Bioethics, Medical Ethics and Health Law Program and Book of Abstracts

149 Pages·2017·3.69 MB·English

UNESCO Chair in Bioethics 13th World Conference
Bioethics, Medical Ethics
Organized in collaboration with: and Health Law
•United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO)
•World Medical Association (WMA)
•World Psychiatric Association (WPA) Ramada Hotel
•International Federation of Medical Students’ Associations (IFMSA) Jerusalem, Israel
•Israel Medical Association (IMA) November 27-29, 2018
•Israel Bar Association
•Zefat Bioethics Forum
•The International Center for Health, Law and Ethics, University of Haifa
Secretariat
ISAS International Seminars
POB 574, Jerusalem 91004, Israel
Tel: [phone]
Fax: [phone]
[email protected]
www.bioethics-conferences.com
Program and
Book of Abstracts

th
UNESCO Chair in Bioethics 13 World Conference on

Bioethics, Medical Ethics
and Health Law

Program and Book of Abstracts

Ramada Hotel
Jerusalem, Israel
November 27-29, 2018

ISAS International Seminars
POB 574, Jerusalem, Israel • Tel: [phone] • [email protected]
www.bioethics-conferences.com
TABLE OF CONTENTS

Message from the Conference President iii

Conference President and Committees iv

Heads of UNESCO Chair in Bioethics Units iv

Call for Establishment of New Bioethics Units vii

General Information viii

UNESCO Chair in Bioethics – International Forum of Teachers Statutes ix

Scientific Program xi

Abstracts (alphabetical order by author)

Oral Presentations 1

Poster Presentations 101

Authors Index 117

ii
MESSAGE FROM THE CONFERENCE PRESIDENT

The UNESCO Chair in Bioethics Haifa welcomes all of you to the 13th World Conference.

Your participation in the 13th World Conference, and the massive attendance of your colleagues has
enabled us to offer this most impressive event, providing both quantity and quality, compared to
all the previous bioethics conferences.

I am pleased to inform you that the number of centers ("Units") of the Chair has recently grown and
now consists of 210 centers located in universities on five continents. The Chair currently operates
about 3,000 volunteers on the steering committees of its units. The Teachers' Forum of the Chair
has more than 800 educators in more than fifty countries.

In addition, the Chair operates many departments, including: The Research Department, the
Education Department, the Bioethics for Youth Department, the Department of Bioethics in the
Holocaust, the Official Bulletin of the Chair, the Journal of the Chair, the annual celebrations of
"World Bioethics Day", the Website, and more.

The Chair continues to publish books and educational materials for teachers and students, and
holds local, national and international seminars, courses and conferences.

The Chair enjoys fruitful cooperation with the World Medical Association and the International
Federation of Medical Students Associations.

Personal invitation:
You are welcome to send an email to the Chair in order to receive information about the following
programs ([email protected]):
♦ Establish a new unit at your university
♦ Join the teacher's forum of the Chair
♦ Join the bioethics project for young people
♦ Register for the Doctoral Program for Bioethics
♦ Register for the 14th World Conference (May, 2020 at the University of Porto, Portugal)

The World Conference offers its participants an international platform for fruitful scientific
discourse on more than 60 topics and subtopics in the fields of bioethics, medical ethics and
medical law.

I wish you all a most interesting, fruitful and pleasant stay at the Conference.

Prof. Amnon Carmi
President of the Conference
iii
Conference President
Prof. Amnon Carmi, Israel

International Organizing Committee

Prof. Blachar Yoram, Chair

Prof. Benyakar Moty Prof. Grinshpoon Alexander
Prof. Chongqi Wu Dr. Kloiber Otmar
Prof. D’Souza Russell Prof. Popova Sashka
Prof. Eidelman Leonid Dr. Seebohm Annabel
Prof. Finberg John Adv. Ullmann Tami
Prof. Gordon David Adv. Wafner Leah

International Scientific Committee

Prof. Linn Shai, Chair

Dr. Chelouche Tessa Prof. Rakic Vojin
Dr. Gallin Stacy Prof. Tabak Nili
Dr. Karni Tami Prof. Tsai Daniel Fu Chang
Prof. Nunes Rui Prof. Ullmann Yehuda
Dr. Peled Maya Dr. Vasinova Miroslava
Dr. Poraz Irit Dr. Wietchner Naama

UNESCO Chair in Bioethics

Head and Chair Holder: Prof. Amnon Carmi

Coordinators of UNESCO Chair in Bioethics Divisions
African Division: Prof. Pierre Effa
Asia-Pacific Division: Prof. Russell D’Souza
Ibero-American Division: Prof. Moty Benyakar
European Division: Prof. Vojin Rakic
Portuguese Language Countries Division: Prof. Rui Nunes

Directors of UNESCO Chair in Bioethics
Administrative Manager: Mrs. Shoshana Golinsky
Education Department: Prof. Russell D’Souza
International Forum of Teachers: Prof. Sashka Popova
Holocaust Department: Dr. Tessa Chelouche, Dr. Stacy Gallin
Research Department: Prof. Rui Nunes
Managing Editor of “Global Bioethics Inquiry”: Prof. Russell D’Souza
Youth Bioethics Education: Dr. Miroslava Vasinova
Website Master: Prof. Daniel Fu Chang Tsai
Coordinator of Bioethics Voices Newsletter: Dr. Miroslava Vasinova
International Committee of World Bioethics Day: Dr. Praveen Kumar Arora
Bioethical Voices Newsletter & Conference Press Office: Dr. Giacomo Sado

Heads of UNESCO Chair in Bioethics Units

Afghanistan / Kandahar: Dr. Noor Khaliq Noor Argentina / University of Buenos Aires – IBIS:
Albania / Tirana: Dr. Altin Stafa Prof. Juan Jorge Michel Farina
Argentina / Maimonides University: Prof. Gustavo Tafet Argentina / University of Moron: Dr. Enrique Mario Novelli
Argentina / San Isidro – Acassuso: Dr. Daniel Lopez Rosetti Armenia / Yerevan: Dr. Susanna Davtyan
Argentina / University National de San Luis: Australia / New South Wales: Dr. Irina Pollard
Dr. Eduardo Raul Ramos Austria / Innsbruck: Prof. Gabriele Werner-Felmayer
Argentina / University of Buenos Aires: Azerbaijan / Baku: Prof. Dr. Vugar Mammadov
Prof. Moty Benyakar Belgium / Ghent: Dr. Sigrid Sterckx
iv
Bosnia-Herzegovina / Banja Luka: France / Nancy: Prof. Henry Coudane
Prof. Dr. Igor Milinkovic Gabon / Libreville: Prof. Pierre Dominique Nzinzi
Bosnia-Herzegovina / Sarajevo: Prof. Dr. Sabina Semiz Germany / University of Applied Sciences & Art –
Brazil / Alagoas: Dr. Angela Canuto Hannover: Prof. Dr. Gerhard Fortwengel
Brazil / Centro Belo: Dr. Jesus de Almeida Fernanades Ghana / Kumasi: Rev. Fr. Dr. John Kwaku Oppku
Brazil / Conselho Regional: Greece / Athens: Prof. Dr. Evangelos D. Protopapadakis
Dr. Joao Goncalves de Medeiros Filho Iceland / Reykjavik: Dr. Salvor Nordal
Brazil / Famaz: Prof. Adriana Leticia Barbosa dos Santos India / Adesh Institute: Dr. GPI Singh
Brazil / Hospital Das Clinicas: Dr. Chin An Lin India / Ahmednagar: Air MSHL. Dr. D.P. Joshi
Brazil / Mato Grosso: Dr. Dalva Alves das Neves India / AIIMD: Dr. Sanjeev Misra
Brazil / National School of Public Health: India / Anand Gujarat State Unit: Prof. Dr. Barna Ganguly
Prof. Sergio Rego India / Annammal: Dr. Austin Jayalal
Brazil / Real Hospital Portuguese: Dr. Maria do Carmo India / Aurangabad: Dr. S.P. Dange
Lencastre de Menezes e Cruz Dueire Lins India / Bhavnagar: Prof. Dr. Chinmay Shah
Brazil / Regional Council Ceara: India / B.K.L. Walawalkar: Prof. Dr. Arvind Yadav
Dr. Ivan de Araujo Moura Fe India / Chennai: Prof. Dr. P. Thangaraju
Brazil / Santa Casa Medical School: India / Chennai: Prof. Dr. P.V. Vijayaraghavan
Prof. Dr. Decio Cassiani Altimari India / Chennai: Prof. Geethalakshmi
Brazil / Santa Catarina: Dr. Armando José D’Acampora India / Chennai CARE: Prof. K. Ravindran
Brazil / Santa Marcelina Medical School: India / CMCHRC Irungalur Trichy: Dr. T.S. Gugapriya
Dr. Jose T. Thome India / DUP Pune: Dr. Shalija Mane
Brazil / Santo Amaro University: India / Durg University: Dr. Shailendra Saraf
Prof. Clovis Francisco Contantino India / Faridkot: Prof. Dr. Raj Bahadur
Brazil / UniCEUB: Dr. Evaldo Lima da Costa India / Gandhinagar: Prof. Dr. Parthasarathi Ganguly
Brazil / University Federal Parana: India / Gangtok Sikkim North East:
Dr. Pedro de Paula Filho Prof. Dr. Mingma Lhamu Sherpa
Brazil / University of Campinas: Dr. Flavio Cesar de Sa India / Gov. MK: Prof. M.K. Ragendran
Bulgaria / Sofia: Prof. Sashka Popova India / Haryana State Rohtak: Prof. Dr. O.P. Kalra
Cameron / Yaoundé: Prof. Pierre Effa India / Jabalpur: Prof. Dr. S.P. Pandey
China: Prof. Chongqi Wu India / Jaipur: Dr. Raja Babu Panwar
China / Binzhou Medical University: Prof. Wang Liqing India / Kochi – Kerala: Prof. Dinesh Narayanan
China / Central South University: Prof. Chen Yunliang India / Kolhapur: Dr. Shimpa Sharma
China / Dalian Medical University: Prof. Shi Yue India / Kolkatta: Prof. Dr. Bhabatos Biswas
China / Fujian University: Prof. CanDong Li India / Kozikode: Dr. Jayakrishnan Thayyil
China / Guangxi Medical University: Prof. Li Xiaoping India / Loni – Maharashtra: Prof. Dr. S.D. Dalvi
China / Hainan Medical University: Prof. Su Yuju India / Lucknow: Prof. Ravi Kant
China / Hangzhou: Prof. Zhang Zhiliang India / Madurai – VELAMMAL Medical College:
China / Health Economics & Management School: Prof. Dr. John Rajpathy
Prof. Tian Kan India / MAEER's Pune: Dr. Priya Chitre
China / Inner Mongolia: Prof. Zhao Xingsheng India / Mahatma Gandhi Vidyamadir's K.B.H. Dental
China / Jining: Prof. Wang Deguo College & Hospital: Dr. Sanjay V. Bhawsar
China / Kuming Medical University: Prof. Deng Hong India / Mangalore: Dr. Nagesh KR
China / Medical Health Open School – Guangxi: India / Mangalore: Prof. Dr. Animesh Jain
Prof. Qin Anning India / Mangalore – KSHEMA Medical College:
China / School of Marxism: Prof. Chen Jun Dr. Satheesh Bhandary
China / Shandong: Prof. Shu Defeng India / Manipal – Karnataka State Unit:
China / Shandong Academy – Bioethics: Prof. Dr. Mary Mathew
Prof. Chen Xiaoyang India / MGUMST University Jaipur Pune:
China / Shandong University: Prof. Man Hongjie Prof. Dr. Simmi Mehra
China / Soochow: Prof. Chen Liang India / MIMER Pune: Prof. (Col) Derek D'Souza
China / Southwest Medical University: Prof. Liao Bin India / MIO Mangalore: Dr. Suresh Rao
China / Weifang: Prof. Hu Youli India / Mullana – Ambala MM University:
China/ Xian Medical University: Prof. Mrs. Xiong Dongmei Dr. Sankalp Dwivedi
Colombia / Bogota: Prof. Andrea Hellemeyer India / Mullana MMCDSR Dental College: Dr. Soheyl Sheikh
Colombia / Villavicencio: India / Mumbai: Dr. Anu Kant Mital
Prof. Ariel Marcel Tarazona Morales India / Mumbai: Dr. R.N. Bharmal
Colombia / Villavivencio: Dr. Gina Lorena Garcia Martinez India / Mumbai: Prof. Dr. Praveen Shingre
Croatia / Osijek: Dr. Ivica Kelam India / Mumbai – Lokmanya: Dr. Mangesh Lone
Croatia / Zagreb: Suncana Roksandic Vidlicka India / Mumbai – MUHS Navi: Dr. Kanchanmala Ghorpade
Cyprus / Limassol: Prof. Andrie Panayiotou India / Mumbai – Somaiya: Prof. Dr. Vinayak Sabnis
Czech Republic / Prague: Dr. Tomas Dolezal India / Mumbai Cooper: Dr. Prasad Pandit
Demark / Copenhagen: Dr. Bogi Eliasen India / Mumbai GSMC KEM College & Hospital:
Fiji / St. Suva: Ms. Sharon Biribo Dr. Santhosh Salagre
Finland / Turku: Dr. Susanne Uusitalo India / Mumbai MGM Navi: Dr. Sudhir N. Kadam
Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia / Skopje: India / Mumbai Nair Dental College: Prof. Dr. K S Banga
Prof. Dr. Dejan Donev India / Nagpur Maharashtra: Prof. Dr. Kajal Mitra
Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia / Tetovo: India / Nanded: Dr. C.B. Mhaske
Prof. Mentor Hamiti India / Nashik: Prof. Dr. Pradip Barde
v
India / Nashik Pune: Dr. Deelip Mhaisekar Nigeria / Nsukka: Prof. Felix Nzube Chukwuneke
India / NCT New Delhi: Dr. B.R. Sharma Nigeria / Port Harcourt: Prof. Victor Wakwe
India / New Delhi: Dr. Adit Desai Norway / Trondheim: Dr. Lars Ursin
India / New Delhi: Dr. Deepak Singla Pakistan / Islamabad: Prof. Rizwan Taj
India / New Delhi – Dr. Ram Manohar Lohia Hospital: Pakistan / Lahore: Dr. Sarosh Saleem
Prof. Dr. Smita N Deshpande Philippines / Manila: Prof. Maria Salome N. Vios;
India / New Delhi – National Board Examinations: Agnes D. Mejia
Prof. (Dr.) Bipin Batra Poland / Lodz: Anna Alichniewicz; Monika Michalowska
India / New Delhi IMA National Unit: Poland / Warsaw: Dr. Joanna Rozynska
Prof. Dr. R. Wankhedkar Poland / Warsaw Lazarski University: Dr. Maria Ciesielska
India / Pharmacy: Dr. T.K. Ravi Poland / Zielona Gora: Prof. Martyna Laszewska-Hellriegel
India / PIMS Ganagachettikula: Dr. Rema Devi Portugal / Porto: Prof. Rui Nunes
India / Raipur Nodal Centre Chhattisgarh State Raipur: Portugal / Portuguese Association: Dr. Francisca Rego
Prof. Dr. G.B. Gupta Romania / Iasi: Prof. Elena Toader
India / Sevagram: Dr. Samir Yelvatker Russia / St. Petersburg: Prof. Galina Mikirtichan
India / SGRDUHS Amristar: Dr. AP Singh Russia / Volgograd: Prof. Alena Donika
India / SGT Gurgaon: Dr. T.D. Dogra Serbia / Beograd: Prof. Vojin Rakic
India / Shillong: Prof. Dr. Rituparna Barooah Slovenia / Ljubljana: Prof. Toni Pustovrh
India / Sree Mookambika Institute: Dr. G. Padmakumar South Africa / Potchefstromm Campus:
India / Srinagar Kashmir: Prof. Dr. Salim Khan Prof. Dr. Reaan (AL) Rheeder
India / St. John's Research Institute: Dr. Olinda Timms Spain / Madrid: Dr. Benjamin Herreros
India / Sundaram: Prof. S. Arulrhaj Spain / Murcia: Prof. Julian Valero-Torrijos;
India / Tamil Nadu Nurses: Prof. S. Ani Grace Kalaimathi Prof. Maria Magnolia Pardo-Lopez
India / Thrissur: Dr. E. Mohandas Sri Lanka / Angoda: Dr. Harischandra Gambheera
India / Thrissur: Dr. MKC Nair Sri Lanka / Kelaniya: Dr. Madawa Chandratilake
India / Trissur Kerala: Prof. Dr. P.C. Gilvaz Sudan / Khartoum: Dr. Hanan I.M. Tahir
India / Trivandrum: Prof. Dr. Geetha O. Sudan / Khartoum: Dr. Sawsan El Mekkawi
India / Vellore Tamil Nadu: Prof. Dr. Kuryan George Taiwan / E-Da Hospital Taipei: Dr. Chi-Wei Ling
India / Wardha Meghe Institute: Dr. Abhay M. Gaidhane Taiwan / Fu-Jen Catholic University Taipei:
Indonesia / Surabaya: Prof. Siti Pariani Dr. Hou-Chang Chiu
Ireland / Galway: Dr. Oliver Feeney Taiwan / Mackay Medical Taipei: Dr. Ling-Lang Huang
Israel / Haifa: Prof. Shai Linn Taiwan / National University Taipei:
Israel / Zefat: Prof. Tamar Gidron Prof. Daniel Fu-Chang Tsai
Italy / Saint Vincent: Dr. Miroslava Vasinova Taiwan / Taichung Taipei: Dr. Jeng-Yuan Hsu
Japan / Tokyo: Prof. Mitsuyasu Kurosu Taiwan / Tzu Chi University: Prof. Ying-Wei Wang
Kazakhstan / Almaty: Dr. Sadykova Aizhan Turkey / Ankara: Prof. Dr. Nuket Ornek Buken
Kazakhstan / Astana: Prof. Bakhyt Sarymsakova Uganda / Kampala: Prof. C. Ibingira
Kenya / Kericho: Prof. Marion W. Mutugi Ukraine / Kyiv: Dr. Radmyla Hrevtsova
Kosova / Hospital & University Clinical Center Shtime: United Kingdom / Birmingham: Dr. June Jones
Dr. Miftar Zenelaj United Kingdom / Cardiff: Prof. Baroness Llora Finlay
Latvia / Riga: Dr. Inars Neiders United Kingdom / Swansea: Mrs. Chantal Patel
Lithuania / Klaipeda: Prof. Dr. Gintautas Vyšniauskas United States of America / Cambridge MA:
Malawi / Blantyre: Prof. Joseph Mfutso-Bengo Dr. Harold J. Bursztajn; Ass. Prof. Terry Bard
Malaysia / Kuala Lampur: Prof. Parameshvara Deva United States of America / Florida:
Malaysia / Selangor: Prof. Chin Kin Fah Prof. Joseph E. Thornton
Mexico / Puerto Vallarta: United States of America / Indiana: Prof. Susan Zinner
Prof. Sergio Alberto Viruete Cisneros United States of America / North Carolina:
Mexico / Queretaro: Dr. Hilda Romero Zepeda Prof. Cristina Richie
Moldova / Chisinau: Dr. Igor Codreanu United States of America / Yale: Dr. Lori Bruce
Montenegro / Podgorica: Prof. Aneta Boskovic Uzbekistan / Tashkent: Prof. Zamira Mukhamedova
Nepal / Dhahran: Dr. Dhana Ratna Shakya Venezuela / Merida: Prof. Ximena Paez
Netherlands / Rotterdam: Prof. Dr. Maartje Schermer Vietnam / Hanoi: Prof. Nguyen Duc Hinh
Nigeria / Kaduna: Dr. Halima Bello-Manga Zambia / Lusaka: Dr. Bornwell Sikateyo

Under the auspices of
♦ United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO)
♦ World Medical Association (WMA)
♦ World Psychiatric Association (WPA)
♦ World Federation for Medical Education
♦ IFMSA – International Federation of Medical Students’ Associations
♦ International Center for Health, Law and Ethics, Haifa University
♦ Israel Bar Association
♦ Israeli Medical Association
♦ The Society for Medicine and Law in Israel
vi
The UNESCO Chair in Bioethics promotes
A Call for the Establishment
of New Bioethics Units
You are invited to establish a new UNIT at your Institute!
*
The United Nations Educational Scientific and Cultural
Organization (UNESCO) established (2001) the
UNESCO Chair in Bioethics (Haifa)

The purpose of the CHAIR is to build, activate, co-ordinate and
stimulate an International Network of Units in Academic
Institutes for Ethics Education.
*
The Chair has established until now 210 Units
in 77 countries and regions in the five continents.
*
If you wish to establish a new UNESCO Unit in your own institute
and to receive more details, guidelines and list of other Units,
see: www.unesco-chair-bioethics.org
vii
GENERAL INFORMATION

Conference Venue:
Ramada Hotel
Vilnai Street, Jerusalem, Israel
Tel: [phone]

Press Office:
Dr. Giacomo Sado, [phone] or at the conference information desk

Social Events:
Get-Together Cocktail, Gala Dinner and Social Evening ($69)
Tuesday, November 27, 2018  Ramada Hotel Ballroom
20:00 Cocktail Dance Performance (by the Jerusalem Folklore Ensemble)
21:00 Get-together Dinner

Farewell Cocktail, Gala Dinner and Social Evening ($79)
Wednesday, November 28, 2018  Ramada Hotel Ballroom
20:00 Cocktail and Solo Performance by Bat-El: Bigger is Better, followed by Klezmer music performance
21:00 Gala Farewell Dinner

Accompanying Persons: Accompanying persons do not have entry to lecture halls. The registration fee includes get-
together dinner, gala dinner and folklore evening, and half-day tour.

Tours: Please contact the hospitality desk

Certificate of Participation: A certificate of participation will be supplied upon request.

An exhibition of art works entitled “Weight of Words, Power of Pictures” depicting case studies of bioethical interest will
be on display in the poster area. The artist will be available for questions for the duration of the Congress.

Access to Lecture Rooms: Your registration fee includes entry to sessions, conference program and book of abstracts, two
lunches and coffee breaks. Seating is on a “first-come, first-served” basis. We recommend you go to the lecture room well
before the session starts. Safety regulations require us to limit access to the session if the room is filled to capacity. A
sweater or jacket is recommended, as the conference rooms may be cool.

Name Badges: Your personal name badge serves as your passport to the scientific sessions. Participants are expected to
wear their badges visibly at all times.
No badge = no entry. Badge replacement costs $25.

Note: ISAS International Seminars, UNESCO, the UNESCO Chair and all the sponsors shall not be responsible for and shall
be exempt from any liability in respect of any loss, damage, injury, accident, delay or inconvenience to any person, or
luggage or any other property for any reason whatsoever, for any tourist services provided. Personal travel and health
insurance is recommended.

Conference Website:
www.bioethics-conferences.com

Conference Secretariat and PCO:
ISAS International Seminars • POB 574, Jerusalem 91004, Israel • Tel: [phone]
[email protected] • www.isas.co.il
In case of emergency: [phone]
viii