larva 516 PROCEEDINGS OF THE ENTOMOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON grasped a cell with its mandibles in a sym- strongly. In contrast, the inner edge of the metrical orientation, and quickly pulled its left mandible adducted slightly, pressing the head away, tearing off a piece of the cell cell to the mouth of the larva. A bite was wall. This was discarded, and the larva re- facilitated with a counterclockwise twist of sumed its series of bites. the head (when viewed dorsally) approxi- Several larvae used their mandibles to mately 20-30°, which applied leverage to occasionally remove epiphytic diatoms the force of the right mandible. Epiphytic from filaments of Cladophora by placing diatom consumption by final instars was not the tips of their mandibles on both ends of observed. the elliptical frustule, and prying it from the The duration ofthe five instars under lab- filament. Larval guts were consistently dark oratory conditions was 4-6, 5-6, 4-6, 4- green from consumption of Cladophora 6, and 12-16 d, while the pupal duration protoplast, therefore it appears that diatoms was 7-8 d. The total duration of the im- constituted only a minor proportion of the mature stages (egg, larva, and pupa) was diet of H. armata. 43-54 d, with a larval/pupal period of 36- Fifth instars constructed cases composed 48 d. of two valves, similar in shape to that il- lustrated by Wiggins (1996). Approximate- Biology of Hydroptila perdita Morton ly 85% of the case material was short fila- ments of Cladophora, and only 15% was Three females induced to oviposit pro- mineral particles bound together by silken duced 11, 115, and 175 (jf = 100.3) eggs, secretions. Larvae occasionally "un- respectively, which were scattered loosely stitched" the ventral edge of their cases, over the water surface. The first eggs and added more material before reattaching hatched after 9-12 d of incubation. The the valves, thus accommodating the in- newly-hatched larvae immediately began to creasing girth of the abdomen as the larva feed mostly on the contents of the apical accumulated food reserves (see Nielsen cells within filaments of Cladophora. All 1948). instars fed in a manner similar to that de- Completed cases were approximately 3.4 scribed for H. armata, although epiphytic mm in length, and ranged from 0.735- diatom consumption was never observed. 0.887 mm in height. Larvae laid down lay- Case building commenced within 24 h of ers of silken secretions to form a cocoon on molting into the fifth instar. This species ap- the inside walls of cases. These bouts of peared to be generalized in its case material activity were executed an undetermined requirements, utilizing algal filaments, sand number oftimes prior to attaching and seal- grains, and detrital material in approximate- ing their cases, each lasting approximately ly equal amounts. One individual even in- 3-10 minutes. Bouts were spread out over corporated what seemed to be a blue carpet a period of several days. or clothing fiber which fell into the rearing Fifth instars pierced individual cells chamber. Otherwise, construction and shape within filaments of Cladophora with their resembled that of H. armata. Larvae at- asymmetrical mandibles (see below); the tached their cases to stones within the rear- right mandible is pointed and was used to ing chambers or the rearing chamber wall puncture individual cells, while the left one and floor, and sealed them priorto pupation. has a serrated inner edge, and apparently The duration ofthe five instars under lab- was used to maintain a grip on the cell oratory conditions was 2-4, 3-4, 2-3, 2-3, when a biting motion was executed. During and 9-12 d, while the pupal duration was a bite, each mandible adducted to different 9-10 d. The total duration of the immature degrees. The point of the right mandible stages (egg, larva, and pupa) was 36-47 d, was inserted into the cell wall and adducted with a larval/pupal period of 27-36 d. VOLUME NUMBER 101, 3 517 Figs. 1-5. Hydroptilaannata. 1,Third instar, lateral view. 2, Fifthinstar, lateral view. 3, Prosternum,anterior up. 4, Left and right mandibles, ventral view. 5, Fore leg, lateral view. Description of Larval Hydroptila annata prothorax, 0.070 mm; mesothorax, 0.073 Ross mm; metathorax 0.086 mm; abdominal seg- First two instars with colorless, un- ment 1, 0.034 mm; segment 2, 0.034 mm; marked head capsules, black eye spots, and segment 3, 0.033 mm; segment 4, 0.035 black setation; bodies dorsoventrally flat- mm; segment 5, 0.030 mm; segment 6, tened. Instars three and four with slight but 0.032 mm; segment 7, 0.038 mm; segment noticeable darkening of sclerites. Body 8, 0.040 mm; segments 9 and 10, 0.042 round in cross section. Head capsule and mm. — thoracic nota covered with dense pile visi- Second instar. Measurements not taken, ble at high magnification only. Head cap- but size increas—e proportional to first instar. sule dimension—s given in Table 1. Third instar. Total length, 2.260 mm; First instar. Total length, 0.692 mm; prothorax, 0.224 mm; mesothorax, 0.258 Table 1. Head width range, median, and factor of increase' of H. annata and H. perdita. 518 PROCEEDINGS OF THE ENTOMOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON mm; metathorax, 0.224 mm; abdominal Description of Larval Hydroptila perdita segment 1, 0.125; segment 2, 0.125; seg- Morton ment 3, 0.143; segment 4, 0.110 mm; seg- Bodies of instars one and two somewhat ment 5, 0.130 mm; segment 6, 0.121 mm; flattened dorsoventrally. Instars three and segment 7, 0.139 mm; segment 8, 0.130 mm; segments 9 and 10, 0.192 mm (Fig. fscoluerriwtiest;hbsolidgyhtrbouutndnoitnicceraobslsesdecatrikoenn.iHngeaodf 1). — capsule and thoracic nota covered with Fourth instar. (Only one specimen ob- dense pile visible at high magnification tained, and placed in 70% ethanol which only. Head capsule dimensions given in Ta- appears to have caused the specimen to contract.) Total length, 1.861 mm; protho- bleFi1r.st instar.—Total length, 0.570 mm; rax, 0.258 mm; mesothorax, 0.177 mm; prothorax, 0.070 mm; mesothorax, 0.070 metathorax, 0.157 mm; abdominal segment mm; metathorax, 0.050 mm; abdominal m1,en0t.037,80m.0m6;3 msemg;mesnetgm2,en0t.048,90.m0m51; msemg;- msemg;menstegm1,en0t.023,1 0m.m03;3 smemgm;ensteg2m,en0t.0244, segment 5, 0.087; segment 6, 0.066 mm; 0.039 mm; segment 5, 0.027 mm; segment segment 7, 0.113 mm; segment 8, 0.128 6, 0.023 mm; segment 7, 0.025 mm; seg- mm; segments—9 and 10, 0.172 mm. ment 8, 0.036 mm; segments 9 and 10, Fifth instar. Total length, 4.022 mm; 0.036 mm; central gill, 0.135 mm; lateral prothorax, 0.094 mm; mesothorax, 0.102 gills, 0.150 mm (Fig. 6). Head capsule uni- mm; metathorax, 0.137 mm; abdominal formly dull yellow, unmarked, and darker segment 1, 0.085 mm; segment 2, 0.102 than rest of body; eye spots dark; setae mm; segment 3, 0.137 mm; segment 4, black. 0.599 mm; segment 5, 0.609 mm; segment Second, third, and fourth instars.—Mea- 6, 0.665 mm; segment 7, 0.466 mm; seg- surements not taken, but size increase pro- ment 8, 0.381 mm; segments 9 and 10. portional in successive instars. Head cap- 0.463 mm. Head capsule and thoracic nota sule yellowish, darkening slightly with age. — with yellowish-brown base color and black Fifth instar Total length, 2.62 mm; pro- banding pattern (Fig. 2); recently-molted thorax, 0.150 mm; mesothorax, 0.125 mm; fifth instars without dark banding pattern on metathorax, 0.140 mm; abdominal segment thoracic sclerites and head capsule. Two 1, 0.070 mm; segment 2, 0.170 mm; seg- small triangular prosternal sclerites poste- ment 3, 0.215 mm; segment 4, 0.305 mm; riorly, concolorous with other sclerites (Fig. segment 5, 0.285 mm; segment 6, 0.265 3). Mandibles asymmetrical and without se- mm; segment 7, 0.215 mm; segment 8, tae; right mandible pointed apically with 0.250 mm; segments 9 and 10, 0.165 mm; small subapical tooth; left one with inner central gill, 0.458 mm; lateral gills, 0.410 edge finely serrated (Fig. 4). Fore tarsus mm. Head capsule uniformly dull yellow with a long subapical dorsal seta, approxi- and unmarked (Fig. 7). Three prosternal mately twice length of tarsal claw; basal sclerites (Fig. 8); posterior sclerites trian- seta of tarsal claw extending past midpoint gular and narrow; central sclerite quadran- ofclaw (Fig. 5). Meso- and metapleurawith gular and tapering posteriorly; concolorous dark brown sutures. Abdomen ofthe mature with other sclerites. Mandibles asymmetri- larva approximately two to three times girth cal; right pointed apically, with small sub- of thorax; sclerites of abdominal segments apical tooth, and one seta at posterolateral 9 and 10 pale; anal claw dark brown. Dorsal corner; left with coarsely serrated inner chloride epithelia elliptical and faint. Pri- edge, and without setae (Fig. 9). Fore tarsus mary setae very dark basally, gradually be- with short subapical dorsal seta, approxi- coming light brown apically. mately length of tarsal claw; basal seta of VOLUME 101, NUMBER 3 519 8 [J Figs. 6-10. Hydroptilaperdita. 6, Firstinstar, lateral view. 7, Fifth instar, lateral view. 8.Prostemum,anterior up. 9, Left and right mandibles, ventral view. 10. Fore leg, lateral view. tarsal claw extending up to midpoint of known, new distributional records, and re- claw (Fig. 10). Meso- and metapleura with cent reports of species new to science from dark brown sutures. Abdomen of mature eastern North America (e.g., Houp et al. larva approximately twice the girth of tho- 1998). Hydroptila armata is easily distin- rax. Sclerites of abdominal segments 9 and guished from H. perdita based on the dark 10 and anal claw brown. Dorsal chloride color pattern of the head and thorax, lack epithelia elliptical and faint. Primary setae of a central prostemal sclerite, presence of very dark basally, gradually becoming light a long subapical tarsal seta, and lack of se- brown a—pically. tae on the posterolateral comer of the right Pupa. Appears similar to those species mandible ofH. armata. No characters were described by Nielsen (1948) and Ito and found to separate the early instars of these Kawamura (1980). Total length, 2.32 mm; species, however the early instars ofH. itoi head width, 0.63 mm; antennal length, 1.28 Kobayashi have brown thoracic and ab- mm. dominal sclerites with long setae (Ito and Kawamura 1980) which contrast those ob- Discussion served on H. armata and H. perdita. Only a few descriptions of larval Hy- Few morphological characters appear to droptila are available. Ross (1944) separat- be of general use for separating final instar ed groups of species from Illinois based on Hydroptila. Prostemal sclerites appear var- color of head and thoracic sclerites, but iable in number (2 or 3) between species; cautioned that color patterns are variable if present, the shape of the central sclerite within species. His key is presently unreli- varies from trapezoidal (//. perdita), dia- able due to species whose larvae are un- mond-shaped (//. tineoides Dalman) (Niel- 520 PROCEEDINGS OF THE ENTOMOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON sen 1948 as H. femoralis Eaton), and pen- areas where H. perdita adults are encoun- tagonal (H. coweetensis Huryn) (Huryn tered are needed to confirm this. 1985). Mandible morphology ofHydropfila Acknowledgments may be the most useful character for spe- cies identification of larvae because shape The Ohio Biological Survey funded our and setation appear to differ among species collecting trips. David Reece (Kent, OH) (Nielsen 1948, Lepneva 1964, Ito and Ka- assisted with the field work, and his friend- wamura 1980, Huryn 1985, Keiper 1998, ship and enthusiasm during these and other Keiper and Foote 1998, this study). Further efforts are greatly appreciated. Oliver S. larva-adult associations through rearings Flint (USNM) and Ralph W. Holzenthal coupled with detailed distributional records (University of Minnesota) provided useful should facilitate the compilation ofregional comments and suggestions which improved keys to species based primarily on mandi- the manuscript. William E. Walton (Uni- ble morphology for Hydroptila and possi- versity of California, Riverside) kindly pro- bly other microcaddisfly genera. vided access to laboratory equipment. Previous investigations indicated that Literature Cited some degree of trophic specialization oc- curs in hydroptilid larvae (Nielsen 1948, English, W. R. and S. W. Hamilton. 1986. The larva Resh and Houp 1986). Recently, Keiper et of Ochrotrichia ariz.onica (Trichoptera: Hydrop- al. (1998) demonstrated that H. woubesiaua vtialriidaatei)onw.itJhounrontaels oonf dtihsetriKbauntsiaonsaEnndtogmeoolgorgaipchailc Betten and Oxyethira pallida (Banks) com- Society 59: 474-479. pleted the larval/pupal period when given Flint, O. S. 1962. The immature stages of Palaeaga- only monocultures of certain algal taxa, petus celsHs Ross (Trichoptera: Hydroptilidae). whereas larvae consuming other algal Bulletin of the Brooklyn Entomological Society 57: 40-44. monocultures did not. Although we gave Flint, O. S. and S. J. Herrmann. 1976. The description larvae only Cladophora during this inves- of, and environmental characterization for, a new tigation, we suspect that H. anuata and H. species of Ochrotrichia from Colorado (Trichop- perdita exhibit a similar degree of feeding tera: Hydroptilidae). Annals ofthe Entomological Society ofAmerica 69: 894-898. specialization. The mandibles of each spe- Houp. R. E., Houp, K. H., and S. C. Harris. 1998. Two cies appear similar to those of H. waubes- new species ofmicrocaddisflies (Trichoptera: Hy- iana (Keiper 1998), and are apparently spe- droptilidae) from Kentucky. Entomological News cialized for piercing individual cells of 109: 99-102. Huryn, A. D. 1985. A new species ofHydroptila (Tri- green algae. choptera: Hydroptilidae) from North Carolina. The collection localities for adults uti- Proceedings of the Entomological Society of lized during this study corroborate state- Washington 87: 444-447. ments by Ross (1944) that each of these Huryn, A. D. and B. A. Foote. 1983. An annotated list species prefers moderate-sized streams. of the caddisflies (Trichoptera) ofOhio. Proceed- ings ofthe Entomological Society ofWashington Ross (1944) collected H. armata fifth in- 85: 783-796. stars in Illinois streams, but the larval mi- Ito. T and H. Kawamura. 1980. Morphology and bi- crohabitat of H. perdita remains unknown. ology of the immature stages of Hydroptila itoi Our observations of larval behavior and Kobayashi (Trichoptera, Hydroptilidae). Aquatic Insects 2: 113-122. feeding habits suggest that larvae ofH. per- Keiper, J. B. 1998. Biology, larval feeding habits, and dita inhabit rock substrates with ample resource partitioning by microcaddisflies (Tri- growths of Cladophora, as this is where choptera: Hydroptilidae). Ph.D. Thesis, Kent State similar species have been taken (e.g., Hu- University, Kent, Ohio. 146 pp. ryn 1985, Wells 1985, Keiper 1998, Keiper Keiper, J. B. and B. A. Foote. 1996. A simple rearing chamber for lotic insect larvae. Hydrobiologia and Foote 1998). Further collections offifth 337: 137-139. instar Hydroptila for laboratory rearings in Keiper, J. B. and B. A. Foote. 1998. Biological notes VOLUME NUMBER 101. 3 521 on Ochrotrichia .xciui (Ross) (Trichoptera: Hy- caddisfly Dibusa angata and its association with droptilidae), a species newly recorded from Ohio. the red alga Lemanea australis. Journal of the Proceedings of the Entomological Society of North American Benthological Society 5: 28-40. Washington 100: 594-595. Ross, H. H. 1944. The caddis flies, or Trichoptera, of Keiper. J. B., D. A. Casamatta, and B. A. Foote. 1998. Illinois. Bulletin of the Illinois Natural History Useofalgal monoculturesby larvaeofHyclroptila Survey 23: 1-326. waiihesiana and Oxyethira pallida (Trichoptera: Solem, J. O. 1972. The larva ofAgraylea cognatella Hydroptilidae). Hydrobiologia 380: 87-91. McLachlan (Trichoptera: Hydroptilidae). Norsk Lepneva, S. G. 1964. Fauna ofthe U.S.S.R.. Trichop- Entomologisk Tidsskrifta 19: 77-79. tera, larvae and pupae ofAnnulipalpia(Translated Vaillant, F 1984. The hydroptilid larvae of dripping from Russian, 1970). Zoological Institute of the rocks, pp. 407-412 In Morse, J. C. ed.. Proceed- Academy ofSciences ofthe U.S.S.R., New Series ings of the 4th International Symposium on Tri- no. 88. 560 pp. choptera. Series Entomologica 30, 486 pp. McAuliffe. J. R. 1982. Behavior and life history of Wells, A. 1985. Larvae and pupae of Australian Hy- Leucotrichia pictipes (Banks) (Trichoptera: Hy- droptilidae (Trichoptera), with observations on droptilidae) with special emphasis on case reoc- generalbiology andrelationships. AustralianJour- cupancy. Canadian Journal ofZoology 60: 1557- nal ofZoology, Supplementary Series 113: 1-69. 1561. Wiggins. G. B. 1990. Systematics of North American Morse, J. C. 1993. A checklist of the Trichoptera of Trichoptera: Presentstatusandfutureprospect,pp. North America, including Greenland and Mexico. 203-210//; Kostarab, M. andC. W. Schaefer,eds., Transactions of the American Entomological So- Systematics of the North American Insects and ciety 119: 47-93. Arachnids: Status and Needs. Virginia Agricultur- Nielsen, A. 1948. Postembryonic development and bi- al Experiment Station Information Series 90-1. ology ofthe Hydroptilidae. Det KongeligeDanske Blacksburg. videnskabernes selskabs Biologiske Skrifter 5: 1- Wiggins, G. B. 1996. Larvae of the North American 200. caddisfly genera (Trichoptera), 2nd ed. University Rcsh, V. H. and R. E. Houp. 1986. Life history ofthe ofToronto Press, Toronto.