APL 6.0 Recommendations - Adelaide City Council

39 Pages·2007·1.06 MB·English

6.0 RECOMMENDATIONS

6.0 RECOMMENDATIONS

Figure
Tinted postcard entitled ‘Sheep on Park Lands’ being a scene in the Light’s Vision ‘Paddock’ locality in Tarndanya Womma/Park 26 looking north-west towards Montefiore Road (note timber post and rail fencing at the rear), and Montefiore Hill, c.1910.
Source: private collection

1 097
6.0 RECOMMENDATIONS
6.0 RECOMMENDATIONS
This chapter summarises and draws recommendations as to appropriate heritage registrations
for places/components identified and assessment in the course of this Assessment Study (2007).

1 098
6.0 RECOMMENDATIONS

6.1 NATIONAL TRUST OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA REGISTER OF SIGNIFICANT (R) -isolated remnant of native vegetation or is a species or variety that is rated Rare, Endangered
TREES or Vulnerable, or is of very localised distribution
(G) - horticultural or genetic value, possibly important as propagating stock, or cultivars particularly
The National Trust of South Australia administers a Register of Significant Trees. The Register resistant to disease or exposure
was established to document, record and recognise trees (tree/trees) of merit and the eligibility (J) - preserves the genetic stock of a listed tree (eg a seedling or cutting of a tree which is nearing the
for inclusion on the Register is subject to a set of criterion. Inclusion upon the Register has no end of its lifespan), a juvenile of possible future significance
legal applicability under the Development Act 1993. (X) - other, (please describe)

There are but a few trees in the Adelaide Park Lands and Squares included on this Register, with In terms of this Assessment Study (2007) numerous trees have been identified that have merit for
the majority in the municipality either being within the Adelaide Botanic Garden or on private inclusion under one or more of the above criterion. For the purposes of this documentation,
landholdings. Within each Park Land block and Square Assessment report, each Registered each tree is individually recommended with the Assessment reports for each Park Land block
tree has been listed and identified. The complete Registration inventory for the municipality is and Square, and the reader should consult these inventories. Categorisation of merit under the
set out in the following table. one or more of the above criterion has not been carried out at this stage; rather tree specimens
of merit and eligibility have been identified.
The following is the criterion used:

Categories and sub-categories for nomination:

• The nominated tree(s) should be significant for one or more of the following reasons:
(REFER TO THE QUESTION ON SIGNIFICANCE ON PAGE TWO OF THE
NOMINATION FORM)

1. Natural value (remnant vegetation, habitat, maintain biodiversity):
(R) - an isolated remnant of native vegetation or is a species or variety that is rated Rare,
Endangered or Vulnerable
(F) - provides valuable fauna habitat (eg hollows suitable for possums or a range of bird species)
(X) - other, (please describe)

2. Historic / cultural value (Aboriginal, colonial, post-colonial, association with person or event,
ethnic, community):

(H) - commemorates or has associations with an important historical event

(V) - significantly associated with a VIP or well known public figure, (eg planted by Royalty or

prominent person)

(E) - significantly associated with an aboriginal or ethnic group

(P) - part of a private or public historic garden or park or town

(C) - is or has been of importance in the life of the local community

(X) - other, (please describe)

3. Aesthetic value (dimensions, age, character, physical features, landmark/landscape qualities):

(B) - outstanding aesthetic beauty

(D) - outstanding dimensions in height, or trunk circumference, or canopy spread

(O) - very old or venerable

(L) - occurs in a unique location or context, and thus provides a special contribution to the

landscape, or is a landmark

(T) - excellent example of topiary

(Q) - curious growth forms or physical features either from natural causes, or pruning

(X) - other, (please describe)

4. Endangered / rare (International, national, state, local, horticultural)

10 99
6.0 RECOMMENDATIONS

Source: National Trust of South Australia, www, 2007.

1 100
6.0 RECOMMENDATIONS

6.2 CITY OF ADELAIDE LOCAL HERITAGE SIGNIFICANCE

Under the City of Adelaide Development Plan (2007) the Corporation may list places and trees as
possessing local heritage merit. The criterion for inclusion is contained in Section 23(4) of the
state Development Act 1993.

The criterion is as follows:

Section 23 (4):
A Development Plan may designate a place of local heritage value if:

(a) it displays historical, economic or social themes that are of importance to the local area; or
(b) it represents customs or ways of life that are characteristic of the local area; or
(c) it has played an important part in the lives of local residents; or
(d) it displays aesthetic merit, design characteristics or construction techniques of significance to the
local area; or
(e) it is associated with a notable local personality or event; or
(f) it is a notable landmark in the area; or
(g) in the case of a tree, it is of special historical or social significance or importance within a local
area (Development Act 1993)

There are several places presently as Local Heritage Places for the Adelaide Park Lands and
Squares, and these are listed in the below table.

In addition, ‘Principle [296] of Development Control’ for ‘Significant Trees’, under the City of
Adelaide Development Plan (2007, p. 86) implies that a tree or group of trees merits designation as a
‘Significant Tree’ under the Plan where, in addition to the criteria contained in Section 23 (4) of
the Development Act 1993, as follows:

296 Where a significant tree or group of trees:
a. makes an important contribution to the character or amenity of the local area; or
b. is indigenous to the local area and its species is listed under the National Parks and Wildlife
Act as a rare or endangered native species; or
c. represents an important habitat for native fauna; or
d. is part of a wildlife corridor of a remnant area of native vegetation; or
e. is important to the maintenance of biodiversity in the local environment; or
f. forms a notable visual element to the landscape of the local area;
development should preserve these attributes.

Note: Trees or groups of trees are declared as significant in the provisions for the relevant Zone or Policy Area. A
tree not listed or identified in the provisions for the relevant Zone of Policy Area may also be significant if it falls
within the class of trees declared to be significant by the Development Regulations, 1993 (City of Adelaide
Development Plan, 2007, p. 86).

Note this criterion is the same criterion for the definition, evaluation and conservation of
‘Significant Trees’ per se under the Development Act 1993.

There are no trees or groups of trees presently listed under Principle 296 for the Adelaide Park
Lands and Squares.

The following places, per Park Land and Square, are presently listed as Local Heritage Places
(City Significance) and (Townscape) and/or Significant Trees in the Park Lands and Squares,
under the City of Adelaide Development Plan (2007) under the state Development Act 1993:
1 101
6.0 RECOMMENDATIONS

Park/Address Description of Place and Elements of Heritage Value Section 23 (4) Development Act 1993 Criteria Certificate of Title
Piltawoldi/Park 1
Nil
Padipadinyilla/Park 2
Nil
Kandarilla/Park 3
Nil
Kangattilla/Park 4
Nil
Ngampa Yerta/Park 5
Nil
Nanto Womma/Park 5
Nil
Kuntingga/Park 7
Nil
Barnguttilla/Park 8
Nil
Tidlangga/Park 9
Nil
Warnpangga/Park 10
Nil
Tainmundilla/Park 11
Carriageway entrance gates, Botanic Park, Hackney Road n/s
Frome Road/Park 11A
Nil
Karrawirra/Park 12
Statue of His Majesty King George V and Pedestal, Angas Gardens, Sir Edwin Smith Avenue n/s
Kadlitpinna/Rundle/Park 13
War Horse Memorial Trough and Obelisk, Rundle Park, corner East Terrace and Botanic Road n/s
Mullawirraburka/Rymill/Park 14
Nil
Ityamaiitpinna/Park 15
Nil
Bakkabakkandi/Park 16
Nil
Tuttangga/Park 17
Nil
Wita Wirra/Park 18
Nil
Pityarrilla/Park 19
Nil
Kurrangga/Park 20
Glover Playground Pavilion, South Park Lands, South Terrace n/s
Walyo Yerta/Park 21
Nil
Minno Wirra/Park 21W
Nil
Wikaparndo/Park 22
Nil
Wirranendi/Park 23
Nil
Tambawodli/Park 24
Nil
1 102
6.0 RECOMMENDATIONS

Narnungga/Park 25
Nil
Tarndanya Womma/Park 26
Memorial to Jah Gardener [sic.], Elder Park, King William Road n/s
Victor Richardson Gates, Victor Richardson Road, off King William Road, Adelaide Oval n/s
Tulya Wodli/Park 27
Nil
Pangki Pangki/Palmer
Gardens/Park 28
Nil
Tandotittinga/Brougham
Gardens/Park 29
Nil
Hindmarsh Square
Nil
Hurtle Square
Nil
Light Square
Nil
North Terrace
*Government House Gate House, Piers and Walling, North Terrace n/s 5760/637
*Nursing School, Royal Adelaide Hospital, Corner North Terrace and Frome Road n/s 5832/785
Tarndanyangga/Victoria Square
Nil
Wellington Square
Nil
Whitmore Square
Nil

Note: * Places initially listed on the Register of City of Adelaide Heritage Items
Source: City of Adelaide Development Plan (Consolidated - 17 May 2007 version), pp. 1-429, Maps Adel/37-64.
n/s = not stated

During the course of this Assessment Study (2007) several places were identified for inclusion as a
Local Heritage Place and or as a Significant Tree. Accordingly, the following places and trees
are recommended for inclusion as a Local Heritage Place or as a Significant Tree under the City
of Adelaide Development Plan (2007) (Note: Existing registrations are included in italics, and the
same listing nomenclature used in each Assessment section per Park Land and Square is used in
the below table for cross-referencing):

1 103
6.0 RECOMMENDATIONS

Park/Address Description of Place and Elements of Heritage Value Section 23 (4) Development Act 1993 & Certificate of Title
Principal 296 City of Adelaide Development
Plan (2007) Criteria
Piltawoldi/Park 1
Piltawodli/Park 1 Upper Carriage Drive– including all Moreton Bay Fig (Ficus macrophylla), Hill’s Weeping Fig (Ficus 23 (4) (d) (f) (g); 296 (a) (f)
microcarpa var hillii), Holm Oak (Quercus ilex), English Oak (Quercus robur), Algerian Oak (Quercus canariensis), and Port
Jackson Fig (Ficus rubiginosa), Lemon-scented Gum (Corymbia citriodora) specimens generally and specifically listed in the
Assessment inventory
Montefiore Road Lemon-scented Gum (Corymbia citrodora) corridor & Specimen 23 (4) (f) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Strangways Terrace Iron Fence Posts 23 (4) (a) (d)
Strangways Terrace Galvanised Iron Fence Post 23 (4) (a) (d)
Upper Park 1 Carriage Drive Holm Oak (Quercus ilex) (1) 23 (4) (g); 296 (a)
Upper Park 1 Carriage Drive Holm Oak (Quercus ilex) (2) 23 (4) (g); 296 (a)
Cork Oak (Quercus suber) (1) 23 (4) (g); 296 (a)
Cork Oak (Quercus suber) (2) 23 (4) (g); 296 (a)
Mid South Course Indian Coral Tree (Erythrina indica) 23 (4) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Barton Terrace Carob (Ceratonia siliqua) 23 (4) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Mill Terrace Tennis Court (1) – including surface and fencing] 23 (a) (c) (d)
Kaffir Plum (Harpephyllum caffrum) specimen 23 (4) (g); 296 (a)
Jeffcott Street Visual Outlook 23 (4) (d)
Montefiore Road Corridor 23 (4) (f)
North Course Carob (Ceratonia siliqua) plantation 23 (4) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Hill Street Visual Outlook 23 (4) d)
Mills Terrace Canary Island Pines (Pinus canariensis) 23 (4) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Montefiore Hill Views 23 (4) (d)
Fairway 1 North Vista 23 (4) (d)
Strangways Terrace Olive (Olea europaea) grove 23 (4) (a) (b) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Stone Pine (Pinus pinea) specimens 23 (4) (g); 296 (f)
Angophora (Angophora costata) grove 23 (4) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Mid South Course Moreton Bay Fig (Ficus macrophylla) 23 (4) (f) (g); 296 (a) (f)
West South Course Moreton Bay Fig (Ficus macrophylla) specimen 23 (4) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Padipadinyilla/Park 2
Port Jackson Fig (Ficus rubiginosa) 23 (4) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Kandarilla/Park 3
Port Jackson Fig (Ficus rubiginosa) specimen 23 (4) (g); 296 (a)
Kangattilla/Park 4
Aleppo Pine (Pinus halepensis) grove 23 (4) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Hackberry (Celtis occidentalis) grove 23 (4) (g); 296 (a)
Lehmann’s Gum (Eucalyptus lehmannii) specimen 23 (4) (g); 296 (a)
Norfolk Island Pine (Araucaria heterophylla) plantation 23 (4) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Kangattilla/Park 4 SA Water earthen-covered reservoir 23 (4) (a) (f)
Ngampa Yerta/Park 5
River She-oak (Allocasuarina cunninghamiana) specimen 23 (4) (g); 296 (a)
Nanto Womma/Park 6
LeFevre Terrace Playground – including fencing, spatial arrangements, Glover Playground, Fence Post, hedging, 23 (4) (a) (b) (c)
extant trees
Kingston Terrace Sugar (Eucalyptus cladocalyx) and River Red (Eucalyptus camaldulensis) woodland 23 (4) (g); 296 (a) (e) (f)
Aleppo Pine (Pinus halepensis) avenue 23 (4) (g); 296 (a)
Aleppo Pine (Pinus halepensis) specimen 23 (4) (g); 296 (f)
Sugar Gum (Eucalyptus cladocalyx) specimen 23 (4) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Carob (Ceratonia siliqua) specimens 23 (4) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Central Gate 23 (4) (b)
Central East Gate 23 (4) (b)
Southern Gate 23 (4) (b)
1 104
6.0 RECOMMENDATIONS

South-Western Gate 23 (4) (b)
LeFevre Terrace East Outlook 23 (4) (f)
Nanto Womma/Park 6 Agistment Paddock 23 (4) (a) (b) (c)
Kuntingga/Park 7
Nil
Barnguttilla/Park 8
Nil
Tidlangga/Park 9
Wrought iron gate posts (2 pair posts) 23 (4) (a) (d)
Galvanised iron fence posts ( posts) 23 (4) (a) (d)
Bundeys Road East Vista 23 (4) (f)
Warnpangga/Park 10
MacKinnon Parade Tan Promenade 23 (4) (a) (d)
Sandcarters Road reserve 23 (4) (a)
Moreton Bay Fig (Ficus macrophylla) specimen (1) 23 (4) (g); 296 (f)
Pear Tree (Pyrus calleryana) grove 23 (4) (f) (g); 296 (a)
Swamp Paperbark (Melaleuca ericifolia) specimen 23 (4) (g); 296 (a)
Moreton Bay Fig (Ficus macrophylla) specimen (2) 23 (4) (g); 296 (f)
Moreton Bay Fig (Ficus macrophylla) specimen (3) 23 (4) (g); 296 (f)
Lemon-scented Gum (Corymbia citriodora) plantation 23 (4) (f) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Kaffir Apple (Dovyalis caffra) hedge 23 (4) (f) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Athel Pine (Tamarix aphylla) specimens 23 (4) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Moreton Bay Fig (Ficus macrophylla) specimen (5) 23 (4) (g); 296 (f)
Corporation Nursery 23 (4) (a) (b) (f)
Warnpangga/Park 10 East Vista 23 (4) (d)
Warnpangga/Park 10 West Vista 23 (4) (d)
Frome Road North Vista 23 (4) (d)
Frome Road North Vista 23 (4) (d)
Tainmundilla/Park 11
Carriageway entrance gates, Botanic Park, Hackney Road n/s
River Torrens/Karrawirra Parri riverscape 23 (4) (f)
Sandcarters Road reserve 23 (4) (a) (b) (f)
Former Botanic Gardens site 23 (4) (a) (b)
Frome Road/Park 11A
Nil
Karrawirra/Park 12
Statue of His Majesty King George V and Pedestal, Angas Gardens, Sir Edwin Smith Avenue n/s
Torrens Parade Ground Escarpment 23 (4) (b) (f)
River Torrens/Karrawirra Parri Watercourse & Lake 23 (4) (a) (b) (c) (f)
Grundy Gardens Pathways 23 (4) (d)
University Footbridge Access 23 (4) (d)
Victoria Drive 23 (4) (a) (d)
‘Town Clerk’s Walk’ 23 (4) (a)
Roberts Place Palm specimens 23 (4) (a) (d) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Moreton Bay Fig (Ficus macrophylla) specimen (1) 23 (4) (a) (g); 296 (a) (f)
English Elm (Ulmus procera) specimen 23 (4) (a) (g); 296 (a)
Moreton Bay Fig (Ficus macrophylla) specimen (2) 23 (4) (a) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Moreton Bay Fig (Ficus macrophylla) grove 23 (4) (a) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Bunya Bunya (Araucaria bidwillii) specimen 23 (4) (a) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Moreton Bay Fig (Ficus macrophylla) specimen (3) 23 (4) (a) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Kaffir Apple (Dovyalis caffra) hedge 23 (4) (a) (b) (g); 296 (a)
Camphor Tree (Cinnamomum camphora) specimen (1) 23 (4) (a) (g); 296 (a) (f)
River Red Gum (Eucalyptus camaldulensis) specimen (3) 23 (4) (g); 296 (a) (f)
1 105
6.0 RECOMMENDATIONS

River Red Gum (Eucalyptus camaldulensis) specimen (4) 23 (4) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Seven Palm Trees 23 (4) (a) (d) (f) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Two Canary Island Pines (Pinus canariensis) 23 (4) (f) (g); 296 (a) (f)
River She Oak (Allocasuarina verticillata) specimen 23 (4) (f) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Bunya Bunya (Araucaria bidwillii) specimen 23 (4) (f) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Norfolk Island Pine (Araucaria heterophylla) specimen (1) 23 (4) (f) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Queensland Kauri Tree (Agathis robusta) specimen 23 (4) (f) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Captain Cook Pine (Araucaria columnaris) specimen 23 (4) (f) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Norfolk Island Pine (Araucaria heterophylla) specimen (2) 23 (4) (f) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Moreton Bay Fig (Ficus macrophylla) specimen (5) 23 (4) (f) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Aleppo Pine (Pinus halepensis) & Canary Island Pine (Pinus canariensis) Grove 23 (4) (f) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Norfolk Island Pine (Araucaria heterophylla) specimen (3) 23 (4) (f) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Torrens Parade Ground Palms 23 (4) (a) (b) (d) (f) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Torrens Parade Ground London Planes (Platanus x acerifolius) 23 (4) (f) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Pioneer Womens’ Memorial Garden Italian Poplars (Populus nigra ‘Italica’) 23 (4) (a) (d) (f) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Pioneer Womens’ Memorial Garden Italian Cypresses (Cupressus sempervirens) 23 (4) (a) (d) (f) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Torrens Parade Ground Cotton Palms (Washingtonia robusta) 23 (4) (a) (b) (d) (f) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Pioneer Womens’ Memorial Garden Holm Oaks (Quercus ilex) 23 (4) (a) (d) (f) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Cotton Palm (Washingtonia robusta) specimen 23 (4) (a) (b) (d) (f); 296 (a) (f)
Grundy Gardens 23 (4) (a) (c) (d) (f)
Pathway of Honour 23 (4) (a) (b) (c) (f)
McEwin ‘War Memorial Drive’ Arboretum 23 (4) (a) (d) (f) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Christian Brothers College Boathouse 23 (4) (a) (b)
Prince Alfred College Boathouse 23 (4) (a) (b)
Popeye’s Boathouse 23 (4) (a) (b)
Torrens Rowing Club Boathouse 23 (4) (a) (b)
Jolley’s Boathouse 23 (4) (a) (b)
Lamp Post 23 (4) (d)
South Australian Naval Memorial Garden 23 (4) (a) (d)
South Australian Naval Memorial Garden Anchor & Plaque 23 (4) (a) (d)
Phineas Philip Davies Memorial 23 (4) (a) (d)
Gates 23 (4) (a) (b)
University Footbridge Light Standards 23 (4) (d)
University Footbridge South Lamp Standards 23 (4) (d)
Grundy Gardens sign 23 (4) (d)
University Footbridge north-eastern lamp standard 23 (4) (d)
Grundy Gardens Lamps 23 (4) (d)
Torrens Parade Ground Escarpment Fence 23 (4) (a) (b)
Torrens Parade Ground perimeter fencing 23 (4) (a) (b)
Frome Road Drain Exit 23 (4) (a) (b)
Red Granite Kerb 23 (4) (a) (b)
University Footbridge east lamp standard 23 (4) (d)
Pathway of Honour east-west vista 23 (4) (f)
Kadlitpinna/Park 13/Rundle Park
War Horse Memorial Trough and Obelisk, Rundle Park, corner East Terrace and Botanic Road n/s
White Cedar (Melia azedarach var australasica) pathway, allée, and trees 23 (4) (a) (d) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Lemon-scented gum (Corymbia citriodora) specimen 23 (4) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Waterworks Octagonal Structure 23 (4) (a) (d)
Moreton Bay Fig (Ficus macrophylla) specimen 23 (4) (g); 296 (a) (f)
Mullawirraburka/Park 14/Rymill
Park
Rymill Lake 23 (4) (a) (d)
Former Tramline Embankment 23 (4) (a)
1 106